Debates of 27 May 2022

MR SPEAKER
PRAYERS 10:14 a.m.

Mr Speaker 10:14 a.m.
Hon Members, I have no
message from H.E. the President, and I
also do not have any formal commu also
do not have any formal communication,
and so we would move on to the item
numbered 4 on the Order Paper, which is
the Correction of Votes and Proceedings
and the Official Report.
Votes and Proceedings and the
Official Report
Mr Speaker 10:14 a.m.
Hon Members, we would
start with the correction of the Votes and
Proceedings of Thursday, 26th May,
2022.
Page 1 ... 15.
Hon Members, in the absence of any
correction — my usher has just brought to me a Message from H.E. the President,
and so before I put the Question on the
Correction of the Votes and Proceedings,
let me just read the Message.
ANNOUNCEMENTS 10:14 a.m.

  • [No correction was made to the Votes and Proceedings of Thursday, 26th May, 2022]
  • [No correction was made the Official Report of Wednesday, 23rd March, 2022.]
  • Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 10:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, you
    are right. It is true that our Hon
    Colleagues on the other Side will be
    having their regional elections tomorrow
    and the day after.
    Mr Speaker, as the Leader of Govern-
    ment Business, the Hon Majority Leader
    together with Leadership should have
    programmed very well to be able to know
    whether Business would be light today so
    that the Hon Members including the
    public, would be aware that Business
    would be light on Friday as a result of
    this.
    However, to keep the public in suspense
    and go to his constituency as the Leader
    of Government Business, and be speaking
    on radio — when we come here to do Business, then he would go and respond
    through the radio. I say this for obvious
    reasons and when he comes, we would all
    learn from him.
    VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:24 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 10:24 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Majority Chief
    Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 10:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    just want to give a quick response to the
    observation made by my Hon Colleague.
    First of all, I would want to show
    gratitude and deference to you, for the
    recognition of the template in terms of
    arrangements for regional elections
    across the country and the caucus is very
    grateful. I do not think there would be a
    justifiable reason for us to state in our
    work programme that as a result of a
    regional elections due, Business would be
    light. No. For the period we have been in
    this House, even in the face of our internal
    arrangements to elections, we have
    always found a way to deal with these
    matters. However, my Hon Colleague
    would recognise that if you look at the
    Business of the House that was presented
    early on, the Business was light and this
    was because at the Business Committee,
    Hon Members had recognised that
    because of the eminent exercise ahead of
    us, we needed to be informed and
    therefore, plan a light programme. So, it
    was consciously done and I am aware my
    Hon Colleague knows about it and should
    not raise the temperature unnecessarily
    this morning.
    Mr Speaker, I also heard him make
    comments about the Hon Majority Leader
    and the good news is that he did not go
    into details so I do not have to respond to
    that and I am sure that at Leadership level,
    we would be able to deal with it.
    So, we are grateful for the recognition
    of the days we have the elections and we
    hope it would be peaceful and we are also
    praying — we know that very soon they would have theirs. So far, it has been
    peaceful at the polling stations
    [interruption] —
    Mr Speaker, it has been extremely
    peaceful from the polling stations through
    the electoral area to the constituencies.
    They should take a cue from what we
    have done and not to raise the
    temperature unnecessarily in this country
    because of internal elections where we
    hear people chasing others. I hope my
    Hon Colleague, who is a very good critic,
    would take a cue and ensure that in
    VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:24 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 10:24 a.m.
    Hon Members, politics is
    actually a serious national business and
    the quality of the politics, particularly
    with regards to the health of political
    parties, seriously impinge on the gover-
    nance of the country. So, we should take
    our political parties seriously because
    they are very strong pillars of the gover-
    nance of the country. It is important that
    we factor that in, particularly, in whatever
    we do as a House, and I would want to call
    on all Ghanaians to take this seriously.
    The second point I would want to raise
    is that Leaders of the House, as I just said,
    they are Leaders of the House and they
    support the Rt Hon Speaker who is the
    Leader of Parliament, not just the Leader
    of the House but of Parliament and
    Parliament goes beyond the House. It is
    an institution and an arm of Government
    and the spokesperson for Parliament is
    the Rt Hon Speaker. The Hon Majority
    Leader speaks for the House which is
    made up of the Hon Members of Parlia-
    ment and Parliament includes the Parlia-
    mentary Service and the supporting insti-
    tutions like health, the Police Service, the
    Fire Service, the National Security and
    other State Institutions that render
    services to Parliament. This is the arm of
    Government called Parliament as an
    institution.
    In fact, in the United Kingdom (UK), it
    is made up of the Queen, the House of
    Lords and the House of Commons; that is
    the institution of Parliament and that is
    why it is sovereign. Well, it is inclusive
    of even the Queen. The Prime Minister is
    part of the House of Commons and so, he
    is part of Parliament and Parliament is
    supreme.
    In Ghana, Parliament is not supreme; it
    is subject to the Constitution, so it is
    important that when the Rt Hon Speaker
    speaks from the Chair, the Leader of the
    House, who is the Leader of the Hon
    Members of Parliament, is not seen to be
    the one countering what the spokesperson
    of the arm of Government says. If he
    wants us to give documentary evidence
    about the non-funding of the House for
    this year, we would provide them. When
    I heard that the Leader of the House has
    gone on air to say that what I said is not
    true, it saddens me.
    In response to what I said yesterday, the
    Government quickly proceeded to release money yesterday to enable the House function. There is evidence to that and that is on record. I would not take the Hon Majority Leader always going on air to counter what I say, particularly when I say it on the Chair. I would not take that. I am in control here and I would continue to be in control until my term of Office ends or you decide otherwise as Hon
    VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:24 a.m.

    BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE 10:34 a.m.

    Chairman of the Business Committee) 10:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am grateful for your indulgence, and I am doing this on behalf of the Hon Majority Leader.
    Mr Speaker, your Committee met
    yesterday, Monday, 26th May, 2022, and
    arranged Business of the House for the
    second Week ending Friday, 3rd June,
    2022.
    Mr Speaker, the Committee accor-
    dingly submits its Report as follows:
    Arrangement of Business
    Formal Communications by the Speaker
    Mr Speaker, you may read any available
    communication to the House.
    Questions
    Mr Speaker, the Business Committee
    has scheduled the following Hon
    Ministers to respond to Questions asked
    of them during the week:
    No. of Questions
    i. Minister for Education 12
    ii. Minister for Works and Housing 6
    iii. Minister for Communication &
    Digitalisation 8
    iv. Minister for Finance 16
    v. Minister for Roads and Highways 8
    Total number of Questions
    50
    VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:34 a.m.

    Mr Abdulai Jacob Iddriss (Savelugu) 10:34 a.m.
    To ask the Minister for Education what
    steps his Ministry is taking to resolve the
    problems faced by students of the Savelugu
    Senior High School that resulted in a
    strike action on 19th February this year.
    Questions —
    Q. 193. Mr Samuel Atta-Mills
    (Komenda/Edina/Eguafo/Abrem): To
    ask the Minister for Education why the
    Business of the House

    “E-block” at Ntranoa in the Komenda Edina Eguafo Abrem Constituency is

    abandoned at 80 per cent completion, and

    what plans does the Ministry have for the

    structure.

    Q. 267. Mr Isaac Adjei Mensah

    (Wassa East): To ask the Minister for

    Education when the 6-Unit Classroom

    Block (GETFund) project in Sekyere

    Hemang, the 3-Unit Classroom Block

    (GETFund) project in Akrofi, and the 3-

    Unit Classroom Block (GETFund)

    project in Kwafokrom in the Wassa East

    District will be completed.

    Q. 268. Mr Abukari Dawuni (Wulensi): To ask the Minister for Education

    whether there are plans to complete the E-

    block project at Nakpayili in the Wulensi

    Constituency, meant for a Community

    Day Senior High School.

    Q. 270. Mr Adama Sulemana (Tain):

    To ask the Minister for Education

    whether there are any plans to construct

    administration blocks for the following

    Senior High Schools in the Tain

    Constituency: (i) Badu Secondary

    Technical Senior High School (ii)

    Nsawkaw State Senior High School (iii)

    Menyi Agriculture Senior High School.

    Q. 697. Mr Davis Ansah Opoku

    (Mpraeso): To ask the Minister for

    Education what activities the Ministry is

    executing to increase reading compre-

    hension among children in the country in

    light of World Bank data which reveals

    that 87 per cent of 10-year olds in sub-

    Saharan Africa cannot read and

    understand adequately.

    Q. 698. Mr Davis Ansah Opoku

    (Mpraeso): To ask the Minister for

    Education what the Ministry is doing to

    address the inadequate performance of

    Senior High School students, since the

    operationalisation of Junior High School

    as part of primary school education

    instead of secondary school is a

    contributor to their low performance.

    Q. 699. Ms Sheila Bartels (Ablekuma

    North): To ask the Minister for

    Education what measures the Ministry is

    putting in place to (a) curb the widespread

    reports of leaked examination papers; and

    (b) implement stringent mechanisms

    against such examination malpractice.

    Q. 700. Ms Sheila Bartels (Ablekuma

    North): To ask the Minister for

    Education what reforms are being

    instituted to empower students to explore

    and easily diversify their educational

    careers through a more flexible curricula

    and overall education system.

    Q. 701. Mr Sylvester Tetteh

    (Bortianor-Ngleshie Amanfro): To ask

    the Minister for Education how the

    Ministry plans to address the major

    management challenge of school

    Business of the House

    supervision, especially at the basic and

    secondary school levels.

    Q. 702. Mr Sylvester Tetteh

    (Bortianor-Ngleshie Amanfro): To ask

    the Minister for Education the meaning of

    the 90-90-90 Plan on Communities of

    Excellence which was mentioned at the

    National Education Week.

    Statements

    Presentation of Papers —

    (a) Fourth Report of the Committee of Selection on the composition

    of other Standing and Select

    Committees.

    (b) Report of the Committee on

    Mines and Energy on the Request

    for parliamentary ratification for

    Ghana's Membership to the African Petroleum Producers' Organisation (APPO).

    (c) Budget Performance Report in

    Respect of the Ministry of Trade

    and Industry for the period

    January to December 2021.

    (d) Annual Statement by the Audit

    Committee of the Fanteakwa

    North District Assembly for the

    year 2020.

    Motions —

    (a) That this honourable House adopts the Investigative Report of

    the Committee on Defence and

    Interior on the Incident of the

    Military-Civilian Brutality in Wa.

    (b) That this honourable House constitute a bi-partisan Com-

    mittee to probe the circumstances

    leading to the death of Madam

    Augustina Awortwe, who died in

    an ambulance when she was

    being transported from Holy

    Child Catholic Hospital at Fijai

    near Takoradi in the Western

    Region to Korle Bu Teaching

    Hospital, Accra on the 4th of

    January, 2022 (Alhaji Mohammed-

    Mubarak Muntaka; Mr Kwabena

    Mintah Akandoh; Dr Mark Kurt

    Nawaane; Mrs. Elizabeth Ofosu

    Adjare).

    Committee sittings

    Questions —

    Q. 355. Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey (Keta): To ask the Minister for Works

    and Housing the measures the Ministry is

    taking to strengthen the Rent Control

    Department to perform its lawful duties.

    Business of the House

    Q.379. Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey (Keta): To ask the Minister for Works

    and Housing the efforts the Ministry is

    making to enforce the law on Leasing

    Assets in accordance with the Rent

    Control Act.

    Q.380. Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey (Keta): To ask the Minister for Works

    and Housing the steps the Ministry is

    taking to address the issue of house

    owners taking more than six months' rent advance from tenants before renting out

    their properties in contravention of the

    Rent Act, 1963 (Act 220).

    Q.986. Mr Yusif Sulemana (Bole/ Bamboi): To ask the Minister for Works

    and Housing who the occupants of the

    UNDP Flats in Cantonments are and

    whether or not they pay rent to

    Government.

    Q. 1084. Mrs Abla Dzifa Gomashie

    (Ketu South): To ask the Minister for

    Works and Housing the status of the

    Phase II of the Blekusu Sea Defense Wall

    in the Ketu South Municipality.

    Q.1120. Ms Dakoa Newman (Okaikwei

    South): To ask the Minister for Works

    and Housing when the final phase of the

    storm drain at Kokompe in Okaikwei

    South Constituency will be completed.

    Statements

    Presentation of Papers —

    (a) Annual Statement by the Audit

    Committee of the Ghana College

    of Nurses & Midwives for the

    year 2021.

    (b) Annual Statement by the Audit

    Committee of the Ashanti

    Regional Coordinating Council

    for the year 2020.

    Motions —

    (a) That this honourable House

    adopts the Report of the Finance

    Committee on the Annual Public

    Debt Management Report for the

    2020 Financial Year.

    (Moved on Thursday, 4th November,

    2021 by the Hon Chairman of the Finance

    Committee, Mr Kwaku Agyeman

    Kwarteng and seconded by the Hon

    Member for Ajumako/Enyan/Essiam, Dr

    Cassiel Ato Baah Forson)

    — Debate to Conclude

    (b) That this honourable House

    adopts the Report of the Finance

    Committee on the Request for

    parliamentary ratification of the

    Charter Establishing the Eastern

    Business of the House

    and Southern African Trade and

    Development Bank (TDB Charter).

    — Consequential Resolution

    (c) That this honourable House

    adopts the Report of the Finance

    Committee on the Financing

    Agreement between the

    Government of the Republic of

    Ghana (represented by the

    Ministry of Finance) and the

    European Investment Bank (EIB)

    for an amount of seventy-five

    million euros (€75,000,000.00) for the COVID-19 Health

    Response Ghana Project.

    — Consequential Resolution

    (d) That this honourable House

    passes a Vote of Censure on the

    Honourable Minister Responsible

    for Health, Mr Kwaku

    Agyemang-Manu in respect of

    the following conduct:

    i. Undertake International busi- ness or Economic Trans-

    action (procurement and

    supply of vaccines) as

    Minister of Health with the

    Private Officer of His

    Highness, Sheik Ahmed

    Dalmook Al Maktoum

    without prior approval of

    Parliament; contrary to article

    181 of the 1992 Constitution

    of the Republic of Ghana.

    ii. Signing Procurement Agree- ment with the Private Office

    of His Highness, Sheik

    Ahmend Dalmook Al

    Maktoum and S.L. Global Ltd

    without prior approval of the

    Board of the Public

    Procurement Authority under

    sections 40 and 41 of the

    Public Procurement Act, 2003

    (Act 663) as amended by Act

    914 which constitutes Crimi-

    nal Offence under the law.

    iii. Dishonest Procurement of Sputnik-V vaccines from the

    Private Office of His High-

    ness, Sheik Ahmend Dalmook

    Al Maktoum and S.L. Global

    Ltd at the cost of US$19.00

    and US$18.5 respectively

    when the ex-factory price of

    the Sputnik-V vaccine generally

    announced was US$10

    confirmed by the Minister to

    the Committee Responsible

    for Health.

    iv. Knowingly procuring Sputnik- V vaccine from Private Office

    of His Highness, Sheik

    Ahmed Dalmook Al

    Maktoum and S.L. Global Ltd

    at the cost of US$19.00 and

    Business of the House

    US$18.5 respectively per

    dose. Nevertheless, informs

    the Committee responsible for

    Health that the ex-factory

    price of the Sputnik-V does

    not exceed US$10.00 per

    dose.

    v. Causing payment in the sum of US$2,850,000.00 (Cedi

    equivalent of GH

    ¢16,331,640.00) to the Private

    Office of His Highness, Sheik

    Ahmed Dalmook Al

    Maktoum under void

    agreement with the Private

    Office of His Highness, Sheik

    Ahmed Dalmook Al

    Maktoum, yet fibbed and

    misrepresented to the Ad Hoc

    Committee on Oaths that no

    payment was made under the

    Agreement to the Private

    Office of His Highness, Sheik

    Ahmed Dalmook Al

    Maktoum and thereby

    committing a crime to wit

    perjury.

    vi. The above conduct, being in direct breach of the Consti-

    tution and laws passed by this

    honourable House, the

    Minister of Health be

    removed from office as

    Minister by a Vote of Censure

    passed in accordance with

    article 82 of the Constitution.

    (Mr James Klutse Avedzi; Alhaji

    Mohammed-Mubarak Muntaka; Mr

    Ahmed Ibrahim; and others).

    Committee sittings

    Urgent Question —

    Mr Abed-Nego Azumah Bandim

    (Bunkpurugu): To ask the Minister for

    Communications and Digitalisation what

    measures the Ministry will put in place to

    stop the extortion of money from

    residence of Nakpanduri and Bimbagu by

    officers undertaking the ongoing SIM

    card re-registration exercise.

    Mrs Lydia Lamisi Akanvariba

    (Tempane): To ask the Minister for

    Communications and Digitalisation what

    urgent steps the Ministry is taking to

    reduce the overcrowding at SIM

    registration centres across the country.

    Questions —

    *260. Ms Lydia Lamisi Akanvariba

    (Tempane): To ask the Minister for

    Communications and Digitalisation the

    importance of the SIM card re-

    registration exercise.

    Business of the House

    Q. 261. Ms Lydia Lamisi Akanvariba

    (Tempane): To ask the Minister for

    Communications and Digitalisation what

    urgent steps the Ministry is taking to get

    the Data Protection Commission (DPC) a

    permanent structure, and how much the

    Ministry pays for the current office

    location every year.

    Q. 263. Mr Wisdom Gidisu (Krachi

    East): To ask the Minister for

    Communications and Digitalisation when

    the following communities in the Krachi

    East Constituency will be connected to

    telephone communication network: (i)

    Pai Old Town (ii) Motoway (iii)

    Kofimango (iv) Jerusalem (v)

    Amuzukope (vi) Sikape (vii) Yaborai

    (viii) Mempeasem.

    Q. 264. Dr Clement A. Apaak (Builsa

    South): To ask the Minister for

    Communications and Digitalisation the

    plans in place to immediately improve

    mobile telephony in the following

    communities in the Builsa South

    Constituency: (i) Doninga (ii) Bachangba

    (iii) Tepala (iv) Uwasi (iv) Wiesi (v)

    Gbedembilisi (vi) Chansa (vii) Gobsa.

    Q. 811. Mr Daniel Ohene Darko (Upper Denkyira West): To ask the

    Minister for Communications and Digi-

    talisation when the Ghana Investment

    Fund for Electronic Communications

    (GIFEC) project in the following

    communities will be completed: (i)

    Jameso Nkwanta (ii) Nyinawusu (iii)

    Besease (iv) Brofoyedu (v) Treposo

    Q.812. Mr Kwadjo Asante (Suhum): To ask the Minister for Communicaitons

    and Digitalisation when the network

    system in the following communities

    would be completed: (i) Dawa (ii) Nsuta

    Wawase (iii) Otwebediadua (iv) Gorjiase

    (v) Zorh (vi) Praprababida (vii)

    Aponoapono (viii) Adidiso (ix)

    Tetekasum (x) Obomofodensua.

    Statements

    Presentation of Papers —

    Budget Performance Report in Respect

    of the Office of Special Prosecutor for the

    Period January to December 2021.

    Motions —

    (a) That this honourable House

    constitutes a bi-partisan Com-

    mittee chaired by a Member of

    the Minority Caucus to:

    (i) investigate the conduct of the

    confirmation or approval

    process by the various

    Assemblies of the President's nominees for the position of

    Chief Executive for the

    Metropolitan, Municipal, and

    District Assemblies (MMDAs)

    in the following Assemblies: (i)

    Business of the House

    Sekyere/Kumawu (ii) Assin

    South (iii) Cape Coast (iv)

    Awutu Senya West (v) Sefwi-

    Bekwai-Anhwiaso (vi) Juaboso

    (vii) Shama, and any other

    Assembly where violence or

    disruption occurred;

    (ii) enquire into the circumstances

    leading to the deployment of huge

    numbers of police and other

    security personnel who obstructed

    or prevented some Honourable

    Assembly Members from partici-

    pating in the voting process, and

    Members of Parliament from

    witnessing the exercise as ex-

    officio members;

    (iii) determine whether laid down

    procedures were followed or

    abuses occurred during the

    process; and

    (iv) make consequential recommend-

    dations for the consideration of

    the House. (Mr Edwin Nii Lantey

    Vanderpuye; Mr Benjamin

    Komla Kpodo; Mr James

    Agalga).

    (b) That this honourable House constitute a Bi-partisan parlia-

    mentary Committee chaired by a

    member of the Minority to:

    (i) Review thoroughly the processes

    and procedures adopted by the

    Electoral Commission in the 2020

    Presidential and Parliamentary

    Elections;

    (ii) Enquire into the circumstances

    that led to the use of a form other

    than the statutorily provided

    Statement of Poll Form (Form A

    and B) in the Schedule to the

    Public Elections Regulations,

    2020 (C.I. 127) by the Electoral

    Commission in the 2020 presi-

    dential and parliamentary elections;

    (iii) Ascertain the quantity of ballot

    papers printed and the discovery

    of excess ballot papers at Innolink

    Printing Press Limited;

    (iv) Inquire into the allegation that the

    Electoral Commission introduced

    ballot papers that were pre-

    thumb-printed and bore the stamp

    of the Commission into the

    system, specifically in the Ashanti

    Region;

    (v) Enquire into the manner in which

    the collation of the election results

    was carried out by officers of the

    Electoral Commission leading to

    multiple declaration of results in

    various Constituencies;

    Business of the House

    (vi) Establish the causes of the

    disturbances and electoral

    violence during the counting and

    collation at Ablekuma Central,

    Banda, Kasoa, Odododiodioo,

    Sefwi-Wiawso, Techiman South

    and in any other place the

    disturbances occurred;

    (vii) Verify the claim by the Electoral

    Commission that it saved the

    nation about US$90 million and

    that the 2020 elections were the

    least costly of all previous

    elections held in the Country

    since 1992;

    (viii) Investigate the alleged procure-

    ment breaches in the Thales

    contract for the biometric

    Verification Devices; and

    (ix) Make consequential recommend-

    dations for the consideration of

    the House within two months.

    (Alhaji Mohammed-Mubarak

    Muntaka; Dr Dominic Akuritinga

    Ayine; Mr Bernard Ahiafor; Mr

    Kofi Adams; and Ms Zuwera

    Mohammed Ibrahimah).

    (c) That this Honourable House adopts the Fourth Report of the

    Committee of Selection on the

    composition of other Standing

    and Select Committees.

    Committee sittings

    Urgent Questions —
    Mr Godfred Seidu Jasaw (Wa East) 10:34 a.m.
    To ask the Minister for Finance when the
    Ministry will issue financial clearance to
    the Ministry of Food and Agriculture to
    clear the large debt owed partners and
    suppliers to ensure availability of subsi-
    dised fertiliser in this farming season.
    Ms Sheila Bartels (Ablekuma North) 10:34 a.m.
    To ask the Minister for Finance the
    current status of funding for the
    construction of Phase II of the Tema
    Motorway, which has been highlighted as
    a major issue for commuters.
    Mr Sylvester Tetteh (Bortianor-
    Ngleshie Amanfro): To ask the Minister
    for Finance the interventions the Ministry
    is employing to clamp the sustained
    increments in fuel prices as witnessed in
    the recent pricing windows.
    Mr Edward Abambire Bawa
    (Bongo): To ask the Minister for Finance
    what the Ministry is doing to slow down
    the increases of petroleum product prices
    at pumps with respect to imposed taxes
    and levies on petroleum products and the
    depreciation of the Cedi.
    Business of the House

    Questions —

    Q.236. Mr Vincent Oppong Asamoah

    (Dormaa West): To ask the Minister for Finance whether the Ministry would consider sourcing additional funding for infrastructural development at the University of Energy and Natural Resources (UENR) in Sunyani just like it was done in respect of the University of Health and Allied Sciences (UHAS) in Ho, the University of Environment and Sustainable Development at Somanya, and recently for the proposed university at Bunso.

    Q.383. Mr George Kweku Ricketts-

    Hagan (Cape Coast South): To ask the Minister for Finance which companies were used as Local Transaction Advisors and Local Legal Advisors for the 2021 Eurobond and how much they were paid in fees as individual companies.

    Q.384. Mr George Kweku Ricketts-

    Hagan (Cape Coast South): To ask the Minister for Finance how much Government has realised (net proceeds) from the Eurobond issued in 2021, and how much it has spent on fees and related roadshow expenses.

    Q.385. Mr Murtala Muhammed

    Ibrahim (Tamale Central): To ask the Minister for Finance how much revenue the State generated from the sale of power to neighbouring countries.

    Q. 386. Ms Theresa Lardi Awuni (Okaikwei North): To ask the Minister for Finance how much was raised in total from Government Bonds since 2017, who the transaction advisors and book runners were since 2017, and how much was paid to each of the transaction advisors and book runners since 2017.

    Q. 675. Mr Frank Annoh-

    Dompreh (Nsawam-Adoagyiri): To ask the Minister for Finance how the 2022 budget will ensure that all the major issues of increased taxes, increased fuel prices and unmaintained roads which were raised during the course of 2021 will be tackled efficiently.

    Q. 676. Dr Stephen Amoah (Nhyiaeso):

    To ask the Minister for Finance the plans the Government has established through the Ministry of Finance to reduce the debt stock which stood at 76.1 per cent in the first half of this year.

    Q. 677. Mr Kwadjo Asante (Suhum):

    To ask the Minister for Finance if the Government, through the Ministry's work plan, intends to return to the International Monetary Fund for financial assistance.

    Q.678. Mr Collins Adomako-Mensah

    (Afigya Kwabre North): To ask the Minister for Finance what assurance the Ministry can give in response to the widely held concern that Government has abandoned projects started by previous administrations.

    Business of the House

    Q.679. Ms Dakoa Newman (Okaikwei

    South): To ask the Minister for Finance

    the progress and impact of the Ghana

    CARES programme as well as the plans

    to raise a US$100 billion fund through a

    Government-Private collaboration, all

    aimed at revitalising the economy post

    COVID-19.

    Q. 680. Mr Frank Annoh-Dompreh

    (Nsawam-Adoagyiri): To ask the

    Minister for Finance how much has been

    invested in fighting COVID-19 and what

    gains are attributable to the investments

    made so far in respect of economic

    recovery.

    Q. 681. Mr Paul Apreku Twum-

    Barimah (Dormaa East): To ask the

    Minister for Finance the measures the

    Ministry has in place to ensure that the

    creation of one (1) million jobs stated in

    the mid-year budget is achieved, in light

    of the current indication that the

    Government payroll is full.

    Q. 485. Mr Suhuyini Alhassan Sayibu

    (Tamale North): To ask the Minister for

    Roads and Highways when the storm

    drain from Naaluro Estate through

    Gumani, Kalpohini to Fuo and Taha in

    the Tamale North Constituency will be

    constructed to protect residents from the

    yearly floods they endure.

    Q. 613. Mr Kofi Arko Nokoe (Evalue

    Ajomoro Gwira): To ask the Minister

    for Roads and Highways the plans the

    Ministry has to construct a bridge over

    River Ankobra for communities on the

    Wiaso - Maham stretch to link the southern part of the Constituency to the

    northern part which is the economic

    power house.

    Q.641. Mrs Gizella Tetteh-Agbotui

    (Awutu-Senya West): To ask the

    Minister for Roads and Highways when

    the Awutu Township roads will be

    completed.

    Q. 715. Mr John Kwabena Bless Oti

    (Nkwanta North): To ask the Minister

    for Roads and Highways when the

    following roads in the Nkwanta North

    Constituency would be awarded to

    contractors, since the estimates have been

    prepared and approved for several

    months now: (i) Kpassa - Tinjase (ii) Kpassa - Kabonwule.

    Q. 742. Dr Mark Kurt Nawaane (Nabdam): To ask the Minister for Roads

    and Highways the status of the Asonge - Zalerigu - Pelungu - Sakoti road, which was under construction but currently

    appears to have stopped.

    Q.743. Dr Mark Kurt Nawaane (Nabdam): To ask the Minister for Roads

    and Highways the status of the Kongo - Bongo Soe (Akayonga) road.

    Business of the House

    Q. 800. Mr Peter Lanchene Toobu (Wa West): To ask the Minister for Roads and Highways when emergency works will commence on the identified roads in Wa West that were washed away by the August 2021 floods.

    Q. 952. Mrs Della Sowah (Kpando):

    To ask the Minister for Roads and Highways what the Ministry's pro- gramme is for Kpando Town Roads, Gbefi Tornu Road, Torkor Road and Aloyi Roads.

    Statements

    Presentation of Papers —

    (i) Annual Report on Public Private

    Partnership Projects for the year

    2021.

    (ii) Annual Public Debt Report for the year 2021.

    (iii) Annual Report on the Manage- ment of the Energy Sector Levies and Accounts for Year 2021.

    Presentation and First Reading of Bills —

    Constitution of the Republic of Ghana (Amendment) Bill, 2021.

    Motions —

    That this honourable House constitutes,

    as a matter of urgency, a bi-partisan

    Committee to investigate allegations of

    irregularities, leakages of examination

    papers and related malpractices in

    examinations conducted by the West

    African Examinations Council (WAEC)

    for candidates of the West African Senior

    School Certificate Examination

    (WASSCE) from 2011 to 2021 and

    submit a report to this House for

    consideration.

    (Dr Clement Abas Apaak; Mr Peter

    Nortsu-Kotoe)

    Committee Sittings
    Mr Speaker 10:34 a.m.
    Hon Members, the
    Business Statement has been presented.
    Any comments from Hon Members? Let
    me start with Mr Kwame G. Agbodza
    before I recognise you, Mr Samuel O.
    Ablakwa.
    Mr Kwame Governs Agbodza 10:34 a.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, thank you for the opportunity,
    and I thank the Hon Majority Chief Whip
    for the presentation. Mr Speaker, I would
    also want to thank you for recognising the
    important role of political parties in
    shaping democracy in our country.
    Indeed, if the major political parties are
    conducting their internal re-organisation,
    it is a national issue and must be
    recognised as such. I would just want to
    plead with my Hon Colleagues on the
    other Side that when it is time for the
    National Democratic Congress (NDC) to
    do so, they must not table controversial
    Business of the House

    Businesses and claim that we were not

    here, especially on the Agyapa Mineral

    Royalties deal. Let it be on record that

    when we the NDC are conducting our

    elections, we would not table contro-

    versial deals.

    Mr Speaker, I would also want to

    comment on something. In light of the

    current issues regarding the transfer of the

    State's interest in part of Achimota Forest to private individuals and entities, I posed

    a Question to the Hon Minister for Lands

    and Natural Resources on the 3rd of

    March, 2022, asking him to provide to

    this House all landed properties

    belonging to the State that had been

    transferred to individuals and entities

    since 2017. I think it would provide the

    Hon Minister the opportunity to present

    that information to the House so that

    everybody would come to know of it

    because it may not only be about the

    Achimota Forest, it could be Atiwa Forest

    or Adaklu Mountain that has probably

    been transferred to somebody. So, I think

    we would want to encourage the Business

    Committee to see whether the Hon

    Minister for Lands and Natural Resources

    could appear before the House next week

    to answer my Question.

    Mr Speaker, there has also been an issue

    that I would want to seek your guidance

    on. Sometime ago, I had cause to ask the

    Hon Minister for Food and Agriculture to

    present to this House, the Report of the

    audit on cocoa roads which had been very

    topical in this country since 2017. The

    Government made the country aware that

    that audit had been concluded, and the

    Hon Minister appeared at the dispatch

    box here and said that he had presented

    that Report to the House.

    Mr Speaker, for the past six months, I

    have been looking through every part of

    Parliament to get a copy of that Report.

    Clerks-at-the-Table told me that they do

    not have a copy of the Report on Cocoa

    Roads Audit, and so I am craving your

    indulgence to direct the clerkship to see if

    they can get that Report as laid by the Hon

    Minister so that Hon Members can be

    given copies. It is very important to our

    Side of the House to be able to understand

    the content of that Report.

    This is because in that Report, we were

    told that road projects were awarded on

    roads that did not exist, and that is a

    serious matter. If the Report has been

    concluded, we would want to see which

    state actors acted wrongly by awarding

    road projects on roads which did not

    exist. Mr Speaker, that cannot be swept

    under the carpet; we take very serious

    view of this, and we wish that you would

    direct the clerkship to get a copy of that

    Report for Hon Members to peruse.

    Mr Speaker, I would want to thank you

    for the opportunity.

    Business of the House
    Mr Speaker 10:34 a.m.
    Yes Hon Member, would
    you want to make or respond to some
    comments?
    Mr Patrick Yaw Boamah 10:34 a.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, rightly so, I would want to make
    some comments.
    Mr Speaker 10:34 a.m.
    Hon Member, you can
    make your comments.
    Mr Boamah 10:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank you
    very much. For the past month, Accra and
    parts of the country have suffered from
    the rains, and out of the 50 Questions, I
    never saw anything earmarked for the
    Hon Minister for Works and Housing.
    I think I saw six Questions for the Hon
    Minister for Works and Housing, but I
    believe he must be summoned to this
    House to tell this country the strategies
    Government is putting in place to
    surmount some of the challenges that we
    have witnessed. Nima, the Kwame
    Nkrumah Circle, parts of Kumasi and
    parts of the Western Region have suffered
    from the rains. I believe it is about time
    that we got to hear from the Hon Minister
    for Works and Housing, the strategies of
    Government, if it is financing or technical
    issues. My Hon Colleague, Hon
    Agbodza, may give me a better rendition,
    but we would want the Hon Minister for
    Works and Housing to appear before this
    House to brief us about Government's programmes towards alleviating the
    plight of people within these
    communities.
    Mr Speaker, secondly, last week or
    sometime this week, the Hon Minister for
    National Security launched what he
    termed; “See Something, Say Some- thing” about terrorism and asked Ghanaians to be active and vigilant against the
    threats of terrorism. We believe that we
    are frontline people when it comes to
    getting key information to assist the
    national security architecture, and it is
    very important that the Hon Minister for
    National Security also appears before the
    House to talk to us and give us some leads
    and what he expects from Hon Members
    of Parliament. I saw the Leadership of the
    Majority and Hon Agalga at a meeting at
    the National Security headquarters. We
    believe that the Hon Minister must give
    us that hearing so that we would also
    assist him that regard.
    Mr Speaker, thank you very much.
    Mr Speaker 10:34 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Samuel
    Ablakwa, you caught my eye early on,
    but I think your issue has already been
    raised, so I would now go to the Senior
    Hon Member, Mr Cletus Avoka. I would
    later come to you.
    Mr Cletus Avoka 10:44 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, my
    concern is with item numbered v(a) at
    Business of the House

    page 2 of the Business of the House

    which reads: “…That this Hon House adopts the Investigative Report of the

    Committee on Defence and Interior on

    the Incident of the Military-Civilian

    Brutality in Wa.”

    Mr Speaker, we recall that your

    Committee on Defence and Interior

    actually took a trip to Wa to do an

    investigation for about two to three days

    and returned. We have written a Report

    which has been gathering dust in this

    august House for the past three to five

    months, and it is becoming embarrassing,

    if not scandalous. It would become stale

    and irrelevant if we do not take it.

    Mr Speaker, with the current spate of

    security, particularly police attacks on

    civilians and vice versa, if we had taken

    this Report, it might have extended the

    tide, and might have also drawn the

    attention of security services and civilians

    to the need for us to co-exist because we

    need each other. It might also have drawn

    the attention that these rampant attacks on

    other civilians or vice versa does not help

    this country in any way, particularly, with

    the threats that we are having from

    outside the country. So, Mr Speaker, I

    would want to crave your indulgence to

    direct the Hon Majority Leader to fix a

    day firmly for this Report to be taken.

    Tuesday may not be opportune because

    they may not be in the House, but

    probably, Wednesday or Thursday of

    next week would be fine. He should

    inform the relevant Hon Ministers, so that

    we take the Report when they are here, so

    that they could also support us with some

    contribution that would guide this august

    House and the security services that they

    head.

    Mr Speaker, also, in respect of this

    initiative of “See Something Say Something”, I support the Hon Member who just made the comment. Early this

    week, somewhere on Tuesday, Hon

    Members of the Defence and Interior

    Committee were within the premises of

    the National Security Ministry and took

    part in launching this laudable initiative,

    after which they implored the Minister to

    try and make a Statement on this august

    Floor, either yesterday or today, so that

    Hon Members would be aware of it, and

    since we come from various consti-

    tuencies, it would help us to address

    security situations in our respective

    constituencies. I believe he is busy now,

    and hence has not been able to make it,

    but if we could add it to the Wa Report

    and take both sometime next week, it

    would help this country in terms of

    security matters.

    Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Kofi Iddie Adams 10:44 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    your Committee responsible for Public
    Accounts just returned from the zonal
    engagements where they looked at the
    Business of the House

    Reports that concern the District

    Assemblies, especially, with regard to

    their Internally Generated Funds (IGF).

    One issue that kept coming up was the

    property rates and the systems and

    mechanisms they have put in place to

    increase their revenue from property

    rates.

    During the last Meeting, Mr Speaker,

    specifically, somewhere 22nd March,

    2022, the Hon Member for Agona East

    made a Statement in relation to

    centralisation of property rate collection,

    which generated a lot of debate in this

    House. The Hon Ministers present denied

    those facts and said that there was no

    intention to centralise the property rate

    collection. At the end of the Comments,

    as captured in the Official Report for 22nd

    March, 2022, column 35 to 69, the Hon

    First Deputy Speaker, who was in the

    Chair actually ordered that the Hon

    Minister for Local Government,

    Decentralisation and Rural Development

    should be scheduled to brief the House as

    to exactly what the Government intends

    to do with the issue of property rate

    because there was so much disagreement

    and so much concerns raised by Hon

    Members who contributed on that day.

    We have the Business of the House for

    the Second Week, and I have not seen any

    indication that the Hon Minister for Local

    Government, Decentralisation and Rural

    Development is being invited to give us a

    brief. There is commentary out there, and

    all of us coming from various districts,

    municipalities and metropolis are aware

    that some engagement is going on in

    relation to getting a group to be

    responsible for these property rates

    collection. Meanwhile, the House has not

    been briefed by the Hon Minister

    responsible for Local Government,

    Decentralisation and Rural Development.

    Mr Speaker, I am only requesting that if

    it is possible, the Business Committee

    should find space for the Hon Minister to

    brief the House as ordered by the Hon

    First Deputy Speaker, during our Sitting

    on the 22nd March, 2022.
    Mr Benjamin Komla Kpodo 10:44 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, without prejudice to the
    directive given yesterday for the Hon
    Minister for Finance to come to the
    House and provide some answers, I
    would want to let you know that the
    Committee on Local Government and
    Rural Development has written officially
    to the Minister for Finance to appear
    before them to explain how he has
    managed the District Assemblies
    Common Fund (DACF), but he has not
    come. The Committee turned round the
    other way to file a Question for him to
    come to the Floor and answer; he has not
    done that, and it has not even been listed
    in the Business Statement of the House
    for next week. However, this was done in
    the last Meeting, and we expected that he
    Business of the House

    would have addressed the issue before we

    even went on recess, but he did not show

    up, and it has still not been listed in the

    Business Statement. I would want to ask

    that we file an official report against him,

    but we want to wait for your directive,

    and that is why we have brought this to

    your attention.
    Mr Andrew Dari Chiwitey 10:44 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, the Akufo-Addo-led Govern-
    ment has introduced the Pollution and
    Sanitation Levy for over a year now, but
    if we get into town, we still see loads of
    garbage which is causing the floods that
    we are experiencing now. It may be over
    50 per cent cost, and I am sure by now
    some moneys would have been collected.
    Mr Speaker, if possible, you may direct
    the Hon Minister responsible for
    Sanitation and Water Resources to brief
    the House on how far they have utilised
    the collections, so that the whole world
    would know that the taxes that we pay are
    being utilised rightly, especially,
    considering the fact that this is a tax
    which is being paid by people who do not
    even reside in the cities. We have poor
    women from the Sawla/Tuna/Kalba
    Constituency, who are also compelled to
    pay the 10 pesewa on the diesel or petrol
    that we buy. So, Mr Speaker, I think that
    it is right for us to have the Hon Ministers
    to brief us on how much they have
    collected and how far we have used the
    moneys collected to the benefit of the
    people of Ghana.
    Ms Zuwera Mohammed Ibrahimah 10:54 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, you would notice that there
    are just three women in the Chamber this
    morning and I would want to believe that
    it is as a result of today's activities marking the World Menstrual Hygiene
    Day, with the theme: “Significance and All You Need to Know”. Those of us from far away constituencies have all
    been speaking on this matter on radio to
    touch base with our constituents, so that
    might explain why one could not find us
    in the Chamber this morning.
    Mr Speaker, looking at the Business
    Statement, there are 50 Questions listed
    for next week, and I could not find any of
    the Urgent Questions that I filed to the
    Hon Minister for Foreign Affairs and
    Regional Integration in March. The
    Official Report of Friday, 18th March,
    2022, has captured on page 25 that I
    sought to ask the Hon Minister for
    Foreign Affairs and Regional Integration
    whether the Ghana Card represents an e-
    Passport for Ghanaians or Ghanaians no
    more require a Ghana Passport to travel.
    These are very critical issues that need to
    be addressed only by the Hon Minister
    because before I filed the Questions, there
    were a lot of commentaries making the
    rounds in this country, of which some
    Business of the House

    were from very prominent Ghanaians

    including H.E. the Vice President and it

    was causing a lot of confusion in the

    minds of Ghanaians. As the Hon Minister

    for Foreign Affairs and Regional

    Integration, we would want to hear from

    her on what her Ministry's position is on e-Passport, e-Card and whether we do not

    require passports any more.

    Mr Speaker, this issue needs to be

    addressed, so that we would know where

    we are going and what we are —
    Mr Speaker 10:54 p.m.
    Actually, your reference
    is to Government's position on those issues, not the Ministry's.
    Ms Ibrahimah 10:54 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, you are
    right, but the Hon Minister, at this level,
    speaks for the Government. I would want
    to impress on the Business Committee to
    ensure that the Hon Minister makes time
    to come to this House and answer these
    Questions so that some closure can be
    brought to these very pertinent matters.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you very much for
    the opportunity.
    Mr Speaker 10:54 p.m.
    Hon Majority Chief
    Whip, are there any responses?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 10:54 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    quite muffle, let me try and relate to the
    observations and issues raised by Hon
    Colleagues, not according to any order.
    The Hon Agboza related to two issues:
    landed properties and their transfers and
    Question filed. If one looks at the agenda
    for this Meeting, there are over 1000
    Questions that have been programmed by
    the Business Committee. I must confess
    to you that I have not gone through all the
    Questions to be able to tell if this specific
    Question had been programmed; what I
    could say though is that I would relate to
    the Clerks-at-the-Table — it is a very important Question — to confirm or otherwise if that Question has been
    programmed. I would then relate
    personally to the Hon Member on that.
    On the Cocoa Road Audit Report, I am
    surprised about the Hon Member's comment, and it is not what he is saying.
    But I guess we should pry further and dig
    further; it may be here or may not be here.
    If it is the case that it is not here, and
    following up on what the Minister has
    said as the Hon Member is alleging, we
    would relate to the Hon Minister, who the
    Hon Member knows has been a very
    faithful attendant to this House and find a
    way of bringing a finality to it. The Cocoa
    Roads issue is a big matter and we are all
    concerned about it, so I am in total
    support of the Hon Member's observation.
    Mr Speaker, the Hon Boamah talked
    about two issues: the campaign on
    terrorism and flooding. He is basically
    calling for the Hon Ministers to appear
    Business of the House

    and address this House. I agree with the

    Hon Member totally. On the issue of

    flooding, it is unfortunate that there is no

    Question relating to this subject matter

    even though the House has programmed

    the Hon Minister for Water Resources,

    Works and Housing on Wednesday. So,

    the Business Committee would have to

    find a way since it is also an urgent

    national concern. The House has to find

    space and programme the Hon Minister to

    come and appraise us.

    As regards terrorism, I equally agree,

    except to say that the House may have to

    constitute a Committee of the Whole

    since it is a matter of national security. It

    cannot be done on a full Plenary.

    Mr Speaker, Hon Avoka is right; he spoke

    to me yesterday in relation to the matter.

    The House should have taken this Report

    before it rose, so the House would do the

    needful — Hon Avoka, the House would do the needful for that Report to be taken.

    Mr Speaker, as regards Hon Kofi

    Adams, I vividly recall the discussion and

    the heated debate in the House on that

    fateful day. Again, we would relate to the

    Hon Dan Botwe and decide on

    something, but we would do it closely

    with the Hon Member, so that we could

    find some common understanding as to

    how the House would be able to deal with

    this concern relating to property rates and

    agents being tasked to collect them as

    well as all the underpinning concerns.

    My Hon Colleague from Ho Central, I

    am surprised to hear that the Committee

    has written officially to the Minister for

    Finance and he has not responded. That is

    the indication the Hon Member gave in

    his observation. The Committee has

    powers, as contained in the Standing

    Orders. It comes to me as surprise, but I

    could only assure the Hon Member that

    we would follow up to ensure that the

    Minister does the needful and appears

    before the Committee.

    Mr Speaker, however, let me also say

    that the Leaderships of the Committees

    would also have to relate to the

    Leadership of the House. If it is the case

    — I do not know if the Hon Member is the Ranking Member or a member of the

    Committee. If the Hon Member is the

    Ranking Member, I do know if he has

    related to the ever-competent Hon

    Minority Chief Whip, my Hon good

    Friend; he is good in this enterprise with

    a lot of experience. I am sure if the Hon

    Member had related to him, we would

    have found a solution. But be that as it

    may, we would find a way out of this; the

    Hon Member should just hold his fire; I

    would relate to my Hon Colleague and we

    would find a way to reach out to the Hon

    Minister for Finance and deal with that.

    Business of the House

    On the Sanitation Levy, the Hon

    Member is calling for the Rt Hon Speaker

    to direct. Again, the relevant Committee

    should be able to take this up. If it is about

    accountability, the Committee has powers

    and we would take a cue from the ever-

    wise and cherished directives and

    admonishments the Rt Hon Speaker has

    been giving this House. The Committee's Leadership should not underrate their

    powers, but if it comes to a point where

    the Hon Member for Ho Central is saying

    the Committee has officially related to the

    Hon Minister and the Hon Minister is not

    responding, then they should let the

    Leadership know, so that we could act

    accordingly.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Well, Hon Members, I
    think that genuine issues have been raised
    through the comments of many Hon
    Members on the Floor. What I could add
    to what the Majority Chief Whip has just
    stated, is to impress on you to use your
    powers.

    Kindly read carefully part nine of our

    Standing Orders on issues of Questions and how Hon Members and the Committees could trace and track Questions that are submitted. When Hon Members submit Questions through the Clerk's Office, they are processed to the Speaker. The Speaker is the sole person

    who admits Questions. Hon Members may file Questions as Urgent, but it might not be admitted by the Speaker as an Urgent Question, so Hon Members would need to follow to see whether their Question really passed through us and was admitted as an Urgent Question. We are aware that by our rules, the Ministers have only three weeks within which to submit Answers to the Questions. So, when you submit your Question, you also have the duty to follow through and we have a record book for Questions in the Clerk's Office. The progress is entered there, so you can always go there to check how your Question is faring.

    Hon Members, please, take note and

    look at the fonts critically. Some of you, sometimes, make mistakes and indicate Written Answers to your Questions. In some of those instances, it means that you want it to be submitted to you and not on the floor. You have to be careful in how you — Sometimes, I make comments and call on Hon Members to see me to discuss how the Questions have been phrased on some of these issues and I do not get any response from the Members. They do not come up for me to draw their attention to how to properly phrase the Question or how to go about it to get the Government to respond to your Questions. Sometimes, you would need the Minister to appear and give a comprehensive statement on some of your Questions —

    As usual, you are in your conversations

    and you are not listening. At the end of the day, you go and misquote me.

    Business of the House

    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim — rose —
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Yes?
    Mr Ibrahim 11:04 a.m.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Speaker, as Leadership, it is our
    responsibility to assist you and to make
    sure that your directives also work.
    Yesterday, you gave a directive that the
    Minister for Finance must appear before
    this House and account to the House on
    how moneys relating to COVID-19,
    which were approved by this House, have
    been spent. After which the House could
    proceed on the facility relating to the £75
    million that was supposed to be approved
    yesterday.
    Mr Speaker, the Report is still before
    this House. You gave that directive in
    order for that Motion not to be on the
    Order Paper every day, and in order not
    to blame the Clerks-at-the-Table in the
    coming days. I would wish that the
    Business Committee would programme
    the Minister within next week from
    Monday to Thursday so that he would just
    appear before the House because if you
    listen to our Hon Colleagues, they say the
    records are there. Therefore, what he is
    supposed to come and do is a
    presentation. So, if he could come on
    Wednesday or latest by Thursday, so that
    once he does that, then on Friday, the
    House may be able to proceed to approve
    or disapprove the facility for him so that
    nobody would blame us that Government
    has got some cheap money of £75 million
    only and Parliament has refused to give
    approval. Therefore, we want to push the
    ball into the court of the Minister for
    Finance and the Leadership of Govern-
    ment Business. Mr Speaker has given that
    directive and we must make sure the
    directive works.
    The public, including the diplomatic
    missions, are very interested in how we
    spend the COVID-19 funds. It is for that
    reason that we, the Minority, are always
    pushing that Parliament must be
    accountable to the people and we must
    hold Government to account. The
    Minister for Finance holds that record, so,
    Hon acting Chairman of Government
    Business, I do not know whether the letter
    from the secretariat has already gone. But
    if, Mr Speaker, we can expedite that
    action, so that we bring finality to this
    issue, latest by Thursday, we can proceed
    to give the approval or disapproval on
    Friday.
    Mr Speaker, the acting Chairman of the
    Business Committee also said the
    security issue relating to terrorism would
    be discussed at the Committee of the
    Whole. Matters of that nature by Standing
    Order 44 must be in Closed Sitting so that
    when the Ministers come, they would feel
    emboldened to be able to give us every
    secret relating to that security related
    issue. So, while he has accepted it and is
    Business of the House

    proposing a Committee of the Whole, I

    want us to go a step further to make it a

    Closed Sitting so that anybody who leaks

    information relating to it could be held

    accountable for his irresponsibility.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

    opportunity.
    Mr Speaker 11:24 p.m.
    Well, I cannot agree with
    you more than that. As Leaders, it is your
    duty to support the Speaker and I would
    want to plead with you leaders to support
    it from the basis of facts and not rumours.
    So, for some of these things, please make
    sure that as Leaders, you trace them and
    get to know the facts before you release
    them to your Members. Even yesterday, I
    was blamed for a number of Motions and
    some requests that have been made. We
    have been told that they are before me and
    on my desk and I am not working on
    them. Meanwhile, there was nothing like
    that before me and yet your Members go
    rumbling around saying Mr Speaker is
    not doing this or that, meanwhile, those
    things you are complaining of are not
    before the Speaker.
    It is this morning that some of what you
    complained of were brought to my desk,
    in fact, to my Secretariat and my secretary
    immediately drew my attention that what
    Hon Members complained of yesterday
    had then just arrived. She is now
    processing them for them to come to me.
    This is the problem and I hold you, Hon
    Leaders, responsible because you are not
    leading the Hon Members effectively and
    you are not communicating well with the
    Speaker. Many of these things that have
    been raised here, if there had been that
    good communication, that verification of
    documents — the Standing Orders have given ample processes and procedures as
    to how these things are done.
    Many Hon Members, fortunately, I
    should say, not unfortunately, we have a
    lot of fresh blood in-House which is good
    for the development of our democracy.
    Therefore, they are not yet well tutored on
    these things. You should lead them and I
    do not see that Leadership, that is my
    worry. That is a real worry to me. The
    Committees have so much powers that
    you could hold the Ministers to account.
    The Speaker has enormous powers to
    hold with your support, the Government
    to account to the people.
    When we talk about accountability, we
    are not talking about financial account-
    ability only. We have given them power;
    we have given them authority; we have
    given them trust and that trust is not just
    that I trust you and that is why I am voting
    for you to lead me. If you go through the
    Constitution, trust in land, the President
    holds the land, the minerals, so many
    things in trust for Ghanaians. That trust,
    we have to hold the President to account.
    Business of the House

    So, if we talk about Achimota forest and

    other lands which H. E. the President is

    holding in trust for the people of Ghana,

    and if anyone thinks that trust is being

    abused, that person has the power to hold

    H. E. the President to account. I have been

    worried about the Ga, Kumasi and

    regional lands in general, but nothing is

    happening. Families are petitioning and

    complaining and I have been drawing

    their attention to the fact that, if they are

    petitioning through the Rt Hon Speaker,

    then they are doing the wrong thing. They

    should petition through Parliament

    because it is a function of Parliament and

    not of the Rt Hon Speaker. The families

    need that leadership, but they are not

    getting it and that is part of the termites

    that are eating away the credibility of the

    politicians. We have to work at it. So, all

    the issues we raised are very important.

    There is a levy on sanitation, the

    moneys are being collected, and the Hon

    Minister has been asked to come and

    account for it, but the Hon Minister has

    not shown up and Parliament cannot do

    anything? That constitutes a serious

    breach of our laws and, in fact, contempt

    of Parliament. We can take them on. That

    is why a Minister can be censured. The

    Ministers are not just appointed by H. E.

    the President; they are appointed by H. E.

    the President with the approval of

    Parliament. H. E. the President and Hon

    Members of Parliament are the two key

    persons elected by Ghanaians and the

    hopes and aspirations of Ghanaians are

    put in their hands.

    Therefore, it is not only H. E. the

    President, but Parliament also has that

    power, and it can withdraw that approval

    through censuring of the Ministers or

    withdrawal of the approval by H. E. the

    President through impeachment. The

    people have given Parliament that power.

    So, when Parliament does not exercise it

    and joins the members of the general

    public in complaining and rumour-

    mongering, it is a complete disservice to

    this nation. Please, I do not want to get to

    this area again. Let us, as a House and as

    individuals, perform our functions, duties

    and responsibilities effectively. We can

    only do that when we are enabled to do it.

    There are some challenges with the law

    — constitutional and statutory — we have to lead the way to work on them.

    I am happy that H. E. the President has

    now agreed that we should continue with

    the constitutional reforms. Initially, he

    was of the view that it is a complete re-

    write of the Constitution, but I did not

    support it. He wanted us to pick one or

    two amendments to work on. We know

    what happened to the area of

    decentralisation. Decentralisation is an

    area that we must work seriously on,

    because what we have now is incomplete

    and we have to work and complete it. I

    Business of the House

    was happy that they added that to the

    portfolio of the Hon Minister for Local

    Government, Decentralisation and Rural

    Development. Unfortunately, I do not see

    anything happening and we have to work

    on it. The cardinal sin of this Parliament

    is, Santrokofi, Akpafu, Lipke and Lolobi

    (SALL), do not forget about it.

    I expect that in spite of the celebration

    of World Hygiene Day, we should have

    more than the four women in the House.

    The issue of hygiene and sanitation is not

    only for women, but for all of us because

    we are all part of it. Their numbers are not

    encouraging and as a House, I insist and

    want the Leaders to take this up; that at

    whatever stage that the Affirmative

    Action Bill is, please let us take it from

    the Executive and work on it as a House.

    It is our function to legislate and not that

    of the Executive.

    If there are constitutional problems, we

    would draw their attention. I do not think

    that the passage of the Affirmative Action

    Bill offends any provision of the

    Constitution; We will not legislate and

    put financial provisions in the Act, and

    that is why I agree with the interpretation

    given by Prof Mike Oquaye Jnr and

    allowed Hon Members to initiate Private

    Members Bills.

    Private Members Bills are of two types:

    a Private Bill and a Private Member's Bill. The Government is mostly con-

    cerned with Public Bills and that is why

    the private sector is not well attended to.

    There is a lot of work we have to do in

    order to enable the private sector to

    flourish because it is the private sector

    that creates the wealth and leads the

    growth of a country. The public sector

    provides the machinery for them to

    operate. So, please let us take our work

    more seriously than we are doing.

    I said in my re-opening remarks that this

    year would be devoted to oversight and I

    mean what I say. We have to do a lot of

    work this year and next year so that by

    2024, which is an election year, we would

    not witness the things that we witnessed

    in 2020.

    Please, do not allow the mob consti-

    tuents to lead you. If they could, they

    would not have elected you to lead them.

    So, Members of Parliament must lead

    them and not join them. If Members of

    Parliament are like them, they would not

    have elected you to be their leaders. I am

    surprised that the Hon Majority Chief

    Whip said that the constituency and

    regional elections are so far, peaceful.

    The evidence is too much to counter that

    position; the elections have not been

    peaceful and I would not like to see that

    in any political party. Is Members of the

    same political party attacking one another

    with cutlasses peaceful? Come on!

    Business of the House

    Please, I would direct the Clerk to

    Parliament and the Table Office to write

    to the Hon Ministers who have been

    mentioned and remind them to appear

    quickly before the House. They could

    only do so when they are programmed by

    the Business Committee, and that has to

    be done, starting next week. They are

    critical matters, particularly those dealing

    with national security. I have had a

    number of meetings with the Hon

    Minister for National Security based on

    letters that he has written to me about the

    security situation of this country and

    particularly, of this House. We are not in

    normal times and all of us must take our

    security seriously. Our security machinery

    is broken down even in the House. When

    I talked about the lack of budget, people

    tried to counter me, but I know what I was

    talking about. Please, let us be more

    serious than we are.

    I understand that some people may have

    problems with us continuing with the

    Business of the House. However, it is for

    a good reason that I decided to crave your

    indulgence for us to continue for today

    even though from the onset, the numbers

    were not encouraging. However, in the

    national interest, we have to do this. So,

    with your kind permission and

    indulgence, I would take it that the

    Business of the House presented is

    adopted, subject to the comments that

    have been made, and that the Business

    Committee and the Clerks-at-the-Table

    would take up the issues and

    communicate officially to the relevant

    Ministers and Ministries. We expect to

    see a change in their attitude towards the

    House. If not, the Rt Hon Speaker himself

    would take up the mantle and the

    unexpected would happen. With this, the

    Business of the House is adopted

    Any guidance from Hon Leaders?

    Yes, Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with respect, under the circumstance, I
    would like to move for the adjournment
    of the House till Tuesday, 31st May, 2022
    at 10 o'clock in the forenoon.
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 11:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    beg to second the Motion for
    adjournment.
    Question put and Motion agreed to.
    ADJOURNMENT 11:24 p.m.