Debates of 3 Nov 2021

MR SECOND DEPUTY SPEAKER
PRAYERS 11:55 a.m.

Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:55 a.m.
Hon Members, before we go into
business, I would like to welcome
our brothers from Nigeria who have
visited Ghana and are here to frater-
nise with us. So, Hon Members, I
have the pleasure to introduce to
you a forty-member delegation of
the Oyo State House of Assembly,
Nigeria, who are on a training ses-
sion on Fundamental Imperatives
on Legislative Work. While in
Ghana, they intend to take the op-
portunity to meet and interact with
their counterparts to share experi-
ences and exchange ideas on issues
of mutual interest.
Hon Members, on behalf of the
House, I welcome them and wish
them fruitful deliberations. The del-
egation is led by the Rt Hon Edward
Adebo Ogundoyin, the Speaker of
the group.
Hon Members, you are welcome

Votes and Proceedings

and the

Official Report
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:55 a.m.
Hon Members, correction of the
Votes and Proceedings of Tuesday,

Page 1…7 -
Mr Habib Iddrisu 11:55 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, page 7, number 3, Dr Mo-
hammed Amin Adam, Hon Mem-
ber for Karaga, was in the House
yesterday but has been marked ab-
sent.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:55 a.m.
Table Office, please take note.
Page 8 -
Dr Nyarko 11:55 a.m.
Mr Speaker, page
8, item numbered 5, Mr Djietror is
captured as the Acting Deputy
Clerk but on page 10, he has been
captured as Deputy Clerk. So, there
should be some form of clarity on
this.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:55 a.m.
Table Office, please take note.
Page 9…10 -
Dr Nyarko 11:55 a.m.
Mr Speaker, page
9, item numbered 6 (ii), “Jonas Gahr Store” the “o” should have a diagonal in it. It is not the normal
“o” so it should be captured cor- rectly. It is somebody's name. It is not the normal store.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:55 a.m.
Very well. Table Office, I hope you
heard him.
Page 10…14?
Hon Members, the Votes and
Proceedings of Tuesday, 2nd No-
vember, 2021 as corrected is
adopted as true record of proceed-
ings.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Members, do we have Official
Reports?
Mr James Klutse Avedzi 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, we have some of the Offi-
cial Reports. I have 23rd, 24th and
29th June, 2021, and then I have 2nd
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Members, we are not correct-
ing the Official Reports. I
understand they are in your pigeon
holes. Please, make sure you go for
them tomorrow so that we can look
into them. We will put all of them
together and address them tomor-
row.
Hon Members, we have some
Statements and we will -
Yes Hon Majority Leader, any
indication?
Deputy Majority Leader (Mr
Alexander Afenyo-Markin): Mr
Speaker, if you may indulge us, we
would seek your leave to vary the
order of Business so that we can go
to Commencement of Public Busi-
ness and proceed with Presentation
of Papers - item numbered 6.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Very well, Yes, Hon Deputy Minor-
ity Leader?
Deputy Minority Leader (Mr
James Klutse Avedzi): Mr
Speaker, Presentation of Papers
would not take much time, so we
can go ahead and do so.
Votes and Proceeding and the Official Report
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Members, at the Commence-
ment of Public Business, page 2,
item numbered 6 - Presentation of Papers. We would start with item
numbered 6 (a). Is the Hon Minister
for Energy around?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, with your leave, the Hon
Deputy Minister for Energy who is
a Member of this House is here. The
Hon Minister is unavoidably absent
attending to some assignment out-
side the jurisdiction.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Very well, leave granted.
PAPERS 12:05 p.m.

Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Yes, Hon Member for Okaikwei
Central, what is it?
Mr Patrick Yaw Boamah 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, may I refer you to Stand-
ing Order 75(2), with your permis-
sion I beg to quote:
“If so desired by the person pre- senting a Paper, a short explana-
tory statement may be made by
him upon its presentation.”
Mr Speaker, a very important
Paper has just be laid by the Hon
Deputy Minister for Energy. I
would want to find out from him if
there is an explanatory memoran-
dum accompanying it, and if he so
desires to apprise the House.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Member, you just said it; “if so desired by the person….” It is at his discretion, so, if the Hon Deputy
Minister has sometime to add - other than that - ?
Mr Avedzi 12:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the re-
ferral of the Paper to the Subsidiary
Legislation Committee - I think it is
an issue that borders local content
on energy. So, could it be a joint re-
ferral to the Committee on Mines
and Energy -
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Deputy Minority Leader, this
is an instrument -
Mr Avedzi 12:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have
not finished. Even if it would not be
a joint referral, at least leadership of
the Committee on Mines and
Energy should participate in it; it is
very important that they have some
technical input from the Mines and
Energy Committee. We have done
this severally, so nothing should
stop us from doing so.
Mr Speaker, thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Deputy Minority Leader, the
referral is specifically to the Subsid-
iary Legislation Committee. If
Members of the Mines and Energy
Committee are desirous to join,
they are at liberty to do that.
Mr Edward A. Bawa 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, sorry. I know you have
ruled on this, but the truth is that
beyond just the law, the content is
also very important. So, even if the
leadership of Mines and Energy
Committee join, they would be able
to augment and inform some of the
drafting and other things they
would be doing. So, the content of
it is also key. If we still want to
insist on having the Subsidiary
Legislation Committee doing that,
at least the leadership of the
Committee should be made to take
part in it, but if it is left to the dis-
cretion of the Subsidiary Commit-
tee and say that the Committee on
Mines and Energy can join, that
may not necessarily be -
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Member, this is an instrument
and normally, per our standard, we
refer instruments to the Subsidiary
Legislation Committee. That was
why I said, “if Members of the Mines and Energy Committee…” whoever desires to join is at liberty
to do that. Most of us are friends to
other Committees, so I do not think
it is an issue.
Mr Samuel Atta Akyea 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, fortuitously, I am a Mem-
ber of the Subsidiary Legislation
Committee and also Chairman of
the Mines and Energy Committee.
So, as a matter of fact, I would be
able to gather a lot from the Com-
mittee on Mines and Energy and
use it at the appropriate time. And
all the Members of the Committee
who so desire to input what we
would be doing, I am ready to help.
Mr Speaker, I am grateful to

Papers

12. 15 p.m.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Very well, I am also a Member of

Hon Deputy Majority Leader, I

would like to listen to the Hon

Member for Akatsi South.
Mr Bernard Ahiafor 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I thank you for giving me
the opportunity.
Mr Speaker, once it is an Instru-
ment or a Regulation, it comes
within the ambit of the Subsidiary
Legislation Committee. The work
of the Subsidiary Legislation Com-
mittee is to take the parent Act and
determine whether the Regulation
before them is within the ambit of
the parent Act, and then bring it to
this House in line with article 11(7).
So, once it is a Regulation, it comes
purely under the Subsidiary Legis-
lation Committee.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Member, I have already ruled.
For now, it has been referred to the
Committee on Subsidiary Legisla-
tion.
Hon Members, we would move
on to the item numbered 6 (b).
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, once again, with your leave, the
Hon Owuraku Aidoo would pro-
ceed to lay that Paper.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Very well, Hon Deputy Minister for
Energy, you may lay the Paper
numbered 6 (b).
By the Hon Deputy Minister for
Energy (Mr William Owuraku
Aidoo) (on behalf of the Minister
for Education) -
Annual Report of the Institute of Statistical, Social and Economic Research (ISSER) of the University of Ghana for the Period 2019-2020.
Referred to the Committee on
Education.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Members, we would move on
to the Paper numbered 6 (c).
By the Minister for Sanitation
and Water Resources -
Budget Performance Report in Re- spect of the Ministry of Sanitation and Water Resources for the Period January to March, 2021.
Referred to the Committee on
Works and Housing.
Papers
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Members, we would move on
to the Paper numbered 6 (d).
By the Minister for Information -
Budget Performance Report in
Respect of the Ministry of Infor-
mation for the Period April to
June, 2021.
Referred to the Committee on
Communication.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Yes, Hon Deputy Majority Leader,
any indication?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, we thank you for indulg-
ing us. We may now proceed with
the original order in which Business
is to be conducted.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:05 p.m.
Hon Members, we would go back to
the item numbered 5 on today's
Order Paper - Statements. Like I
said, we have a couple of State-
ments. The first one is to be taken
from the Hon Member for
Bole/Bamboi, the Hon Yusif
Sulemana on the impact of high and
rising cement prices in the construc-
tion industry.
Hon Member for Bole/Bamboi,
the floor is yours now.
STATEMENTS 12:25 p.m.

Mr Yusif Sulemana (NDC - Bole/Bamboi) 12:25 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am grate- ful for this opportunity to make a Statement on the high and rising ce-
ment prices and their impact. Mr
Speaker, given present technology,
cement is the most popular and uni-
versally accepted binder material in
construction. The reason for this is
found in the following characteris-
tics of cement:
1. It gains sufficient strength very quickly relative to other materials;
2. It is able to withstand com- pressive stress;
3. It is easy to mix and compati- ble with local materials;
4. It is easy to transport; and
5. It makes construction quicker and cheaper.
Papers

As a result, it is extremely rare

to come across any form of con-

struction without some amount of

cement used in the process. It is

therefore not surprising that cost of

cement forms a very important

component of construction. Indeed,

my research reveals that as a rule of

thumb, cement constitutes about 16

per cent of total construction cost.

What this means is that changes in

cement prices impact construction

and people directly.

Mr Speaker, the impact of ex-

treme cement price increases on the

construction industry, the State and

individuals is unbearable and pro-

found. Specifically, for construc-

tors with ongoing projects, this im-

mediately affects project cost. For

instance, in 2019, the President cut

sod for the construction of the mili-

tary housing project at a cost of

US$100 million. At that time, ce-

ment sold at about GH₵32.00 per bag. Today at over GH₵50.00 per bag, the cost of this project will au-

tomatically go up by an extra

US$10 million.

Mr Speaker, in such a situation,

a contractor is forced to undertake

immediate remedial measures.

Such measures will involve either

the utilisation of margins to meet

the increased cost or a demand for

renegotiation of contract terms to

cater for the higher prices. In the ab-

sence of Government's willingness to renegotiate the economic terms

of such contracts, you would likely

see inferior execution of projects

through adjustment of quantities.

There is also the likelihood of de-

lays in delivery and in the extreme,

abandonment of projects.

Mr Speaker, at the individual

level, the transmission of high ce-

ment prices to high cost of living is

easily traceable. In this respect,

people who are currently construct-

ing homes would have to adjust

their budgets upwards while their

incomes remain unchanged or sus-

pend their projects, altogether. For

example, if it would cost you

GH₵100,000 to build your home, you would need GH₵108,000 if ce- ment prices increase by 50 per cent.

For those who rent, it would not be

surprising to witness higher rents as

a result.

Mr Speaker, this Statement is

triggered by the recent dramatic

change in the trend of cement price

increases. Between 2012 and 2019,

prices increased at 7.5 per cent per

annum. However, since 2019, they

have risen by 50.4 per cent cumula-

tively. In March 2019, cement sold

Statements

for GH₵33.00 per bag. It sells be- tween GH₵52.00 and GH₵55.00 today depending on where you are.

Mr Speaker, this does not augur

well for a nation with a huge infra-

structure deficit. The Hon Minister

for Works and Housing at the Home

Ownership Series in April this year

stated that our housing deficit cur-

rently stands at over 2 million hous-

ing units. Similarly, there are 88

districts without district hospitals;

2,417 schools under trees; 2,986

schools in deplorable condition

across the country. This is accord-

ing to a 2nd June, 2021, Graphic

Online report. Mr Speaker, accord-

ing to the Minister of Roads &

Highways, as reported by ghana-

web.com, 55,733 kilometres, repre-

senting 77 per cent of the total road

network is unpaved. This huge in-

frastructure deficit already requires

huge financial outlay.

Mr Speaker, at the 2021 Sus-

tainable Development Goals

(SDGs) Investment Fair, it was re-

vealed that Ghana's annual infra- structure investment will need to

reach US$9.3 billion by 2030 and

cumulate to US$96 billion by 2040

if we are to achieve the SDGs. With

cement prices almost doubled in the

last year, we will need some

US$15.4 billion more, assuming we

arrest the current situation and pre-

vent further increases in the price.

Mr Speaker, juxtapose this finan-

cial requirement with our capital

expenditure—which in the last 10 years has averaged just over US$1

billion per annum, according to

data from Bank of Ghana. When

you do this, you will note that it is

in Government's interest to put in place some quick measures to pre-

vent further increment in the prices

of cement.

The question, therefore is, what

has caused this dramatic rise in the

price? Mr Speaker, while it has be-

come fashionable to blame all our

woes on the Covid-19 pandemic, an

objective analysis of this particular

situation should tell us that it is ra-

ther internal factors that are respon-

sible. Or at best, the effects of

Covid-19 have been exacerbated by

internal factors. Yes, Mr Speaker, I

am not oblivious of the disruption

in international trade occasioned

bythe pandemic. Nonetheless, my

position is informed by a quick

comparative research of cement

prices in neighbouring markets.

For instance, Mr Speaker, in Ni-

geria in 2019, cement sold for

₦2,550 per bag. Currently, it sells for ₦2,800 signifying a less than 10 per cent cumulative rise within the

period. In April this year, the Chief

Statements

Executive Officer of Dangote Ce-

ment Plc in Nigeria granted an in-

terview in response to consumer

complaints about its discriminatory

prices across the different countries

it operates. Among other things, he

said:

“While a bag of cement sells for an equivalent of US$5.10 including

VAT in Nigeria, it sells for

US$7.20 in Ghana and US$5.95 in

Zambia ex-factory…”.

Mr Speaker, my research shows

that three factors account for this

significant difference:

Firstly, there is a US$0.50 per

ton fumigation levy that has been

imposed on imported clinker.

Clinker is the main raw material for

cement production, forming up to

80 per cent of the total output. Ac-

cordingly, any tax imposed on it

would automatically translate into

higher cost of production. Govern-

ment's decision to leave this levy in place at this time, when the Covid-

19 pandemic has already driven im-

port cost upwards, has aggravated

the situation.

Secondly, the Ghana Ports and

Harbours Authority (GPHA) has

barred vessels carrying clinker

from berthing at terminals 1 and 2

thereby restricting them to only one

berth. This, the Authority explains,

is to prevent pollution in case of an

accident. However, the distance be-

tween the terminals makes this rea-

son untenable because any pollu-

tion within one terminal would

reach the others within minutes.

Restricting these vessels to just one

berth creates delays at the port. Ac-

cording to the Chamber of Cement

Manufacturers, Ghana, each day a

vessel is delayed at the port, the im-

porter, the cement manufacturer,

pays between US$35,000 and

US$45,000. This obviously adds to

the cost of production, and has to be

borne by the cement consumer.

Lastly, cement prices are also

affected by a myriad of taxes: im-

port duties on raw materials; VAT

as adjusted through the one per cent

Covid-19 Health Levy; as well as

the many taxes on fuel prices in-

cluding the recent Energy Sector

Recovery Levy of 20 pesewas per

litre, and the Sanitation and Pollu-

tion Levy (SPL) of 10 pesewas per

litre.

Mr Speaker, the cumulative ef-

fect of these factors is responsible

for the phenomenal hike in the

prices and as noted, the impact of

this spans the length and breadth of

this country. I, therefore, use this

platform to recommend the follow-

ing. That Government:

Statements

1. removes the US$0.50 per ton fumigation levy on imported

clinker. It makes no scien-

tific sense to impose fumiga-

tion levy on clinker anyway;

2. orders the GPHA to allocate additional berths to clinker-

carrying vessels, even if tem-

porarily, to prevent delays at

the port;

3. adds cement retail to the ex- emptions list for the one per

cent Covid-19 Health Levy.

4. rethinks the Energy Sector Recovery and Sanitation and

Pollution Levies on fuel

prices. Nothing can justify

their imposition in a pan-

demic era especially when

every other country is doing

the opposite.

In conclusion, Mr Speaker, we

have a long way to go to address our

current infrastructure gap. This

journey is made longer if cement, a

major component in construction,

becomes too expensive to buy. This

current rate of price increases has

become a crisis and requires imme-

diate crisis-response from our

Government. Anything but that will

be devastating especially given the

recent threat by the cement manu-

facturers to increase prices further

to GH₵60 per bag by year's end.

Mr Speaker, I thank you once again, for

the opportunity.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:35 p.m.
Hon Members, we have other State-
ments, so I will invite two Hon
Members from each Side to make
contributions.
Before then, I am told our
friends from Nigeria would like to
take leave of us. Rt Hon Adebo
Ogundoyin, Speaker of Oyo State
House of Assembly; Hon Fadeyi,
Deputy Speaker; Hon Onaolapo,
Majority Leader; Hon Alarape, Mi-
nority Leader, Hon Akeem
Adedibu, Chief Whip and all the
other Hon Members who are here,
we would want to thank you for
making time to be with us here. We
wish you well, and pray that you
learn very effectively from Ghana-
ian culture, hospitality and anything
you need to know from Ghana. We
are so grateful for being with us.

Hon Members, we would get

back to the Statement, and first

invite the Hon Member for Obuasi

West to make his contribution.

Statements

Mr Kwaku Agyeman

Kwarteng (NPP - Obuasi West): Mr Speaker, I thank you for the op-

portunity to contribute to the State-

ment made by the Hon Ussif

Sulemana. First, I commend him for

bringing such an important matter

here.

Mr Speaker, it would be recalled

that a similar Statement was deliv-

ered in this House by my good Self

and Mr Speaker referred it to the

Joint Committees of Finance and

Trade and Industry. We are work-

ing on it and we would bring a Re-

port to this House as soon as we

can.

Mr Speaker, but this Statement

has proceeded to make suggestions

and to make recommendations that

require some comments. It is true

that Covid-19 has increased, espe-

cially, freight cost so; any items that

we are importing into this country

now attracts higher freight charges.

That, from our preliminary observa-

tion, is largely responsible, not

wholly but partially responsible for

the rise in some of the building

products we see on the market.

Mr Speaker, but the problem

with the suggestion made by the

Hon Member that the solution lies

in Government taking off some

taxes and some levies, in order to

get the cost of those imported items

go down in my respectful opinion,

is insensitive to the economy. Mr

Speaker, when I say so I mean that

we have just come from the year

2020 in which the revenue shortfall

was some fourteen billion Ghana

cedis (GH¢14 billion). Then again,

Covid-19 required that Government

found money to finance unplanned

expenditures such as the creation of

isolation centres; such as the provi-

sion of relief for frontline workers;

such as for vaccines; such as for all

the things that Government needed

to do to protect the lives of our peo-

ple.

Mr Speaker, what is needed now

is strategies that would help Gov-

ernment recover the financial losses

we made into those expenditures at

the time Government announced to

us and came here for approval that

they overspent the Fiscal Responsi-

bility Act. And this House said yes,

given the need to protect the lives of

our people, we give you, Govern-

ment, the approval to spend money

that we do not have. That was the

approval of this House.

Mr Speaker, as Government

comes here for the Budget, I think

the question we should be asking

Government is, what strategies are

Statements

in the Budget to recover the big def-

icit? That is the question we should

be asking, and if we do not do that

and the economy deteriorates and

the cedi falls, then the vulnerable

and the poor would suffer badly and

the political leaders responsible for

those positions would pay the price

to God. So, let not anybody suggest

that at the time when Government

revenue should be protected to pro-

tect the cedi is the time we should

be removing taxes.

I would be extremely disappointed

if in the coming Budget Govern-

ment comes to say that in spite of

the approval that this House gave

you to spend money that Ghana did

not have; hence the way they want

to recover is to now give more re-

liefs; Mr Speaker, what kind of eco-

nomic management would that be?

We would be setting this economy

on a path that would eventually hurt

the poor. Let us be sensitive.

Mr Speaker, political expediency is

comfortable; in fact, it would be politi-

cally comfortable for Government to

come to say they have removed these

taxes and people would cheer and the

Government would get the

applause, politically, it would be

comfortable but the consequences

of the cedi and the economy would

be such that the poor and the vulner-

able would pay a painful price for

such a political move. And I urge

my Hon Colleagues to help Govern-

ment deal with the gap that arose as

a result of the pandemic in 2020 and

stop calling on the Government to

do what would hurt the economy.

Mr Speaker, I thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:45 p.m.
Yes, let me invite the Hon Member
for - is it Ho West? Hon Bedzrah.
Mr Emmanuel Kwasi Bedz-
rah (NDC - Ho West): Mr
Speaker, I thank you. I would like
to commend my Hon Colleague,
Hon Ussif for a well-researched
Statement to let the whole world,
including Ghanaians know that
building materials especially ce-
ment forms some amount or per-
centage when it comes to costing
building products.
Mr Speaker, this Statement has
brought to fore the understanding
that when you are building a house
and you need materials to build the
house, you need to depend on one
major material called cement.
Statements

Mr Speaker, in this part of the

world, coming from the construc-

tion sector, it is true that the sixteen

per cent of cement adds to the cost

of constructional materials. But in

other parts of the world, it is no

longer the sixteen per cent because

cement might not be used primarily

in the construction industry. But as

it stands now, in our part of the

world, cement still is used in our

traditional construction method.

Mr Speaker, having said that, I

was expecting my Hon Colleague,

Hon Kwaku Agyeman Kwarteng,

when he made a Statement here last

year, concerning the increasing

prices of building materials in this

country, and you referred the State-

ment to a Committee to come out

with a solution as to how Govern-

ment could do something about the

rising cost of building materials, I

was expecting him to tell us that in-

deed, the Committee has met and

they have come out with a solution.

Unfortunately, he saidss they have

not come out.

And our Hon Colleague has

thought through and researched and

come out with some recommenda-

tions, and I was expecting the Hon

Kwarteng to invite our Hon

Coleague to the Committee to also

expand on those recommendations

that he has put out there. Unfortu-

nately, he landed by some of the

recommendations which are insen-

sitive.

Mr Speaker, in that sense, our

Hon Colleague has also made the

recommendation that apart from

those prices or some of the sugges-

tions made to Government, he has

also made some suggestions that I

think are sensitive. One of them is

alluding to the fact that the Minister

for Works and Housing, recently

said that the housing deficit is two

million. And if the housing deficit

is over two million in this country

and people are living in shanty

houses or people do not have places

to sleep, and the major material in

the construction mix is cement, and

the cost is going too high, and the

Chairman of the Finance Commit-

tee does not see it as insensitivity to

people who are living and sleeping

in shanty places that they are not

supposed to live in, then, I do not

want to presuppose that or presume

that the recommendations that they

would bring to this House would

Statements

not support and would not reduce

the prices of any materials.

Mr Speaker, I am a builder my-

self. And every now and then, we

go to the market and it is not only

cement that is going high but

because this Statement is about

cement, we would limit our discus-

sion to cement. Having said that,

iron rods have gone astronomically

higher than any other building ma-

terial. You cannot imagine, that be-

tween the year 2016 and 2021,

prices of building materials are no

longer affordable to people and they

cannot build houses. What can we

do as a nation? This Statement is

appealing to all of us as Members of

this House to proffer suggestions.

I believe that only one berth has

been allocated for clinker which is

a major component in the manufac-

ture of cement. You would have to

even fumigate it. You would be

taxed for fumigating clinker. I have

never heard this anywhere in the

world that clinker that was brought

in should be fumigated. Therefore,

you are taxed for the fumigation of

clinker. Very soon, even sand

would be fumigated. Is that how we

are building this nation?

Mr Speaker, I therefore ex-

pected my Hon Colleague to incor-

porate some of these suggestions. I

have one additional suggestion to

make. There is a local material

called pozzolanic cement which

could be used in addition to cement,

so it reduces the quantity of cement

used. Pozzolanic cement can also

be marketed because it is manufac-

tured here in Ghana. It was devel-

oped by the Council for Scientific

and Industrial Research (CSIR) and

Building and Research Institute of

the Kwame Nkrumah University of

Science and Technology (KNUST).

The use of those materials could

be encouraged and Government

should support them, so that if one

uses 10 bags of cement, it can be re-

duced to five bags of cement. The

cost of pozzolanic cement which is

cheaper could then be added to it.

This is in addition to these three rec-

ommendations.

Mr Speaker, I support my Hon

Friend, that these recommendations

should be incorporated by Hon

Kwarteng's Committee. They must

Statements

look holistically at the building ma-

terials, so that we consultants would

also get jobs to do. We are not get-

ting jobs to do because the prices of

materials are going high and we

cannot afford to lose our clients.

Mr Speaker, with these few

words, I thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:45 p.m.
Hon Member for Tema West?
Mr Carlos Kingsley
Ahenkorah (NPP - Tema West):
Mr Speaker, thank you for giving
me the opportunity to contribute to
this very intelligently couched
Statement from my Hon Deputy
Ranking Member and also friend
from Bole-Bamboi.
Mr Speaker, it is very interesting
to note that recently, the prices of
cement which of course not too
long ago, used to be heavily regu-
lated has skyrocketed and is affect-
ing almost every facet of life,
including iron rods and other build-
ing materials that are used in addi-
tion to cement to put up buildings.
Mr Speaker, I do not want to
believe that the price hikes are as a
result of Government's taxes or any additions with regard to the
nuisance taxes that are making
manufacturers increase their ce-
ment prices. I rather think that the
additional charges that cement
manufacturers have to pay to get
their raw materials through our
ports, might be one of the reasons
we are seeing what we are experi-
encing today.
Mr Speaker, it is interesting to
note, that clinker which comes in
bulk form when transported from
the port to the manufacturer's premises would have to go through
fumigation charges. I do not
understand. What are we fumigat-
ing on that bulk cargo in the tipper
truck? These and other charges that
have found themselves into the cost
of production have certainly come
to increase and sky-rocket prices of
not just cement but other products.
I would challenge this House -
I am aware that Mr Speaker has
already referred this matter to the
Finance Committee with the active
involvement of the Committee on
Trade and Industry but we have still
not come up with anything final on
this request. I would want us to sit
down and do a quick response to
this request and bring you a Report.
Whatever this Committee comes up
to say, whether they should watch
their charges or properly apportion
their charges appropriately should
be fully implemented.
Statements

Mr Speaker, I would however,

quickly like to add that this is an

industry that is heavily regulated.

Indeed, if you look at L. I. 2240 of

2016, when a similar situation arose

and the price of cement started

going up, the then Government

came up with this law to ensure

some stabilisation. I must say that

the law came to do a lot of good and

as we speak, the Minister for Trade

and Industry has the responsibility

to ensure that if people in the indus-

try decide on their own to increase

the price of cement, he has the right

to use every means to regulate the

price.

One of the means is to encour-

age importation to stabilise the

prices of cement. The law even goes

ahead to say that before the cement

manufacturers increase their prices,

they need to sit down with the

Ministry of Trade and Industry and

discuss. Have they discussed the

recent skyrocketing prices? I do not

know. So, I would want to use this

opportunity to ask the Hon Minister

for Trade and Industry to ensure

that they use every fair means to get

these manufacturers to sit down

with them and discuss some of

these increases. This is because

some of them are a bit too high.

Today, it has increased by

almost 50 per cent as compared to

what we were buying cement in

2017. I think that if we do a little bit

more work, we would be able to

bring down the prices of cement. As

I said, today as we speak, the only

way to bring the cost down is to

give importers the opportunity to

bring in cement from outside and let

us see if the pricing would not draw

down what the manufacturers are

trying to push down our throats.

Mr Speaker, with these few

words, I congratulate my Hon Col-

league from Bole-Bamboi. The

referral to the Finance Committee

and the Committee on Trade and In-

dustry should come quickly for you

to implement whatever recommen-

dations we would put therein.

Thank you Mr Speaker.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
Hon Ato Forson?
Mr Cassiel Ato Baah Forson
(NDC - Ajumako/Enyan/Essiam): Mr
Speaker, thank you for the oppor-
tunity to also contribute to the
Statement that was made by our
Statements

Colleague the Hon Member for

Bole-Bamboi.

Mr Speaker, in responding to the

Statement, the Chairman of the Fi-

nance Committee said that inas-

much as we should be concerned

about the prices of cement, he does

not think that there is the need for

Government to remove the levies

that have been imposed by Govern-

ment on the supply of some of these

items, particularly, cement.

Mr Speaker, in his statement, he

made reference to the fact that due

to COVID-19, the Government of

Ghana lost revenue in the excess of

GH¢14 billion. I beg to say, that is

not what is in the Budget Statement

submitted to the Parliament of

Ghana. The Budget Statement that

was submitted this year by the Hon

Majority Leader said in Appendix

2A, that Government has provision

to collect total revenue and taxes

amounting to GH¢53 billion as part

of the revised Budget. The actual

outturn however was GH¢55

billion.

Mr Speaker, I concede that the

earlier Budget said that they would

collect GH¢62 billion but even if

they do that, the shortfall in revenue

=

does not amount to GH¢14 billion

but GH¢12 billion.

I am referring to appendix 2(a)

of the Budget Statement. So, it can-

not be the case. I often disagreed

with Government anytime they

thought that the best way to get

money is to tax and blame COVID-

19. That cannot be the case. If we

are not careful, we would end up in-

troducing inefficiencies in the econ-

omy by imposing taxes.

Mr Speaker, I would want to

submit to you that we should look at

the matter that has been submitted

to us in the form of Statement, in a

way that would benefit the econ-

omy. The price of cement is sky-

rocketing and it has affected almost

everything. That is why I agree with

you early on - when the Hon Chair-

man of the Finance Committee

some months ago came before the

House, he said that we should con-

stitute a committee to look into the

prices of cement. The price has

gone up to the extent that it has af-

fected the cost of houses - and

housing is a basic necessity which

should not be that expensive.

Statements

However, housing in Ghana has

become too expensive because of

the price of cement. That is why I

said that the Government of

Ghana's policy has introduced a lot

of inefficiencies. So, they should

look at the taxes all over again and

where possible, remove some of

them particularly, for cement be-

cause it does not assist the economy

at all.

Mr Speaker, the price of iron

rods has also skyrocketed and al-

most everybody is complaining be-

cause it has piled on to hardships.

So, if Government in the Budget

Statement said to us that the way to

go is to impose taxes, I would disa-

gree with that. They should rather

check expenditure. Government ex-

penditure is the problem and not

taxes so they should look at it and

those ones that are frivolous should

be removed and not to impose

taxes. That is why I submit that this

matter is something that we should

all be interested in because our con-

stituents need houses. The prices of

houses have increased because of

the price of cement and iron rods.

We should revisit this matter again

and look at the prices because I

strongly believe that there are areas

we could cut.
Mr Kwarteng 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, an
earlier decision by your good self is
that the Committees on Finance and
Trade and Industry should look at
the matter in relation to the rise in
the prices. I took the wisdom of my
good friend that this Statement may
also be referred to us so that we con-
sider them together.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
Very well.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would comment last because the Hon Deputy Minority Leader yielded to the Hon Member for Aju- mako/Eyan/Essiam, Mr Forson [Pause]
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
Hon Member for Bodi, Mr
Sampson Ahi?
Mr Sampson Ahi (NDC - Bodi) 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I thank you for
the opportunity to contribute to this
important Statement.
Mr Speaker, we all know that
every human being on this planet
wants to own a house but the person
has to go through stages to be able
to acquire it. However, as it has
been said earlier, prices of cement
in 2020 in my constituency was
GH¢38 per bag but today, it is GH¢
52 per bag and this is due to the
Statements

taxes and levies that have been im-

posed on other components needed

for the production of cement. This

is an important Statement which

should not be swept under the car-

pet but we should seriously interro-

gate and do something about it.

Mr Speaker, as Ghanaians, I

would want to suggest that we

should also look at the appropriate

technological way to build houses.

Currently, everybody wants to build

with sandcrete but our forefathers

used landcrete to build and some of

such houses are over 100 years.

Traditionally, if people use

landcrete to build they would be

laughed at and considered as poor

or unenlightened people. We should

also consider other options in the

construction industry because if we

depend largely on cement - in other

countries cement is just a minute

component of material in the con-

struction of houses but Ghanaians

would traditionally want to use

sandcrete which involves the use of

cement before the blocks could be

moulded and is costly as well. So, if

we could change our taste from

sandcrete to landcrete or even to

thatch or other ways of building

houses, we would not talk about the

high cost of cement in this

country -
Mr E. Opoku 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
rise on a point of information which
is permissible under the Standing
Orders.
Mr Ahi 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would
yield to him.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
I
would not grant it.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
the Hon Member for Bodi, has
yielded to him.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:55 p.m.
I
would not grant it. Hon Member for
Bodi, if you have finished with your
contribution, tell me otherwise, you
may continue.
Mr Ahi 12:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, please, I
need his information to continue
with my contribution, so if you
could allow him?.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker;
No! I would not admit it. [Laugh-
Mr Ahi 1:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I agree
entirely that the cost of building
materials is too expensive in this
country and the Hon Member for
Ho West, Mr Bedzrah said, it is not
only cement which is expensive but
Statements

there are other materials like iron

rods so the Government should be

able to do something about it. My

Hon Colleague said that the prices

are not because of the taxes that

have been imposed on the people

which is not true.

Mr Speaker, if we go through

the price build up, we would see

that a chunk of it is as a result of

taxes and levies that have been im-

posed on the pricing formula for ce-

ment. So, we should do something

about it. I would also want to call on

Ghanaians to try and develop taste

in using other materials so that we

can reduce the cost of building in

this country.

Mr Speaker, with these few

words, I would want to thank you

and plead that you allow Hon Eric

Opoku one minute to fill in the gap.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:05 p.m.
Hon Eric Opoku, there is no gap for
you to fill.
Yes, Hon Members, let me
come to the Majority Leadership.
Deputy Majority Leader (Mr
Alexander K. Afenyo-Markin):
Mr Speaker, I thank you for the op-
portunity to make a few comments
on the Statement made by our re-
spected Colleague.
Mr Speaker, this is an important
piece of information that he has
brought to our attention. In particu-
lar, if you look at page 3 of the
Statement, he makes an observation
on point two and this is a matter that
I think the Ministers for Transport
and Trade and Industry could to-
gether look at because if merely
berthing is leading to extra charges
to these manufacturers, then it
should be addressed. I believe that
they would take the matter on
board. But the impression that this
Statement also created to the effect
that taxes have contributed to the
price escalation, I beg to contend
that this is not wholly correct. [In-
terruption] -I humbly contend that
that is not wholly correct. [Inter-

Mr Speaker, yesterday, I passed

a comment that my Hon Colleagues

on the other Side were intolerant

and they are still demonstrating it.

Statements

Mr Speaker, first, the interna-

tional price for clinker has

increased globally by 27 per cent

and I would want to draw the atten-

tion of the maker of the Statement

that that is the first point to which

he agreed. He also agreed that

freight charges have skyrocketed. If

somebody was previously paying

2000 US$ for a container today that

person pays over 12,000 US$.

Mr Speaker, we are not talking

about Ghana charges but the freight

charges. When one imports, they

are charged the cost, insurance and

freight (CIF) rates. Those are

charges that the importer pays from

the source. This is an external factor

which has nothing to do with

Ghana.

Mr Speaker, when containers -
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:05 p.m.
Hon Sulemana, you brought this
important topic for discussion. You
have made the Statement; allow
Hon Members to also contribute.
[Interruption] So, allow him to fin-
ish; when he finishes then -
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, freight charges have gone up glob-
ally. Freight charges on prices that
are paid by importers have nothing
to do with the Ghanaian economy
or Government's decision.
Mr Speaker, we know that for
the past six months or so, we have
had containers becoming scarce.
So, one may be importing from
China, India and Europe but one
may not be getting containers to
ferry one's goods. Meanwhile, I know businessmen and women who
are paying extra charges. If they
want express, they have to pay
more. This has nothing to do with
the Ghanaian economy and the
Government of Ghana's decision.
Mr Speaker, clinker is affected;
so, that must also be mentioned.
Mr Speaker, now, let us analyse
the issue of tax wholly because my
Hon Colleague has brought taxation
up. The question is, apart from the
COVID-19 one per cent tax that he
has talked about as having been
imposed and the mention of 0.50
US$ levy per tonne, those charges
that were on clinker importation
were charges that preceded this
Government; True or false?
Statements

Mr Speaker, the maker of the

Statement failed to talk about the

rate of increase between 2012 and

2016. How does he expect us to

accept him to have made an objec-

tive analysis of the situation when

he only limits himself to 2019? That

is not objective enough. It is im-

portant to draw his attention. He

started his research somewhere and

I would take him back. In his State-

ment, he kept repeating research,

research, research; similar situa-

tions occurred long before 2017,

2018, 2019 and 2020. Between

2012 and 2016 -
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:05 p.m.
Yes, Hon Deputy Minority Leader?
Mr James K. Avedzi 1:05 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the Hon Deputy Majority
Leader is veering into a debate. He
is to make comments on the State-
ment. If he goes that way, defi-
nitely, he would get a reaction be-
cause if he says taxes that have been
imposed on clinker importation
have been there before 2017, that is
not true. The taxes that have been
mentioned by the maker of the
Statement where he talked about the
one per cent is on COVID-19 levy
- Was COVID-19 there before we
came to power? No! Was the fumi-
gation tax there before? No! Was
the sanitation and pollution levy
there before? No! So, he is com-
pletely going into areas that he
would get reactions. He should just
stay on course and speak to the
facts. What he is saying is com-
pletely out of order. These taxes
were not there before 2017.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am not getting out of the comfort
zone. They are only acting in bad
faith. I know them; they are my
friends. They cannot take a bitter
pill. I have not finished my analysis.
I agree that these impositions were
approved here but let us look at the
quantum as the basis for our analy-
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:05 p.m.
Hon Deputy Majority Leader, you
should address the Chair.
[Interruption] No, it is not on.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, yesterday, I told you that they are
intolerant. Today, they are repeat-
ing same. The Hon Member has
spoken from a three-page State-
ment; at least, listen to me. That is
democracy.
Mr Speaker, he contends in his Statement that these taxes have given rise to the escalation of prices.
Statements

Now, I counter that by telling

him that it is not wholly true be-

cause to say that these have led to

this, he must look at the quantum.

The one per cent levy cannot be the

factor for the escalated situation we

have. However -
Mr Buah 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the Hon
Member is misleading the House
and he should be forewarned every
time he speaks - [Laughter] - the Hon Member has issued a State-
ment; he could contribute to the
Statement as required by the Stand-
ing Orders but he cannot be point-
ing fingers at him continuously - What is that?

In any event, the reference he

made to taxes --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:15 p.m.
Hon Member, you have made your
point.
Mr Buah 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the ref-
erence the Hon Member made to
taxes were references to new taxes.
For example, US$0.50 per ton fu-
migation levy is new. It has just
been introduced.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:15 p.m.
Hon Member, your Hon Deputy
Minority Leader has already al-
luded to all these issues you are
Mr Buah 1:15 p.m.
Hon Afenyo-Markin
can contribute to the debate without
pointing fingers at the Hon Member
who made the Statement.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:15 p.m.
Hon Deputy Majority Leader, con-
clude and let us move to another is-
sue.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker, so, the point I would like to make is
that the Statement as presented, is
misleading. The supposed facts are
inaccurate; the contention of the
Hon Member who made the State-
ment that prices of cement have
skyrocketed as a result of levies and
taxes cannot be correct. It can only
hold if the quantum is such that it
has a direct effect on the price.
Mr Speaker, I accordingly dare
the Hon Member who made the
Statement to take his time since he
has consistently made reference to
research to tell us the 1 per cent san-
itation levy and its effects on pro-
ducer price. Then we can have a
good discussion but for now, I dare
challenge him that all he has said in
relation to the price of cement at the
Statements

current retail point can never be

factual.

However, I humbly submit that

external factors such as charges on

freight and the price of clinker glob-

ally have rather contributed signifi-

cantly to such prices as we have at

the producer point.

Mr Speaker, I conclude by com-

mending Hon Sampson Ahi who

spoke before me. He was once there

as the Deputy Minister for Works

and Housing and suggested alterna-

tive ways of looking at the con-

struction sector and was right on

point. This is because he has been

part of policy making.

When we are talking about con-

struction, we should sell new ideas

to our people -- [Interruption] [Laughter]
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:15 p.m.
Hon Member, I hope you have con-
cluded.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker, there is this pre-fabrication con-
struction technology that has been
with us for years but our people do not seem to like such approach. I think the time has come for us to market such a technology and others that can aid cheaper construction. These are important because I recall some 20
years ago when Ghana Cement
(GHACEM) was the sole producer
of cement and enjoyed monopoly,
we thought that by opening up for
other brands to come in, the prob-
lem would be solved but it does not
appear to be so since they all de-
pend on the clinker and so on.
So, I think that we have to take
this matter seriously and look at the
recommendation; the good sugges-
tions from Hon Ahi which looked at
the interest of Ghanaians -- [Hear! Hear!] -- and not the rather jaun- diced analysis of the situation with
the aim of, for want of a better
word, scoring cheap political points
by the Hon Member who made the
Statement. This is because he did
not do accurate analysis. He aimed
at scoring cheap political points. He
can simply contend it but those are
my comments.
Mr Speaker, this is because
when one stands on the Floor and
decides to use 1 per cent - I dare him and I challenge all of them on
the other Side to write to calculate
the percentage on the manufactur-
ing price. He cannot mislead the
House that 1 per cent sanitation tax
has led to the prices at the retail
point, he should calculate and pro-

Statements
Mr Avedzi 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I think
that we are moving to an area that
will not auger well for this House.
If an Hon Member prepares a State-
ment duly admitted by your good
Self and you allow that Member to
read that Statement on the Floor,
and a Leader from the Majority
Side tells the Member that he
wanted to score cheap political
points, it will not auger well for us.
Mr Speaker, the Hon Leader has
not been fair to the Hon Member
who made the Statement at all. If 1
per cent is not important, why did
the Government even come out
with 1 per cent? They needed that
revenue and it means that the 1 per
cent is important.
So, for the Hon Deputy Majority
Leader who is the Leader of Gov-
ernment Business to say that an
Hon Member made a Statement to
score cheap political points, we take
strong objection to that. He is noted
for making statements that do not
auger well for the cohesion of the
House.
Mr Speaker, please direct him to
do the right thing. He should with-
draw that statement and apologise
to the Hon Member who made the
Statement.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:15 p.m.
Hon Deputy Majority Leader,
please withdraw that Statement.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
in all seriousness, this is a House of
record. Yesterday, Hon Isaac Yaw
Opoku brought a Statement and
when it got to the turn of Hon Eric
Opoku to make comments, his con-
tention was to the effect that the
Statement presented was inaccurate
and that it was his duty to point out
the inaccuracies because it was mis-
leading. The Hon Deputy Minority
Leader rose to defend the position
to say that he is entitled to debate
the issues if the facts were inaccu-
rate.
Mr Speaker, all I am saying is
that the Hon Member provides three
points to say that --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:15 p.m.
Hon Deputy Majority Leader, your
point is understood. My position is
that the fact that you said the State-
ment was meant to score cheap po-
litical points means that the Hon
Speaker who more or less admitted
it, did not look - Please, just with- draw that statement.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:15 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I think that this is a language that we
use as politicians but if on this oc-
casion it is a problem that it would
Statements

be inappropriate to use ‘cheap polit- ical points', I withdraw. They are my respected Hon Colleagues and if

they are offended by it, they should

accept my sincere apologies.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Very well.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:25 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
having said that, it is then fair to
conclude that the Statement as pre-
sented is inaccurate and misleading
and same must not be seen as an ob-
jective analysis of the situation. I so
submit.
Mr Speaker, thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Very well. You are entitled to that.
Hon Members, as the Hon
Chairman of the Finance Commit-
tee alluded to early on, a similar
Statement has been made and re-
ferred to the Joint Committee of Fi-
nance, Trade and Industry.
So, we will add this particular
Statement as well and the Joint
Committee should let us receive the
Report as soon as possible.
Mr Ahi 1:25 p.m.
Mr Speaker, since we
are talking about the building indus-
try, I want to plead that you allow
the Committee on Works and Hous-
ing to also be part of the Joint Com-
mittee.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Very well.
The Committee on Works and
Housing could also join the Joint
Committee.
Hon Members, we would take
the second Statement --
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:25 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
please we have an application to
make. Respectfully, if we may vary
the order of business and take the
Motions numbered 8, 9, 11 and 16.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:25 p.m.
Hon Members, we would take the
items numbered 8 and 9 on page 3
of the Order Paper. Hon Chairman
of the Committee?
Statements
MOTIONS 1:25 p.m.

TP 1:25 p.m.

GNPC 1:25 p.m.

ABFA 1:25 p.m.

Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:35 p.m.
I
am inclined to invite two Hon
Members from each Side to contrib-
ute to the debate.
I would begin with the Hon
Member for Nhyiaeso, Dr Stephen
Amoah.
Dr Stephen Amoah (NPP -- Nhyiaeso) 1:35 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would
like to, first, say kudos to the man-
agers of the Ministry of Finance for
the fact that PIAC's Report has
clearly indicated without any ambi-
guity or debate that if we look at the
liftings of the crude oil and other in-
flows, as a result of the unfortunate
COVID-19 pandemic, all these pa-
rameters have been reduced, yet our
Ministry of Finance, under the good
leadership of Hon Ken Ofori-Atta
and the Deputies, has been able to
put the money to very good and ju-
dicious use.
Mr Speaker, I am quite surprised
that my senior Colleague, the Rank-
ing Member on the same Commit-
tee, is actually trying to place em-
phasis on the figure of 2 million be-
ing actually challenged by PIAC. I
would like to find out whether the
Auditor-General's Department, as part of their jurisdiction and defined
core responsibilities do not audit the
Ministry of Finance and its outlets
and if they do, is there anything that
indicates the fact or otherwise that
such amount has been used without
any supporting materials? This is
because I know that before such a
statement is made, first, we need to
consider the reporting framework.
Secondly, we need to consider the
materiality and the narrative and the
supporting document to show that
we cannot trace this money along
the critical activity path that would
enable us draw some of these infer-
ences. So I would like the Ranking
PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)

Member to further give us particu-

lars and materials to support this as-

sertion because it is entirely false.

Mr Speaker, I think what we

have to do is offer credence to the

appropriate authorities and their

core responsibilities before we em-

phasise and support some of these

claims. All that I am saying is that

the Ministry of Finance has put up a

very splendid and exclusive perfor-

mance in managing the resources of

this state in spite of the fact that our

fiscal space has been congested be-

cause of the COVID-19, slowing

our market and industry operations

and activities and slowing produc-

tivity, leading to low revenue gen-

eration. Unlike other countries,

Ghana, despite the challenges

brought in by the pandemic, has

been able to make use of resources

very well. We should rather praise

the Ministry of Finance so that it

would motivate them and the future

ones to do same.

Mr Speaker, I would like to end

by saying that PIAC's Report is good but we should check the as-

pects of it that has made my senior

Colleague, in my opinion, make

these comments without any mate-

riality. It should rather take the Au-

ditor-General's Report to make these conclusions and inferences.

Mr Speaker, thank you for the

opportunity.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Thank you very much. Let me come
to the Hon Member for Ellembele.
Mr Emmanuel A. Buah (NDC
-- Ellembele): Mr Speaker, let me thank the Finance Committee for
the very good work done on the
PIAC Report for 2020.
Mr Speaker, in paragraph 340,
the Report talks about the develop-
ment of the upstream oil and gas
sector and it talks about the fact that
there has been a stoppage of drilling
activities. It listed that almost all the
companies operating the upstream
sector had to stop work. All the
work programmes that had been
given them were stopped. One of
the reasons given was the pan-
demic. But Mr Speaker, that should
be a matter of great worry for this
Republic.
Mr Speaker, this is important be-
cause the oil and gas production
that have been talked about are all
coming from three producing fields
- TEN, Jubilee and Sankofa.
Mr Speaker, I am very proud of
where I sit because those are the
handiworks of the NDC Govern-
ment.
PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)

Nothing has been added and that

is a fact. More importantly, we

should be concerned that we are not

increasing oil and gas production,

and that really goes to the core of

the revenue we are looking for for

development. We must focus on

that. Why am I concerned? Re-

cently, we heard of the exit of a ma-

jor oil company in Ghana; that

sends signal to the industry. When

ExxonMobil goes to a country and

leaves under questionable circum-

stances -- As I speak, the Govern- ment of Ghana has been taken to

court by another major company;

ENI Exploration and Production

Limited. Tullow Oil has issues with

the Government of Ghana in taxes - - [Interruption] It is in the Report; this is about oil production. These

are very important matters that we

must be concerned about because it

goes to the core of increasing our oil

and gas production.

Mr Speaker, what is also worri-

some in this Report is the annual

budget funding amount, and how

we have utilised it for the last 11

years. I was lucky to be here when

we passed the Petroleum Revenue

Management Act in 2009; I remem-

ber that very well. Our objective

was to ensure tha,t as a country, we

were different, and that we would

utilise oil revenues to the benefit of

the people of Ghana.

Mr Speaker, in this Report,

PIAC has said that they cannot ac-

count for GHȻ827 million - [Inter- ruption.] It is in the Report. Do you

want me to read it? If you cannot

read it, I will read it for you. Para-

Paragraph 5.3 - Unutilised bal- ances of the ABFA, Mr Speaker,

with your permission, I beg to read:

“The Committee observed from the report that a total

amount of GHȻ827.60 mil- lion of the unspent ABFA

was utilised to partially

meet shortfalls…”

But PIAC went ahead to say that

they completely disagree with this

view.

Mr Speaker, the point is that we

must address this issue because it

has been lingering for some time.
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon Minister, I will come to you; I
will give you time to talk.
PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)
Mr Buah 1:45 p.m.
Mr Speaker, another
important matter is that the Report
talks about 4000 projects that are
spread across the country and???
how we are utilising oil revenue. I
think that,as a country, after 11
years of oil production, we must
come back to ask the question. So,
after 11 years of oil production,
what can we point to that we used
the oil revenue for? We spread it so
thin. The argument was made that
we must really think big. Is it rail-
ways for the next 10 years? Is that

Please, stop it. Do not let me go

there because if we start talking

about expenditure --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon Member, address the Chair.
Mr Buah 1:45 p.m.
Mr Speaker, so that is
a matter that must be brought to the
attention of the House. We must re-
visit how we have spent oil revenue
in the last 11 years, and make a de-
cision to deal with big items that
would make an impact on our coun-
try. Frankly, as we speak, we cannot
point to big projects that we have
used the oil revenue for, and that is
unfortunate.
Mr Speaker, it is also very im-
portant that we talk about the
PIAC Report to understand a con-
scious decision we made in this
House that we would not allocate
money for the ABFA, but we would
also leave money aside for future
generations, because this is a finer
resource. Let us be united at this
point that it does not matter how
tough it becomes; nobody should
think of touching the Heritage
Fund. It is not for us the living; it is
for generations yet unborn. [Inter-
ruption.] We rushed and spent the
Stabilisation Fund. They were here.
So, they should let us agree that we
are not - I hope the Minister for Fi- nance has no designs on the Herit-
age Fund because I know we will
resist it.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Hon Member, please conclude.
Mr Buah 1:45 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am
concluding. The other important
point is about gas production. The
NDC Administration brought this
country to the gas era -- [Interrup- tion] It is the reason long Liquefied
Petroleum Gas (LPG) lines were
gone, and it is the reason almost 70
per cent of power plants in Ghana
are now using indigenous gas.

Mr Speaker, you heard that the

NDC Administration has done a lot

PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)

of take or pay projects. Today, as I

speak, we have seen a reduction in

that production. Why in the world

will anybody bring a take or pay

Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) Pro-

ject when we have more than

enough gas in the Western Basins

and it is a take or pay for this Gov-

ernment which preached no take or

pay projects? What is sad and dan-

gerous is that, as I speak, Ghana

Gas is owed - in the Report, it is GHȻ800 million, but it is over a bil- lion dollars today in gas supplied to

Volta River Authority (VRA). This

debt to the energy sector must be

dealt with, because it has the poten-

tial for sending us back to dumsor

and really destroying this economy.

Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

opportunity.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:45 p.m.
Yes, Hon Deputy Minister?
Deputy Minister for Finance
(Mr John A. Kumah) (MP): Mr
Speaker, I thank you very much. I
would wish to correct a misleading
impression that has been made from
the Report that is before this hon-
ourable House.
Mr Speaker, on the specific is-
sue of utilisation of balance of the
ABFA on the amount of GHȻ827
million, on page 11 of the Report -
I am sure the Hon Member who just
spoke did not advert his mind to the
full Report - the Ministry of Fi-
nance explained that the
GHȻ827.60 million that was uti-
lised was not as a result of shortfall
in the ABFA receipt for 2020 but,
rather, they were in respect of out-
standing projects under the ABFA
that were completed in 2020 and
were duly paid for.
Mr Speaker, Hon Members
would recall that PIAC in its previ-
ous reports drew our attention to the
existence of this matter. The said
projects were completed in the year
under review and upon the presen-
tation of certificates, payment was
effected which amounted to
GHȻ827.60 million. These facts
have been provided to the Commit-
tee and captured in the Report and
yet we have been told in this House
that an amount of GHȻ827 million
cannot be found, when receipts and
certificates have been provided at
the Committee level to explain the
circumstances of this amount. So, it
is misleading and inaccurate for the
Hon Member to refer to this matter
as outstanding -- [Hear! Hear] It
has been discussed and settled at the
Committee level and captured in
this Report on page 11.
PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)

Mr Speaker, thank you very
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Let me give the last opportunity to
the Hon Member for Ho Central.
Mr Benjamin K. Kpodo (NDC
-- Ho Central): Mr Speaker, thank you for the opportunity. I join the
Hon Ranking Member to applaud
PIAC for their new vim which they
have exhibited in pursuing this as-
signment given to them.
Mr Speaker, PIAC Report is like
an audit report. They delve into how
much was realised, how much oil
was produced, and how the moneys
were used.

I would even recommend that

apart from the Report going to the

Finance Committee, it should also

be referred to the Public Accounts

Committee (PAC), so that all the

stakeholders in the oil revenue man-

agement process appear publicly to

answer questions at the Public Ac-

counts Committee. That would ex-

pose them to greater details in an-

swering the questions or filling up

the gap.

Mr Speaker, the Public Interest

and Accountability Committee

(PIAC) has embarked on its own

monitoring activities. Indeed, they

had a team in my constituency to

come and inspect two clinic pro-

jects which were undertaken using

the Annual Budget Funding

Amount (ABFA). They were in the

Ho West Constituency as well, and

that is how come they are able to

produce some of these reports.

Mr Speaker, there is this hang-

ing issue of an amount of US$50

million. The Government which

took the money is telling the Ghana

National Petroleum Corporation

(GNPC) that they cannot give them

that money any longer because they

took it from their capped amount,

but it is the same Government that

introduced the Earmarked Funds

Capping and Realignment Act,

2017 (Act 947). They are telling us

that as a result of what they have

done, GNPC's amount of US$50 million is gone, but why is GNPC

still holding this amount of US$50

million as a receivable that they are

expecting from the Government? I

think that we should put an end to

this so that we do not have it reoc-

curring in our reports.

Mr Speaker, the issue of unu-

tilised ABFA is a serious matter.

The budgets are constructed every

PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)

year, and funds that go into the

ABFA are expected to be applied to

carry out projects. Now, when we

go to project sites, we realise that

contractors have abandoned the

sites because they have not been

paid, yet, they say that they have

kept the unutilised money. So,

where is the money? Where have

they kept it? Because PIAC even re-

ports on it, and I can quote from

their own report. It says and I beg to

read:

“… PIAC observes that all the disbursements do not

provide details of the pro-

jects and programmes that

were supported. The Com-

mittee looks forward to

these details to enable it

monitor implementation.

PIAC has been of the posi-

tion that unspent ABFA

should be deposited back

into the Petroleum Holding

Fund (PHF) for realloca-

tion the following financial

year. The Ministry on the

other hand holds the view

that the Petroleum Revenue

Management Act (PRMA)

provides for withdrawal

from the PHF/ABFA but

not deposit of ABFA into

the PHF. There is the need

to find a common ground in

the spirit of the PRMA that

would avoid the accumula-

tion of unspent ABFA as

experienced over the past

three years.”

Mr Speaker, therefore, like

PIAC, we are concerned about

moneys allocated to the ABFA but

not used. However, if it is not used,

then where is it being kept? Is it be-

ing kept in the Consolidated Fund;

or, has the Ministry got another

bank account into which these un-

spent amounts are kept? Or, is it

missing? Those are the questions

which PIAC is asking. I read di-

rectly from the PIAC Report and

not the Finance Committee's Re- port.

Mr Speaker, another major issue

which I would have to raise is that

PIAC relied solely on the PRMA

Act, (Act 815) to do its report.

There is a big shot coming from

there: In June 2019, the Supreme

Court gave new directives about the

use of oil and gas proceeds, but they

have not taken account of it. If one

reads the whole Report, one would

not find the relevance of the Su-

preme Court ruling in the use of oil

money. It is not there because I can-

not find it on any page. If the Hon

Chairman finds something related

to that, then he can bring it up. I

would --

PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Hon Member, please conclude. [In-
terruption] --
Hon Kpodo, do not respond to
Mr Kpodo 1:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I think
that --
Mr Kwaku Agyeman Kwart-
eng: Mr Speaker, I rise on Standing
Order 93 (4), which requires Hon
Members not to make references to
subject matters that are not on the
Table for discussion. The Supreme
Court ruling was on the minimum
of five per cent constitutional re-
quirement that should go to the Dis-
trict Assemblies' Common Fund
(DACF). The Report that we are
discussing today has to do with the
Committee's Report on PIAC. So, I
think that the Hon Member is out of
order, and I hope he is called to or-
der.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Very well.
Hon Member, just restrict your-
self to the PIAC Report. Mean-
while, you have taken a lot of time;
so, you may conclude for us.
Mr Kpodo 1:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I reject
the issue raised by the Hon Chair-
man of the Committee. If PIAC is
doing an audit of petroleum reve-
nue, then it must take into account
all relevant laws, and the ruling of
the Supreme Court is part of
Ghana's laws, which must be taken into consideration. So, Mr Speaker,
I ask that you direct the Attorney-
General to furnish the ruling of the
Supreme Court to the PIAC so that
when they are doing their audit they
would take account of whatever di-
rectives are there. This is because
these directives concern the distri-
bution of oil revenue. We have a
whole chapter on the use of ABFA,
and the Supreme Court has given
directives as to how the ABFA
should be used.
So, I do not see why they would
not comment on it. I think it is be-
cause they lack the details of the
ruling of the Supreme Court. So, I
think that the Attorney-General
should officially serve PIAC, so
that they would use it in determin-
ing how the petroleum revenue
should be used.
Mr Speaker, I have earlier said
that since this Report is like an audit
report, it should be forwarded to the
Public Accounts Committee as
well, so that they can invite all the
PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)

relevant stakeholders; GNPC, Min-

istry of Finance and all others who

are stakeholders to also answer as to

how they have applied the funds of

the State in relation to oil proceeds.

Mr Speaker, I thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Very well. However, on your di-
rective for me to ask the Supreme
Court to furnish PIAC with its rul-
ing, I do not think it is necessary.
The Supreme Court's judgements
are available; so, whoever is inter-
ested can furnish himself with it.
So, I do not think there is the need
for it. [Interruption] - Whatever it
is, the Attorney-General is availa-
ble; so, whoever wants the report on
the Supreme Court's judgement can
access it. I do not think it is some-
thing that is hidden.
Hon Members, I was going to
put the Question.
Question put and Motion agreed
to.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Hon Members, we would move on
to --
Mr Sampson Ahi 1:55 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
this is just to draw your attention to
the time. It is almost 2. 00 p.m., so,
you should avert your mind to it.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Very well.
Hon Members, we would there-
fore move on to the Motions num-
bered 10 and 11.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:55 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, it should rather be Mo-
tions 11 and 16.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:55 p.m.
Very well.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Hon Members, let us turn our atten-
tion to page 4 of the Order paper,
and take the Motion numbered 11.
Before the Hon Chairman does that,
as the Hon Sampson Ahi drew our
attention, the time is 2 o'clock, and I respectfully direct that Sitting con-
tinues after the stipulated time.
Hon Chairman, you may move
the Motion.
PIAC Report on mgt and use of Petrol. Revenues (Jan - June 2020) and (Jan - Dec 2020)
MOTIONS 2:05 p.m.

Chairman of the Committee (Mr Kwaku Agyeman Kwarteng) 2:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to move, that this
honourable House adopts the Re-
port of the Finance Committee on
the Annual Report on the Petroleum
Funds for the 2020 Fiscal Year, and
in doing so, present your Commit-
tee's Report.
1.0 Introduction
Further to the presentation of the
Budget Statement and Economic
Policy of the Government of Ghana
for the year ended 31st December,
2021, the Annual Report on the Pe-
troleum Funds for 2020 was first
presented to the House pursuant to
Sections 15 and 48 of the Petroleum
Revenue Management Act, 2011
(Act 815) as amended by Act 893.
The report was referred to the
Finance Committee for considera-
tion and report in accordance with
article 179 of the 1992 Constitution
and Orders 140 (5) and 169 of the
Standing Orders of the House.
The Committee met with a Deputy Minister for Finance, Hon Abena Osei Asare and the technical teams from the Ministry of Finance, Bank of Ghana, Public Interest Accountability Commit- tee (PIAC), Ministry of Energy, Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA), Energy Commission, Ghana Road Fund Secre- tariat, National Petroleum Authority, Electricity Company of Ghana, Volta River Authority, Ghana National Petro- leum Company (GNPC), Ghana National Gas Company (GNGC) and Controller and Accountant General's Department and reports as follows:
2.0 Documents Referred to
The Committee referred to the
following documents:
a. 1992 Constitution;
b. The Petroleum Revenue Management Act, 2011
(Act 815) as amended by
Act 893; and
c. The Standing Orders of Parliament.
3.0 Purpose of the Report
The purpose of the Report as
stipulated in Section 48 0f Act 815
is to inform the House on the au-
dited financial statements of the
previous year comprising:

i. The receipts and transfers

to and from the Petroleum

Holding Fund;

ii. The deposits into and

withdrawals from the

Ghana Stabilisation Fund

(GSF) and the Ghana Her-

itage Fund (GHF); and

iii. Balance Sheet including a

note listing the qualifying

instruments of the Ghana

Petroleum Funds.

Section 15 0f Act 815 as

amended by Act 893 requires the

Finance Minister to reconcile the

actual total petroleum receipts and

the Annual Budget Funding

Amount (ABFA) of the previous

year and submit a written report to

Parliament not later than the end of

the first quarter of the current year.

It is in compliance with this sec-

tion that the Minister responsible

for Finance has submitted this re-

port to Parliament. The report also

covers receipts into the Petroleum

Holding Fund (PHF) and withdraw-

als from the PHF to the various des-

ignated accounts in accordance

with the Act.

4.0 Observations

4.1 Upstream Developments

The Committee observed that

during the period under review, the

Ghana Negotiating Team (GNT)

continued its negotiation of Petro-

leum Agreements and engagement

with bid winners of the Licensing

Round as well as other companies

which applied through direct nego-

tiations.

The Ministry of Energy also

granted authorisation to the Ghana

National Petroleum Corporation

(GNPC) to undertake exploration

and production activities in the GH-

WB-01 Block awarded to them in

the Tano basin.

Pursuant to Subsection (9) of

Section 10 of the Petroleum (Explo-

ration and Production) Act, 2016,

(Act 919) and Regulation 19(6) of

the Petroleum (Exploration and

Production) (General) Regulations,

L.I. 2359, the Ministry of Energy

published an invitation for direct

negotiations for Petroleum Explo-

ration and Production Rights in re-

spect of Block GH_ WB_04 off-

shore. Similarly, an invitation for

direct negotiations for Petroleum

Exploration and Production

Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020

Fiscal Year

Licences for fifteen (15) Blocks in

the Eastern Basin-Offshore Ghana

has been sent out for interested

companies to apply.

The Committee observed that the

Petroleum Agreement (PA) negoti-

ations with Eni Ghana and First

E&P Ltd was far advanced despite

some delays which were occa-

sioned by the Covid-19 pandemic.

When complete, the negotiated PA

would be sent to cabinet for ap-

proval and to Parliament for ratifi-

cation in accordance with article

268 (1) of the 1992 Constitution.

4.2 Petroleum Receipts for 2020

Total petroleum receipts for

2020 was US$666.4 million which

is 0.9 per cent above the target

ofUS$660.5 million but lower than

the 2019 outturn ofUS$937.6 mil-

lion by 28.9 per cent. The relatively

lower revenues in 2020 was mainly

on account of lower achieved aver-

age crude oil price of US$43.3,

compared to US$63.2 in 2019. The

breakdown of the receipts (in US$

million) is shown in the Table 1 be-

low:

Table 1 - Breakdown of Re-

ceipts for 2020

Budgeted Revised Actual

Budget

Royalties 236.79 144.7 195.36

Carried and Participating Interest 505.99 380.39 300.93

Surface Rentals 1.11 1.35 0.93

Corporate Income Tax 191.14 134.01 168.77

PHF Income 2.55 0 0.23

0 0 0.18

Total 937.13 660.45 666.40

Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020

Fiscal Year

4.3 Allocation of 2020 Petroleum

Receipts

The report revealed that out of

the total petroleum receipts of

US$666.39 million for the year

2020, US$638.64 Million was dis-

tributed. The rest, amounting to

US$27.75 million, represents

receipts from Corporate Income

Tax and Surface Rentals were not

distributed in 2020 as there was no

subsequent lifting proceeds for the

year to be distributed with this

amount. Details of the allocation 1s

captured in Table 2 below:

Table 2 Allocation of 2019 Petro-

leum Receipts

Item Actual

Transfer to GNPC 198,649.2

o/w Equity Financial Cost 154,816.0

o/w Crude Oil Net Carried and Participation Interest 43,833.20

ABFA and GPFs 439,993.8

o/w Annual Budget funding Amount 273,382.4

o/w Ghana Petroleum Funds 166,611.4

o/w Ghana Stabilisation Fund 116,628.0

o/w Ghana Heritage Fund 49,983.40

Total 638,643.00

Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020

Fiscal Year

4.4 Utilisation of the Annual

Budget Funding Amount (ABFA)

The total ABFA utilisation

amounted to GH¢2,771.12 Million

with the ABFA has been spent on

the priority areas.

The actual utilised ABFA ex-

ceeded the programmed revised

ABFA by GH¢1,114.93 million, a

deviation of 67.3 per cent. Details

of the utilisation of the ABFA is

captured in Table 3 below:

Table 3 Utilisation of ABFA

Revised Actual (M) Variance (M)

Budget (M)

Agriculture « 112.87 79.02 -33.85

Education and Health 567.96 698.24 130.28

Service Delivery

Road, Rail and Other

Critical

925.47 1,958.97 1,033.50

Infrastructure Development

Industrial Development 46.80 31.80 -15.00

Public Interest and 3.09 3.09 00

Accountability Committee

Total 1,656.19 2,771.12 1,114.93

Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020

Fiscal Year

4.5 Unutilised balances of ABFA

The Committee was informed that from 2017 to 2019, total unutilised ABFA balances amounted to GH¢1.48 billion.

Details of the unutilised ABFA

are captured in Table 4 below:

Table 4 Details of unutilised
ABFA 2:05 p.m.

rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Hon Member for Karaga, please
take off that word; take it off.
Dr Adam 2:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have
taken out that word with your per-
mission.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Very well.
Hon Member, continue.
Dr Adam 2:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Exx-
onMobil itself has explained why
they had to leave Ghana -[Interrup-
tion]y --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Hon Members, why? I have asked
him to withdraw that word.
Hon Member, please withdraw
that word.
Dr Adam 2:05 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have
withdrawn accordingly.
-- [Interruption] [Uproar] j --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:05 p.m.
Hon Members, my instruction was
for him to withdraw; I did not add
‘apologise' please.
Dr Adam 2:25 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Exx-
onMobil itself has explained on
their website at the time they left
Ghana that they were cutting down
on new projects and they were not
ready to invest in frontier areas.
This is just because of their energy
transition plan. And it was not only
Ghana that they left; they left South
Africa. They actually had two blocs
in South Africa yet they left South
Africa and some other countries in
Asia, so, we cannot blame the Gov-
ernment of Ghana for the exit of the
ExxonMobil when ExxonMobil is
just implementing its own energy
transition plan.
Mr Speaker, if they are accusing
us of not adding on to production,
the contracts they signed with the
companies - let them tell us what capacities those companies had.
They signed contracts with compa-
nies that did not have capacity, and
these companies could not do ex-
ploration. How do we increase pro-
duction if they signed contracts
with companies that cannot do ex-
ploration? And to date, because of
the scrutiny of our Government, we
Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020
Fiscal Year

have terminated four of such con-

tracts. We have terminated the con-

tracts with UB, Swassco, Britania

and Sahara because we are looking

for companies that would have the

capacity and that would partner

with us to do the exploration and

increase.

Mr Speaker, they are also talk-

ing about some US$50 million, as

if this Government took US$50

million from the GNPC and refused

to give it back to the GNPC. That is

not correct! This US$50 million as

the Hon Member for Ho Central

said, was taken by the NDC Gov-

ernment in 2014. They took the

money from GNPC in 2014; if they

had the money, why did they not

return it in 2015 or 2016 and they

now would want to accuse this

Government of taking money from

the GNPC and not giving it back to

the GNPC. They should explain to

Ghanaians what they did with the

US$50 million they took from the

GNPC. And when they were taking

it, did they not know that GNPC is

not a quasi-fiscal agent?

Mr Speaker, yesterday, His Ex-

cellency, the President presented

Ghana's position at COP26 on our policy for the oil industry. Because

of the energy transition, there is a

fast movement by some countries

that there should be a reduction in

oil production. In fact, Interna-

tional Energy Agency (I. E. A) is

even recommending that no bank

should invest in oil and gas projects

any longer.

But the reality is that countries

like Ghana, cannot stop producing

oil and gas because it is so im-

portant for us to get the revenue.

The revenue we are talking about

would not come about if we do not

invest in further explorations to

produce oil. Therefore, we must

rise to support our President to at-

tract the needed investment into our

oil and gas industry, so that we can

increase exploration, find the oil

and increase production, so that we

can increase the revenue that we so

need to support our economy.

Thank you, Mr Speaker, for the
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:25 p.m.
Let me come to Hon Edward Bawa.
Mr Edward Abambire Bawa
(NDC - Bongo): Mr Speaker, thank you very much for the oppor-
tunity to contribute to the debate. In
doing so, I would first want to con-
gratulate the Finance Committee
for a very good job done. Before I
go straight to what I want to talk
Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020
Fiscal Year

about, it is important to put a few

things in the right perspective.

One, we have a situation where

my Hon Colleague who just spoke

indicated that if you look at the ad-

vance that was given to the Minis-

try of Finance on page 10 - [Inter- ruption] It is important for my Hon

Colleague to understand that the

PIAC Report is based on the Report

that he is talking about in terms of

the Petroleum Holding Funds. So,

as I comment on this, I am putting

them together to make sense of the

argument I am making.

I would like to indicate clearly,

that out of the 11 items that have

been stated, which totals to

US$549,324,551.50, apart from the

US$50 million, all the 10 items

were taken by this current Govern-

ment. So, if you want to be really

objective in your analysis, it is im-

portant to talk about all these items

and not just isolate the US$50 mil-

lion as a basis.

Mr Speaker, what is even more

criminal is that if you look at item

numbered 11, they talk about the

Ministry of Finance BOST Under-

recoveries. I am happy that the Hon

Member who spoke before me, was

the Deputy Minister - I do not know if he is still is the Deputy

Minister in charge of Petroleum. In

trying to deal with this, one of

things that he has not told us is the

fact that if you look at the BOST

Under-recoveries, this under-re-

covery is taken care of by the price

build-up. There is a particular item

on the price build-up which is

known as the energy debt recovery.
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:25 p.m.
Hon O. B. Amoah?
Mr O. B. Amoah 2:25 p.m.
Thank you,
Mr Speaker.
I just would want to find out
from my Hon Colleague on the
other Side whether he said he does
not know that Hon Adam is the
Deputy Minister for Energy and
Petroleum. [Interruption] He said
he did not know whether Hon
Adam is the Deputy Minister.
Mr Bawa 2:25 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I can
understand my Colleague, Hon O.
B. Amoah, he is a bit tired. As a
senior Deputy Minister, I can un-
derstand his concern.
What I was indicating was that
as far as I know, between 2017 and
2020, my Hon Colleague was the
Deputy Minister responsible for
Petroleum. As we speak today, I do
Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020
Fiscal Year

not know and I cannot state facts

that I do not have. That is the point

I made.

Mr Speaker, if they are more

comfortable, let me indicate, that

my Hon Colleague is the Deputy

Minister for Energy -- One thing

that he has not told this House is

that if you look at the price build-

up, there is an item there known as

the Energy Recovery Levy.
Mr Kwarteng 2:25 p.m.
On a point of
order. Mr Speaker, I rise again on
Standing Order 93 (4) to point out
that the matter under discussion is
Motion numbered 11, which is on
petroleum funds. The BOST
charges and petroleum taxes he
referred to are not part of Petro-
leum Funds. [Hear! Hear!] He is
therefore not speaking to the sub-
ject under discussion and I request
he be made to come back to the
discussion.
Mr Speaker, secondly, under
our governance arrangement, there
is no such designation as Deputy
Minister in charge one thing or the
other. So, for the Hon Member to
make those suggestions here is to
introduce things that are extraneous
to the Constitution and I hope that
he is brought to order.
Thank you.
Mr Bawa 2:35 p.m.
Mr Speaker, luckily
enough, I have patience to wait for
them but I would still make my
point. My point is that if you look
at the initial Report that my Hon
Brother commented on, there is an
item there called BOST Under-re-
coveries. I indicated that already,
Ghanaians pay for this particular
under-recovery under a charge
known as the Energy Debt Recov-
ery Levy of GH¢0.48p per litre.
So, for Government again to go
to GNPC to pick up to US$21.3
million to settle that same under-re-
covery is something that Parlia-
ment should not just look at for the
sake of commenting but should in-
vestigate it. This is because Ghana-
ians are already being charged for
this, so for us to have a situation
where the Ministry for Finance can
go back to GNPC and pick this up
is something we should look at.
That is one of the applications I am
trying to make.
Mr Speaker, my second point
which is based on what we are go-
ing to talk about is on the petroleum
receipts themselves. If you look at
the sources of the Petroleum Funds,
there are seven sources. We have
the carried and participating inter-
est from both oil and gas, royalties
from both oil and gas, corporate
Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020
Fiscal Year

income tax, surface rentals, addi-

tional oil entitlements and petro-

leum holding funds income. We

have other sources such as signa-

ture bonuses.

If you look at page 3 of the

Report, you would realise that the

breakdown receipts for 2020

account for only five items. Con-

spicuously missing is the issue of

the carried and participating inter-

est from oil and gas and royalties

from gas. There is a reason for it.

Mr Speaker, since 2017, not a sin-

gle cent has been paid into the Pe-

troleum Holding Funds from gas,

whether as a result of carried inter-

est, participating interest or royal-

ties and there is a reason for this.

Mr Speaker, you would realise

that the indigenous gas that we pro-

duce is all consumed locally and

what happens is that Ghana Gas

processes this gas and gives it to the

power companies. The power com-

panies generate power using that

fuel and give it to the Electricity

Company of Ghana (ECG). ECG

uses that to then distribute the

power, collects the moneys and

then are supposed to now pay up-

stream.

Mr Speaker, unfortunately, be-

cause ECG is not able to collect

those moneys, they are unable to

pay power generators. The power

generators are not able to pay

Ghana Gas for the gas they have

gotten; therefore, Ghana Gas is un-

able to pay GNPC. Due to that, we

do not get these moneys going into

the Petroleum Holding Funds.

When about two or three years

ago, we indicated that the issue of

the collapsed Power Distribution

Services (PDS) Limited Agree-

ment had a very telling effect on the

economy, people did not under-

stand what it was. People thought

that it was just a simple procure-

ment process that went bad but it

went beyond that.

The issue of that money of

GHȼ190 million that we lost was supposed to improve ECG to en-

sure that in terms of their collec-

tions and losses, they would be

high, but unfortunately, today,

ECG has made losses up to about

34 per cent. If a company makes

losses to up to about 34 per cent and

they are unable to pay Ghana Gas

and GNPC, definitely, under the

Petroleum Holding Funds, we

would not get this. That was why I

indicated that as a country, we

should not allow our selfish and

bridled quest for riches affect our

national agenda. That is why today

Annual Report of the Petroleum Funds for the 2020

Fiscal Year

in Bongo or Adaklu, maybe, the fu-

ture Edward Bawas or the Serwaa
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Hon Member, please, withdraw
that name.
Mr Bawa 2:35 p.m.
Mr Speaker, should
I withdraw the “Edward Bawa''? I mentioned two names; I mentioned
the future “Edward Bawas'' and “Serwaa Bronis'', so which one should I withdraw?
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Hon Member, withdraw the latter.
Mr Bawa 2:35 p.m.
Mr Speaker, by your
directive, I would withdraw the
“Serwaa Bronis'' and replace it with “Serwaa Akotos''. [Laugh- ter.] I just wanted to mention two
Ghanaian names - just as I men- tioned “Edward Bawa''. I did not mean any malice.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Hon Member, conclude.
Mr Bawa 2:35 p.m.
Mr Speaker, all
these activities, whether they are in
one sector or the other, are interre-
lated and most often than not, if we
always think that because an inci-
dent happened in one sector it has
no telling effects on other sectors - This current occurrence where gas
money is not paid into the Petro-
leum Holding Funds is because of
an incidence that happened in a
sector that does not belong to it.
Mr Speaker, on this note, I
thank you so much for the oppor-

Question put and Motion

agreed to.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 2:35 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, we would take the item
numbered 16.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Hon Members, item numbered 16.
MOTIONS 2:35 p.m.

Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:35 p.m.
Hon Members, item numbered 17
RESOLUTIONS 2:35 p.m.

WHEREAS 2:35 p.m.

Mr Afenyo-Markin 2:45 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, nothing now remains save
that we are in your hands.

Mr Speaker, while at it, let me,

on behalf of my Hon Colleagues,

congratulate our big sister, Hon

Doyoe. I am told today is her spe-

cial day and we congratulate her.

She is loved by all of us. She is af-

fable and we pray that the good

Lord grant her many more years to

serve her constituents and mother

Ghana.

Hon Doyoe, congratulations.

Is there any communication af-

Mr Speaker, has she anything to

communicate soon after this labour in respect of her big day? [Inter- ruption] -

Mr Speaker, I have received

from her in silence a good commu-

nication soon hereafter and each

Hon Member is invited. It is her

pleasure.

D.C Ltd and the GCRI Ltd Agreement to Redevelop the Accra Racecourse Fiscal Year
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:45 p.m.
Very well, let me come to you, Hon
Deputy Minority Leader.
Mr James K. Avedzi 2:45 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, we would want to thank
you for holding the fort. You sat
since morning and it is getting to
3.00 p.m., so we are in your hands.
Mr Speaker, before you adjourn
the House, I would want to add to
my Hon Colleague's message of congratulation to our dear sister
who is celebrating her 54th birthday
today. She is 54 years old today, so
those who think that she is still a
young girl, know that she is not that
young.
So, Hon Member, happy birth-
day.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:45 p.m.
Very well, Hon Members, let me
also join in congratulating our sis-
ter on the feat of 54 - Is it 54 or 64?
Fifty-four.
She is rejuvenating; she is rather
growing young. Anyway, God
bless you.
Hon Members, it is past 2.00
p.m. and therefore, there is no Mo-
tion to be taken before I adjourn the
House.
ADJOURNMENT 2:45 p.m.