Debates of 21 Feb 2023

MR SPEAKER
PRAYERS 11:04 a.m.

Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
Hon Members, we will take the item numbered 4 — Correction of Votes and Proceedings and the Official Report.
We will start with the Votes and
  • [No correction was made to the Votes and Proceedings of Friday, 17th February, 2023]
  • Dr Kingsley Nyarko 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, please, I need clarification on the last paragraph of column 70. It was written as “Unknown Speaker”. It presupposes that the person who spoke was not identified.
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Hon Member, thank you for drawing our attention. We would crosscheck to see what actually happened.
    Hon Members, in the absence of any
    further corrections, the Official Report of Thursday, 7th July, 2022, is hereby adopted as the true record of proceedings.
    We will move on to the item numbered
    5 — Urgent Questions.
    The Hon Minister for Health should
    take his appropriate seat. The Urgent Question stands in the name of Mr Francis-Xavier Kojo Sosu, the Hon Member of Parliament for Madina Constituency.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    URGENT QUESTIONS 11:04 a.m.

    MINISTRY OF HEALTH 11:04 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Hon Member, do you
    have any supplementary question?
    Mr Sosu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, yes. I would
    like to know from the Hon Minister for
    Health what urgent steps the Ministry
    would take to include the 40 per cent?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    that is a difficult question for me to answer. When we started the NHIS, and over the several years that we have practised it in our country, we did not have childhood cancers covered. It is only recently that we are gradually
    bringing in some of these cancers. When things improve, we do sustainability analysis of our health insurance system, and when there is a leeway to bring in some of these cancers, we include them.
    Mr Speaker, we are focusing and
    giving priority to children and women with cancers, and I believe that anytime that we add on to our benefit package, these would be included. However, we must tread cautiously for the sustain- ability of the health insurance we pride ourselves in.
    Mr Sosu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like to know from the Hon Minister whether, as a Ministry, they have taken note of the number of children with tumours and cancers sometimes paraded around the various streets with the intention of raising funds to support their treatment. If that has come to their attention, has the Ministry any plans to take steps to deal with that situation, given the fact that, at least, some cancers are covered under the
    NHIS?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I said earlier in my Answer that we had taken care of 60 per cent of childhood cancers. Apparently, the 60 per cent seems to constitute the commonest cancers in children. So definitely, there would be some 40 per cent left which are not very predominant as compared to the 60 per cent that we are dealing with now. However, as I said, we are not neglecting — we do not want to leave anybody behind, but we are treading cautiously to ensure the sustainability of our service.
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Hon Member, you may
    ask your last supplementary question.
    Mr Sosu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like to
    know from the Hon Minister what the
    Ministry would do about this outstanding
    40 per cent because it is becoming a
    nuisance, that one would be driving
    around the street and a child with some
    form of tumour or cancer would be
    paraded, with people soliciting for funds
    to support that child. Would the Ministry
    consider some public education in
    respect of this situation so that anytime
    children are paraded around like that,
    people who have knowledge or infor-
    mation on those children could refer
    them to some facilities that the Ministry
    would probably prescribe? It does not
    look good as a country, that one would
    be driving around the streets and children
    would be paraded. Sometimes, I feel we
    have become like a country without
    conscience. So, would the Ministry
    consider an action like that?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the Ministry is working in collaboration
    with several Civil Society Organisations
    (CSOs) and Non-Governmental Organi-
    sations (NGOs) that do advocacy in
    educating the populace on the types of
    cancers that we have. From the way my
    Hon Colleague is speaking, one can feel
    straightaway that those who parade the
    streets might not have encountered any
    facility even for any diagnosis to be
    done. It may be that the type of diseases
    that they have would be part of the 60 per
    cent that we are dealing with so we need
    to up our education. I have taken note of
    that to ensure that children with such
    conditions are first taken to hospitals for
    them to be diagnosed until the doctors
    say that those conditions are not covered
    under NHIS and so they should go back
    and find some other solution. Other than
    that, we would continue to have such
    situations in the middle of the streets.
    So, we will up our education and
    health promotion issues and see how best
    we can get all those children in the streets
    to the hospital, first for diagnosis, before
    we can differentiate between what is
    covered by the benefit package and what
    is not. However, the very common ones
    are the four that have been captured.
    Going forward, it is very likely and it is
    part of our strategy to add on the
    remaining cancers in children.
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Hon Members, we have
    exhausted the Urgent Question.
    Dr Kissi — rose —
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Hon Member, do you
    want to ask a supplementary question?
    Dr Dickson Adomako Kissi 11:04 a.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, yes.
    Mr Speaker, I would like to find out
    from the Hon Minister for Health if he is
    also aware that a lot of these cases
    sometimes are not necessarily cancers. I
    have seen some with hole-in-heart
    issues, fistulas or congenital anomalies,
    which are not necessarily cancers or

    tumours, and I think that in addition to

    his work, is it possible that the Ministry

    of Gender, Children and Social

    Protection could support in catering for

    some of these children on the streets?

    Unfortunately, they are paraded as

    tumours, but they are not.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    am very much aware of that situation.
    Some of them are not cancers. That is
    why in my Answer, I indicated to my
    Hon Colleague that the very common
    ones are those that have been stated. So,
    they should go to the hospital and be
    diagnosed to determine whether it is
    cancer.
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    We will move on to the
    item numbered 6, non-Urgent Questions.
    The first Question is the Question
    numbered 450, which stands in the name
    of Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey, the
    Hon Member of Parliament for Keta.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS 11:04 a.m.

    MINISTRY OF HEALTH 11:04 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Hon Minister, was the
    policy introduced by the Government or
    the Party?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:04 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    permit me to insert “Government”, for it
    to read: “… by the New Patriotic Party's
    Government …”
    I thank you for your correction.
    Mr Speaker 11:04 a.m.
    Yes, a party can propose
    a policy, but to introduce it, it must be by
    a government. So, even if you had said
    “the New Patriotic Party's Government”,
    that would have been understandable.
    Hon Member, do you have any
    supplementary questions?
    Mr Gakpey 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like
    to find out from the Hon Minister,
    whether he is aware that the Free
    Maternal Health Policy is working as it
    is in place but the pregnant women are
    paying for laboratory and caesarean
    section costs.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    am aware of some of the things
    happening in some of our facilities,
    where we have some service delivery
    incidences covered by the health insurance
    package, but some facilities continue to
    charge and even charge for medicines, et
    cetera. However, I would plead with my
    Hon Colleague that until people begin to
    complain and tell us what is happening
    in the local facilities, we find it difficult
    identifying all these challenges.
    So, if my Hon Colleague is citing
    examples in his constituency, we have
    National Health Insurance Authority
    (NHIA) district officers.
    So, find a way to let them know, and
    they would carry the message to us. Then
    we would confront the facilities engaged
    in those activities and try to resolve such
    incidences.
    Mr Gakpey 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like
    to find out from the Hon Minister, based
    on his answer, whether he is aware of an
    investigative piece done by Joy FM,
    called ‘Pay or Die', where pregnant women are detained until they pay for
    their expenses before they are released.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    am afraid, I am not aware of this
    documentary that my Hon Colleague is
    talking about.
    Mr Speaker 11:24 a.m.
    Hon Member, you may
    ask your last supplementary question.
    Mr Gakpey 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like
    to find out from the Hon Minister
    whether he was able to do something
    about the issues that cut across the whole
    country about pregnant women paying
    for laboratory services. If he did
    something about that when it came to his
    attention, what was his strategy?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, we
    pick a lot of information from the media,
    but in this particular instance, I am
    afraid, I cannot own up that I am aware

    of this. I am not aware but I would check

    on it and see what was actually reported.

    However, I believe that is exactly what

    he has put in front of me now to answer.
    Mr Speaker 11:24 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Members, we
    would move on to the Question
    numbered 571 on the Order Paper, which
    stands in the name of the Hon Member
    for Nalerigu/Gambaga, Mr Seidu Issifu.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    Plans to Upgrade Gambaga
    Health Centre to Municipal Hospital
    Mr Seidu Issifu (NDC — Nalerigu/ Gambaga) 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Hon Minister for Health the plans the
    Ministry has to upgrade the Gambaga
    Health Centre to a municipal hospital.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, we
    are aware that Gambaga is the capital of
    the East Mamprusi Municipality. There
    is a Baptist hospital at Nalerigu which
    serves as a district hospital to the
    population. Therefore, due to proximity
    and the Ministry's policy of one district one hospital, it is not currently feasible to
    upgrade the facility into another district
    hospital.
    However, let me assure this House that
    as and when the Ministry receives any
    financial proposal in line with the
    Government Hospital's Infrastructural Project, Gambaga will be duly considered
    for refurbishment and an upgrade to a
    polyclinic.
    Mr Speaker 11:24 a.m.
    Hon Member, do you
    have any supplementary question?
    Mr Issifu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, in the Hon
    Minister's response, he alluded to the fact that due to proximity, Gambaga
    Health Centre is not on their radar for an
    upgrade. Is the Hon Minister aware that
    the Baptist Medical Centre (BMC) does
    not only serve the Nalerigu-Gambaga
    enclave? It extends to Yunyoo,
    Bunkpurugu and, possibly, Chereponi.
    The coverage area of this hospital is
    quite vast, so, there is a lot of congestion
    in this hospital. Therefore, I was rather of
    the view that because of these
    peculiarities, if possible, Gambaga
    should be looked at as a special case for
    consideration to be upgraded into a
    polyclinic. Is the Hon Minister aware of
    the level of congestion in BMC and its
    status as a referral hospital?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    mentioned that we are looking forward to
    upgrading the Gambaga Health Centre
    into a polyclinic when resources become
    available. When that is done, we would
    offload some of the congestion in BMC
    to the Gambaga polyclinic, but that
    would depend on how quick we can get
    resources to do that. However, at least, I
    know of other smaller facilities in the
    Hon Member's constituency. I have visited Binde and the facility there was
    super. They take a lot of primary care
    issues there. There are other small

    compounds beyond Binde to Yunyoo

    and Bunkpurugu. Therefore, regarding

    the congestion in BMC, if we are able to

    upgrade the Gambaga Health Centre into

    a polyclinic and increase the service

    delivery at Gambaga, the congestion

    would slow down a little bit for us.
    Mr Issifu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, it looks like
    the Hon Minister and I are operating at
    the same level. Due to these complexities
    and the nature of the problems we have
    at the BMC, I would want to find out if
    the Hon Minister could assist us to make
    it a special case.
    Mr Speaker, I said a special case
    because the Gambaga Health Centre
    already has some facilities that are close
    to that of a polyclinic. They have a
    medical doctor, a physician assistant, et
    cetera. What the health centre requires is
    just the provision of the wards and a
    theatre. So, it is very easy to get this to
    that status. I want to find out whether the
    Hon Minister can assist us catalyse this
    need, in order to get it upgraded.
    Mr Speaker 11:24 a.m.
    Hon Minister, actually
    the Hon Member is asking for the
    hospital to be upgraded to a municipal
    hospital, not a district hospital. Your
    answer is about district hospital, but the
    Hon Member is asking for a municipal
    hospital, which we know, is higher than
    a district hospital. That is what the Hon
    Member is asking for because the place
    is now a municipality, and Gambaga is
    the capital. So, the Hon Member is
    looking for a higher one, and not a small
    district hospital.
    Hon Minister, please, it is just about
    upgrading. The Hon Member has given
    you all the facilities they have. Can you
    add something to it to make it a
    municipal?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    have taken note of my Hon Member's
    plea, but there are other things that are
    coming round to that same area. North-
    East deserves a regional facility, and we
    have earmarked between Nalerigu and
    Gambaga to put up a regional hospital.
    So, putting up a new Mamprusi Municipal
    Hospital in addition to a regional facility
    — However, I have taken note of his
    plea, and we would see how best we can
    work on that. I know that area quite well,
    so I would see the best I can do for the
    people in Nalerigu/Gambaga.
    Mr Issifu 11:24 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I do not agree
    with the last statement made by the Hon
    Minister.
    Mr Speaker 11:24 a.m.
    Hon Member, it is not
    about agreeing or disagreeing. You ask a
    question, and the Hon Minister gives you
    an answer. You can disagree with the
    Hon Minister, but in this instance, you
    are to ask a supplementary question. If
    you disagree with him, go and meet him
    to disagree with him, but in this case, you
    are to ask another supplementary
    question.

    I am giving you special dispensation

    because of Gambaga. Gambaga is a

    special town; it is not just the scarp.

    Historically, Gambaga has been the

    capital of the whole Northern Territories.

    It is a special town that should be given

    some special consideration. I support

    you but ask your last supplementary

    question.
    Mr Issifu 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, my last
    question to the Hon Minister for Health
    is to draw his attention to the fact that if
    the country is looking at putting up a
    regional hospital, it should not be a
    compensation for the municipal hospital
    because there are regional hospitals,
    polyclinics, et cetera in other areas. All
    these things are geared towards quality
    healthcare delivery. I would like to
    propose to the Hon Minster that whether
    there is a regional hospital in the offing
    or not, there is a need to look at this
    Gambaga Health Centre status and how
    quick we can upgrade it to a municipal
    hospital. This is my plea to the Hon
    Minister.
    Mr Speaker 11:34 a.m.
    Very well.
    Hon Member, it is not a supplementary
    question. Instead, it is an appeal.
    Mr Emmanuel Armah-Kofi Buah 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, in the Answer provided by
    the Hon Minister, he stated that the
    Baptist hospital in Nalerigu is the reason
    there would not be a district hospital.
    What I would like to know from the Hon
    Minister is whether the Baptist hospital
    is a government hospital or a mission
    hospital. He also said that there are plans
    for a regional hospital.
    The Hon Minister then proceeded to
    provide timelines on that regional
    hospital that he talked about, stating
    when the funding will be ready, which is
    the basis for not building the municipal
    hospital that has been asked for. Could
    the Hon Minister give us more details
    about the regional hospital?
    Mr Speaker 11:34 a.m.
    Hon Member, I have
    given you this dispensation because of
    your position as a Leader. However, you
    have asked a number of questions as
    supplementary questions, which should
    not have been so.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    cannot answer some of the questions
    asked by the Hon Deputy Minority
    Leader; I cannot answer questions about
    some specific dates and timelines in the
    Ministry's strategic plan. It would be very difficult for me to do so.
    Mr Speaker, as I stand here, I always
    think about the Committee on Government
    Assurance and I would want to avoid a
    situation where the Hon Member would
    take me there to ask me questions. I do
    not want to commit myself to anything.
    It is part of our strategic plan; it would
    happen and the timing would not be very
    far away.

    Mr Speaker, I would like to inform my

    Hon Colleague that the Ministry of

    Health, the Government of Ghana, and

    the Missions have been collaborating to

    run some facilities for us in some

    districts. Some mission hospitals have

    been identified, dedicated and assigned

    as our district hospitals. We pay their

    doctors and nurses. We also give them

    equipment if we have them, and at times,

    we help them to carry out infrastructural

    projects, and the Baptist Medical Centre

    (BMC), is one of such facilities.
    Mr Speaker 11:34 a.m.
    Hon Members, we will
    now move on to Question number 720,
    which stands in the name of the Hon
    Member for Madina, Mr Francis-Xavier
    Kojo Sosu.
    Specific Measures to Improve Health
    Infrastructure at Madina
    Mr Francis-Xavier Kojo Sosu (NDC
    — Madina): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Hon Minister for Health what specific
    measures are in place to improve health
    infrastructure at Madina, including the
    construction of a CHPS compound
    within Madina West and Madina Zongo,
    and the operationalisation of CHPS
    compounds at Otinibi and Teiman.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    wish to state that currently, the named
    communities have not been captured in
    our 2023 plans and there is no budget for
    any construction of CHPS compounds.
    The Ministry is, however, liaising with
    the Ghana Health Service (GHS) for
    assessment based on the requests and
    evaluating them for consideration and
    budget in the ensuing years.
    Mr Speaker, the Ministry's ability to implement this will largely depend on
    the quantum of budgetary allocation to
    the Ministry in subsequent years. The
    Otinibi and Teiman CHPS compounds
    are all ongoing projects under the
    Assembly.
    Mr Speaker, the Ministry will work
    closely with the Assembly to ensure
    completion and use.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Speaker 11:34 a.m.
    Hon Member, do you
    have a supplementary question?
    Mr Sosu 11:34 a.m.
    Yes, Mr Speaker.
    I would like to understand the Hon
    Minister for Health clearly. Is he saying
    that the health infrastructure of Madina
    or the allocation to the improvement of
    the health infrastructure of Madina is not
    captured under the 2023 Budget allocation?
    That is the first part of the question. I
    heard him say that that was not captured
    in the 2023 Budget Statement.
    The second part of my question is
    about the steps taken by the Ministry to
    improve health infrastructure; consi-
    dering the fact that Madina, as a
    constituency, is expanding with over
    200,000 citizens living there. Is the Hon
    Minister saying that the constituency

    was not captured in the 2023 Budget

    Statement as far as infrastructure is

    concerned?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, as
    part of our plans, we are thinking about
    the entire nation and we identify
    constituencies based on assessments. We
    have not been able to capture the specific
    communities he is talking about in our
    very short-term plans. However, based
    on the Hon Member's demand, we have asked GHS to do that assessment to see
    how we could easily situate a facility
    over there.
    Mr Speaker, I would ask my Hon
    Colleague to liaise with land owners in
    Madina to enable us get land to put up
    what would become the Hon Member's ‘way of going forward' in that place. The unfortunate thing is that the Ga East
    Hospital, where we used to treat
    COVID-19, was supposed to have been
    a district hospital for Madina. However,
    due to land issues, we had to relocate the
    facility, and that is how come we got it
    closer to the Ghana Atomic Energy
    Commission (GAEC). Therefore, as we
    are working towards improving facilities
    everywhere, two things determine the
    siting and location of the hospitals — land and budgetary resources.
    Mr Speaker, when we get budgetary
    resources but we do not have land, it
    would be difficult to put up the facility.
    However, on our part, we would look for
    budgetary resources, and I would appeal
    to my Hon Colleague in that area to also
    begin to look for land. Let us see how we
    would collaborate when we get
    resources. We would not find challenges
    with the land.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Sosu 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like to
    thank the Hon Minister for extending a
    hand of fellowship towards me,
    particularly, with respect to the fact that
    when the matter was brought to his
    attention, he was willing to do something
    about it. For example, within Madina
    Zongo, there is a place that could be used
    for a CHPS compound, and anytime the
    Hon Minster is ready, we could work on
    that.
    Mr Speaker, also, when we talk about
    land for a major infrastructure, the Danfa
    Chief has reached out to help in that
    regard. I know that there was some effort
    to begin some Agenda 111 projects
    there. At least, something is going on
    over there, and I believe that a little
    commitment from the Government
    should be able to lead us through.
    Mr Speaker, talking about health
    infrastructure, the Municipal Health
    Directorate itself has some challenges
    when it comes to funding. As we speak
    now, they have to relocate, so, I would
    like to find out the specific steps that the
    Hon Minister would take to assist the
    Municipal Health Directorate as part of
    its contribution to health infrastructure in
    Madina to furnish their office and
    provide accommodation.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:34 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, ideally, I did not prepare to come and answer questions on health directorates; they are a different ball game altogether. However, since all depend on budgetary allocation and resources, anytime funds are available, we would see how best we can support the Directorate.
    ANNOUNCEMENTS 11:44 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 11:44 a.m.
    Hon Members, I would want to crave your indulgence, parti- cularly, the Hon Minister for Health, to acknowledge the presence in the House of a distinguished delegation from the Parliament of Panama. Their Parliament is referred to as the National Assembly of Panama, and I would proceed to introduce them to you.
    They are on a very important visit to
    Ghana. The delegation is in the House, to among other things, hold discussions in the area of parliamentary collaboration, bilateral economic operation, and ways of strengthening relations between the two countries. The visit is further intended to create the platform for networking between Hon Members and their counterparts in Panama, with the aim to deepen relations between the two Legislatures.
    Hon Members, with your kind
    permission, I introduce the delegation.
    My Colleague Speaker, Hon Crispiano
    A. Navarro is the President of the
    National Assembly [Hear! Hear!]. He is
    accompanied by his beautiful wife, Mrs
    Margarita De Leon Martinez, who is the
    President of the Spouses of Parlia-
    mentarians in the National Assembly.
    [Hear! Hear!] Hon Members, your Hon
    Colleagues in Nigeria also have House of
    Representative Members' Wives Asso- ciation of Nigeria, but you do not have
    one.
    Hon Members, with the Speaker of the
    National Assembly is Hon Kayra Harding
    Bart, the Vice-President of the National
    Assembly, and the Vice President of the
    ParlAmericas Parliament. For your
    information, the ParlAmericas Parlia-
    ment is the union Parliament of all Latin
    American Parliaments; a similar one we
    have is the Economic Community of
    West African States (ECOWAS) Parlia-
    ment [Hear! Hear!].
    She is not in the House alone; she is
    here with her husband. Her husband is
    our own, a son of the soil; he is a Ghanaian,
    Mr Prince Anthony Kwasi Bart-Appiah
    — [Hear! Hear!]. By the name alone, we know where he comes from. He is the
    son of the Omanhene of Akwamu. Many
    of you do not know how important
    Akwamu is to the history of Ghana. Go
    and read about it. The key of the Osu Castle
    is at Akwamufie. They have conquered
    and taken over the castle before.

    Hon Members, on your behalf, I would

    want to warmly welcome them, together

    with the Panama Consul-General to

    Turkey, in the name of H. E. Abraham J.

    Segovia De Leon. They are accompanied

    by a number of officials. The first is Mr

    Darren A. Robinson; the second, Mr

    Camero F. Gordon; and the last but not

    least, Mr Maximilian G. N. Monasterio.

    Hon Members, these are investors who

    have come to explore the country to find

    opportunities to invest in Ghana. We

    have already invested through marriage.

    [Laughter] The information I gather is

    that they have this special interest, which

    they would like to actualise between

    On behalf of the Hon Members of

    Parliament, the Parliament of Ghana and

    on my part, I welcome the delegation to

    Parliament, and I wish them fruitful

    deliberations. You are back home. You

    are always welcome. Enjoy the warm

    hospitality of the people of Ghana. You

    are welcome.

    Hon Members, we would get back to

    Questions. After that, you could interact

    with them. Those of you who would like

    to go to Panama, they would definitely

    make it possible. I do not know how

    many of you have ever been there. How

    many of you have ever been to Panama?
  • [The Hon Member for Ketu South raised her hand.]
  • Mr Speaker 11:44 a.m.
    One Hon Member?
    Hon Members, we will immediately
    form a friendship association and
    arrange for us to visit Panama.
    Hon Members, the next Question
    numbered 740 stands in the name of the
    Hon Member for Sawla/Tuna/Kalba, Mr
    Andrew Dari Chiwitey.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    Mr Alalzuuga — rose —
    Mr Speaker 11:44 a.m.
    Yes, please?
    Mr Albert Akuka Alalzuuga 11:44 a.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity.
    My Hon Colleague and Friend, Mr
    Andrew Dari Chiwitey, is receiving a
    delegation of chiefs from his
    constituency, so he has delegated me to
    ask this Question on his behalf.
    Mr Speaker 11:44 a.m.
    Hon Member, you may
    ask the Question on his behalf.
    ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS 11:44 a.m.

    MINISTRY OF HEALTH 11:44 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 11:44 a.m.
    Hon Member, do you
    have supplementary questions?
    Mr Alalzuuga 11:44 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, yes.
    I would like to find out from the Hon
    Minister what steps he would take to
    ensure, as indicated in his Answer, that
    this project would be repackaged in 2023
    for furnishing or finishing?
    Mr Speaker 11:54 a.m.
    Hon Member, I see the
    Answer to be the Composite Budget and
    the Annual Action Plan for the District
    Assembly and not the Ministry of
    Health. The district assemblies are not
    under the Ministry of Health, and I do
    not know how the Hon Minister can
    come in here.
    Mr Alalzuuga 11:54 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I was just
    wondering if the Hon Minister can help
    to ensure that this project is — because it is directly under his Ministry, although
    the project is not. I am told that the
    Porun community is far away from the
    Sawla township, and the people really
    have challenges in terms of health
    service delivery. Somehow, we would
    like the Hon Minister to help ensure that
    the facility is completed, even though it
    was not awarded by him.
    Mr Speaker 11:54 a.m.
    Hon Minister, is there
    anything that the Ministry of Health can
    do to help complete the project?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:54 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the only thing I can tell my Hon
    Colleague is the fact that the information
    we got actually came from the District
    Directorate of Health; they were those
    who went to find out from the Assembly
    how they were trying to finish that
    facility. I may only have to get back to
    them and try to press them to push the
    District Chief Executive to ensure that

    during their 2023 budget imple-

    mentation, this facility is not left behind.

    We would be ready to support with

    equipment when they finish with the

    project. So far as doors are not fitted,

    there are few more things to do. The only

    thing we can do is to wait and let them

    finish it. The repackaging, unfortunately,

    cannot be done by us. It is those who

    awarded the contract who can actually

    terminate and repackage. Thus, we

    would try and remind the District Chief

    Executive of the area to see how best he

    can work with the 2023 Composite

    Budget to complete the facility.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Speaker 11:54 a.m.
    Yes, any further
    supplementary question?
    Mr Alalzuuga 11:54 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, this is
    just an appeal. I know the community in
    question, even though I am not from that
    constituency. We are appealing to the
    Hon Minister to use his good office to
    ensure that this project is completed for
    the good people of Porun.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Speaker 11:54 a.m.
    Hon Member, that is
    just an appeal and not a supplementary
    question.
    Mr Frank Annoh-Dompreh 11:54 a.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, with respect, even though the
    Hon Minister has answered the Question,
    some of the answers are worrying
    because we have read from the Hon
    Minister's own Answer that the contract was awarded in 2016, and what is
    outstanding is painting and finishing
    works. It is worrying and the difficulty is
    that there is the dearth of flow of funding
    from DDF.
    I would like to find out from the Hon
    Minister if we have an establishment at
    the Ministry that supervises to know
    health-related projects that necessarily
    are not funded by the Ministry. For
    instance, DDF comes under the auspices
    of the district assembly, but the Hon
    Minister is here answering Questions
    related to that, so what is the correlation
    between the Hon Minister's outfit and projects that are health-related, yet are
    being funded by the district assembly?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:54 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    think that I have said early on that we
    collaborate with the assemblies. We have
    actually informed the Metropolitan,
    Municipal and District Chief Executives
    (MMDCEs) that anytime they want to
    embark upon health projects, they should
    let us know.
    In the first place, we have an
    infrastructure department that even
    approves of their design before they
    award these contracts, but there are
    several health projects dotted across the
    country which are on the blind side,
    unfortunately, of the Ministry, and the Rt
    Hon Speaker is aware of these things that
    I am talking about. They would not
    inform the Ministry until an MP comes

    here to ask about a facility, then we go

    and do a search and find that it was

    awarded by the District Assembly. When

    it comes to our notice in this way, we

    then begin to talk to the Assembly to see

    how and what help we can give to

    support.

    Mr Speaker, this one involves a

    contract to be funded by DDF. The

    contract is awarded and they may have to

    take the contract termination processes

    to actually terminate, repackage, re-

    award and let us see which new funding

    that they would use. Now that they have

    identified the source for funding to

    complete it in 2023, we would continue

    to collaborate and get to them to see how

    best that project will be completed.

    Honestly, we do not even have the

    resources to push them. The only thing is

    that our Regional and District Directors

    will continue to put the pressure on the

    Assembly to see how best they can

    complete this project.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Murtala Muhammed Ibrahim 11:54 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like some clarity
    from the Hon Minister on the issue of
    health centres or facilities that are
    provided by the Metropolitan, Municipal
    and District Assemblies (MMDAs) and
    sometimes, MPs. I refer to the
    relationships or linkages that exist
    between the Ministry for Local
    Government, Decentralisation and Rural
    Development and the Ministry of Health.
    I say this because there are instances
    where health facilities are provided, but
    the capacity to man them are exclusive of
    the Ministry of Health or GHS which
    falls under the Ministry of Health. Under
    that circumstance, what happens?
    Mr Speaker, I got a Qatari charity to
    provide a clinic in my constituency.
    After the clinic was provided, the
    responsibility to furnish the place was
    then left for me as the MP to provide, and
    I knew that it was the responsibility of
    the GHS, but I had to do that. Having
    provided the facilities, the manpower to
    run the facility was a problem because
    the Metropolitan Health Directorate felt
    that there was no communication
    between them and the Metropolitan
    Assembly. How do we avoid some of
    these challenges?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 11:54 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    this seems to be a peculiar constituency
    and MP-specific matter. I have also had
    that experience, but if one is an MP and
    tries to put up a facility, they do not do it
    on the blind side of the District or
    Municipal Health Directorate. When
    they get to know, they follow up with the
    MPs and offer them the support that they
    need.
    There was one particular community
    in my constituency that decided to put up
    a CHPS compound themselves. They did
    the design, went up to the roof, and came
    to me, and I went to visit the place. At
    the time, I was not the Minister for
    Health, but I saw a lot of things wrong

    with the design so, I went to the District

    Directorate.

    They had an estate person there, and

    they took him to the facility to look at

    how best we can pull down some places

    to redesign the place to suit what the

    health workers would like. That was

    done and, eventually, I took over that

    facility to provide resources from my

    Health Fund together with the District

    Director to try to fix that place. When

    they finished, I had to fall on the

    Ministry to try to see if we could get

    some equipment leftover in the stores to

    put in there. For furniture, I still had to

    procure some with my Health Fund to fix

    that place and the place is now working.

    Mr Speaker, immediately the District

    Director gets involved, it becomes his

    responsibility to provide the nurses and

    midwives to work, and it does not

    become the responsibility of the MP

    again. However, if the Hon Member

    wants to own and run it himself for the

    community, then, he would not get the

    staff that he needs. When the Hon

    Member finishes and hands it over to the

    District Directorate, they would give him

    the appropriate staff and capacity that is

    needed to manage the facility.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Speaker 11:54 a.m.
    Hon Members, we
    would now move on to the next Question
    numbered 1046, which stands in the
    name of the Hon Member for Anyaa/
    Sowutuom, Dr Dickson Adomako Kissi.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    Dr Kissi 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, it is always a
    wonderful opportunity. This Question
    has to do with non-communicable
    diseases, specifically hypertension,
    stroke and diabetes. A lot has been done
    with regard to COVID-19, and I know
    how much the Ministry has spent to
    support the reduction of the deaths
    associated with COVID-19. However,
    hypertension, diabetes and stroke are
    actually killing a lot of our people, and I
    would like to know what measures the
    Ministry is currently taking to help
    reduce the loss of very precious lives to
    these diseases.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    Hon Member, I really
    love and encourage people to innovate
    and try to improve on things, but this is a
    House where we have rules - a way of doing things - so you have to ask the Question as you presented it. In what you
    just said, you have used some terms
    different from what is in the Question.
    The Hon Minister has submitted a
    written Answer according to the
    Question you posed to him. Now, you
    have used different terminologies.
    Dr Kissi 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank you. I
    would take notice of that. So, may I read
    it?
    Mr Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    Yes, ask the Question.
    Steps to Address Non-Communicable
    Diseases
    Dr Dickson Adomako Kissi (NPP — Anyaa/Sowutuom) 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Hon Minister for Health the steps being taken to address diseases such as stroke, hypertension, and diabetes to reduce the large number of lives lost due to these diseases in our country.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the Ministry of Health is under-taking the following steps to reduce the large number of diseases such as stroke, hypertension, and diabetes in the country:
    1. The Ministry of Health, recognising
    the increasing incidence of Non- Communicable Diseases (NCDs), has reviewed and launched the National NCDs policy and strategy, and implementation has started and is on-going. The objectives of the NCDs policy are to:
    • Reduce exposure to risk
    factors that contribute to NCDs;
    • Strengthen early detection
    and management to reduce morbidity and mortality from NCDs;
    • Strengthen the health system
    for NCD prevention and control;
    • Strengthen multi-sectoral
    collaboration for NCD
    prevention and control; and
    • Ensure sustainable funding
    and other resources for NCD
    prevention and control.
    2. Treatment guidelines for cardio-
    vascular diseases have been
    completed and this is in use;
    3. Treatment guidelines for diabetes
    have reached the final draft stage
    and would soon be completed for
    use;
    4. Treatment guidelines of all the
    other NCDs are ongoing;
    5. Piloting of Wellness Clinic for
    early detection and diagnosis of
    NCDs has commenced in six
    districts as part of the imple-
    mentation of the NCD policy and
    strategy;
    6. The Essential Medicines list is
    being updated to include NCD
    drugs;
    7. The Ministry has inaugurated the
    National NCD Steering Committee,
    which comprises all Metro-
    politan, Municipal and District
    Assemblies (MMDAs), to assist in
    the governance of NCD prevention
    and control;

    8. Partnership with Novartis for Diabetes clinics;

    9. Partnership with Roche for Herceptin for Breast Cancer

    Treatment on National Health

    Insurance Authority (NHIA) drug

    list; and

    10. Partnership with Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale

    Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) for the

    implementation of the Heart

    Initiative.
    Mr Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    Yes, Hon Member, any
    supplementary questions?
    Dr Kissi 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, there would be
    no supplementary to that. It is very
    satisfactory. Thank you.
    Mr Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    I am most grateful.
    Hon Members, the same Hon Member
    for Anyaa/Sowutuom, Dr Dickson
    Adomako Kissi, has another Question to
    ask. That is Question number 1047.
    Hon Member, you may do so now.
    Improving the Ambulance Commute
    Time to Enhance the Efficiency of
    the Ambulance Service
    Dr Kissi Dickson Adomako (NPP —
    Anyaa/Sowutuom): Mr Speaker, I beg
    to ask the Hon Minister for Health how
    the ambulance commute time can be
    further improved to enhance the
    efficiency of the Ambulance Service,
    noting the bad nature of some roads in
    my constituency such as Aunty Aku,
    Anyaa NIC, Santa Maria, Lomnava, and
    Sowutuom roads.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    one of the key performance indicators of
    the operations of the National
    Ambulance Service (NAS) is Case
    Response Time (CRT), which is the time
    it takes the ambulance to respond to an
    emergency call after being dispatched by
    the Emergency Medical Dispatch
    Centre. The current average CRT of the
    Service is 20 minutes. Internationally,
    this should not be more than 10 minutes,
    all things being equal.
    One of the factors resulting in the high
    CRT is the bad road network, which
    affects the movement of the ambulance
    to respond to cases swiftly. The bad road
    network also affects the ambulances
    leading to mechanical component
    failures and thereby hampering the
    operations of the Service.
    To improve the ambulance commute
    time to enhance operational efficiency of
    the Service, there are two issues, which
    could be considered.
    The first one is to improve the road
    network in the Anyaa/Sowutuom
    Constituency, which is the responsibility
    of the Urban Roads under the Ministry of
    Roads and Highways as well as the
    Municipal Assembly.

    The second one is the establishment of

    additional ambulance stations within the

    Municipality to ensure that ambulances

    do not travel long distances to respond to

    emergency cases.

    The second issue, which is the

    responsibility of the Ministry of Health,

    requires the procurement of more

    ambulances and the training of

    Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs).

    Currently, the Government is in the

    process of procuring additional 112

    ambulances for the NAS, whilst the

    Service is also in the process of training

    more EMTs, who will be deployed to

    open more stations.

    I would like to inform the Hon

    Member for the Anyaa/Sowutuom that

    an additional ambulance station would

    be established in the constituency when

    the new ambulances are received and the

    personnel are trained. We would

    collaborate with the Urban Roads and the

    Municipal Assembly to ensure that the

    road network within the constituency is

    improved to enhance the operational

    efficiency of the NAS.
    Mr Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    Yes, any supplementary
    question?
    Dr Kissi 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am actually
    very happy with the connection of the
    road network and how the Hon Minister
    has collaborated. I am also thankful to
    note that we would be getting another
    ambulance considering our population.
    So, I think these Answers are just apt.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you very much.
    Mr Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    Hon Member, we are
    grateful for your brevity.
    Next is Question number 1151 which
    stands in the name of Mr Alfred Obeng-
    Boateng, the Hon Member for Bibiani-
    Anhwiaso-Bekwai.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    The Hon Second Deputy Speaker to
    take the Chair. Yes, go on.
    Plans to Improve Facilities of Sefwi
    Bekwai Health Centre
    Mr Alfred Obeng-Boateng (NPP — Bibiani-Anhwiaso-Bekwai) 12:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    I beg to ask the Hon Minister for Health
    what plans the Ministry has to improve
    the facilities of Sefwi Bekwai Health
    Centre, given its importance to the
    healthcare needs of the people within the
    Municipality.
    12.13 p.m. —
    MR SECOND DEPUTY SPEAKER
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:04 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Minister?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the Ministry of Health is aware that the
    population of Sefwi Bekwai is growing,
    and as part of our policy, it will require a

    much wider service package than it has

    currently. This means that the Health

    Centre will need to be upgraded in order

    to attract the required facilities and staff.

    However, the facility at Sefwi Bekwai

    has not been earmarked for upgrading in

    our 2023 Capital Investment Plan, and

    for that matter our budget for an upgrade

    this year.

    Mr Speaker, we would, however,

    liaise with the Ghana Health Service

    (GHS) to carry out an assessment based

    on this request, and evaluate the facility

    for consideration and budget in the

    ensuing years. Our ability to implement

    this would largely depend on the budget

    allocation to the Ministry in subsequent

    years.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Member for Bibiani-Anhwiaso-
    Bekwai, any supplementary question?
    Mr Obeng-Boateng 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    am very happy that the Hon Minister for
    Health is now aware of the large
    population of people within the Bekwai
    enclave. I am also happy that he is aware
    of the nature and condition of the only
    healthcare delivery centre within the
    area. My question is, could the Hon
    Minister, as an interim measure, assist in
    renovating the only healthcare centre we
    have within the Bekwai enclave, as we
    wait for future upgrade?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    have already mentioned that an
    assessment is going to be done, but I
    would consult with my Hon Colleague
    on the corridors and outside the Chamber
    to see what interim and immediate
    measures we could take to support his
    request.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Hon
    Member for Bibiani-Anhwiaso-Bekwai,
    have you exhausted your supplementary
    questions?
    Mr Obeng-Boateng 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    yes, I am all right.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Hon Members, let us turn to the
    Question numbered 1328 which stands
    in the name of the Hon Member for
    Juaboso, Mr Kwabena Mintah Akandoh.
    Yes, Hon Member for Juaboso?
    Dr Mark Kurt Nawaane 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    he is not around.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Very
    well. Hon Member for Nabdam, Dr Mark
    Kurt Nawaane, let us hear you on behalf
    of the Hon Member for Juaboso.

    Plans to Re-develop Accra

    Psychiatric Hospital

    Dr Mark Kurt Nawaane on behalf of

    Mr Kwabena Mintah Akandoh (NDC

    — Juaboso): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask

    the Hon Minister for Health what plans

    the Ministry has for the re-development

    of the Accra Psychiatric Hospital.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    wish to state that the re-development of
    the Accra Psychiatric Hospital remains a
    priority for the Ministry and is captured
    under the Agenda 111 flagship project.
    A consultant has been appointed and
    the design phase is about to be
    completed, beyond which tenders would
    be called for execution.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Member, any supplementary
    question?
    Dr Nawaane 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the land on
    which the Accra Psychiatric Hospital is
    located is a prime land. Two years ago,
    when we paid a visit to the place as a
    Committee, we expressed our reser-
    vation about part of the land being
    released to a private developer; that is
    whether it was going to be a Public-
    Private Partnership (PPP) and part of the
    land was going to be released to a private
    developer or the Government was going
    to develop everything.
    Now that the design phase from the
    Hon Minister's Answer has been completed, I would like to know what
    type of arrangement is in place, and
    whether the Government is going to
    develop the whole land or part of it is
    being given to a private developer?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    that was being considered, but not
    anymore. After this was listed as part of
    Agenda 111, the idea, concept and
    thinking of a private developer joining to
    develop the Accra Psychiatric Hospital
    has been suspended. We are not thinking
    about that any longer. We are going
    ahead to design, implement, and build a
    proper Government facility for Accra
    Psychiatric Hospital.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Member, your last slot?
    Dr Nawaane 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, it is clear
    that Agenda 111 projects cannot be
    completed by the end of the year 2024 as
    promised by the President. Indeed,
    during the Budget hearing, they said that
    about 30 per cent would be completed in
    2027. When we paid a visit to the place,
    in fact, it was appalling, so in the interim,
    what steps is the Ministry taking to
    improve the condition of the hospital?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    have also been visiting the Accra Psychiatric Hospital. From time to time,
    when we get some little allocations on our infrastructure budget, we support a

    little. Sometime in the year 2022, we had to allocate for the refurbishment of toilet

    facilities at the hospital. Unfortunately, we are not getting much to do what we

    actually plan to do, but when we get some resources, we do not forget about

    the Accra Psychiatric Hospital. We put in some little things to try to support the

    facility.
    Mr Buah 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, in the Hon Minister's Answer, he stated that the re- development of the Accra Psychiatric Hospital is really a priority for
    Government. He goes on to say that a consultant has been appointed and a
    design phase is about to be completed. What he did not do is to give us specifics.
    Could the Hon Minister provide
    timelines for when the consultant would complete his work, and when the design
    phase would be completed, since this is the priority for Government?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    may have to do some checks to respond to this.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:14 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Hon Members, we would now turn to the Question numbered 1332 which
    stands in the name of the Hon Member
    for Akim Oda, Mr Alexander Akwasi Acquah.
    Hon Member for Akim Oda, the floor
    is yours. [Pause] —
    Hon Member, if you could move to another seat, because it appears there is a problem with your microphone.
    — [Pause]—
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 12:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    think there is a problem. He has moved
    about four times and he is still struggling,
    so probably, with your leave, he should

    [Pause] —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:24 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, even speaking from my table,

    Efforts to Increase Intake at

    Nursing Training Colleges
    Mr Alexander A. Acquah (NPP — Akim Oda) 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Hon Minister for Health efforts being
    made to increase the intake at Nursing
    Training Colleges especially in places
    like the Akim Oda Nursing Training
    College that has the capacity to admit
    more students.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    though some Nursing Training Colleges
    (NTCs) like Akim Oda, as my Hon
    Colleague said, have the capacity to take
    up more students, there are other
    requirements such as inadequate number
    of tutors, learning materials, and training
    sites amongst others that might be
    causing the limited admissions. The

    Ministry is, therefore, working assiduously

    to train and recruit more tutors, expand

    the laboratories and provide adequate

    learning materials to ensure quality

    training for the requisite skill mix.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:24 p.m.
    Mr
    Acquah, do you have a supplementary
    question?
    Mr Acquah 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would
    want to ask if the Hon Minister is open
    to private developers who would want to
    take advantage of the vast land to build
    structures on a Private Public Partnership
    (PPP) basis.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    that is an option, but PPP would have to
    go through a certain process as actually
    enacted in the Public Private Partnership
    law, so we would look at that area.
    I would want to inform my Hon
    Colleague that, yesterday, I was in
    Sunyani Nursing and Midwifery
    Training College. The Principal and his
    management in that school have put up a
    three-storey building facility for
    accommodation for the students, and
    everybody who went there with me,
    including the Director General of the
    Ghana Health Service (GHS), and
    Regional Director of GHS, was amazed
    at how that was done through Internally
    Generated Fund (IGF). So, let us look at
    how IGF is utilised in that school; let us
    see how we can expand capacity in the
    school to give you a lot more numbers
    that you are looking at.
    I propose two options: the Hon
    Member's suggestion of PPP and efficient utilisation of IGF to see how
    they can build something that would
    make us add on to the numbers.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:24 p.m.
    Mr
    Acquah, have you exhausted all your — very well.
    So, we will take the last Question from
    you: Question 1333, so you may take
    your last substantive Question.
    Efforts to Improve the Capacity
    of Old Hospitals
    Mr Alexander A. Acquah (NPP — Akim Oda) 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Hon Minister for Health what efforts are
    being made to improve the capacity of
    very old hospitals like the Akim Oda
    Government Hospital, which is about 90
    years old, and in other communities that
    are not benefiting from the government
    flagship programme, Agenda 111.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the Ministry is aware of the population
    growth in Birim Central and its environs,
    and also of the fact that it is not covered
    under the Agenda 111 flagship project.
    Therefore, the Ministry has planned for
    an upgrade and redevelopment of the
    Akim Oda Government Hospital.
    Mr Speaker, further to this, a
    Memorandum of Understanding (MoU)
    has been signed between the Ministry

    and a prospective contractor. To this end,

    the Ministry has commenced the

    preparation of a project concept note for

    the consideration of the Ministry of

    Finance, as required by the Public

    Investment Management Regulation. I

    hereby inform Hon Members that the 90-

    year-old Akim Oda Hospital would soon

    receive befitting facelift to serve the

    good people of Birim Central and its

    catchment area when the necessary

    processes are completed.
    Mr Acquah 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I was in the
    hospital yesterday, and I realised that the
    hospital has just two years to be 100
    years, so it is not 90 years. It is 98 years.
    Would the Hon Minister be kind to
    share with me when the MoU was signed
    and the contractor he referred to?
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:24 p.m.
    Hon
    Minister, do you wish to share the
    information with the Hon Member of
    Parliament?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with your indulgence and that of my Hon
    Colleague, let me share that specific
    information with him on the corridors
    outside the Chamber.
    Mr Acquah 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, with your
    kind indulgence, I would want to refer the Hon Minister to page 21 of today's Daily Graphic. Yesterday, I visited the hospital, and Daily Graphic was kind enough to feature it. I am sure if the Hon Minister refers to that portion of the
    newspaper, he would see that the good people of Akim Oda really need the hospital to be revamped, and I would want to know how soon is the Hon Minister's “soon”.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, when we move into semantics like this, it even makes the question a little more difficult. I have told my Hon Colleague that, with your indulgence, we would engage in the corridors. I came to talk about how quickly we would complete Fomena and Kumawu Hospitals. I was using the word “soon”, but I could not give a specific date.
    Mr Speaker, today, you would bear
    with me that these facilities are fully completed, and we would soon inaugurate them. So, my Hon Colleague should take me into confidence; we would discuss this outside the Chamber.
    Mr Buah 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, frankly, this is an Hon Minister of State responsible for Health. He has been asked a Question in Parliament, a House of records, and he would give us vague answers, without specifics.
    Can the Hon Minister be kind enough
    to give the Hon Member some specific assurance of timelines on when this would be done? He should give us some timelines; please, this man is representing the good people of Akim Oda, and they are counting on him to bring them answers. The Hon Minister should give him the answers, so he can take them to Akim Oda.
    Mr Acquah 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I have
    confidence in the Hon Minister; he is
    actually —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:24 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, I have not called you — [Laughter] — I was expecting the Hon Minister to respond to the Hon Deputy
    Minority Leader.
    Hon Minister, are you minded to
    respond to the Hon Deputy Minority
    Leader?
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    have said here over and over that I do not
    give assurances; I do not promise my
    Hon Colleagues, and I do not give
    timelines because I do not control
    everything on earth. The Hon Minister
    for Health functions when there is money
    and proper MoU has been signed
    between the potential contractor and
    whatever it is like.
    Mr Speaker, at barely initial stages of
    negotiations and discussions, I would
    find it very difficult and naive to start
    giving timelines when I know very much
    that I cannot give my hand on in three
    weeks, one month or even six weeks. So,
    I always say that I am working on some
    of these things, but I fall short of giving
    specific dates to avoid the situations
    where some of my Hon Colleagues
    would draw me to the Committee of
    Government Assurance to answer
    questions that I may not easily give
    answers. So, we are working on some of
    the things, but I would still fall short of
    giving timelines. When I have not
    assured you of nothing, how would you
    take me to the Committee of
    Government Assurance?
    Mr Bawa — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:24 p.m.
    Mr
    Bawa, I thought this is a constituency-
    specific Question.
    Mr Edward Abambire Bawa 12:24 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, yes, I just want to draw your
    attention to something while I ask the
    question. Consistently, when an Hon
    Member asks for timelines, the Hon
    Minister for Health would always refer
    to the Committee of Government
    Assurance as the basis for which he
    would not give timelines. As Members
    of Parliament, we would want to be able
    to supervise him, so it is the milestone
    that would let us supervise him.
    So, he should give us the estimate of
    what the timelines are.
    Mr Agyeman-Manu 12:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    may need to do some checks in order to
    give timelines to this particular one.
    Mr Acquah — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:34 p.m.
    Very
    well. Hon Member, did you want to say
    something?
    Mr Acquah 12:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I just
    wanted to say that I am ready to work
    with the Hon Minister to ensure that the
    facility is given the needed upgrade very
    soon.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:34 p.m.
    Very
    well. Hon Minister for Health, on behalf
    of the House, I would like to thank you
    for attending upon the House to answer
    11 Questions, including an Urgent
    Question. We are grateful to you. You
    are hereby discharged.
    Hon Members, let us turn to the item
    numbered 7 on today's Order Paper — Statements. We have three Statements,
    and the first one stands in the name of the
    Hon Member for Ketu South — Ms Abla Gomashie, and it is on International
    Mother Language Day.
    Hon Member, let us hear you.
    STATEMENTS 12:34 p.m.

    Ms Abla Dzifa Gomashie (NDC — Ketu South) 12:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am grateful
    for the opportunity to make this
    Statement as we mark this significant
    International Mother Language Day.
    Mepamokyew, me ma mo akye o.
    Medekuku, ho agbe ndi. Ofaine me babo
    omanye ee. Kunaa laafia. Mr Speaker, I
    just greeted the House in four (4)
    Ghanaian languages.
    Mr Speaker, 21st February of every
    year is dedicated to the celebration of
    International Mother Language all over
    the world. This day is an annual
    observance sponsored by the United
    Nations Education, Science and Cultural
    Organisation. (UNESCO). This year
    marks the 24th edition, with the theme
    “Multilingual education: A necessity to transform education”. The primary objective of the International Mother
    Language Day (IMLD) 2023 is to
    promote the preservation and protection
    of all languages, the awareness of
    linguistic and cultural diversity and
    multilingualism, as well as fostering
    quality, inclusive and equitable learning.
    Mother tongue is said to be a very
    significant part of a person's identity.
    Mr Speaker, in Ghana today, with the
    many indigenous languages we have, it
    is rather unfortunate that the number of
    children who can fluently speak and
    write their mother tongue is
    discouraging. Currently in Ghana, the
    language policy mandates the use of a
    child's mother tongue as the language of instruction (LI) from kindergarten
    through to primary 3, with English as the
    LI thereafter.
    Unfortunately, Mr Speaker, evidence
    proves that this directive is not being
    adhered to. A survey conducted by
    Family Health International (FHI 360) in
    2018 by sampling 7,105 schools revealed
    that only 57 per cent of the schools
    employed teachers who spoke the
    designated language of instruction.

    Osei Twumasi Ankrah (2015) reveals

    that academic achievement is improved

    when students learn in their local or

    native languages. He also stated that the

    language policy in Ghana stipulates that

    those local languages be used for

    instructions in basic school levels up to

    primary three. However, in practice, this

    is rarely the case due to structural and

    logistical challenges.

    According to research conducted by

    Yvonne Eyram Nutakor and Nana Aba

    Appiah Amfo (2018), language is the

    primary symbolic medium through which

    cultural knowledge is communicated,

    negotiated and reproduced. Most Ghanaian

    children today, in fact, cannot speak their

    mother tongue. English has become the

    most common form of communication in

    our schools, homes, offices and churches.

    Avenues for children to hear and speak

    our local languages have completely

    been erased. This is made worse by the

    subtle monocultural community being

    promoted by some sections of our

    country.

    It is a fact that in Africa, English

    language has overshadowed indigenous

    languages. Many African countries still

    use their coloniser's languages in their official transactions and deliberations, as

    well as a medium of teaching and

    learning in schools.

    Mr Speaker, article 39(3) of the 1992 Constitution stipulates that “the state shall foster the development of Ghanaian languages and pride.” Ghana has more

    than 46 different languages, which includes Twi, Ga, Ewe, Hausa, and Dagbani. Our school curricula these days do not make provision for the Ewe, Ga, and Twi lessons like we used to have before.

    Mr Speaker, my recommendation is

    that the Ghana Education Service (GES) needs to revise our school curriculum to bring back learning of our beautiful local languages. The average Ghanaian child cannot speak or write his or her own mother tongue, and that is disheartening, and this cuts them off from a lot of opportunities.

    Mr Speaker, the Ministry of Tourism,

    Arts and Culture can also encourage the broadcast of more locally produced educational and entertainment pro- grammes on our radio and televisions to create more awareness. This will increase the interest in our mother tongues.

    Mr Speaker, as an advocate for

    preserving our cultural values, it is imperative that I speak up on the deteriorating nature of this conundrum. GES cannot do this alone. Charity, they say, begins at home. Our dear mothers and fathers have a role to play. Let us make it our absolute responsibility to interact with our kids in our mother tongue at home so that they can easily pick up the language. A child's formative years, which is from zero to five years, is the point at which the brain can consume a lot of information, thus they can learn faster. When these years are ignored, children become adults who cannot speak their own language.

    Unfortunately, some parents speak

    English at home with their kids, albeit

    their English language itself being

    questionable. Teachers also speak

    mostly English with them at school. So,

    at what point exactly will our children

    actually hear our local languages and

    learn? Mr Speaker, if we do not make a

    deliberate attempt to change this current

    situation, our children will have no

    mother tongue to pass on to their

    children in the future. We will lose the

    fight and lose the dividends thereof.

    In conclusion, as the people of Nigeria

    celebrate their Igbo, Yoruba, Hausa, et

    cetera; the people of France celebrate

    their French language and the people of

    China celebrate their Mandarin, let us

    also embrace our indigenous languages.

    Ehe de, ehegbe ye wodona. Let us not

    lose our identity by copying blindly.

    Instead, let us cherish our own. To my

    fellow Hon Members, we can contribute

    to this cause by ensuring that we speak

    mainly in our local languages in our

    communities when we engage our

    constituents.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

    opportunity. Akpe na mi. Naagode. Meda

    moase. Nye yi wa la donn.

    Some Hon Members — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:44 p.m.
    Thank
    you very much. Hon Members, let me
    first come to the Hon Member for
    Afadzato South.
    Mrs Angela O. Alorwu-Tay (NDC
    — Afadzato South): Mr Speaker, thank
    you for the opportunity to comment on
    the Statement made by the Hon Member
    for Ketu South. Ms Abla Gomashie,
    thank you very much for this Statement,
    which is very dear to my heart and I
    believe that of a lot of Ghanaians.
    Mr Speaker, today, when a child is
    born in a particular home, the parents
    decide not to use the mother language.

    The first language the child would

    first of all learn from the parents would

    be “sit down”, instead of nuanye, tenase,

    ta shi, et cetera.

    Mr Speaker, we have lost it as a

    country because even in this Chamber,

    our Standing Orders make room for

    Ghanaian languages to be used, but since

    I came to this House in the Seventh

    Parliament, I have never had the

    opportunity of listening to any Hon

    Member make a Statement in Twi or

    Ewe for an interpreter to interpret for our

    Hon Colleagues who do not speak those

    languages.

    Mr Speaker, would it not be better to

    start from this House by declaring a day

    for mother language so that, at least, in a

    Session, we could have 10 languages

    being used here in the House for

    somebody to interpret to start as a way of

    information to parents and outsiders?

    Mr Speaker, for UNESCO to have

    established this celebration in 1999,

    which is about 24 years now, means that

    they also saw the need for us to use our

    mother language in all we do. In our

    schools — I remember when I was in class 1, we were taught Ewe. When I

    joined my colleagues in Accra, we learnt

    some Ga. Today, in my constituency, the

    Ewe teachers are not even available for

    them to teach our children the mother

    language. It is said that when a language

    fades, cultural diversity goes away with it.

    Research conducted by one professor,

    whose name I have forgotten, is that in

    every two weeks, a mother language

    fades away; it is completely forgotten.

    Today, in this country, one goes to the

    market and instead of our market women

    to ask: “Wo be to den?” most of them would ask: “What are you buying?”.

    Let us do our best as a House to make

    sure that the policies we come out with,

    deliberations in our language would also

    help in that direction to the outside world

    that we are now ready to keep to our

    mother language and heritage.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

    opportunity to contribute to the State-

    ment and I also thank Ms Abla Dzifa

    Gomashie for a very well-researched

    Statement.
    Mr Samuel A. Akyea (NPP — Abuakwa South) 12:54 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am
    grateful for the opportunity to say few
    words by way of contribution to this all-
    important Statement at the behest of my
    Hon good Sister, Ms Abla Dzifa Gomashie.
    Mr Speaker, our colonial past has done
    a lot of damage to our culture and there
    is no dispute about it because, apart from
    us being colonised by Britain, they have
    even changed our language in material
    particular. Those who are well versed in
    education say that there is no language
    that a child can use for cognition and
    development more than the mother
    tongue. These are well-researched
    conclusions of fact that educationists
    have come out with.
    Unfortunately for us, we have believed
    more in the English language than our
    own mother tongues. What is even very
    sad is that we do not communicate the
    English language as much as the original
    owners do. Hence, half the time, we do
    not master the English language so well,
    and we have also jettisoned our mother
    tongue.
    I hold a humble view about what we
    would do about this aberration. We
    should begin from the very least of
    education, the elementary school level,
    in which it should be compulsory that
    education should come through a child's mother tongue — this is something we should enforce.
    Nonetheless, we would not throw
    away the English language, but with
    time, and alongside it because we are not
    in a village but in an international arena,
    where the English language is dominant,

    we should use it alongside the mother

    tongue. I believe that is the way to go

    since, as we are talking now, I do not see

    how we can do serious business in the

    United States of America (USA) with

    Twi.

    Equally, one cannot do good business

    in China with Ewe. When one goes to

    India, I cannot see how one can engage

    an Indian using Nzema, which is the

    language of my Hon Deputy Minority

    Leader. Therefore, on the inter-national

    stage, it has become imperative that the

    language that commands attention and

    understanding is the English language, and

    one cannot do anything about it. Even in

    this country, it seems to me that serious

    communication is being done in English

    language by some of our dominant FM

    stations. However, that should not

    detract from the fact that cognition and

    education, scientifically, is better

    transmitted, especially for infants when

    it is done in their mother tongues.

    There is a problem we all have as

    parents. I am sure most MPs here engage

    their children in the English language

    rather than the language of the parents.

    For instance, I am an Akyem man who is

    married to a Ga woman, and we do not

    speak Ga in my house because I do not

    speak Ga anyway, apart from, ohe ye fow

    I do not speak any good Ga language.

    Sometimes, I say, kaa gba nnaa, to wit,

    do not worry me. I say that to my wife

    because of how I feel sometimes.

    Moreover, my children do not speak

    Ga nor Twi, so Ms Gomashie is right.

    Until we start from the bottom and we do

    not throw away what is natural to us, the

    Hon Member's submissions would be

    valid and we would suffer in the end.

    Therefore, I think that the Hon

    Member who made the Statement has

    touched on a very important issue and it

    is the dichotomy which is a challenge.

    Are we to go with the foreign language

    at the expense of the local language? I

    think we should find a healthy balance

    and we would be better off for that.

    Mr Speaker, I am grateful for the

    opportunity to add to what my Hon good

    Lady said.

    Dr Clement Abas Apaak (NDC—

    Builsa South): Mr Speaker, ma nye fi

    gyam fi le tae mi suik a imbisi, to wit, I

    thank you very much for giving me the

    opportunity to also contribute in my

    mother language.

    Mr Speaker, this is a very important

    conversation that we ought to have as a

    nation and I am very glad that our Hon

    Sister, Ms Abla Dzifa Gomashie, chose

    today to make such a very important

    Statement. With my background in

    anthropology, and I think this is common

    knowledge, language is the medium

    through which traditions and cultures are

    passed on from one generation to the

    other.

    What this presupposes is that once one

    loses the language or one does not learn

    the language, he or she may be carrying

    him or herself as a Builsa, Ewe, Akyem

    or Frafra, but he or she is deficient. One

    would never fully appreciate the culture

    and traditions of one's people. So, the importance of learning the mother

    tongue cannot be over emphasised.

    As has already been stated by other

    Hon Members who contributed to this

    great Statement, the research is

    abundantly clear that between ages zero

    and five is where children have the

    capacity to learn multiple languages and

    that is also where we the parents have to

    make an effort to ensure that they learn

    what we call the mother tongue.

    Mr Speaker, while we speak about this

    generally, I think we also ought to look

    at the training of our teachers,

    particularly in the colleges of education,

    as it has to do with Ghanaian languages.

    It is true that we are not doing well.

    There are many schools where they are

    supposed to teach Ghanaian languages,

    at least, at the junior high school level,

    yet they cannot find the requisite teachers

    trained in those specific languages to

    teach. Therefore, while we look at our

    own role in beginning these processes at

    home, particularly, those of us who claim

    to have been educated, we must also look

    at the formal structures in place to augment

    what we can start at the home level.

    Mr Speaker, as Ghanaian as we are,

    many of us come from mixed family

    backgrounds. I think the Hon Member

    for Abuakwa South, Mr Samuel Atta

    Akyea, just indicated that he is an

    Akyem man and his wife is a Ga. I am a

    Builsa man; my wife is from Akwapem.

    My father is a Builsa man and my mother

    is a Kasena, and it has served me well.

    Fortunately for me, I can speak all those

    languages and it even makes my life a lot

    easier. So, it is not just for the children,

    but even for us as adults, it is not too late

    to learn other languages because it

    enhances our work, especially us

    politicians. If we can speak multiple

    languages, it is always an advantage.

    Bringing it back home, I think this

    should require some serious policy

    formulation and implementation, where

    we have to make a conscious effort to

    train enough teachers in Ghanaian

    languages so that they can augment what

    we would start from the home.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker, for indulging

    me. Ma nyɛla fi jaam.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:54 p.m.
    I would
    now move to Leadership. Hon First
    Deputy Minority Whip, are you ceding
    to — Let me hear you.
    Deputy Minority Whip (Mr Ahmed
    Ibrahim): Mr Speaker, I thought you
    were going to take one contribution from
    each Side, and then you would come to
    Leadership.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:54 p.m.
    We have two other Statements.
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 12:54 p.m.
    Alright. Then, let me do this. Mr Speaker —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:54 p.m.
    Let me go to the Hon Member for Oforikrom first. Dr Marfo, you may go ahead, but please be brief.
    Dr Emmanuel Marfo (NPP — Oforikrom) 12:54 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, let me appreciate the Hon Member for bringing such an important issue to the fore.
    Mr Speaker, I think the reason why
    perhaps, it has become difficult for us to promote our mother tongue is because over the years, we have not been able to develop our own language for science and business. Just like the Hon Member for Abuakwa South said, whether we like it or not, English has become the language of science and business, and so it would be very difficult for any group of people to be able to advance, to socialise and actually be an actor in the global world if they are not able to speak the languages that have been institu- tionalised as international languages for purposes of engaging other people in other jurisdictions.
    So, since every parent wants their
    ward to grow to become a responsible
    global citizen, we have tended to
    encourage our wards to speak English, to
    the extent that even in our schools — we go to some schools that have clearly
    written: “Speak English or do not speak
    any other language”. Parents have been motivated to even begin to teach their
    children and instruct them at home using
    the English language instead of teaching
    them their mother tongue. I think that we
    can combine the two.
    Since the schools are focused on
    teaching the official English language, I
    think the parents can also focus on
    teaching the mother tongue at home, so
    that they speak the mother tongue with
    their children, and when they go to
    school, they can learn the English
    language. Surprisingly, children have the
    ability to learn multiple languages,
    especially when they are below the age
    of 10, and so even when parents want
    them to master English, their mother
    tongue and French, they would be able to
    do so.
    I think this is an important call, and it
    should remind all of us that although we
    want our wards to be able to speak
    English so that they can participate in
    global business, at the same time, since
    language is an epitome of our culture,
    anyone who cannot speak his or her
    language is somebody who is throwing
    his or her culture away. It is important
    we remind ourselves of the importance
    of keeping our mother tongue while
    trying to learn the national or
    international language.
    Mr Dafeamekpor — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:54 p.m.
    Hon
    Member for South Dayi, please be brief.

    Mr Rockson-Nelson E. K.

    Dafeamekpor (NDC — South Dayi): Mr Speaker, me tso akpe manya gblor

    gaa ade a nawo be e nam morkporkpor

    be ma fonu tso fe nya si nye nuto danye

    si tso Ketu South gblo na mi egbea.

    Mr Speaker, me pe see me de akwanya

    yi da wa ase pii, se w'ama me kwan see menka asem kakra enfa nsem a menua

    baa ofiri Ketu South detoo dwa —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:54 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, will you do the interpretation?
    Mr Dafeamekpor 1:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, mi
    tao madaboshi akɛ oha mi gbɛ ko ni m'awie noko yɛ sane ni minyɛmi onukpa ni jɛ Ketu South ekɛɛwↄ yɛ shia nɛɛ mli.
    Mr Speaker, I am simply thanking you
    for the opportunity to add a few words in
    support of the Statement made by my
    sister in respect of this matter on the
    Floor.
    Mr Speaker, the records show that
    even our own native languages that we
    speak individually in the various
    localities were developed for us and
    written in terms of the alphabet
    formulation by the Germans when they
    came here. We have failed to build on the
    foundations that the Bremen Mission
    laid for us in formulating and mastering
    the languages, first with us, and
    progressing by formulating the alphabets
    with which we form constructions in the
    various native languages.
    By echoing what the Hon Member for
    Abuakwa South said, which was again
    echoed by my Brother, the Hon Member
    for Oforikrom, we are unable to commu-
    nicate scientifically, and so we are
    handicapped in training our children
    using our native languages. In the liberal
    hours, it is easy, but in the world of the
    sciences, we are totally handicapped.
    Mr Speaker, when we travel to East
    Africa, all the countries speak Swahili. It
    is an official language, and gradually,
    they are formulating the scientific
    symbols and algorithms into Swahili.
    The Chinese have formulated all the
    scientific formulas and all that they need
    for their science development in
    Chinese. The Chinese would not come to
    us to learn our language.

    The Chinese do not learn other

    languages, as they stick to their Chinese

    language. Even the food that they eat — they would not eat the different culinary

    with dishes but they would develop a

    Chinese dish, establish a Chinese

    restaurant, and label it in Chinese, which

    takes us to do the translation to know that

    it is a Chinese restaurant.

    Mr Speaker, there are so many

    languages in this country, which is a

    challenge as we are unable to settle on

    one or two in addition to the formal

    English language. So, inasmuch as I

    agree that we need to transact more in

    our native languages and relate more in

    our mother tongues, it is also important

    that we pay attention to the existing

    structure. As we speak, it is only the

    school of languages at Ajumako that

    trains our teachers and students in our

    native languages. Let us find out, as a

    House, how many languages are being

    taught at Ajumako as we speak?

    In 2017, as a young parliamentarian, I

    had a cause to raise the issue of the

    dwindling number of teachers or persons

    who were training as tutors, pursuing

    courses in the Ewe language, because the

    Ghana Education Service currently does

    not post teachers to the Volta Region

    because they teach Ewe. About three

    years ago, there was a letter issued by the

    Ga state demanding that some teachers

    who had trained in the Ga language were

    being posted out of Greater Accra and it

    was a concern for them because if Ga

    teachers were posted out of Accra, it

    became difficult for them to teach their

    children the Ga language. So, I agree

    with my Hon Colleague who made the

    Statement that we should do more in

    speaking and transacting in the local

    language, but it is also important that we

    take responsibility for the non-

    effectiveness with which we transact.

    Mr Speaker, the Constitution provides

    that if an Hon Member is on the floor and

    decides to communicate in his or her

    native language, resources should be

    provided for that Hon Member, so that

    whatever he or she says would be

    interpreted. I do not think we have

    explored that avenue thus far and it is

    part of the handicap that we have.

    On this note, I agree and I want to

    appreciate the issues raised by my Hon

    Colleague. I wish that a committee could

    look into it and come back with some

    report for further action.

    Mr Speaker, thank you for the

    opportunity.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:24 p.m.
    I now
    come to leadership.
    Minority Chief Whip (Mr Ahmed
    Ibrahim): Mr Speaker, thank you very
    much for the opportunity. However,
    before I proceed, let me show much
    commendation to our Hon Colleague
    who made the Statement. The Statement
    is as beautiful as the one who made it. —
    [Laughter] —
    Mr Speaker, our Hon Colleague has
    raised a serious issue — the teaching of
    and promotion of Ghanaian language. I
    remember, about 30 years ago, when I
    was in the kindergarten, my teacher used
    to put me on his laps and be teaching me
    the alphabets in Ghanaian language. I
    still recollect what I was taught 30 years
    ago. However, if we ask Hon colleagues
    to recite the alphabets in Ghanaian
    language in this Chamber, it would be a
    challenge and that is the very foundation
    of the promotion of the Ghanaian
    languages.

    When I got to the University of Ghana,

    with regard to those who took courses in

    Linguistics and English, more emphasis

    was laid on the Ghanaian languages, so

    they became multilingual because of the

    phonetics that they were taught. So, if

    one wants to talk about the promotion of

    Ghanaian languages, much emphasis

    must be laid on the very foundation. We

    are quick to say and recite the alphabets

    in English instead of reciting them in our

    local languages which we learnt some

    years ago. Because I was taught the local

    alphabets about 30 years ago, any

    Ghanaian language book that is given to

    me, I just break the words into syllables

    and read. That is the very foundation of

    the promotion of the Ghanaian languages.

    The Hon Member for South Dayi cited

    what happens in the East African

    countries which is very true because we

    go there on study visits. They do

    proceedings in Kiswahili irrespective of

    whether one understands that language.

    Their Standing Orders and everything

    are in Kiswahili. Kenya, Zambia, and

    Tanzania Parliaments conduct their

    businesses in Kiswahili and one might be

    sitting in their Chamber but would not

    understand the proceedings.

    Mr Speaker, Ghanaians have refused

    to adopt the Akan language which

    constitutes about 49.1 per cent of the

    population in Ghana. East African

    countries like Kenya, Tanzania, and

    Zambia have adopted one language

    which is Kiswahili. However, in Ghana,

    those in the Upper West Region speak

    Dagaare; in the Upper East Region, they

    speak Frafra; in the Northern Region,

    they speak Dagbani; in the Savannah

    Region, they speak Gonja; in the Bono

    Region, they speak Akan; in the Ashanti

    Region, they speak Asante Twi. So, even

    the Akan is also segregated. Hence, there

    is no universal local language adopted by

    Ghanaians.

    Mr Speaker, in this House, Order 47 of

    the Standing Orders is very clear and

    with your permission I quote:

    “The proceedings of Parliament shall ordinarily be conducted in the

    English Language, except that a

    Member may exercise the option

    to address the House in either

    Akan, Nzema, Ga, Ewe, Hausa,

    Dagbani, Dagaare or in any other

    local language provided facilities

    exist in the House for its

    interpretation.”

    What this means is that if an Hon

    Member expresses himself or herself in

    any Ghanaian language, the onus does

    not lie upon that Hon Member to translate

    it, but that is what we do in this Chamber.

    The Standing Order says that provided

    facilities exist for its interpretation”.

    Mr Speaker, when Hon Members go to

    International Parliamentary Union (IPU)

    and businesses are conducted, there are

    interpreters who interpret it in English,

    Portuguese, French, Spanish, and about

    seven or nine international languages.

    They provide those facilities for

    interpretation. However, in this House,

    the Standing Orders says we must

    provide the facilities for interpretation,

    but do we have interpreters who can

    interpret whatever local language is

    spoken? These are the challenges.

    Mr Speaker, on an important day like

    this, I would have opined that we

    conduct parliamentary business today in

    Akan but if it is raised there would be

    objections.

    An Hon Member would say he or she

    is a Dagaati and that the Ghanaian

    language he or she was taught in school

    was Dagaare. So, that person may have a

    legitimate concern.

    Mr Speaker, before independent

    Ghana, we used to have what was called

    the “Asante Empire” which extended to La Cote d'Ivoire and Togo. So, the whole Empire was bigger than even the

    size of Ghana, as we have it today - what language was being spoken? We have

    diverted from that. Now, when we even

    speak of Akan, we have Asante Twi,

    Akuapem Twi, Fante — it has been divided in such a way that even when it

    comes to the point of adopting one, it

    would become a challenge.

    So, how did the East Africans begin by

    getting it right? Who told Kenyans that

    they must adopt Kiswahili which made

    Tanzanians and Zambians to follow suit?

    These are sovereign countries but they

    have all come together as the East

    African Bloc to adopt one local language,

    which is what is taught in their schools.

    However, as one sovereign country, we

    have adopted about nine Ghanaian

    languages — not Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), but

    sovereign Ghana. A number of sovereign

    countries forming the East African Bloc,

    — one Ghanaian language. Was this also introduced by Kwasi Broni? No! This is

    a problem that has been self-inflicted and

    if we want to solve it, we must begin

    from the kindergarten.

    Mr Speaker, when we talk about

    Ghanaians in the diaspora, we always

    look at the United States of America and

    Germany but we have Ghanaians in the

    ‘internal diaspora'. There is somebody from the Eastern Region resident in the

    Greater Accra Region but never visits the

    Eastern Region. These are just boundary

    regions. Somebody is from the Central

    Region resident in the Greater Accra

    Region but never goes to the Central

    Region. So, we meet them and their

    parents speak English with them at home

    and they have become Ghanaians in

    ‘internal diaspora'.

    Mr Speaker, these are serious

    challenges. Somebody told me that his mother said they are from Techiman. So, I asked the person if he has been to Techiman before. This person has been in the Greater Accra Region, attended international school, secondary school and university but never goes to Techiman. After this generation and the next, this person would have become a

    Ghanaian from Techiman in the ‘internal diaspora' in Accra.

    Mr Speaker, this is a serious issue that

    the Hon Member has raised and on the next International Mother Language Day, we must transact business in, at least, one of the Ghanaian languages and this would serve as a test-case for those who are teaching — they would have some pride — especially those who teach Ghanaian languages in the various junior and senior high schools. In my school, Sunyani Secondary School (SUSEC), the tutor who taught Ghanaian languages, in the curfew days, was arrested by the Police. He said, “oh me yɛ tikya nii wo SUSEC”. So, he was asked “What do you teach in SUSEC?” and he said “adiɛ no”. The teacher could not gather courage to say he teaches Akan. He said “adiɛ no”. Adiɛ bɛn?

    Mr Speaker, so, if even the tutor could

    not mention that he teaches Akan in Sunyani Secondary School but referred to it as adiɛ no — So, because of that, students who studied Akan also referred to it as adie no when it was time for the subject and that became the name. We must take pride in our mother tongue and in our local languages. The opportunities are there and that is the only way we can best promote them.

    Mr Speaker, thank you for the

    opportunity.

    Majority Chief Whip (Mr Frank

    Annoh-Dompreh): Mr Speaker, I thank you for the treasured space. I wish to be

    brief but it should not be lost on me to congratulate and thank the Hon Member who made the Statement.

    Mr Speaker, we have listened and

    contributed to a number of Statements on

    the floor of this House but this is

    significantly important and for some

    reason, I think this is the first time I have

    witnessed an Hon Member make such a

    commemorative Statement to mark the

    “International Mother Language Day” — a bit of history though.

    I am told that a country like

    Bangladesh envisaged and made the

    suggestion to the United Nations in

    1999. This was recently adopted by a

    resolution that it should be one of the

    days celebrated on the calendar of the

    world.

    Mr Speaker, statistics also has it that

    about 40 per cent of the world's population do not have access to

    education in a language they understand

    or their mother tongue. A number of my

    Hon Colleagues have spoken and

    lamented enough about the difficulty.

    Going forward, what should we be seen

    to be doing?

    Mr Speaker, it is not for nothing that

    the Asian Tigers, Hong Kong, Singapore,

    South Korea, and Taiwan take pride in

    their indigenous languages. The

    importance of mother tongue cannot be

    overemphasised and I pray that at the

    conclusion of this Statement, we would

    be in your hands to make some

    consequential referrals for us not to let

    this matter end today but continue to talk

    about it and come to an effective

    conclusion in terms of enforcement.

    Mr Speaker, I am told that Fante is part

    of the curriculum of the Medical School

    of the University of Cape Coast, my

    alma mater. We hear of English

    proficiency, all over the world, when one

    is seeking admission in Europe, one

    needs to take the English proficiency

    Test. We could also do same. Why do we

    not have indigenous language

    proficiency? Maybe, at the risk of being

    controversial, if our mother tongue is

    taken seriously, and on the average, each

    person speaks one or two, it would help

    reduce many of the conflicts we have in

    our country.

    Mr Speaker, I am an Ashanti. My

    mother is an Ashanti while my father is

    an Akyem but I was brought up in the

    Volta Region. So, I greet my Hon

    Colleagues from the Volta Region, my

    senior colleague at the university, my

    senior Casfordian, Mr Dafeamekpor, and

    we speak Ewe. “Ne mido go mianonoewo, midona evegbe”. When I speak Ewe, people are amazed. That is

    how come I am able to relate so well with

    my constituents and they often ask

    whether I am an Akan or Ewe. That is the

    power of language.

    Right from creation, God showed us

    the way and that is why He — my senior Colleague would help us. I do not know

    whether it was Babylon — [An Hon

    Member: The Tower of Babel] — The Tower of Babel. And God in His wisdom

    said people would not speak one

    language. It is not for nothing. God in

    His wisdom, at that time, was teaching us

    some wisdom, that we should appreciate

    the importance of diversity of language

    in creation. It is sad. I am very saddened

    that this thing, as fundamental as it is,

    appears to have been lost on us and we

    have wondered for so long.

    Mr Speaker, I implore you, even as I

    end my contribution — we punish our children for not being able to speak good

    English language. Many of us here are

    guilty. At the court of law, if one is not

    able to make their presentation in good

    English language, their case may not

    even be heard. It is sad, so we have to

    renew and change our minds and

    thinking.

    If one is a Member of Parliament and

    their English language is not good, and

    they are not fortunate to have attended

    one of the “Achimotas” and the likes, they risk losing their seats. Maybe, it is

    part of the reasons some people lost their

    seats. They say that “He cannot speak in the Chamber because he cannot speak

    good English”, meanwhile they have something good to contribute. So, this is

    a very important Statement. I profusely

    commend my Hon Colleague for such an

    important Statement. The context in

    which she puts it, and the reference she

    made to article 39 of the 1992 Constitution

    clearly indicates that as a country, we

    must make a conscious effort to develop

    our indigenous languages.

    Mr Speaker, I do not want to be

    repetitive, so I would just conclude. I

    would like to implore you that this

    should not just be one of the Statements

    that we just contribute to and leave it to

    gather dust. I would implore you to make

    some consequential referral and continue

    in the search, and implore duty bearers

    that ultimately, we should be able to

    enforce this and change the status quo

    and the narrative.

    I thank you, Mr Speaker, for the

    treasured space.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:24 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    I thank you and all the contributors. I
    once listened to an anthropologist who
    said that God did not create Ghanaians
    for nothing. He created and planted us
    here as Ghanaians: Ewes, Akans,
    Dagaares, Gas and whatever tribe we
    talked about for a reason, and I think that
    we have to be proud of it. We have to
    speak with our children, because it is now
    becoming an issue. No family would like to
    speak Twi, Ewe, Ga with their children,
    because they would go to school and their
    colleagues would laugh at them.
    I think we need to take a second look at it.
    While I am thanking the Hon Member who
    made the Statement, let me refer this
    Statement to the Committee on Education to
    liaise with the Hon Minister to see how best
    we can start making this a policy in the
    educational sector, so that the children will,
    at least, begin schooling with the local
    languages from kindergarten and the other
    beginning classes. They can start with their
    mother tongue. It is very important. We are
    told that children would be able to learn
    effectively when they start with their mother
    tongues.
    The Statement is being referred to the
    Committee on Education. They should look
    into it and report to the House.
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 1:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, if you
    could include the leadership of the
    Committee on Youth, Sports and Culture,
    because language falls under culture, so the
    leadership can assist the Committee on
    Education in that direction.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 1:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with respect, I would like to agree with
    my Hon Colleague and Friend to say that
    it is important that it is done and also
    emphasise that with your leave, if you
    could give timelines, I think it would be
    important that they work within a certain
    time frame. This Meeting is a short one
    as we know.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:24 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    So, we would add the leadership of the
    Committee on Youth, Sports, and
    Culture and they are supposed to report
    back to the House within three weeks.

    We would take the second Statement

    from the Hon Member for Yunyoo, Mr

    Oscar Liwaal, on the benefit of shea nut

    industry on women empowerment.

    Hon Member, the floor is yours. Let us

    Benefits of Shea Nut Industry on

    Women Empowerment in Ghana
    Mr Oscar Liwaal (NPP — Yunyoo) 1:34 p.m.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker for the
    opportunity to make a Statement on the
    impact of the shea nut industry on women
    empowerment in Ghana. The shea tree
    which is also known as vitellaria paradoxa
    grows naturally in the wild in the dry
    Savannah belt of Africa, from Ghana, in
    the West to Sudan in the East, and onto
    the foothills of the Ethiopian highland.
    In Ghana, the population of shea nut
    trees grows naturally in the wild and has
    been estimated to be 9.4 million and over
    in the whole of Northern Ghana.
    Mr Speaker, the shea industry
    currently provides employment and
    income for over 900,000 women in the
    five regions of northern Ghana, according
    to the United Nations Development
    Programme (UNDP), 2010 impact
    assessment report. The industry has been
    projected to equalise the cocoa industry
    as shea butter, a product from the shea
    nut, has become an important export
    commodity in Ghana. Export earnings
    from the community reached GH₵52 million in 2014, 96 per cent rise over the
    GH₵26 million recorded in the 2013 period.
    Mr Speaker, for many women within
    the northern sector, the main source of
    income is the production of shea nuts and
    shea butter, thereby making shea
    manufacturing of great socio-economic
    importance to the local people.
    Benefits
    It is obvious that the economic
    resilience derived from shea nuts in
    terms of income, assets and savings and
    the social indicators of well-being,
    education, health and living standards,
    cannot be over emphasised.
    The overall potential of the shea
    industry as a source of employment,
    poverty reduction, propelling growth in
    northern Ghana and a source of foreign
    exchange for the country is therefore not
    fully realised. Profits from selling shea
    butter have also been found to account
    for at least 12 per cent poorer household
    income at a challenging time between the
    end of yearly food stores and before a
    new harvest. This implies that sheabutter
    processing is a major alternative
    livelihood activity for most women in
    northern Ghana, per a research by
    Aduse-Poku in 2017.
    Challenges
    Mr Speaker, despite these sterling
    benefits, there are challenges and the
    most common challenge identified by all

    players in the sector includes the hard

    work associated with processing nuts

    into butter and the lack of processing

    machinery. The shea butter producers

    lack capital, inadequate equipment,

    access to water, access to roads, and high

    cost of fuel wood, limited access to

    credit, and limited access to international

    markets, among others.

    Recommendations

    Mr Speaker, with the enormous

    benefits of shea nut and butter, it is

    therefore recommended that the Ministry

    of Food and Agriculture, in conjunction

    with COCOBOD, map out strategies to

    ensure access to financial and other

    material support from Government and

    other institutions for women in the shea

    nut industry. This way, the producers

    would be able to boost their shea nut

    business and trade at the international

    level and contribute their quota to

    national development.

    Mr Speaker, in addition, the Ministry

    should undertake vigorous research and

    development to enable them identify

    better and easier processing methods,

    machines, and more uses for shea

    products. This would not only boost

    quality and quantity of the shea products,

    but also reduce production costs.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

    opportunity.

    Some Hon Members — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:34 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, thank you very much. I will
    start with my Senior, the Hon Member
    for Wa Central.
    Dr Abdul-Rashid Hassan Pelpuo
    (NDC — Wa Central): Mr Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity to contri-
    bute to this very important Statement.
    Mr Speaker, the shea nut industry is
    very important for the people of Ghana,
    and especially for those of us who live in
    the north of Ghana. Shea nut is largely
    grown in the northern part of Ghana and
    in the savanna regions. It is a natural
    process by which trees, there, grow by
    the seeds that fall on the ground without
    anybody directly planting them.
    However, it is a gifted situation in which
    everywhere one goes in the northern part
    of Ghana, one finds the shea plant
    growing. The fruit of the shea nut has
    such good quality that it produces edible
    fruits which are used to produce oil, and
    the residue can also be used to make
    paint, manure, and other products.
    Mr Speaker, it is such a critical plant
    in that it improves the lives of people
    and, normally, it is women who largely
    collect the shea fruits and process them
    for sale. Because of the nature of the
    plant and its usefulness to our lives, it has
    become a worldwide industry. A lot of
    people buy it to produce cream and
    edible oil, and for other industrial
    purposes. As I speak, I know of a

    company in Canada which established a

    small shea nut industry in Wa, where the

    plants are taken care of, the fruits are

    utilised, and oil is produced and

    exported.

    Mr Speaker, I would like to urge the

    Government to look beyond the people

    picking and selling the shea nuts at

    cheaper prices to middlemen and people

    who want to use them for export. It is

    important to fortify the usage of it in

    Ghana and make sure that we strengthen

    the people who collect and process them

    so that we can have the industry grow

    beyond just the manual usage.

    Mr Speaker, it is important to note that

    if the women are empowered to use

    technology to pick and process the shea

    nuts, millions of people would be

    employed. When women are employed

    and they are empowered to manage their

    own affairs, it is possible — and I agree with what Dr James Kwegyir Aggrey

    said that when we strengthen the woman,

    we strengthen the population. It is

    possible for the women to take care of a

    good population, and Ghana is going to

    benefit a lot.

    It is not just a fact that we have more

    poor people in Ghana. It is a fact that we

    invest less in the north. Several situations

    exist where we can create opportunities

    for people to better themselves and to

    improve productivity in the north, and

    one area is improving the shea nut

    industry. I agree with the Hon Member

    who made the Statement that when we

    put emphasis on it, the emphasis would

    have a multiple effect on both the local

    and national economy.

    Mr Speaker, this Statement is one that

    we can explore further, and I wish the

    Hon Minister for Food and Agriculture

    and the Hon Minister for Trade and

    Industry were here to listen to this

    Statement and to put in efforts to see

    what they can do in enlarging the market,

    improving the industry and ensuring that

    more young people are involved in it in a

    more modern manner than what we see

    today.

    Today, women walk into the farms,

    into the dark, and into all corners of the

    wilderness to pick shea nuts. Anything

    can happen. We can have improved

    methods in doing this but that would be

    ensured by national involvement and

    commitment to it so that we can enlarge

    the market and the industry to create

    value for the people in the industry.

    Mr Speaker, as I said, it is an area we

    can explore deeper than we see today,

    and it can help in national development,

    relieve the many unemployed people

    who are in the north and the many who

    troop to the south to be kayaye, which we

    do not accept in the normal course of

    events. We would like to see people

    work for themselves, and this is an area

    to get people to work for themselves. If

    we inject income into the area, many

    young people will stay at home and work

    in the industry, and we can have an

    improved life situation in the north.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for the

    opportunity and I hope that this

    Statement would go as far as to the Hon

    Ministers for Food and Agriculture, and

    Trade and Industry so that they can plan

    towards doing something positive about

    it.

    Some Hon Members — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:44 p.m.
    I will
    come to the Hon Member for Offinso South even though we do not pick shea nuts in Offinso. However, I can see that you used to work at COCOBOD, and therefore you have something to offer the House. So, let us hear you.
    Dr Isaac Y. Opoku (NPP — Offinso
    South): Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Speaker, first of all, I thank the
    Hon Member who made the Statement, my good Friend, Mr Oscar Liwaal, the Member of Parliament for Yunyoo Constituency.
    Mr Speaker, the shea industry has a
    huge potential which is not being exploited. As you rightly said, I worked with COCOBOD and before I became an Hon Member of Parliament, I was the Executive Director for CRIG, the research wing of COCOBOD. COCOBOD has established a research station at Bole, specifically to research into shea, and if one visits the by-product division of the CRIG, the unit has developed a number of varieties of the shea nut. There are quite a number of them, and it is strange that nobody is taking interest in the establishment for the various uses.

    Mr Speaker, shea oil is the second

    most important food oil apart from palm oil. If one takes the vitamins in the mesocarp, the vitamin C is about three times what is found in an orange. Again, for the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industries, the shea nut is very vital.

    Mr Speaker, as the Hon Member

    earlier said, we are not giving enough

    attention to the shea nut industry, so

    farmers would have to pick from the

    wild. They are either not getting enough

    fruits or the quality of what they pick

    may not be very high.

    Mr Speaker, if we really want to

    develop the shea industry, we have to

    domesticate the shea tree as we have

    done for cocoa. The most challenging

    aspect of the shea industry is the long

    gestation period for the tree. It takes

    between 15 to 30 years for the shea nut

    to be harvested. However, research by

    the CRIG has reduced the gestation

    period from between 15 to 30 years to

    about two years. So, now, one can plant

    the shea nut tree and start harvesting

    after two years.

    Mr Speaker, if we really want to

    harness the uses of shea crops, we have

    to cultivate the shea plant as we do for

    cocoa. The CRIG is gathering a lot of

    varieties. They want to gather a lot of

    genres for the shea nut industry.

    However, the constraint they have now is

    that a lot of the shea trees are being

    destroyed, either through domestication

    or felling of the trees for firewood or

    burning for charcoal.

    Mr Speaker, again, the other constraint

    for domestication is the pest and

    diseases. Cocoa research has been able to

    develop varieties that are tolerant and

    also resistant to pests and diseases. If we

    want to reduce unemployment in the

    north, I think the way to go is to develop

    the shea nut industry. It may interest you

    to know that CRIG has even developed

    bio-diesel from the shea. The potential

    for shea is so huge and we would

    encourage the incoming Hon Minister

    for Food and Agriculture to ensure that

    much attention is given to the shea

    industry just as is given to the cocoa

    industry in the south.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for giving me

    the opportunity.

    Some Hon Members — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:44 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, I am inclined to give the
    opportunity to the lady.
    Yes, Hon Member for Krowor, Ms
    Agnes Naa Momo Lartey.
    Ms Agnes N. M. Lartey (NDC — Krowor) 1:44 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you for
    the opportunity to contribute to the
    Statement ably made by my Hon
    Colleague.
    Mr Speaker, when it comes to the shea
    nut industry, we all know that it is largely
    female-dominated. When we talk about
    women empowerment, it is important
    that we look at it not as an event but as a
    process. So, we need to look at it right
    from the onset — what are the factors that would contribute to women giving
    off their best in this industry? Most often,
    empowerment, not being an event, is not
    looked at holistically. So, at the point
    where the entire process is commodified,
    that is where the government takes an
    interest in looking at the money that is
    derived from it. However, we hardly
    think of how it improves the livelihoods
    of the people involved in that industry.
    Sadly, this is what is affecting most
    women.
    Mr Speaker, assuming the women
    were even doing it for the income that is
    generated from the shea nut industry, it
    is important that they get the motivation
    to be able to do it and give off their best.
    We need to create that enabling environ-
    ment not just by paying lip service. It is
    important that the technology that is
    needed in this industry is provided for
    the women just like any other industry
    that is male-dominated. We need to look
    at it from the scratch — what tech- nologies are needed and which people
    need to be trained and re-trained. At the
    end of the day, what do we get from the
    training? What benefit does those that
    are in the industry derive? How does it
    improve their livelihoods and their
    households?
    Mr Speaker, when one comes to a
    home within the Greater Accra Region,

    it could be realised that most homes are

    headed by females. If the situation is the

    same in places such as the north, then, we

    are going to have — especially if there are a lot of polygamous homes, we will

    realise that empowering women to

    economically be on their feet will

    improve livelihoods of not just the

    women but also their households. So, I

    would encourage us, as a people, that the

    policies we put in place should not be

    policies that only go to favour men but

    policies that would also favour women.

    It does not matter the industry that we

    find ourselves in.

    Mr Speaker, this shea nut industry has

    been there for a very long time and it is

    very disappointing and unfortunate that

    both government and private individuals

    have not holistically looked at the

    processes that shea nuts go through and

    how they could be improved. Now that

    we have looked at the diesel and some

    other byproducts, that it could produce

    one would realise that it has become

    something that could be commoditised.

    At the end of the day, it would be male-

    dominated. For instance, not too long

    ago, cooking was the preserve of women.

    As soon as men came in and they became

    chefs, one would realise that the value of

    cooking is hyped. Now, men are

    struggling with women over who cooks

    better. As a result, whatever is needed to

    make sure that the catering service or

    industry is improved is also advancing. I

    would plead with all of us as

    policymakers that we look at it

    holistically not only as an event.

    Mr Speaker, the Statement could not

    have come at a better time than this. So,

    all of us need to put our hands on deck if

    we really want to work towards improving

    the income-generating activities in the

    country and the economic livelihoods of

    the people and the nation. It is also

    important for us to look at how we

    individually contribute to ensuring that

    the skills of people that are developed are

    actually enhanced to make sure that they

    are happy with what they do to give off

    their best, right from the local level to the

    national level.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you very much for

    the opportunity.
    Dr Sebastian N. Sandaare (NDC — Daffiama/Bussie/Issa) 1:54 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    thank you for the opportunity to
    contribute to this very important and
    well-researched Statement on the benefit
    of the shea nut industry on women
    empowerment in Ghana delivered by the
    able Hon Member for Yunyoo
    Constituency, Mr Oscar Liwaal.

    Mr Speaker, we can spend the whole

    day talking about the importance of the

    shea nut industry and we would not even

    finish because it has a very huge

    economic potential as far as northern

    Ghana and the whole Ghana is concerned.

    Mr Speaker, many of us, in fact, I

    would say that all the Hon Members of

    Parliament who are from the north in this

    Chamber benefited hugely from the shea

    industry. That is what our mothers or

    grandmothers used to take care of many

    of us in our education. In fact, the women

    use the proceeds from shea processing to

    sometimes take care of their husbands. I

    said this because I know that at times,

    when the men are hot, they take some of

    the shea nut from their wives to the

    market to sell so that they could get

    something for the day.

    Mr Speaker, what we should talk

    about more is value addition because as

    for the benefits and the importance of

    shea nut, they are very huge. It serves as

    nutrition; the shea fruits are very

    nutritious. During the season where we

    have shea fruits, many children and

    people up north do not look for food;

    they just eat some sweet shea fruits,

    drink water, and they are good to go for

    the day.

    Mr Speaker, we eat the fruits and we

    process the nuts for oil and so many

    things. Even the shells are of economic

    importance. As a country, we have to see

    how we could place similar importance

    on the shea industry, as we do for the

    cocoa industry. We see the loans we

    approve in this House and many other

    roles stakeholders play when it comes to

    cocoa. We could do same for shea, and

    that would not benefit only the north but

    the country would also derive a lot of

    economic importance from it.

    Mr Speaker, as the Hon Member who

    made the Statement said, there are other

    areas that we would also have to look at

    because the shea tree is facing a lot of

    challenges: one, from bushfire; and two,

    our people now cut the shea trees for

    wood and other funny reasons when we

    should be protecting the shea tree as the

    Hon Member for Offinso South

    mentioned. The Bole Shea Nut Research

    Station is there to ensure and improve

    upon the traditional shea tree we have up

    north, which I think is good.

    Mr Speaker, in concluding, I would

    like to say that efforts have been taken,

    and what we need to do is to build on

    these efforts. We all remember that the

    National Democratic Congress (NDC)

    established the Buipe Shea Nut

    Processing Factory, and I believe that

    this Government could also do more, and

    future governments could do even more.

    So, we all have to put relevance on the

    shea industry so that it would be of huge

    benefit to empowering women up north,

    and in Ghana as a whole.

    Mr Speaker, if you would remember,

    in those days, one could not get shea

    creams in shops. However, these days, in

    any shop or supermarket, there are well-

    processed shea creams that our ladies

    and even the gentlemen like better than

    other creams.

    Mr Speaker, I would like to thank you

    very much for the opportunity. I also

    thank the Hon Member who made the

    Statement. In fact, it is an important

    Statement that needs some referral to one

    of the Committees to further look into

    because its importance is very huge for

    this country.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, thank you very much. I would
    now come to the Leadership.
    Hon Deputy Minority Whip, you may
    kindly speak.
    First Deputy Minority Whip (Mr
    Ahmed Ibrahim): Mr Speaker, this is a
    very important Statement. In 2018, we
    passed the Tree Crops Development
    Authority Act, 2019 (Act 1010). If
    Ghana would concentrate on any tree
    crop apart from cocoa, I think that the
    shea nut tree should be number one.
    Mr Speaker, this is a tree that grows
    wild in the savannah and northern
    regions. However, it is unfortunate to
    notice that most of these shea nut trees
    are now being cut and used for charcoal.
    The tree grows wild and it takes over 100
    to 150 years to have them populated in a
    certain area.
    Mr Speaker, when we were in middle
    school in the olden days, during the
    Provisional National Defence Council
    (PNDC) era, an attempt was made to
    create shea nut farms, and one of them
    was in my district, the Banda District. It
    was about 100 acres of shea nut farm but
    when we go there today, we cannot count
    up to 10 trees. This is because the shea
    nut tree grows in the wilderness. When
    attempt is made to plant it, it may not
    even bear fruit; even for it to germinate
    and grow well would be a problem.
    These are things we are given by nature.
    Mr Speaker, we could not create the
    shea nut farms, and those that are given by nature are also being cut for firewood. In my Constituency and local community, it was a taboo to cut a shea tree for either firewood or other purposes. These were the taboos that were created by the local communities. However, with the emergence of modern governance, these taboos are not being enforced as they used to be. Also, because of the non- enforcement of the district assemblies' bye-laws, people have just relaxed the taboos and bye-laws, and those trees are just being cut.

    Mr Speaker, when we look at the

    economic, social and health benefits of the shea nut tree, I think that it is time for this House to legislate and sanction those who cut shea nut trees for firewood or for other purposes because in the local communities, even if one is clearing an area for a farm and there is a shea tree on the land, the tree cannot be felled. The laws make that an abomination. However, because some of those bye- laws are now not enforceable in the law court, almost all the shea trees in areas such as Tain, Banda and others are being cut for firewood purposes.

    Mr Speaker, so, the House must see to

    it that we legislate because if we look at

    the economic importance and the kind of employment the shea trees created in those days and now these trees are being cut off, we cannot sit down and fold our arms for such an atrocity to go on. So, I would like to end by urging the Hon Minister for Food and Agriculture to prioritise the protection of the little shea trees that are left.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    Do we have an Hon Minister for Food and Agriculture?
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 2:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    thought Mrs Mavis Hawa Koomson was
    made the Hon Minister responsible for
    Food and Agriculture. So, she must
    prioritise legislating to protect the little
    shea trees that are left because shea
    butter is being exported to the USA and
    UK for foreign exchange, and I believe it
    is a good direction to go. This is the
    humble comment I would like to make
    towards the legislation and protection of
    the few shea trees that are left.
    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    Thank
    you very much. Before the Hon Majority
    Chief Whip would comment, I think Dr
    Isaac Yaw Opoku said that, according to
    the research that has been undertaken,
    the shea tree can now be grown and
    within two or after two years, it can start
    fruiting — that is if I got Dr Isaac Opoku right. So, it is no more over 100 years. If,
    indeed, research has established that,
    then I think it is something that we have
    to do more to get the trees producing.
    Hon Majority Chief Whip, before you
    come with the concluding contribution, I
    would like to implore the House to allow
    me to extend the Sitting beyond the
    normal hours; it is now 2:00 p.m.
    So, Hon Leader, you may take the
    Floor.
    Mr Frank Annoh-Dompreh 2:04 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, thank you. I would just be brief
    on this. I think the Hon Member who
    made the Statement has dealt with the
    matter in proper context, and he is an
    industry person, so he has put up all the
    facts. I would just like to add that, because
    we passed the Tree Development
    Authority law, this is a matter that should
    not get out of the lens of this Authority.
    It is surprising that it has not received the
    needed attention. It is a huge resource.
    Mr Speaker, I would only commend
    the Hon Member. You rightly nudged
    and admonished my Hon Friend and was
    wondering if we have an Hon Minister
    for Food and Agriculture. We are aware
    his Party has issued a three-line whip that
    nominees by the President, in this
    context, the one for the agricultural
    sector should not be passed. In one
    breath, we want the shea nut and Tree
    Development Authority to blossom and
    the shea nut industry to grow, yet they
    are refusing to support the passage of
    these nominees. I would like to implore
    him to his Party Leadership that the
    agricultural sector and all the other
    nominees are so critical. I do not even
    want to say temper justice with mercy

    because his Party is not doing us any

    mercy; it is their constitutional

    responsibility.

    Mr Speaker, I get surprised; in one

    breath, they say they would not pass

    them; in another breath they say they

    would go and vet them. What are they

    vetting them for? If they were going to

    say that from the outset, they should have

    waited to vet them before they say they

    would not pass the nominees based on

    how they acquit themselves. This is

    unfortunate. I just pray that from now

    until tomorrow, they would have a

    change of mind.

    Mr Speaker, I know the Hon Member,

    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim, prays a lot and he is

    a good Pentecostal. He should go and

    pray fervently for us to change the

    fortunes on the agricultural sector of our

    country. We do not have to waste time.

    He should have listened to all the

    wonderful and beautiful ideas of the

    nominee, but if he is not passed, how

    does he implement them?

    I see the Hon Former Deputy Minority

    Leader paying attention to his phone; he

    should listen to me. He should go and

    talk to his Hon Colleagues. Mr Speaker,

    he should talk to their Colleagues and

    advise them. We have to pass —

    Mr Avedzi — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    But
    Hon Leader, why are you inviting him?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would yield to him. He should speak.
    Mr James K. Avedzi 2:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    thank you. I take objection to the comment passed by the Hon Majority Chief Whip. Looking into my phone does not block my ears from listening to what he was saying. So, to say that I should listen to him was completely wrong. I heard every bit of what he was saying. He should withdraw that statement and tell the House that he made a mistake by thinking that I was not listening to what he was saying.
    He said that all these good ideas, if we
    do not implement them, we would not get anywhere. All these were said by him; I was listening to him, please.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    Mr
    Avedzi, I think it has been a long time since the Hon Member heard your voice so he just wanted to invite you to —
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    you captured it right. I have missed him and I can stay clear of that but particularly, he should talk to his Hon Colleagues and National Executives to stop issuing such three-line whip; it would not augur unity and the unity of purpose for this country moving forward.
    Mr Speaker, on a more serious note, I
    think this is a matter that is so critical.
    We have to commend the Hon Member
    who made the Statement and, clearly, Mr
    Ahmed Ibrahim has some privileged
    awareness of the industry. I would
    implore him to liaise with the Hon

    Member who made the Statement and

    ensure that all the good ideas see the light

    of day.

    Mr Speaker, it is also critical because

    if we look at the poverty level in that

    area, it is very grinding and it is our

    women who are suffering and shea nut is

    their main economic stake. It cannot be

    toyed with. I hope he would advise his

    people to support us in passing all the

    nominees so that we can develop the

    shea nut and he, Mr Avedzi, would

    benefit from the industry.

    Mr Speaker, is he laughing?
    Mr Avedzi 2:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank you. I
    think my Hon Colleague always wants to
    listen to my sweet voice. He is pointing
    at me to talk to my Hon Colleagues, and
    he made reference to the National
    Executives of my Party. He said I should
    talk to them to stop issuing some kind of
    directives.
    Mr Speaker, the proposal coming from
    him is good but he has forgotten that
    recently, his National Executives also
    issued a directive on the approval of the
    removal of the Hon Minister for Finance;
    the directives and position that was given
    to them was even more than a three-line
    whip. When one is living in a glass
    house, stones should not be thrown. They
    threw stones and it is coming back to hit
    them. So, if he is advising me to do that,
    I would like to equally advise him to do
    same. He should start from his house; he
    should clean his house first before he
    goes out. Thank you.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    Thank
    you very much. we would now take the
    last Statement. I believe Hon Members
    are quite tired but we have to take the last
    Statement.
    Yes, Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:04 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with respect and with your leave, I have
    related to my Hon Colleague, coming
    under Standing Order (53) to vary the
    order of Business and go on to Public
    Business; I seek your leave.
    Mr Speaker, with your leave, we can
    take item number 8(F) and I would like
    to do it for and on behalf of the Hon
    Majority Leader of the House.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:04 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Yes, Hon Minority Chief Whip?
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 2:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, we
    have no objections. The laying is not that
    controversial but it is a very contro-
    versial Report. Once it is laid, copies
    must be made available to Hon
    Members. We should not lay it and go
    home and return the next day before Hon
    Members would be searching for copies,
    because we need the copies to do other
    research, so that we could debate it on

    Thursday; that is the Report of the

    Special Budget Committee on the

    Electoral Commission's Constitutional Instrument (CI), so it is a very

    controversial and turbulent Report, and

    every Hon Member in this House must

    be given a copy —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:14 p.m.
    Why is
    it controversial and turbulent?
    Mr A. Ibrahim 2:14 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, if you
    read the Report itself, that is what it says.
    The Committee raised serious object-
    tions, and Hon Members must be given
    copies of it.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:14 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Hon Members, let me invite you to
    page 6; the item listed 8(f) is to be laid
    by the Hon Chairman of the Special
    Budget Committee.
    PAPERS 2:14 p.m.

    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:14 p.m.
    I would
    like to urge the Clerks-at-the-Table to
    make sure that every Hon Member gets a
    copy of the Report.
    Hon Members, we have come back to
    the last Statement which stands in the
    name of the Hon Member for Domeabra/
    Obom, Ms Sophia Karen Edem Ackuaku,
    on Future Trends Ghana-Africa Manifesto.
    Yes, Hon Member for Domeabra/
    Obom, the floor is yours. Hon Members
    are eager to listen to you; let us hear you.
    STATEMENTS 2:14 p.m.

    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:24 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Hon Members, the Statement has been
    read to us and we would take — Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Hon Members in the Seventh Parlia-
    ment, when a Statement was about to be
    read, it was distributed to Hon Members,
    but it appears that is not the case
    nowadays. The Hon Member who makes
    the Statement keeps it to himself or
    herself, and after a very wonderful
    Statement has been read, nobody would
    have a copy to enable them contribute.
    That is a bit — so, let us try to share.
    So, Hon Member for Afadzato South,
    we are listening to you; I saw you rise.
    But before you speak, let me listen to the
    Hon Majority Chief Whip.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, it
    is quite unfortunate. I think my Hon
    Colleague should do his work; he is not
    doing his job. As an Hon First Deputy
    Whip, he should ensure that the Statement
    is distributed across, especially when it is
    emanating from their Side.
    Mr Whip, do your job.
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 2:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    you know this Statement was given
    today by the Hon Member with the
    expectation that it would be taken
    tomorrow, but Business is light so it has

    been adjusted to be taken today because

    tomorrow is the 30th Anniversary.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:24 p.m.
    Hon
    Deputy Minority Whip, are you sure?
    At the pre-Sitting, the Statement was
    given and you requested that it be taken.
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 2:24 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, in
    fact, I minuted on it today, and that is
    why I said that it was supposed to be
    taken tomorrow, but because of the 30th
    Anniversary tomorrow, that is why we
    are taking the three Statements today.
    The Statements that would be taken
    tomorrow would be on the 30th
    Anniversary, and nobody would be
    accommodated with his or her Statement.
    That is the reason.
    Mr Speaker, you know I am competent
    enough. I act where it matters. This is a
    controversial one, and they are in my
    bosom, and I am just sharing with Hon
    Members; there is another controversial
    one which I have already shared. On
    Thursday, we would meet things
    squarely; the Hon Majority Chief Whip
    knows.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:24 p.m.
    Anyway, let us listen to the contributors.
    Hon Member for Afadzato South, be
    brief.
    Mrs Angela O. Alorwu-Tay (NDC
    — Afadzato South): Mr Speaker, thank you for the opportunity to contribute to
    the Statement made by my Hon Sister,
    Ms Sophia Karen Edem Ackuaku, on the
    “Future Trend Ghana-Africa Manifesto”.
    Mr Speaker, this is an eye opener.
    Today is my first time of hearing about
    this particular institution, and I thank her
    for bringing it to the floor of the House.
    I have learnt something new today in
    addition to what I have already been
    reading. I thank the group leader, Dr
    Farzam Kamalabadi, for the good job he
    is trying to do for the African continent.
    However, just to appeal to the group that,
    as stated in the last paragraph of the
    Statement that he will be meeting and
    having an in-depth meeting with our
    Head of State and other stakeholders,
    they should not forget to include Parlia-
    ment in that stakeholder consultation, so
    that we get to know more and help them
    to achieve whatever they want to achieve
    for the continent.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:24 p.m.
    Very
    well. Now, let me come to Leadership.
    First Deputy Minority Whip (Mr
    Ahmed Ibrahim): Mr Speaker, thank
    you for the opportunity thank the Hon
    Member who made the Statement for
    bringing this to our attention.
    Mr Speaker, thinking of African
    developmental issues, this African
    manifesto is a good intention, and it is a
    good group to be formed. As Africans,
    we must look within, but this has been a
    challenge to most African countries to
    plan ahead and be able to organise what

    we have and to formulate our policies

    alongside being able to develop the

    continent of Africa.

    Mr Speaker, we are talking of Africa,

    but I would like to look within the

    country, Ghana. Drafting a manifesto

    that would stand the test of time, even

    budgeting within a year without a

    supplementary or review Budget, has

    been a problem, so it would not be out of

    place to be thinking of African

    manifestos. I think this is a wake-up call

    for African politicians and for that matter

    Ghanaian politicians, to be able to know

    what matters to our people and

    development structures that we must use.

    Mr Speaker, I am not a member of the

    Pan-African Parliament; even moving

    from advisory to the legislative duty has

    been a challenge, and a manifesto must

    be translated into law. That is why when

    manifestos are drawn and political

    parties win elections, they draw their

    Budget alongside the manifestos, and

    that Budget Statement is approved by the

    passage of the Appropriation Act. Once

    the Appropriation Act is passed, it then

    becomes a law that empowers the winner

    to be able to translate the manifesto into

    legislation and action.

    Mr Speaker, we are talking about

    Africa. Is the Pan-African Parliament not

    just advisory? If we have a parliament

    that is just advisory, therefore, drawing a

    manifesto for that continent, how can we

    translate it into a law? So, I think getting

    an African manifesto would not be out of

    place, but it must begin from the African

    Continental Parliament. We must

    empower an African Parliament to move

    from advisory to legislation. Once that is

    done, that is the very foundation for the

    manifesto to be translated from advisory

    or for just mere policy proposal into law.

    Mr Speaker, then comes our national

    development planning. How long are we

    able to even plan domestically? So, that

    has been a challenge, and I think this

    should be a very good stepping point for

    us to be able to confront that challenge

    and be able to surmount that problem.

    Mr Speaker, I would want to conclude

    by thanking the Hon Member who made

    the Statement for bringing this to our

    attention. It is moving us from just

    partisan issues to ideological base, where

    political parties or the entire Africa

    would be moving with African ideology,

    so that we would be able to know where

    write the African manifesto because

    manifestos are by-products of ideology.

    So, what is the African ideology? These

    are matters to be discussed in the near

    future.

    Mr Majority Chief Whip Annoh-

    Dompreh: Mr Speaker, I would not be

    significantly different from my com-

    petent Hon First Deputy Minority Whip

    that commending the Hon Member who

    made the Statement also puts matters in

    context.

    Mr Speaker, starting off where he

    ended on the note of Pan-African

    Parliament, I am privileged to represent

    the House at the Pan-African Forum.

    Yes, it is true that when one looks at the

    constitution or the orders that control the

    affairs of the Pan-African Parliament, it

    is wholly advisory; thankfully, we set in

    motion, and my Hon Colleague, Ahaji

    Muntaka, plays a significant role in the

    House for the necessary amendment to

    be effected to the standing orders

    regulating the affairs of the Pan-African

    Parliament.

    Mr Speaker, I am glad to say that we

    have gone beyond the first face, and in

    last two years' election that was plagued with a litany of violence antics, my

    humble self was nominated as the

    Electoral Commissioner, and we made

    our country proud, by conducting a very

    transparent, free and fair elections,

    where we got Mr Fortune Charumbira,

    who comes from —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:24 p.m.
    We
    learnt you fought over there.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:34 p.m.
    There were
    violent exchanges before, and then the
    African Union came in and formed this
    electoral body. So we conducted a free
    and fair election after the unfortunate
    display of violence. So, it is something
    we can pride ourselves in.

    Mr Speaker, seriously, what we should

    also be careful about is the duplication of

    crusades, slogans and manifestoes,

    which if we are not careful, with would

    put us on a collision course.

    It is a wonderful idea from the Hon

    Member. However, we already have a

    template in existence. The African Union

    (AU) has put in place what it calls

    Agenda 2063, so do we have to repeat,

    review or it is a question of enforcement?

    In my humble view, I think it is a

    question of enforcement. If we look at

    the world order, right down from the

    Second World War in 1945, the world

    order changed. When we look at the

    economic policy that has been handed

    over to Africa, the Economic Recovery

    Programme (ERP), the Structural

    Adjustment Programme (SAP) and the

    Programme of Action to Mitigate Social

    Costs of Adjustment (PAMSCAD), they

    have all come with conditionalities that

    do not really feed into the core of the

    concerns of the continent. Why? They

    give us aid with one hand, and tell us to

    withdraw subsidies to the social sectors

    of the economy. Meanwhile, it is proved

    that on the average, moneys spent on

    cattle in developed countries, such as

    America and the others, are more than

    what we spend on humans; so, let us not

    reinvent the wheel. There are a thousand

    and one models that we can cite.

    Mr Speaker, the Greece example is a

    wonderful one. If we look at the

    economic trajectory that Greece went

    through in their economic recovery and

    the support the International Monetary

    Fund (IMF) of the Bretton Woods

    institution gave them, it is significantly

    different from how Africa is being

    treated. We need to take our destiny into

    our hands.

    Mr Speaker, we recently talked about

    energy transition. Experts have said that close to 60 per cent of the raw materials needed in the production of the variables for energy transition, solar and solar batteries, are deposited in Africa, so we need to leverage on that, but as to whether we can do it again is another thing. We have all the mineral deposits. People come here and ship our minerals in droves to other countries. We cannot add value to our gold; we cannot add value to what we have.

    Mr Speaker, look at what is happening

    in Congo. It is reputed as the richest country in the world, yet that is where we have more conflicts. How come that all the African countries that are rich in raw materials have more conflicts than the others? Maybe, we would have a better day when we can properly dissect this concern.

    I commend the Hon Member, though I

    would like to caution that we should be careful with slogans and reinventing the wheel. — [Interruption]— [Mr A. Ibrahim: One Village One Dam.] I just commended my Hon Colleague for his competence, so I do not know if he is inviting me to pierce the veil. [Laughter]

    Mr Speaker, I would commend my

    Hon Colleagues. We would all rally

    around in whatever we can do. Ms

    Ackuaku, we have an existing template,

    Agenda 2063, so let us not be seen to be

    departing significantly from it. I think

    that if we pursue this with the unity of

    purpose, we should be able to make a

    meaning. — [Interruption] — [Mr A. Ibrahim: Agenda 111] Mr Speaker,

    Agenda 111 is important, and they know

    that it is work in progress. It is better to

    start something than to sit idle.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you for the space.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:34 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Hon Members, we have brought
    Statements time to a close. We thank all
    the Hon Members who made the
    Statements — Ms Abla Dzifa Gomashie, Mr Oscar Liwaal, and Ms Sophia Karen
    Edem Ackuaku — for the three wonderful Statements we received today. Again, let
    me thank those who contributed to the
    Statements.
    Mr James K. Avedzi 2:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    just want to say that the name is
    “Ackuaku”. I heard something different.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:34 p.m.
    I
    pronounced it the Akan way; the Ashanti
    way, so it is “Ackuaku”.
    Leadership, any indication?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    think we have exhausted what we
    planned to do, and since we have already
    gone beyond 2 p.m., we are in your
    hands.
    Mr A. Ibrahim 2:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I agree
    with my Hon Colleague; we are in your
    hands. I would want to add that
    tomorrow is Wednesday, 22nd February,
    2023, the day for the launch of the 30th
    anniversary celebration, so Hon
    Colleagues should take note of it — [Interruption] — Mr Speaker, there is a challenge. We are in Parliament, and
    tomorrow is the launch of the 30th
    anniversary celebration, so Hon Members
    must endeavour to be here on time and in
    our Christmas attires.
    Mr Speaker, 30 years ago, on 7th
    January, 1993, Ghana moved into the
    Fourth Republic dispensation, and that
    has been the longest Republic that we
    have had, tomorrow is a day for us, as a
    Parliament, to celebrate. It is just about a
    two- to three-hour programme that has
    been planned. I believe the Chairman
    would have been here to throw light on
    the kind of activities we would have.
    I would like to plead with Hon
    Members to ensure that there are not
    many empty seats because it would be
    telecast live. The diplomatic corps and
    some members of the Judiciary and the
    Executive would be here. Other
    dignitaries have been invited as well. If
    we are inviting external bodies to come
    into our home, we must make sure that
    we put our house in good order.
    Also, there must be a calm atmosphere
    in the Chamber because there would be
    Statements from the Leadership of both
    Sides and Speakership. We must make
    sure we give the necessary support so
    that the whole of Africa and the world
    would speak well of the Parliament of
    Ghana.
    Mr Speaker, this is the short message I
    would like to put across. Maybe, the Hon
    Chairman did not brief the Hon Leader.
    That is why he did not say it, but it is
    coming from both Sides of the House.
    Mr Speaker, you would have to confer
    with the Clerk-at-the-Table about the
    time. I thought it was 10.00 a.m., but I
    have been told that it is 9.00 a.m. Per the
    Standing Orders, Hon Members are used
    to coming to Parliament at 10.00 a.m., so
    attendance to any programme that is
    organised before 10.00 a.m. becomes a
    challenge. However, we must prioritise
    to come as early as possible tomorrow. If
    the time is 9.00 a.m., we must be here
    between 8.30 a.m. and 9.00 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, that is the message I
    wanted to put across.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:34 p.m.
    Thank
    you very much.
    Yes, Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:34 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    would like to speak in solidarity with my
    Hon Colleague, but to also say that
    anytime there has been such an occasion,
    the House has risen to it. We are known
    to be a House that always acquits itself
    with true credibility, so I have no doubt
    that we would come in our numbers

    tomorrow. As my Hon Colleague has

    proposed, we should come in our

    Christmas attires. Hon Members should

    come to support.

    Mr Speaker, I just want to conclude.

    When I look on the side of the Minority,

    I see the faces of my Hon Colleagues, Mr

    Ablakwa, Mr Avedzi, my good Friend

    and the competent Hon Minority Chief

    Whip —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:34 p.m.
    I hope
    you are not inviting them.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 2:34 p.m.
    No, Mr Speaker.
    I just want to plead with them that when
    they go home and sleep on their soft
    pillows, they should reconsider their
    decision not to support the ministerial
    nominees; they should reconsider and
    support them. We need them so that we
    can approve them and move this country
    forward; we cannot do without them.
    Mr Speaker, on that note, I would like
    to end and support my Hon Colleague on
    the things he said. As Hon Whips, we
    would also take it as a mandate to carry
    Hon Members along inform them of the
    time, especially now that we are
    reporting at 9 o'clock. We can inform
    Hon Members duly for us to respect it.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:44 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Majority and Minority Whips, you
    have to do your work. I now understand
    that Mr Ahmed Ibrahim is the Vice
    Chairman of the Planning Committee, so
    I think we can whip our Members to be
    on time.
    Hon Members, on that note, we draw
    the curtains down, and I would like to
    thank the House for your cooperation.
    We adjourn the House to tomorrow at 9
    o'clock, as it has been announced to us.
    We hope all Hon Members would be on
    time.
    ADJOURNMENT 2:44 p.m.