Debates of 24 Feb 2022

MR SECOND DEPUTY SPEAKER
PRAYERS 11:39 a.m.

Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:39 a.m.
Hon
Members, we will take the item numbered
4 on today's Order Paper -- Correction of Votes and Proceedings and the Official
Report. We have the Votes and
Proceedings of 23rd February, 2022 for
correction.
Hon Members, any corrections?
Page 1…15
Hon Members in the absence of any
corrections, the Votes and Proceedings of
23rd February, 2022 --
Hon Members, my attention has just be
drawn to the fact that yesterday, two Papers
were laid. However, the Votes and
Proceedings did not capture them; so, I
direct the Table Office to take note of that
and address it.
Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 11:39 a.m.
Mr Speaker, for
the avoidance of doubt, may the Clerks-at-
the-Table let us know the Papers that were
laid, which were not captured in the Votes
and Proceedings, so that we may know
those specific Papers and be able to trace
them?
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:39 a.m.
Hon
Deputy Majority Whip, your request would
be addressed in the course of time. So, we
would move on to the Official Report of
10th February, 2022. It is available to all of
us, so, Hon Members, any corrections?
Mr Yusif Sulemana 11:39 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on
column 86 of the Official Report dated 10th
February, 2022, on the last paragraph, the
word “uncertain” in the second sentence is supposed to be rather captured as “certain.” I would read it for us to get the right
rendition. It should rather read: “… I am certain, having listened to him…” That was what I said. Therefore, the word there
should not be “uncertain”, but rather “certain”.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:39 a.m.
The
Table Office should please take note of
that.
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:39 a.m.

Mr Rockson-Nelson Dafeamekpor 11:49 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I thank you for this privilege
to wish you a happy birthday.
Mr Speaker, John Keats, that famous
English poet, once wrote that, ‘it is by our own deeds are we mythologised'. Today, we are mythologising you because of your
good deeds. May you live well, grow from
strength to strength, and may you be
returned to Parliament for Fomena. [Some

Mr Speaker, on this note, I wish you all

the best.
Mr Patrick Yaw Boamah 11:49 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, I also would want to add my voice
to the Hon Second Deputy Majority Whip,
Ms Alhassan to wish you a happy birthday,
and also to assure you of the support of the
ruling Party that nominated and made you
the Hon Second Deputy Speaker -- [Hear!
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:49 a.m.

Mr Cassiel Ato Baah Forson 11:49 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, I would want to also join Hon
Colleagues in wishing you a very happy
birthday. You are the true definition of a
rejected stone that has become a chief
cornerstone. Mr Speaker, may your
enemies never see peace --? [Laughter]. It is my prayer that you return to this House
as a Member of Parliament; once again as

Mr Speaker, I wish you well.
Mrs Elizabeth Ofosu-Adjare 11:49 a.m.
Thank
you, Mr Speaker, for the opportunity to
wish you a happy birthday. I have known
you for over 20 years, and I know the kind
of person you are. You really deserve to be
the Second Deputy Speaker of this House.
You have distinguished yourself, and
we pray that the good Lord will continue to
bless you, and return you to this House
anyhow. No matter how you come, we
know you would be level headed, and
continue doing what you are doing. The
sky is the limit for you. Happy birthday!
Dr Kingsley Nyarko 11:49 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I am
very happy that we are celebrating you
today, and our Friends on the other Side are
saying kind words about you. It tells me
that you are a good person. You are
respected in this House and beyond. I also
would want to put on record that I taught
your wife when she was doing her master's degree.
Mr Speaker, from what has been said, I
pray that when you sit in the Chair to cast
your ballot, our Friends would not come
after you because, if they did that, then, it
would negate all the good things they have
said about you. I am sure that from what I
have seen from them today, when it is time
for us to vote on the E-Levy, based on your
good deeds, they will all vote in support.
Mr Speaker, I hope that from what I am
seeing today, our Friends would see you as
a unifier and somebody who would lead us
to ensure that this Parliament and this
country progresses. May God bless you
and continue to make you great, and may
this day bind us together and make us think
more about Ghana. May this day bind us
together for us to show patriotism to
advance the cause of this country.
Long live, Mr Speaker. God bless you. I
hope that in the next Parliament, you shall
be here to continue your exploits and good
deeds. God bless us all.
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:49 a.m.

Mr Sampson Ahi 11:59 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on the
occasion of your birthday, I wish you a
happy birthday. I pray that this day brings
you energy, success, good health and
wisdom.
Mr Speaker, as you celebrate your
birthday, I would want to remind you about
a proverb by the ancient Greeks which
says: beware of the Greeks when they offer
you gifts.
It is just to say that God has elevated you
to this position, and while you mingle with
the Majority Group, be very careful. -- [Laughter] -- Because you were rejected three years ago but by the grace of God,
you are today occupying the high office of
Second Deputy Speaker through the
support of the Minority Group -- [Hear! Hear!] --
Mr Speaker, I pray that because we
supported you, God will grant you the
wisdom to continue to remain neutral and
independent always so that you give good
judgement as you have been doing. Mr
Speaker, beware of the Greeks when they
offer you gifts.
I thank you very much.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:59 a.m.
Hon
Members, I thank all—
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:59 a.m.
All right;
the Hon Deputy Minority Leader, and the
other Hon Member.
Mr Avedzi 11:59 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I wish you a
happy birthday. I know today, you are
celebrating your 56th birthday, and you are
my younger brother.
Mr Speaker, the Members from the
Majority side would want to draw you into
some problem by saying that they have
nominated you to become the Hon Second
Deputy Minister. Mr Speaker, our
Standing Orders are clear; that both First
and Second Deputy Speakers shall not
come from the same party. So, by
accepting that, they are drawing you into
that Party and it would be a challenge for
you. So, Mr Speaker, reject that one. They
have not nominated you; you are not a
Member of the New Patriotic Party (NPP).
In fact, we nominated you, and it is better
you accept our nomination than theirs
because theirs would draw you into
trouble. Beware of that because both the
First and Second Deputy Speakers shall not
come from the same party.
So, the Hon Patrick Boamah, do not
draw the Hon Second Deputy Speaker into
a problem. Mr Speaker, I wish you a happy
birthday. Remain strong; remain the
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:59 a.m.

Mr Habib Iddrisu 11:59 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I wish
to join my Hon Colleagues to wish you a
happy birthday but only to add that life is a
difficult journey, and sometimes you need
to make difficult decisions. And you can
make such difficult decisions that would
actually elevate you high or discover you.
The fact that you went independent was as
a result of a tough decision our party took,
and you also took a tough decision to go as
an independent candidate. And it is
because of these two tough decisions that
you are the Hon Second Deputy Speaker
today. If you had not been able to take such
decisions, we would not have discovered
you as one of the best Second Deputy
Speakers we have today.
Mr Speaker, I join my Hon Colleagues
to tell you that at age 56, you are playing
your second half; make good use of it. And-
- you know that there is blood in you, and you know where that blood came from.
I wish you a happy birthday.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:59 a.m.
Hon
Members, let me thank all of you for the
well-wishes and best blessings that have
been bestowed on me. I am so grateful to
you. Incidentally, I did not celebrate my
birthday; I have never done one before so
do not be surprised if you do not see me
celebrating any birthday. I am not -- [Interruption] -- I was born exactly the day Dr Kwame Nkrumah was overthrown.
Today is 24th February, and that was the
day I was born. I am very grateful to you
all.
Hon Members, let us get back to the
business of the day. The item numbered 5
-- Questions. Do we have the Minister for Energy here?
Mr Habib Iddrisu 11:59 a.m.
Mr Speaker, with
your leave, the Hon Deputy Minister for
Energy is here to answer the Questions on
behalf of his Minister.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:59 a.m.
Yes, Hon
Owuraku, may you take the appropriate
seat? -- [Pause] -- Hon Members, shall we take the first Question which stands in
the name of the Hon Frank Annoh-
Dompreh, the Hon Member for Nsawam-
Adoagyiri.
Ms Alhassan 11:59 a.m.
Mr Speaker, may I seek
your leave to ask the Question on behalf of
my boss, the Hon Majority Chief Whip?
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 11:59 a.m.
Anyway,
he discussed the matter with me prior to
Sitting, so you can go ahead.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS 11:59 a.m.

MINISTRY OF ENERGY 11:59 a.m.

Minister for Energy) 11:59 a.m.
Thank you, Mr
Speaker. Happy birthday to you, Mr
Speaker.
Mr Speaker, the payments made so far
by the Government of Ghana (GoG) on
behalf of the Electricity Company of
Ghana (ECG) Limited to Independent
Power Producers (IPPs) covers the period
from 2016 -- 2021 (as at June, 2021).
The payments were made to both the
IPPs and fuel suppliers on behalf of ECG.
A total of GHȼ12,079,567,156.33 was paid to the IPPs whereas GHȼ4,366,383,302.39, to fuel suppliers as at the end of the second
quarter of 2021. This is summarised in
Table 1 and Table 2, below:
GoG Payments 2016 -- 2021 GoG Payments to Fuel Suppliers on Behalf of ECG
YEAR AMOUNT/GHS REMARKS
2016 343,206,500.00 -
2017 1,072,452,401.19 -
2018 1,971,600,645.00 -
2019 2,751,406,551.68 -
2020 4,328,648,558.46 -

Total 12,079,567,156.33 -

Oral Answers to Questions

GoG payments to fuel suppliers on behalf of ECG

YEAR GoG PAYMENT GHS REMARKS

2019 1,840,884,332.77

2020 1,597,103,969.62

Total 4,366,383,302.39 -
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Hon
Member, any supplementary question?
Before you come in, let me draw your
attention to Order 60 (2) of our Standing
Orders. It appears that we spend so much
time on Questions and yesterday, we spent
almost three hours on Question time. We
are not to actually exceed one hour of our
time in questioning Ministers. We can only
do that in exceptional cases with the
permission of the Rt Hon Speaker. I am just
drawing your attention so that we could
restrict ourselves with the follow-up questions.
Yes, Hon Member for Pru East?
Dr Kwabena Donkor 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, in
the Hon Minister's Answer, he listed payments made on behalf of ECG. I would
want to ask the Hon Minister whether
Government made these payments because
ECG could not pay or whether
Government owed ECG and used part of
this payment in the clearinghouse process?
I would also want him to tell me when the
first IPP was signed in the Fourth Republic?
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Hon
Member for Pru East and former Minister
for Energy, do you not think that it would
be better for all of us if you filed a separate
Question? I say so because it appears this
question is even more involving than the
main Question. So, respectfully, I urge that
you file a separate Question to the Minister
to come and answer.
Mr James Klutse Avedzi 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
could the Hon Minister tell us the source of
funding of this payment made on behalf of
ECG? Is it coming from the Consolidated
Fund or is there a special fund from which
the money was used to pay? He should let
us know the source.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Aidoo 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, quite honestly,
I cannot stand here before this august
House and give a definitive answer. Suffice
to say that as he knows, Government
payments usually come from the
Consolidated Fund.
Mr Avedzi 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the Hon
Minister should be able to tell us whether it
is a budgetary allocation approved by this
House before the money was taken from
the Consolidated Fund to pay or it is
coming from a special fund like Energy
Sector Levy Act (ESLA) Fund or
whatever. It is simple.
Mr Aidoo 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, in all fairness
to myself, I think that this question should
be directed to the Ministry of Finance.
Thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Hon
Leader, I am coming, listen to me -
Mr Avedzi 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg you. The
Hon Minister brought figures to us, that
they have paid this amount of money. Does
he want to say that he does not know where
he got the money from to pay? Where did
he get the information from? Is he hiding
information from the Members of
Parliament? He brought an Answer to a
Question, that he has paid
GH¢12,079,567,156.33, so I asked what
the source of the money is from and he says
I should ask the Minister for Finance. Is it
the Minister for Finance who brought the
Answer to me? Please!
Mr Aidoo 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I can
definitively tell this House and the Hon
Deputy Majority Leader, that this payment
did not originate from the Ministry of
Energy. It originated from the Ministry of
Finance and that is why I asked him to do
the needful by filing a Question to the
Minister for Finance to answer him.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Very
well. That is the last supplementary
question.
Mr Rockson-Nelson Etse Kwami
Dafeamekpor: Mr Speaker, the Hon
Minister in submitting his Answer to
Parliament, in Table 1 for instance, said
that for 2021, they paid
GH¢1,612,252,500.00 as at the second
quarter and in Table 2, there is also an
indication that they paid
GH¢928,395,000.00 as at the end of the
second quarter. This is February 2022. Is
the Hon Minister able to tell us how much
has been paid for the remainder of 2021
under Table 1 and the remainder for 2021
under Table 2?
Mr Aidoo 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the data that
was available to us when we enquired from
the Ministry of Finance is what we have
brought to the House.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Hon
Members, we would move to Question
numbered 303 which stands in the name of
Dr Clement Apaak, MP for Builsa South.
Hon Member, the Minister is available
for your Question.
Mr Suhuyini Alhassan Sayibu -- rose
-- 12:09 p.m.

Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Yes, Hon
Member for Tamale North?
Mr Sayibu 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I join Hon
Colleagues in wishing you a happy
birthday and thank you very much for
recognising me.
Mr Speaker, you have given very good
guidance on how long Question time
should last? I just thought that I should take
advantage to seek your guidance too on a
related matter. Going through the Standing
Orders, Questions are directed at Ministers
of State and I could not find any place in
the Standing Orders that makes room for
Deputy Ministers to answer Questions that
are filed by MPs.
So, I just wish to get guidance from you,
if that is in line with our Standing Orders
or if there is a variation based on your
discretionary powers.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:09 p.m.
Hon
Member, you are right but our practise has
been that if the Minister of State
responsible for the Ministry is unavoidably
absent and for whatever reason, the Deputy
Minister is available, the leadership can
confer and if the consensus is there, we
allow the Deputy Minister to answer the
Questions. I believe that is what has gone
on.
Hon Clement Apaak, you may ask your
Question.
Dr Clement Abas Apaak 12:09 p.m.
Happy
birthday, Mr Speaker. Seeing that I am
your neighbour in the Job 600 Tower
Block, it is mandatory that I also wish you
a happy birthday. Although you have
indicated that you would not celebrate it, as
your able neighbour, I would celebrate in
your stead.
Connection of some Communities in
Builsa South to National Grid under
SHEP 4/5
Dr Clement Abas Apaak (NDC -- Builsa South) 12:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask
the Minister for Energy when the following
communities in the Builsa South
Constituency would be connected to the
national grid under SHEP 4/5: (i) Nyansa
(ii) Vundema (iii) Kalasa (iv) Bachingsa
(v) Wupiensa (vi) Doninga (vii)
Bachingsa-Nyanbisa (viii) Gbedema Zeng.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Aidoo 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
communities namely, Nyansa, Vundema,
Kalasa, Bachingsa, Wupiensa, Doninga,
Bachingsa-Nyanbisa and Gbedema Zeng
forms part of the Ministry of Energy's ongoing SHEP-4 Rural Electrification
Programme in the Builsa South District of
the Upper East Region.
A total of 248no. High Voltage (HV)
poles required for the communities have
been supplied to the site. Conductor
stringing of the HV network has been
completed at Vundema and Doninga
communities.
The full complement of pole-top
accessories to allow for the execution of
the installation works is yet to be supplied
to the remaining communities. 159no. Low
Voltage (LV) poles required for the
communities have been supplied and
planted at site. Conductor stringing of the
LV network has been completed at
Bachingsa. The remaining communities
are yet to receive full complement of pole-
top accessories to commence installation
works.
The delays in the execution of the
electrification project in the communities
are as a result of shortage of some key
materials/equipment including stay
equipment, conductors, transformers, meters, et
cetera. The Ministry has taken delivery of
some of the materials/ equipment and
would arrange for the release of same for
installation works to resume at site.
The Ministry of Energy expects to
complete the installation works in the
above-mentioned communities by the end
of this year.
Dr Apaak 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, for the records,
I noticed that one of my communities has
been wrongly spelt. It is not “Bachingsa”; it is “Bachongsa”.
Mr Speaker, I appreciate the Hon
Minister's response; however, it is at variance with what I know. As of
November 2019 till date, we have not
witnessed any activity in terms of
connecting the said communities to the
national grid, so I am at a loss to the
information that he has provided. Would he
be clearer to indicate what he claims has
been done within the context of the five
contractors who have been contracted to
undertake SHEP 4/5 electrification in
Builsa South?
Mr Aidoo 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the information
I gave is what is available at the Ministry.
If the Hon Member wants me to give
details as to the quantity of materials that
have been supplied to the various
communities, I would be able to do that,
but apart from that, the answer I have

Oral Answers to Questions

provided is what is available at the

Ministry.
Dr Apaak 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I appreciate the
Hon Minister's response and I am willing to share with him the information available
to me, including the names and the
companies of the five contractors.
I would make that information available
to him so that we get the details about what
is going on on the ground and what,
perhaps, may have been communicated to
him by the consultant overseeing the
project.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:19 p.m.
Very
well.
We would move to Question 306 which
stands in the name of the Hon Member for
Bongo, Mr Edward Bawa.
Is the Hon Member in the House?

We would move to Question 315 which

stands in the name of the Hon Member for

Assin North, Mr James Gyakye Quayson.

Is the Hon Member in the House? --

Connection of some communities in

the Assin North Constituency to the

National Grid (Canaan,

Tatarenkwanta, Aninkragya, et cetera)
Mr James Gyakye Quayson (NDC -- Assin North) 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Energy what steps the
Ministry is taking to connect the following
communities in the Assin North
Constituency to the national grid: (i)
Canaan (ii) Tatarenkwanta (iii)
Aninkragya (iv) Kyeikrom (v) Subinso (vi)
Dwenakyir (vii) Ayitey (viii) Gold Coast
Camp (Kokwado) (ix) Krofofordo (x)
Adawu/Kwaku Adu (xi) Agbodza.
Mr Aidoo 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the communities
namely, Canaan, Tatarenkwanta, Aninkragya,
Kyeikrom, Subinso, Dwenakyir, Ayitey,
Gold Coast Camp (Kokwado), Krofofordo,
Adawu/Kwaku Adu and Agbodza do not
form part of any of the Ministry's ongoing projects. The communities have been noted
and would be considered for connection to
the National Electricity Grid in subsequent
phases of the electrification programme.
Mr Quayson 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would like
to ask the Hon Minister which phase these
communities would be added to the list. He
indicated that the work is being done in
phases but the Ministry must have a
programme so that I could, at least, request
the time when it would be done.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Aidoo 12:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the Hon
Member's supplementary question is a rephrase of the original Question.
However, I would want to make it clear to
him that, indeed, we do compile a list as
and when we receive them and when we
have enough, we look for funding and set
the projects rolling. The above
communities have been captured and they
would form part of future projects that the
Ministry would initiate.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:19 p.m.
We
would move to Question 318 --
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:19 p.m.
Hon
Member, are you not satisfied?
Mr Quayson 12:19 p.m.
No, Mr Speaker, I have
another supplementary question.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
All right,
let us hear you.
Mr Quayson 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I appreciate
the Hon Minister's response, but just to bring to his attention, in the last few
months, there was the deployment of
workmen to those areas to do some
measurements. I would like to know if the
Ministry had deployed technicians to
measure the distances involved in these
communities? I am hoping that there is
some plan of work in place or, at least,
future plan of work in place.
He might think it is a rephrase of my
Question but it is absolutely not. The
communities are feeling the need for it
because they are the ones who even
connected with me and said the Electricity
Company of Ghana (ECG) has come in to
do some measurements and I would like to
know if the Hon Minister is aware of that?
Mr Aidoo 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, records at the
Ministry of Energy do not confirm what the
Hon Member is saying. If ECG has been
there to do some work, I cannot answer to
that but as far as the Ministry of Energy is
concerned, it does not form part of any of
our programmes that are rolled out as yet.
As I said, for the third time, they would
form part of future projects that have been
initiated by the Ministry.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
Very
well. Hon Members, we move to the
Question numbered 318, which stands in
the name of the Member for
Nadowli/Kaleo, Hon Anthony Sumah.
Connection of Booduori, Da-Dambaa
et cetera Communities to the National
Electricity Grid
Mr Anthony Mwinkaara Sumah
(NDC -- Nadowli/Kaleo): Mr Speaker, I

Oral Answers to Questions

beg to ask the Minister for Energy when

the following communities in the

Nadowli/Kaleo District will be connected

to the national grid: (i) Booduori (ii) Da-

Dambaa (iii) Gonle.
Mr Aidoo 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
communities namely, Booduori, Da-
Dambaa and Gonle do not form part of any
of the Ministry's ongoing electrification projects. The communities have been noted
and will be considered for connection to
the National Electricity Grid in subsequent
phases of the electrification programme.
Mr Speaker, but I would like to also
draw the attention of the Hon Member that
our consultant in his area has informed us
that there is some electrification project
going on in these communities which have
been initiated by the Northern
Development Authority. We just learnt that
and I do not know if he is aware?
Mr Sumah 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I do not have
any reason to doubt the source of the Hon
Minister, but I was really taken aback when
the Hon Deputy Minister said that there
was no ongoing electrification project in
these communities. For instance, regarding
Booduori, what is required now is just
electricity meters for them to be connected.
With Da-Dambaa, it is left with station
dressing, which is the transformer and
related accessories. In the case of Gonle,
some households have the electricity
meters; others have not got them, and
others have not had the service droppings.
So, it is just the meters, transformers, and
service droppings for these communities to
enable them to have electricity.
So, if it is now under the Northern
Development Authority, is it the case that
his Ministry has no responsibility to
provide the meters and transformers for
these communities?
Mr Aidoo 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, as I said earlier,
the three communities mentioned really are
not on our radar. As I said again, the
Northern Development Authority initiated
the project that is ongoing. It has nothing to
do with the Ministry. So, if it is meters and
some transformers that are left to connect
the good people of the area, then perhaps,
he should write to the Ministry for us to see
how best we can help to get the
communities lit up.
Mr Sumah 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I thank you
and the Hon Deputy Minister. I would
follow up to the Ministry so that we can get
the rest of the accessories to help them
connect to the national grid.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
Very
well. Hon Members, we move to the
Question numbered 319 that stands in the
name of the Member for Manso Nkwanta,
the Hon George Kwabena Obeng Takyi.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Suleman Adamu Sanid 12:29 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, with your permission, may I ask
the Question on behalf of the Hon Member
who is on an emergency assignment in his
constituency?
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
I get the
impression from the way you are even
seeking the leave that he has not asked you
to do that on his behalf.
Mr Sanid 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have his
authority. He called me this morning that I
should do that on his behalf.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
Hon
Members, I have said this over and over
again. The Second Deputy Whip asked a
Question on behalf of the First Deputy
Whip because the First Deputy Whip is
unavoidably absent from the jurisdiction of
Ghana. He sought my permission before
even entering the Chamber. That is what
the Standing Orders require of us.
Anyway, I will ask you to ask the
Question, but let us take note of that. It is
not just in the Chamber that you say that
you are rising to ask a Question for or on
behalf of a Member. Let the Presiding
Officers get to know of the unavoidable
absence of a Member whose Question has
been advertised on today's Order Paper.
So, Hon Member for Ahafo Ano North?
Resumption of electricity projects in
Samanhyiakrom, Tweapease et cetera
Communities
Mr Suleman Adamu Sanid on behalf
of (Mr George Kwabena Obeng Takyi)
(NPP -- Manso-Nkwanta): Mr Speaker, I thank you very much and I take a cue
from your admonition and advice.
I beg to ask the Minister for Energy
when works on the electrification projects
abandoned in the following communities
will resume: (i) Samanhyiakrom (ii)
Tweapease (iii) Abom (iv) Camp (v)
Nanhin (vi) Bariko (vii) Miawani (viii)
Apaukrom.
Mr Aidoo 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Samanhyiakrom,
Tweapease, Abom, Camp, Bariko, Pakyi
Banko, and Nanhin communities have
been earmarked to benefit under the
Ministry's ongoing electrification project being executed in Volta, Eastern, Ashanti,
Brong Ahafo (Bono, Bono East, Ahafo)
and Western Regions by M/S China
International Water and Electric
Corporation (CWE).
Although the project started, it has
encountered challenges in the release of
funds from the side of the Chinese
Government. The two Governments are
working assiduously to allow for
continuation of works as soon as possible.

Oral Answers to Questions

Miawani and Apaukrom communities

do not form part of any of the Ministry's ongoing electrification projects. The

communities have been noted and will be

considered for connection to the National

Electricity Grid in subsequent phases of the

electrification programme.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
Yes, Hon
Sulemana Sanid, any supplementary
question on behalf of the Member?
Mr Sanid 12:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I thank you
very much, there is no supplementary
question from the Hon Member. I thank the
Hon Deputy Minister so much.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:29 p.m.
Very
well. Hon Member, we turn to the Question
numbered 580 by the Hon Member for
Sene West, Hon Twumasi Kwame
Ampofo.
Extension of Electricity to Kuleger,
Gobu et cetera Communities
Mr Twumasi Kwame Ampofo (NDC
-- Sene West): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister for Energy when electricity
will be extended to the following
communities in the Sene West
Constituency: (i) Kuleger (ii) Gobu (iii)
Santa (iv) Agerger (v) Kwadwoboi Kura
(vi) Ahari (vii) Besager (viii) Krusakrusa
(ix) Kuku Kwasi (x) Alegale (xi) Bakpa
(xii) Kukujato (xiii) Asempaneye (xiv)
Sosi.
Mr Aidoo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Kuleger, Gobu,
Santa, Agerger, Kwadwoboi Kura, Ahari,
Besager, Krusakrusa, Kuku Kwasi,
Alegale, Bakpa, Kukujato, Asempaneye
and Sosi communities do not form part of
any of the Ministry's ongoing electrification projects. The communities
have been noted and will be considered for
connection to the National Electricity Grid
in subsequent phases of the electrification
programme.
Mr Ampofo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would like
to find out from the Hon Minister when the
subsequent phases of the electrification
programme will commence?
Mr Aidoo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I do not know
if the Hon Member was in the Chamber
when I was answering the Question by the
Hon Member for Assin North? It is the
same. He has just drawn our attention - there are thousands of communities that do
not have electricity. So, he has drawn our
attention and we have taken note of it, and
as and when we get funding to start new
projects, we would come to the Sene West
Constituency to provide electricity to his
people.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:39 p.m.
Hon
Member, your last supplementary
question.
Mr Ampofo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, communities
such as Kuleger, Gobu, Santa, Alegale and
so on are all around Tatobator. Tatobator
and some communities are already
connected to the national grid with high
tension poles, transmission lines, and
transformers. Based on this, can the
communities be connected to the national
grid before the subsequent phases of the
programme?
Mr Aidoo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, this is a
legitimate question and we would have a
look at it if it can be done as easy as the
Hon Member is suggesting before the next
programme of the Ministry.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:39 p.m.
Very
well.
Hon Members, we would move to the
Question numbered 582 which stands in
the name of Mr Peter Yaw Kwakye Ackah,
Hon Member of Parliament for Amenfi
Central.
Mr Peter Yaw Kwakye Ackah 12:39 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I would also like to add my voice
in wishing you a happy birthday. I believe
you remember the very good times we had
together, especially when your people
rejected you? I was very close to you and
the many discussions we had — I would like to remind you of this; ‘Pass me not, oh, Gentle Saviour, hear my humble cry'. This is because when you were down, I was a
pillar for you.
Plans to Connect Atonsu,
Kwaboakrom and other Communities
in Amenfi Central to the National
Electricity Grid
Mr Peter Yaw Kwakye Ackah (NDC
--Amenfi Central): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Hon Minister for Energy what plans
the Ministry has to connect the following
communities in the Amenfi Central
Constituency to the national grid: (i)
Atonsu (ii) Kwaboakrom (iii) Gyeaboase
(iv) Aboum (v) Kramokrom (vi) Agave
(vii) Donkorkrom (viii) Kwagyeibom (ix)
Owusu Dapaa (x) Yaw Sabeng (xi)
Manhyia (near Manso-Amenfi) (xii) Manyia
(near Woraterem) (xiii) Asarekrom.
Mr Aidoo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Atonsu,
Kwaboakrom, Gyeaboase Aboum,
Kramokrom, Agave, Donkorkrom,
Kwagyeibom, Owusu Dapaa, Yaw
Sabeng, Manhyia (near Manso-Amenfi),
Manyia (near Woraterem) and Asarekrom
do not form part of any of the Ministry's ongoing projects. The communities have
been noted and will be considered for
connection to the National Electricity Grid
in subsequent phases of the electrification
programme.

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Ackah 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would like to
inform the Hon Minister that there are
some communities in my constituency that
were almost provided with electricity by
the erstwhile Mahama Administration and
it was about 80 per cent complete. These
towns are Fureso, Gwirigum, Anobil,
Dankwawora, Asaasetre, Kojo Yaw, and
several others which have not been
completed.
Again, the Hon Minister, in his Answer
said that the communities in question have
not been on the radar. I would like to know
if the reason for the total rejection of the
communities has to do with their Member
of Parliament's total rejection of the obnoxious, insensitive, and distasteful e-
levy?
Mr Aidoo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I believe that
some of the communities that were
mentioned by the Hon Member are actually
not part of the Question that was posed to
the Ministry this morning. So, if he would
want me to answer any question in respect
of those communities, I would respectfully
ask him to ask a substantive Question on
those communities. However, as far as
these communities that have been
mentioned here are concerned, yes, they
have been captured now that the Hon
Member has brought them to our attention
and they will form part of the subsequent
programmes that the Ministry would
embark on.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:39 p.m.
Very
well.
We would move to Question -
Mr Ackah 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the last
supplementary question, please.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:39 p.m.
Yes, Hon
Member, let us hear you.
Mr Ackah 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you very
much. I just want to know the reason the
other communities have been abandoned
and the new ones also do not form part of
the Ministry's plans, but never mind?
I would like to know if the Hon Minister
could appeal to the powers that be such that
they can save some money to carry out
these works in my constituency? This is
because they are mainly cocoa producing
areas and if the Hon Minister could appeal
to the President to sacrifice a little bit of his
extravagant and luxurious travels and save
some money for these communities which
actually do the work for us to be able to
have this life?
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:39 p.m.
Hon
Member, why do you want to invite
unnecessary -- in your questions? Anyway, your question is rejected.
We would move to the Question
numbered 594 in the name of the Hon

Oral Answers to Questions

Member for Wassa East, Mr Isaac Adjei

Mensah.

Resumption of SHEP electrification

projects in Wassa East District
Mr Isaac Adjei Mensah (NDC -- Wassa East) 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Hon Minister for Energy when the stalled
rural electrification projects (SHEP) in the
following communities in the Wassa East
District of the Western Region will
resume: (i) Awiadaso 1, 2, & 3 (ii) Akrofi
(iii) Amankesease (iv) Asatrase (v)
Kramokrom (vi) Bosomase
Mr Aidoo 12:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the Awiadaso,
Akrofi, Amankesease and Asatrase
communities in the Wassa East
Constituency have been earmarked to
benefit under the Ministry's ongoing electrification projects being executed by
M/S China International Water and
Electric Corporation (CWE Ph-2) in the
Volta, Eastern, Ashanti, Brong Ahafo
(Bono, Bono East, Ahafo) and the Western
Regions. Works in these beneficiary
communities are yet to commence.
The project is expected to be completed
by the end of 2022. Kramokrom and
Bosomase communities do not form part of
any of the Ministry's ongoing electrification projects.
The communities have been noted and
will be considered for connection to the
National Electricity Grid in subsequent
phases of the electrification programme.
Mr I. A. Mensah 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
respectfully, I would want the Hon Deputy
Minister to be kind enough to give us an
indication on when these projects would
commence because we know when it
would be completed, but if we do not know
when it will start, then we would not know.
Mr Speaker, so the Hon Deputy Minister
should give us a timeline within which the
project would start because the
communities must be ready for activities of
the contractors which would include
clearing the area and so on.
Mr Aidoo 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, in answering
the Question, I mentioned that the
company that has been selected for this
project is M/S China International Water
and Electric Corporation, and in an earlier
Answer, I mentioned that there have been
some challenges regarding the release of
funds from the Chinese Government, but
the two Governments are working very
hard to resolve the issue.
Mr Speaker, as soon as the challenges
are solved, I am sure that the contractor
would come to site and complete this. The
M/S China International Water and

Oral Answers to Questions

Electric Corporation is very fast, so we are

just waiting for the funds and then work

would commence.
Mr I. A. Mensah 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, my
understanding is that there are challenges
with getting funds for M/S China
International Water and Electric
Corporation, but would the Hon Minister
assure us that by the end of 2022, this
project would be completed?
Mr Aidoo 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, indeed, I was
very reluctant when I mentioned the
completion date to be by the end of 2022.
Mr Speaker, it is very much dependent on
the negotiation between the two
Governments, but as soon as the impasse is
solved, they would come to site and I can
promise that. However, as to the
completion by the end of 2022, I beg to
withdraw that.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:49 p.m.
Hon
Members, we would take the Question
numbered 595 which stands in the name of
Hon Isaac Adjei Mensah.
Resumption of Rural Electrification
Projects in Patatwumso, Afag 1&2 et
cetera Communities
Mr Isaac Adjei Mensah (NDC -- Wassa East) Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Energy when the stalled rural
electrification projects (SHEP) in the
following communities in the Wassa East
District of the Western Region will
resume: (i) Patatwumso (ii) Afag 1 & 2 (iii)
Wantakara (iv) Bethlehem (v) Musunkwa
(vi) Nyamebekyere (vii) Ahumakormua.
Mr Aidoo 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
Patatwumso, Bethlehem, Musunkwa,
Nyamebekyere and Ahumakormua
communities in the Wassa East
Constituency have been earmarked for the
Ministry's ongoing electrification projects being executed by M/S China International
Water and Electric Corporation (CWE Ph-
2) in the Volta, Eastern, Ashanti, Brong
Ahafo (Bono, Bono East, Ahafo) and the
Western Regions. Works in these
beneficiary communities are yet to
commence. The project is expected to be
completed as soon as the impasse between
the two Governments are resolved.
Afag 1&2 and Wantakra communities
do not form part of any of the Ministry's ongoing electrification projects. The
communities have been noted and will be
considered for connection to the National
Electricity Grid in subsequent phases of the
electrification programme.
Mr I. A. Mensah 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would
want to give a background that in 2016
when the SHEP commenced, about 20
communities including the above
mentioned communities were informed
that they would be considered under the

Oral Answers to Questions

Programme. In 2020, we were told that the

project had been suspended and at the time,

one of the companies that was well-known

in rural electrification had been scheduled

to do the work. However, during the first

quarter of 2020, a letter from the Ministry

which was signed by the Hon Deputy

Minister for Energy indicated that the

project would start in August and

September. Mr Speaker, all these

communities were notified and the people

were happy about that, yet nothing

happened.

As I ask this Question on the Floor, all

these communities are now not part of the

project. Mr Speaker, in that letter, 15

communities, excluding these communities,

were notified as beneficiaries of the project

from commencement to completion.

However, the Hon Deputy Minister is now

saying that these communities that were

initially notified and have since been

waiting, are now not part of the new project

to be done by M/S China International

Water and Electric Corporation.

Mr Speaker, so if the Hon Minister

would be kind enough to confer so that

these communities would be considered in

the next phase since they were already

notified about this.
Mr Aidoo 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, yes, they would
be considered.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:49 p.m.
Very
well.
We would now take the Question
numbered 604 which stand in the name of
Hon Frank Annoh-Dompreh.
Significance of Pwalugu
Multipurpose Irrigation Dam Project
and Status of Works since 2020
Ms Lydia S. Alhassan (on behalf of Mr
Frank Anno-Dompreh (NPP -- Nsawam- Adoagyiri): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Energy the significance of the
Pwalugu multipurpose irrigation dam
project to the people of the Upper East
Region and what is the status of works
done since its approval in 2020.
Mr Aidoo 12:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, The Pwalugu
Multipurpose Irrigation Dam has two main
components (i.e. power and irrigation)
being jointly implemented by the Ministry
of Energy and Ministry of Food and
Agriculture. The hydropower component
is being managed by the Ministry of
Energy whereas the irrigation component
is by the Ministry of Food and Agriculture.
The project when completed will provide
enormous benefits to the people of Upper
East as well as the entire Northern Region.
Key among these benefits are as follows:

Oral Answers to Questions

Flood Mitigation Efforts: Heavy

rainfall in the White Volta catchment,

coupled with spilling from the Bagre Dam,

causes heavy flooding in the Upper East

and North East Regions and results in

damage to property and loss of life.

Information from the National Disaster

Management Organisation (NADMO)

indicated that a total of about 69,468

people were affected with 19 deaths as well

as about 27,902 acres of farms affected.

The Pwalugu Multipurpose Dam when

constructed would provide a permanent

solution to the problem.

Support to Government Flagship

Programmes: The Pwalugu Multipurpose

Dam and Irrigation Project will underpin a

number of Government's flagship programmes such as Planting for Food and

Jobs and One District One Factory and

provide enormous benefits to the people in

the northern regions. It will lead to the

revival of the Pwalugu Tomato Factory as

well as the full utilisation of the Avnash

Rice Mill, among others. At full

production, the Avnash Rice Mill is

expected to produce 500 tons of rice a year.

Other similar factories are expected to be

established to provide well-paying jobs as

well as contribute to improving the

economy of northern Ghana. The Pwalugu

Multipurpose Dam and Irrigation Project

will benefit about 32,000 farmers as well as

over 200,000 transporters, aggregators,

agricultural services providers, among

others.

Improvement in Power Supply

Quality in Northern Ghana: The

Pwalugu Dam will also generate about 60

MW of hydropower and improve the

quality of supply to the northern part of

Ghana and enable increased export of

power to Burkina Faso. In addition, there is

a solar component of 50MW solar power

plant.

Status: Under the hydropower

component, the Volta River Authority

(VRA) has already completed all the

necessary preparatory activities such as the

Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA),

the land survey, land valuation,

Resettlement Action Plan, and acquisition

of the requisite permits.

The EPC contractor has since mobilised

some of its major construction equipment

and facilities to the site such as the concrete

batching plant and quarrying plant.

Contractors are scheduled to start the

construction of access roads and bridges, as

well as a camp equipped with water and

power supply facilities.

The Ministry of Energy is liaising with

the Ministry of Finance (MoF) for release

of funds to start construction works on the

hydropower dam.

Oral Answers to Questions

Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:59 p.m.
This is a
general Question so I may allow a follow
up question from any Hon Member.
Mr Edward Abambire Bawa 12:59 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the Question was on the status. As
of two years ago, the story was that they
were still trying to construct the access
route to the project site. As we speak now,
beyond just the cutting of sod that was
done when the President went there, there
is no activity there. So, I just want to ask
the Hon Deputy Minister for Energy where
the contractor is as we speak?
Mr Aidoo 12:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, indeed, there
has been funding challenges as I said in the
Answer to the Question. The Ministry of
Energy is liaising with the Ministry of
Finance to get funds released for the work
to start. So, that is the situation we are
encountering right now. It is a question of
funding.
Mr Issifu Seidu 12:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would
want to find out from the Hon Deputy
Minister what the contract sum for this
project is and how much money has been
disbursed so far?
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:59 p.m.
Hon
Member, respectfully, I may not admit this
question. File a separate Question for this.
Dr Godfred Seidu Jasaw 12:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
in the Hon Deputy Minister's Answer on page 24 of the Order Paper, the second line,
which with your permission I quote:
“The Pwalugu multipurpose irrigation dam has two main components (i.e.
power and irrigation) …”
Mr Speaker, just for the records, the
Hon Minister for Finance in presenting the
2021 and 2022 Budgets, informed this
House that the multipurpose dam has three
components.
Today, the Ministry of Energy is
reducing it to two components and in the
Budget Statement, we are told that the first
component is flood control; the second
component is power supply and then
irrigation project.
Mr Speaker, may I find out if the
components have reduced to two for the
records of this House?
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:59 p.m.
I do not
think the components have reduced.

Oral Answers to Questions

Mr Alexander Kwamena Afenyo-

Markin: Mr Speaker, if we may all

develop the rules -- The Hon Member may have those concerns but when it comes to

supplementary questions, we are anchoring

them on the Answer the Hon Deputy

Minister has provided. So, if there are some

disparities or there is some other

documents, it is not for the Hon Deputy

Minister to specifically answer in

accordance with what the Hon Member

thinks he has. Perhaps, I would urge the

Hon Member, with the greatest respect, to

file a specific Question himself in respect

of some other documents he has cited. I

think that is the best way to proceed.
Mr Speaker, let me read Order 69 12:59 p.m.
“As soon as a Question is answered in the House, any Member beginning
with the Member who asked the
Question may, without notice, ask a
supplementary Question for the
further elucidation of any matter of
fact regarding which the answer has
been given, but a supplementary
rose
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:59 p.m.
Hon
Deputy Minority Leader, let us listen to
him. Afterwards, you would be given the
opportunity to talk.
Hon Deputy Majority Leader, let us
hear you.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, as
for me, I took my time to learn the rules and
I am guided by the rules. I am talking for
myself. I can speak for matters that I know.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:59 p.m.
Hon
Deputy Majority Leader, please, go on.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
would read the Order again:
“As soon as a Question is answered in the House any Member beginning
with the Member who asked the
Question may, without notice, ask a
supplementary Question for the
further elucidation of any matter of
fact regarding which the answer has
been given, but a supplementary
Question must not be used to
introduce a matter not included in the
Original Question.”
Mr Speaker, simply put 12:59 p.m.
the Hon
Deputy Minister has given an Answer; the
content of which a supplementary question
must emanate. If the Hon Member has
some other documents or information
given by some other Ministry, my view is
that he may, guided by this, now seek
clarification from that Hon Minister, which
would be an entirely new Question. But he
cannot use a supplementary question to

Oral Answers to Questions

attack the Hon Deputy Minister and say

that somebody said something else so he

should answer something that he is not

privy to.

Mr Speaker, this is simply the import of

Order 69. Whichever document he has -- Mr Speaker, other than that, we can never

make progress in this House. Somebody

would rise and say that he has some

document and what does the Hon Minister

say to it? But these are not his words. The

document the Hon Member is relying on is

not a document that the Hon Deputy

Minister has procured or has brought

before this House. He is not answering in

accord with those documents. So, Mr

Speaker, let us make progress.
Mr Avedzi 12:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I completely
disagree with my Hon Colleague.
Mr Speaker, the same Order that he
quoted, Order 69, says:
“As soon as a Question is answered in the House any Member beginning
with the Member who asked the
Question may, without notice, ask a
supplementary Question for the
further elucidation of any matter of
fact regarding which the answer has
been given…”
Mr Speaker, the Hon Deputy Minister
gave an Answer to a Question and in that
Answer, he provided facts, which is at
variance with the information before this
House in the Budget Statement.
If the Hon Member is asking for further
elucidation to confirm that what the Hon
Deputy Minister has said are two
objectives of that project, which is at
variance with what the Minister for
Finance said in the Budget Statement, that
cannot be said to be an introduction of a
new question. It is for the Hon Deputy
Minister to say that now, the project is for
two objectives: power and irrigation, and
that would clarify the matter.
Mr Speaker, I think you should allow
the Hon Deputy Minister to respond to the
question asked by the Hon Member.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
Hon
Members, I think we are all singing the
same hymn. The Hon Member was just
trying to find out whether the earlier
component which was three has been
reduced to two. But I understand that
irrigation and dam are the same thing. If the
dam is created, irrigation and power are
derived from it.
Hon Deputy Minister, can you say
something to us?

Oral Answers to Questions
Mr Aidoo 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, exactly, the
dam gives rise to irrigation and power
plants simplicita. In any case, I will do
more checks and come back to the House
if need be to answer it.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
Very
well, Hon Members, we would turn to
Question numbered 761. Is the Hon
Member for Suhum around? Hon Kwadjo
Asante is not around. I believe nobody has
been tasked to ask the Question on his
behalf?
So, we would move to Question -
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, with
respect, I had an engagement with my
respected Colleague -- [Interruption] -- And his instructions were that I should take
your leave to proceed on the Question
numbered 761, which his constituents are
anxious to hear an Answer.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
Hon
Leader, the leave is granted.
Difficulty in securing Household
Electricity Meters
Mr Afenyo-Markin on behalf of (Mr
Kwadjo Asante) (NPP -- Suhum): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister for
Energy why it is so difficult to secure
household electricity meters in this
country.
Mr Aidoo 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the institutions
involved in the release of energy meters are
the Ministry of Energy under the National
Electrification Scheme (NES), and the
utilities (ECG and NEDCo). Under the
NES, meters are released free of charge
when the electrification projects are
completed. However, customers are
supposed to pay a fee for certification of
their installation works by Certified
Electrical Wiring Inspectors. Following
the completion of the works, the projects
are handed to the utilities for operation and
maintenance. Any expansion works and
request for meters after the completion of
the electrification works are sent to the
utilities for consideration subject to
payment of the applicable fees.
On the other hand, electrification
projects undertaken by the utilities in the
peri-urban/urban areas go through the
following procedures for the release of
meters:
Certification of applicant's premises by the Certified Electrical Wiring
Inspector;
Buying, filling and tendering of
Application Form;
Estimation of relevant cost of service
connection;
Payment for service connection;

Oral Answers to Questions

Release and installation of meters; and

With the availability of meters, the

installation of the meter is supposed

to be done within one week, and even

within 24 hours in some cases.

The Ministry's attention has been drawn to the delays in the release of meters by the

utilities and is working with the latter

(utilities) to ensure that the unnecessary

bureaucracies are curtailed and the

provision of adequate funding in their

budgets for the procurement of the needed

quantities of meters for the public.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
Hon
Leader, do you have his leave to ask
supplementary questions?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, with
respect, it is consequential; I rely on your
first leave.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
All right,
let us hear you.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, in
the Hon Deputy Minister's Answer, he said the metres are given for free, but we would
pay a fee for installation. What steps are
they taking to ensure that those who do the
installation do not take advantage of the
ordinary Ghanaian?
Mr Aidoo 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, a point of
correction. The meters are not given for
free all the time. They are given for free
when rural electrification project or
electrification project comes to an end,
then as part of the project, metres are given
out. But citizens in the affected
communities pay a little fee to the installers
who are certified by the Energy
Commission for the safety purposes.
Mr Speaker, they cannot charge
arbitrarily, so that protects citizens from
being unduly charged exorbitant amount.
The Energy Commission handles that part
of it.
Mr Ahi 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, it is a fact that
securing meters into newly built homes in
Ghana is very difficult. I agree with the
Hon Deputy Minister that when a new
electrification project is done, metres are
distributed freely, but when they are being
extended to newly developed
communities, it sometimes takes five
months for home owners to secure meters,
and it is very expensive. What is the
Ministry doing about this situation?
Mr Aidoo 1:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I think I
answered that Question. For the sake of the
Hon Member, I would repeat what I said.
“The Ministry's attention has been drawn to the delays in the release of
meters by the utilities and is working

Oral Answers to Questions

with the latter (utilities) to ensure that

the unnecessary bureaucracies are

The Ministry has met with the utilities -- that is a fact. Also, we have also met with

the metre manufacturing companies within

the country. Funds are being sought to

procure more, and to eliminate the

bureaucracies in the system.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
Hon
Members, I reminded you this morning that
Question time should not go beyond one
hour. We have managed the time, if we are
not careful -
An Hon Member -- rose --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:09 p.m.
You
would have a substantive Question to ask.
Yes, Hon Member for Ho West?
Mr Emmanuel K. Bedzrah 1:09 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I was not around but I heard you
celebrated your birthday; happy birthday.
Mr Speaker, the Hon Deputy Minister
stated that the meters are for free but fees
are paid to certified electricians. I would
want to know from the Hon Deputy
Minister whether they have a standard fee
or whether the certified electricians charge
any amount at all?
Mr Aidoo 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I cannot
actually give the figure as to how much is
being charged, but there are guidelines that
have been put up by the Energy
Commission. Again, on a point of
correction, the meters are not all the time
given for free. They are only given for free
when we complete an electrification
project in specific communities. We give
an allowance of about five months within
which a person can wire his property for
the metre to be given to him.
Unfortunately, people wait for a year
before they put in application for free
meters. That would be an unending supply
of meters, so, there is a cut-off point after
which we do not supply for free.
Mr Speaker, I thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:19 p.m.
Hon
Member for Bongo, your last question.
Mr Bawa 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I need this
clarification from the Hon Minister; all
meters, irrespective of whether they are in
the projects or are extensions, are supposed
to be for free, and that is why even on it, it
is written that it is the property of the
utility. It is the service charged -- that is even in the Hon Minister's own Answer, to get that, what is being asked for at the
various stages; connection fees and other
things, were released recently. So, my

Oral Answers to Questions

question to him directly is, have they

changed their policy to selling meters?

This is because metres are always

supposed to be free, but it is the service

charged, which the Electricity Company of

Ghana (ECG) just reviewed on the 1st of

February, 2022, which is always charged,

but not the meter itself. Have they changed

their policy?
Mr Aidoo 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, no, the policy
has not been changed. What we refer to as
fee is a requisite amount that is charged by
the utilities. Anybody who requests for any
utility, whether from ECG or the Northern
Electricity Distribution Company
(NEDCo) for a metre is charged a
prescribed fee, and that is what we call the
“payment” for meters.
However, meters that are given without
the requisite payment are those that are
given to communities whose rural
electrification have been completed. We
give them out for free without the requisite
payment.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:19 p.m.
Very
well.
We would move on to the Question
numbered 818, which stands in the name of
the Hon Abdulai Abanga, the Hon Member
for Binduri.
Completion of Electrification
Projects under SHEP-4 Programme in
some Communities in Binduri District
Mr Abdulai Abanga (NDC--Binduri) 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister for
Energy when the electrification projects
under the SHEP-4 programme in the
following communities in the Binduri
District of the Upper East Region would be
completed: (i) Zeego (Zaago)/Bankago
Ext. (ii) Atuba-Mognori (iii) Atoba-Avoase (iv)
Fansia-Bugrin/ Zeego/Kolnatinga (v) Atuba
Main Town.
Mr Aidoo 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Zeego (Zaago)/
Bankago Ext., Atuba-Mognori, Atoba-
Avoase, Kansia-Bugrin/Zeego/ Kolnatinga
and Atuba Main Town forms part of the
Ministry of Energy's ongoing SHEP-4 Rural Electrification Project in the Binduri
District of the Upper East Region. High
Voltage (HV) poles are yet to be supplied
to site to allow for works in the
communities to commence.
110no. out of 540no. Low Voltage (LV)
poles required for the communities have
been supplied and planted at site.
Conductor stringing has been completed at
Kansia-Bugrin/Zeego/Kolnatinga. The full
complement of pole-top accessories to
allow for the execution of installation
works in Zeego (Zaago)/Bankago Ext.,
Atuba-Mognori, Atoba-Avoase and Atuba

Oral Answers to Questions

Main Town communities are yet to be

supplied.

The delays in the execution of the

electrification project in the communities

are as a result of the shortage of some key

materials/equipment including stay

equipment, conductors, transformers, meters,

etc. The Ministry has taken delivery of

some of the materials/ equipment and will

arrange for the release of same for

installation works to resume at site. The

Ministry of Energy expects to complete the

installation works in the above-mentioned

communities by end of 2022.
Mr Abanga 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I only hope
that as promised by the Hon Minister, by
the end of this year the people of these
communities would enjoy the electrification
project.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:19 p.m.
Very
well.
So, you would get up again and ask the
follow up substantive Question on the
same page, the Question numbered 819.
Completion of Electrification
Projects under SHEP-4 Programme in
certain Communities in Binduri
District -- Follow up
Mr Abdulai Abanga (NDC -- Binduri) 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Energy when the
electrification projects under the SHEP-4
programme in the following communities
in the Binduri District of the Upper East
Region will be completed: (i) Tinogo (ii)
Gotisaliga (iii) Nin-Sarko (iv) Nara-Sung
(v) Tinogo.
Mr Aidoo 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, Tinogo,
Gotisaliga, Nin-Sarko and Nara-Sung
communities forms part of the Ministry of
Energy's ongoing SHEP-4 Rural Electrification Project in the Binduri
District of the Upper East Region. 90no.
out of 103no. High Voltage (HV) poles
required for the communities have been
supplied and planted. HV installation
works have been completed with a
Transformer Substation at 80 per cent
completion status at Nara-Sung
community. 553no. out of 869no. Low
Voltage (LV) poles required for the
communities have been supplied and
planted at site. Conductor stringing of the
LV network is ongoing at Tinogo, Nin-
Sarko and Nara-Sung communities.
The delays in the execution of the
electrification project in the communities
are as a result of the shortage of some key
materials/equipment including poles,
conductors, transformers, meters, etc. The
Ministry has taken delivery of some of the
materials/equipment and will arrange for
the release of same for installation works to

Oral Answers to Questions

resume at site. The Ministry of Energy

expects to complete the installation works

in the above-mentioned communities by

the end of the year.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:19 p.m.
Hon
Abanga, do you have any further
supplementary questions?
Mr Abanga 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I thank you
very much for the responses. I think that I
have seen signs of contractors back on site
and working. So, I am sure that by the end
of the year, the people of Binduri in these
communities would enjoy electricity.
Mr Speaker, I thank you very much.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:19 p.m.
Hon
Members, let us turn to page three and take
Question numbered 306, which stands in
the name of the Hon Member for Bongo,
the Hon Edward Abambire Bawa.
Completion of Rural Electrification
Projects in certain Communities in the
Bongo District
Mr Edward Abambire Bawa (NDC -- Bongo) 1:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Energy when the Rural
Electrification Projects in the following
communities in the Bongo District would
be completed: (i) Borigo (ii) Apuwavgo (ii)
Yekine (iii) Beo-Boki (iv) Kangingo (v)
Sapooro (vi) Atampintin (vii) Apatanga
(viii) Akulyoo (ix) Soe (x) Agomo (xi)
Bongo Zu (xii) Akundoo (xiii) Ayopia-
Agaake (xiv) Sikabisi (xv) Abokobisi.
Mr Aidoo 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
communities namely, Borigo, Apuwavgo,
Yekine, Beo-Boki, Kangingo, Sapooro,
Atampintin, Apatanga, Akulyoo, Soe,
Agomo, Bongo Zu, Akundoo, Ayoopia-
Agaake, Silkabisi and Abokobisi forms
part of the Ministry of Energy's ongoing SHEP-4 Rural Electrification Project in the
Bongo District of the Upper East Region.
High Voltage (HV) networks and
substation works have been completed in
Bongo Zui. Low Voltage (LV) networks as
well as customer service connections are
ongoing.
HV and LV networks have been
completed and transformers installed in
Apatanga and Ayopia-Agaake. Metre
installation works are being carried out in
these communities.
A total of 136 HV poles required for the
Borigo, Apuwongo, Yekine, Beo-Boki,
Sapooro, Soe and Akundoo communities
have been supplied to site. Most of the
required pole-top materials have been
supplied with the 136 of these poles
planted and 31 strung with conductors.

Oral Answers to Questions

330 LV poles required for the project

for Borigo, Apuwongo, Yekine, Beo-Boki,

Sapooro, Soe and Akundoo communities

have been supplied and planted. Most of

the pole-top accessories required for the

communities have been supplied to site

with stringing ongoing in Apuwongo and

Yekine.

Agome, Sikabisi and Abokobisi are yet

to receive materials for both HV & LV

works to commence works.

The rest of the communities, namely,

Atampintin and Akulyoo, were part of the

Thengashep Phase I project. The contractor

was not able to complete the works because

the project ran out of funds. The

outstanding works are to be completed

under a new contract package.

The delays in the execution of the

electrification projects in the above

communities are as a result of shortage of

some key materials/equipment including

poles, stay wooden blocks, conductors, et

cetera. The Ministry has taken delivery of

some of the materials/equipment and will

arrange for the release of same for

installation works to resume at site.

The Ministry of Energy expects to

complete the installation works in the

above-mentioned communities by the end

of the year.
Mr Bawa 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, in the
Minister's Answer, he indicated that “Agome, Sikabisi and Abokobisi are yet to receive materials for both HV & LV works
to commence.” When will they receive these materials?
Mr Aidoo 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I cannot give a
specific day when the materials would be
sent to the communities, but like I said, the
Ministry has taken delivery of same. There
are a lot of places that these materials are
to be sent, and I am sure as and when it gets
to the turn of the Hon Member's communities, they will be sent.
Mr Bawa 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the Hon Deputy
Minister indicated in the last but one
paragraph on page 21 of the Order Paper
that Atampintin and Akulyoo were part of
the Thengashep project that run out of
funds, and that a new contract is to be
signed. You would realise that all these
communities I have mentioned, they are
supposed to finish the works by the end of
the year. That is what the last paragraph of
the Answer indicates. Has the new contract
for these two communities been awarded to
a contractor?
Mr Aidoo 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I cannot say for
sure whether the contract has been signed,
suffice to say that they have been
earmarked to be repacked for a new
contractor to complete works in these two
communities. I will liaise with the Hon

Oral Answers to Questions

Member and give him the actual

information as to whether the contract has

been signed or when it would be signed.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:29 p.m.
Final
supplementary question.
Mr Aidoo 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I realised that
for almost every supplementary question I
asked, the Hon Deputy Minister said that
he does not know --
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:29 p.m.
Hon
Bawa, ask your question.
Mr Bawa 1:29 p.m.
The reason I am making this
point is that that is the meat of the
Question, and I am not getting answers to
them.
As we speak, for the other communities
that the Hon Deputy Minister talked about
they are supplying materials, I can assure
him that the contractors are not on site.
When would they be on site?
Mr Aidoo 1:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the contractors
are not on site because the materials are not
there. They will go to site as and when the
materials are delivered.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:29 p.m.
Hon
Members, on behalf of the House, I would
like to thank the Hon Deputy Minister for
Energy, Hon William Owuraku Aidoo, for
attending upon the House to answer 14
separate Questions from you. Hon Deputy
Minister, we are grateful to you. You are
hereby discharged.
Hon Leaders, are we going to take
Statements?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
rightly so, but the Hon Minority Leader has
signalled that he has something to say in
respect of your birthday.
A call for the safety of Ghanaian
Students in Ukraine
Minority Leader (Mr Haruna Iddrisu) 1:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have to indulge you because
I will not be here when you go to the
Commencement of Public Business. But I
mentioned this matter to the Speaker that I
wanted to invoke Standing Order 72 to
raise a matter of urgent public importance
which is to call on the Hon Ministers for
Foreign Affairs and Regional Integration,
the Interior and the Finance Ministry to
work together to take urgent steps to ensure
the safety of Ghanaian students in Ukraine,
and their immediate evacuation. This, we
must do to assure the students and their
parents that they are Ghanaians and they
deserve our support. It is a matter of public
importance. I indulge you that we raise this
matter because the Minister for Finance
must make money readily available to the

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

Minister for Foreign Affairs and Regional

Integration. We know the number of

Ghanaian students in Ukraine. Quite a

number of them are studying medicine

with some probably even sponsored by

Hon MPs.

Mr Speaker, the situation in Ukraine is

very worrying. We would not go into the

diplomatic matters related to Ukraine for

now until we are guided by what Ghana's foreign policy position would be on that

matter. It is a near-war in Ukraine and

Russia is not yielding to the diplomatic

manoeuvres of the West, particularly led

by the French President, Emmanuel

Macron and many other Heads of States.

Mr Speaker, I understand that today is

your birthday. Even though times in

Fomena are not the best for you, I wish you

the very best.

As you observe your birthday, those

who are sponsoring terrorists against the

Hon Second Deputy Speaker in the

Fomena Constituency are hereby warned to

allow him have the sanity of mind to serve

Ghana in the high duty of Second Deputy

Speaker in supporting the Rt Hon Alban

Bagbin.

Mr Speaker, so happy birthday. I wish

you and your family well. God grant you

good health and long life. You are a

gentleman of a kind. So, to those who are

sponsoring the terrorists in the name of the

New Patriotic Party in Fomena, Mr

Speaker, I pray that they shy away; this is

not the best birthday gift you can be given.

Mr Speaker, I thank you.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:39 p.m.
Yes,
Leader, may I hear you? -- [Pause] -- Or Leader, before you come in, is there
anybody who would like to comment on
the Ukraine issue? Is there anyone who
would like to pass a comment on the
Statement the Minority Leader raised?
Let me hear the Hon Member for
Abuakwa South.
Mr Samuel Atta Akyea 1:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
it is gratifying to note that sometimes, we
can converge at one point as a people, and
that is very good. I am very excited about
the fact if we have a scenario in which
Ghanaians are endangered, it becomes a
national issue. And I pray to God that we
should have such common purposes most
of the time. That is the essence of having a
very vibrant Parliament.
Mr Speaker, we cannot be sure the way
the matters are escalating in Ukraine. If we
pay regard to what America is saying, what
President Putin himself is saying, and the
rest of the world leaders are saying, the
safety of our people cannot be guaranteed.
In these circumstances, I can only say that

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

we do not have to play lottery with their

lives because we do not trust the next

military manoeuvre that is going to come

from the Russian leader. And our best bet

is that it is good to be educated but not to

die prematurely or to be hurt prematurely.

Let us bring them to the place of safety, and

when life returns to normalcy, they could

always go back. I heard one student crying

seriously that it is even difficult to go for

classes. They told them that they would not

have lectures anymore. If that is the state of

affairs, why should they be there? Because

the teachers are afraid and they would not

want to go to the classrooms.

So, I think my good brother has sounded

something positive for this nation, and

those who have the wherewithal to ensure

that they come to safety, should mobilise

and bring them to our dear country.

Mr Speaker, this is a little contribution I

would like to add to what the Minority

Leader just said.

I am grateful to you, Mr Speaker.
Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:39 p.m.
Yes, the
Hon Angela Alorwu-Tay. But I would
leave the Chair for the Rt Hon Speaker to
take over.
Mrs Angela Oforiwa Alorwu-Tay
(NDC -- Afadzato South): Thank you, Mr Speaker.
The situation in Ukraine is beginning to
be a bad one. I had a call from my niece
this morning that they did not even have
food to eat especially, those in Kiev. So, if
the Government would mobilise to have
our students or children brought home as
soon as possible, that would help us.
Mr Speaker, they are trying to move to
other cities that are not close to Kiev but
they cannot even get any means of
transport to get to those other cities far
away from Kiev. So, the issue that the
Minority Leader raised is an important one
that our Leadership would have to start
working on -- [Pause] --
MR SPEAKER
Mr Speaker 1:44 p.m.
Hon Member, continue.
Mrs Alorwu-Tay 1:44 p.m.
Thank you, Mr
Speaker.
Mr Speaker, my statement before I sat
down was that there is the need for all
Ghanaian students in Ukraine to be brought
home. And this should be done as soon as
possible.
Mr Speaker, on that note, I appeal to the
two Leaders in the House to take this
matter as a project and work on it as soon
as possible.

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

Thank you.
Mr Emmanuel Armah-Kofi Buah 1:49 p.m.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. We thank the Hon
Minority Leader for the Statement.
Mr Speaker, I think that the point that I
would want to make on this very important
Statement is this pending crisis that has to
do with the possibility of energy crisis in
the world. How as a country, we would
prepare to ensure that we take steps to
address the potential increases in crude
prices and gas prices, and how would we
protect our economy.
Mr Speaker, it is very important that we
take note of that. If you recall, every time
there has been such crises, crude prices
would go up. And for developing countries
like Ghana, its impact on economy is
always very great.
So, I think that this crisis while it is
destabilising, what is really critical for us
is that we look at the consequences for us
in terms of its impact on our economy, and
take the corrective steps to ensure that we
can really protect and have energy security
that is, indeed, very critical for our long
term economic development.
Mr Speaker, I thank you for the
opportunity.

Deputy Majority Leader (Mr

Alexander Kwamina Afenyo-Markin):

Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

opportunity.

Mr Speaker, first, I think the position

taken by the Minority Leader on all fours

was well-founded. We must care about our

own citizens in Ukraine, considering what

is happening there. I believe Government

is monitoring the situation and the

appropriate steps would be taken to ensure

the safety of our people who are

particularly studying there.

Mr Speaker, but I have my own view on

this matter, which I believe Hon Members

would agree to. That when somebody

coughs, another person sitting somewhere

catches cold. There is no doubt on my mind

that just as COVID-19 disrupted the world

economy, this war is also disrupting the

world economy and affecting developing

nations like Ghana.

Mr Speaker, already, the unemployment

situation is something that is a burden on

us as a country. Ghanaians are worried

about fuel prices; they go to the pump and

it is unbearable, and we have this

escalation which is also leading to high

prices of crude. Mr Speaker, not the least is

even our currency because Ghanaian

traders now live in a state of uncertainty.

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

So, people are trying to change their Cedi

into forex; you are ordering products from

Ukraine, Eastern Europe and even in

Europe; there is general uncertainty. We

depend on a lot of import.

Mr Speaker, so, this is a time for us as a

country to have a new approach to our

politics because everything would end in

this Chamber. And that is why I am happy

the Hon Minority Leader, the little time he

had, he raised this important matter.

It is a huge issue, and politicians on both

Sides, whether NPP or NDC, this is not the

time for partisan politics; this is the time to

work together because it is a whole crisis

that would not be limited to the people of

Effutu but those at Ellembele, Garu, Keta

and Jomoro would all go through the same

crisis. It is everywhere.

Mr Speaker, there is a call for us to rise

up as patriots to think about new ways. As

a businessman, I am concerned, knowing

that the value chain would be affected;

imports and duties would be costly. If you

look at what is happening to the cedi, the

dollar is now at a certain figure.

[Interruption] Unless Hon Members do

not want to appreciate the text of the

Statement made by Hon Haruna Iddrisu, he

said that he was raising an issue of urgent

public importance and my comments are

squarely in line with those concerns. In

doing so, I must bring to the attention of the

House, the reality.

This is not politics of the National

Democratic Congress (NDC) or New

Patriotic Party (NPP). This is about an

international catastrophe which is affecting

Mother Ghana and there is the need for us

to take away the politics and now have a

new way of thinking to support our

Government. This is because the call to

evacuate Ghanaian citizens from Ukraine

would come at a cost. No European

country would evacuate our citizens for us.

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization

(NATO) would not do that, America would

not do that and there would be pressure on

the limited resources that we have.

As a nation, Ghanaian businesses which

are supposed to do well to pay taxes would

suffer, businesses would not do well as

expected and projections would be

affected. That is the reality, and I must

bring this to the attention of all of us, so

that any policy that would be brought

would be seen in that light.

The Hon Deputy Minority Leader did

not speak into the microphone but if he is

talking about the E-Levy, this is the more

important reason we need it. He did not

speak into the microphone but if he is

talking about the E-Levy, that was the next

point I was going to make, that we should

congregate around it and find a way of

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

generating revenue as a country to save the

situation. This is because we are not in

normal times. Hon Haruna Iddrisu could

not have raised this matter at a better time

than now. This is a patriotic call from him

and I agree with him.

Hon Haruna Iddrisu, a patriot and a

Ghanaian who is looking at the reality, has

brought to our attention this important

international issue. We do not live in

isolation but live within the Economic

Community of West African States

(ECOWAS) and African Union (AU) blocs

and we are a member of the United Nations

(UN).

We are part of the world economy and I

am saying that our economy is being

affected and would be affected, and we

should look at the reality. Businesses

would be affected. I am a business man and

I know what is happening. Lawyers would

be affected and entrepreneurs would suffer

because of this Ukraine situation. Many of

our compatriots import from Ukraine,

Eastern and Western Europe. Import would

be obstructed, booking vessels would not

be as they should be, and Government

revenue at our ports would be affected.

Mr Speaker, we should know and that is

why Hon Haruna Iddrisu brought this to

our attention. With all these, we should

now look at an innovative way to generate

revenue in this crisis to sustain social

intervention programmes as a country.

[Interruption] Mr Speaker, I am the pro

tem leader of the House and if they do not

want me to speak on their behalf --
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
Hon Deputy Majority
Leader, I think that is enough. We have
heard you loud and clear.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
take a cue and I take a bow.
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
Make sure you do not
take away what you have said with your
later interventions. So, as a man of
experience, I would let you stop there, then
we can move on.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, let
me thank you and say God bless.
Mr Speaker, the Hon Haruna Iddrisu
congratulated your Deputy on his birthday
and we had agreed that I would also say
some few words, so I have moved away
from Standing Order 72 issue.
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
Which of my Deputies?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, not
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
Not the prodigal son.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, these
are your words.

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
So, you may add your
voice to it.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, with
your leave.
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
Granted.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
would want to congratulate him on this
great day. I do not believe in birthdays
though, but I think that it is a day for us to
reflect that the Lord Almighty has given us
a new day. It comes with wisdom and we
learn more, so I congratulate him; he has
demonstrated fortitude.
I know that in his first term, he went
through crisis. Politics in our own backyard
can be rough but he survived it and I know
that he would survive. We need him. He
represents a true gentleman and we all
know that, considering his posture in the

Mr Speaker, when you were the leader

of the House, I recalled that you advocated

against reckless heckling. I can tolerate

heckling because I must tolerate it, but it is

getting to the level that you described in

2015 as reckless heckling.
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
I am in control.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
know.
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
And I took it that you
were making some of these statements in a
very light manner. So, I actually did not
take what they were doing as heckling but
just contributing to livening the House. I
am aware that you have been sitting for
some time and from time to time, you need
to throw in some humour, so that Hon
Members can use it to relax, de-stress and
continue with the business, that is why I
allowed it; but you may conclude now.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 1:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, they
were doing it too much, especially when

Many of them doing that are my juniors

and they should know that monkeys play

by sizes. What is their number on the

Floor? Mr Speaker, you are number three

and on this Floor, I am number two.

[Laughter] For the time being, I am the

Mr Speaker, I thank you.
Mr Speaker 1:49 p.m.
That was the purpose of
what I did by referring to my number. You
would recall that on that day, there was
tension on the Floor when the Hon
Majority Leader was engaging me in a
debate. So, Members were wondering what
was happening, so I decided to diffuse the
tension by throwing in that jab which at
An Hon Member 1:49 p.m.
A proper jab --

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine
Mr Speaker 1:59 p.m.
Yes, a proper jab. And I
think it took off the steam from the House
and then went on smoothly. So, from time
to time, it is allowed to come in with such
humour for the business to liven up. The
people outside may not understand it but
those of us who are in the House and are
experienced and know what happens here
should take advantage of it because it is
good. We do not have any other brothers
and sisters apart from ourselves and
whether you like it or not, you just did not
come here on your own volition. A divine
intervention brought all of us to this House
and we are the people to keep one another
until we leave. And we expect that when
we leave the world, we are the people to
gather to make sure that we have a fitting
departure. That is why every weekend I
send delegations to the funerals of all
former Hon Members of Parliament and I
make contributions towards that. It is not
easy but that is how the parliamentary
family is.
In spite of our political differences we
are still brothers and sisters. We should
continue in that spirit and transmit that to
our supporters on the grounds that when we
debate in the House, it is not a war situation
but a contest of ideas; it is a market place
to share and buy. Definitely we have
principles and values which differ but that
is the diversity that God has created and it
is not the making of any of us. Our maturity
would determine how we tolerate each
other and how we move together with the
differences that we have. Temperaments
and heights might not be the same but
please, we are all Ghanaians and we have a
national interest.
I have told you that as much as possible,
I would be impartial but that I am not
neutral because I must align with the
national interest. You may align with your
political party's interest but I would align with the national interest. On any issue that
is discussed in the House, I have an
interest, so I cannot be seen as neutral but
in the execution of my functions as the Rt
Hon Speaker, I have to be impartial. So,
once you mentioned the Hon Deputy
Minority Leader's name and said that he said something even though I did not hear
it and you stated yourself that it was off the
microphone, he has the opportunity to
rebut.
Hon Deputy Minority Leader, it is your
turn now.
Mr Avedzi 1:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the Hon
Deputy Majority Leader said that I
mentioned “E-Levy” but I did not mention that. He is seated far from me so how did
he know that I mentioned “E-Levy”? My Hon Colleague who is seated close to me
did not even hear that. I want it to be on

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

record that I did not mention any “E- Levy”.

The Hon Deputy Majority Leader was

comfortable that this issue was raised and

he wanted to use it to campaign for the “E- Levy”. We are talking about the lives of our students and citizens in Ukraine and

that is the reason the Hon Minority Leader

mentioned that the Government must take

steps to secure and support our students to

come back. The Hon Deputy Majority

Leader always wants to find comfort with

issues that they want to blame for their

non-performance. They still mention

COVID-19 as the reason for non-performance,

and all of a sudden it is now Ukraine --
Mr Speaker 1:59 p.m.
Hon Deputy Minority
Leader, you have fallen into the same trap
he fell into. The second part of the issue
you raised is under Standing Order 93(4)
which says:
“The speech of a Member must have reference to the subject matter under
discussion”.
You said the Hon Deputy Majority
Leader went off tangent to add other things
that were not the subject matter of the
discussion. I hold that, but you have also
veered into an area that he never even
mentioned. He did not talk about “COVID- 19”. He only talked about you having said “E-Levy”, which you have rebutted. We
would continue but do not fall into the
same trap.
Mr Avedzi 1:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I just would
want to set the records straight that I did not
talk about “E-Levy”, that because of the Ukraine issue we are urging the E-Levy to
be passed in order to raise money --
Mr Speaker 1:59 p.m.
Do you still want to
continue along that line?
Mr Avedzi 1:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would end
by saying that I did not mention any “E- Levy”.
Mr Speaker 1:59 p.m.
I saw the Hon Member
for Tamale Central, Mr Suhuyini Sayibu on
his feet.
Mr Sayibu 1:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I was on my
feet in relation to the subject matter that
was raised by the Hon Minority Leader and
I were of the view that the Hon Deputy
Majority Leader did not speak to the
subject that was raised but I took your
guidance and sat back.
Mr Speaker 1:59 p.m.
Hon Members, we would
move on to the next item but before we do
that, it is important I defuse some fake
news which has been circulated that I
granted an interview and said that the Hon
Member for Dome/Kwabenya, Ms Adwoa
Safo, received permission from me to
absent herself from Parliament on health

A call for the safety of Ghanaian Students in Ukraine

grounds. I want it to be known by all that I

have not granted any such interview

anywhere and I have not said anything like

that anywhere. The Votes and Proceedings

of the House are so loud that she was

absent without permission for all those

days -- that is on the Votes and Proceedings of the House. It is not the Rt

Hon Speaker who determines who is

present or absent. No! The Votes and

Proceedings would capture those who are

present, absent and those who are absent

with permission.

I have received a lot of calls from a

number of media men on that issue and that

is why I do not want to delay to let the

world know that I have not said such thing

anywhere, please. Tomorrow, I would

address the issue of absentee Hon

Members very clearly for everybody to

understand.

Looking at the nature of business before

us, I would direct that Sitting should be

held outside the normal prescribed Sitting

hours.

We would take item numbered 6 -- Statements.

I have admitted a number of Statements

but we would take the first one from the

Hon Member for Afadjato South, Mrs

Angela Oforiwaa Alorwu-Tay, which is a

tribute to the memory of Togbega

Asemtsyra IX, Paramount Chief of Have

Traditional Area.

Hon Member, you may read your

Statement.
STATEMENTS 2:09 p.m.

Mrs Della Adjoa Sowah (NDC -- Kpando) 2:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you for the
opportunity to contribute to the tribute read
by my Hon Colleague, Hon Angela
Alorwu-Tay.
I met Togbega at the Akpini Traditional
Council, situated in my Constituency in
Kpando. He was a man of great dignity. He
was one of the few chiefs that carried
themselves very well. He was also part of
the peace process in settling the chieftaincy
issues in my own hometown, Kpando.
Togbega was full of wisdom. He conducted
and carried himself as such. He always had
a wise word to share with us any time we
met him. He always joked that he was not
a political chief, and that he was a chief for
every political party.

Statements

Mr Speaker, Togbega was very

instrumental in a lot of things in the

Regional House of Chiefs. We met him

when, as a Caucus, we visited the Regional

House of Chiefs. He advised us on how we

should work together to ensure the unity

and development of Ghana, and

particularly the Volta Region. Indeed, the

people of Have have lost a great man, and

I do not know how they would replace him.

I pray for God to give them guidance and

wisdom in enstooling a successor. I also

pray that God gives them peace during his

burial for this great loss.

Deputy Minority Leader (James

Klutse Avedzi): Mr Speaker, I also rise to

contribute and comment on the tribute to

the memory of Togbega Asemtsyra IX, the

paramount chief of the Have Traditional

Area.

Mr Speaker, Togbega was 80 years

when he passed on. According to the

Statement, Togbega, after obtaining the

MSLC in 1952, was an employee of VRA,

and he rose through the ranks to become

the Stores Superintendent.

Mr Speaker, Togbega ruled for over 50

years. That tells you the kind of person he

was in leading the people of Have that as

the paramount chief of the area, he was

able to reign for over 50 years. During that

period, the people of Have saw, in terms of

development, the Have Technical Institute

and the Have Health Centre.

Mr Speaker, the Hon Member who

made the Statement made it clear that

Togbega was a member of the Akpini

Traditional Council as well as a member of

the Volta Regional House of Chiefs. Mr

Speaker, it is clear that the people of Have

have lost an illustrious son and a leader

who, we should all pray that his

replacement should also follow his

footsteps.

I add my voice to pay tribute, and give

condolences to the family of Togbega, the

people of Have in the Afadzato South

Constituency, the people of the Volta

Region and Ghana as a whole. We wish

Togbega well and we pray that he is

accepted into the bosom of the Lord till we

meet again. We ask the people of Have to

do a thorough search in order to have a

good replacement for the late Togbega.
Mr Speaker 2:19 p.m.
Hon Members, we would
move on to the next Statement that stands
in the name of the Hon Member for Tamale
North -- Mr Alhassan Suhuyini Sayibu.
Hon Member, you may make your
Statement on the Media and Responsible
Free Speech in Ghana.

Statements

Media and Responsible Free Speech

in Ghana

Mr Suhuyini Alhassan Sayibu (NDC

-- Tamale North): Mr Speaker, thank you very much for the opportunity to make this

Statement of public importance.

Mr Speaker, I beg to quote President
Nana Akufo-Addo and he says 2:19 p.m.
“I would say again that I much prefer the noisy,
boisterous, sometimes scurrilous media of
today to the monotonous praise singing
sycophantic one of yesteryears”.
Mr Speaker, permit me to state upfront
that I am all for responsible free speech and
against the use of the coercive powers of
the State to achieve that. Just like you and
many lovers of democracy, I have been
profoundly disturbed by not only the
resurgence of military takeovers of
democratic governments in sub-Saharan
Africa, but especially, by the number of
discussions on and off media platforms in
Ghana about how well our democracy is
serving us and whether the coups in the
affected African countries can be justified.
Our youth unemployment rate has
worsened over the years and it is almost
equal to the pre-independence figure of
around 20 per cent. The World Bank
reports that under-employment is at around
50 per cent. It is, therefore, needless to add
that despondency and stress levels are high.
These make our compatriots very
vulnerable as they seek a saviour or, at
least, hope for one. Indeed, all of us in
privileged political positions are in a
precarious position and we ought to be
extra mindful of our actions and inactions.
Mr Speaker, when I listen to these
discussions contrasting the benefits of
democracies to coup regimes, two
arguments that stand uncontested yet are
the freedoms, especially that of expression
and the right to seek redress in an impartial
judicial process that our Constitution
guarantees.
Even though the two may not be enough
to preserve our democracy, if their
promotion is not linked to other needs of
our society, I daresay that an encroachment
of these two will leave our democracy
without justification to uphold.
Mr Speaker, our nation went at great
lengths to repeal the Criminal Libel Law
and ironically, President Akufo-Addo was
at the forefront of that as Ghana's Hon Attorney-General and Minister for Justice
then.
Indeed, in June 2021, the President said
at Alisa Hotel and I beg to quote:
“I am proud of the modest role I played in the process of the repeal of
the Criminal Libel Law. As the

Statements

Attorney-General who piloted the

repeal through Parliament, I was also

responsible for the discontinuation of

the then pending prosecutions under

the Criminal Libel Law of notable

Ghanaian journalists; Tommy Thompson,

Kofi Koomson and Eben Quarcoo for

publications against personalities of

the then Government.”

Mr Speaker, it is therefore tragic that

despite the repeal of the Criminal Libel

Law, the end pride of a President for his

role, both in opposition and later as

Attorney-General and his professed choice

for noisy, boisterous, and sometimes

scurrilous media over the monotonous

praise signing sycophantic ones of

yesteryears, we are yet unable to find

justice for Ahmed Suale, an undercover

journalist who was gunned down after his

identity was compromised by,

unfortunately, an Hon Member of this

House at a time, when he and his

colleagues premiered their investigations

into Ghana Football and exposed grand

corruption and collusion.

For the first time in our Fourth

Republic, over a hundred radio stations

were shut down for what authorities say

were regulatory breaches despite a widely-

held perception that it was politically

motivated, selective, and targeted at media

that was critical of the Government.

Mr Speaker, as at now, I have lost count

of the number of State-sponsored or

complicity in the arrest, harassment, and

detention of journalists in the last couple of

years. Journalists of Modern Ghana News

website recounted a harrowing torture they

received at the hands of national security

operatives when they were arrested for

their work. The likes of Umar Sanda of Citi

Fm, David Tamakloe of Whatsapp News

fame, the Upper East reporter of EIB

Network, Edward Adeti, and so on have all

suffered in the hands of people working in

the name of the State for their news

publications.

Let me repeat for emphasis that I am for

responsible free speech and I prefer the use

of the persuasive powers of the State to

achieve it over the use of the coercive

powers of the State.

Mr Speaker, we must guard against the

threat to the most valuable argument today

used in defence of our democracy. The

freedom to criticise our leaders and their

conduct without fear of incrimination.

In the last couple of days, Mr Mensah

Thompson, a civil society activist with the

African Center for Parliamentary Affairs

(ACEPA), has had to be detained in

custody for a publication he immediately

retracted and apologised for, after

admitting his hitherto credible sources

misled him on that particular issue.

Statements

Mr Speaker, a broadcaster with Power

fm, Mr Oheneba Boamah Bennie, was

sentenced to a 14-days imprisonment for

publishing what is said to be false news in

relation to Justices of the Supreme Court in

the last election petition case. A journalist

with Media General, Captain Smart, has

been arrested bizarrely at different times

for a number of reasons, recently including

some pronouncements he made on the

peace and security of the country on air and

what his employees believe was a

deliberate set-up to charge him for

extortion. Perhaps, the latest was the arrest

of Mr Bobie Ansah of Accra fm after his

show, after 10 p.m. while on his way home.

Let me conclude by saying that given

the precarious nature of our sub-region, the

growing despondency of, especially, our

unemployed youth and the questions about

whether our democracy is fit for purpose,

we in political positions ought to guard

against the temptation to reduce or

encroach on the channels and opportunities

for venting frustrations.

Mr Speaker, I am for free, responsible

speech just I am sure you are too. However,

I am against the use of coercive powers of

the State to guarantee it because in the long

run, that is not sustainable.

Once again, I am most grateful for the

opportunity to make this Statement.
Mr Kofi Iddie Adams (NDC -- Buem) 2:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you very much
for the opportunity to contribute to this
very important Statement ably made by my
Hon Colleague from Tamale North
constituency.
Indeed, democracy has been defined in
our local parlance as “ka bi ma menka bi”, to wit, “speak and let me also speak” or “let us sit and jaw-jaw”.
If we would truly work to advance our
democracy, and for that matter, free
speech, a responsible one for that matter, as
ably indicated by the Hon Member who
made the Statement, the media must not be
threatened by the use of cohesive force. Mr
Speaker, indeed, it is not for nothing that
the media has been raised and described as
the fourth estate of the realm, having
considered the Executive, Legislature, and
Judiciary.
The media has been considered as
another unofficial arm of the governance
structure of every country. If their work
and that of civil society is threatened by
such acts as have been raised in the
Statement, then it tends to endanger our
democracy and this must not be happening
at a time when research clearly shows that
unemployment in a certain bracket of our
population, the youth, is so high. Mr

Statements

Speaker, if they cannot express themselves

and also feel that expressing oneself has

been endangered in a democratic situation,

then people would resort to other means

that would not progress our democracy.

Mr Speaker, if people who can speak for

and on behalf of people also feel threatened

and they decide to be quiet, then

Government, be it the Executive, Judiciary,

or Legislature may not know what may be

happening behind them because both the

media and civil society together serve to

inform and also convey our issues to the

people that we lead. This Statement has

come at a time that many cases of death

have not been unravelled and we are

equally confronted with frequent arrests.

Mr Speaker, this is really important and I

know that a number of persons have

granted a lot of interviews and your good

self has had cause to raise concerns about

the invitation or arrest of persons for

expressing concerns even if they so made a

mistake.

Mr Speaker, it becomes even more

dangerous when a person who publishes a

statement realises his or her mistake and

apologises, but to go further to invite,

detain, and prosecute such a person cannot

help our democracy. So, I join the Hon

Member who made the Statement to urge

the institutions that must help democracy

to advance, not to be seen squeezing and

drying out democracy.

Mr Speaker, thank you for the

opportunity and I also thank the Hon

Member who made the Statement for

drawing our attention to what he thinks is

going wrong.
Mr Moses Anim (NPP -- Trobu) 2:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you for the opportunity to
contribute to the Statement on the Floor.
Mr Speaker, Ghana has tried many
systems of governance and at a point in
time, we realised that democracy is the way
to go. Before 1992, we all know the
contributions that Ghanaian citizens from
all walks of life gave towards the
promulgation of the 1992 Constitution. We
know how the media, the fourth estate of
the realm, played a great role in the attempt
to move this country from a military
regime and autocracy to a democracy
where we all now make an input, deliberate
responsibly, dialogue, build consensus,
and come together as one people to move
this country forward.
Mr Speaker, as Hon Members of
Parliament, we have responsibilities and I
believe that even having the privileges as
Hon Members is not sacrosanct.
Definitely, Hon Members of Parliament
must also demonstrate responsibility
although some constitutional privileges are
accorded to us. Mr Speaker, it does not

Statements

mean that Hon Members of Parliament can

go beyond bounds for institutions not to

also work. Also, it does not mean that

institutions should also work beyond their

mandate or go against the democratic

tenets and principles that we all uphold.

Therefore, the Constitution which

regulates all of us is very important in

matters like this.

Mr Speaker, also there are Acts of

Parliament that we have put together to

ensure a serene environment where the

rights of individuals are observed and, in

demonstrating our rights, the recognition

that the other fellow Ghanaian or human

being also has some rights. That is why it

has been said that one's freedom ends at a point where another person's rights begin.

Mr Speaker, just as former President

Obama said and was hailed, although I did

not see why he had to be hailed because

what he said was an old adage, that we

should not bring strong individuals but

rather build strong institutions. Mr

Speaker, every democracy knows this.

Some time ago, Italy lost its Prime

Ministers every three months, yet the

country was still governed because the

institutions were working. So, it is the

institutions that we must encourage to

work and also ensure that they work within

the confinement of the law.

Mr Speaker, we know that the National

Media Commission (NMC) has code of

ethics and control measures that can be

placed within the institutional framework

of the Constitution. And as I said, the

media has played a critical role since the

military regime to constitutional rule in

1992 and we can mention them. However,

we have now gotten to a point where, as has

been said by Mr Speaker before, if we are

not careful with this unbridled approach

where anything can be said by anybody

without recourse to the constitutional

framework and approach, then we could

get to a point where this country would get

out of hand.

I believe that as human as we are and as

fallible as we can be, this is the time for us

to be very circumspect and play a

balancing act such that our statements and

utterances would not let other people think

that they cannot be touched even when they

go outside the boundaries set by the

Constitution or Acts of Parliament. Mr

Speaker, we would have to play a balanced

act such that discipline and control would

be the guidelines for this country.

Yes, Parliament has been criticised but

criticism comes to Parliament and even

yesterday morning, Mr Speaker, you

admonished us on how the public even see

us as Hon Members of Parliament in

relation to our responsibilities. The

President is criticised and he is not the first

Statements

President to be criticised. Mr Speaker, I

remember that some time ago, I came close

to you and you mentioned that constructive

criticism is equally important, and respect

and dignity that we would accord

ourselves. What we do to ourselves as

politicians is already known. The way we

run one another down and play to the

gallery and allow other people to run

everybody down is an issue.

So, Mr Speaker, where we are today, I

believe that we need to allow institutions to

work within the framework of their

mandates and responsibilities, and let us be

very careful of the way we try not to

balance the out-search that someone would

look good and another would look bad

because at any material moment, the

expediency project that we continue to

have as politicians would continue to run

this country down. The expediency without

principle -- the principle that underpins democratic accountability -- if we are not careful and we go on this tangent, it would

get to a point where because the axe is not

on my neck, I may think that the fight is a

good fight.

Therefore, for me, it is a timely

Statement anyway. Names are being

narrated and mentioned as if it is the only

period that such acts have happened. No. If

I want to extrapolate and go backwards, we

can equally mention names but we do not

have to defend because two wrongs do not

make right. Let us face it and say that

wherever we are today, whatever anybody

does, he is being regulated.

Mr Speaker, we are here and not able to

pass the E-levy. Do we think that if the

President had his own way, he would not

come and join us here to pass the E-levy?

He would, but he has not got that power

because the 1992 Constitution is clear and

everybody has his boundaries. I think that

where we are today, we have to be

circumspect for posterity sake.

Mr Speaker, I am very grateful for the

opportunity.
Dr Mark Kurt Nawaane (NDC -- Nabdam) 2:39 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you for the
opportunity to contribute to this Statement
and I thank Hon Suhuyini Sayibu for this
timely Statement.
Mr Speaker, around the 1960s, there
was what we called the Preventive
Detention Act (PDA) that was used to
arrest people on so many occasions during
the Nkrumah era. Today, we sit down and
try to analyse it, and I believe that a good
number of us think that it was incorrect.
But Nkrumah was reacting to a situation,
so sometimes, we try to balance up and
understand the history of those times.
Mr Speaker, there has been a coup d'état at Burkina Faso, Mali, and Guinea, and it

Statements

appears that its ripple effects seems to

descend on us. I must say that there appears

to be some phobia in the political

establishments here in Ghana. Power

corrupts and absolute power corrupts

absolutely. Cowards die many times before

their death.

Mr Speaker, the issue at stake is not who

is right or who is wrong, but it appears that

-- let me classify it. There are two types. In one case, it appears that the State startles

rightly but the process of getting the

individual to face the law is where they get

it all wrong and we are creating

unnecessary heroes. Anybody who is

arrested and goes and comes -- a prison graduate. We know the prison graduates,

the Big Six. But we are creating more

prison graduates unnecessarily.

Mr Speaker, so initially, when

somebody gets a case, the State is supposed

to initiate the process of arrest and possibly

grant the person a bail. But what do they

do? In some of the cases, after initiating the

process, there is a behaviour which I would

term as “I would teach that person a lesson syndrome” that is played out. When someone is told that he would be taught a

lesson, it means that it is likely that whether

he likes it or not; whether the court has

granted him a bail or not; whether he has

signed all the bonds or not, he would spend

the night at the police station or cells. This

is where we are getting it wrong. I do not

want to go into the accusations. I am not a

lawyer to talk of felony and second degree

felony and so on, but that someone is going

to spend the night in the cells or the person

to be seen is going to spend the night in the

cells no matter how one begs, they would

say that the order is from above.

They would also say that the one

handling that case is not available. Or one

has to wait because the officers in-charge

claim they need to seek instructions from

somewhere else. This particular syndrome

of “I will teach him a lesson” is what is destroying our democracy. It is what is

putting fear into the citizenry -- our journalists, from performing their duties.

Mr Speaker, I am not going into the

substance of the case. I am talking of an

instance where the process has been

initiated and one is at a stage that he can go

home and report himself later. There is

even an instance where somebody reported

at 1 o'clock and he had to spend the night still at the cells.

There are instances where somebody

has finished all the processes and yet they

would put him into a vehicle and drive him

through the town and move around the

town; go to wherever they want to go, and

finally go and put him into some cells. His

family would be looking for him and they

cannot find him; his employers would be

looking for him and they cannot find him,

Statements

and all his friends would be looking for

him and they cannot find him. Then, the

next day, they leave him. We must stop this

“I will teach him a lesson” syndrome. We had better stop it and go strictly according

to the law.

If we can go according to the law, I

believe that these complaints -- this idea that so many people are being arrested

would be something of the past. Yes, one

can allege anything and arrest anybody. It

is an allegation until it is proven at the law

court. So, one can always be hit with an

allegation. Any of us here can be

unfortunate. One can go out there and be

hit with an allegation of something else that

can lead him to the police station.

But being arrested and being detained in

the cells when even the courts have

indicated that a person can go home is

worrying to me. I am appealing to the

institutions: the Police, the National

Investigations Bureau (NIB), the law

courts, and all the other players in the legal

field to stop the syndrome of “I will teach him a lesson.”

Thank you, Speaker.
Mrs Della Sowah (NDC -- Kpando) 2:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you for the opportunity
to contribute to the Statement brilliantly
made by Hon Suhuyini Sayibu.
Mr Speaker, today, our democracy is
growing. Next year will mark 30 years of
parliamentary democracy. As the Hon
Member who made the Statement said,
many people went to great lengths for the
repeal of the Criminal Libel Law, but today
what we see is that Ghana is going
backwards.
Today, journalists are afraid to talk
about things freely in the way they did a
few years back. People talk about standard:
Standards that were applied yesterday and
it was all right, but today, if one tries it, the
person will find him or herself in jail.
Journalists spoke freely about issues. There
was a news coverage when the then
candidate, President Nana Addo Dankwa
Akufo-Addo said that it was unacceptable
for US$1 to equal GHȻ2.00. Today, how many journalists can say that US$1 equals
GHȻ7.00 and it is wrong? They will be afraid to carry this news item.
Mr Speaker, the then running mate, His
Excellency Dr Bawumia said, it is
desperation to tax savings; a failed
Government will do that. What do we see
today? E-Levy! At every opportunity, I see
the other Side trying to justify it;
everything now is E-Levy. We have moved
from everything COVID-19. Journalists
cannot even talk about it freely because

Statements

they are afraid that if they do, they will find

themselves in jail.

Mr Speaker, the kind of things that are

being attributed to the current President

and the First Lady, for which journalists

are being arrested, are the same kind of

things that were attributed to former

President John Mahama and his wife,

Lordina Mahama.
rose
Mr Speaker 2:49 p.m.
Hon Member, I can see
the Hon Deputy Majority Leader on his
feet. Yes, Hon Member?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 2:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
rule on the matter on which we are
discussing is clear. We are to comment on
the Statement and our comments should
not generate debate.
Mr Speaker, it is not a statement of fact
that journalists are unable to make
comments because they are afraid of being
jailed. We have to be fair to each other in
this Chamber. I think that my respected
Hon Colleague can do better than that. I
rest my case.
Mr Speaker 2:49 p.m.
Yes, Hon Member, you
may continue.
Mrs Sowah 2:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I saw the Hon
Leader on his feet when I made the
reference, but when my Hon Colleague on
his Side made the same, because he spoke
for E-Levy, he was all right. When I made
the same statement against E-Levy, now it
is not all right. This is exactly what we are

Mr Speaker, in this country, one is not

free to make a phone conversation. My

own cousin, Dr MacPalm, was sent to jail

because of a telephone conversation -- [Interruption] -- The man who reported him is in the Military with forged

certificate as the Court heard.
Mr Speaker 2:49 p.m.
Hon Member, you are
going beyond because we are limited to
comments that will not in any way affect
pending cases in court. But what you are
referring to is a pending case in court, so
please try as much as possible not to be pre-
judicial.
Mrs Sowah 2:49 p.m.
Mr Speaker, my Hon
Colleague's Statement on what is happening in journalism is real, and I think
as a nation or as a parliament, we should
look at it closely because the culture of
silence is creeping on us very fast. People
are afraid to speak out for fear of being
arrested. People are afraid of speaking their
minds calling a spade a spade.
We must look at that critically, so that
what is happening in the neighbouring
countries does not happen in Ghana. Where

Statements

we are getting to, if people are silenced too

much, the next thing will be something we

are all praying against.

Mr Speaker, with these few words,

thank you for the opportunity to contribute.
Mr Speaker 2:49 p.m.
May I listen to the Hon
Member for Kwadaso?
Dr Kingsley Nyarko (NPP -- Kwadaso) 2:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am grateful for
the opportunity to contribute to the
Statement ably made by Hon Suhuyini
Sayibu.
Mr Speaker, you have been around for a
very long time. You are one of the most
astute politicians of our time. I would be
happy if you use your experience to inform
this House or to advise us to do away with
extreme partisanship, and always ensure
that our commentaries, ideas, and
suggestions will always inure to the
progress of this country.
Mr Speaker, if I decide to go back into
history and even restrict myself to the
Mills-Mahama Administration, I can give
you a litany of examples and happenings
regarding the abuse of media freedom that
occurred, but I do not think that is the
reason why we are here. We are here
because we see this as an issue that we
must all address frontally, so that we would
live in harmony and peace in this country.
Mr Speaker, if you would indulge me, I
remember that in 2010, our own good
Friend, Hon Kofi Adams, rushed to the
studios of Power FM, because a gentleman
by name Nana Darkwa had made a
statement about former President Rawlings
that he burnt his own house. He rushed
there with police officers and arrested him.
Our own John Kumah was accused of
referring to the former President Mills as
gay and he was arrested. A lot of them
happened in Kumasi.
But we have to chart a new course.
Nobody should assume and come to the
wrong determination or conclusion that
issues that happened to media persons are
restricted to a particular regime; that is not
true. We must condemn anybody who
assumes that. If we see this as a canker, the
question is, how do we as individuals deal
with it? That is very important. Using
isolated cases to indict a particular regime
is wrong, and it is disingenuous.
Mr Speaker, article 12(1) of the 1992
Constitution reads, and I quote:
“The fundamental human rights and freedoms enshrined in this Chapter
shall be respected and upheld by the
Executive, Legislature and Judiciary
and all other organs of government

Statements

and its agencies and, where applicable

to them, by all natural and legal

persons in Ghana, and shall be

enforceable by the Courts as provided

for in this Constitution.”

Mr Speaker, also, article 12(2) says, and

I quote:

“Every person in Ghana, whatever his race, place of origin, political opinion,

colour, religion, creed or gender shall

be entitled to the fundamental human

rights and freedoms of the individual

contained in this Chapter but subject

to respect for the rights and freedoms

of others and for the public interest.”

Mr Speaker, therefore, it means that we

must all be guided by what we say. The fact

that the media is supposed to have freedom

does not mean that they should speak

recklessly. People who speak recklessly

must be told in the face that their utterances

can undermine the peace and security of

this country. However, sadly, what

happens is that because of political interest,

when it suits us, when some people in the

media make some unpalatable comments,

we hide behind them because we use that

to advance our interests, but we forget that

when the worse happens, all of us would be

victims to that. Is that how we want to build

this country? We must be circumspect as

politicians, and we must be bold to

condemn persons when they go contrary to

societal rules and norms.

Mr Speaker, with the recent happenings

that our Hon Colleague, the Hon Suhuyini

alluded to, if we go into the merits of each

of them, they all had different

interpretations and happenings. I

remember one of them was accused of

contempt of the court, and that was how the

person was put behind bars. If somebody is

accused for contempt, who do we blame?

This is because we know that in this

country, some persons were charged with

this same offence, and they were put

behind bars. I remember Ken Korankye

and Atubiga, who were all charged for

contempt. Therefore, if somebody is

charged for contempt by the court, then

why do we say that it is the abuse of the

media or an act to curtail the freedom of

expression? That is not true!

Mr Speaker, one of them, for instance,

Bobie Ansah made some unfounded

allegation about the two First Ladies. He

was invited by the Police, but he declined

the invitation. Is that what we would want

to encourage in this country, that if one

does something wrong and the Police

invites him he declines the invitation? Is

that what we want to encourage? I would

not want to bore us with examples because

I have a lot of them. However, my plea to

the House and to you, our Hon respected

Statements

Speaker, is to let the House know that we

have one country, so we have to protect this

country, guide this country, and guard our

utterances and all that. We should be able

to do that and let the media understand that

if they sit behind the console, they should

think about the soul of the country and

think about what they say.

Mr Speaker, it is true that when the

Criminal Libel Law was repealed, we had

civil remedies, but we all know that in this

country when somebody deliberately

maligns a person and he decides to take

action against such a person, the victim is

told to go to court. The person knows that

what he is saying is untrue, but when he is

confronted, he asks the accused to go to

court, when he knows that what he is

saying is false. We do not have to

encourage that, and I would want to plead

with all of us that as much as possible, we

should eschew extreme partisanship, and

let the love of this country lead and guide

us. That is the only way we would make

progress.

Mr Speaker, I thank you very much for

indulging me. I am grateful to you as

always.
Mr Speaker 2:59 p.m.
Hon Members, I was
going to allow the Hon lady who stood up
early on to speak, but now I see an Hon
gentleman, so, he would be the last person,
then we would move on to the next
Statement.
Mr Peter Lanchene Toobu (NDC -- Wa West) 2:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I thank you very
much for the opportunity to contribute to a
very important Statement delivered by my
Hon Colleague, who also happens to have
a background in media practice, the Hon
Member of Parliament for Tamale North.
Mr Speaker, media freedom is a
complete requirement in our Constitution.
The freedom of speech is supposed to
contribute to our democratic sustenance,
but I think that one thing that is happening
in Ghana, which is quite important to
mention, is the unhealthy political
equalisation as we experience in this
House. What was wrong in the year 1993,
if it is wrong in this year 2022, then we
should say so. However, the fact is that if
we continue to bend backwards to bring up
history to equalise the wrongs of today,
then I think that our democracy is suffering
from something that we can call
“Kwashiorkor”; we are not growing.
Mr Speaker, Ghana as a State is divided
into four huge organs; the Executive that
has the coercive power, the legislature,
which Rt Hon Speaker, you are heading,
trying to reform and put it in better
perspective, and the Judiciary. Mr Speaker,
the media is always considered as the
fourth estate of the realm, and I would want

Statements

to state this for the record today, that if the

media is here and they consider themselves

as we all believe that they are number four,

then they should not wait for numbers one,

two and three to fight for them. They

should please fight their own battles,

develop themselves and hope that numbers

one, two and three would support them to

grow.

Mr Speaker, in some time past, we

repealed the Criminal Libel Law, and the

simple question that everybody can ask,

would be to know the major objective of

the repeal of the Criminal Libel Law. We

intended to ensure that media pluralism

and media freedom was going to be

enhanced, but today, if we have section 207

and section 208 in the Criminal Offenses

Act that is still being used to demoralise the

media, then it is for us as a country to look

at it. What was the objective of repealing

the Criminal Libel Law? If that objective is

defeated by the continuous existence of

sections 207 and 208 in the Criminal

Offences Act, then we ought to rise up as a

people and do something about it.

Mr Speaker, I have seen on many

occasions where people point accusing

fingers at the Police for recklessly arresting

journalists, but I can state as a matter of fact

that if the President had listened to the

recommendations of the Emile Short

Commission to abolish the SWAT team at

the National Security, then I believe that

the many disgrace that we are seeing as a

country could probably be reduced. This is

because many of the things that are

happening; the arrests that we see, are as a

result of the SWAT team at the National

Security Ministry, not being accountable to

the Inspector General of Police (IGP) or the

Chief of Defence Staff. They go out there

and do anything, but I can tell us that at any

point in time that we see a uniformed

officer being under the control of the

civilian, the only thing that we can find is

mess.

Mr Speaker, the Police are sometimes

allowed to take part in what is provided in

article 88 of the 1992 Constitution. What is

in article 88 is just the duty of the Attorney-

General. The responsibility of the Police is

to prevent, detect and investigate crime. It

is not the job of the Police to get into court

to prosecute crime. The checks and

balances are in the Constitution. We should

ensure that the Police does not abuse those

checks and balances by prosecuting crime.

We should let the Attorney-General recruit

enough lawyers and have State Attorneys

across all districts in the whole country to

do his job, and avoid getting the Police into

such a mess, such that they would be the

same persons to investigate and prosecute.

The checks and balances are required.

Mr Speaker, in conclusion, if we want

to allow our media to gain that popularity

and importance in the constitutional

Statements

framework, then we should allow them to

develop and also encourage the National

Media Commission and the Ghana

Journalist Association to take the bull by

the horn and develop their own organ to the

point that they would gain that much

respect from the Executive, the Legislature

and the Judiciary. After all, the four

together makes a country beautiful.

Mr Speaker, with these few words, I
Mr Speaker 3:19 p.m.
Hon Members, we would
take another Statement. I gave indication
early on that the Hon Member was going to
be the last person. We have two more
Statements, one is commemorative. In fact,
it is a tribute to the departure of one of our
former Hon Colleagues, and the other one
is on tourist attractions in the constituency.
If Hon Leaders want us to continue with
more contributions to the earlier Statement,
I can allow you, but please be guided. One
of the things I learnt early in my political
life when I was the Chairman of the
Committee on Constitutional, Legal and
Parliamentary Affairs from 1997 to 2000
⸺ His Excellency the President was the Ranking Member. We worked together
very well. I remember making some
scathing remarks about the Government in
power. After Sitting, the veteran politician,
senior statesman and economic guru, the
late Hon J. H. Mensah, who was the
Minority Leader then, called me to his
office. He told me that as a politician, I
must learn to speak from both sides of my
mouth. When one side says yes, the other
should say no. I told him that that was not
of me, and that I could not do it. If that is
how politics was, I would opt out. When I
was in secondary school, we had a song, it
was a record dance, which was “let your yes be yes, and your no be no”.
Countries do not develop because of
natural resources; they develop as a result
of the quality of the human resource.
Please, let our yes be yes, and our no be no.
Do not change your tongue depending on
the seat you sit on. We must have
character. I have kept on telling you that if
I am asked to choose between knowledge
and character, I will choose character, and
not knowledge. Read further on many of
these things you have said. Do not take the
perspectives of politicians; dig deep into
history and you will know the truth.
Our country is suffering because of
misrepresentation and distortion of history.
The voice of democracy is the media. Most
of you are here because you wanted to be
the voice of your people. When you are the
voice of the people and you say things here,
and the media does not carry it out, your
people would not even know that you
spoke. That is the value of the media. The

Statements

media makes and unmakes politicians. The

pen is mightier than the sword.

You are Hon Leaders. I give you two

minutes each. You can make your

contributions.

Mr Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa (NDC

-- North Tongu): Mr Speaker, I commend the Hon Suhuyini Alhassan Sayibu for

making this very important Statement on

free speech and media freedoms in Ghana.

Having been a media practitioner himself,

he has been consistent and principled in

this House about the need to protect media

freedoms, and expand the frontiers of free

expression and not to muzzle the press or

intimidate practitioners and undermine the

tenets of free speech which is a

fundamental human rights in the 1992

Constitution.

Mr Speaker, as a country, we have come

a long way in protecting free expression.

We enshrined in our 1992 Constitution the

protection of free speech and free media.

We dedicated a whole chapter in the

Constitution for media freedoms. That

should tell you how, as a country, we knew

right from the beginning that our

democracy cannot be sustained without

media freedoms and free expression.

We even went further and created a

constitutional body, the National Media

Commission (NMC) to be the vanguard,

protector of these media freedoms and to

insulate even the state-owned media from

governmental control. Therefore, when we

talk about free expression and media

freedoms, our Constitution established the

framework. Mr Speaker, over the years, we

have all said that we should deepen that

culture, and that is why President Kufuor is

commended for repealing the Criminal

Libel Law.

Mr Speaker, it appears that in recent

times, the gains that we have made as a

country are being eroded. It is not me or the

Hon Member who made the Statement who

said that. The international community has

come to accept a very important barometer,

the World Press Freedom Index. That is the

barometer that assesses how well countries

are doing when it comes to press freedom.

Unfortunately, Ghana has lost its

number 1 spot. Not too long ago, we were

number 1, the shining example. We were

the star performers when it came to press

freedoms in Africa. Unfortunately, we

have lost that number 1 spot. If you read

the latest report on World Press Freedom

Index, they raised concerns particularly

about the murder of Ahmed Hussein-Suale,

and how no arrest has been made till now

and no update on the investigations has

been provided. That must trouble all of us.

Statements

They also have a litany of persons who

have been arrested in the course of their

duties. I noticed that the Hon Member who

made the Statement provided a number of

these names, and I do not want to bore you

with the list, considering our time

constraint. However, what is clear is that,

independent bodies say that we have to sit

up. The Media Foundation for West Africa

(MFWA) has also published a tall list of

journalists who have been persecuted in the

course of their work. They even claimed

that they had to whisk the celebrated

investigative journalist, Manasseh Azure

Awuni, out of this country because of

threats to his life. They had to contribute

money and send him to South Africa for

some protection or a safe haven. Mr

Speaker, this is not something we should

be proud of.

Mr Speaker, all of us in this House know

that without the media, the work we do in

this Chamber cannot get to our people. We

all know that the work we carry out in our

Constituencies, without the media, our

people would not know, and we cannot be

accountable to the people who elected us.

So, we need the media.

Mr Speaker, I believe that the time has

come for us to repeal those sections of the

Criminal Code: Section 207 and 208

relating to false publication. It is clearly re-

introducing the Criminal Libel Law

through the back door. And I would appeal

to the Attorney-General to take steps to

have that repealed. If the Attorney-General

would not do it, I believe that the Rt. Hon

Speaker may soon have to grant leave for

some Private Member intervention so that

we would repeal that aspect of the Criminal

Code.

Mr Speaker, this is because I agree with

the Media Foundation for West Africa; I

agree with the Civil Society Organisations

who are saying that if you feel that some

false publications have been made, and it

affect, your person, like in the case of the

First and Second Ladies and in the case of

Bobbie Ansah, you have civil remedies.

You can go to Court with a defamation suit,

and the Court, if it confirms that indeed,

you have been defamed, they would take

steps to have your reputation, which has

been injured, restored. And there would be

sanctions.

Mr Speaker, so, there are civil remedies;

civil avenues available. We should really

repeal these provisions in our laws so that

our journalists can work freely. The time

has come for us to expand the frontiers of

free expression and media freedom. Let us

remember that those provisions in the law

that we are using against opponents today,

we may be in power today but we would

not be in power always, and another

Government could use it against us and use

it against our allies. So, we must always

think nationally, patriotically and think

Statements

about nurturing this democracy;

strengthening this democracy so that at the

end of the day, we would be able to have

that healthy democracy that transforms

society that we all seek.

Mr Speaker, with these few words, I

commend the Hon Member who made the

Statement, and I pray that His Excellency,

the President would have a second thought

on all the prosecutions and persecutions

going on. The Attorney-General would be

well advised; we would take a second look

and a hard look at the ratings and how we

are being down-graded on the World Press

Freedom Index so that we would return on

the path of media excellence.

I thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
Mr Speaker 3:19 p.m.
Yes, the Majority
Leadership?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 3:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, you
may proceed to the next Statement; I have
nothing useful to add.
Mr Speaker 3:19 p.m.
Thank you so much for
your magnanimity.
I think we can move on to the next
Statement. I met these Statements here
selected by my Second Deputy Speaker,
and this comes from the Hon Member for
Sissala West, the Hon Mohammed
Sukparu, on the need for Government to
improve on tourist attractions in the Sissala
West District.
Yes, Hon Member, you may present
your Statement.
Tourism Enhancement in Sisala
West District
Mr Mohammed A. Sukparu (NDC -- Sissala West) 3:19 p.m.
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Mr Speaker, I am grateful for the
opportunity to speak on this very important
subject of tourism enhancement in the
Sissala West District. Tourism is one of the
largest contributors to Ghana's Gross Domestic Product (GDP), contributing up
to 3.3 billion dollars in 2019, according to
the Ghana Tourism Authority. This figure
dropped by almost half in 2020 with the
sector contributing only 1.9 billion dollars,
a decline fairly attributable to COVID-19
and the consequent reduction in the foreign
tourists who visit the country.
Mr Speaker, the decline in revenues
from this sector, partly due to the
pandemic, is a wakeup call on us to
encourage domestic tourism by improving
and marketing tourist attractions in the
country. The Sissala West District
possesses tremendous tourism potentials
which must be urgently harnessed to
generate revenue for government, provide

Statements

employment for the citizens and enhance

general development in these areas.

The Gbele Forest Reserve is the fourth

largest in Ghana, housing the rarest wild

animal and bird species, ranging from

different species of antelope, baboons,

green monkeys, elephants, violet turacos,

yellow-billed oxpeckers and warthogs.

Younger Honourable members who

watched cartoons would agree with me that

cartoon lovers who watched The Lion King

and saw the character Pumba would love to

see a live warthog for themselves. These

natural endowments and scene of wonders

are, however, being left untapped due to

lack of government commitment to make

the reserve attractive. It is high time

government, through the ministry of

tourism, puts the Gbele Reserve on the

radar.

Mr Speaker, I was shocked to realise

that outside of the Upper West Region,

little is known about the Kalgbe Crocodile

pond, home to hundreds of crocodiles in

Gwollu. Urgent steps must be taken by the

Ministry to expose citizens and foreigners

alike to a place like this.

Mr Speaker, the Gwollu Slave Defence

Wall and the Worugu Slave Escape Rocky

Mountains are magnificent works of art.

The slave wall is Sissala and Ghana's own version of the Great Wall of China; both

built for the same reason (to prevent

foreign) invaders and slavers from entering

the Sissala Lands. Just as the Great Wall of

China is branded to remain a colossal

tourist attraction into this century, we can

also brand and improve the remnants of the

Gwollu Slave Defence wall to attract both

local and foreign tourists.

Mr Speaker, in other jurisdictions like

China, Mexico and Russia, ancient herbal

medicinal practices are still very attractive

to citizens. It can be similar in Ghana with

little push from government. Gratefully,

we are endowed with centres which render

the most desired of herbal medications

anywhere on planet earth. The residents of

Jefisi are renowned for their mastery of the

cure for leprosy and have been in the

practice of this traditional medicines for

centuries.

Mr Speaker, I can also speak of the

Gwollu Bone Setting and Viagra Centre.

Yes, Mr Speaker, I mean Viagra. The

centre is notable for its ability to cure

impotence in men and improve sexual

health and longevity. We are all aware, Mr

Speaker, that due to stress most men do not

last in bed and instead of finding lasting

solutions, they resort to aphrodisiacs which

have long term detrimental effects.

The Gwollu Viagra Centre provides

lasting and natural solutions without side

effects. The centre is also capable of

healing fractured bones and disabilities. I

Statements

have no doubt that with proper marketing,

Ghanaians and foreigners alike would

patronise this centre. Mr Speaker, the tomb

of Dr. Hilla Limann, the former President

of the third Republic also lies in Gwollu

and its tourist potentials must be explored.

The Sissala district is a very traditional

one, upholding cultures from many

generations which are showcased in

festivals all year long.

The tourism potential of the district is

enormous and same is evident in my

presentation. I therefore call on

government, through the Ministry of

Tourism to consider these few areas that I

have mentioned among others and to work

towards marketing them to attract tourists.

This will contribute to efforts of successive

governments to eradicate unemployment

and develop the district. My outfit is

willing, ready and able to support

government and any individual in this

venture.

Thank you very much for the

opportunity, Mr Speaker.

Several Hon Members -- rose --
Mr Speaker 3:29 p.m.
I was not expecting this
number of people to rise up to try and
contribute to this Statement. I am aware
that it is a good marketing strategy and I
know a lot more Ghanaians would
patronise the centre, particularly the men
who are suffering. I would take only two
from each Side of the House. We have five
of you standing, so I would take one
gentleman and one lady.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 3:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
want to make a suggestion. Since there is a
last Statement to be made which you
announced, I humbly suggest that we take
that, so that we can have a composite - When the Hon Member talked about that
thing, it excited a lot of people and that is
why a lot of Hon Members got up. So, with
your leave, the Hon Member to make the
last Statement can take it and then you can
open up.
Mr Speaker 3:29 p.m.
Well, the last Statement
stands in the name of the Hon Member for
Jomoro, which is a tribute to be paid to the
late Hon James Van Leuven Mensah,
former Member of Parliament for Nzema
West Constituency, now Jomoro
Constituency. Hon Member, you may
make the Statement, and then I would open
the Floor for comments.
Mr Ibrahim 3:29 p.m.
Mr Speaker, after the
Statement to be made by Hon Dorcas
Toffey which is a tribute, I know per our
convention and practise that there may be a
minute's silence. The one the Hon Member for Sissala just presented is on tourism
which is about business. We cannot

Statements

combine business with a funeral. Tourism

is not just about -- I do not want to disagree but truly speaking, you cannot

combine tourism and a funeral. Could we

restrict the contributions, then after that,

the tribute could come? It is true that

tributes are different and we cannot

combine the two.

The Hon Deputy Majority Leader

should have consulted me on that and I

would have supported him. If he had

consulted me, I would have given him this

my superior argument, that we cannot

combine the two. The fact that he has said

it does not mean I should support it, but

truly speaking, he knows that funerals and

tourism are not the same and cannot be

combined. Can we combine funerals and

tourism? No. Mr Speaker, my Hon Brother

agrees with me.
Mr Speaker 3:29 p.m.
I would be adjourning the
House at exactly 4 p. m. because I have to
receive some important dignitaries in my
office. I wish that in Ghana, we were not
combining funerals with tourism but we
even go beyond that. We combine funerals
with tourism and politics and you all know
that our funeral grounds are now tourist
attractions where people come from all
over the world just to come and see the
display of culture, traditions and the rest.
Then the politicians take advantage to
show who is who.
So, they are no more funerals but tourist
attractions, cultural festivals and political
grounds where people meet to part
numbers. So, I think that the Statements
would go together because the aphrodisiac
people are itching to be part of it. So, Hon
Member for Jomoro, kindly do so. We
would give our former colleague the due
respect and allow Hon Members to make
their comments. Do not fall into the trap of

Tribute to late Hon James Van

Leuven Mensah, Former MP for

Nzema West (now Jomoro)

Constituency
Ms Dorcas Toffey (NDC -- Jomoro) 3:29 p.m.
I promise that I will not.
Right Honourable Speaker, thank you
for the opportunity to read this tribute in
honour of the memory of the late former
Honourable Member for the then Nzema
West Constituency (Now Jomoro Constituency),
Hon James Van Leuven Mensah.
Mr Speaker, "this world is a stage and
men and women are merely actors: they
have their entrance and exit” ⸺William Shakespeare.
Mr Speaker, the late James Van Leuven
Mensah was born at Kengen on the 8th of
February, 1937 to Egya Joseph Numuah
Mensah and Agnes Nyankeh Adelah, all of

Statements

blessed memory. He was the fourth of

seven children, all of blessed memory.

Hon Leuven Mensah lost his father at a

tender age and was thereafter raised by his

mother with support from his uncles,

Nyankeh Beyelah and Nyankeh Armah.

Mr Speaker, the late MP had his basic

education at the Beyin Roman Catholic

School from 1944 to 1950. He enrolled in

Achimota Secondary School in 1951 and

graduated with a Cambridge Overseas

School Certificate (G.C.E. Equivalent) in

1955. For his tertiary education, he pursued

Science at the College of Technology (now

KNUST) in Kumasi, in 1956.

He later enrolled on the A.C.C.A

programme at the School of Administration,

Achimota (now GIMPA) in 1962. In June

1965, he joined the Balham and Tooting

College of Commerce in London for his

final A.C.C.A. Mr. Speaker, in recognition

of his professional achievements and

conduct, he was given a 'Fellow Member

of the Association of Chartered and

Certified Accountants of England and

Wales' award in 1973.

Mr Speaker, the late Hon Leuven

Mensah attended the Chart University

College for an intermediate LLB in 1983.

He subsequently enrolled in the University

of Buckingham Law School to achieve his

final LLB in 1985. In 1986, he proceeded

to the Pennsylvania State University Law

School and obtained his Masters Degree in

Law (LLM).

Mr Speaker, after graduating, the late

Hon Leuven Mensah pursued a career in

banking with U.A.C. (now Unilever) as his

first place of work in 1956 before going to

the United Kingdom to complete his

Accountancy Qualification.

He secured his complete A.C.C.A

qualification in 1965 and returned to

Ghana. He worked at the Bank of Ghana on

his return. He began with the Foreign

Operation and Exchange Control

Department, where he worked as Deputy

Manager from 1969-1971. He later joined

the Internal Audit and Bank Examination

and gradually progressed from working as

Manager, Deputy Chief Manager through

to Chief Manager (1971-1979). He doubled as the Ghana Supply

Commission's Managing Director from

1975 to 1979.

Mr Speaker, the late Hon Leuven

Mensah joined Dr Hilla Liman's Peoples

National Party in 1979. He contested and

won the Nzema West Constituency (now

Jomoro Constituency) parliamentary seat

on that ticket in that same year to become

the only member of parliament for the area

in the Third Republic. He also served as the

Chairman for the Ghana National Trading

Corporation (G.N.T.C) from 1979 to 1981

Statements

and doubled as the Chairman of the

Parliamentary Select Committee on Land,

Forestry, Fuel and Power from 1979 to

1981.

After the coup of December 1981, the

late Hon Leuven Mensah went into exile

and on his return, served as the Chairman

of the Board of Directors of the Jomoro

Rural Bank until he fell sick. Mr Speaker,

he could not survive the sickness and

finally kicked the bucket on the 9th of

October, 2021. Death is indeed our

inevitable end (that is, Job 14:1-2) and

sadly, Mr Speaker, Ghana has lost a great

politician and statesman.

The late Hon MP left behind seven

children and eleven grandchildren.

Mr Speaker, the records of this

honourable house reveals that, the late Hon

James Van Leuven Mensah was a man of

great candor and complete integrity. His

hard work and dedication to service in

every field he found himself was very

refreshing and exemplary. His excellence

and success in all his endeavours therefore

did not emerge as a surprise, and as a

former Member of Parliament, he was and

will always be remembered for his great

contribution to education, banking and

finance, great lobbying skills leading to

access to electricity and the general welfare

of the people of Nzema West.

Mr Speaker,

“yesterday was but a dream, tomorrow is only a vision, but today well lived

makes yesterday a dream of happiness

and every tomorrow, a vision of hope” Kalidasa.

On that score Mr Speaker, I would like

to end my tribute to the late Hon Leuven

Mensah with an assurance to the good

people of Jomoro that, the late Hon James

Van Leuven Mensah may have departed,

but his remarkable legacies live on and

shall be protected by those of us who now

walk in his illustrious shoes.

Thank you Mr Speaker and this august

House for the opportunity.

By: Hon Dorcas Toffey-Jomoro

Constituency.
Mr Speaker 3:49 p.m.
Hon Members, we would
combine both Statements, so we would
increase the number of Hon Members who
would contribute.
I would plead with the Hon Member
who made the Statement to put off her
microphone.
Dr Abdul-Rashid Hassan Pelpuo
(NDC -- Wa Central): Mr Speaker, I

Statements

thank you for the opportunity to contribute

to the two Statements. However, I would

contribute briefly on the last one.

Mr Speaker, it is true that all the world

is a stage as the great Shakespeare has said

and all the men and women are merely

players. They have their exits and their

entrances, so at every point in time each of

us moves towards an exit. After fretting our

muscles and playing with ourselves and the

rest of the world, we head towards an exit

point. Hon Members of Parliament are just

other human beings who would suffer the

consequence of death, once upon a time

just as the former Hon Member we are

paying tribute to, has passed on.

Mr Speaker, he was a man who served

his people and served the Lord. He was a

noble Ghanaian who dedicated himself to

the service of his country. May he rest in

perfect peace.

Mr Speaker, tourism, is an important

financial enterprise which every country in

the world looks up to as a venture that

brings money to the country. It is not an

exchange of physical goods and services

but a tertiary service-oriented investment

area, where because of visits by citizens of

other countries to our country and because

we in Ghana would do a domestic tourism,

we earn money out of it.

Mr Speaker, in the last four years, the

number of tourists who came into our

country reduced from our earning

GH¢600,000 to GH¢200,000. Again, the

world tourism industry itself collapsed up

to a point and the world has lost about

US$4 trillion because of the COVID-19

impact. However, it is essential that we talk

about domestic tourism and encourage

people to do it because it would enable us

to understand and know each other and to

also appreciate the environment of one

another.

I am happy the Hon Member who made

the Statement mentioned the Gwollu Wall

in particular, which is very symbolic of a

people who wanted to protect themselves;

of a people who saw what it was to see

themselves as one people and to be able to

fight against intruders without necessarily

taking bows and arrows. China did the

same and we glorify them for that but

Ghana has done the same at Gwollu. We

should begin to sell this concept and idea

so that in the end when people begin to

appreciate who we are by looking at the

past and seeing what value it was in that

past, we could increase the value today.

Mr Speaker, I would want to encourage

all of us that there are so many things we

could look at and appreciate in our country.

The Hon Member who made the Statement

talked about the Upper West Region where

there are so much tourist sites but there are

Statements

other areas as well where there are things

that create value so if we visit such places,

we would increase the financial value of

our country. When we visit such places and

pay for accommodation and tour fees, we

contribute to the economy.

The Hon Member who made the

Statement got it all right when at the end of

it he mentioned some key advantages, one

of which is very exciting and I am sure

some other persons would appreciate,

about how much we could gain personally;

physiologically being part of a tourism

venture to his constituency. If we see it to

be something of a health value, we from the

Upper West Region would be happy to

receive you and give that strength of heart

and mind to do what you could do to make

a family happy.

Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

opportunity.

Mr Emmanuel Armah-Kofi Buah

(NDC -- Ellembele): Mr Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity and I also thank the

Hon Member who made the Statement for

bringing to the limelight the tourism

potential of his constituency.

The tourism attraction that he

mentioned; the animal haven and other

attractions, the seas of wonders and the fact

that there is lack of investment in those

areas. This story resonates across the

country because I could talk about my

constituency and the Jomoro District.

This Statement is very important and we

must all support tourism especially, when

we are talking about E-Levy and raising

revenue for our State. A lot of countries do

not have any resources except for tourism

and they have managed to do it well.

Mr Speaker, we can only succeed if we

promote tourism in Ghana and it is

something we must note.

I would also like to thank the Hon

Member for Jomoro Constituency for the

tribute to the Hon James Leuven Mensah

whose life can be described as a life of

service. If you read his tribute, it was very

clear that this is a man from a very humble

beginning who lost his father at a very

tender age and the story tells about how

effective our extended family system was.

Somehow, his uncle supported his mother

and he was able to grow up successfully.

Mr Speaker, there was something very

profound in the Statement about how a

young man from Benyin in the village got

admission to Achimota. That was the

system that worked; he did not need to

know anybody. All he had to do was to

play by the rules and to work hard and the

Statements

system will reward him to go to the best of

schools.

That is what this country must return to

and make sure that we can make it across

every sector to let our young people know

that if they work hard, this system will

reward them. It is a very critical issue and

the reason Mr Leuven Mensah who came

from that village can today be described as

a man who was so successful, not only as

an accountant but as a politician and an

accomplished lawyer indeed.

His record and work at the Ghana

National Trading Corporation (GNTC), the

Bank of Ghana, the Ghana Supply

Commission at the highest level must be

noted. Interestingly, he came to Parliament

as a representative of the good people of

Jomoro.

Mr Speaker, his role in Parliament was

also very critical; noted for promoting

education and encouraging a lot of young

people to advance themselves as he was

one for education. The Hon Member who

made the Statement talked about the fact

that he belonged to the People's National Party (PNP) that is the leftover of the

Convention People's Party (CPP). Interestingly, today marks the 56th

Anniversary of the overthrow of Dr

Kwame Nkrumah on the 24th February,

1966. It is clear the PNP ended that era of

that tradition.

Mr Speaker, I take the opportunity

today to pay tribute and to remember those

who perished on that day; the community

of Apataim of almost hundred young

people who were killed in that part of the

Western Region because they were looking

for Ambrose Yankey; a security operative

of Dr Kwame Nkrumah and everybody on

sight was killed. Today is a day that we

remember all that.

We also remember something very

profound when it comes to his years in

exile. As politicians, we must remember

and make sure that we live up to the

expectations of the people of Ghana

because we are all at risk.

More importantly, when he even went

into exile, they talked about him pursuing

education and after all those years in exile,

he came back to continue serving. He went

to his community and became the Board

Chairman of the Jomoro Rural Bank. His

entire life was of service, dedication and

humility for this country.

Mr Speaker, this is a man that this

honourable House is proud of, one who has

served his country and on this day, we pay

tribute in thanking him for his service to

Ghana and may God keep his soul.

Mr Speaker, thank you.

Statements
Mr Speaker 3:49 p.m.
Hon Members, I would
want to listen to the sweet, melodious and
peaceful voice of the Hon Member in front
of me; Hajia --
Ms Lariba Zuweira Abudu (NPP -- Walewale) 3:59 p.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you for
giving me the opportunity to contribute to
the Statement made by my Hon Colleague
from Gwollu. Gwollu is a very beautiful
place that I would encourage all of us to try
and visit. He spoke on tourism which is
part of our cultural heritage and tradition
and a very good economic and money-
making venture for all of us in this country
at large.
Mr Speaker, I would like to encourage
that Gwollu and the sites that he made you
mention of, are not the only places that
people would go to witness tourism - Hotel Dubai in the Upper West Region is a very
nice place to visit. I had the opportunity to
visit the place and the animals there, you
need to see them. The hotel itself is a tourist
attraction where you can go on a hike to see
what our illustrious son has been able to
put in place.
In the North East Region which is a very
small growing one, we have the Gambaga
Scarp, the Nigerian War Walls and when
we get to Jena, we have the two rivers; the
White and the Black Volta running through
but do not interact and that is a very nice
tourist attraction.
Mr Speaker, I would urge my Hon
Colleagues to identify tourist sites in our
constituencies and sell these ideas to the
Hon Minister for Tourism, Arts and
Culture. Also, on holidays, we, together
with our constituents, should try to visit
these sites and this would encourage our
constituents to visit these sites and then
promote our tourist attraction areas.
On this note, I would just want to
sympathise with my Hon Colleague for the
loss. May he rest in perfect peace. As a
former Hon Member of Parliament, he may
have died as a pauper because as Hon
Members, at the end of the day, life is not
easy to sail through.
Thank you, Mr Speaker.

Mr Edwin Nii Lantey Vanderpuye

(NDC -- Odododiodioo): Mr Speaker, thank you very much for giving me the

opportunity to contribute to the Statement

ably made by my very good Friend and

Brother; Hon Sukparu from the Sissala

West Constituency.

Mr Speaker, if you sit behind the

television to watch, especially the

international networks such as Cable News

Network (CNN) and you see

advertisements of tourism potentials of

Statements

some of these islands across Africa like

Seychelles, Maldives and other places, you

would imagine what it would be like for

Ghana to add a little effort to what we have

done so far to at least, uplift the level of our

attention towards tourism.

Upon watching CNN yesterday, I saw

that almost 2 million people visited

Seychelles just to enjoy their beautiful

water bodies. I asked myself what we are

doing to exploit the potential of the many

tourist attractions across the country since

Seychelles is an island similar in size to

that of the Upper West Region? The

benefits of tourism cannot be

underestimated. In fact, tourism has the

potential to be our most important and

highest export earner, that is if we really

develop it well.

Mr Speaker, it is the sort of commodity

that can easily be branded and sold but over

the years, we have continuously lamented

about our lack of attention to tourism and

as such, we are losing all the revenue

expected as a country to be derived from

such a God-given resource. As we speak,

instead of our beaches becoming a

potential tourist attraction sites, they have

become places of defecation and where

rubbish is damped. Instead of developing

the potential of our beaches and

waterfronts in order to generate the

necessary resources and revenue for the

country, we are soiling them.

Worse of all is the fact that today, it has

become fashionable for Ghanaians living

within the country, especially our ladies, to

see Dubai as a tourism paradise.

It is a craze now, as everybody wants to

go to Dubai, meanwhile we have more

tourism potentials than Dubai but people

are not interested in domestic tourism.

Mr Speaker, domestic tourism would

not only give us revenue but also educate

our children and give them knowledge

about our country. Our children are in

schools and are being taught about the

culture of places like Scotland and so on,

yet, they do not even know the culture in

their own country.

Mr Speaker, the geography we learnt

when we were in school has been diluted

today and we do not even see them in the

current textbooks. Some of our children do

not even know anywhere or even 50 metres

away from their homes.

Two years ago, I decided to explore this

by putting my children in my vehicle and

we travelled 10 days across the country.

When we returned, all of them wrote

reports of what they saw and I could see

some changes in them. Mr Speaker, it is

important that as legislators we put

pressure on the Executive to see these God-

given and untapped resources as a potential

sources of revenue for this country.

Statements

Mr Speaker, one of the painful things is

that even when people from abroad travel

to Ghana with money, they do not get any

place to spend the money. For instance, if

they travel to Kakum National Park, they

would just walk on the canopy-walkway

and return with the dollars still in their

pockets. We are not developing Kakum

National Park as an integrated tourism

resort where people will spend money. We

continue to pay lip service to the

development of our tourism industry

because there are tourism potentials across

the country including the Kakum National

Park, Cape Coast Castle, Nzulenzu,

Kintampo Water Falls, Boabeng Fiema

Monkey Sanctuary, Tongo Hills, Adaklu

Hills, water tourism at Volta Region, and

places at the paradise of Ghana which is

Ada.

Mr Speaker, the Ada waterfront is being

developed today but it is being done as

residential accommodation and not for the

development of tourism. The Ada

waterfront could be developed for water

sports so that people would be involved in

such games for us to make money.

Mr Speaker, I thank the Hon Member

for drawing our attention to this. I

remember we organised the Emancipation

Day during the tenure of the NDC

Administration and we sent some people to

the Assin Manso Slave River Side, but that

was all. In China, millions of people climb

the Great Wall of China every day and it

has now become the highest tourism earner

for China. They are making billions of

dollars from indigenes, nationals and

foreigners. Mr Speaker, every weekend, I

see thousands of people climb the Aburi

Mountain but we are not doing anything

there to turn the place into a tourism earner

so that we can draw some money.

In concluding, I would pray that today

becomes the last day for us to talk about

export potentials and tourism potentials

that exist in this country but that we shall

take steps to develop them and earn money,

so that we can avoid the draconian E-Levy

that we want to place on Ghanaians.

Mr Speaker, thank you very much.
Mr Speaker 4:09 p.m.
Hon Members, as I
mentioned early on, I have to attend to an
important assignment. I said that I would
adjourn the House at 4.00 p.m. but it is now
10 minutes after 4.00 p.m. so I would plead
with Hon Members for us to end the
contributions so that I can represent the
House at an event.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 4:09 p.m.
Mr Speaker, we
would want to allow you to proceed, so the
Leadership would just contribute for two
minutes each.

Statements

First Deputy Minority Whip (Mr

Ahmed Ibrahim): Mr Speaker, thank you

for the opportunity to contribute to the

Statement.

Mr Speaker, even though I was just one

year old in 1973, I would join my Hon

Colleague, Hon Toffey, to wish our former

Hon Colleague well. But I would not be

able to say much about his character and

nature. However, as long as they were the

pacesetters who paved the path on which

we stand today as Hon Members of

Parliament, I would want to wish him well

and I say that may his soul rest in perfect

peace.

Mr Speaker, on the other Statement

about tourism, what must we do again as a

country to improve upon our tourism

potentials? God has endowed Ghana with

so many tourism potentials in our

mountains, valleys, seas, mineral

resources, human resources and many

others. We have gone a step further to

establish a dedicated fund for tourism

called the Tourism Development Levy.

After we established this Levy, what have

we been able to do with that dedicated

fund?

Mr Speaker, as a country, we are quick

to establish Funds including Road Fund,

GETFund, Tourism Fund, Infrastructural

Fund and yet, when we collect the moneys,

we place them in the Consolidated Fund

and forget about them. Mr Speaker, where

we are now, I believe that we may have to

let the Hon Minister for Tourism, Arts and

Culture enumerate to us so that we can

assess what we have achieved with the

Tourism Development Levy that was

established. If we say that tourism is the

fourth foreign exchange earner in this

country, then we must know where we are

doing well and where we are not.

Mr Speaker, religiously, people embark

on trips to Israel and the Western Wall yet

in Ghana, we have the Mystic Stone at

Larabanga which efforts have been made

from 1954 to relocate it but to no avail. Our

Muslim brothers go there always for

religious activities.

Mr Speaker, religiously, Muslims travel

from all over West Africa to Pru West for

the Mallam Maikano's Religious Festival which is a very large tourist attraction. So,

we have religious tourism, commercial

tourism, educational tourism and health

tourism. With regard to health tourism, in

the whole of West Africa, I do not know

which country can rub shoulders with

Ghana in terms of health infrastructure. If

we want to boast of our health

infrastructure, let us improve upon our

health facilities; concentrate on that and let

the Tourism Development Levy add up to

that. We may be perfect in one unique

thing.

Statements

In education, Liberians used to come

here. Even Mugabe from Zimbabwe came

here to attend university. Liberians would

come, Sierra Leoneans would come, and

Nigerians would come. What is it that we

can do to maintain this?

Mr Speaker, because of time, I may not

want to go into details. But as a country, we

should not just be quick in thinking that if

I travel outside the country to another

country, I can achieve educational

excellence. People came here and went

back and became the Presidents of their

countries. So let us develop our educational

sector and we will boost educational

tourism. Let us develop our health sector

and we shall boost health tourism. Let us

develop our markets in the whole West

Africa and we shall boost commercial

tourism. It is on that note that the previous

Administration under John Mahama

established the Kejetia Market with about

10,000 stores. It has no co-equal in the

West African sub-region. That is tourism.

Mr Speaker, in fact, we have people

who travel from Mauritania to Kejetia,

from Nigeria to Kejetia, from Sierra Leone

to Kejetia, and from Niger to Kejetia. That

is why we have Alabar in Kumasi. My

brother from Kumasi would tell you.

Mr Speaker, with all these things, we

have done well as a country and there is

still much to be done. In terms of tourism,

Ghana has a very good potential to improve

upon it and I believe that with the Tourism

Development Levy, we can go far.

Thank you, Mr Speaker, for the

opportunity.

Deputy Majority Leader (Mr

Alexander Kwamena Afenyo-Markin):

Mr Speaker, thank you for the opportunity.

I am going to make few comments on the

two Statements and limit myself to the

dictates of Order 72.

Mr Speaker, our Hon Colleague from

Jomoro delivered her Statement with deep

nostalgia and ended with these veritable

words which I shall proceed to quote:

“On that score, Mr Speaker, I would like to end my tribute to the late Hon

Mensah with an assurance to the good

people of Jomoro that although the

late Hon Mensah may have departed

his remarkable legacies live on and

shall be protected by those of us

who now walk in his illustrious

shoes”.

Mr Speaker, she could not have put it

better than this. Sometimes, we get onto the

seats and we forget about all the good

things that people have done. From

everything she said, I think I found this

most striking that she is willing and,

determined to walk in the remarkable

Statements

legacies this Hon gentleman left. Indeed,

his has joined the parliament above where

debates would continue. I think that all of

us as Members of Parliament must take a

cue and remember the good things that our

predecessors did and honour the

contributions of others who have had their

bites in the public political space. And

above all, we should also be mindful that

one day, the principle of six feet would

reduce us also to the same state. The Mason

would say,

“The ground level of all human greatness shall reduce us to the same

state.”

I would not bore you, Mr Speaker, since

we do not have time.

Then Mr Speaker, if we go to our friend

who delivered the Statement on tourism for

the first time, we are hearing of an Hon

Colleague telling us about the potential in

his area. Can all of us take turns to tell the

world? This is because when we meet here

at this plenary, it is not only us; the world

is watching us. Can we tell the world about

what we have in our various communities?

I agree with the Hon Member for

Odododiodoo when he commented to the

effect that these days, we seemed to have

forgotten about our own backyard and we

are exploring tourism elsewhere and

adding on to the foreign exchange of other

countries.

Mr Speaker, sometimes in our homes,

because of the little pump and ease, we

even forget to speak our Ghanaian

languages with our children. That in itself

is dangerous. Mr Speaker, I must confess

that recently, I had the occasion to

reprimand my own daughter and caution

her not to speak back in English else she

would not have the opportunity of going

where she wants to go. She would stay

here. It is sad.

So, Mr Speaker, we must market our

own country and having heard the Hon

Member for Sissala West talk about his

constituency, I would say that Effutu is

right here. Its capital is Winneba and that is

why when the opportunity came and with

your support, I carried ECOWAS to

Winneba. I wanted Members of the sub-

regional Parliament to know that it does not

only happen in Accra. So if you go to

Winneba today, you would first meet the

Reconciliation Roundabout, J. B. Danquah

and Kwame Nkrumah posthumously

reconciling with a hand shake. So that is

what we greet our visitors with.

Then you enter and meet the Unity

Square. From the Unity Square is the

Osimpam Heritage Centre. Then you turn

westward towards the Police College.

Down the coast, you see the beautiful

beach with the ocean smiling at you with

its melodic sounds greeting you. You

would also see the Koshiwa Village. We

Statements

are remembering the Ewe community that

settled there and did drag-net fishing and

by the way, they voted overwhelmingly for

me. We have done a nice fishermen's square, which you would meet there. Then

you go and meet the Ofarnyi Kwegya

square. These are all things that boosts the

tourism potential of the capital of the

constituency.

Mr Speaker, above all, apart from the

Winneba Youth Choir with their choral

music, we have the Winneba Masquerade

Festival, which we celebrate on the 1st of

January of every year. We started this in

1957 and we have been celebrating it.

These are things that I am sure many

people know about but today, I am letting

the world know that on the 1st of January

each year, they should not remain in their

homes. They should come to Winneba after

their 31st night prayers and there, they

would enjoy the Winneba Masquerade

Festival.

Mr Speaker, I thank you for your kind

opportunity and for granting me the

audience, and we thank Hon Members for

a well-rearched Statement, particularly by

the Hon Member for Sissala West. I would

want to read over the Statement again and

I would make meaning out of it for future

debate.

I thank you, Mr Speaker.
Mr Speaker 4:19 p.m.
Let me also thank Hon
Members for the rich Statements,
comments and contributions. This
happened to be the day for the products of
the Guans. Those two gentlemen and the
lady who made the Statements are likely to
be the offspring of the Guans which is a
very large ethnic group in Ghana. One of
the early settlers in the land called Ghana
are the Guans. That is why the Sissalas
sometimes understand the language of the
Nzemas and the Nkonyas and others.
They are all from the Guan tribe, which
is a tribe that moved around 700 AD towards the Savannah area. So, Hon Members need to
learn all this. We would create space for many
Members to do research and come out with rich
Statements, so that we can correct the errors of
history. What we have in our books as the
history of this country is a myopic
misrepresentation from political perspectives
of what Ghana is.
I have had time and read through, and I
know a lot about Windy bay, which is now
called Winneba. So, the Hon Member just gave
us a bit about the pretence of our early
founding fathers who said they were
reconciling and that cycle was done. But did
they really reconcile? They polarised our
politics and introduced bitterness, and that is
still enslaving some of us, and we carry it along
even till today. That should give way to a new
Ghana.

Statements

So, we will create this opportunity for Hon

Members. Let us correct the errors of the past.

I am happy that today, there are some snippets

of encouraging Statements from Hon Members

about looking forward, not getting stuck, and

not having a gridlock as we have in the country

now. It is because of this gridlock that there is

not much Business before us. We cannot move.

So, we would have space for Hon Members to

make such Statements. Let us solve that

problem as the Leaders of the country.

We are only political leaders of the country.

There are traditional and spiritual leaders, and

we have the media, which is the voice of the

people. So, there is a complete distribution of

power. That power of voice is with the media

and the political power is with us. That is only

divided into the Executive power, which is

handled by the Executive. They execute,

implement, and they are the agent we have put

together to develop, but the main engine is this

House, Parliament, because we represent the

people, and they represent the State, not the

people. That is why Hon Members of

Parliament are called representatives of the

people -- Senior prefect, I have feedback -- I know about that.

So, it is important for us to recognise this.

Let us initiate the legislation. We have the

power to make the law and not the Executive.

It is because of the weakness of Parliament that

they were initiating most of the legislations.

They have the opportunity as stated in the 1992

Constitution to do so, but that does not prevent

us from initiating legislation in every area of

our human life. In some areas when we initiate

legislation, it has to pass through the

Executive; those are the public Bills. We will

make the laws, not them.

In the case that we are talking about the

media, let us look at the laws, revise them, and

let us strengthen the National Media

Commission. I have been here since 1993, and

every year, there is a Statement on the media.

We talk and shift the blame on some other

people. This House must legislate on it; we

should not wait. I am directing the Committee

to take that up and get some of them to sponsor

it. Parliament will support them to reach out to

the other stakeholders for us to relook at the

laws that we passed in the early days of our

democracy. We should ensure that what we

want today is what is captured by the law, and

then we will all follow so that we do not

continue to change our tongues depending on

which seat one is seated. With this, I would

want to plead with all of you to stand up and

give our former Hon Colleague the due respect

by wishing him a safe and peaceful passage.

One minute silence, please.

Hon Members, may the soul of the late Hon

James Van Leuven Mensah and the souls of all

the faithful departed rest in perfect peace.

Amen. Hon Members, with this, I am sure I

have your kind permission to adjourn the

House. I will not be available tomorrow; I will

be busy trying to solve some problems to help

the House move forward. So, the Hon Second

Deputy Speaker will be presiding. With your

kind permission -- Unless you would want us to adjourn till about 4.00 p.m., then I would be

available.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 4:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, there is
nothing useful on the Floor, and there is no
other competent parliamentary Business to be
considered for today. We are entirely in your
hands, save that adjournment should be taken
subject to us coming back at 10.00 a.m. in
accordance with your directive as the Hon
Second Deputy Speaker to take the Chair.
Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 4:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I agree
with my Hon Colleague. I would like to add
that last week Friday, a directive was given by
the Chair that the Leadership, together with the
Ministry of Finance and the Administrator of
the Common Fund, should reconcile the
figures on the District Assemblies' Common Fund (DACF) with the Local Government and
Rural Development, and report back to the
House next Tuesday, but today is Thursday.
So, once we are adjourning, the Hon Deputy
Majority Leader should take a cue. Tomorrow
is our last working day, so we must be able to
convey that meeting and generate a report, so
that on Tuesday, we can brief the Chair -- [Interruption] -- I have been hinted by the Ranking Member for the Committee on Local
Government and Rural Development that even
the reporting day should have been the past
Tuesday. We have not been able to do the
assignment that was given to us.
Mr Speaker, if the Hon Deputy Majority
Leader could liaise with the Ministers, so that
we can do that quickly and report back to the
House, so that the tension on the releases of
DACF will be brought to finality.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 4:19 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
sentiments, having been regularly
communicated, same shall be conveyed.
Mr Speaker 4:19 p.m.
Hon Members, the
information at my disposal -- this is not to discourage the Committee from doing their
work -- if something is not done within the next three months, Government may not even
be able to pay salaries. So, we have to take
leadership; we have to do a lot of things.
With this, the House is adjourned till
Friday, 25th February, 2022 at 10 o'clock in the forenoon.
ADJOURNMENT 4:19 p.m.