Debates of 1 Dec 2005

MR. FIRST DEPUTY SPEAKER
PRAYERS 10:25 a.m.

CORRECTION OF VOTES 10:25 a.m.

AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE 10:25 a.m.

OFFICIAL REPORT 10:25 a.m.

Mr. First Deputy Speaker 10:25 a.m.
Correction of Votes and Proceedings of Wednesday, 30th November, 2005. Pages 1, 2, 3 . . . 18 -- [Pause.] [No correction was made in the Votes and Proceedings of Wednesday, 30th November, 2005.]
Mr. John A. Ndebugre 10:25 a.m.
Mr. Speaker,

M r. F i r s t D e p u t y S p e a k e r :

Unfortunately, I do not have copies here on my desk; so we will defer them for some other day.
BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE 10:25 a.m.

Minister for Parliamentary Affairs/ Majority Leader (Mr. F. K. Owusu- Adjapong) 10:25 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, the Business Committee met yesterday, Wednesday, 30th November 2005 and arranged Business of the House for the Seventh Week ending Friday, 9th December 2005.
Mr. Speaker, since Friday, 2nd December 2005 is a public holiday, the Committee decided to meet yesterday instead of our usual Thursday meetings in order to be
able to report to the House today. Mr. Speaker, the Committee accordingly submits its report as follows:
Arrangement of Business
Bills, Papers and Reports
Mr. Speaker, Bills, Papers and Reports may be presented to the House for consideration. Others which are already with the House may be taken through their various stages of passage.
Statements
Mr. Speaker may allow duly authorized Statements to be made in the House.
Continuation of Debate on the 2006 Budget Estimates of MDAs
Mr. Speaker, the House will continue to debate motions for adoption of Committee reports and approval of the 2006 Budget Estimates of the various Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs).
Mr. Speaker, other motions may be debated and their consequential resolutions, if any, may also be considered during the week.
As hon. Members would observe, there still remain a number of reports and Budget Estimates of MDAs to consider. The Committee therefore urges hon. Members to attend Sittings of the House regularly in order to make their submissions.
Mr. Speaker, the Committee however wishes to urge hon. Members to endeavour to be as brief as possible and also avoid repetitions during their presentations.
Mr. Speaker, all unfinished business relating to the Budget Estimates and its motions after the close of today, will be
rearranged and carried to the following week.
Conclusion
Mr. Speaker, in accordance with Standing Order 160 (2) and subject to Standing Order 53, the Committee submits to this honourable House the order in which the Business of the House shall be taken during the week.

Laying of Papers

( a ) R e p o r t o f t h e S p e c i a l Budget Commit tee on the Annual Budget Estimates of the Office of Parliament for the year

2006.

(b) Report of the Finance Committee on the Loan Agreement between the Republic of Ghana and the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) for an amount of SDR 13,050,000 (USD 18,964,000 equivalent) for financing the Root and Tuber Improvement and Marketing Programme (RTIMP).

(c) Report of the Finance Committee on the Concessional Credit Agree- ment between the Republic of Ghana and the Export-Import Bank of India for an amount of US$60 million for the financing of Rural Electrification and Construction of the Office of the President at Flag Staff House.

(d) Repor t of the Commit tee on Employment, Social Welfare

and State Enterprises on the Annual Budget Estimates of the Public Sector Reform for the year

2006.

Motions --

(a) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢45,230 million for the services of the National Commission on Culture for the 2006 fiscal year.

( b ) T h a t t h i s h o n o u r a b l e House approves the sum of ¢40,487 million for the services of National Development Planning Commis- sion for the 2006 fiscal year.

(c) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢3,665,844,000,000 for the services of the Ministry of Road Transport for the 2006 fiscal year.

(d) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢102,805 million for the services of the Ministry of Justice for the 2006 fiscal year.

(e) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢154,863 million for the services of the Judicial Service for the 2006 fiscal year.

(f) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢67,762
Minister for Parliamentary Affairs/ Majority Leader (Mr. F. K. Owusu- Adjapong) 10:25 a.m.
million for the services of the Ministry of Communication for the 2006 fiscal year.

(g) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢584,930 million for the services of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning for the 2006 fiscal year.

Committee Sittings

Motions --

(a) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢100,822 million for the services of the Ministry of Manpower Deve- lopment, Youth and Employment for the 2006 fiscal year.

(b) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢5,663 million for the services of the National Labour Commission for the 2006 fiscal year.

(c) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢215,704 million for the services of the Ministry of Environment and Science for the 2006 fiscal year.

(d) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢162,933

million for the services of the Ministry of Information for the 2006 fiscal year.

(e) That this honouable House approves the sum of ¢1,326,840,000,000 for the services of the Ministry of Works and Housing for the 2006 fiscal year.

(f) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢906,885 million for the services of the Ministry of the Interior for the 2006 fiscal year.

(g) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢39,563 million for the services of the Ministry of Tourism & Modernization of the Capital City for the 2006 fiscal year.

(h) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢594,590 million for the services of Revenue Agencies for the 2006 fiscal year.

Consideration Stage of Bills --

Minerals and Mining Bill.

Committee Sittings

Motions --

(a) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢163,699 million for the services of the Office of Parliament for the 2006 fiscal year.

(b) That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢41,840 million for the services of the Ministry of Fisheries for the 2006 fiscal year.

(c) Adoption of the Report of the Finance Committee on the Loan Agreement between the Republic of Ghana and the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) a for loan amount of SDR

13,050,000 (USD 18,964,000

equivalent) for financing the Root and Tuber Improvement and Marketing Programme (RTIMP).

(d) Adoption of the Report of the F inance Commit tee on the Concessional Credit Agreement between the Republic of Ghana and the Export-Import Bank of India for

an amount of US$60 million for the financing of Rural Electrification and Construction of the Office of the President at Flag Staff House.

Presentation and First Reading of Bills --

The Appropriation Bill, 2006

Second Reading of Bills --

The Appropriation Bill, 2006.

Committee Sittings

Fridays, 9th December 2005.

Consideration Stage of Bills --

The Appropriation Bill, 2006.

Third Reading of Bills --

(a) The Appropriation Bill, 2006

(b) Minerals and Mining Bill.

Committee Sittings
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 10:35 a.m.
Hon. Members, that is the proposed Business for the oncoming week. Are there any comments thereon?
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, thank you very much. Mr. Speaker, if you will recall, the last time the Chairman of the Business Committee presented the Business Statement, I drew his attention to an Urgent Question I filed for the hon. Minister for Information. And Mr. Speaker, with your indulgence, Urgent
Chairman of the Business Committee (Mr. Felix Owusu-Adjapong) 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, there are equally important Urgent Questions that came ahead of this particular Question, so we are having a lot of Urgent Questions. But you may recall that the Business Committee said that to enable us work smoothly on these Estimates, there were not going to be Questions. And yesterday they repeated that decision; it is unfortunate that it was not recorded but I took it that we shall notice that the Business Committee met and agreed that there will be no Questions for next Week.
Let me also emphasize that in fact, if we were to go by Urgent Questions, perhaps his will not be the first to be listed; we will then go by the time they came so that we can be seen to be fair to all persons.
Mr. Alfred K. Agbesi 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, for about two weeks now, an hon. Member of this House is alleged to have been arrested. Mr. Speaker, the news is all over the place but we do not know the actual facts, as at today.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 10:35 a.m.
Hon.
Member, I hate to do this but if you think it is a very urgent matter and you would want it to be treated by the hon. Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, you may file a Question on that -- [Uproar.] Yes, you do that. This is not part of the Business Statement that we are discussing, so please would you take your seat and let somebody else discuss what we are talking about?
Mr. Francis A. Agbotse 10:35 a.m.
Mr.
Speaker, we are laying L.I. 1816 today, but it is not scheduled for discussion by this House next week and I would want to draw attention to that.
Mr. Owusu-Adjapong 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, when these Papers are laid, we try occasionally to make sure that hon. Members have got them. Now, you will notice that we normally say that “. . . subject to the Standing Orders”, we can always bring topics and items that have matured. So when we get the documents and we are satisfied that hon. Members have got copies, we will arrange for time for it to be looked at. That is the process.
Mr. Yieleh Chireh 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I have looked at the Business Statement and the pages are not numbered. But I have also received an additional Paper listing a number of MDAs; there is no date and there is no indication as to when their Estimates will be approved. But it is among the documents I received and I would want some clarification from the Chairman of the Business Committee.
Mr. Owusu-Adjapong 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is part of the secretariat's error because I myself knew that there should have been for instance, the Consideration Stage of the Minerals and Mining Bill and when I read the document I was holding and it did not include that, I was surprised. It was later on that my attention was drawn to the fact that whilst printing or in stapling them, they omitted one sheet. So Mr. Speaker, with your indulgence, I can read that one sheet as part of the items to be discussed.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 10:35 a.m.
Please,
go ahead.
Mr. Owusu-Adjapong 10:35 a.m.
Mr. Speaker,
if you look at Wednesday, 7th December, there would have been motions numbered “a” and “b” and this particular sheet would then continue with the “c” to the “i”; and these are:
a. Ministry of Environment and Science -- ¢215,704 million
b. Ministry of Information
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 10:35 a.m.
Hon.
Members, are there any other comments on the proposed Business Statement for the week?
Hon. Members, that should bring us to the end of discussions on the Business Statement. We have a short Statement to be made by the hon. Minority Leader in terms of tributes to a past Member of Parliament, incidentally my predecessor. Go ahead.
STATEMENTS 10:45 a.m.

Mr. Kojo Armah (CPP - Evalue- Gwira) 10:55 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to associate myself with my very good friend, the hon. Minority Leader, in this moving tribute to the late Mr. John Aitpillah. The Nzema word “Aitpillah”, we do not pronounce the ‘t', so we say “Apila”.
Mr. Speaker, Mr. Aitpillah was a very serious, hardworking, committed elder statesman of the district where I had the honour to serve as the District Chief Executive (DCE). I had known Mr. Aitpillah for a very long time, being very close to my family in-law in Nzema; but I had also known him as a teacher in Axim. I had a lot of respect for Mr. Aitpillah in his political career. I knew as a matter of fact that he was a member of the NDC, but in practice, Mr. Aitpillah related very well with all members of the political divide in Nzema.
After his retirement from Parliament he came to stay in Axim with his dear wife and children, engaged in local politics by becoming a Presiding Member of the District Assembly; and he handled that office very well. Again, due to age he had to retire after the first term of two years to give way to somebody else. He continued to proffer his advice very freely, candidly and without bias to all manner of people who sought the advice. As the DCE at the time, I benefited a lot from him. Anytime there was a function and I needed a Chairman, I had to call on him, and when I called on him, it did not matter the short
notice, Mr. Aitpillah would be available.
Those of us in the district who had the opportunity to work with him will remember Mr. Aitpillah for the easy flow of quotations from Shakespeare -- from all the literature books that one can think of. There was not any statement that Mr. Aitpillah would make without bringing in one stanza or another of very witty quotations to remind us that literature is the rock of wisdom.
Mr. Aitpillah was also a very active
church member, a Deacon of the local Anglican Church and he made announcements, attended funerals and he always deputised for the local Priest when he was out of station.

Indeed, it was something of satisfaction to me that at his age you could always see Mr. Aitpillah walking very briskly from his house to the church which was some distance and anytime you asked him he said that was his form of exercise. It is ironical that a few days before he died, he was going to church and he suffered some little relapse; he stood for some ten minutes and when somebody offered to hold his hands he said, no, he was only meditating. He continued to the church, came back and not long after, he had his first collapse and he was rushed to the hospital never to come back.

I must say that those of us in Nzema East District have lost somebody we could count on as a father, as a friend and as a counsellor. As he begins his journey home today, maybe, tomorrow when the wake will be kept, we can only wish him a peaceful rest and may the good Lord keep him in His Bosom.

I thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 10:55 a.m.
Hon.
Members, that brings us to the end of Statement time. We will now start with Public Business.
PAPERS 10:55 a.m.

-- 10:55 a.m.

CONSIDERATION OF ANNUAL 10:55 a.m.

ESTIMATES 10:55 a.m.

Mr. Speaker, the 2006 budget of MOFA is based on six main pillars 10:55 a.m.
To reduce over-reliance on cocoa as a major foreign exchange earner by developing two more cash crops - mango and cashew.
To expand the area under irrigation a n d i n t r o d u c e a g r i c u l t u r a l machinery, among others, thereby upscaling the modernization of the agricultural sector.
To expand grains and legumes production through modernized ag r ono mica l p r ac t i c e s and expansion of existing farms.
To improve service delivery at district and farm levels.
To enhance root and tuber production through modernization
of cultural practices and value addition; and
To help create youth employment.
The rationale is to ensure a quantum leap in agricultural growth to pave the way
Mr. Speaker, the 2006 budget of MOFA is based on six main pillars 11:05 a.m.
for the expected economic growth. The strategy is both by area expansion in some cases, and by productivity enhancement in others.

Food Crop Production
Mr. Speaker, major programmes to enhance food crop production in the year are 11:05 a.m.
It is to increase the production and availability of quality planting materials and improved seeds to farmers. It is also to strengthen capacity of certified seed producers of major cereals through training and monitoring visits. Again, it is to promote the use of bio-agents and chemicals for pest control and to set up strategic stock reserves for chemicals to control calamity pests including army worms and larger grain borers. Mr. Speaker, it is to enhance farmers' access to research and technology through improved extension service delivery.
We are also thinking of facilitating the establishment of additional 10,000 hectares of soya beans for both human consumption and to support the poultry industry. There is also the support for 40,000 smallholders with certified seeds, and agro-chemicals to more than double their maize output and to facilitate the establishment of additional 20,000 hectares of sorghum to support the brewery industry.
Under cash crops, Mr. Speaker, the programme for cash crops is to access primary nursery operators to establish mango nurseries for the cultivation of 5,000 hectares of mango in 2007.
There is also the support for farmers
Chairman of the Committee (Dr. M. K. Antwi) 11:05 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to second the motion and to present the report of the Committee.
1.0 Introduction
Mr. Speaker, the Minister for Finance and Economic Planning, Mr. Kwadwo Baah-Wiredu, on Thursday, 10 th November, 2006 presented to Parliament the Budget Statement and Economic Policy of the Government of Ghana for the 2006 financial year in accordance with article 179 of the 1992 Constitution.
Pursuant to Standing Order 140
(4) and 176, Mr. Speaker referred the draft Estimates of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture to the Committee for
TABLE 11:05 a.m.

Mr. J. K. Gidisu (NDC - Central Tongu) 11:15 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to equally support the motion on the floor, especially with regard to the budget of the Ministry.
Mr. David Oppong-Kusi (NPP - Ofoase/Ayirebi) 11:25 a.m.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity to support the motion on the floor.
In supporting the motion, I would like
to dwell on one of the objectives stated on page 3 of the Committee's Report, 5.02, which says, and I quote:
“To facilitate modernisation of agricultural production to achieve food self-sufficiency and food security.”
Mr. Speaker, modernised agriculture is one of the key developmental objectives of this Government under the Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy (GPRS); and it is a very desirable objective.
Unfortunately, many people think of
modernised agriculture only in terms of tractors, mechanised ploughs, harrows and all those sophisticated equipment, as well as structures like irrigations, small and large. But Mr. Speaker, there is a very important component of modernised agriculture, which is always relegated to the background, and that is the people themselves who are going to practise that modernised agriculture.
Mr. Speaker, most of the people who
are supposed to modernise our agriculture are those living in the villages, those who till our lands, using methods that my grandmother used many, many years ago. When it comes to modernisation of agriculture, you will realise that most of the people who are currently engaged in
agriculture are either people who have no other jobs to do or who have always been in agriculture, in the sense that they have always tilled the land. No steps have been taken to actually train and give skills to people who are going to really do this work.
For example, when you go to the villages most of the people who fall out at the junior secondary school (JSS) or senior secondary school (SSS) stages are forced onto the farm. They follow their fathers or mothers to the farm and then continue with the old ways of farming.

There are a lot of institutions around the country which can give practical training to farm hands. Mr. Speaker, if we really believe that agriculture employs the majority of our people, then the time has come for us to give skills to the people who engage in agriculture. And I am asking the Ministry to increase the number of farm institutes -- like the one they have at Asawase -- so that we can have more of our people who fall out at the junior secondary school level, who fall out at the senior secondary school level, those who are interested in going into agriculture as a profession, to have a place to go to be trained, so that they can apply the skills they have on our lands.

Mr. Speaker, if we have tractors, if we

have irrigation systems, and if we have skilled labour, the combination of these three will propel our agriculture into a modernized one. I am asking that every district be given at least one agricultural training school, in the long-term, so that those who are interested in agriculture can then avail themselves of this opportunity.

Mr. Speaker, without training in
Mr. David Oppong-Kusi (NPP - Ofoase/Ayirebi) 11:25 a.m.


Mr. David Tetteh Assumeng (NDC

- Shai Osudoku): Mr. Speaker, in supporting the motion, I want to draw the Ministry's attention to the Volta River.

We have the Volta River in this country and day in day out, this river flows into the sea. And one would ask: What maximum use are we putting this resource to? We have the Kpong Irrigation Project; there are about five thousand people benefiting from that project. Today, if you go there, rice farmers cannot get market for their produce. Large quantities of rice are being produced over there. We cannot market it. So I want to draw the attention of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture to some of these issues.

We must also look for marketing arrangements, so that farmers can also benefit from this. Now, if there are no marketing arrangements then definitely the youth will drift to the cities and towns. We want the youth to go into farming but here and then there is no market for their produce and so they will drift into the cities. I want to draw the Ministry's attention to this.

And in line with this, as well, we

are talking about drilling boreholes for irrigation. Mr. Speaker, I think that this must be given a second look. When rivers

are just in abundance and we cannot make maximum use of them, we are now going to go underground. Why can we not allow this underground water to remain for the long-term so that we can make maximum use of the resources that are available, that we cannot use so much? And I am saying the Volta River is there; let us make maximum use of these resources. Let us expand the irrigation project.

The Kpong Irrigation, there is still land; the Accra Plains, there is land and we are going hungry in this country. We are importing rice. I mean, it is a shame. It is a shame. We must give a second look if we really want to remain independent, in terms of food production.

Mr. Speaker, I want to be very brief.

We will support the motion but I want the Ministry to take a second look at the issue of rice production, marketing and borehole drilling for irrigation.

Thank you, Mr. Speaker.

Mr. S. N. Aryeetey Attoh (NPP

- Trobu-Amasaman): Mr. Speaker, I rise to lend my support to the motion on the floor. In supporting the motion, Mr. Speaker, I do not intend to reinvent the wheel as has already been put on the floor. I am most impressed about the motivations that the Ministry is putting in place, which have engendered the promotion of non- traditional crops and livestock, especially in the grass-cutter production area.

These motivations, I believe, will ease or ameliorate the threats to Ghana's agriculture, which are: lack of perennial water system for crop development, environmental degradation, and even the players between the production, distribution and then the consumers. It will also help ameliorate the rural-urban migration in the production of agriculture.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 11:25 a.m.
Yes, hon. Member for Evalue-Gwira?
Mr. Kojo Armah 11:25 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I believe Cocoa Marketing Board ceased to exist long ago. We now have Cocoa Board, so if the hon. Member may want to refresh his memory and come out with the proper nomenclature.
Mr. Attoh 11:25 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, the Ghana Cocoa Board does not draw from the Consolidated Fund; it relates directly with the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning. Therefore, expenditures and all other reports do not come to the Committee. The Cocoa Board has indicated that the Committee should contact the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning for the performance report. But Mr. Speaker, you would agree with me that if the Committee has the oversight responsibility of the Board, it is sad to hear that the Committee should refer to the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, which also does not inform the Committee.
The Committee, therefore, is not in
the position, within the year, to assess the performance of the Board, neither is it able to make contributions towards the effective running of the Board. The Committee, therefore, considers this unacceptable and urges Parliament to intervene to enable the Committee to carry out its mandate creditably so that it can report to this august House as far as cocoa affairs are concerned.
Nii Amasah Namoale (NDC - Dade Kotopon): Mr. Speaker, I would like to contribute to the motion on the floor.
Mr. Speaker, in reading the Committee's Report, page 8, the last paragraph, it says:
“Help stabilize food prices, improve the wellbeing of farmers, ensure food security and to establish the national food strategic stock, MOFA will purchase marketed surplus of maize and other legumes.”
Mr. Speaker, my contribution to support the budget on agriculture is that the Government is going to support MOFA to buy surplus food that is produced and keep it, and then use it to stabilize food prices so that our farmers will enjoy the money that will come to them; so that prices will not fall and then we have food security. I think this is a very noble idea and I support it with all my mind and with all the principles in my head.
Mr. Speaker, this is the social democracy principle that guides the policies of the social democrats. So far as this Government is concerned, I am very happy that they have adopted the social democracy principle to move this country forward. I am also supporting this budget because when you go to page 17, it talks about Agriculture Engineering Services Directorate, that is 12.11. It says:
“ . . . o n l o c a l m a n u f a c t u r e d
agr icu l tu ra l machinery and equipment as well as manufacturers of such tools of work. . . This in the opinion of the Committee would generate the market for these products worldwide and contribute to the development of our economy. The Committee recommends that the directorate should do more to support our farmers in the supply of these equipment and machinery . . .”
Mr. Speaker, this is also Government's intervention, social democracy principle; so I think all social democrats should pack themselves and support the budget for the Ministry of Food and Agriculture because if you look at the objective of the Ministry, the seven objectives that have been outlined in the Committee's Report, you can see that they are talking of formulation, ensure, facilitate and strengthening institutional capacity.
Mr. Speaker, when you look at strengthening institutional capacity -- I think yesterday or so we were talking of women affairs. Women in Agricultural Development (WIAD) Directorate in the Ministry of Food and Agriculture, if you go through the whole of the budget you do not see WIAD even in passing. I want the Ministry to use the money that has been allocated to them to strengthen Women in Agricultural Development Directorate so that even though their name has not been mentioned in passing in the budget, money should be given to them to strengthen them.
Mr. Speaker, with this contribution, I would like to say that the hen has finally come home to roost. Social democracy has now finally come home to roost because people have seen that this is the basis to strengthen our democracy and to strengthen our development.

Mr. Speaker, the idea that they are going to buy foodstuff, grains and legumes, they should do the same thing and buy the rice at Dodowa and Kpong Irrigation Projects. The idea of Ministry of Food and Agriculture going to buy the grains and legumes from other places, they should use the same money also to buy the rice that has been left unmarketed at Dodowa and Kpong Irrigation Projects so that farmers will also get some money in their pockets.

With this, Mr. Speaker, I am done. Thank you very much and I support the motion.
Mr. Simon Osei-Mensah (NPP - Bosomtwe) 11:25 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to support the motion on the floor, that this House approves the sum of ¢682,138 million for the services of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture for the financial year 2006.
Mr. Speaker, and in so doing I would want to comment on two aspects. The first one is the Veterinary Services Directorate. Mr. Speaker, this directorate always faces a problem of acquisition of vaccines. Fortunately enough, they raise significant revenue internally. As at the end of September this year, the Internally Generated Funds (IGF) raised by the Veterinary Services stood at ¢10.6 billion.
Mr. Speaker, as has been requested by the Committee that part of the IGF should be released to the Veterinary Services to undertake various programmes, which are of great concern to us as far as our health is concerned; because they use these vaccines to treat most of these animals of certain ailments or diseases.
Mr. Speaker, I would want to add my voice that the Ministry of Finance and
Economic Planning should have a second look at it and allocate a portion of the IGF from the Veterinary Services Directorate to them for them to acquire sufficient vaccines to undertake their programmes.
Mr. Speaker, another issue I would like to raise is that the Ministry should speed up with the process of rehabilitating the irrigation that they have identified in the budget, namely, Weija, Aveyime, Afife, Kpando, Torkor, Fata, Akomadan, Tanoso, Subingya, et cetera, so that this would ensure all-year round production of agricultural produce. In so doing, then we would be on a path to ensuring absolute food security in this country.
Mr. Speaker, whilst irrigations are being developed, we should not also lose sight of the fact that there was a law that said that 5 per cent of all irrigable land must be allocated for aquaculture. Now that we have a full Ministry for Fisheries, it is appropriate, as we embark on these irrigation projects, to take that law into consideration and reserve 5 per cent of these irrigable lands for aquaculture development, which also plays a part in ensuring food security, so far as fish is concerned.
With these few words, Mr. Speaker, I lend my support to the motion.
Mr. Clement Kofi Humado (NDC
- Anlo): Mr. Speaker, I also rise to support the motion on the floor and also to use the opportunity to make a few observations, which I believe will enrich the programmes of the Ministry.
Mr. Speaker, we all know of the recurrent food deficit situation in some parts of this country, especially the Northern, Upper East and Upper West Regions. It is my view that as we move into the growth stage of the Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy (GPRS), this situation
should become a thing of the past.
The hon. Deputy Minister has appropriately pointed out food security as the first objective. However, my area of contention is where they should target those particular crops, which form the diet of the people; and they are millet, sorghum and upland rice.
Mr. Speaker, if you look at the information from the Statistics Research and Information Directorate of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture, these crops have over the past four years been declining in production, and the nation is not yet self-sufficient in the production of those particular crops, hence the recurrent food shortages that we have in the northern areas of this country.
I have looked at the programmes of the various directorates under the Ministry of Food and Agriculture very carefully, Irrigation Company of Upper Region (ICOUR), Land Conservation and Reclamation Project (LACOSREP), Upper West Agricultural Development Project (UWADEP) and all of them which are located up there; they do not have any specific programmes to target the production of these staple food crops; and these things were discussed during the Committee's session.
I would, therefore, want to urge the hon. Deputy Minister to examine the programmes of those projects up there very well and ensure that these crops are targeted. Providing irrigation facilities alone is not the solution. What is grown on those facilities is also part of the solution; and I have not seen in any of the programmes targeting the staple diet of the people of these areas.
My last point is on statistics. As we move into GPRS II, the issue of Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) at production levels will become a focal issue. Some of us will be looking at this very, very carefully. And when I look at the programmes of the various directorates, they talk more on other things but very little on improving the capacity of the Ministry to track statistics, to collect data, to process data and to disseminate data.
And again, I am suggesting to the Ministry that we should disaggregate the crops' GDP from the livestock because the livestock seems to be doing well. In the crops sector it is only the roots and the tubers and the few others that are doing well. If we disaggregate, we would be able to know what is happening to the cereals.
Mr. Speaker, with these few comments, I support the motion and urge the House to approve the amount required or requested by the Ministry for the efficient running of the Ministry, for the year 2006.
Mr. Joseph Yaani Labik (IND -- Bunkpurugu/Yunyoo) 11:45 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I am on my feet to support the motion before this House but also to make a few comments, because I am a farmer and I am also a son of a peasant farmer.
Mr. Speaker, one of the serious areas
I have been expecting the Ministry of Food and Agriculture to address, is the marketing aspect of the farmers.
Mr. Speaker, as we speak now, this
is the time the peasant farmer is being exploited; because the peasant farmer is harvesting and he needs to sell his produce to buy clothing for the children for Christmas, to buy cloth for the wife for Christmas. This is the time he also needs money to take care of his children's school fees. In this country, as we stand now, apart from cocoa, which has a price fixed
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 11:45 a.m.
Hon.
Member, you should be landing by now. You have a minute more to land.
Mr. Labik 11:45 a.m.
Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. Mr. Speaker, I would want to put on record that I was personally not so happy yesterday when I noticed that the President's Initiative, on cotton and sorghum had no allocation, meaning that we will continue to live in hunger in the three northern regions.
With this, Mr. Speaker, I support the motion before the House.
Mr. Lee Ocran (NDC -- Jomoro) 11:45 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, whilst I rise to support the motion on the floor, I have just some few comments to make.
One. The major problems facing our agriculture over the years have not been the acquisition of land but rather accessing credit - financing has been a very big problem. Times were when the Agricultural Development Bank used to lend money to the farmers, but during the Financial Sector Restructuring Programme, they shifted into commercial banking and therefore, farmers find it quite difficult to get access to credit.
No definite measures have been made in the budget; and on page 7, that is last year, some farmer groups were given some credit; how much they were given is not mentioned. In the current one, they have lumped credit together with HIV and so on, for farmers and I do not think that is fair enough. Farmers seriously need credit if they are to make any headway.
The next is that no serious mention is made of the extension services and I do not know under which heading now extension services come. But if the farmers have improved seedlings and they have no technical support, it will be very difficult for them to engage in any meaningful production. I hope the hon. Minister for Food and Agriculture will take on board these suggestions.
The last comment I would have to make is about the Coconut Sector Rehabilitation Programme. The Coconut Sector Rehabilitation Programme is a programme very dear to the hearts of the people living in the Central and Western Regions where the Cape Saint Paul Wilt disease has devastated the coconut industry, which is the bedrock of the livelihood
of the people in those two regions. Thanks to the French Government, some rehabilitation programme is going on, but the Ministry of Food and Agriculture or Ghana Government is supposed to make an input and there is absolutely no mention of this project in the Ministry's budget. So I think the hon. Minister would go and revise his or her estimates so that the people in the Central and Western regions, I mean the coastal inhabitants, will also find something worthwhile to do.
With these few comments, I support the motion.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 11:45 a.m.
I call
on the hon. Deputy Minister for Food and Agriculture to, in some few words, wind up.
Deputy Minister for Food and
Agriculture (Ms. Anna Nyamekye): Mr. Speaker, I will thank all my hon. Colleagues for all the useful suggestions they have made. Every comment has been taken note of and I think the Ministry of Food and Agriculture is going to make sure that this is taken on board. I guess that is why we bring the budget here for all of us to discuss so that as a House, we do justice to it. I am grateful to you for all the suggestions.
Question put and motion agreed to.
Resolved:
That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢682,138 million for the services of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture for the 2006 fiscal year.
ANNUAL ESTIMATES 11:55 a.m.

Minister for Energy (Prof. Aaron Mike Oquaye) 11:55 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to move, that this honourable House approves the sum of ¢515,904,000,000.00 for the Ministry of Energy for the fiscal year 2006.
The breakdown of the figures is as follows:
GOG Donor Total
¢
¢ ¢
P e r s o n a l E m o l u m e n t s
3,731,000,000 --
3,731,000,000
Administration
3,346,000,000
3,346,000,000
Service 1,774,000,000
14,967,000,000 16,741,000,000
HIPC 11:55 a.m.

SPACE FOR TABLE 11:55 a.m.

SPACE FOR TABLE 11:55 a.m.

Dr. Kwame Ampofo (NDC -- South Dayi) 11:55 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to also support the motion on the floor and in doing so, to briefly comment on the report and the budgetary allocations to the Ministry.
Mr. Speaker, as we all know, energy really forms the bloodstream of any
Dr. Kwame Ampofo (NDC -- South Dayi) 12:05 p.m.
economy and so it is important that the energy infrastructure is supported to be robust so that the growth of the economy can also proceed in a planned manner without any hiccups.
Mr. Speaker, in the report, we find that one of the areas where investments in the energy sector is expected to yield economic returns considering the massive funding that it receives is the area of rural electrification.
Mr. Speaker, on page eight (8) of the report, we find out that the Ministry is undertaking a very important activity which has been dubbed Productive Uses of Electricity (PUE). I personally consider this activity to be very vital if electrification is to result in poverty reduction or alleviation from our rural areas. It is, therefore, gratifying that the Ministry is adhering to this programme.
What I am not happy about, however,
is that this PUE programme had been on-going for, at least, not less than twenty years because in the late 1980s, I know that a unit of the PUE was set up in the Ministry. Up till now, from the report and from what the Ministry told us, they are still undertaking studies and I think we have gotten to the point where we should be committing funding to the PUE programme in terms of implementation, in terms of actually making the electrification of all the electrified areas start using the electricity for productive uses instead of conducting studies.

Last year, we approved in the neighbourhood of ¢200 million for the Ministry and the report indicates that this amount all went into studies that were meant to identify the opportunities for PUEs. I wish to take this opportunity to

ask the hon. Minister and the Ministry to come out with complete programmes that will be more of implementation rather than studies to identify.

Mr. Speaker, there is the issue also on

the West African power project and I wish to encourage the Ministry to pursue this particular project with all the vigour that it needs because this is to integrate the power systems of our subregion and from the work that I have done in this area.

Indeed I was one of the three consultants who did the background study and I covered Ghana, Nigeria, Sierra Leone, Liberia, the Gambia and I can say that Ghana is in a very unique position to take advantage of this West Africa power project so that we can indeed become a net exporter of energy; it will give us the opportunity to actually use Ghana as the base. We have a lot of human expertise to produce the power. This powerful project will be the system, the means by which we can evacuate the power that we produce here. Therefore, it is a project that was well-thought-out and I am glad that the Ministry is pursuing it but I think we should plan and plan well so that the advantages that it will bring to Ghana will really be gotten.

Mr. Speaker, the other issue is the Bui Hydroelectric Project. As I said some time ago, the Bui project is not a new idea. In fact, the Bui gorge was identified as early as in the 1920s as a potential site for a major dam. Because of that several studies have been conducted under the Bui gorge area. One such study was done by a company called J. S. Zhuk Hydroprojeckt of the then Soviet Union. They did extensive work on that.

Later on, a company called SMEC, that is Snony Mountains Engineering Corporation of Australia also did a lot of

studies on it in 1994. Thereafter, a French company by name Coyne Et Bellier (CGB) of France through a grant of the French Government also updated the information that the previous company provided. Therefore, all I am trying to say is that we all agree that the time has come for another hydro system to be put into the system, looking at the capacity growth requirement of the energy system.

However, lessons learnt from the construction of the Akosombo Dam should inform us to be cautious as to how we proceed with the Bui Hydroelectric Project . I am talking about the environmental implication. I am talking about displacement of people. I am talking about the social implications as we are experiencing with the 52 resettlement townships that were displaced from where the Volta Lake now occupies. We expect such environmental effects to occur also with the Bui Hydroelectric Project. What is more worrying is that the project, indeed, will affect and destroy some of the forest reserves in the area apart from the over 2,000 people that it is going to displace.

I hope the Ministry is taking the necessary steps because I did not see any budgetary allocations to prepare the grounds for abating some of these problems, except that it is put here that two million dollars is being used for the environmental impact assessment. But we need to do the social impact and the social requirement, the social needs assessment because you are going to displace people and they are going to be taken to places far from where they live.

Mr. Speaker, I think I will rest my case

here because we have gone through the budget with the sector Minister and his
Minister for Private Sector Reforms (Dr. Paa Kwesi Nduom) 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I wish to associate myself with the motion dealing with the budget estimates for the Ministry of Energy.
Mr. Speaker, on the matter of rural electrification, I believe that adequate provisions have been made but there are certain other issues that we must consider. We still do have some communities which are not able to provide for their community share of the rural electrification programmes in terms of cost and many of these communities exist in the poorer areas of the country. I know that in the past some HIPC funds had been made available to assist but then there is a lot more work that need to be done in those areas.

So I would suggest perhaps greater collaboration between some of our own hon. Colleagues in this House and the District Assemblies working closely in collaboration with the Ministry of Energy so that those communities that are

deprived of the use of electricity can also enjoy this benefit.

Again, it is in this regard that I would like to comment on the statement made by my hon. Colleague who just made his contribution relating to the West African Gas Pipeline Project (WAGP) and opposed the use of HIPC funds. My hon. Colleague made a point that electrification is more or less a commercial matter -- [Interruption] -- Well, that was the point that he made and that it was more commercial as opposed to social. There is nothing more social and more poverty-reducing than electrification. And the West African Gas Pipeline is meant -- [Interruption.]
Dr. Ampofo 12:15 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr.
Speaker, the hon. Member is misleading the House. A gas pipeline is a gas pipeline, electrification is electrification; they can be interlinked at a point but I am saying that the gas coming through the pipeline -- yes, it is going to ultimately be used for producing electricity but it is also going to be used directly for other things. We cannot say that it is electrification and therefore in my presentation I did not say that HIPC funds should not go for electrification. In fact, I would have supported it if the HIPC funding were going for rural electrification directly or for the productive usage. This I will support but not for the Gas Pipeline Project.
Dr. Nduom 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I think
the hon. Member, should inform himself adequately. I know he is an informed person in this field but if he reads and has read, which I am sure he has, the documents and the rationale and the justification that have been made for the WAGP Project, one of the essential elements is for the production of electricity and indeed, the main off-taker for this
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:15 p.m.
Are you
on a point of order again? What is it about?
Dr. Ampofo 12:15 p.m.
On a point of order. It
is on the same issue.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:15 p.m.
What is
the issue?
Dr. Ampofo 12:15 p.m.
The issue is that the hon.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:15 p.m.
Hon. Member, we need not split hairs over this. It is a question of opinion at this stage as to whether to produce electricity with gas pipeline or with Hydro and so forth; it is a question of opinion, so let him make his contribution.
Dr. Ampofo 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, his
understanding of the issues are wrong.
Dr. Nduom 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, the hon. Member does not want to continue on this line because I do understand what is defined for the uses of HIPC funds and indeed, it is for poverty reducing projects. What else is poverty reducing than electrification?
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:15 p.m.
Hon. Dr.
Nduom, could you please make a little progress and ignore that.
Dr. Nduom 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, on the
Osagyefo Power Barge -- The hon. Member should inform himself properly; and I know he is an expert in this area, so he should continue to read.
Mr. Speaker, on the Osagyefo Power Barge, it is indicated here that proposals have been sought and they are being evaluated. Mr. Speaker, this is an important project for the country but I also want to indicate that it is an important project for the people in the Western Region and in the Effasu Mangyea area and so it is a project that I would urge the Ministry of Energy to continue to pursue with vigour, with some urgency to make sure that the project not just continue to be sited there but also that it provides the essential benefits for the entire country and the associated social investments that are needed in the area where the project is sited must also be put there.
Just as in the Akosombo area some social benefits have been put there, so also in the Effasu Mangyea area, social investments must be put there similar to what has been done in the Aboadze area where the Thermal Plant has been sited. It is an important project and we must support it; and we must make sure that it is pursued with some urgency.
Mr. Speaker, as far as the Bui Dam is
concerned it is a good project; it is the right project; what has been put in the budget for the studies is also the appropriate project to be done at this time. The rest of it, in my understanding, is to come from investments that are to come from outside of Government.
Mr. Speaker, when you look at everything else that is there, I believe that the Ministry of Energy is on the right course; we need to support it; we need to encourage them to implement a number of these initiatives, the Gas Pipeline, the Osagyefo Power Barge, and the rest with some urgency so that the benefits we are all looking for can come in 2006.
And with that, Mr. Speaker, I thank you for allowing me to make a contribution; and I do support the motion.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:15 p.m.
I will take
one more contribution -- from the hon. Minority Leader.
Minority Leader (Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin) 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I want to contribute to the debate in our attempt at approving the budget allocation for the Ministry of Energy.
Mr. Speaker, I sympathize with the Ministry very much because clearly, from the allocation the Ministry is just going to depend on the generosity of our development partners, termed “donors” and the availability or otherwise of HIPC funds. Mr. Speaker, when I looked at the allocation and the components of the allocation, I realized that we are going to be expecting our developing partners to dole out as much as ¢240.1 billion out of the ¢515. 9 billion and we are expecting that HIPC will make available ¢275.7 billion and the only contribution that will be coming from central Government is ¢30.7 billion, internal-generated revenue.
Definitely, I know HIPC is forgiving us
Prof. Oquaye 12:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, thank you for the opportunity to make a few winding-up comments.
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry is very grateful to hon. Members for all the contributions made. The suggestions will all be taken into very serious account. The Government is very much concerned with the issue of employment opportunities for Ghanaians and it is doing everything already in this direction, mindful of the fact that there is the need to balance all interests so that the project will remain on course.
Nevertheless, all other comments are well appreciated.
Mr. Speaker, we therefore beg to move for the approval of the estimates accordingly.
Question put and motion agreed to.
Resolved:
That this honourable House approves the sum of ¢515,904,000,000 for the services of the Ministry of Energy for the 2006 fiscal year.
ANNUAL ESTIMATES 12:15 p.m.

Dr. A. A. Osei 12:15 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, the HIPC inflows are funds that we generate internally that we would have had to use to pay the debts. So these are not coming from outside. We would have had to take them outside but the funds are generated internally to be sent out. So the use of the word “HIPC inflows” is a misnomer. You generate it internally; it should have gone outside, so they are not inflows, sir.
Mr. Bagbin 12:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is just semantic because he started by saying “the HIPC inflows”. That is how he started -- “the HIPC inflows”. So we know the mechanism involved but definitely it means that we have to depend on that. The whole Energy Ministry is going to depend on that. I just did a bit of mathematics and I saw that it is really going to be stepping on very, very slippery grounds.

Mr. Speaker, I think that we also have to look at priorities again in the Ministry. The SHEPs 3 and 4 have been ongoing for a long time and in fact, the initial procurement of resources such as the poles and the wires have been in the bush and
Chairman of the Committee (Mr. Kwame Osei-Prempeh) 12:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to present the Committee's report.
1.0 Introduction
The 2006 Budget Statement and Economic Policy of the Government was presented to the House by the hon. Minister for Finance and Economic Planning, hon. Kwadwo Baah-Wiredu on Thursday, 10th
November 2005 in accordance with article 179 of the Constitution.
Pursuant to Standing Order 140 (4), Mr. Speaker referred the Budget Estimates of the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs for consideration and report.
1.1 References
The Committee referred to the following documents during the deliberations:
i. The 1992 Constitution of the Republic of Ghana
ii. The Standing Orders of the House
iii. The Budget Statement and Economic Policy of the Government of Ghana for the 2005 Financial Year
iv. The Budget Statement and Economic Policy of the Government of Ghana for the 2006 Financial Year.
1.2 Acknowledgement
The Committee wishes to express gratitude and appreciation to the hon. Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, hon. F. K. Owusu-Adjapong for his active and invaluable participation during the deliberations of the Committee. We hereby express thanks to the officials of the Ministry and the representatives of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning for the information they provided for the Committee.
1 .3 Miss ion S ta tement o f the Ministry for Parliamentary Affairs
The Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs exists to serve as the main link between the Executive and the Legislature.
The Ministry provides supportive services to MDAs whose Ministers are not Members of Parliament, when these
SPACE FOR TABLE 12:35 p.m.

Mr. Mahama Ayariga (NDC - Bawku Central) 12:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to the motion before the House.
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry has some outlined objectives captured on page 2 of the report that has been presented to this
Mr. S. K. B. Manu (NPP - Ahafo Ano South) 12:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I also rise to add my voice to the motion moved by the hon. Minister for Parliamentary Affairs.
Mr. Speaker, there is no doubt that when we talk about democracy in any State, the institution of Parliament is that which epitomizes it. However, Mr. Speaker, this institution in many countries is faced with problems of discharging its functions to merit the role that the institution plays in furtherance of the democratic dispensation of those nations.
When we come home to Ghana, Mr. Speaker, as rightly pointed out by the hon. Minister, the hon. Minister for Parliamentary Affairs liaises with the Executive so that together, collaboratively,
Mr. Emmanuel K. Bandua (NDC --Biakoye) 12:45 p.m.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity to speak to the motion.
I think that inasmuch as the hon. Minister for Parliamentary Affairs needs more resources in order to perform his duties -- he serves as a link between Parliament and the Executive -- I am inclined to believe that because of this dual capacity he finds himself in, sometimes it is very difficult for him to put pressure on the Executive to ensure that some of the benefits that should inure to us do come.
It is because of this that I want to stress on the service conditions for Members of this House. In fact, it has taken such a long time that some of us are getting worried. So we would plead with him that we are not trying to impugn his performance in the House, but we want to say that there is the need for him to do more in order that hon. Members are able to perform their duties more efficiently and effectively.
Mr. Speaker, secondly there are several other things. Like the hon. Member said, we do not have office facilities and these are things that hinder the performance of our duties. The catering facilities in this area are very bad. The way hon. Members of Parliament go to places to eat everywhere -- water, all these things are problems. In fact, if you are the number one Minister, which we all acknowledge, which you have also said, we believe and expect that you give us number one services in this House; otherwise, we may decide to withdraw this title which you have imposed on yourself.
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry plays a very crucial role. Under the Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy II (GPRS), it has been given additional responsibility such as liaising with the various Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs) and even trying to work in concert with the Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development to ensure that problems down there are resolved properly. We would appeal to the hon. Minister for Finance and Economic Planning to give him sufficient resources to enable him go down to the grass roots to ensure that good governance is really understood at the grass roots.
In fact, he has done a really good job in trying to resolve the dispute between some Members of Parliament and the District Chief Executives. In fact, it is a big feather in his cap and we hope that he would continue to ensure that the District Chief Executives do not frustrate Members of Parliament in their effort to bring development down to the grass roots.
I think they also need office facilities. I understand that at the moment, the Ministry for Parliamentary Affairs is operating in an uncompleted building. If that is so, I think that is not good enough.
I would therefore appeal to the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning to ensure that additional resources are given to this Ministry to enable it perform, so that hon. Members of this House would also benefit from the very good services which the hon. Minister is talking about in this House.
Mr. Joseph Yieleh Chireh (NDC - Wa West) 12:55 p.m.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the kindness you have shown to me.
I would urge that we vote for the last time to give the amount that this Ministry has been billed to get. In saying so, I am saying that clearly, we have duplication of functions. If you look at the objectives -- and I would refer to the objective number five -
“To enhance, promote and develop democratic culture among all sections of the people”.
What is the National Commission for Civic Education supposed to be doing?
Mr. Speaker, you go to any of the other places and you would realize that all the objectives that have been given, are given to specific MDAs. Therefore, for a Ministry for Parliamentary Affairs to be created, I think it is anomalous.
Yesterday, I was arguing about the manpower situation we have -- personnel. Now, if you create more institutions, you have difficulty staffing them. You are creating a huge bureaucracy that may not be able to produce all you require. As for the linkages between the Legislature and the Executive, for me, it does not exist; otherwise, by this time the report that we have been clamouring for should have been implemented. If he needs fuel to go to the Castle, maybe, we would all have to contribute from our meagre salaries to give him the fuel to go there.

But Mr. Speaker, I think that it also undermines the whole independence of the Legislature. Why? We have the Parliamentary Service Board. What is the Parliamentary Service Board supposed to be doing? Who is supposed to be doing the investment aspect of developing all the things we are talking about for Parliament? If the Judiciary is independent and their budget is given to them, sometimes untouched, why should the Minister who sits in Cabinet also now be the one we are urging to get more money from the same Executive to help the Legislature stand on its own? It is anomalous.

Rather, we should emphasise the importance of the Parliamentary Service Board. The Speaker, as we know in the hierarchy of persons in this country, is very high. And so for a Minister now to come and tell us the President does not feel fine about this or the Executive thinks otherwise of what we are thinking, I think it is not correct. We should vote massively for this vote so that he implements all the projects immediately, before the end of 2006, so that we do not have any Ministry again called Ministry for Parliamentary

Affairs.

Mr. Speaker, thank you.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
That should bring us to the end of this debate.
Mr. Owusu-Adjapong 12:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I have listened to the concerns of my Colleagues. Definitely, when there a lot of problems we should not be too surprised with these contributions.
As regards the insufficient facilities available, as regards the current level of remuneration, I want to plead that when we come to discuss the motion for the vote for the Office of Parliament, we should look at it so that I would not fall into the same temptation of trying to use the Ministry to respond to matters relating to the Office of Parliament. The best I can say for the moment is that it is not for nothing that even though we listed all the independent bodies together when we were planning for the approval process, we have singled out Office of Parliament and this is because there are a lot of things that we all need to do as to how we manage funding of Parliament.
Happily, we have got some information which had been made available to my Colleague, the Minority Leader and my Colleague, the Majority Chief Whip for them to have a critical look at it. So permit me not to stray into areas that would be handled at Office of Parliament. So whatever limited independence we want to have, as regards the relationship between Parliament and the Executive -- I say “limited” because our Constitution does not guarantee absolute independence, and that is why we have Members of Parliament also being Ministers. At that point, we will discuss this.
Therefore, let me thank you and ask you to be a bit patient; let us do the exercise we are doing as regards the budget for the
Mr. K. A. Okerchiri 12:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, if we may go on to motion No. 19 - Ministry of Health.
ANNUAL ESTIMATES 12:55 p.m.

Mr. First Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
Majority Leader, please the convention is that - [Interruption.]
Mr. Owusu-Adjapong 12:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I got up and when I was not called, I thought you were satisfied with it. But the real thing is that I should ask for your permission, formally, to enable the Deputy
Mr. Owusu-Agyei 12:55 p.m.
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to move, that the sum of ¢4,786,548,000,000 be provided for Recurrent and Capital Expenditure for the Ministry of Health including the National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) for the year ending 31st December, 2006.
This is made up of ¢1,920,133 million from the Government of Ghana (GOG) and ¢838,782 million from our donors, the traditional ¢313,972 million from internally-generated funds, and ¢1,513,660 from the National Health Insurance levy and ¢200 billion from HIPC.
Mr. Speaker, these resources will be used to support the mission of the Ministry of Health, which is to work in collaboration with all partners to ensure that every individual, household and community in Ghana are adequately informed about their health and have access to health and health-related service.
The functions of the Ministry of Health are as follows: promote good health, prevent diseases and injuries, and restore health of the sick and the disabled.
The Ministry of Health is achieving these objectives through increasing access to quality health and nutrition services, ensuring sustainable health-financing arrangements that will check the poor and enhance efficiency in service delivery.
Review Performance in 2005. Mr. Speaker, a review of the Ministry's performance in 2005 concerns the following achievements in 2005. The prevalence rate of HIV/AIDS has dropped from 3.4 per cent to 3.1 per cent in 2005.
No case of polio has been recorded this year. The number of measles cases has dropped from 23,000 in 2000 to less than 20 confirmed cases nationwide, this year. The guinea-worm eradication programme was re-designed to make Ghana free of guinea-worm in the next four years. The number of guinea-worm cases reduced by about 50 per cent compared to the same period last year.
A new anti-malaria drug policy involving the use of ar tesunate- amodiaquine to replace chloroquine, in addition 700,000 insecticide-treated nets and 400,000 table tablets for this treatment were distributed to all age groups, and intermittent preventive treatment was administered to pregnant women.
Mr. Speaker, the National Health Insurance Scheme was made fully operational in 63 of the 123 districts. Fifteen 15 per cent of all Ghanaians had been registered, exceeding the 10 per cent target set for 2005. Five regions are linked to the National Ambulance Service and fifty new ambulances have been procured to expand the programme. Admissions into training schools have been increased by about 25 per cent in 2005.
Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin 1:05 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I can see a strange face and I would want to know whether
or not he is a stranger -- the one seated near the hon. Minister for Education and Sports (Mr. Yaw Osafo-Maafo). I have in fact never seen him here and I would want to know who he is.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:05 p.m.
Well, I do not need to call on you, hon. Majority Leader; I am aware that - [Interruption.]
Mr. Felix Owusu-Adjapong 1:05 p.m.
Mr.
Speaker, I am worried and I wish my hon. Colleague would withdraw this because it means that when we were trying to go to Germany he was not watching what was happening; that is my worry.
Mr. Speakr, to ask who is sitting here when we have qualified to go to Germany means he did not know that after the hon. Minister for Education and Sports (Mr. Yaw Osafo-Maafo), it was the hon. Deputy Minister who has been moving all around to take us to Germany. That is why I am getting a bit worried whether he wants to enquire about the hon. Deputy Minister responsible for Sports, Mr. O. B. Amoah.
Mr. Owusu-Agyei 1:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to continue. Mr. Speaker, a number of infrastructural projects were implemented in 2005. These include, construction of office complexes for Ghana College of Physicians and Surgeons, Food and Drugs Board, Nurses and Midwives Council and National Health Insurance Counci l-- ongoing.
Priorities for 2006
Mr. Speaker, in 2006 the Ministry will consolidate the gains made in 2005 as a basis for scaling up priority health interventions.
Mr. Speaker, the Capital Investment programme will involve the following 1:05 p.m.
Expansion of the training schools;
Procurement of equipment and transport;
Rehabilitation of Bolga Hospital under BADEA will continue;
Implementat ion of ADB III Project at Tarkwa and Bekwai will commence;
Setting up of Blood Transfusion Centres at Tamale, Sekondi, Ho, Korle-Bu and Komfo Anokye will be a major focus for 2006.
Regulation
Mr. Speaker, the institutional and human resource capacities of the regulatory bodies will be strengthened to enable them perform their roles in inspection, monitoring and enforcement of regulations required to ensure good practices and standards.
Collaboration
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry will continue to collaborate with Mission facilities to improve access to quality health services particularly for the people in the rural and the deprived areas. To that end, the Ministry will support selected CHAG institutions in the form of rehabilitation and re-equipping. This will be pursued vigorously in 2006 and the ensuing years.
National Health Insurance Scheme
Mr. Speaker, the National Health Insurance Scheme wil l be made operational in all districts and programmes will be introduced to ensure accelerated registration to cover 50 per cent of the population by the end of 2006. Policy Development
Mr. Speaker, health services delivery in the country has been emphasizing curative service and to a more limited extent preventives service. The Ministry will therefore be developing a new health policy and strategic framework to replace the current health strategy that comes to an end in 2006. The new policy will emphasise preventive and regenerative health and nutrition that aims at ensuring that the people live healthy lives in healthy environments.
Conclusion
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry of Health is requesting for ¢4,786,548,000,000 (four trillion, seven hundred and eighty six billion and five hundred and forty eight million cedis) to meet the planned expenditure. The breakdown of the Ministry's 2006 budget is as follows:
¢1,920,133,000,000 (one trillion, nine hundred and twenty billion, one hundred and thirty-three million cedis) from Government of Ghana;
¢838,782,000,000 (eight hundred and thirty-eight billion, seven hundred and eighty-two million cedis) from Donors;
¢313,972,000,000 (three hundred and thirteen billion, nine hundred and seventy-two million cedis) from Internally Generated Funds
(IGF)
¢200,000,000,000 (two hundred billion cedis) from HIPC, and
¢1,513,660,000,000 (one trillion, five hundred and thirteen billion and six hundred million cedis) from the National Health Insurance Levy
Chairman of Committee (Dr. Francis Osafo-Mensah) 1:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to second the motion.
1.0 Introduction
The hon. Minister for Finance and Economic Planning presented the Budget Statement and Economic Policy of the Government for2006 financial year to the House on Thursday, 10th November 2005.
Pursuant to Standing Order 140(4) and 178, the draft Annual Budget Estimates of the Ministry of Health was referred to the select Committee for consideration and report.
A meeting was held to consider the draft Annual Budget Estimates with the hon. Deputy Ministers for Health, Directors of the sector Ministry and the schedule officer of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning (MOFEP).
The Committee commends them for their assistance.
2.0 Reference Documents
The underlisted documents were used as reference materials:
i. The 1992 Constitution of Ghana,
i i . T h e B u d g e t S t a t e m e n t a n d E c o n o m i c P o l i c y o f the Government of Ghana for 2006 financial year,
i i i . T h e M e d i u m T e r m Expenditure Framework (MTEF) for 2006- 2008 and the Annual Estimates for 2006 (Volume 29) of the Ministry of Health,
iv. The Annua l Es t imates o f the Ministry of Health for 2005; and
v. The Standing Orders of Parliament of Ghana.
3 .0 Miss ion S ta tement o f the Ministry of Health
The Ministry of Health has the following as its Mission Statement:
i. The development and promotion of proactive policies for good health and longevity,
ii. The provision of universal access to basic health services.
Objectives
The Ministry operates by the objectives cited below, in pursuance of its policy within the Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF):
i . To i n c r e a s e g e o g r a p h i c a l and f inancial access to al l basic services for all people living in Ghana,
ii. To provide better quality care in all health facilities and outreach centres,
iii. To improve efficiency at all
levels of the health sector,
iv. To foster closer collaboration a n d p a r t n e r s h i p b e t w e e n the health sector on one hand and communities, other sectors and the private sector,
v. To increase overall resources in the health sector yearly,
vi. To bridge equity gaps in access to quality health services; and
v i i . To e n s u r e s u s t a i n a b l e financial arrangements that protects the poor.
5 . 0 R e v i e w o f t h e Ministry's Performance in 2005
5.1 Funds Allocated
5.2 The House approved the sum of four trillion, two hundred and nine billion, six hundred and ninety million cedis
(¢4,209,690,000,000)
5.3 Programme of Work for 2005.
5.4 The major thrust of health care delivery in 2005 was on:
Disease Prevention and Control;
Improving emergency preparedness;
Improving health service delivery;
Providing support for financing arrangements for the protection of the poor and the vulnerable; and Implementing s trategies for reducing brain drain of key health personnel.
5 .5 Some Achievements of the Ministry in 2005.
APPENDIX A 1:15 p.m.

Mr. G. Otchere (NPP Ayensuano) 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I have a small observation to make.
Mr. Speaker, I think we need to expand the nursing training colleges so that we can take more nurses and dispose of them as we do to footballers. These days, you will realise that all our nurses and our para-medical staff are leaving our shores to other countries. So I believe if we are able to take more nurses in our training colleges, it will serve as a good opportunity for encouraging our young people to be trained as nurses.
Mr. Speaker, if you look at the eastern corridor of this country, you will realise that there are more articulated trucks packed by the roadside. Only God knows what happens under the cover of darkness.

So we urge the Ministry to collaborate with the National AIDS Commission so that we would intensify their programme between Nsawam and Suhum; that will give some opportunity to some of our women living around that area.

I therefore, support the approval of the amount that has been allocated to the Ministry of Health.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu (NDC - Tamale South) 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to associate myself with the motion and to urge hon. Members to massively support the approval of the said amount for the Ministry of Health, recognizing that we need to strengthen our health institutions. We need to develop our health
infrastructure and also to improve upon the human resource capacity for an effective health delivery system.
But Mr. Speaker, in doing so, I would like to refer to page 6 of your Committee's Report, item 7.4, on Capital Investment. Mr. Speaker, the Tamale Regional Hospital, as you may be aware, has now been elevated to a teaching hospital or, better still, a referral hospital, which is supposed to serve the health needs of the people of not just the Northern Region but also the entire northern Ghana.
Mr. Speaker, as you also may be aware, the Tamale Regional Hospital has become so important a health institution that is to support the University for Development Studies Medical Training Programme. If you look at the Committee's Report we are expressing concern about the weakness in the human resource base, yet we have institutions such as the University for Development Studies which is helping in churning out qualified medical doctors.
Mr. Speaker, for the last four years, students who are supposed to undergo clinicals at the Tamale Teaching Hospital, because of the sorry state of the hospital, are compelled to be transferred either to the Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital or to the Korle-bu Teaching Hospital. Mr. Speaker that has undermined the capacity of the University of Development Studies and it almost resulted in the near collapse of the medical school.
Mr. Speaker, if you visited the regional hospital, at best, I can describe it as being in a sorry state, sorry state because even the stench at the laundry is as bad as that which is in the mortuary. And if you visited even the physical infrastructure since 1974 not much has been seen. The hospital currently has a population of less than 20 medical doctors when, in fact, the minimum should be about 40 doctors.
So one would have expected that under Capital Investment Government would have made a specific commitment to the rehabilitation of the Tamale Regional Hospital, not only to befit the status of a referral hospital but also of a teaching hospital, in order to support the University of Development Studies Medical School. But if you take your Committee's Report it only says “development of new projects in deprived areas.” Mr. Speaker, where? Deprived areas in Ghana? Juabeso, through Tamale through Bongo are all deprived areas.
It lacks specifics as to what is to be done in this area. I think that the Tamale Regional Hospital needs an urgent intervention if we are to provide the people there with access to medical care.
Mr. Speaker, I may now move on to my second issue about the Ministry's mandate. As you may be aware, this House in 2003 approved the National Health Insurance Act. Under the Act we were informed by the Minister for Finance and Economic Planning in his Budget Statement that Government expects ¢1.3 trillion as money accruing from the Health Insurance Levy. Mr. Speaker, somewhere in June this year this House had the responsibility to approve the disbursement under the National Health Insurance Scheme.
Mr. Speaker, I can remember too well that when the House met we approved an amount of ¢139 billion for the purpose or for use of indigenes, poor people as was categorised in the Report. I can remember the hon. Deputy Minister for Finance and Economic Planning who facilitated the approval of that request here. We also additionally approved ¢40 billion for the aged. We also approved an additional ¢160 billion for people under
Mr. Speaker, I shudder to ask 1:25 p.m.
Where is the money that this honourable House approved? Unless of course the Minister for Health and his agencies are in contempt of this House, we cannot approve money for them to disburse. Yet the District Health Mutual Insurance Scheme having received the money as at September even though the approval was done in June, the Minister for Finance and Economic Planning comes to this House to say that, yes, we expect ¢1.3 trillion --
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Hon. Member, you should be landing by now.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:25 p.m.
I certainly will do, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister gave a directive that consultancy work on the National Health Insurance Scheme be suspended. This House would want to know the status of the suspension order he gave. Mr. Speaker, all the money is going into individual pockets by way of bureaucracy. The people of this country deserve access to quality medical care and I think that if it was effectively implemented - [Interruption]
Dr. A. A. Osei 1:25 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, my young hon. Colleague has just made a categorical statement that all the money is going into peoples pockets. Mr. Speaker, this is a very serious allegation and if he does not have the evidence the whole of the nation is listening to him. We do not want to think that we are misleading Ghanaians so he should honourably withdraw that statement, unless he has the evidence right now.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I think I will qualify it with “most of the money”, goes into consultancy. [Interruption] Mr. Speaker, if they are not comfortable with that, then “much of the money.” - [Interruptions.]
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Hon. Iddrisu, let us be a little bit serious. I think you need to withdraw for us to make progress.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I have evidence that much of the money has gone into consultancy. We have forgotten that when we met in June we approved a large amount of money for the bureaucracy.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Hon. Member, your hon. Colleague has challenged you that you made a categorical statement that all the money is going into private pockets.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, some of the money goes into - Mr. Speaker, I withdraw “all” and substitute it with “some.”
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Hon. J.H.
Mensah, it has been a long time that we heard your voice.
Mr. J. H. Mensah 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, the hon. Member cannot take refuge in these words. We hire people to do work for the National Health Service and they must be paid. Therefore, necessarily a lot of that money will go into people's pocket. The budget for Health is dominated by payment for personnel service and therefore to create an impression of wrong-doing by just saying some of the money just goes into people's pockets -- It is the implication behind it that there is something un toward happening; that is what he wanted to convey and that is totally unjustifiable, unless he can say that there is unjustifiable diverting of money into people's pockets -- unjustifiable -- and he has not a singular of evidence to sustain such a proposition. Therefore, he should just withdraw and carry on with his submission.
Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin 1:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I agree that to use the word “all” could actually be misleading, and he has withdrawn the word “all.” No, he says he is replacing it with “some.” Now that makes people uncomfortable again. But what hon. the Senior Minister has just said, if he wants evidence to be produced to let him know that some of the money is entering unjustifiably into the pockets of people, we can do that. We can to that on the National Health Insurance Scheme.
Mr. Speaker, but to always insist that we should produce the evidence here - [Interruption] - That is not how things are debated in Parliament. You cannot carry all documents on you to Parliament to debate and to be producing evidence. If there is an issue and then one needs time to produce evidence one is given the time. It cannot be said that one is to produce the evidence here, you are to prove it here, it is not done.
Mr. J. H. Mensah 1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, all
we would request in that case is that you give the hon. Member till Tuesday to produce the evidence in this House.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Hon. J.
H. Mensah, what did you say? I did not hear exactly what you said.
. J. H. Mensah: Mr. Speaker, I was
saying that the hon. Member wants to plead justification and that they have evidence, and what I would like to suggest is that we should request the hon. Member to suspend his statement for the time being and produce the evidence on Tuesday, and repeat that statement with the evidence.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Hon.
Member for Tamale South, are you taking the challenge?
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker,
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
No, hold
on, hon. Member for Tamale South -
Mr. Haruna 1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I accept the challenge.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Then
please take your seat for a while, for the five minutes that you say you are capable of producing it, I will come back to you. Yes, any other hon. Member who wants to contribute towards this debate?
Deputy Minister for Tourismj and
Modernization of the Capital City (Mr. S. Asamoah-Boateng): Mr. Speaker, I would like to support the motion on the floor for the approval of the Estimates for the Ministry of Health.
Mr. J. Y. Chireh 1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
You do
not have any point, could you take your seat?
Mr. Chireh 1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I think that - [Interruption.]
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Hon.
Yieleh Chireh, you are out of order.
Mr. Asamoah-Boateng 1:35 p.m.
Thank
you, Mr. Speaker, for allowing me to continue. Most people do create the erroneous impression that the budget of the Ministry is always dominated by the figure on emoluments - salary payments to personnel within the Health Service. But Mr. Speaker, as my Colleague, hon. J. H. Mensah just said, it is true that to deliver a quality health service in any society you need to find the people to do it; if the people are not there, there will be no service.
And in fact, you need to find the people and pay them to remain and provide the service we are looking for. Rather than the expression that we do need to spend money on investment - that we all appreciate, but you cannot ignore the human factor. And so if the emoluments aspect or Item 1 is always heavy, we must find a way to justify it; and for the service we are looking for we need the people there.
My hon. Colleague, the hon. Minister for Education and Sports has just told me that, for instance, in education if you build the school structure and you do not pay the teacher there will not be any school system available. So we need to find the money, and for that reason we do have to justify the emoluments.
Mr. Speaker, I just want to make a few suggestions on the Health Service before I take my seat. We do have a situation where our health personnel, when we train them, find their way outside the country and this is classified as brain drain. We have been talking about it. Mr. Speaker,
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Yes, the
hon. Member for Tamale South is back. I saw you coming in and still you could have the floor.
rose rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
The hon.
Member has the floor so please could you allow him to make his point.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker,
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Hon.
Member, is that all your reason for saying so?
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:35 p.m.
In fact, as we
are speaking, Mr. Speaker, they have fired the Executive Secretary of the National Health Insurance Scheme. We invested a lot of money in training him; we need to know the circumstances leading to his exit. If not because of the reasons I have raised, he ought to have remained as the Chief Executive.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
Yes, let
me go back to the hon. J. H. Mensah. What do you have to say to that before I make a ruling?
Mr. J. H. Mensah 1:45 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I am very much concerned about the impressions that the hon. Member is seeking to create. He has quoted these figures; he has then by implication suggested that these are improper in some way. That is the crux of the argument. What is there so improper about informing the House that in the Budget for the National Health Service it is proposed to spend so much money on this, so much money on that? If he has evidence, not only that he disagrees with it, he can disagree with it as much as he likes, nobody cares. But if he has evidence of impropriety then he can justifiably bring these figures to the House and sustain them by producing the evidence of impropriety.
Mr. Speaker, this way of misleading the
House and the public and everything and creating despondency about the National Health Service should not be allowed to remain on the record of this House like that. It is a disgrace.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon.
Minister, I thought you wanted to say something?
Mr. Osafo-Maafo 1:45 p.m.
Yes, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Bagbin 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I supported the hon. Member and I said that we would produce evidence to show that moneys wrongly got into pockets and that there was impropriety in the usage of some of the moneys that were accrued unto the National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS); and the hon. Senior Minister gave Tuesday and I agreed that we can produce the documents to support the allegation.
That was what the hon. Minister proposed and that is my position. His position, he thought, was just talking about the usage of the money on the bureaucracy, that is why he was going to rely on the Hansard to support his point, and the fact that the Executive Secretary has been dismissed. That was what he raised. But I went to the second length of what the hon. Senior Minister was saying and said that by Tuesday we can produce documents
Mr. J. H. Mensah 1:45 p.m.
On a point of order.
Mr. Speaker, the contributor to the debate was the hon. Member for Tamale South. If the hon. Minority Leader wants to make a submission of his own, let him do so; but it is not in accordance with our procedures that he should substitute himself for the hon. Member for Tamale South. The hon. Member for Tamale South sits on one seat; the Minority Leader sits on one seat. He should justify what he says on the floor and not just carry on with wild allegations - [Interruption.] He said he would do it in a short period. What he has produced does not do it. [Interruptions]
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon.
Members, let us take it a little easy.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hold on,
I have not yet called you. You have just read your proof to the hearing of all of us in this Chamber and I believe you stand by it. There are two issues before the House now. First of all, your own assertion that you did say “all” the money go into private pockets -- Of course, you did change your position along the line, that “some…” and so forth -- I did ask you if that we should allow you a little time to do that.
Indeed, you said you would take the challenge and we should allow you only five (5) minutes but your proof, of course, does not amount to any proof. All that you are saying is that some people who work for Government, particularly for the health sector are paid. I do not believe that is what you want the House to believe, that this is what you referred to as money going into private sector unjustifiably. That is one issue and I believe you have to definitely withdraw that. It is improper; it is not part of our rules here.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Yes, I
have given you the floor.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, thank you very much. I have listened to
your sermons and the reference I made - [Interruptions.] Yes, the Speaker's sermons. [Interruptions.]
An hon. Member: The Speaker's sermons?
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:45 p.m.
Why?
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Let him continue, allow him.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:45 p.m.
That is how I construe his words of advice.
Mr. Speaker, I was not making conclusions based on my reference to the figures. I would prove with evidence. I think that - [Interruption.] Mr. Speaker, when they are barbering you, you do not touch your head. They are being impatient.
Mr. Speaker, if you look at the reference I made, I wanted to tie it to my evidence. We approved subsidies for exemptions and all the money was approved to support District Health Insurance Schemes. Mr. Speaker, I have in my hands The Ghanaian Times of Tuesday, November 29th, 2005 and Mr. Speaker, with your permission I beg to quote:
“District Health Insurance Schemes face collapse.”
In it I have reason to raise impropriety because Parliament approved the funding to support District Health Mutual Insurance Schemes in June. This was the plea of the Navrongo District Health Insurance Scheme, and with your permission I beg to quote:
“The Schemes are desperately trying to access the administrative funds and subsidies that they are entitled to under the National Health Insurance Act, 2003.”
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon.
Member, my ruling is that you should withdraw. The ruling is that the evidence that you were given the opportunity to provide to this House does not amount to evidence. That is the Chair's conviction and I am asking you on that ground to withdraw what you said and apologise.
1. 55 p.m.
Mr. Haruna Iddrisu 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, the
connotation of impropriety is withdrawn. Mr. Speaker, I conclude. Mr. Speaker, finally, the issue of enrolled nurses - Mr. Speaker, one basic theory -- We all complain about brain drain. I think that the Ministry of Health must adopt a new strategy to train more. And in my view, Mr. Speaker -- I am glad that the hon. Minister for Education and Sports is here - We should begin to strengthen the nurses training colleges as diploma awarding institutions and possibly place them under the Ministry of Education and Sports because if they were under the Ministry of Education and Sports they also could source the GETFund to support health infrastructure.
With these comments, Mr. Speaker, I
support the motion for the approval of the funds and ask that the Ministry of Health should institute a forensic audit into the National Health Insurance Fund from the period 2003 to 2005. That will better guide in helping me with the evidence that I badly need to support the assertions that
I have made.
Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin (Minority
Leader): Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, in my contribution in support of the motion, I want us to seriously consider a number of issues. Mr. Speaker, we all accept the fact that you only have a healthy mind in a healthy body and that it is a healthy nation that can create wealth. In fact, they say health is wealth. Mr. Speaker, we have all accepted that and I believe we are trying as much as possible to focus our efforts to achieve that objective.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon. Bagbin, just a minute before you continue. Hon. Members, it is about a few minutes to two o'clock and the Leadership has advised that instead of having a double Sitting, we are going to have an extended Sitting. So I am informing the House. Continue, hon. Minority Leader.
Mr. Bagbin 1:45 p.m.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, I was saying that I was expecting the Chairman of the Committee to explain paragraph six of their report but he did not. This is because he said that - and I quote:
“An amount o f ¢4 ,786 ,548 million has been allocated to the Ministry of Health as indicated in Appendix A. However, summation of the components stated in the budget Statement gives a figure of ¢4,786,547 million.”
That is a different figure. But throughout the report no explanation has been given as to why the difference and then at the end of the day we are being asked to approve the figure that does not tally with the actual data in the budget. I thought that the hon. Chairman should
have given some explanation but that did not come.
Mr. Speaker, I also want to draw the attention of the Committee and the Ministry to the Budget Statement that was read here, especially paragraphs 737 and 738, where again we are having problems with data. In paragraph 737, the statement spoke about the establishment of the National Health Insurance Schemes.
In fact, it said that by the close of October 2005, 123 schemes had been set up throughout the country. Then the next paragraph, they said that their expectations were that by the end of December, 2005 all the schemes that would have been established would be 121. There are contradictions there; they need to look at that and reconcile them.
But it is important, Mr. Speaker, for
us to look at two critical issues. We are talking about conditions of service for the personnel in the health service and we are told that ninety per cent of what is being allocated is going into emoluments.
Mr. Speaker, but we know that condit ions of service go beyond emoluments. And as much as we want to support that there is also the urgent need for us to refocus on the health sector. Because for me, I believe that the health sector is the number one priority of this nation, not education. Education ranks second, because without good health, you can never be educated. I strongly believe that we have to look at that seriously. In fact, a visit to very senior medical officers at the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital would show that the flats they live in are completely an eyesore.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon. Theresa Tagoe, Member of Parliament for Ablekuma South?
Ms. Tagoe 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, on a point of order. I would like to know when he last visited them because the Social Security and National Insurance Trust (SSNIT) has built a lot of new bungalows, across the Ndafa Park. Probably, he does not know that. So if he goes there, he will see the difference. Even the young doctor who died was a junior officer and was living in one of the flats. So he go there and see. The senior officers are not in flats; they are in bungalows all over the place. That is my constituency, please; I have the command - [Interruption.] -
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon. Theresa Tagoe that does not amount to a point of order. Allow the hon. Minority Leader to continue.
Mr. Bagbin 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I was there on Monday this week. Hon. Theresa Tagoe, I was there on Monday this week.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon. Minority Leader, please address the Chair. Ignore her heckling and address the Chair.
Mr. Bagbin 1:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, that is her constituency and I want her to listen and maybe take up the issue. I was there this week I visited Senior Medical Officers and they are living in flats that befit the description I am giving. I can give her the names of the doctors and she can go and see for herself because it is an eyesore and I believe that we should do something about it. I am raising that because I also believe a larger chunk of the money should go into things like administration and investment.
I know it is a service and that is why sometimes I am afraid, the Ministry tries to extend its mandate beyond manageable limits. When the hon. Minister himself was talking about placing more emphasis on preventive health, that is a good area, it strays into other sectors such as local government because if you are talking about sanitation and the rest. I think that we should not bite more than we can chew. And I think that the Ministry should reconsider that policy because for us we see health service as one of curative treatment. The preventive is important but a lot of it belongs to other sectors -- works and housing, local government and the rest. So I do not want the assumption of extra duties. That is my humble opinion.
Mr. Speaker, it is important that in looking at this budget, we look at some of the things we have been saying all around. Others have pinpointed it and I am aware that in my region what has been constantly drummed home is that there is the construction of a regional hospital for the region. We do not still have a regional hospital, we rely on the municipal hospital at Wa. And throughout this budget there is no provision for that but it has been stated many times by officers of the Ministry, by high ranking government officials. I think that that issue has to be looked at.
Mr. Bagbin 2:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I also believe that - Yes, I listened to the hon. Senior Minister the other time talk about and it is repeated in the Budget the payment of Additional Duty Hour Allowance (ADHA). Yes, there is the need for us to rationalize it but the rationalization should not be such that we would be reducing the benefit to the staff.
It is very, very important. The rationalization should not reduce what goes to the staff. It is important that we continue to increase and improve the
remuneration and benefits that go to the workers there. I had hoped that my hon. Friend, Mr. Asamoah-Boateng would have continued the efforts of the Home-Coming Summit. It is through such interventions that we are able to iron out properly how to situate people such as medical staff and other professionals who leave the country. But as I told you in my speech in April 2001, it was going to be a nine-day wonder because people did not understand the rationale before they jumped on board. It seems I have been justified.
Mr. Asamoah-Boateng 2:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker,
I want to correct my hon. Colleague that I do appreciate the context in which he put the Home-Coming Summit but he is misleading the House.
Mr. Speaker, the Home-Coming

No, not him alone but others like him. But it is still ongoing and there is a Secretariat at the Ghana Investment Promotion Centre (GIPC) headed by one of my colleagues. So the work is still ongoing but speed needs to be brought in which my colleague - [Interruption] -
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
So your
point is that it is not a nine-day wonder?
Mr. Asamoah-Boateng 2:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is not.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Very well.
Well, again thank you Mr. Speaker; it is on the back burner and it will come up one day. But he is aware that I contributed seriously towards the success of the programme. Infact, the documents as he is aware, were already prepared and contacts were mad and he continued that policy; and congratulated him for that.
But it is important that we do not let it slip back; it is a very good source of income. In fact, other countries like Pakistan get over $8 billion per year in that kind of programme and the Phillipines is earning far more than that and that is why they have reached low middle-income level whilst we are still struggling down there.
Mr. Speaker, I would want to urge my hon. Colleagues to also try to support the District Health Insurance Schemes and the District Health Programmes by sponsoring some of the Personnel in the Health Sector. We could support the trainees in the health institutions; we could support the medical students when they are traveling for their electives -- they struggle a lot to get funding. If we are able to support and encourage them, at least, we could get some agreement with them to, for instance, serve for some years in our districts before they move out of the districts.
So Mr. Speaker, it is a proposal that I think we should consider. I believe seriously that the provision that is in the budget is on the low side. Because we may see that ¢4.7 trillion is huge but the national Budget definitely is above ¢36
trillion and I believe that more should go to the Health Sector than we have. It is with this that I have no option than to support the small amount and maybe pray that in future we could reconsider and improve upon the allocation to the Ministry of Health.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Hon. Deputy Minister, could you wind up.
Mr. Owusu-Adjei 2:05 p.m.
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I wish to thank all hon. Members for the tremendous interest they have shown in the Ministry of Health Estimates. I have taken on board all the observations and comments which have been raised on the Ministries budget. But I would want to respond to just a few of them since it would not be necessary to respond to everything.
The first thing I want to react to is the difference of 1 million in the Ministry's budget. The total budget figure is as hon. Members see, but the ¢1 million came as a result of , should I put it, simple arithmetic error, particularly when you add up the decimal points. Where the decimal points fall below a certain figure then when you add them up it comes to something lower. That is why in the Budget Statement itself that figure is indicated as we can see; if you add up it shows a shortfall of ¢1 million cedis.
We have noted that and we have called the attention of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning to it - [Interruptions] It was spotted at the committee level and we have called their attention to it.
Mr. Speaker, I wanted to respond to a few more of the issues raised but my hon. Colleagues are saying that since I have taken everything on board I had better ended here.
ANNUAL ESTIMATES 2:15 p.m.

Minister for Education and Sports (Mr. Yaw Osafo-Maafo) 2:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I beg to move that this House approves the sum of ¢8,278,571,000,000 for the services of the Ministry of Education and Sports for the 2006 fiscal year.
Mr. Speaker, the request is made up
of the Government of Ghana (GOG) component of ¢5,360,469,000 and ¢408,601,000 from donors. It also used ¢1,386,300,000 from the GETFund and ¢300,000,000 from HIPC Relief Fund and ¢813,201,000 from internally generated fund. We therefore sought to put all together with the amount given.
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry of Education
and Sports has three implementing agencies under the sector and these are, the Ghana Education Service responsible for pre-tertiary educational programmes, the National Council for Tertiary Education in charge of tertiary education programmes and the National Sports Council responsible for the formulation and promotion of sporting policies and programme in this country.
The three agencies have been allocated
approximately 93.1 per cent of the GOG and donor budget of the Ministry. There are other relatively small and implementing agencies namely, the Non- formal Education Division, the National Service Secretariat, Ghana Library Board, Ghana Book Development Council, the West African Examination Council, Ghana National Commission for UNESCO, National Co-ordinating Committee for Technical and Vocational Education and Training.
Mr. Speaker, it is clear that this Ministry
is big. The Ministry therefore has one Minister of State and three Deputies who have been assigned specific roles. These seven agencies together with four Directorates of the main Ministry have been allocated 6.4 per cent of the Ministry's budget for 2006. The main Ministry is responsible for the formulation, co- ordination and monitoring and supervision of the efficient management of projects in the education sector.
Mr. Speaker, development of our human
resource continues to be at the centre of this Government's developmental agenda and it was very clear from the State of the Nation Address that, that is the number one priority of the Government.
Mr. Speaker, if education goes well it
even reduces the health budget; if hygiene is taken up very seriously at very basic levels, its consequences are enormous. Mr. Speaker, education is the measure of our own development and therefore this Government has decided to go through an educational reform that will commence the year 2007. Therefore, certain measures have to be taken to get ourselves prepared for that occasion. And a number of steps are being taken to do exactly that.
Mr. Speaker, in the course of last
year 53 districts were put together and they were provided with what we call the capitation grant; and the results were
very positive. The enrolment at the primary level in these deprived districts increased from 76 per cent to 80.12 per cent. And between 2002 - 2005, this experiment enabled the Government to roll out capitation grants throughout the whole country. And therefore, from the beginning of this year, 13th September -- At the beginning of this year capitation grant was introduced nationwide.
Mr. Speaker, we are very happy with
the results because the idea was to indeed improve on access to education. Therefore, we are expecting improvement in enrolment and we had projected an increase of about 30 per cent countrywide. We are still gathering data but data reaching us so far indicates that in many villages in the deprived areas, enrolment in Primary One (P1) has doubled. And I noted that just around Amasaman, as many as about 26 per cent of those who enrolled in class one were above the age of eleven, which is a clear indication that people were not going to school because they could not afford it; and we are very happy with this result.
We hope that when we gather all the data, which will be by the end of December, we would be able to say that the capitation grant has indeed improved access to education. This of course is not without cost. Because these number have increased, Mr. Speaker, we may have to run shift in some primary one classes within this country and therefore also increase the number of teachers; and this will finally also affect infrastructural additions to the school.
Mr. Speaker, this year the computerized
school selection and placement system was also put into operation. There have been a number of criticisms and we have taken all of them on board and I can assure my hon. Colleagues that we will certainly

refine the system and improve upon it. We must look ahead and we must improve upon the whole system of placement; the computerized school selection and placement system has come to stay and I would want to emphasize that.

Indeed, Mr. Speaker, the year before

when we used the manual system, a total number of 130,000 pupils were placed in the second cycle schools. This year we placed a total of 158,600 and in some very good schools like Presec, Prempeh College, Mfantsipim and Achimota, parents danced around when the schools reopened. They never hoped that they would find their wards there but the computer has placed them there because of performance.

And I think this way of doing things provides better access for all of us and it should be encouraged. We are aware of the role old boys and girls play in these schools and we are aware of the role of churches, the chiefs et cetera. Next year we would take all these into consideration to give it a better human face.

Mr. Speaker, as we embark on the

educational reform, training colleges become our number one priority and therefore we sought this year to concentrate on improving the training colleges to prepare teachers coming out to be such that they themselves can implement the reform. We have 38 training colleges in Ghana, 15 of them have been selected to specialize in addition to their regular courses on mathematics, and science and technology and therefore we are providing these 15 training colleges with additional science laboratories and equipment.

We are providing to each training college in Ghana a library, which is important for our faculty development. And because of the problem associated with teaching practice and transportation, we are providing for each training college

in Ghana a bus.

Mr. Speaker, I am happy to say that

almost all the buses for the training colleges have arrived in the country and at least 30 of them would be given out next week.

We have been faced with a very serious

problem of study leave with pay. We have a situation where those applying for study leave with pay are far more than those coming in and this poses a problem.

Last year, whereas 15,750 people had applied for study leave with pay, all the thirty eight training colleges in this country were having a total output of 8,200. And therefore, if you allowed the study leave with pay to go un-monitored, we are going to have a minimum of 7,500 empty classrooms. That is not the way out and, therefore, we introduced the quota system a couple of years ago; we are refining the quota system.

And I am happy to note that when the quota system was decentralized for this year's admissions there were no complaints. And therefore, we have decided, based on Alhaji Gbadomoshi's recommendations -- it was a committee of enquiry to decentralize this quota system so that the decisions are made at the districts; we experimented it and it worked.

But to make teachers also have access to training - teachers need continuous education -- we have to now support distance education. The Government has decided that in the next academic year, it will pay the total tuition fee involved in distance education for teachers, as long as they go through some guidelines. We have selected subjects which will attract

this full scholarship. Certainly, if one is going to do a subject

that cannot be taught in the classroom, one cannot enjoy that kind of scholarship. And therefore, we have the guidelines for it and as long as one is within those guidelines, tuition would be made free for one to take his or her study leave.

Mr. Speaker, I think that everybody

is very much concerned about tertiary education in this country and the Government has allocated nine hundred and forty-nine billion and forty one million cedis for tertiary education in this country. This is about 16.4 per cent of the total budget and as expected, about eighty four per cent of this budget is for personal emoluments. In the overall educational budget, eighty nine per cent is for personal emoluments and as had been expressed because education and health basically provide service, we expect that ratio. But we need of course to catch up with infrastructure.

Mr. Speaker, the main problem facing

our tertiary education in this country is that enrolment has not caught up with infrastructural development and this is creating a lot of problems for all the universities. And therefore, we have voted a lot of money, for the next five years, to improve on infrastructure on our university campuses and technical schools. It is a necessity.

We know that some of our development partners are not happy with the level of investments we are making in tertiary education, but it is necessary because enrolment had gone up to a level which had not been caught up by infrastructural development and we think that we need to do this.

We note a major problem faced

by students in the universities is that of movement within the campuses. If you take some of the universities, their

laboratories, lecture halls, residential halls, et cetera, are distances apart and sometimes they have very little time to move in-between. And therefore, we are experimenting within three campuses at the moment -- campuses of the University of Ghana, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, University of Development Studies, University of Education, Winneba and the University of Cape Coast -- intra-university buses to provide service to students to move very easily within the campuses. This we believe will remove some of the problems facing our students.

On the sporting side, Mr. Speaker,

the Government will continue to provide support for the sports side and in this year's budget, forty seven billion two hundred and sixty-six thousand cedis has been set aside for promoting sporting activities in this country. We would, in the case of the sporting side also, depend on corporate bodies for support, because sporting activities all over the world, especially football, are funded partially from the corporate world. And we are going to promote a lot of that kind of interest to get money from the corporate world to support our sporting activities.

Mr. Speaker, following the qualification

of our national football team, the Black Stars, for the 2006 World Cup Tournament in Germany -- the nation's first ever - all the needed support and attention have been drawn to this and we need a lot of resources to prepare the Black Stars for Germany. We have received so far, quite a generous support from various donors. We have about three hundred million cedis from the banking institutions basically which have already come. Ghana Commercial Bank gave us a hundred million and opened a special account for people to add to it.
Minister for Education and Sports (Mr. Yaw Osafo-Maafo) 2:25 p.m.


Zenith Bank gave us one hundred and twenty million cedis, Areeba gave us a hundred million cedis. The responses to our preparations to Germany 2006, I will say, are very positive and we want to use the media to continue to appeal for more support.

I am also happy to note that the German Government has kindly agreed to allow the team and its handlers to have ten days in Germany, free of charge, both in accommodation and facilities, to support their training. We are all very grateful to the German Government for this kind gesture to us and we will make full use of it. Get there much earlier and then eat, drink and train free of charge for, at least ten days.

Mr. Speaker, as I said, education is

the number one priority and we are very determined to make it function, and function well. Each one of us here in this House is concerned about education and I am very encouraged about the kind of interaction I have had from Colleagues on their attempt to improve educational facilities in their constituencies. We will continue to provide them with all the support they need.

Members of Parliament were given some special support under the GETFund through the District Directors of Education.

I am surprised to note that only eighty- six of our Members indeed made use of the facility; and we have a few weeks to go to the end of the year. My appeal to my Colleagues is that collaborating with their district directorates, they would be entitled to something to support them towards education in their respective constituencies; and let us make use of this as a matter of urgency.

Mr. Speaker, with these comments, I beg to move, that the House approves ¢8,278,571,000,000, to support the
Chairman of the Committee (Mr. S. K. B. Manu) 2:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to second the motion and to present the Report of the Committee on Education, Youth and Sports.
1.0 Introduction
Further to the presentation of the 2006 Budget Statement and Economic Policy of the Government by the hon. Minister for Finance and Economic Planning on Thursday 10th November, 2005, and subsequent Motion for its adoption, the Annual Estimates for the fiscal year 2006 of the Ministry of Education and Sports was referred to the Joint Committee on Education, Youth, Sports and Culture for consideration and report pursuant to Orders 140 (4) 186 and 187 of the Standing Orders of the House and article 179 of the Constitution.
1.1 Committee Sitting
The Committee held a number of meetings to consider the Estimates of the Ministry. Those who assisted the Committee in this endeavor were the Minister for Education and Sports and his technical team as well as officials from the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning. The Committee is grateful to the Minister and all the officials for their extensive cooperation in this regard.
2.0 Reference Document
The following documents were used as reference guide during the Committee's deliberations:
(a) The 1992 Constitution of Ghana
( b ) T h e S t a n d i n g O r d e r s o f the Parliament of Ghana
( c ) T h e B u d g e t S t a t e m e n t a n d E c o n o m i c P o l i c y o f the Government of Ghana for the 2005 financial year.
( d ) T h e B u d g e t S t a t e m e n t s a n d E c o n o m i c P o l i c y o f the Government of Ghana for the December 2006 financial year.
(e) The Draft Annual Estimates of the Ministry of Education and Sports for the 2005 financial year.
(f) The Draft Annual Estimates of the Ministry of Education and Sports for the 2006 Financial Year.
3.0 Mission Statement and Objectives
The Ministry of Education and Sports exists to provide relevant education to all Ghanaians at all levels irrespective of gender, tribe, religion and/or political affiliation to ensure national development and also formulate and implement policies to accelerate Sports development for all Ghanaians to achieve national integration and international recognition. In pursuit of this, the Ministry will provide:
i. Basic education for all
ii. Education and training for skill development with emphasis on science, technology and creativity
i i i . Higher educa t ion for the development of middle and top level manpower requirements
iv. Facilities to ensure that citizens are functionally literate and self-reliant.
In providing these services, the Ministry will be guided by the under-listed values:
a. Quality education
b. Efficient management of resources
c. Accountability and transparency
Consequently, the Ministry seeks to achieve following objectives:
i. To enhance the quality of teaching and learning
i i . To increase access to and participation in education and training
iii. To upgrade and extend technical and vocational, agricultural and business education and training
iv. To promote good health and environmental sanitation in schools
v. To strengthen governance, planning and resource management within the education sector
vi. To promote and extend provision of science and technology education and training
v i i . To i m p r o v e t h e q u a l i t y and relevance of academic and research programmes.
v i i i . To p romote and ex tend p rov i s ion o f Sc ience and Technology Educat ion and Training.
ix. To promote and extend Pre-School Education
x . To p r o v i d e g i r l s w i t h equal opportunities to access full cycle of education.
xi. To Identify and promote education programme that will assist in the prevention and management of
HIV/AIDS.
xi i . To promote Good Heal th and Environmental Sanitation in schools and Institutions of Higher Learning.
xiii. To facilitate the provision of spor ts and recreat ional facilities in deprived communities.
x i v . T o s t r e n g t h e n t h e existing management system for optimum sports development
x v . T o p r o m o t e p r i v a t e sector involvement in sports develop- ment; and
xv i . To r e sea r ch , f o rmu la t e , monitor and evaluate policies to create enabling condition for sports development.
4.0 Review of Performance in 2005
Education Sub-Sector
In 2005, the focus was on activities leading to increasing access to education, improving the quality of education delivery and ensuring the attainment of gender parity in schools.
The Education Strategic Plan (ESP) was vigorously implemented to facilitate among other things, the attainment of the targets of Universal Primary Completion earlier than the target year of 2015, and Gender Parity in schools by the end of the year.
As a result, the following achievements were recorded:
National Primary Gross Enrolment
TABLE 2:25 p.m.

TABLE 2:25 p.m.

Mr. A. N. Tettey-Enyo (NDC - Ada) 2:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I rise to support the motion that this House approves the sum of ¢8,278,571,000,000 for the services of the Ministry of Education and Sports for the 2006 fiscal year.
In supporting this motion, I wish -
Mr. J. Y. Chireh 2:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, a point
of correction or clarification. My copy of the Report does not have page 2 and since we are going to discuss it, I thought that something should be said about that.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Can you
collaborate with your other Friends sitting by you. Or is it general? Is it that all Members have not got that page?
Mr. Chireh 2:35 p.m.
I conferred with a number
of my Colleagues here and there is no page 2, so we do not know what is on page 2. And since we are discussing it,
Mr. Speaker, I think that we should do things properly. That is why I raised it
.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Chairman
of Committee, what do you say to that?
Mr. Manu 2:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is a genuine
observation he has made and I am even asking myself why I did not see it. But my copy does not have it either. However, if you look at that page, it contains the continuation of documents we used in doing our work and the objectives, which is standardized and well known. It does not affect the figures of the budget and I think we can safely pass the budget without that page. I submit, Sir.
Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin 2:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it
is important that this be made available; not now. We can go on with the debate but it is necessary for the Official Report, because definitely his report will have to be fully captured in the Official Report.
Mr. Manu 2:35 p.m.
In ten minutes, I will make sure it is available.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
But let the
debate continue. Hon. Tettey-Enyo, make your contribution.
Mr. Tettey-Enyo 2:45 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, again,
thank you for the opportunity and I am happy that this problem has been resolved amicably. The Chairman of the Committee will make every effort to supply the missing document.
Mr. Speaker, while contributing in
support of the motion, I would wish to seize this opportunity on behalf of the Committee, to express our sincere appreciation of the effort the hon. Minister for Education and Sport made to fully participate in the drawing up of the budget on the floor and also to participate fully in
the budget hearing we had with the MDAs.
have had the experience of meeting
Ministers showing their interest in this exercise but I greatly appreciate the effort made by the hon. Minister, hon. Osafo- Maafo in this respect.
The document which the Chairman summarised, at the end of it, we have our recommendation. In the course of the deliberations, we went into a number of issues to support the implementation of this budget, which we think is on the low side, taking note of the necessity for the Ministry of Education and Sports to use 2006 as the door to the implementation of major reforms, starting from 2007. So we were greatly interested and concerned about the implementation processes that would make effective use of public funds in ensuring that at least, the objectives for 2006 would be achieved and pave the way for a successful implementation of what follows from 2007.
Some of the issues we raised are not recorded here but for Members of the House to appreciate the need to approve this meagre budget for the Ministry, I need to bring up one or two of these issues that were raised and thoroughly discussed with a complete understanding of what we could do. We saw in the Budget Statement the fact that we are improving upon the PTRs or the Pupil Teacher Ratio, particularly, in the three northern regions. Of course, this phenomenon is not peculiar to the three northern regions; you can see pockets of this problem in most districts elsewhere in the country. But we sought to know what exactly was making it possible for progress to be made in the improvement of the PTRs.

The Pupil Teacher Ratios (PTRs) relate to the teacher supply, especially in the rural areas; and most of the activities
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:45 p.m.
Hon.
Member, you should be working towards landing.
Mr. Tetteh-Enyo 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, the
Report of the Committee is in the hands of hon. Members and they can read the details. I was only trying to highlight some of the problems; so I will wind up.
We would want the Ministry of Education to see to the correction of the anomaly, if the project itself is ¢4 billion, you can imagine the cost of making corrections about the programmes in order to solve our problems. The Ministry should be ready and be in touch with the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning for the appropriate sums to be raised, to see to it that corrections are really made.
We also observe that we have already started having problems with the capitation fees, which we have reckoned that ¢30,000 is given per pupil. We discussed during the meeting with the Ghana Education Service (GES) the fact already deductions are being made from the ¢30,000 towards activities not at the school level but at certain district, regional and national level purposely for sports and culture. We drew the Minister attention to this so that the full sum of ¢30,000 would really be capitation fees for use in performance improvement at the school level.
Mr. Speaker, as I have said, I need to cut short my contribution but the main thrust of my intervention is that this is a thoroughly discussed budget and the Committee was satisfied that this is the minimum this House can approve for the
Ministry of Education and Sports. I implore all members of this House to support and approve the motion.
Deputy Minister for Education and Sports (Mrs. A. Baiden-Amissah): Mr. Speaker, I rise to associate myself with the motion to approve the budget of ¢8,278,571,000,000 for the services of Ministry of Education and Sports for the fiscal year 2006. Mr. Speaker, as I do so, I would wish to draw attention that the focus of the budget as far as pre-tertiary education is concerned, is increasing enrolment and raising quality, reducing gender disparities, improving the effectiveness of expenditures and improving the management, especially teacher deployment and distribution of text books, among others.
Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister has already elaborated on the capitation grant and what is doing for the country. What I would want to add is that it has even increased enrolment at the kindergarten stage, since sensitization is going on here and there. If you visit a kindergarten, you will realize that a lot of them have now been sent to school, and we are preparing them towards the main primary education since the schools reform stipulates that in the year 2007 we expect the kindergarten to become part of the mainstream primary education.
Mr. Speaker, another area that has actually increased and continues to increase enrolment in school is the feeding programme. In fact, it was started by the World Food Programme (WFP) in the three northern regions and it has actually yielded dividends. You realize that in the three northern regions, the WFP normally gives some rations to the girls to take home and this is supposed to feed all of them for one week; and as they come again the following week, they are given. Now, the Government has started the Ghana -- NEPAD School Feeding programme and this has already taken off. It has taken off as a pilot project. It started from October and it is ending in December as a pilot programme.

And 10 schools in 10 districts in all the 10 regions, have been covered.

These schools were selected not at

the headquarters of the Ministry but by the districts, and these 10 schools are in deprived areas. An amount of ¢1 billion has been spent by the Government on the pilot project and 1,840 pupils have been covered. Next year, we are continuing and we will cover a total of 2,600 schools and pupil population of 500,000 children.

Mr. Speaker, the Nether lands Government has promised to give us some backing in the early part of next year. The Department for International Development (DFID) has also come in to help. The Catholic Relief Service is also trying to help in a way, but the Catholic Relief Service will not give us cash. They will also select some schools and help them. I believe that with these added, we would have more successes in the expansion and the enrolment in schools.

Mr. Speaker, as I say this, I also want to mention the gender parity. As I am talking, we have not been able to achieve the gender parity index but whatever be the case we have made a stride because the gender parity ratio now is one is to point 93 which is an achievement and we believe that by the year 2015, we would have clocked the 100 per cent that we are talking about.

In talking about expansion, once we are increasing the number of children in schools, we must also think of infrastructural development. I am talking about the expansion of classroom blocks. The 440 units, that is six-unit classroom blocks that we started in the year 2003

has also chalked some successes. As I am talking, we are trying to complete 247 classrooms by the end of the year, hoping that these will be able to absorb the excesses that we are talking about. Even handicapped children, in the year 2005, schools were able to absorb 4,203. In fact, it moved from 4,203 to 4, 435 children, which means, the Ministry is also thinking of the handicaps.

Mr. Speaker, the textbooks that we are talking about, it is the policy of the Government to have a textbook ratio of 1:1 in schools. It is for this reason that the Ministry gave contracts to 16 Ghanaian companies and, two foreign companies and as I am speaking, the two foreign companies have been able to honour the contract agreement; they have brought their books. With the Ghanaian companies, out of the 16, only three have been able to honour the agreement; and these three published their books in Takoradi. so they are able to - The others have entered into sub contracts with people outside and are bringing in the books from outside.

For this reason, primary schools have not been able to get the books that are required. So instead of them rather coming on air to say that they have not been able to honour the contract agreement, they have rather organized press conferences to speak against the Government, that supplementary readers are going to be given to another foreign company.

Mr. Speaker, I would just want it to be on record that these people have actually failed us and failed the Government and for which reason, we should rather come out to make noise, and not them. Even apart from this, we are giving them ancillary items to publish.

Mr. Speaker, I would want to conclude by talking about teacher education in Ghana. Mr. Speaker, as I talk about
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:55 p.m.
No, hon. Member.
Mrs. Baiden-Amissah 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I will end very soon. Mr. Speaker, as I talk about teacher education in Ghana as the Minister said, the Government is trying to sponsor teacher education as from the period - [Interruptions.]
Mr. Asamoah Ofosu 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, as by practice in this House when it comes to budgetary debate on Annual Estimates like this, time is allocated for presentation. I do not know whether it is still applicable, especially as regards the hon. Deputy Minister's very long and winding presentation in support of this thing. Most of the things lie in our knowledge. Sometimes when it gets very long - [Interruption.]
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:55 p.m.
Hon. Asamoah, I do not see your point?
Mr. Ofosu 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is very difficult to contemplate and understand what is being said.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:55 p.m.
Agreeably, the hon. Deputy Minister is part of the Executive. As a matter of fact, she is a Deputy Minister, but she is also a Member of this House and she is making a contribution to a motion that we all as Members will do. If you do not want her to do that - [Interruption.]
Mr. Ofosu 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I am only seeking your guidance whether the time limit is still applicable.
Mr. Ofosu 2:55 p.m.
Yes, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:55 p.m.
Leave
that to me.
Mr. Ofosu 2:55 p.m.
When people were given five minutes and fifteen minutes!
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 2:55 p.m.
Leave that to me.
Mr. Asamoah 2:55 p.m.
I thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I know you will apply it very soon.
Mrs. Baiden-Amissah 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, in addition to distance education being pursued by the two universities, teacher education division has also started some untrained teachers programme This started last year in which 5, 400 teachers were trained from the Afram Plains and the three northern regions. These are deprived areas that do not have enough teachers. Next year we are adding 12,000 untrained teachers from the Ashanti and Brong Ahafo Regions. Mr. Speaker, the following year we shall move to the Western Region and the others.
Mr. Speaker, with these few words, I urge my Colleagues to support the motion to approve the sum stipulated on the Order Paper.
I thank you Mr. Speaker, for your attention.
Mr. Lee Ocran (NDC - Jomoro) 2:55 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, notwithstanding the fact that the Deputy Minister has already moved, I will continue with my submission. [Mr. Ocran]
Mr. Speaker, I am happy to note that since hon. Osafo-Maafo took over from the Ministry he has introduced populist sentiments into the administration of the Ministry and these populist sentiments have permeated into his budget of 2006.
Mr. J. A. Ndebugre 2:55 p.m.
On a point of order, Mr. Speaker. My very good Friend mentioned a word and I want him to be very sure. Is he talking about popular or populist? Is he saying that hon. Osafo Maafo has introduced popular policies or populist policies so that we would be very clear? I think he wanted to say popular but it appears I heard “populist” or something like that.
Mr. Ocran 2:55 p.m.
I do not think my hon. Friend wants to coach and teach me how to speak English. I said “populist” and I mean “populist”. I know the difference between popular and populist.
I can see that he has been taking a
lot of credit for the Capitation Fund. But the Capitation Fund, in our view is a constitutional provision. He is just complying with what the Constitution says. It is not the benevolence of anybody -- [Interruptions.] Whoever was in power, the Constitution states two years after coming into force of the Constitution -- he did not take part in the writing of the Constitution. Two years after coming into force of the Constitution - [Interruption.] - and 10 years thereafter, there should be free, compulsory basic education - [Interruption.]
Mr. Kojo Armah 2:55 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I think my hon. Friend is misleading this House. Constitutional provisions are cold-prints, very cold-prints. They are there. And the FCUBE provision
has been there since the Constitution was written in 1992 until it took effect in 1993. I believe it is good for the Minister who activated that cold-print into action to take some credit for it.
And therefore, this attitude of always saying that somebody did it, the thing is there, do not -- I believe it is not a good democratic practice. We should allow the Minister to carry his calm where he should be.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Hon. Minority Leader, are you also rising on a point of order?
Mr. Bagbin 3:05 p.m.
That is so.
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I yield to him.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
You are yielding? So you would not continue? You are yielding for what?
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
For the point of order, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Hon. Lee Ocran, this whole attitude of yielding, I want to be very clear. You mean you are yielding so that you will not continue with your own - [Interruptions.]
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
No, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
What are you yielding for?
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Point of information, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Point of
information?
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Yes, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Very well - Hon. Minority Leader?
Mr. Bagbin 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, my very good Friend, hon. Kojo Armah is not being fair because we had to give credit to the first President of Ghana for putting a system in place to educate him and all of us. But today, others are benefiting from that education. So the programme of the FCUBE is not something that one can just lift and implement. It is a whole programme that takes a number of years and at each stage there is an introduction or infusion of an ingredient. That does not mean that at that time that that ingredient is introduced, that person is the one who is implementing the Free, Compulsory Universal Basic Education (FCUBE).
So what he said, that it was a blueprint in the Constitution until somebody lifted it is incorrect. This is because it is a programme for a period of time and we are told that at the end of this time it should be fully implemented. That is what is happening and that is a programme. So he is misleading and giving a wrong perception about what is happening. The capitation has come at a good time; we accept it; we would support it and we would try to improve upon it.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Hon. Lee Ocran, continue. Your time has been halved for having given it out -- [Interruption.]
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, article 38(2) of the Constitution states, and Mr. Speaker, with your permission, I beg to quote:
“The Government shall, within two
years after Parliament first meets, after the coming into force of this Constitution, draw up a programme for implementation within the following ten years for the provision of free, compulsory and universal basic education.”
Calculate - Two (2) years plus ten years and you would know that it is 2005 - [Interruptions.] The hon. Member did not take part in draffing the Constitution so he should keep quiet and let me talk. [Interruption.] The hon. Member does not know the FCUBE programme? Let me go on - [Intaerruption.]
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Hon. Member, are you also on a point of
order?
Mr. Agyabeng 3:05 p.m.
Yes, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
What is your point?
Mr. Agyabeng 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, for insisting that the hon. Minister for Education and Sports just lifted the Capitation Grant and started implementing it. If you look at the Capitation Grant, the history of it, before the Capitation Grant, no basic schools were supposed to pay school fees, according to the Ministry of Education and Sports and the Ghana Education Service.
All the fees they were paying were levies charged by District Assemblies. They were not supposed to pay fees. So District Assemblies that can pay for those levies were paying so there were no school fees at the basic level. In my district, for instance, in 1992 when I was the District Chief Executive (DCE) we saw that they could not pay the levies charged by the
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Hon. Member, please wait for your turn. Allow hon. Lee Ocran to continue. [Interruptions.]
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I do not want to be disturbed by the DCE's effusions. I am happy that the hon. Minister himself has introduced populace sentiments into the Ministry of Education and Sports because at one time on this floor he lifted something from the First Republic and said that science students would have to be given incentives at the tertiary level for more people to learn science. I was looking into the budget to see whether he has been able to put this very laudable programme into the budget. Unfortunately, it is not there and I would wish that if he continues to be the hon. Minister for Education and Sports, he should try to put that one in the next budget because it is a very good thing.
I am also happy that on page 17 of the Report, the Committee writes:
“Drop in illiteracy rate - The Committee noted with satisfaction t h a t d u e t o t h e p r a g m a t i c programmes and activities on the Non-Formal Education Division, (NFED), particularly the literacy and functional skills programme, the nation's illiteracy rate has dropped by 10% over the past ten years according to the World Bank report.”
In 2001, an attempt was made to abolish the non-formal education. People said it was not important. I am happy that at least, people have now realised the importance of education because there is no limit to age in learning. You can continue learning throughout your life and let us continue with good programmes to
Mrs. Baiden-Amissah 3:05 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, my hon. Friend on the other side is misleading the House. He said that apart from the Holy Child Training College, there is no other training college in the southern part of the Western Region. Wiawso Training College is in the southern part of the Western Region. [Interruption.] Yes. [Interruption.] No. The hon. Member should go and do his geography well.
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, she was a teacher; she does not know that north is north. Wiawso is in the north; it is not in the south of Western Region; I am sorry.
Mr. Speaker, I wish that the teaching of the language - [Interruption.] Go and take the map and you will see it.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Please, hon. Members, do not just interject without being called. If you want to rise on a point of order, please, do stand near your seat and you will catch my eye. You do not have to - [Interruption.] It is all
right. Let him continue.
Mr. Ocran 3:05 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, the teaching of local languages or the learning of local languages is very important. People should start to think in their languages first and I thought that the budget would make provision for the training of more teachers in the local languages so that at least, at the basic level students or pupils can learn to read and write their own languages.

With this, I lend my support to the budget.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
I call on the hon. Minister to wind up.
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:05 p.m.
Very well, the hon. Minority Leader wants to make a contribution.
Minority Leader (A. S. K. Mr. Bagbin) 3:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, this is a very, very important sector and there is the need for us to draw his attention to some concerns so that they could take them on board.
Mr. Speaker, let me say that, maybe, I disagree a bit with the hon. Minister on the issue of priorities because he tried responding to my issue about health being number one, in a subtle manner.
Mr. Speaker, I agree that human resource development is a number one priority but it goes beyond the educational
sector to involve others. The amount that we are approving for the educational sector is quite good. I would have wished that the sports sector was delinked from the Ministry of Education and Sports because it has made it too huge and almost unmanageable. I believe that we could have taken that to still go with the Youth which I think is most appropriate in recent times.

Mr. Speaker, I think that in the budget they talked about a quota system for training colleges. That introduction, in my view, is a bit dangerous, if we have to deal with quota systems. Because the number of training colleges that we have are a few and the locations are not very equitable and if you are talking about quota systems, some areas are likely not to get equal attention. So Mr. Speaker, they have to look at that issue.

And the issue of study leave with pay, I believe that what they have adopted should be ad hoc, just the interim. But the long terms should be that we should open more training colleges and we should increase the enrolment because we need to train the teachers too and it is not only through the open university system, but also there are other courses that you need to be in school to be able to learn.

So I believe that, yes, there is the need for us to take that as an interim measure but we should go beyond that to train more teachers, we should try to incentivate them, to encourage them, to encourage our youth to go into the teaching as a profession. But even the registration fees for training colleges now are about ¢4 million. When you have to go in and register it is about ¢4.3 million. That definitely is on the high side for many of our rural folk. And when even they are admitted, they cannot take opportunity for those courses.
Mr. S. K. B. Balado Manu 3:15 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, the point that the hon. Member is making is misleading. This point came up when we were looking at the budget - the point that people leave the course midway. What came up was that people whilst waiting for some other avenues, yet to be opened to them, go to the training colleges, take the allowances and when those opportunities are opened to them, they leave. They rather cheat the Government by that. It is not that the allowances are not forthcoming and they leave; that is not the reason. We delved deep into this matter. [Interruptions.]
rose
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:15 p.m.
Hon. Asaga, what do you rise on?
Mr. Asaga 3:15 p.m.
Point of information.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:15 p.m.
Who is yielding to who?
Mr. Asaga 3:15 p.m.
To hon. Manu.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:15 p.m.
He has already made his point.
Mr. Asaga 3:15 p.m.
But he has misled the House and I just want to correct it because saying that they go into the institutions and take the allowance, is not true because first of all, to be admitted you must pay about ¢4.7 million. Why should I pay ¢4.7 million to go and be taking a paltry allowance until I get a different job. So what he is talking about there is no incentive.
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:15 p.m.
Hon. Asaga, you are out of order.
Mr. Bagbin 3:15 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, what hon. Manu said could be true but it is equally true that some people leave midway because of the difficulties in paying fees. That is an established fact and if he wants, I can refer him to some people for him to contact.
The other issue I wanted to raise concerning the teacher trainees is the support that we can give them and the fact that the Ministry itself should be part of this programme. Mr. Speaker, in my constituency, I support the teacher trainees and at the end of the day, I expect that they be posted to the district to at least give two or three years service before they are posted outside the district because I have used the district's resources to support their education.
Unfortunately, the Ministry does not take that into consideration and a lot of them are posted outside and when we want to object to that we had a serious difficulty. So I am drawing the attention of the Ministry to that. That they should accept that issue and try to let us retain some of
rose
Mr. Bagbin 3:15 p.m.
I do not know what my hon. Colleague was trying to do by standing to object or support what I am saying, but I am just referring to what happens in my constituency; it might not be nationwide.
Mr. Speaker, I think also that in looking at teacher trainees we still have a long way to go. I am saying this because of the input of teachers in the educational system. There are a lot of complaints; some are being addressed, but when we look at the Auditor-General's Report of the Ministry - unfortunately, the hon. Minister himself could not attend but the hon. Member for Parliament for Shama constituency came the second day -- There is the urgent need for us to monitor the utilization of the money we send to the Ministry. A lot of that money ends up being completely recklessly misused.
To the extent that people can draw programmes, ask for moneys, do not implement the programmes and share the money. And when the auditors get to them, then they start calling each other to refund the money. Now, the value is not the same and even the purpose of the budgetary allocation has been lost.
We have identified a lot of it and I am sure in the report of the Committee, some of these things would be brought out so that together we can see how we can manage to cement some of the loopholes in the system so that we better utilize the resources we allocate to them. The ¢8.2 trillion, I believe if they say is not the minimum, there is nothing we can do but to accept that and with that I support the motion.
Mr. Osafo-Maafo 3:25 p.m.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, I must thank my Colleagues very much for the suggestions made.
A fundamental point was stressed by the Leader of the Minority but I put it differently. The way out of teachers re- embedded in certain districts is through decentralization and sponsorship by District Assemblies. This is happening in many districts and doing very well and we should all move in that direction. It will be sad if after a district has sponsored a teacher, that district is not allowed to make use of that teacher and I will take this problem on board but I believe it is a question perhaps of knowledge within the District Directorate about these teachers being sponsored by the district.
I went to Akropong Training College and I was so impressed with a question I posed the whole college - “How many of you are sponsored by districts”? And at Akropong Training College two-thirds are sponsored by specific districts and they were very happy that “I am for Shama, I am for Kumasi, I am for this. It is a good idea. If you go to a place like Germany, there is nothing like central location of teachers; all teachers come from various regions and districts and this is where you go to train on behalf of a district and you are bounded to teach at least for a certain minimum period on behalf of that district. If we go that way, I can assure you, we would be resolving this question of teachers and allocation of teachers.
Mr. Speaker, I noted something I wanted to correct and this is very important and I want my hon. Colleagues to listen to me. We have thirty-eight training colleges. Entry into a training college qualification was aggregate 24 . This year, after the training colleges have been opened, we were about half empty, so we reduced it from 24 to 30 to enable more people to
enter. And we accepted also lower marks in English and Mathematics to allow people to enter.
Mr. Bagbin 3:25 p.m.
On a point of order. Mr.
Speaker, he is simply supporting the issue I raised and in fact, during our time, I can recall a number of people who left Sixth Form s to go into training colleges because of the attractive nature of the conditions there. So we would need to improve on those conditions so that we can get more people there after. All in the other institutions he saw that they were even rejecting people but why are they not going into the training colleges?
Mr. Osafo-Maafo 3:25 p.m.
So as I said, there
is a fundamental problem and it must have something to do with the conditions of service, with the package of incentive for teachers and as a nation, we must address that problem; because if you are not attracting people into a particular field and they are competing professionals being trained and all people prefer to become nurses rather than teachers, prefer to become this than teachers then you have a problem. And your problem is that your incentive for teachers the scheme is not good enough. Therefore, it is a fundamental problem that we must address.
Mr. Speaker, if you imagine that 89 per cent of our budget is on emoluments,
that is wages and salaries -- But I would admit that teachers are not the best paid group in this country. So if we were to go up by another 30 per cent, what will happen to this Budget. Can you imagine? It means that what we consider to be huge is not high enough to enable us provide a package that is attractive, that can keep teachers in the classroom. So we have got to go to the drawing board and address the question of incentive to teachers and I will say that the package at the moment is not attractive enough. And this is borne out by the rate of people entering and people leaving and if your inflow is less than your outflow you always have a problem.
On the question of science I was quite
amazed about the comment given by hon. Colleague . I did tell the House that the Government has already provided additional facilities for fifteen training colleges to specialize in Mathematics and Science. So it is not like we are not taking steps to actualize our ideals. We believe that Mathematics and Science are critical. The teacher coming out to teach, if he is going to make Science and Mathematics interesting, should himself be trained properly in these areas. So if you want Mathematics and Science to be strong in the basic, junior secondary schools (JSS) and primary schools they must be strong in your training colleges; that is where you must start from.
The other incentive package in terms
of scholarships and schemes which are not expressed in this budget, but I can assure you that we are pro-science, we are pro- Information Communication Technology (ICT) and we are pro-mathematics and this is being reflected in the number of other internal schemes we are offering. And therefore, yes, we are doing it and we are starting from the training colleges and we are going to keep them together.
Mr. Speaker, with these comments I want to thank my hon. Colleagues for
their support.
I therefore move, that this august House approves the sum of ¢8,278,571,000,000 recommended for the Ministry of Education and Sports for the 2006 financial year. Mr. Speaker, I move.
Question put and motion agreed to.
Resolved.
That this House approves the sum of ¢8,278,571,000,000 for the services of the Ministry of Education and Sports for the 2006 fiscal year..
Mr. First Deputy Speaker 3:25 p.m.
The
motion is carried and thank you hon. Minister and it is on our record that the Committee members have indeed praised you for your commitment and taking part or participating in the discussion of your allocation this year. Thank you, hon. Minister.
Mr. Okerchiri 3:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, with
your permission, we may move on to Motion No. 17.
ANNUAL ESTIMATES 3:25 p.m.

MINISTRY OF LANDS, FORESTRY 3:25 p.m.

AND MINES 3:25 p.m.