Debates of 28 Oct 2022

MR SPEAKER
PRAYERS 10:22 a.m.

Mr Speaker 10:22 a.m.
Hon Members, I have not received any Communication from His Excellency the President and I do not have any Formal Communication today. So, we would move straight to the item numbered 4 on the Order Paper — Correction of Votes and Proceedings and the Official Report.
Votes and Proceedings and the
Official Report
Hon Members, we would start with the correction of Votes and Proceedings of Thursday, 27th October, 2022.
Hon Members, page 1 … 8 —
Mr Kwame Gakpeh Dzudzorli — rose —
Mr Speaker 10:22 a.m.
Hon Member, yes?
Mr Kwame Gakpey Dzudzorli 10:22 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page 8, the item numbered 31, I, Mr Kwame Gakpey Dzudzorli, Hon Member of Parliament for Keta Constituency, was right here in the Chamber yesterday but I have been marked absent.
Mr Speaker 10:22 a.m.
Hon Member, sorry, repeat what you said.
Mr Gakpey 10:22 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page 8, the item numbered 31, I was marked absent but I was here in the Chamber yesterday. The
Leadership of the Minority can even attest to that. I was even the one who held the fort for the Hon Minority Leader.
Mr Speaker 10:22 a.m.
Hon Member, there is usually a list that is circulated for Hon Members present to attest their signatures to. Your name is not on the list —
Mr Gakpey 10:22 a.m.
Mr Speaker, yes but most of the Clerks-at-the-Table, saw me in the Chamber yesterday —
Mr Speaker 10:22 a.m.
Hon Member, are you sure you heard what I said? Hon Member, did you hear me?
Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 10:22 a.m.
Mr Speaker, maybe my Hon Colleague did not hear you. Even though he was here yesterday, Mr Speaker is saying that there is a list that he was supposed to sign which he did not. So, maybe, that is where the problem is coming from.
Mr Speaker 10:22 a.m.
Hon Members, once again, in order to assist the Table Office to rightly compile the names of Hon Members who attend the Plenary session, please, always ensure that once you have attended the session, try to sign against your name on the list. It is very important and so, we would take notice of that and direct the Table Office to make the correction that you were present yesterday. However, in future, we would not do that for any other Hon Member again. I think this is sufficient notice.
Hon Members, page 9…13 —
Hon Member, yes?
Mr Andrew Chiwitey Dari 10:22 a.m.
Mr Speaker, the item numbered 1 on page 13, if you would kindly permit me to read the first sentence:
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:22 a.m.

Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Hon Member, you are right
so I would draw the attention of the Table
Office to make the necessary corrections,
because it was not the Committee that went
there to print the textbooks, I think that they
visited the companies that were contracted
to print the Government textbooks for Basic
Schools.
So, Table Office should kindly make the
necessary corrections.
Page 14 … 22 —
Mr Andrews Dori Chiwitey — rose -—
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Yes, Hon Member for
Sawla/Tuna/Kalba?
Mr Chiwitey 10:32 a.m.
Mr Speaker, once again,
thank you.
Mr Speaker, the item numbered 3, “In Attendance”, the first name 10:32 a.m.
“Ms Vida Dortey” — I know the lady very well and the spelling of her surname, “Dortey” is “D- i-o-r-o-t-e-y” and not “Dortey”, so, it should be, “Ms Vida Diorotey”.
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Sorry, can we get the
spelling of the name again?
Mr Chiwitey 10:32 a.m.
Mr Speaker, the spelling
is, “D-i-o-r-o-t-e-y”.
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Yes, that is quite a unique
name unknown to many, that is why maybe
— Clerks-at-the-Table, it is not “Dortey”; it is “D-i-o-r-o-t-e-y”; kindly do the necessary correction.
Page 23 …29?
Hon Members, in the absence of any
further corrections, the Votes and
Proceedings of Thursday, 27th October,
2022, as corrected, is hereby adopted as the
true record of proceedings.
Hon Members, we would now move to
the item numbered 5 on the Order Paper
which is the Business of the House for the
Second Week.
Yes, Chairman of the Business Committee?
Mr Frank Annoh-Dompreh — rose —
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Yes, Hon Majority Chief
Whip?
Mr Annoh-Dompreh 10:32 a.m.
Mr Speaker, with
respect, the Hon Majority Leader is
unavoidably absent and I would seek your
kind leave to present the Business of the
House on his behalf.
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:32 a.m.

Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Yes, Minority Front
Bench?
Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 10:32 a.m.
Mr Speaker, per
our rules, he is a member of the Business
Committee and he is well positioned to
present it on behalf of the Hon Chairman.
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Hon Members, the Majority
Chief Whip who is a member of the
Business Committee will present the Report
of the Committee for and on behalf of the
Chairman of the Committee, the Hon
Majority Leader.
Please, you can do so now.
BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE 10:32 a.m.

Majority Leader) 10:32 a.m.
Mr Speaker, the
Business Committee met yesterday,
Thursday, 27th November, 2022, and
arranged Business of the House for the
Second Week ending Friday, 4th November,
2022.
Mr Speaker, the Committee accordingly
submits its report as follows:
Arrangement of Business
Formal Communications by the Speaker
Mr Speaker, you may read any available
communication to the House.
Question(s)
Mr Speaker, the Business Committee has
scheduled the following Ministers to
respond to Questions asked of them during
the week:
No. of
Question(s)
Minister for the Volta Region 1
Minister for the Interior 12
Minister for Food & Agriculture 11
Minister for Health 11
Minister for Environment, Science, Technology & Innovation 2
Minister for Railways Development 1
Minister for Roads and Highways 7
Total Number of Questions 45

Business of the House

Mr Speaker, in all, seven Ministers are

expected to attend upon the House to

respond to 45 Questions during the week.

The Questions are of the following types:

i. Urgent - 11;

ii. Oral - 34

Statements

Mr Speaker, you may admit Statements

to be made in the House by Hon Members,

in accordance with Order 72 of the Standing

Orders of Parliament.

Papers and Reports

Mr Speaker, Papers may be laid during

the week and reports from Committees may

also be presented to the House.

Motions and Resolutions

Mr Speaker, Motions may be debated and

their consequential Resolutions, if any,

taken during the week.

Referral at Committees

Mr Speaker, the Business Committee,

again, urges Committees with referrals to

expedite work on same for the

Consideration of the House.

Reponses to Parliamentary Questions

Mr Speaker, per the Draft Agenda for this

Meeting, Hon Members have already filed

about 775 Questions. Again, Hon Members,

having returned from the long recess, have

also started filing new Questions reflecting

the needs of their constituents.

In view of the above, the Business

Committee urges Ministers of State to

endeavour to attend upon the House to

respond to Questions whenever they are

scheduled to do so.

Conclusion

Mr Speaker, in accordance with the

Standing Order 160 (2) and subject to the

Standing Order 53, the Committee submits

to this honourable House the order in which

the Business of the House shall be taken

during the week.

Tuesday, 1st November, 2022.

Urgent Questions --

Ms Abla Dzifa Gomashie (Ketu

South): To ask the Minister for the Volta

Region when the relocation of the victims

of the Tidal Waves in the Ketu South

Constituency will commence.

Mr John Kobina Abbam Aboah Sanie

(Mpohor): To ask the Minister for the

Interior what measures the Ministry is

putting in place in the wake of the recent

disturbances and unrests in our schools and

campuses, to improve security and to

address the issues of students' agitations and demonstrations.

Mr John Kobina Abbam Aboah Sanie

(Mpohor): To ask the Minister for the

Interior measures being outlined or

implemented by the Ministry to tackle the

menace of police brutality and attacks on

civilians, sometimes innocent students in

recent times.
Dr Zanetor Agyeman 10:32 a.m.
None

Korle): To ask the Minister for the Interior

what measures the Ministry is putting in

place to mitigate the devastating impact of

the most recent floods on persons living in

the affected areas.

Business of the House

Mr Emmanuel Kwadwo Agyekum

(Nkoranza South): To ask the Minister for

the Interior what urgent steps the Ministry

is taking to restore full Police Service

presence in the Nkoranza South Munici-

pality after withdrawing their services since

the 18th of May, 2022.

Questions --

*

937. Mrs Della Sowah (Kpando): To

ask the Minister for the Interior the

possibility of realigning policing of

Gbefi to be under Kpando Police

District in line with the demarcation

of the Constituency.

*940. Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey

(Keta): To ask the Minister for the

Interior the number of suicide cases

recorded among Ghana Police

Service personnel and measures

being taken to mitigate it.

*941. Mr Alhassan Kobina Ghansah

(Asikuma/Odoben/Brakwa): To

ask the Minister for the Interior

what plan the Ministry has to give

a facelift to the Asikuma, Odoben,

and Brakwa Police Stations in the

Asikuma - Odoben - Brakwa district.

*1080. Mr Francis-Xavier Kojo Sosu

(Madina): To ask the Minister

for the Interior the state of after-

care-services in Ghana and

measures being taken to improve

after care services with the view

of achieving effective integration

of ex-convicts.

*1338. Mr Alexander Akwasi Acquah

(Akim Oda): To ask the Minister

for the Interior efforts being made

to accommodate the Oda

Divisional Police Command in a

very appropriate premises as the

Command has been operating in a

rented apartment since it was

created.

*1558. Mr Kwadjo Asante (Suhum):

To ask the Minister for the

Interior what is the nationality

break down of foreigners who

have registered with the National

Identification Authority so far.

*1439. Mr Oscar Liwaal (Yunyoo): To

ask the Minister for the Interior

when the Ministry will provide

Yunyoo District with a police

patrol van to improve patrols in

the District.

*1440. Mr Adams Mohammed Sukparu

(Sissala West): To ask the

Minister for the Interior what

steps the Ministry has taken to

improve police presence in and

around the Sissala West District

to deter criminal activities and

threats of terrorism.

Statements

Presentation of Papers --

(a) Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture

for the period January to December,

2021.

(b) Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Fisheries and Aquaculture

Development for the period

January to December, 2021.

(c) Budget Performance Report of the Public Services Commission for

Business of the House

the period January to December,

2021.

(d) Budget Performance Report of National Development Planning

Commission for the period January to

December, 2021.

(e) Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Railway Development

for the period January to December,

2021.

(f) Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Energy for the period

January to December, 2021.

(g) Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Finance for the period

January to December, 2021.

Motions --

That this honourable House adopts

the Report of the Finance Committee

Credit Facility Agreement between

the Government of the Republic of

Ghana (represented by the Ministry

of Finance) and the Export-Import

Bank of Korea for an amount of thirty

million United States dollars

(US$30,000,000.00) to finance the

Medical Equipment Provision Project in

Response to COVID-19.

Consequential Resolution —

Committee sittings.

Urgent Questions —

Mr Desmond De-Graft Paitoo (Gomoa

East): To ask the Minister for Food and

Agriculture measures the Ministry intends

to adopt or have adopted to reduce food

insecurity in the country.
Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey (Keta) 10:32 a.m.
To ask the Minister for Food and
Agriculture what measures the Ministry is
instituting to avert Bacterial Black Spot
(BBS) Disease affecting mango farmers and
forcing them out of business.
Mr Muhammed Bawah Braimah
(Ejura-Sekyedumase): To ask the Minister
for Food and Agriculture what steps the
ministry is taking to bring down the high
cost of food production in order to avert
food shortages in the country.
Questions --
*942. Mr Robert Wisdom Cudjoe
(Prestea-Huni-Valley): To ask the
Minister for Food and Agriculture
which organisations and individuals
in the domestic cocoa processing
business benefited from the
COCOBOD secured revolving
capital of $200 million, as stated in
paragraph 694 of the 2022 Budget
Statement and Economic Policy of
Government.
*945. Mr Iddie Kofi Adams (Buem):
To ask the Minister for Food and
Agriculture the details and location
of the beneficiaries of the 1000
units of rice harvesters distributed
to the Women-Based Farmer Rice
groups across the country.
*964. Mr Yusif Sulemana (Bole/Bamboi):
To ask the Minister for Food and
Agriculture what measures and
policies Government has instituted
to prevent herdsmen from
destroying farmlands and farm
produce and its consequent clashes

Business of the House

between herdsmen and farmers in

the Bole District.

*965. Mrs Gizella Tetteh-Agbotui

(Awutu-Senya West): To ask the

Minister for Agriculture what

effort the Ministry is instituting to

establish mechanisation centres

for farmers in the Awutu Senya

District.

*1405. Mr Vincent Ekow Assafuah

(Old Tafo): To ask the Minister

for Food and Agriculture what is

the current state of Youth in

Innovative Agriculture Program

facilitated by the National

Entrepreneurship and Innovation

Program.

*1406. Mr Kwadjo Asante (Suhum):

To ask the Minister for Food and

Agriculture how much debt is

outstanding in respect of fertilizer

supplies to cocoa farmers.

*1407. Mr Kwadjo Asante (Suhum):

To ask the Minister for Food and

Agriculture what is the state of

the forty thousand (40,000) non-

adjustable weighing scale that

were purchased to be used by

Licensed Buying Companies

(LBCs).

*1409. Mr Abed-Nego Azumah Bandim

(Bunkpurugu): To ask the Minister

for Food and Agriculture whether

FarmerTribe, an agro chemical and

seed distribution company based in

Tamale, is licensed by the Ministry

to import and sell hybrid maize

seeds in Ghana.

Statements

Presentation of Papers --

(a) Annual Report of the Public Utilities Regulatory Commission for 2020.

(b) Reconciliation Report on the Petroleum Holding Fund for year

2021.

(c) Annual Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Information for the

period January to December, 2021.

(d) Annual Public Debt Management Report for the Year, 2021.

(e) Reconciliation Report on the Petroleum Holding Fund for year

2021.

(f) Annual Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Energy for the

period January to December, 2021.

(g) Annual Budget Performance Report of the Ministry of Information for the

period January to December, 2021.

(h) Report of the Finance Committee Credit Facility Agreement between

the Government of the Republic of

Ghana (represented by the Ministry of

Finance) and the Export-Import Bank

of Korea for an amount of thirty

million United States dollars

(US$30,000,000.00) to finance the

Medical Equipment Provision Project

in Response to COVID-19.

Committee sittings.

Business of the House

Urgent Questions --
Dr Clement A. Apaak (Builsa South) 10:32 a.m.
To ask the Minister for Health what steps
the Ministry is taking to ensure that medical
doctors posted to deprived parts of the
country take up their postings.
Mr Kwame Dzuodzorli Gakpey (Keta) 10:32 a.m.
To ask the Minister for Health measures the
Food and Drugs Authority is taking to
address fallen standards of palm oil on local
markets.
Mr Alexander Roosevelt Hottordze
(Central Tongu): To ask the Minister for
Health what has accounted for the shortage
of essential drugs in health facilities across
the length and breadth of Ghana.
Questions --
*455. Mr Edward Abambire Bawa
(Bongo): To ask the Minister for
Health when the results of the 439
foreign trained doctors, who wrote
the Licensure Registration Exami-
nations on 26th February, 2021,
would be released.
*570. Mr Seidu Issifu (Nalerigu/
Gambaga): To ask the Minister
for Health if there are plans to
build CHPS Compounds in the
following communities in the
Nalerigu-Gambaga Constituency
to ensure access to healthcare: (i)
Kpikparigbini (ii) Dabari (iii)
Gurugu (iv) Soansobigi (v)
Sumnibomah No. 1 (vi)
Naminyala (vii) Nayoku (viii) La-
Atarigu.
*573. Mr Yao Gomado (Akan): To ask
the Minister for Health the plans
the Ministry has to upgrade the
following health centres to
polyclinics: (i) Kadjebi Health
Centre (ii) Ahamansu Health
Centre (iii) Dodo-Amanfrom
Health Centre.
*738. Dr Mark Kurt Nawaane
(Nabdam): To ask the Minister for
Health what are the possible
causes of “copayments” by NHIA registered members at health
facilities and what measures the
Ministry is considering to curtail it.
*1043. Mr Jabaah John Bennam
(Zabzugu): To ask the Minister
for Health when the Zabzugu
District Hospital will be provided
with a mortuary to reduce the
challenge of depositing dead
bodies at Yendi and Tamale
which are a significant distance
from Zabzugu.
*1045. Dr Kissi Dickson Adomako
(Anyaa Sowutuom): To ask the
Minister for Health what
activities the Ministry is engaged
in to improve blood donations in
the country and what benefits are
available to donors.
*1145. Mr Michael Okyere Baafi (New
Juaben South): To ask the
Minister for Health what
additional infrastructure has been
provided to the Koforidua
Regional Hospital to enable it
operate effectively as a Regional
Hospital.

Business of the House

*1147. Ms Dakoa Newman (Okaikwei

South): To ask the Minister for

Health when the COVID-19

block of the Kaneshie Poly Clinic

will be handed over to the good

people of Okaikwei South to help

ease congestion and improve

Healthcare.

*1316. Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey

(Keta): To ask the Minister for

Environment, Science, Technology

and Innovation whether proper

Environmental Impact Assessment

was conducted before a license

issued to Kensington Industries

Limited of India.

*1317 Dr Hamza Adam (Kumbungu):

To ask the Minister for Environment,

Science, Technology and Innovation

what measures are being put in

place to stop the exodus of

scientists from research institutes

in the country.

Statements --

Presentation of Papers --

(a) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Ga East Municipal

Assembly for the Year 2020.

(b) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Takoradi Technical

University for the Year 2020.

(c) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Koforidua Technical

University for the Year 2020.

(d) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the University of

Energy and Natural Resources

(UENR) for the Year 2020.

(e) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of Cocoa Processing

Company Limited for the Year 2020.

(f) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the University of

Health and Allied Sciences, Ho for

the Year 2020.

(g) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the Sunyani Technical

University for the Year 2020.

(h) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the Ministry of

Education for the Year 2020.

(i) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the University of

Ghana for the Year 2020.

(j) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the Ministry of

Transport for the Year 2020.

(k) Annual Statement by the Audit

Committee of the Ghana Atomic

Energy Commission for the Year

2020.

Committee sittings.

Questions --

*885. Mr Seidu Issifu (Nalerigu/ Gambaga):

To ask the Minister for Railways

Development the state of the Accra

Skytrain Project after the signing of a

Business of the House

Memorandum of Understanding

between the Government of Ghana

and the Africa Investment (AI)

Skytrain construction of South

Africa.

*481. Mr Benjamin Komla Kpodo (Ho

Central): To ask the Minister for

Roads and Highways when the

road from Volta Barracks through

Kpenoe, Takla, and Hodzo to

Tokokoe will completed.

*626. Mr Twumasi Kwame Ampofo

(Sene West): To ask the Minister

for Road and Highways what has

accounted for the delay in the

construction of the Atebubu - Kwame Danso road and the

following feeder roads: (i) Kwame

Danso - Akyeremade Battor (ii) Kwame Danso - Konkose (iii) Kyeamekrom - Chaboba (iv) Kyeamekrom - Tatto Battor (v) Menkor - Todaykope (vi) Shafa - Dogondage (vii) Bunji - Dunkwape (viii) Lemu - Mantukwa (ix) Mantukwa - Kwaese.

638. Mr Kofi Arko Nokoe (Evalue

Ajomoro Gwira): To ask the

Minister for Roads and Highways

the plans the Ministry have to

renovate the Dominase bridge on

River Ankobra in the Nzema East

Municipality.

*643. Mr Vincent Oppong Asamoah

(Dormaa West): To ask the

Minister for Roads and Highways

when contractors working on the

underlisted roads in the Dormaa

West Constituency in the Bono

Region, which were under

construction before 2016 but have

since been abandoned, would be

resumed: (i) Atesikrom - Yaakrom - Diabakrom (ii) Nkrankwanta - Adaborkrom (iii) Kasapin - Camp

15.

*953. Mr Bismark Tetteh Nyarko

(Upper Manya Krobo): To ask

the Minister for Roads and

Highways when the contractor

working on the Asesewa Town

Roads will return to site and the

date of completion of the project.

*988. Mr Peter Yaw Kwakye-Ackah

(Amenfi Central): To ask the

Minister for Roads and Highways

when the following roads will be

completed: (i) Asakragwa-Agona -

- Amenfi-Homjebre Road (ii) and

Asankragwa-Kyeikrom - Bonsie- Ohenekrom Road.

*1169. Mr John Kwabena Bless Oti

(Nkwanta North): To ask the

Minister for Roads and

Highways when the Kpassa to

Kabonwuli road would be

awarded to a contractor.

Statements --

Presentation of Papers --

(a) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Driver and

Vehicle Licensing Authority for

the Year 2020.

(b) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Council for

Scientific and Industrial

Research for the Year 2020.

(c) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Ghana

Business of the House

Immigration Service for the Year

2020.

(d) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Ministry of

Information for the Year 2020.

(e) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Ghana

Broadcasting Corporation (GBC)

for the Year 2020.

(f) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Ghana News

Agency (GNA) for the Year

2020.

(g) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the National Film

and Television Institute (NAFTI)

for the Year 2020.

(h) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Mampong

Municipal Assembly for the Year

2020.

(i) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Bekwai

Municipal Assembly for the Year

2020.

(j) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Adansi

Asokwa District Assembly for

the Year 2020.

(k) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Jaman North

District Assembly for the Year

2020.

(l) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Kwadaso

Municipal Assembly for the Year

2020.

(m) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Offinso North

District Assembly for the Year

2020.

(n) Annual Statement by the Audit Committee of the Adentan

Municipal Assembly for the Year

2020.

Motions --

That this honourable House adopts

the Report of the Finance Committee

Credit Facility Agreement between

the Government of the Republic of

Ghana (represented by the Ministry

of Finance) and the Export-Import

Bank of Korea for an amount of thirty

million United States dollars

(US$30,000,000.00) to finance the

Medical Equipment Provision

Project in Response to COVID-19.

Consequential Resolution

Committee sittings.
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Hon Members, the
Business of the House arranged by the
Business Committee for next week has been
accordingly presented. It is now time for
comments, if any, by Hon Members.
Mr Ahmed Ibrahim — rose —
Mr Speaker 10:32 a.m.
Yes, Hon First Deputy
Minority Whip?
Mr A. Ibrahim 10:42 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I was in the
Business Committee meeting on Monday,
24th October, 2022, however, I was late
yesterday. On Monday, when we met, two
critical issues were raised, and the Hon
Chairman of the Business Committee
assured the Committee when we met on

Business of the House

Thursday, 27th October, 2022, that he would

ensure that we programme the Reports of

the Electoral Commission (EC) and that of

the National Identification Authority (NIA)

for next week Thursday.

Mr Speaker, I have combed through the

Report which takes care of activities from

Tuesday to Friday. The Report of the

Committee of the Whole on NIA is

conspicuously missing in the Business of

the House. The Report of the Committee on

Special Budget on the activities of the

Electoral Commission and the new

Constitutional Instrument (C.I.) that the

Electoral Commission intends to bring are,

also conspicuously missing in the Business

of the House.

Mr Speaker, while the meetings took

place three and half months ago, the Clerks

were supposed to write the Report to be

presented when the House resumes. We

went on a break for three and half months;

we are back and at the first Business

Committee meetings, they were raised. The

Hon Majority Leader and Leader of

Government Business, who is also the

Chairman of the Business Committee

assured us that he would ensure the reports

were ready and would be programmed for

next Thursday. After the Committee has

considered, debated and adopted the

Reports, the EC and the officials of the NIA

would be scheduled to appear before the

House, so that we could iron out some of the

differences that would arise from the

answers they gave, since we met them

differently on their data, and on the

justification for the steps that they are

taking.

Mr Speaker, the whole nation as well as

Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) are

interested in this.

The whole House wanted to meet the

Electoral Commission (EC), but Hon

Chairman opted that it should be Special

Budget Committee. So, now that the

Committee has met them, the Report should

be brought to the House for every Hon

Member to know what happened and what

is going to happen; we cannot keep them in

the dark.

Hon Majority Chief Whip and Acting

Chairman of the Business Committee, you

may assure this House when those Reports

are going to be presented to the House, and

also alert the House when officials of the

EC and National Identification Authority

(NIA) would be appearing before House.

The assurance was that we must debate,

adopt the Report and meet the officials

before we know the next line of action on

the Constitutional Instrument (CI) that they

are bringing. We do not want to ambush any

Hon Member in this House.

Hon Majority Chief Whip, is there any

indication?
Mr Speaker 10:42 a.m.
Hon Members, are there
any more comments before the Acting
Chairman comes in?
Hon Majority Chief Whip, take note of
the comments, so that when you come, you
can respond to them.
Yes, Hon Majority Leader?
Mr Haruna Iddrisu 10:42 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I have
two observations. One is in relation to
article 187(6) of the 1992 Constitution and,
with your indulgence, I will refer to it. It is
a matter that I brought up strongly at the
Business Committee and Mr Speaker, we

Business of the House

need your guidance. Article 187 (6) is on the

Auditor-General and it reads:

“Parliament shall debate the report of the Auditor-General and appoint where

necessary, in the public interest, a

committee to deal with any matters

rising from it”

Mr Speaker, there is some conflict of the

law. The Supreme Court has ruled on

matters relating to surcharge and

disallowable allowances by the Auditor-

General. The conflict is whether the

Auditor-General can proceed to do those

things even when Parliament has not

constituted this committee. I think that

Parliament must help the public purse in

getting this committee constituted. I raised

it at the Business Committee and with the

Hon Majority Leader and he agreed with me

that, probably, we should get a retired jurist

or a retired Member of Parliament with

good standing in accounting because

misappropriation, embezzlement and all the

fraud associated with the Auditor-General's Report — Tomorrow, when we are asked of what we have done beyond the Public

Accounts Committee, we do not seem to

have any answers.

Mr Speaker, we would need your

guidance for us to constitute this seven-

member committee. You have chaired this

Committee and we are proud you

discharged yourself like Mr Kan-Dapaah

and many others who have chaired it, but

beyond Public Account debate, what should

we do vis-à-vis the Supreme Court ruling?

Mr Speaker, the second issue is what Mr

Ahmed Ibrahim has raised. There is

discrepancy in the numbers between what

the EC has registered as voters, which is 17

million, and what is on the roll of the NIA.

We have heard that the EC wants to rely on

the NIA data. The primary question Mr

Ahmed Ibrahim asked is, what has

happened to the EC's own biometric data and that, today, they are avoiding the use of

their own biometric data they collected and

they want to collect bio-data from the NIA.

We need a reconciliation of the numbers

because we are very convinced that article

42 confers a right on Ghanaians to be

registered as voters by the EC.

The NIA is unlike the EC, which by

virtue of article 45 of the 1992 Constitution,

says that it shall not be subject to the

direction and control of any person or

authority -- the words are mine -- including the President, but NIA is subject

to ministerial control. Therefore, we want

the two bodies to come here -- EC and NIA -- let us see the discrepancy and variance in their numbers because we will not accept

any attempt by the EC to disenfranchise any

Ghanaian because they want to rely on an

identity card which is not available to

Ghanaians. We mean serious business on

this matter and we would jealously protect

and safeguard that right as provided for in

article 42 of the 1992 Constitution.

Mr Speaker, what the Mr Ahmed Ibrahim

is saying is that the two institutions must

come here and then we will hear from them

and reconcile the numbers. In fact, the EC

must further explain to this House how

come Ghanaians who have attained the age

of 18 years in 2021 and 2022 have not been

given the opportunity to be on the electoral

roll; that is a denial of the right under article

42 of the 1992 Constitution. The Constitu-

tion imposes a burden on us to protect this

Constitution, so any effort by any institution

to erode that right will be resisted and we

will resist that oppressor's rule.

Mr Speaker, thank you.

Business of the House
Mr Speaker 10:42 a.m.
Yes, Hon Acting Chairman?
Mr Annoh-Dompreh 10:42 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I do
not think there is a cause for alarm. In this
House, as is practised on many occasions,
there are Businesses that have been
discussed at the Business Committee and
inadvertently left out when the Business
Statement is finally presented. I think this is
pure omission because I was at the Business
Committee just as my Hon Colleague said;
it was mentioned and the Hon Majority
Leader gave an indication that he would
eventually ensure that it finds expression
within the Business Statement.
I guess it is because the Report is not
finally done with. We would relate
appropriately and get the Report, so that we
can present it duly; but to programme these
institutions to appear before us, I do not
think there is any difficulty, so that would
also be done. We would relate properly to
the Hon Chairman of the Business
Committee and I am confident that the
needful would be done.
Mr Speaker, I could not have agreed
more with the Hon Minority Leader on
article 187(6) of the 1992 Constitution. On
many occasions when the Auditor-
General's Reports come up, this matter has always come as a subject of discussion and
more often, we have just paid lip service to
it, practically ensuring that this thing is
always left undone.
Mr Speaker, this morning, you duly
related to why the Ad hoc Committee has
not been formed. I would want to assure
Hon Colleagues that we would relate
properly to the Hon Majority Leader and
Chairman of the Committee. The Hon
Minority Leader rightly admitted that the
Hon Leader of Government Business also
agreed that matters related to article 187 of
the 1992 Constitution is something that
should not be in doubt. So, I do not think
that we are at cross-purposes; we are all
speaking to the same concern and I am
confident that eventually, we would resolve
all these concerns. So, to double assure Hon
Members, these institutions would be
programmed duly when the necessary
consultation is done.
Mr Speaker, I thank you.
Mr Speaker 10:42 a.m.
Yes, Hon Member?
Mr Kwame Governs Agboza 10:42 a.m.
Mr Speaker,
I thank you for the opportunity. I would like
to find out form the Hon Majority Chief
Whip, if it would be possible to schedule the
District Assemblies Common Fund
(DACF) Administrator urgently to meet
with Hon Members to apprise us on steps
she is taking to make funds available to the
Regional Coordinating Councils (RCCs)
and the District Assemblies since the
inability to release these statutory funds is
making the RCCs and the Assemblies
dysfunctional.
Basically, people go to work and do
nothing because their budget cannot be
implemented due to lack of funding. I
believe it is affecting the effectiveness of
Members of Parliament (MPS) as well
because they have also leverage on little that
comes to us to support the little projects in
our communities. Could the Hon Leader of
Government Business schedule the DACF
Administrator to also appear before the
House to apprise us what is going on?
Mr Speaker, I thank you for the
opportunity.
Mr Speaker 10:42 a.m.
Yes, Hon Acting Chairman
— Well, there is another person; just take the two together and then you can respond.
Yes, Hon Member?

Business of the House
Mr Kofi Iddie Adams 10:52 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
thank you very much.
Mine has to do with the appearance of the
Hon Minister for Food and Agriculture to
answer some Questions.
During the last days of our Second
Meeting, I filed a Question which was
admitted and published on the Order Paper
including the Answer for the Hon Minister
to come to the House to answer. He came
around but he did not get the opportunity to
read out the Answers. I have realised that he
has been scheduled to appear here again on
2nd November, 2022, to answer some
Questions.
However, the earlier Questions he could
not read have not been added to the
Answers published on the Order Paper. I do
not know whether it is the consideration that
once they have been published, they have
been answered, so I can take the next step
as far as the Answers published in the Order
Paper are concerned.
Dr Clement Abas Apaak 10:52 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
thank you for indulging me.
I would like to find out from the Management
Committee of the Parliamentary Friendship
Association why there seems to be a lack of
progress after you inaugurated the
Management Committee on the 23rd of
June, 2022, where you called on all of us to
actively participate by joining these
associations to improve our parliamentary
diplomatic skills.
One would have thought that by now,
Hon Members would know which
friendship associations they have been
assigned to, the leadership thereof, and they
would have initiated some level of activity.
That is not happening, and I think it is only
fair that we know why.
Mr Speaker 10:52 p.m.
I think the Hon Acting
Chairman can now respond.
Mr Annoh-Dompreh 10:52 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
think the first concern by my Hon good
Friend, Mr Kwame Agbodza, is a justifiable
call.
Before we rose, it was a discussion that
Leadership engaged in, but I can assure you
that we have started discussions to find out
what the schedule and the plan is to deal
with these arrears specific to the Common
Fund. So, I support the Hon Member. We
would do the needful.
Mr Speaker, on Mr Kofi Adams' question, we would relate to the Table
Office. He spoke to it because it was an
outstanding Question and the agricultural
sector has been programmed to appear
before the House. Ordinarily, we would
have expected that Question would be
picked, but he can also admit that there are
processes involved in this before the
Questions finally appear on the Order
Paper. I am sure it has to do with
notification. So, we would relate to the
Table Office and deal with it.
Mr Speaker, the last question by Mr
Apaak, with your leave, the Hon Deputy
Majority Leader has some good answers to
his question. So, I would defer that question
to him to answer.
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Hon Members, before I
move to the adoption of the Report, it is
important for me to add a word on the issue
that has been raised in connection with the
Public Accounts Committee's (PAC) recommendations. This issue cropped up

Business of the House

when I was the Chairman of PAC, and that

was what urged Parliament to pass a law to

establish the PAC Recommendations,

Implementation Committees at every

Ministry, Department and Agency (MDA),

so that after the recommendations are

adopted by the House, those committees

were empowered to take them on and see to

the implementation or rectification of

whatever errors or gaps that were identified.

I think those committees are functioning.

In fact, when I was the Chairman, I used

to request the list of membership of the

committees from each MDA annually and

they used to submit them. If you really

followed up throughout, they have been

submitting their reports to the Committee.

Parliament has succeeded in using the

Auditor-General's Department in retrieving a lot of the funds that are usually found to

have either been embezzled, mismanaged or

whatever.

There have been some prosecutions in

this matter. Maybe, we would need to get

the PAC to regularly brief the House on the

progress made so far. If we are not satisfied

with the performances of those committees,

and we think that after the consideration of

any report, there is the need for us to

establish a committee to follow up on some

issues, we could then proceed to do so.

However, we thought that it was not

necessary to be establishing committees

after the debate of any of the reports; we

decided to establish permanent Committees

at that level because of the

implementational challenges.

Therefore, I would direct that the PAC

should follow-up on this concern and

submit to the House a report on the

performance of those implementation

Committees for us to discuss and see

whether they are effective. If they are not,

and we want to improve upon it, and

establish a permanent committee in the

House chaired by any Jurist or whatever, we

could then proceed to do so. However, it is

a concern of not only Hon Members, but the

entire country. It is something that we have

to take seriously. I do not see the Chairman

of the PAC; I have information that he is on

a national assignment out of the country, but

I am sure that some Hon Members of the

Committee are available, and they should

draw his attention.

I believe that within a month, we should

get the Report before we go on recess. I am

sure the Vice Chairman listened to me. So,

we will proceed on that issue accordingly

and see how best we could improve upon

the current situation.

I have not also seen anything from the

Electoral Commission (EC), and I have not

been given any brief by the EC on any

proposed Instrument coming from them. I

raised this issue some time ago; I am yet to

receive them and to be briefed on it. Until

that is done, they should forget about laying

such Instrument in the House.

I think, there has been a misinterpretation

and a misunderstanding of the concept of

independence of the various State institutions

or arms of Government that are stated by the

1992 Constitution to be independent. The

independence is in the performance of their

functions. When the matter comes before

Parliament, that is the performance of our

function and not their function.

They cannot say that they are not subject

to the control of anybody, including the

institution of Parliament. For that time, that

is our function which we are going to

perform, and we are not subject to the

Business of the House

control of any arm of Government or

institution of State.

So, please, the Electoral Commission

(EC), the Bank of Ghana (BoG), including

the Judiciary, should take note that their

independence does not mean that

independence has ousted Parliament from

performing its functions; so, if the

Constitutional Instrument (C.I.) is to come

to the House, the proper thing must be done.

Both procedural and substantive laws must

be followed.

I would not allow any such Instrument to

be laid in this House until I am briefed, and

I think that it is the proper thing to do

together with the House to make sure that

the right thing is done in accordance with

the provisions of the Constitution. Anybody

who is not satisfied is permitted to proceed

to the Supreme Court on this matter. [Hear!

So, please, it is in their own interest to

proceed to have the pre-laying meetings,

not only with the Committee, but with the

Leadership of the House before anything

can be submitted and be captured by our

Order Paper. That, I believe, is sufficient

notice to all.

Hon Members, on the issue of the

Parliamentary Friendship Associations, I

am really down-spirited that it has taken

such a long time for the House to get to

know the membership of these Friendship

Associations and to write to our various

Associations and Parliaments for the full

compliments of these associations.

On daily basis, I receive requests from

various Parliaments and Associations

asking for the list of our Hon Members, and

I have always minuted them to the Clerk to

Parliament. It is recently that I have been

briefed that they have to be inaugurated, and

they have not been inaugurated; so, I have

directed that they get a date for us to do the

inauguration. These are urgent matters.

Anywhere we would go, if we are having

bilateral meetings, these things are usually

raised. The Management committee should

take due notice of this and act urgently on

this matter.

For the issue of the District Assemblies' Common Fund (DACF), I am sure the

information would have been sent to the

administrator, and as the acting chair has

stated, due notice has been taken and action

would be taken accordingly.

Mr Alexander Afenyo-Markin — rose

Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Hon Member, do you
expect me to recognise you?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker, under
normal circumstance —
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
The circumstances are not
normal. [Laughter] Yesterday, I asked you
to see me immediately after Sitting —
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Yes, Mr Speaker.
There were some emergencies, and I duly
communicated to your usher that there was
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
To who?
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker,
because he said you were in, and there were
some people with you, so I communicated
to him that there was an emergency that
would take me out immediately. I did, Mr
Speaker —
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
You communicated to my
usher, not to me. Well, the usher would

Business of the House

recognise you when you get up on the Floor.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker, that is
not the case. I apologise to you for the
miscommunication.
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
You are my son. You have
my number. You have everything of mine.
Your Hon Colleague came and we waited
yet you never showed up.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I am
sorry. He assured me that it was
communicated.
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Hon Members, I have told
you that the ability to catch my eye includes
conduct of good behaviour — [Laughter] — so that will be your last. I would forgive you.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker, you
know I am always obedient.
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Yes. Now, you have caught
my eye. You can say what you want to say.
Mr Afenyo-Markin 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I
would speak to the issue with regard to the
Friendship Association, because I chair the
Management Committee. Everything that
must be done has been done. A
memorandum was brought and I minuted to
your good Office. They brought their
budget.
Mr Speaker, you are down-spirited
because it has not been done. However, the
administrators are also looking for a
convenient date which would be suitable to
you to preside over the inauguration. So,
obviously, we would be knocking at your
door to see your convenient time, but we are
ready. Hon Members have expressed their
concern and they want it done as soon as
possible.
Mr Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Well, I would await the
memorandum. I have not received any such
memorandum in my office, and so we
would work on it immediately it comes.
Hon Members, the Business Statement as
presented by the Hon Majority Chief Whip,
for and on behalf of the Hon Majority
Leader and Chairman of the Business
Committee is hereby adopted, subject to the
various comments that have been made by
Hon Members.
Hon Members, the Hon First Deputy
Speaker to take the Chair.

11.10 a.m. —
MR FIRST DEPUTY SPEAKER
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Yes, Hon
Leader?
Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker,
Leadership has related appropriately, and
we have come to some conclusion, so I
would want to move a Motion for the House
to be adjourned to Tuesday, 1st November,
2022 at 10 o'clock in the forenoon.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:02 a.m.
Any —
Alhaji Muntaka 11:02 a.m.
Mr Speaker, rightly so,
our Hon Colleagues drew our attention to
the Cabinet meeting that is ongoing, and
today being Friday, other Committees
meetings have been advertised, and they
were of the view that we spend more time at
the Committees to finish the Committees' work, so we could have many more Reports
next week, God willing.

Therefore, I second the Motion for the

House to be adjourned to Tuesday at 10

o'clock in the forenoon.

Thank you, Mr Speaker.

Question put and Motion agreed to.
ADJOURNMENT 11:02 a.m.