Debates of 26 Feb 2008

MR. SPEAKER
PRAYERS 10 a.m.

Mr. Speaker 10 a.m.
Order! Order! Hon. Members, we have in this honourable House, a Parliamentary delegation from the National Assembly of Burkina Faso. It is a powerful delegation and it is led by the Deputy Speaker, hon. Some Placide.
The other Members of the Parliament are as follows:
1. Savadogo Yacouba
“. . . the lands in Tamale to the original owners. . .”
The word “the” should be added.
And then, column 116, Mr. Speaker was now speaking and I thought that that was the wrong thing they were saying for you. The order of that sentence is not right. First of all, you thanked the hon. Deputy Minister and discharged him before you went on to say: “Commencement of Public Business -- item 6”. But if you see the way it is captured there, it is all mixed up; it should be corrected.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker 10 a.m.
Thank you very much for these corrections.
Then we have the Official Report for Tuesday, 18th December, 2007. Item 3 -- Questions -- hon. Minister for Health.
Mr. A. O. Aidooh 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, may we seek your indulgence to permit the hon. Deputy Minister to act for the Minister.
Alhaji M. M. Mubarak 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, you would recall that we keep complaining again and again about the absence of the hon. Minister for Health. Mr. Speaker, I wonder whether the hon. Minister for Health takes this House very seriously. His Questions are always answered by his deputies - [Inter-ruption.]
Mr. Speaker 10:10 a.m.
Hon. Member for Asawase, I am sure he has an explanation. Majority Leader, do you have an explanation for his absence?
Mr. A. O. Aidooh 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I am aware that he has written to inform the House, that he is out of the country.
ADF/RDA 2nd Secretary
2. Ouedraogo Michel CDP 1st Rapporteur
3. Sanou Te Gandi CDP 2nd Rapporteur
4. Diabouga D. Fidele CDP Member
5. Diasso Malakido Mahamed CDP Member
6. Fancani Niquiebo CDP Member
7. Tiemtore Salifo CDP Member
8. Sangli Malendi Jean Paul CDP Member
9. Traore Jules Dekrin CDP Member
10. Ouedraogo Boubacar CDP Member
11. Pare Oumarou CDP Member
We have other seven supporting staff. On behalf of the House and on my own
behalf, I welcome you to Ghana and wish you a pleasant stay here in Ghana.
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 10:10 a.m.

rose
Mr. Speaker 10:10 a.m.
Yes, hon. Member for Wa West?
Mr. Chireh 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, Thursday, 24th January, 2008. Under column 85, the second paragraph, starting with my name there; Mr. Speaker, with your permission,
I beg to quote:
“Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister mentioned Dorimon in the Wa West and not Wechiau District. . .”
This is because the Answer to that Question had Dorimon in Wechiau District and I said no, it was Wa West District and not Wechiau District. So that correction ought to be made.
Mr. Speaker 10:10 a.m.
Thank you, very much.
Mr. Chireh 10:10 a.m.
The second one, column 87; again it is a matter of correction of the name. The Answer to that Question again was that Vierra and I said no. Mr. Speaker, with your permission, I beg to quote that portion:
“. . . the hon. Minister indicated that Vieri which is in my constituency has a police station. . . .”
What I am saying is that the spelling is “Vieri” and not “Vierra” as it appeared in the Official Report. So that correction ought to be made too.
Finally, column 95, first paragraph, third line, “in view of” and not “in lieu of”. This is because the hon. Member said: and I beg to quote:
“I want to know from the hon. Minister whether in view of Akotombra being. . .” and not “in lieu of”.
Mr. Speaker 10:10 a.m.
Thank you, very much.
Yes, we also have the Official Report for Friday, 25th January, 2008.
Mr. Chireh 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, column 113, it is just an omission of the word “the” in paragraph six, the last line where the hon. Member for Tamale South posed the Question:
Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I think my hon. Colleague, the Majority Leader should come properly. Why is he out of the country? If the hon. Minister decides to go on his own frolic and he is out of the country and because of that we should always allow his deputies to come and answer Questions? The records will show that this Minister has consistently refused and failed to appear before this House to answer Questions and this is not something we will take.
Mr. A. O. Aidooh 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, my hon. Colleague has used three verbs: “he has failed” “he has eluded” “he has deli- berately refused”. [Laughter.]
Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister is on a national assignment in Geneva and that is true. So on this occasion, he has neither failed, eluded nor deliberately refused to appear before us. He is on a national assignment in our own interest out of the country in Geneva.
Mr. Bagbin 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, my hon. Colleague is aware that the procedure which he is following is that they discuss with the Ministers before they even agree on the date to fix the Questions for the Minister to come and answer. Is he saying
that he knew at that time that the hon. Minister would be attending an official assignment in Geneva and he yet fixed it for today for the hon. Minister to come and answer? Is that what he wants this House to believe?
Mr. Speaker 10:10 a.m.
Minority Leader, the point is well made. I hope this will not happen again -- [Interruption.]
Mr. A. O. Aidooh 10:10 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, we must get these issues clarified. One, after Mr. Speaker has authorized a Deputy Minister to act, that ends the matter. Mr. Speaker, in a system of government where we have the Arms of Government, Parliament and the Executive being equal and coordinate Parliament cannot ordinarily subject the Executive to its will neither can Executive do the same and so they have to co-ordinate.
So if a business of the Executive takes a Minister out of the country, Parliament cannot insist that he must by all means appear when he has his deputy appearing before the House. That Mr. Speaker, is what is meant by making the Arms of Government equal and co-ordinate.
Mr. Speaker 10:10 a.m.
Hon. Members, let us make progress. I have already directed that this thing should not happen again. That is all. Please, let us go on. I have given my word that this thing would not happen again. So let her represent the hon. Minister for today -- [Inter-ruptions.]
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS 10:10 a.m.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH 10:10 a.m.

Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, to date, the Council has no record of any
petition of premium set illegally, if it had had petitions of illegal premiums set the Ministry would be actually informed.

Maj. (Dr.) (Alhaji) Ahmed (retd): Mr. Speaker, I did not quite get the answer the hon. Deputy Minister gave to this particular supplementary question. The question is whether she is aware that they raised the premium from GH¢7.2 to GH¢20 without the approval of the Council.
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I
am not aware.
Maj. (Dr.) (Alhaji) Ahmed (retd): Mr. Speaker, in her Answer she said that if it is established that it was charged without consulting the General Assembly of the Scheme then this calls for an investigation. I would like to ask the hon. Deputy Minister whether she will cause an investigation to be conducted into this matter.
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I will
encourage the hon. Member of the House to let the Scheme members file a petition through the appropriate authorities and then we will take it over to investigate.
Mr. Speaker 10:20 a.m.
Order! Order! Hon.
Member, this is not a question. Do you have other supplementary questions?
Maj. (Dr.) (Alhaji) Ahmed (retd): Mr. Speaker, my question is that I am a card holder of the scheme, and I am asking her, following the Answer she has given, whether she will cause an investigation to be conducted into this matter.
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, as soon as I have the petition, I will do that.
Mr. Albert Bongo 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I would like to know from the hon. Deputy Minister if somebody living in that community that had set a minimum premium of GH¢20 who cannot afford that amount but can pay the GH¢7.20 will enjoy from the Scheme or not.
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, the Scheme has the General Assembly and then the governing board. I feel the hon. Member should consult the Scheme's General Assembly and then the governing board before we will come in and accept any consideration. But we cannot act without the General Assembly or the governing board doing so. They must consider the member's petition.
Mr. Kwame Osei-Prempeh 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I want to know whether the Ministry has any mechanism of checking and monitoring the levies charged by the various District Mutual Health Scheme. Mr. Speaker, I am asking this because my own District Mutual Health Scheme charges GH¢20 while the three adjoining district charge GH¢12. I would want to know if the Ministry or the National Health Insurance Council has a mechanism to know what is happening on the ground.
Dr. (Mrs) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, the Council has a monitoring system and until a report is filed, we will not be able to do any investigation. But we have members in the communities monitoring the programme.
Mr. A. S. K. Bagbin 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I just want to know from the hon. Deputy Minister whether in setting the premium, they take into consideration the willing- ness of the people to pay. I am talking about the willingness, the ability, I have seen here. Do they also take into consideration the willingness of the people to pay the premium?
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I am surprised the hon. Member of Parliament is saying he is a member of the governing board and in setting the premium, they have meetings with the people in the community. This is because the governing body approve - [Interruption] -- I am answering the question, please. And so with the meeting, once the community members accept to pay the premium then the governing board goes ahead to charge that premium. They have to have consultation with the community. All members are involved before the premium is actually set, and it is a differential between the GH¢7.20 and the GH¢48.
Mr. Bagbin 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, to be
charitable to the hon. Deputy Minister, I think she did not hear my question. This is because she was saying something different from my question. My question which I want to repeat is this, in her Answer, she talked about the ability to pay which is one of the considerations taken in setting the premium, and I am asking whether they also consider the willingness of the people to pay in setting the premium. They are two different things.
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:20 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, we have the governing board, that is made up of representation from all the communities, and this governing board with the consultation of the members in the community set up the premium. I am sure before the premium is set they might have consulted the members of the community before. So without the approval of the members in the community, they will not be able to come up with the premium, set up, the upward adjustments.
Mamobi Polyclinic
Q. 1098. Maj. (Dr.) (Alhaji) Mustapha Ahmed (retd) asked the Minister for Health when the programme to upgrade the Mamobi Polyclinic to a Sub-Metro Hospital would be completed.
Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, the scope of works for the upgrading of the Mamobi Polyclinic comprised the replacement of existing medical equipment, the re-roofing of the building and completion of the top floor of the Maternity Block.
In the case of the replacement of the existing medical equipment, the medical equipment has been delivered to the site by the supplier, ready for the installation which would be completed by the end of April, 2008. This supply of medical equipment was funded under HIPC.
The civil works on the other hand has been delayed due to funding. The civil works were started with funding from the Health Fund, but this funding source has been discontinued by our partners due to Multi-Donor Budget Support (MDBS) concept. The Ministry is still negotiating with Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning for additional funding to complete the upgrading process of the Mamobi Polyclinic.

Maj. (Dr.) (Alhaji) Mustapha

Ahmed (retd): Mr. Speaker, the hon. Deputy Minister in her Answer says the scope of works for the upgrade of the polyclinic comprises replacement of existing medical equipment, re-roofing of the building and completion of the top floor of the maternity block. I would like to ask the Deputy Minister at what stage are these construction works as at now and what percentage of works has been completed. Thank you.
Dr. (Mrs.) Gladys N. Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
Mr. Speaker, I can say that I have no idea of the percentage. But what I know is that work on the project has been suspended. We are looking for funds and as soon as we have them we shall continue work on the block. Thank you.
  • [MAJ. (DR.) (ALHAJI) AHMED
  • Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I do not have the list but they are many. As Deputy Minister, I will consult the Directorate and then I will get the list for his information.
    Nipa Nua Hospital Vessel (Assistance)
    Q. 1109. Mr. J. Z. Amenowode (on behalf of Mr. J. T. Agbenu) asked the Minister for Health what assistance the Ministry would give to the VRA to run effectively the Nipa Nua Hospital Vessel which had been mandated to see to the health needs of the people living along the Volta Lake.
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the Ministry of Health in the past supported the Nipa Nua Hospital Vessel with staff and other logistics for outreach programmes in the hard-to-reach riverine areas. However, the Ministry procured 25 boats (13 fibre glass boats, 10 aluminium dingies, and 2 wooden boats) for the Ghana Health Service to offer such services in line with its policy to make health services accessible to all Ghanaians living anywhere in Ghana.
    The Ministry is yet to develop a multi- regional approach to health services which would provide services to the Eastern, Volta and Northern Regions where these hard-to-reach riverine areas are mostly found. It is in this programme that support for the Nipa Nua services would be captured.
    Volta River Authority (VRA) actually is a private institution and so we know that it will be able to take care of the programme until we are ready to support it.
    Mr. Amenowode 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I would want to know from the hon. Deputy Minister if she is telling us that with the purchase of the 25 boats, the Ministry does not need the services of Nipa Nua Vessel at all.
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the Ministry needs every service that any private facility will provide for the people and that is why we have memoranda of understanding to support all private institutions, especially the Christian health associations. Thank you.
    Mr. Amenowode 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I believe the hon. Deputy Minister actually knows the capacity of Nipa Nua Vessel as compared to the 25 boats. Nipa Nua, to my information, is a complete floating hospital with the capacity to do minor surgery as against the 25 boats that are involved in malaria and other minor OPD services. Now, I am asking the Deputy Minister if it would not be proper to fully support the floating hospital in addition to the emergency boats.
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I know that the hard-to-reach areas are very important and we need all services around and that is the main reason why the Ministry has deployed more boats to support Nipa Nua. Nipa Nua should write to us and request the services. To date I have not yet seen any request from Nipa Nua on my desk.
    Mr. Amenowode 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I think these are some of the reasons why the leadership was insisting on the Minister being here. The Question I asked was that Nipa Nua performs very vital services that the 25 boats do not do. And I asked whether she would consider giving full support to Nipa Nua and she said Nipa Nua should petition -- Mr. Speaker, my
    question is, if the Deputy Minister herself knows the importance of Nipa Nua, should Nipa Nua petition before they offer health services to the people along the Volta Lake?
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, health services are different. We cannot just get up and go and support. They should let us know exactly what they need - the services that they need. Mr. Speaker, one has to procure equipment and so whatever they need then we procure. All the areas of services they need assistance, they should let us know so that we support those areas. We cannot just suddenly get up and go and support whatever. They should let us know.
    New Edubiase Hospital (Ambulance)
    Q. 1199. Mr. Alfred W. G. Abayateye
    (on behalf of Mr. Ernest K. Yakah) asked the Minister for Health what plans the Ministry had to provide New Edubiase Hospital with an ambulance.
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the Ministry of Health in the past provided ambulances to health institutions to enable them carry out effective inter- hospital transfers. However, it has been observed that, most often than not, the ambulances are considered properties of the institutions stationed in the health facilities and do not help neighbouring communities.
    These same health insti tutions sometimes park their ambulances and rely on the services of the National Ambulance Service (NAS) to transport patients to other health institutions.
    Thus, the new policy of the Ministry after this observation is that, the Ministry will no longer allocate ambulances to the health facilities, but rather increase the fleet of the National Ambulance Service (NAS), which can in turn extend pre- hospital emergency medical services to cover communities.
    Mr. Abayateye 10:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the Deputy Minister is saying that the new policy is that the Ministry will no longer allocate ambulances to health facilities. I want to find out whether an ambulance has been allocated to the locality so that New Edubiase can fall within if the hospital itself cannot be allocated one.
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the National Ambulance Service has so far been established in five regions and Ashanti Region is one of them. And so I am sure the New Edubiase area also has the ambulances available to them. And so the number that they should call is 193 and the ambulance will come for any patient who needs the facility.
    Mr. Abayateye 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I want to ask the hon. Deputy Minister, looking at the delicate position of New Edubiase, if you know where New Edubiase is, it is at the tip of the Ashanti Region to the Central Region towards River Pra and knowing the position, the location of New Edubiase and even now the distance from that place to Kumasi, how effective could ambulances be sent when there is this emergency?
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am sure New Edubiase is closer to Obuasi and even Fomena. So I am sure that they can reach the Service by calling 193. That is what we want to establish for the nation as is being done in other parts of the world.
    Mr. E. T. Mensah 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I have a little problem with the Answer given by the Deputy Minister. The Answer has been broken into four paragraphs but she ended at the third paragraph. Does it mean that the fourth paragraph is not part of the Answer? If that were so then she should move for this to be expunged so it is not

    captured in the Hansard. When she was answering the Question she ended here that and I beg to quote:

    “the Ministry will no longer allocate ambulances to health facilities, but rather increase the fleet of the National Ambulance Service (NAS), which can in turn extend pre-hospital Emergency Medical Services to cover communities.”

    That is where she ended but the Answer that has been captured here extends to other paragraphs. So my question is that if she had decided on hind-sight that it should not be part of her Answer, she should better move so that it is expunged from the records so that it is not captured by the Hansard.
    Dr. (Mrs.) Ashitey 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, in answering the supplementary question, I said the ambulance services are in the regions. Currently, we have five regions and so the emergency services would be extended to the districts as well. We have five regions covered by now.
    Mr. Speaker 10:40 a.m.
    Deputy Minister, thank you for coming. You are discharged.
    MINISTRY OF THE INTERIOR 10:40 a.m.

    Minister for the Interior (Mr. Kwamena Bartels) 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the control of the land border posts, including Aflao and Elubo is undoubtedly a sovereign security issue, which is determined by the National Security Council. As such, the decision to close all border posts at 6.00 p.m. to travellers has been set within national and sub-regional
    Mr. Zigah 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, there are so many unapproved routes into the country and if the hon. Minister is telling this House that because of insurgency and other trans-national crimes, that is the
    main reason for the closure of Aflao and Elubo borders after 6.00 p.m., I want to know from him how safe are the unapproved routes along the boundaries of this country.
    Mr. Speaker 10:40 a.m.
    Hon. Member, please this question does not arise. It is not supplementary; ask another question, please.
    Mr. Zigah 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, one of the prime objectives of the ECOWAS Protocol is to allow free and easy movement of goods and services. With the exception of Aflao and Elubo, travellers are in continuous transit even to Central Africa. Will the hon. Minister accept the closure as an advantage for robbers and thieves to operate at the frontier and to consider providing security to protect the travellers until the border is opened the following morning?
    Mr. Bartels 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, that is already being done and we will continue to reinforce the provision of security at the borders.
    Mr. Zigah 10:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, considering Ghana as the gateway to Africa will be meaningless if there is time frame for entry into the country, may I know from the hon. Minister how soon his Ministry will improve the two border posts in terms of increasing men and providing adequate logistics to allow twenty hours entry as ECOWAS Protocol requires.
    Mr. Bartels 10:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, we are already increasing the strength of the border patrol unit of Ghana Immigration Service. We are also increasing the strength of the Customs, Excise and Preventive Service (CEPS) staff. So looking at the security situation in the sub-region, we would consider seriously extending the time further than what is prevailing now.
    Mr. Ken Dzirasah 10:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister in paragraph 4 of his
    Answer indicated that after 1995, through bilateral negotiations the Republic of Togo accepted to open their border from 6.00 a.m. to 6.00 p.m. and later on reviewed it from 6.00 a.m. to 10.00 p.m. If the negotiations were bilateral in nature, why is it that we also have not responded by extending it from 6.00 a.m. to 10.00 p.m. upon review?
    Mr. Bartels 10:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the increase to 10.00 p.m. by the Togolese was unilateral, that was not bilateral, that was not bilateral. The bilateral one was up to
    Mr. Dzirasah 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I think the hon. Minister has cleverly dodged my question. What I am asking is, what is the position of the Government in response to the gesture, whether reluctantly or otherwise by the Togolese authorities?
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, we are actually considering that.
    Pusiga Pulimakom Constituency (Police Station, etc)
    Q. 1227. Mr. Simon A. Akunye asked the Minister for the Interior what plans the Ministry had to provide a permanent police station and residential accommodation for Pusiga Pulimakom Constituency.
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I have informed this august House on a number of occasions that the Government has adopted a holistic approach to solving the problem of residential and office accommodation facing all the Security Agencies including the Ghana Police Service. I further explained that the Government is sourcing for funds from both local and international sources to enable her embark on provision of mass accommodation for the security agencies including the police.
    In addition, I indicated that a team has been set up to assess the budgetary implication of all uncompleted housing
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.


    projects of the security agencies to enable the Ministry source for funding to complete them.

    Mr. Speaker, it is anticipated that the Ministry would be in a position to address the office/residential accommodation problem facing the entire security agencies including the police when we are through with the exercise. At this stage, I would like to assure my hon. Colleague, Mr. Simon A. Akunye, that Pusiga Pulimakom Constituency would be taken care of in the exercise by providing it with a permanent police station and residential accommodation when funds are secured.
    Mr. Akunye 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I asked this question because of the deplorable situation of the Pusiga Police Station. The police were using rented premises which have been taken away by the landlord. The police are now managing a three- roomed building which is woefully inadequate for them to carry out their normal duties. So I thought that the Ministry of the Interior would consider the Pusiga Police Station issue a special or urgent case.
    Mr. Speaker 6 p.m.
    This is a statement you have made -- [Laughter.]
    Mr. Akunye 6 p.m.
    Given the situation which Pusiga Police Station is now facing, I would want to find out from the hon. Minister what urgent steps he would take to solve the problem for us.
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I believe the hon. Member of Parliament and the District Assembly would be in a position to assist the Ghana Police Service. Since they need it so urgently and our preparations are not as ready as he is expecting, I believe the District Assembly should be able to assist us together with the hon. Member of Parliament.
    Administration of the Police Service (Report)
    Q. 1231. Nii Amasah Namoale asked the Minister for the Interior when the Inspector-General of Police would submit a report giving details of the administration of the Service to the Ministry for onward submission to Parliament in accordance with section (36) of the Police Service Act, 1970. (Act 350).
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the Inspector-General of Police is aware of the need to submit a report giving details of the administration of the Service to the Ministry for submission to Parliament in line with section 36 of Act 350, 1970. The IGP has accordingly been submitting the Reports. I am informed that the Police Administration is preparing last year's annual report which would be submitted in due course.
    Nii Namoale: Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask the hon. Minister when was the last time the Police Administration submitted their report to the Ministry.
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I need notice on this. I believe the last one was 2006 but I am not certain, I would like to be given notice to get the definitive information on this matter.
    Nii Namoale: Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask the hon. Minister to tell us when was the last time the Ministry submitted the Police report to Parliament and under which title.
    Mr. Bartels 6 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I believe this question flows from the previous one for which I asked to be given time to provide the information.
    Nii Namoale: Mr. Speaker, I asked this question because I have been in this House for the past three years and two months and I am yet to see the Police report. So would the hon. Minister let me know where I can get the Police report so that I would read and make comments on.
    Mr. Speaker 6 p.m.
    Your question again, please.
    Nii Namoale: Mr. Speaker, I am asking the hon. Minister why he did not submit the Police report to Parliament and I want to know where I can get it -- where I can get the Police report?
    Mr. Speaker 6 p.m.
    Hon. Member, please, one question at a time. Ask your question please.
    Nii Namoale: Hon. Minister, where can I get the Police report that was supposed to have been submitted to Parliament to read?
    Mr. Bartels 11 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, as I said, when I get the opportunity to get the information, I will give him a copy of the information.

    Sefwi Wiawso Police Divisional Headquarters (Logistics)

    Q. 1251. Mr. Evans Paul Aidoo asked the Minister for the Interior when vehicles, communication equipment and other logistics would be provided for the Sefwi Wiawso Police Divisional Headquarters to befit its status.
    Mr. Bartels 11 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I have already informed the House about plans adopted by the Government to solve the problem of vehicles and communication equipment, et cetera facing the security agencies including the police.
    Mr. Speaker, in respect of vehicles, the

    Ministry has taken delivery of a number of vehicles under the India-Exim Bank credit line, for the security agencies including the Police. I am aware that a number of Tata vehicles have been allocated to the police for distribution to police stations lacking this facility.

    In the case of the Sefwi Wiawso Divisional Headquarters, I am informed that the station has been provided with a Landrover. This station would be considered for additional vehicles when we have met the needs of other stations lacking vehicles.

    Mr. Speaker, in respect of commu- nication gadgets/equipment, I reported to the House that the Ministry has identified that the best way to handle the situation is to look at the problem holistically. In this connection, a Chinese company has been contracted to provide dedicated communication network for all the security agencies, including the police.

    The first phase which is confined to Accra and its environs has already started and would be extended to all the regional capitals this year. The last phase involves the extension of the network to the districts.

    I can at this stage assure my hon. Colleague that Sefwi Wiawso Police Divisional Headquarters will be considered in the provision of the communication network facilities in this exercise.
    Mr. E. P. Aidoo 11 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, Sefwi Wiawso as he said is a Divisional Headquarters with an old Land Rover. I do not know when it was allocated to them and this Land Rover was brought from Tarkwa. Would the hon. Minister consider giving one of the new Tata vehicles to Sefwi Wiawso Divisional Headquarters?
    Mr. Bartels 11 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, they already have one. There are so many divisions and various police posts that have nothing at all. So we pray that they would make do with what they have. Some more are

    coming and when they do come, we would consider Sefwi Wiawso for an additional vehicle. Thank you.
    Mr. Speaker 11 a.m.
    Question number 1300 -- Hon. Joe Danquah, Member of Parliament for Tain?
    Maj. D. Y. Oduro (retd): Mr. Speaker, the hon. Member is unavoidably absent and has mandated me to ask the Question on his behalf.
    Mr. Speaker 11 a.m.
    Where is he?
    Maj. Oduro (retd): Mr. Speaker, he is in the constituency on a Bui Dam exercise.
    Mr. Speaker 11 a.m.
    Hon. Member, then ask the Question.
    Brong Ahafo Regional Police Barracks and Berekum Police
    Barracks
    Q. 1300. Maj. Oduro (retd) (on behalf of Mr. Joe Danquah) asked the Minister for the Interior when the Brong Ahafo Regional Police Barracks at Sunyani and the Berekum Police Barracks would be completed and commissioned.
    Mr. Bartels 11 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, as indicated in my previous brief, a team has been set up to assess all uncompleted residential/ office accommodation of the security agencies and come out with its budgetary implications to enable the Ministry source for funds to complete such projects.
    The Police Administration's inability to complete and commission the barracks at Sunyani and Berekum is largely due to financial constraints. I believe the measures taken by the Government to address accommodation problems facing the security agencies would help solve the problem of completion and commissioning of police barracks at Sunyani and Berekum.
    Mr. Speaker 11 a.m.
    Hon. Minister for
    STATEMENTS 11 a.m.

    Minister for the Interior (Mr. Kwamena Bartels) 6 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, once again with your kind permission, I would like to provide an update to this noble House on the communal clashes between the Kusasis and Mamprusis at Bawku and its environs which started on 31st December, 2007. This is in discharge of my responsibility under section 4 (3) of Act 491 -- The Public Order Act.
    Latest Development -- Violent Incidents
    Mr. Speaker, as you may recall, on 12th February 2008 during my briefing to this House on the conflict, I did indicate, among others, that by an Executive Instrument, Government had reimposed the dusk-to-dawn curfew on Bawku Municipality and its environs on 12th February, 2008 with the curfew hours being from 8.00 p.m. to 5.00 a.m.
    Unfortunately, Mr. Speaker, later on the same day (12th February, 2008), there was a resumption of violence between the two factions, which was occasioned by the alleged firing of an AK 47 rifle, by two unidentified gunmen at a mosque at Sabon-Geri, a suburb of Bawku, where a group of Muslims were offering prayers.
    Fortunately, Mr. Speaker, no one was hit and when the Security Personnel arrived at the scene, they retrieved one live and twenty expended shells of AK
    47 ammunition. Investigations into the incident are still ongoing and no arrest has yet been made.
    Mr. Speaker, on the following day, 13th February 2008, the firing extended to other parts of Bawku and one male adult sustained serious injuries and was transported by air to the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital, where he is presently receiving treatment. Mr. Speaker, as a result of the resumption of hostilities, the curfew hours were changed to 5.00 p.m. to 6.00 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the latest hostilities that resumed on 12th February, 2008 has led to a catalogue of serious acts of violence, which include the following:
    1. In the evening of 13th February, 2008, a group of people attacked and stabbed one person at Natinga, a suburb of Bawku but the timely intervention by the Police/Military Patrol team saved him from being lynched. The victim is presently on admission at the Bolgatanga Presbyterian Hospital.
    2. On 13th February, 2008, during enforcement of the curfew, the Military Patrol team came under attack by unidentified group of people at Natinga, a suburb of Bawku, and succeeded in removing the magazine of a G3 raffle of one of the soldiers. Fortunately, Mr. Speaker, the magazine and its content (twenty live ammunitions) has since been retrieved and six (6) persons arrested have since been granted bail.
    3. On 15th February 2008, Mr. Speaker, during curfew hours, a male adult who was travelling from Kulungugu to Bawku on a motorbike, was attacked and shot at by unidentified gunmen who took away his
    motorbike in the process. The victim is presently on admission at the Bolgatanga Presbyterian Hospital and the suspects are still at large.

    4. Again, Mr. Speaker, on the 15 th February 2008, upon a tip off, the security agencies searched a house at one of the Bawku suburbs and found one live G3 ammunition, military accu-trement and an axe, and it is suspected that these imple-ments were to be used in hostilities. One person who was arrested in the process has since been remanded in custody.

    5. On 16th February 2008, there was a misunders tand ing between second year and third year students of the Bawku High School when they went to fetch water from a well but the Senior House Master of the school succeeded in resolving the matter. However, Mr. Speaker, on the following day, 17th February 2008, a student, from one ethnic group, allegedly pulled a locally-manufactured gun and shot at another student, from another ethnic group but missed him narrowly. The suspect is still at large with the weapon.

    6. On 23rd and 24th February, 2008, six houses and a welding shop in the Bawku township respec- tively were set ablaze by an unidentified group of persons.

    7. Finally, Mr. Speaker, just yesterday, 25th February, 2008, four houses at Sabon-Geri, one cargo truck and one pick-up of the Quality Medical Centre were set ablaze by unidentified

    persons.

    Mr. Speaker, it is nearly two months now since the outbreak of violence in the Bawku Traditional Area between the Kusasis and Mamprusis, and although Government, through the security agencies, with the support of the political and traditional leaders of the area, has succeeded in ensuring relative peace and tranquility in the area, the situation is still unstable as the above incidents demonstrate.

    Mr. Speaker, the mounting tension in the community led to the closure of all first cycle schools in the Bawku township yesterday, 25th February, 2008 for a day.

    Mr. Speaker, in view of the volatile nature of the situation, the Government, acting on the advice of the Upper East Regional Security Council (REGSEC), has decided to maintain the dust-to-dawn curfew on Bawku Municipality for as long as it is necessary. Indeed, Mr. Speaker, by an Executive Instrument, the curfew has been reimposed on Bawku Municipality yesterday, 25th February, 2008 with the curfew hours being from 5.00 p.m. to

    Latest Development -- Efforts towards Peace

    Mr. Speaker, since the outbreak of the violence, the Government has demon-strated, in no uncertain terms, its commitment towards bringing peace through whatever means possible. As part of this effort, the Upper East Regional Security Council, with the support of the leadership of the two factions and the MPs of the area, organized a reconciliatory meeting on 18th February 2008, which was attended by all the ethnic groups in the area, members of the Upper East Regional Security Council, Municipal and District Chief Executives, Members of Parliament from the area, religious leaders and other stakeholders.

    Mr. Speaker, the focus of the meeting was on how to bring the hostilities and violence to an immediate end and build
    Minister for the Interior (Mr. Kwamena Bartels) 6 a.m.


    confidence and trust in each other. At the end of the meeting, a communiqué, signed by the leaders of the two main factions as well as the other ethnic groups in the area and witnessed by the Upper East Regional Minister, was issued.

    Mr. Speaker, as per the communiqué, parties have resolved to do whatever it takes to ensure immediate restoration of normalcy in the area so as to revamp the vibrancy of the area in terms of its socio- economic activities and unity of its people.

    Mr. Speaker, I am convinced that if the thirteen-point communiqué is fully implemented, it will go a long way to complement Government efforts and fast track the process of bringing peace, stability and tranquility to the area. I therefore plead with the parties to honour their words.

    Conclusion

    In conclusion, Mr. Speaker, I must say that due to the security measures put in place so far, including the curfew and beefing up of the security presence on the ground yesterday, coupled with the commitment to peace demonstrated by the two groups and politicians of the area, relative normalcy is returning to the area.

    At this point, Mr. Speaker, permit me, on behalf of this House, to salute the gallant men and women of our security agencies, for their devotion to duty and high sense of patriotism, which have brought about the relative peace and stability that the people of Bawku and its environs enjoy today.

    However, Mr. Speaker, whilst we celebrate our security agencies, we should be mindful of the fact that the situation is still very volatile coming as it were from what happened even just yesterday and must therefore continue to be a matter of concern to all.

    As a result, Mr. Speaker, I want to, once again, appeal to all factions to give peace a chance through compromises and the utilization of constitutional and other legal structures in the resolution of their differences. We must remember that we are one people with a common destiny; we are Ghanaians with a high sense of unity where a child in a community is everybody's child; and above all, we are peace-loving people, with unquestionable sense of sharing, compromise and accommodation of divergent views. Therefore, we should let our actions reflect our values.

    Mr. Speaker, I want to assure this House that the Government will continue to play its part; and the security agencies will continue to protect life and property. We urge the people in the area, particularly, the leaders, to do their part. Mr. Speaker, I am optimistic that if we continue in this direction, peace and tranquility will be restored to the area sooner than later.

    Finally, Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. Colleagues in this House, particularly, those from the conflict catchment areas, for their co-operation and support, which the Government hopes to continue to count on as we strive to resolve this conflict.

    Mr. Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity.
    Mr. Mahama Ayariga (NDC -- Bawku Central) 11:20 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, once again, we are hearing a Statement from the hon. Minister for the Interior on the conflict in Bawku area.
    Mr. Speaker, the closing paragraph of the Statement thanks hon. Members of this House from that catchment area for their co-operation and support and hopes that the Government can continue to count on us in the effort to resolve this conflict. Mr. Speaker, I want to assure the hon. Minister that the Government certainly can continue to count on us in the effort
    to resolve the situation in Bawku. But it must be on the condition that we will do the right things that will resolve the situation in Bawku.
    Mr. Speaker, the evidence we have shows that we have increased the number of soldiers and police officers and police- men in the Bawku Municipality. But Mr. Speaker, it has not entirely stopped aggression from both sides. Mr. Speaker, we have imposed curfew on the people of Bawku.
    Indeed, on one occasion, they had to go to bed at 3.00 p.m., in the afternoon when the sheep and goats and fowls in town were still roaming about. Mr. Speaker, it has not stopped people from burning houses in the night during the curfew and from attacking other people during the curfew.

    Mr. Speaker, we have effected arrests, but it has not stopped people from attacking anybody who is considered as an opponent found in their neigh-bourhoods. Mr. Speaker, in simple terms, we have deployed the military solution without the sort of success that the people of Bawku are entitled to by way of their right to also live in a peaceful atmosphere.

    It is in that light, Mr. Speaker, that I wish to make this very important statement, for our people have a saying that if you know that when there is trouble you cannot run away and leave somebody, when you are going to the jujuman for medicine for vanishing make sure you take that person along.

    Mr. Speaker, the truth has to be stated and both sides have taken a position. The Mamprusis take a position that until H.E. the President of this country, President John Agyekum Kufuor and the

    NPP Government come out with a clear position on the chieftaincy issue in Bawku, they are not going to abate aggression.
    rose
    Mr. Speaker 11:20 a.m.
    Order! Order! Deputy Attorney-General, are you on your feet?
    Mr. Osei-Prempeh 11:20 a.m.
    Yes, Mr. Speaker, on a point of order. The hon. Member for Bawku Central is saying something which concerns his own people and therefore he is speaking their view. Mr. Speaker, he knows that the Constitution of this country places a limit on the President of this country going into chieftaincy matters.
    Is he asking that the President should come out openly and say who the rightful chief of Bawku is before the people lay down their arms? And is he supporting such a dangerous statement which has no legal and constitutional basis for him to articulate this on the floor of the Parliament of this country? Mr. Speaker, I believe that the hon. Member should stop there, withdraw and go back and advise his people.
    Mr. Speaker 11:20 a.m.
    Hon. Member for Bawku Central, only comment please, no debate.
    Mr. Ayariga 11:20 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, taking a cue from you I will not respond to what he has said. But let me just reiterate what I said that the Mamprusis, from reports that I gather directly from them, are disappointed that the President has not
    Mr. Ayariga 11:20 a.m.
    shown a direct --
    Mr. Speaker, he has sent the Minister for the Interior, that is his Minister; he has sent the Minister of Defence, that is his Minister; he has sent soldiers; he is the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces. He is in charge of the police, he has shown some concern, there is no doubt about that.
    He has taken some action, there is no doubt about that. But they are saying that just as he found it important to embark on a plane and go to Kenya, he should have also embarked on a similar plane and come to Bawku to meet all the sides -- in fact, a helicopter not a plane, to come to Bawku and meet all the sides and have frank and open discussions.
    Mr. Speaker, the Deputy Attorney- General and Minister for Justice is able to tell us in this House that the President cannot be involved in chieftaincy matters. Mr. Speaker, I said this sometime ago in this House but still the people want to hear it from high-ranking government officials and in particular the President before they will take that answer.
    On the other hand, Mr. Speaker, the
    Kusasis are not happy because they do not see this as a matter of chieftaincy at all. So far as they are concerned, the chieftaincy issue has been resolved by PNDCL 75 and sealed by the Supreme Court decision. And so, so far as they are concerned, this is not about who is the legitimate chief of Bawku, but the question of whether or not the State is going to sit idly by and allow some others to disregard a decision of the legitimate institutions of this country.
    In this regard, they also are not happy with the continuous pronounce-ments by top government officials which create

    an impression that this is a chieftaincy matter and not simply a question of the enforcement of the decision of the Supreme Court.

    Mr. Speaker, it is in that regard that I think we must be frank and open about the situation on the ground. We can continue to send more soldiers, more police officers, we can extend the curfew to 12 mid-day until 8 o'clock in the morning -- and I do not know what conversations have taken place between them and top government officials to make them believe that they could do anything about the situation -- until the President himself comes out publicly and shows a direct interest and goes to the place, and sits with all the parties, and is open and frank about what he as President can do and what he cannot do, Mr. Speaker, every week or two weeks you will come back to this House and make a statement on the curfew situation in Bawku.

    Mr. Speaker, on that note, let me re- iterate the proverb with which I began this statement, that if you know you cannot run away and leave somebody when there is trouble, when you are going to the jujuman's house send him along for medicine for vanishing. Even though it is not easy, I am compelled to say the truth so that the Government will know in case there is a pretence that we do not know what the solution to this problem is, in case we think that the solution to this problem is entirely a military one and therefore increasing the size of soldiers and police on the ground will resolve the issue. It will not.

    It must force some peace, but from all the indications that I am getting from the ground, it will not bring us lasting total peace that will ensure that people live in confidence, that their security is to be taken for granted unlike what is happening presently.

    On that note, Mr. Speaker, let me assure him that I am willing to co-operate and continue to support the Government but I am calling on the Government to do the right thing, what I have prescribed today before this honourable House.
    Mr. M. A. Awuni (NDC -- Binduri) 11:20 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I wish to thank the Minister for the Interior for the way in which he has submitted his report on the conflict in Bawku.. But I also want to inform him that the people of Bawku are in a curfew starting from 5.00 p.m. to 6.00 a.m. but houses and other financial ventures are still being burnt down in the night by the people of Bawku.
    Therefore, I want to appeal to the security forces through the Minister that much is yet to be done by the security agencies. The people cannot be said to be indoors from 5.00 p.m. to 6.00 a.m. while in the course of the night other people have the chance of going out to burn houses. If we accept the fact that the security forces are there, then why is it that these things are still happening during curfew hours? So I am appealing to the Minister that we still need more because our situation is not favourable. This is the little I have to contribute.
    Alhaji Sumani Abukari (NDC -- Tamale North) 11:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I would want to support the statements of the Ministers of Interior and the hon. Member for Bawku Central, hon. Ayariga. The Bawku situation is a very sad situation indeed and I personally feel saddened because it seems to be taking the same steps that the Dagbon crisis took from the beginning.
    I want to advise my brothers and sisters of Bawku that they should please, please, please smoke the peace pipe. We in Dagbon know what we are going through

    today. We know that it is sending us backwards. Our education has gone back, we produced some of the best scholars in the country sometime ago, our commerce has reduced, our development hss reduced because of the persistent conflict that we have in Dagbon.

    But you see, Mr. Speaker, some of these problems cannot be resolved by the military alone as hon. Ayariga indicated. It is important for the military and the police there to keep the peace. But as long as the laws of the land are not respected, as long as decisions of the Supreme Court, the highest court of the land are not respected, Mr. Speaker, as long as the customs, traditions and practices of the people are not respected by any group of people in these areas, it is going to be difficult for us to have peace in Bawku or for that matter in Dagbon.

    In fact, the two cases are very similar and I am really saddened that Bawku would be allowed by the people there to degenerate to the extent that Dagbon is gone.

    So I am appealing to my brothers and sisters in Bawku, to lay down their arms. They should not go the Dagbon way. They should smoke the peace pipe, and let us see whether they can stay there as brothers and sisters. Bawku is not for the Kusasis and Mamprusis alone. There are several other tribes there. My own people, the Dagombas are also there. The Hausa, the Moshies, many tribes are also there. It would have been a very beautiful area if there were peace there. It is a place that was very promising. It was a commercial centre for the North sometime ago.

    Mr. Speaker, I hope that as the hon. Member said, the Government would do a bit more to ensure that the people are
    Alhaji Sumani Abukari (NDC -- Tamale North) 11:30 a.m.


    move forward.

    Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
    Mr. Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    At the commencement of Public Business, item 5 -- Presentation and First Reading of Bills -- hon. Minister for Harbours and Railways?
    Mrs. Kusi 11:30 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, with your indulgence, I beg to ask for permission for the hon. Minister of State for Water Resources, Works and Housing to act in place of the hon. Minister.
    BILLS -- FIRST READING 11:30 a.m.

    Mr. Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    Hon. Members, let us move to item seven (7), Motion. Deputy Minister for Manpower, Youth and Employment. You have five minutes.
    MOTIONS 11:30 a.m.

    Mr. Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Are you concluding?
    Mrs. Osei-Opare 11:40 a.m.
    I am ending Mr.
    Speaker.
    The real challenge in the informal sector is something that we need to deal with. I would like to say that, the Ministry of Manpower, Youth and Employment has embarked on a labour market information system that will help to give live data on the job market situation and will also encourage our institutions to know what types of expertise to develop to meet the national needs of the labour market.
    Mr. Speaker, with this contribution, I would urge hon. Members to support wholeheartedly the motion that this House thanks His Excellency the President for the State of the Nation Address he delivered
    and I also want to thank you hon. Speaker, for this opportunity.
    Mr. Lee Ocran (NDC - Jomoro) 11:40 a.m.
    Mr.
    Speaker, thank you very much for allowing me to contribute to the President's State of the Nation Address. Mr. Speaker, before I proceed I want to draw attention to the contribution by the hon. Member for Ayawaso West Wuogon, Mrs. Osei-Opare, that some of the progress that the country has made is conversion of the first class residential place, like East Legon, Airport Residential Area into a place for selling second-hand-cars and second-hand- clothing; that is progress indeed.
    Mr. Speaker, I want to refer to the President's Address in the year 2001 and this is what he said and with your pemission, I quote:
    “Mismanagement , mass un- employment, high cost of living, colossal national debt, high depen- dency on foreign aid, extensive corruption in public life, hope- lessness and despair; this is the legacy of the last two decades.”
    Mr. Speaker, I want to ask hon. Members here and the whole nation 11:40 a.m.
    Where do we go? Where do we stand now? Mass unemployment. Yes, it is there. Colossal national debt; the debt which was ¢41 trillion has now ballooned to ¢772 trillion as at the last budget and now we continue borrowing - [Inter-ruption.]
    Mr. Osei-Mensah 11:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, on a point of order.
    Mr. Ocran 11:40 a.m.
    Allow me to make my
    comments. Oh!
    Mr. Osei-Mensah 11:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker,
    my hon. Colleague is saying that now what do we see in the country. Mass unemployment. Mr. Speaker, who created
    Mr. Osei-Mensah 11:40 a.m.
    We had a govern-
    ment that started the junior secondary school programme and children about the age of about 14 years, when they failed they had no other means of re-sit and for that reason they could not continue with their education, so they ended up on our streets. We have come and given them the opportunity to re-sit - [Hear! Hear!] - And we are creating jobs for them -- the youth employment programme. The debris that they left, we have cleared them and built a superstructure and we are going to put up and add the finishing touches. So Mr. Speaker, he is deceiving the public and this House. [Hear! Hear!]
    Mr. Ocran 11:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, with much
    respect, the hon. Member would have the chance to speak; he should allow me to speak.
    Mr. Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon. Member please,
    go on.
    Mr. Ocran 11:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the President
    said high dependency on foreign aid. They have been in government for seven year; we know. Every person who enters the Castle and shakes his hands, he will ask for aid; that is the first thing he does; Even for accommodation, he will ask for aid. When did the dependence on foreign aid end? They should look at their own budget and tell us where have they gone from these remarks. Mr. Speaker, [Interruption.] The hon. Member should not interrupt me again.
    Mr. Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon. Member for
    Mr. Ocran 11:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the President went on and with your permission, I quote him:
    “The edifice known locally as Job 600 stands in its uncompleted state as an eye-sore and disgrace to all of us. Hon. Members therefore, continue to be deprived of offices and support services required to make them effective. We shall finish the refurbishment of Job 600 and ensure our Members of Parliament are appropriately equipped admi- nistratively to serve the nation.”
    Hon. Members, where are the offices? [Some hon. Members. No!] Hon. Members, are you equipped? [Some hon. Members. No!] Have you got secretaries? [Some hon. Members. No!] Mr. Speaker, seven years on after this promise -- [Interruptions.] I go on Mr. Speaker.
    Mrs. Osei-Opare 11:40 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker,
    Mrs. Osei-Opare 11:40 a.m.
    $25 million. I thank my hon. Colleagues for the correction. Where is that money so that we can continue with that project so that it does not become an eye-sore? Mr. Speaker, I need clarification. Are you aware that there was $25 million given to us for this work and we cannot find the money?
    Mr. Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon. Member, you do
    not have to ask questions here.
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, she is ignorant about the facts, so I will continue. Mr. Speaker, the President goes on and with your permission, I beg to quote him:
    “The total debt stock of our country stood at ¢41.1 trillion at the end of December, 2000.”
    May I ask hon. Members, what is the national debt today? [Interruptions.] Thank you very much and the President goes on; the President continues:
    “We shall take appropriate action towards full cost recovery and implement a plan to reduce the stock at Tema Oil Refinery debt over time.”

    How much is the Tema Oil Refinery debt? Is ¢1.1 trillion as at today.
    Mr. Speaker, I continue 11:50 a.m.
    “We will aggressively tackle the huge budget deficits with the aim of balancing the budget by the end of this government's first term in office.”
    I repeat; “. . . by the end of this government's first term in office.” The budget deficit as at 2006 was 7.8 per cent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). He promised that seven years ago. [Interruptions] -- He said and I quote him:
    “It is unacceptable for Ghana which has all that it takes to produce sufficient food. . . .”
    Prof. Gyan-Baffour 11:50 a.m.
    On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I think the hon. Member here is trying to deceive the whole country and everybody in this House. He has not got the source for those figures that he is manufacturing. He is just quoting figures. The deficit for last year was six per cent and it is not 7.8 per cent
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, you see, this is the problem with professors. I said as at 2006 and he is talking about 2007. The professor should listen very carefully.
    Mr. Speaker, and the President said 11:50 a.m.
    “It is unacceptable for Ghana which has all it takes to produce sufficient food to feed her people and export to less endowed countries to spend massive foreign exchange to import from other countries including those in the desert.”
    The Speaker, as at 2000, we spent $100 million on rice importation. As at 2006, we spent $300 million.
    Some hon. Members: Oh!
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    And I continue. Is that not so, the professor? The President went on:
    “The recent trends in educational financing also pose the danger that secondary education would be priced completely out of the reach of the children of ordinary Ghanaians. This is equally unacceptable.”
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Order! Order! Hon. Members, as you know, I have been directed to take very few interruptions. So I am being selective. Therefore if you are not called, then you know that these are the instructions.
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
    Mr. Speaker, I continue 11:50 a.m.
    “There is still a predominance of infectious diseases, malaria,
    diarrhoea, acute respiratory infection, tuberculosis and in- creasing HIV/AIDS as the leading causes of morbidity. Guinea-worm infestation, which declined sub- stantially in the past four years has reappeared. …”
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Whom are you addressing, hon. Member?
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am addressing the House.
    rose
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon. Member for Ayirebi/Ofoase, what is your point of order?
    Mr. Oppon-Kusi 11:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I have a point of order and also because a lot of people are listening to us.
    Mr. Speaker, one of the problems we have in this country is our inability to use mathematics to develop. The hon. Member said that at one point he was paying ¢600,000 but now he needs to pay about ¢1.2 million - [Interruptions.] Whatever he said, whether the figures are true nor not, if one does not put this in the proper perspective - how much was he earning then and how much is he earning now?
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Order! Order!
    Mr. Oppon-Kusi 11:50 a.m.
    We should not throw dust into people's eyes. How much was he earning then and how much is
    Mr. Oppon-Kusi 11:50 a.m.


    he earning now? Mr. Speaker, because people are listening, I might as well say that thirty years ago I only had to pay ¢40 to go to secondary school. I could have as well say that and then throw dust into people's eyes. Please, when he is making the argument, he should not throw dust into people's eyes. How much was he taking those years? He should tell us.

    Mr. Speaker, I want him to tell us so that we will know whether he is spending a higher percentage of his salary or a lower percentage of his salary.
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon. Member, this is not Question time. Let him continue. Please, hon. Member for Jomoro, continue.
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I would ignore him but I want to tell him that I continue to earn more money, so I do not know what he is talking about. My moneys keep increasing. I work very hard.
    Mr. Speaker, one of the interesting things the President said was about railways. That the railway had not seen any substantial investment for how many years and that within his period he was to construct railway to the North.
    Mr. Speaker, in 2001, trains were running from Takoradi to Kumasi. Trains were running from Aboase to Takoradi Port carrying bauxite. Trains were running from Nsuta carrying managanese. Trains were running from Accra to Nsawam. Today, none of those lines run. Now, bauxite is carried by trucks destroying the roads that we left behind. What has the Ministry of Railways and Ports done?
    Mr. Speaker, all that they have succeeded to do is to rehabilitate the Accra to Sakumono rail lines and one will see only five passengers. The only thing they have succeeded in doing is to put a big picture of Mr. Kufuor and write, “Happy

    Birthday, Mr. President”.
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Please, conclude.
    Mr. Ocran 11:50 a.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am a Ranking Member, I have two minutes more.

    On 24th December, 2000, the money was there. Maybe, the hon. Member for Ayawaso-West-Wuogon was a lecturer at the University of Ghana, Legon she did not know. I was in government, so she should listen to me. Mr. J. H. Mensah, that money was there. The African Development Bank had approved the money.
    Mr. Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon. Member for Jomoro, your time is up now.
    Mr. Ocran noon
    Mr. Speaker, these gentlemen and ladies have blown too much hot air and they are now eating humble pie.

    Minister of State, Ministry of Water Resources, Works and Housing (Ms. Cecilia A. Dapaah): Thank you, Mr. Speaker for giving me the opportunity to join my hon. Colleagues in thanking His Excellency the President of the Republic for fulfilling his constitutional role of giving us the State of the Nation Address.

    Mr. Speaker, within the one-and-a- half hours that His Excellency spoke, he exuded warmth, respect and confidence. In fact, from the accounts he gave, we all know and we have all realized that this country has a lot to be thankful for. We have come very far in our governance. We have come very far in our developmental effort and now we have great expectation, we have hope and indeed, we have faith in ourselves.

    The can-do-spirit of the Ghanaian which started in the sixties has come back. Now, if we are even to take sports, for example, we have both our males and females doing very well internationally and on the Continent of Africa.

    Mr. Speaker, permit me to touch briefly on three areas that His Excellency was kind enough to touch on in his Address. I want to first start with water. We all know the importance of water. During this season which is a dry season in our land, we have a lot of water scarcities, and

    I believe this is normal but at the same time we have all contributed to creating this situation.
    Mr. J. Z. Amenowode noon
    Mr. Speaker,
    on a point of order.
    Mr. Speaker noon
    Are you raising a point
    of order or you are contributing?
    Mr. Amenowode noon
    Mr. Speaker, I
    think she is misleading Ghanaians that the “can do” spirit of Ghana started in the 1960s. My history tells me it started long before that.
    Ms. Dapaah noon
    Mr. Speaker, as far
    Mr. C. S. Hodogbey noon
    Mr. Speaker,
    on a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I heard
    Mr. C. S. Hodogbey noon


    the hon. Member on the floor talking about water and the Government being committed to provision of water for Ghanaians. If she has listened to radios and watched the television this morning, even at our hospitals the officials are buying water to conduct their surgery. I said the other day that prior to this Government coming to power areas which were flowing with water, today the pipes are dry.

    So we see so much of the yellow can which people code name “Kufuor cans” “Kufuor Jeri cans” going round everyday looking for water. What is she trying to tell Ghanaians? She is deceiving this House.
    Ms. Dapaah noon
    Mr. Speaker, I do not see
    the point of my hon. Colleague because we all know that we have water scarcity and we are here as a House to discuss the problems of this nation and I am in the sector and I am here to provide some of the solutions to this problem that we have. I am not shying away from the problem of scarcity, so I would proceed.
    Mr. Speaker, we all know about the
    aggressive projects that this country has put in place with regard to urban water, for instance. As we speak, the Accra East-West interconnection is going on, there is an expansion of the Weija Water Project, which hopefully before the end of the year would come on stream. We have Kwanyaku Water Project, Cape Coast Water Project, Koforidua Water Project, Tamale Water Project, we all share the plight of the Tamale people, we all know what is going on there now. Bafikrom is on, Kumasi Barikese is going to be expanded. With regard to rural water, we have done a lot of projects in this area as well.
    Mr. Speaker, I want to appeal to all of us that during this dry and humid season,
    Ms. Dapaah noon


    there is no wastage of the small water that we have. We should also try and protect the water sources and our rivers because we have turned our rivers and waters sources into refuse dumps and breeding grounds for mosquitoes.
    Mr. Mahama Ayariga noon
    Mr. Speaker,
    on a point of order.
    Mr. Speaker, I would have allowed it
    to pass but my deep concern about the plight of the rural people compels me to raise a point of order. Mr. Speaker, she is clearly misleading this House. If you look at the 2006 Budget Statement relating to 2007 fiscal year, Mr. Speaker, there was a promise in the rural areas to construct over a thousand hand-dug wells.
    But Mr. Speaker, if you look at the 2008 Budget Statement at page 154, we are told that hand-dug wells, very easy to do, very cheap to do for the rural areas, this Government constructed only 63 hand-dug wells all over the country. So on what basis is she telling this country that they had provided enough water for the rural folk of this country? Mr. Speaker, she is clearly misleading this House.
    Ms. Dapaah noon
    Mr. Speaker, I have not
    said anywhere in my contribution that the Government had provided enough water for all people. This can never be true. I did not say that. So I urge my hon. Colleague to withdraw that. We have in this document all that we have done in the area of both urban and rural water. He can come to me later and cross check.
    Mr. Speaker, I want to take this
    opportunity, as I said, to appeal to all of us and especially to our water company that in order to forestall illegal connections and
    stealing of pipelines, all external works with regard to pipelines should be carried out by the Ghana Water Company. Also, we should do water harvesting; we have it in the water policy which would come on stream very soon and there should be good water management in our homes.
    The little water that we have, we have some of our colleagues even when they are shaving open the full tap to make sure they finish shaving before they put it off. I believe little drops of water make a mighty ocean.
    Mr. Speaker, digging of wells and boreholes can also help ameliorate the situation but I would appeal to all of us that we do so in consultation with the Ghana Water Resource Commission because of the unsuitability of some of the water that we get from some of these wells. Some have salination in them, some have ion and some have fluoride. Mr. Speaker, I believe very soon when all our water projects are on stream, we would have some hope in our water situation.
    I have not had water running in my
    house for the past six months. So I am also going through what my hon. Colleagues are going through. Therefore it is not a shame. We all know about the expansion project that is going on.
    Mr. Speaker, I want to touch on the area
    Mr. Speaker noon
    Madam, you may be
    concluding now.
    Ms. Dapaah 12:10 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, we are
    on course with the construction of about 4,000 units of houses in Kpone, Bortey- man, in the Ashanti Region, Wa and Tamale and we have gone further to even arrange mortgage facilities for those who would want to access some of these houses.
    We have spoken to Ghana Home Loans,
    Home Finance Company (HFC) and other Banks like Barclays and they are ready with mortgage loans for those of us who are interested in obtaining some of these houses.

    Mr. Speaker, as the President paid tribute to the private real estate deve- lopers, let me commend them for the wonderful work that they are doing. Our motto as a party for this Government is “Development in Freedom” and really these real estate developers have given us the proof that when you have that “can-do” do spirit, you can do a lot.

    Most of the real estates or the construction that you see around us, and the President called a miracle in the construction business is being done by private people, and they need to be commended.

    Mr. Speaker, I will briefly touch on the heritage projects which the President spoke about on page 34 and I quote:

    “The Flagstaff House is being rebuilt to accommodate the next President in dignity. Additionally, Peduase, Akosombo and Akuse which were built in the First Republic as Presidential retreats have all been refurbished. Not for the vanity of the Presidency, these are all national assets that deserve better than the neglect to which they have been consigned in the past. I will appeal to all of us to make sure that we carry out the maintenance culture to be able to keep these assets in good shape for posterity.”

    Mr. Speaker, I have two minutes, so I would wind up.
    Mr. Speaker 12:10 p.m.
    No, you do not have two
    minutes. Your time is up.
    Ms. Dapaah 12:10 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, in fact, His Excellency has succeeded in protecting our heritage which has been won for us through the blood and toil of our fathers. As he stated in his Address, he will leave Ghana better than he found it. [Uproar.] Mr. Speaker, the President, His Excellency, John Agyekum Kufuor has been seen as burning himself like a candle whilst giving light to others.
    Mr. Speaker, thank you for the opportunity to contribute to the motion.
    Dr. Yakubu Ahmed Alhassan (NDC -
    Mion): Mr. Speaker, thank you very much for the opportunity to contribute to the President's State of the Nation Address.
    Mr. Speaker, in doing so, I would like to take the President's own basis for the statement. Because he did say that he was urging Ghanaians not to engage in useless ventures of comparing his Government to others, and that he was rather going to put his Government in perspective in the light of the fact that he was going to leave Ghana in a better shape than he came to meet it.
    It was also significant that the President confessed that he was not going to reinvent the wheel. And everybody expected that from 2001, he was going to oil the wheel so that it can turn much better.
    Mr. Speaker, this will be the basis
    upon which my contribution will be. In doing so, I would like to take a certain portion of the agricultural sector of food crop production in the country from 2001 to date.
    Mr. Speaker, I would say that agriculture under the President's administration
    over the past seven to eight years has rather visited a chequered presence in our economy taking the particular important crop of cotton. The cotton industry as at 1999/2000 was perhaps a struggling industry but I think that today it is a shattered industry that has visited a lot of pain and poverty on the actors. Mr. Speaker, I would like to put this in perspective because that has been the cry from the other side that issues must be put in perspective.
    In the year 1999/2000 crop season, the Ghana Cotton Company which is the largest player in the cotton industry put 26,000 hectares of land to crop and that yielded 26,600 metric tonnes of seed cotton. As many as 50,000 farm families were the beneficiaries, financially and economically. Mr. Speaker, as at 2006, the Ghana Cotton Company has collapsed to the point that in the year 2006/7 only 14,000 hectares of land was put to crop.
    That gave a yield of just about half of the seed cotton yielded in the year 2000. Clearly, this is indicative of an industry that is collapsing under the weight of a very weak agricultural policy so far as cotton is concerned.
    Mr. Speaker, if you look at the run down of the industry against the fact that the scenario as we have today is that of very high input cost for production of anything in this country, and the fact that the Government does even want to hear about subsidy let alone discuss it, the situation gets even more desperate. But why were we told in 2001 that the cotton industry was collapsing under a more terrible regime under the previous government, and it was identified -
    I believe that the first instinct of President Kufuor was to sell the cotton industry to private ownership. That did not happen, or at least, if it happened it was not successful. And they tried to sell
    Mr. Simon Osei-Mensah 12:20 p.m.
    On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I am rising on a point of order. Mr. Speaker, when we are talking about these issues, it will be appropriate that we put them in the right perspective. Mr. Speaker, if you look at any production process, it ends with the final consumer. In this House, several people from the Minority side have raised issues that domestic rice farmers are unable to dispose even the little that he is talking about because there is lack of market. And who caused this? [Uproar] --
    Mr. Speaker, previously, what we knew was that the consumption was on locally produced rice. During their time from1979 up to the time they left power, the influx of imported rice killed the taste for locally produced rice. [Uproar] -- And because of that even the little that he is talking about when it is produced, it is not disposed of. So who should invest in the rice production, increase the production for it to get rotten in the villages?

    So what the Government is doing now is to encourage the consumption of locally produced rice. That is why Government institutions that is schools are being encouraged to use locally produced rice and if the demand is good then production can go higher to meet the level of market that is required.

    Otherwise, whatever amount we pump into rice production will go waste. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
    Mr. Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    Hon. Member for Mion,
    Dr. Alhassan 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. Member for helping me make my point because all that he has succeeded in doing is to explain the circumstances that informed President's policy in 2001 and the President had not succeeded. That is the point I am making. Indeed, the issue of public institutions consuming locally produced rice existed in the 1990s under the very government they succeeded. Why it has failed is up to the present situation to explain.
    Mr. Speaker, if I can go on. These figures that I am quoting are not my figures. They are coming from the Government's own Ghana Statistical Service's External Trade Section. Mr. Speaker, I expected the President to at least acknowledge that there were certain things that he did not succeed in doing and that could help the next President to shape his policies.
    Mr. Speaker, why did all these policies fail? The Government that came in under President Kufuor imposed tariffs on imported rice and the idea was to use the funds from it, if possible, to plough into the generation of the local rice industry. But what happened? The law was not only neglected in implementation but it was brought back to this House to be revised backwards to the point where the levels of tariffs collapsed the industry. Clearly it was going to be an industry that would be buried by failed policies.
    Mr. Speaker, I do not want to touch on the poultry industry otherwise it will be serious:
    “Because the price of poultry products, from 2001 to date, have gone up 500 per cent.”
    Mr. Speaker, I would like to say that if you go further there is a lot of talk about cocoa which has made a lot of progress
    under the present Government with peak production of 700,000 tonnes. But the basic question is, why has this figure not been sustained? Sustainability in our production sector has always been the question. It is not that we cannot increase it. We can increase it but how to sustain such increase is the problem. Since the 740,000 tonnes it has been reducing downwards. The President ought to have explained it.
    Mr. David Oppon-Kusi 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I have been forced to raise this point of order. The hon. Member has been impressing us with figures but when it came to cocoa he said there has been a lot of talk about increase in production. He has the figures. Cocoa production has doubled and these are the figures. People are listening. Please he should not say there is a lot of talk. It is not talk, it is facts. There is no talk about cocoa production. It is a fact that cocoa production has doubled. It is a fact. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
    Dr. Alhassan 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I guess my
    Mr. J. H. Mensah 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I
    Mr. Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    Order! Order!
    Mr. J. H. Mensah 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, this
    is a piece of scientific information that my hon. Friend knows very well. Therefore

    when he is talking he should bear in mind his scientific training. If he would be true to his scientific training, he would not say the things that he is saying.

    Mr. Speaker, again after that you measure the stable production platform of the mature cocoa crop. Please, I entreat the hon. Member to be true to his scientific training.
    Dr. Alhassan 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am very grateful to the hon. emeritus Member who is a senior citizen of this House. I will be the last person he will give a lesson in the agronomy of cocoa. But suffice it to mention that the yield of a cocoa plant after first generation is supposed to be high. But it levels off before it starts going down. In the particular case of cocoa, that will be after ten years -- [Interruption] -- Mr. Speaker, if I may go on.
    Mr. Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    You do not have much
    time.
    Dr. Alhassan 12:20 p.m.
    Just a few more points.
    Mr. Speaker, the drive of the current Government under President J. A. Kufuor was to encourage commercial farming. In their view the small scale farming was not really a state of the art and therefore there was the need to encourage commercial farming. Mr. Speaker, even there, not much success had been registered. But the ratio of commercial farmers to rural farmers in 2000 - 2001 is 2.5 per cent.
    Today, it is only 3 per cent, one per cent rise in 7 years. [Interruptions.] That rise in commercial farming is not with respect to food crops: It is with respect to export crops -- mango, cashew, et cetera. -- that is what has contributed the 1 per cent but in terms of food crops it has remained so, it has even worsened.
    Mr. Speaker, agricultural credit remains
    a big challenge for this country and in fact the agricultural development bank has been the one sustaining agricultural credit. This is a subject hon. J. H. Mensah will be very interested in. It is the bank that has tried to sustain agricultural credit for farmers in this country.
    Mr. J. H. Mensah 12:20 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am
    only interrupting my hon. Friend again because I stood on the floor of this House and had inserted into the record of our proceedings the fact that lending by the ADB to agriculture had diminished from the period 2001 to 2006. He ought to have heard. And on the contrary, lending from ADB to commerce had increased by five hundred billion cedis and I had those figures inserted into the parliamentary record deliberately because we make statements like this -- that this is a bank which is sustaining agriculture -- the facts are there for the hon. Member to read and the facts come from the Banking Survey,
    2007.
    So the hon. Member should inform himself.
    Mr. Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    Hon. Member for Mion,
    your time is up, so please, conclude.
    Dr. Alhassan 12:30 p.m.
    I will conclude in two minutes. Mr. Speaker, the heckling was just too much; so I thought that I could be given more time.
    Mr. Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    You have had fifteen minutes including heckling, you must
    Dr. Alhassan 12:30 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am about
    to conclude but I just want to illustrate the point.
    Mr. Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Hon. Whip, how many minutes did you permit Ranking Members?
    Ms. Akua Dansua 12:30 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I thought you gave twenty minutes but in this particular case, the heckling and the interruptions were too much.
    Mr. Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Please, correct yourself, how much time for Ranking Members?
    Ms. Dansua 12:30 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I understand it is ten minutes but in this particular case, because he was heckled so many times, I think that he should be given some few minutes to wind up.
    Mr. Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Please, resume your seat. Hon. Member for Mion?
    Dr. Alhassan 12:30 p.m.
    Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The point I wanted to illustrate is that the people who are advising us to sell our banks that are succeeding in a very competitive financial environment are themselves nationalizing private banks in their countries. For example, Northern Rock in the United Kingdom (UK). Mr. Speaker, the Senior Minister should take that on board.
    Mr. Speaker, I will not say anything about the shea-nut industry because President Kufuor has not made a single move to put smiles on pickers of shea-nuts or those who process them.
    Mr. Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Are you concluding?
    Dr. Alhassan 12:30 p.m.
    Yes, Mr. Speaker, I am concluding, Mr. Speaker. There were certain issues that I believe that the
    President ignored though they were of such paramount importance that he should have told us something about those things.
    Mr. Speaker, recently, the Government of Ghana appended its signature to an interim economic partnership agreement that was of concern to many farmers and agricultural actors in this country. The President ought to have said something, explain why we appended our signature to the interim agreement.
    Mr. Speaker, there was a lot of pomp and pageantry about the Pwalugu Tomato Factory. The factory is standing there, farmers have tomatoes and they cannot send them to the factory because there is no electricity going to the factory. The Ministry of Food and Agriculture and the Ministry of Trade, Industry, Private Sector Development and PSI and Volta River Authority are confused as to which body should send electricity to Pwalugu Tomato Factory yet so much noise was made about it.
    Mr. Speaker, lastly, the Educational Reform is a legacy the President is going to leave behind as he bows out, come January, 2009 and His Excellency Prof. Mills takes over. Mr. Speaker, in an answer to a question in this House, the Minister for Education, Science and Sports confessed that there were no textbooks to run that reform. Somebody was saying the junior secondary school pupils were coming out unemployed, et cetera.
    At least they had some books to read, but these ones do not have any books to read and I do not know what they would be like - trained illiterates in secondary school.
    Mr. Speaker, the environmental cost to all our economic policies have increased in the last eight years from five per cent to six per cent. It is not a surprise that the Ministry of Environment, Science and
    Technology that existed for decades was “killed” without any explanation under President Kufuor. I thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
    Deputy Minister for Foreign Affairs, Regional Integration and NEPAD (Ms. Shirley A. Botchway): Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for giving me the opportunity to join my Colleagues in thanking His Excellency the President for his very comprehensive presentation to the House.
    Mr. Speaker, I believe it is in order that we say a big thank you to His Excellency the President for his good stewardship over the past seven years. It was such a joy to listen to this very humble man who ended up being very modest about his achievements. Mr. Speaker, a lot has been said by way of contributions and so I will try not to be repetitive.
    The New Patriotic Party (NPP) Government has over the past seven years taken bold and pragmatic steps to significantly take us from the economic landscape of this country to one of hopefulness. It is quite clear, Mr. Speaker, that we are on our way to achieving middle income status within the next decade.
    His Excellency has focused on some major pillars of progress which are good governance, micro-economic stability, a robust programme of infrastructural deve lopment and pr iva te sec tor development. These are all aimed, Mr. Speaker, at preparing the grounds for launching us into a growth phase, the phase of industrialization as he said and this will all be led by the private sector.
    I will touch on one area and that is the private sector development. Government can boast, Mr. Speaker, of the President's Special Initiatives in agribusiness which is starch and oil

    production, garments and textiles and also salt. Mr. Speaker, Government is supporting participating communities as well as investors by providing technical assistance, development of infrastructure and facilitation to access finance. The private sector is providing local and foreign investment partnerships, commercial financing and entrepreneurial leadership and management.

    The Government has constructed new purpose-built factory units which have been leased to the garment companies. Also, training centres have been built in Accra and Kumasi and over 7,000 sewing operators have been trained. High calibre management and supervisory personnel have been recruited to develop and manage the very efficient production systems that have been put in place. So far, over 3,200 jobs have been created through fifteen new companies which have been established.

    Orders have been secured for participating companies from major international buyers. Under the revitalized industries which were once distressed, we have the revitalized Pwalugu Factory which is now called Northern Star and Juapong Textiles which is now called Volta Star. Pwalugu, Mr. Speaker, now has a state of the art tomato processing plant with a capacity of 100 tonnes daily. It will start production very soon. Juapong is also producing gray baft. Over 500 people also have been employed in Juapong which is now Volta Star.

    Mr. Speaker, for lack of time I will not touch on the district industrialization p rog ramme which suppor t s t he establishment of at least one flagship commercially viable industry in all our 138 districts. This is in partnership with communities, the private sector and District Assemblies. Yes, I am sure. Business plans have been finished and
    rose
    Mr. Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Hon. Member for North Tongu, do you have a point of order?
    Mr. Hodogbey 12:30 p.m.
    Honestly, yes. Mr. Speaker, I would not have commented on the statement if the hon. Member of Parliament had not touched on the Juapong Textiles and Pwalugu Factory which they normally claim as the best district industrialization programmes. I represent the people of Juapong. Juapong is my district capital. I just want to let the House know that by trying to use Juapong Textiles as an example of industrialization, they are deceiving this nation.
    Since more than a year ago, when the President revitalized Juapong Textiles, the factory is not functioning as a factory. It is only a handful of people who are there maintaining the machinery. For her to say they have employed over 500 people is not true. I just do not want to say she is deceiving the House but it is not true that Juapong has absorbed 500 people. The people there now are less than even 100 and they are just maintaining the machinery.
    Ms. Botchway 12:40 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I will also leave out the industrial estates which are the multi-purpose industrial parts in the Free Zones enclaves that we have also built. Five factory units are in operation at the moment including a furniture city and an ICT park and it has the potential of employing over six thousand people in all the production units.
    There is also a garment enclave in Accra-Adjabeng - which hosts four
    factories and these are operational. Additional three factories are under construction.
    I will stop here, but is no wonder that the President stated that the next phase of our development should take us into industrialization. It is quite clear that we are heading in that direction. Our sound micro-economic policies have ushered in that Golden Age of Business which would result in a lot of job creation. I wish to join my hon. Colleagues in thanking and congratulating His Excellency the President and I thank you, Mr. Speaker, for this opportunity.
    Mr. Inusah Fuseini (NDC - Tamale Central) 12:40 p.m.
    Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for this opportunity to contribute to the Statement made in this House by the President when he delivered his State of the Nation Address on the 14th day of February, 2008. Mr. Speaker, I will not want to delve much into the Address as I consider it to lack so much in material detail in what the President ought to have reported to this House when he appeared on the 14th day of February 2008.
    Suffice it to say that the President did make a very important statement when he said on page two that his abiding principle has always been to leave the place better than when he found it. In this respect, I think that the President was saying that to him he has left Ghana better than he found it.
    Mr. Speaker, nothing can be far from the truth - and I refer to a statement that was made by Macbeth that:
    “life is like a story told by an idiot full of sound and furies signifying nothing”.
    This Address is a neatly written statement of achievements that are said to have been chalked by the President signifying absolutely nothing. This is
    Mr. Ofori Boafo 12:40 p.m.
    On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, the hon. Member in his prelude to the statement he is presenting to the House was alluding to part of Macbeth, making reference to things done by idiots and people of low credibility and he is referring to the State of the Nation Address by the President. I view his analogy as improper by comparing our esteemed President to idiotic characters referred to in Macbeth. He therefore should withdraw it. It is disrespect for the high office of the President in this country.
    Mr. Fuseini 12:40 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I hold the President of this Republic in high esteem and my senior Colleague knows that I respect Mr. Kufuor as the President of this country. So do I respect anybody who is ambitious to want to be the President of this country. I will not consider the President an idiot at all. What I said was that Shakespeare writing in Macbeth said that life is like a story told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. That was what I said. It is a quotation. I did not say that the President's statement had been made by an idiot and it is full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. I did not say that.
    Mr. Speaker, I will confine my contribution to page 9 of the State of the Nation Address where the President said, and Mr. Speaker, with your permission, I quote:
    “Other initiatives which have been implemented include the Capitation Grant, the School Feeding Pro- gramme and improved student' loan schemes, all of which have contributed to increase intake of pupils and students.”
    Mr. Speaker, on account to Ghana's School Feeding Programme, I was invited to address the Council of the World Food Programme in Rome just about a week ago. Together with a group of pupils from Ghana, I told the Ghana story, So, Mr. Speaker, Ghana's School Feeding Programme has become a model for other developing nations around the world.
    Mr. Ofori Boafo 12:40 p.m.
    On a point of order. Mr. Speaker, I had earlier on raised a point of order but the answer or explanation given by the hon. Member to my mind, with the greatest respect, was not satisfactory. The question is, why that analogy? Why that analogy of idiots and so forth in relation to the State of the Nation Address made by the President?
    That the State of the Nation Address signified nothing, it is empty, it is something which is not credible and which is not worthy to have been presented to this House?
    This is the interpretation that any reasonable person would put on the reference he is making. I wish therefore that he withdraws this particular statement coming from him as an hon. Member and also as a person belonging to a noble profession.
    Mr. Speaker 12:40 p.m.
    Hon. Member for Tamale Central, please, take it on board and respond.
    Mr. Fuseini 12:40 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am most grateful. Mr. Speaker, I do not think that we can behave like Humpty Dumpty and interprete statements as we find them. This is not my statement, it is the statement of Shakespeare and I just quoted it for relevance. What I was saying was that - [Interruption.]
    Mr. Speaker 12:40 p.m.
    What are you saying?
    Mr. Fuseini 12:40 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am just saying that this has not been my statement, it is not my statement; I am
    rose
    Mr. Speaker 12:40 p.m.
    The hon. Member has withdrawn what he said. I thought he had withdrawn it, did he not? To make progress, please -
    Mr. Fuseini 12:40 p.m.
    Well, Mr. Speaker, I have withdrawn any attachment to what I have said to President Kufuor. If that statement seeks to create an impression in the minds of hon. Members in this House and Ghana at large that President Kufuor is an idiot, I have withdrawn it, that was not my intention and I will never associate him with such a statement.
    What I am asking is, what is the Ghana story? What is the Ghana story under the School Feeding Programme, that President Kufuor says has won the admiration of the world?
    Mr. Speaker, I am referring this House to a report that had been conducted under the Ghana School Feeding Programme by PriceWaterHouse and Coopers to buttress this point. At page 71 of the report, and with your permission let me read it to this House what has been found out by this noble and creditable institution on the operation of the Ghana School Feeding Programme.
    Mr. Speaker 12:40 p.m.
    Page?
    Mr. Fuseini 12:40 p.m.
    Page 71.
    Mr. Speaker 12:40 p.m.
    Year of the report, please.
    Mr. Fuseini 12:40 p.m.
    The year of the report is the year ending 31st December, 2006.
    Mr. Speaker, it says and with your permission, I quote 12:50 p.m.
    “In July 2006, there were reported cases of unwholesome tomato paste supplied by Afrik Link in Brong Ahafo, Central, Northern, Upper West, Upper East and the Greater- Accra Regions. There were also complaints of expired products supplied to affected schools. This suspicion arose when it came to light that the cans used for packaging had been painted over to conceal the label of the company from which they were purchased.”
    Mr. K. K. Mensah 12:50 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I crave your indulgence here. The hon. Member is reading from a report which the public is not aware - [Interruption] - Is it in the public domain? If it is not, Mr. Speaker, I am afraid we would not entertain this report because it is supposed to have been issued under confidentiality and not be read in an open house like this House.
    Mr. Speaker 12:50 p.m.
    Hon. Member for Tamale Central, you may wish to show the report to the House just by holding it up.
    Mr. Fuseini 12:50 p.m.
    [Hon. Member holds the report up] - Mr. Speaker, this is the report prepared on the 29th day of November 2007 and sent to the Deputy Minister, Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Environment, P.O. Box M50, Accra; Attention: Hon. Maxwell Kofi Juma, MP.
    Mr. J. H. Mensah 12:50 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, while I have no reason to doubt that the hon. Member possesses such a document, I think in the interest of fair debate it is not appropriate when a big programme like the Ghana School Feeding Programme is being managed and a fault is found somewhere in the system to attribute any wrong doing to the President of the Republic just because he said the School Feeding Programme is a model - [Interruption.]
    Mr. Speaker, we must take these things in fair proportion. So if somebody investigates a programme which is running to feed so many hundreds of thousands of children and he points out a fault in the management of the programme, and impugn the President's performance on the grounds that there was some fault in such a programme, is neither fair nor even appropriate for a House like this.
    Mr. Speaker, I entreat my hon. Friend that if he has some evidence from that report that President Kufuor did something that shows incompetence or irresponsibility or non-accountability or corruption, he should bring it to the notice of the House. But that some out of the date tomatoes were supplied to some children is a fault that must be corrected but is not a matter that should be brought to the House to impugn the performance of the President.
    Mr. Speaker 12:50 p.m.
    Hon. Member for Tamale Central, I hope you would make
    photocopies available, will you not?
    Mr. Fuseini 12:50 p.m.
    Very well Mr. Speaker, I would make photocopies available to the House. Mr. Speaker, I am not faulting President Kufuor for initiating the project. I am talking about the Ghana story and the Ghana story is that in July 2006, Ghanaian children were fed with unwholesome products, that is the Ghana story. I am saying that the Ghana story is that 540,888 pupils are those benefiting under the Ghana School Feeding Programme. I am saying that the Ghana story is that 975 schools in the whole country are benefiting from this programme.
    I am saying that the Ghana story is that 23 per cent of schools in poor areas are benefiting from the programme when the programme has been instituted with three core objectives - to reduce poverty and malnutrition, to boost school enrolment, retention and maintenance and to encourage and boost production of local foods crops.
    Dr. (Mrs.) G. N. Ashitey 12:50 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I believe the hon. Member is misleading this House because the year in question, the programme I know was still at pilot stage and definitely people would have taken advantage of the programme. I believe the programme has been monitored and everything is now in good shape and so I feel the hon. Member should tell the right story. At the time in question, it was at the pilot stage and people, as we all know, would have liked to take advantage of this situation to dupe or use unwholesome products.
    So I feel the hon. Member is still misleading this House. Let us tell the right story. The success story is that the children who are benefiting are growing up and they have good skins, they no more have rashes and many of them are growing and they are taking their right heights.
    Mr. Fuseini 12:50 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I am telling
    Mr. Fuseini 12:50 p.m.


    the Ghana story and I believe that the hon. Member has contributed to telling the Ghana story. The Ghana story is that last year, students in Madina, Accra and some areas in Tema had diarrhoea by virtue of the food that they were served under the School Feeding Programme; that is the Ghana story. I am obliged by any consideration to tell a success story of the Ghana School Feeding Programme. I am telling the Ghana story as I see it.

    I am saying that the programme is supposed to be extended equally in all regions and districts in Ghana but by virtue of this, only two districts are supposed to benefit from this programme across the country.

    Mr. Speaker, I am saying that the Ghana story again is that some districts in this country have more schools under the programme than others. I am saying that there are some districts in this country which are not yet benefiting from the programme. Mr. Speaker, I am saying that the Ghana story is that between January and April 2007 an amount of ¢25 billion was released to the Ghana School Feeding Programme for the purposes of carrying out specified activities under the programme.
    Mr. Speaker 12:50 p.m.
    Are you concluding, hon. Member?
    Mr. Fuseini 12:50 p.m.
    I am about concluding, Mr. Speaker.
    rose
    Mr. Speaker 12:50 p.m.
    Hon. Member for
    Ofoase/Ayirebi, do you have a point of order?
    Mr. Oppon-Kusi 12:50 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I had
    this point of order for a very long time, when he started telling his Ghana story. Mr. Speaker, we are all Ghanaians and what happened in Brong Ahafo Region did not happen in my district and I am sure it did not happen in many other districts. That might be his story - [Interruption] - he may say a story - [Interruption.]
    rose
    Mr. Speaker 12:50 p.m.
    Hon. Member for Sege, it is only when you are called upon that you can make a point.
    Mr. Oppon-Kusi 1 p.m.
    He may have his story, but this is not the Ghana story. The School Feeding Programme is operating in my district and we have not received unlabelled tomatoes or tomatoes that are unwholesome. If it happened in his constituency he should let us know.

    Mr. Speaker, the Ghana story is that today, 2008, a lot of Ghanaian children are receiving free food including those in his own district and the children are better off for it. Mr. Speaker, if people selectively pick on two incidents and make them appear as if they are a reflection of what is happening, then they are not being truthful to the whole nation. How many of these programmes are running? How many of these incidents happened? When did it happen and what corrective measures have been taken? He is telling a story and he should tell the whole story.
    Mr. Fuseini 1 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, the whole
    story is that out of this amount of ¢25 billion that was released to the Ghana School Feeding Programme an amount of ¢2 billion Cedis was used to make signboards and directional signs to the Ghana School Feeding Programme. This amount, ¢25 billion was to be used to feed students. Little wonder therefore that when the meals were supplied to the
    schools, the students had diarrhoea. That is the whole story.
    Mr. Speaker, just last Friday in the
    Chronicle, it was reported, Mr. Speaker, if hon. Members care to know, the Ghana School Feeding Programme even though laudable an initiative under Pillar III of the New Partnership for Africa Development (NEPAD) is facing very, very serious problems that if the President of the Republic had dared to investigate these problems before embarking on the trip to Rome, the Ghana story would have been different from the way President Kufuor perceived it.
    Mr. Speaker, the Ghana story in Italy would not have been captured in the demonstration by the school children who were made to sing to the praises of the Europeans that it was by virtue of their money that they are not suffering stunted growth.
    Mr. Speaker 1 p.m.
    Hon. Members, let us
    turn to Order Paper Addendum II.
    PAPERS 1 p.m.

    Mr. Speaker 1 p.m.
    Leadership, at this stage --
    Mrs. Kusi 1 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, I beg to
    move, that this House do now adjourn till tomorrow at 10.00 a.m.
    Ms. Akua Sena Dansua 1 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker,
    my attention has been drawn to the first Addendum to today's business, the motion for the adoption of the Report of the Committee on Subsidiary Legislation.
    Mr. Speaker 1 p.m.
    Unfortunately, I do not
    see the hon. Minister who was contri- buting. I adjourned this matter for him to complete his contribution to enable the Chairman to wind up but I do not see him around.
    Ms. Dansua 1 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker, so are we deferring that to tomorrow?
    Mr. Speaker 1 p.m.
    All right.
    Ms. Akua Sena Dansua 1 p.m.
    Mr. Speaker,
    on that note, I second the motion for adjournment.
    Question put and motion agreed to.
    ADJOURNMENT 1 p.m.

  • The House was accordingly adjourned at 1.08 p.m till 27th February, 2008 at 10.00 a.m.