Debates of 1 Feb 2022

MR FIRST DEPUTY SPEAKER
ABSENCE OF MR SPEAKER 11:58 a.m.

PRAYERS 11:58 a.m.

Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Hon
Members, we shall commence with
the correction of Votes and
Proceedings of Friday, 28th January,
2022.
Page 1 …8
Mr Emmanuel Kwasi Bedzrah 11:58 a.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you. Page 8, item
numbered 9, Hon Augustine Tawiah
has been marked absent though he
was here on Friday.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Very
well.
The Table Office would take note
and make the appropriate
corrections.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Page
9 -
Mr Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa 11:58 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I am most grateful. Item
numbered 7 on page 9 should read:
“General Constance Ama Emefa Edjeani-Afenu, first female com-
manding officer of the Ghana Armed
Forces, first female deputy military
adviser of the permanent mission in
New York” and not “in the New York”.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Very
well.
Table Office would take note.
Page 10 …12
Mr Osei Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 11:58 a.m.
Mr Speaker, sorry for taking us back.
I am just wondering which Votes and
Proceedings we are dealing with. Is
it Friday's?
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Hon
Majority Leader, yes. It is Friday,
28th January, 2022.
Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 11:58 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, it appears I have been
served the wrong Votes and
Proceedings and so I was a bit taken
aback.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Very
well.
Still on page 11 - Yes, Hon Member?
Mr Kofi Iddie Adams 11:58 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, if I could take us back to
page 10, the name captured there is
Alban Kingsford Sumana Bagbin as
the Speaker. However, I remember
that on Friday, you took the Chair
throughout the Sitting and I do not
know whether that is appropriate?
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Hon
Member, the Table Office will make
the correction. It begins with; ‘The House met at eight minutes after 5
o'clock and the Hon First Deputy Speaker took the Chair'. So, it may be an error and they would correct it.
Page 12.
Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 11:58 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, sorry for taking us back to
page 8. These three Hon Members;
Patrick Banor, Alfred Obeng-
Boateng and Kofi Okyere Agyekum
were here.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
Hon
Member, sorry, what paragraph were
you referring to?
Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 11:58 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, I was referring to Hon
Members who have been captured as
absent on page 8, item numbered 3
though they were present.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
I do
not see Hon Patrick Boamah on the
list of Hon Members who were
absent.
Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 11:58 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, it is captured at item
numbered 2.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:58 a.m.
It is
Hon Patrick Banor, but I heard ‘Hon Patrick Boamah'.
Very well.
Table Office will take note and
effect the appropriate corrections.
Hon Members, the Votes and
Proceedings of Friday, 28th January,
2022 as presented and corrected is
hereby adopted as the true record of
proceedings.
Yes, Hon Minority Leader?
Mr Haruna Iddrisu 12:08 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, before you go further to the

Order of Business, may I invoke

Standing Order 53 and in particular,

Standing Order 160. I raised this

issue so that the Leader of

Government Business would provide

clarity and certainty to an important

matter of public interest and for the

purpose of the Ghanaian economy

and fiscal consolidation.

Mr Speaker, Standing Order 160

provides that:

“(1) There shall be a Business Committee consisting of

twenty Members, and

composed of the Majority

Leader as Chairman, the

Chief Whips of the

parliamentary parties and

other Members.

(2) It shall be the function

of the Committee

subject to Order 53

(Order of Business) to

determine the business

of each Sitting and the

order in which it shall be

taken; …”

Mr Speaker, last Friday, there was

effort to introduce the E-Levy Bill,

2021 at the Second Reading stage for

us to debate its principles. Earlier on

when we adopted the Business

Statement for the previous week, we

were told that the E-Levy Bill, 2021

would have to been introduced

tomorrow. However, we were getting

it introduced on Friday but as I watch

the Order of Business for today,

pursuant to Order 53, I do not see

anything relating to the E-Levy Bill,

2021.

Mr Speaker, there can be no

surprises on this important matter so

I would want the Hon Leader of

Government Business to lead us

through to know if it would be

reintroduced, if it would be a new

Bill, if the Bill is gazetted according

to article 106 or we would have to

suspend our Standing Orders to take

the Bill under a certificate of

urgency?

Mr Speaker, Hon Members need

to know this because as we have said

publicly, we would want to stand

with the public in our position and

rejection of the Bill. We do not want

to be taken by surprise; so, the Hon

Leader of Government Business

should indicate to us when the Bill

would be brought to Parliament and

in what form we should anticipate or

expect it.

Mr Speaker, we cannot continue

with this uncertainty of its

introduction; when would the

principles of the E-Levy Bill, 2021

be subjected to a thorough debate

before it passes through both the

Consideration and the Third Reading

stages, and its rejection because we

have decided?

Mr Speaker, I thought to raise this

matter so that the Hon Chairman of

the Business Committee would do

what is appropriate within our

Standing Orders and carry us along

as it is required of us under Standing

Order 160 and article 106 of the 1992

Constitution.

Mr Speaker, thank you.

Majority Leader (Mr Osei

Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu): Mr Speaker,

thank you very much.

Mr Speaker, as the House may

recollect, when I presented the

Business Statement for this week,

indeed, for last week, there was no

indication that the E-Levy Bill, 2021

would be taken. That is true. Mr

Speaker, but subsequent to that, there

were some engagements between the

Leadership of the two caucuses, and

it was determined that the E-Levy

Bill, 2021 may be introduced in the

House last week Friday.

Mr Speaker, at the Speaker's conclave, we had this discussion

further and so it was not a matter of

surprise. When I came to present the

Business Statement for this week, I

said that if we are able to conclude

the discussions on the way forward

for the E-Levy Bill, 2021, then it

would be introduced in the House on

Friday. If we could not finish, then it

would be introduced this week.

However, the course of the

discussion facilitated the

introducetion in the House on Friday

and, as we all witnessed, we could

not make much progress and that is

why I said that if it could not, then it

may be done this week.

Mr Speaker, even before walking

into the Chamber, the Hon Minority

Leader who is the Hon Ranking

Member of the Business Committee,

asked about its status and I told him

that we would come to some

determination even though it has

been advertised for tomorrow.

If we look at the Provisional

Order Paper for tomorrow, we would

see that it has been advertised for

tomorrow but even with that, I told

him that we would need to confer on

it because to all intents and purposes,

we may not be able to do it

tomorrow. Mr Speaker, so the Hon

Minority Leader asked whether that

was an assurance and I said to him

that that was a double assurance that

it would certainly not be considered

tomorrow, but together we would

determine it. I have already made that

assurance, and so it is not as if

anybody wants to spring any surprise

because it would have to be decided

on and I would signal him for us to

agree on a common date.

Mr Speaker, the Hon Minority

Leader is adding that they have taken

a position and that they would want

to stand with the public to reject the

E-Levy Bill, 2021 and he said this

with all emphasis. Mr Speaker, we on

this Side want to stand with the

Republic to ensure the revitalisation

of the economy. [Hear! Hear!] If

people want to see the collapse of the

economy then so be it for them; but

we would want to stand with the

Republic.

Mr Speaker, I thank you very

much.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:08 p.m.
Hon
Minority Chief Whip?
Alhaji Mohammed-Mubarak
Muntaka: Mr Speaker, thank you.
Ordinarily, when the Hon Leaders
speak on an issue, then the matter is
supposed to rest, but as we may know
and pursuant to Standing Order 160,
we would need to have clarity and
that is why we always have a
Business Statement. The Hon
Majority Leader is telling us that
even though it has been indicated in
the Business Statement for this week
that tomorrow has been scheduled for
the E-Levy Bill, 2021, it cannot be
done tomorrow and that he would
liaise with the Hon Minority Leader
to get a tentative date. Mr Speaker, as
the Hon Majority Leader may know,
the House works with the Business
Statement so if there is the need for
any variation, then we may not take
it so that we meet again at the
Business Committee to reschedule a
new day, but not a discussion
between the two Hon Leaders. Mr
Speaker, all of us need to know so
that people can plan what they want
to do during the week.
So, I would want to plead with the
Hon Majority Leader that if he is not
sure that it can happen this week then
he should say so. And if he is certain
that it could be this week, then he
should tell us exactly when, so that
we can all prepare adequately since
he is telling us now that it would not
be considered contrary to what has
been programmed on the Business
Statement. However, with his com-
ments about standing with the
Republic, I can assure him that we
are all standing with the Republic.
[Laughter] All of us are standing

with the Republic. Because of the

suffering of the masses who

represent the Republic, we stand

firmly with them in the rejection of

the E-Levy Bill, 2021.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:08 p.m.
Hon
Members, item numbered 5 -— Questions.
Mr Habib Iddrisu 12:08 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
I seek your leave for us to vary the
business on the Order Paper and take
item numbered 6 - Statements.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:08 p.m.
Hon
Minority Leader, there is an
application for us to vary the order of
business and take item numbered 6
before item numbered 5.
Mr Haruna Iddrisu 12:08 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, my understanding and
assurance from the Hon Deputy
Majority Whip is that you may vary
the order of business and take
Statements and when the Hon
Minister is in the House, then we can
return to Questions.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:18 p.m.
Very
well.
Hon Members, item numbered 6
— Statements.
There is a Statement standing in
the name of the Hon Minority Leader
in honour of the late Hon Mumuni
Abudu Seidu, a former Deputy
Majority Leader.

Yes, Hon Minority Leader?
STATEMENTS 12:18 p.m.

Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:28 p.m.
Yes,
Hon Member for Abuakwa South?
Mr Samuel Atta Akyea (NPP - Abuakwa South) 12:38 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
thank you for the opportunity to add
my voice to this well-crafted eulogy
in memory of a senior of this House,
the late Member of Parliament for

Wa Central, in the person of Hon

Mumuni Abudu Seidu.

Mr Speaker, our departed senior

Colleague was well advanced in age;

he was 82 years old when he died.

For us Christians, the endowment

from God is three scores and ten, and

when one crosses 70 years, it is my

respectful view that the person has

the grace of God and it is a bonus.

Mr Speaker, what comes to me as

a very important dimension to this

eulogy is the fact that he was an

educationist; a very long-standing

teacher. If we pay regard to the fact

that he was the headmaster of Wa

Secondary School for nine (9) good

years. A teacher is an invaluable

asset, because his output will always

affect generations. When there is one

good teacher, the students that he

would teach becomes very

important, and the domino effect is

that the students will become

prominent. If they are not wayward,

their children will become prominent

and it goes on. I am not surprised in

the least that this great teacher has

been able to produce a good friend of

mine, His Lordship, Mr Yonny

Kulendi, who is a Supreme Court

Judge. As a matter of fact, the Rt Hon

Speaker, Alban Sumana Kingsford

Bagbin was one of his students. How

sad it would have been if we did have

such a teacher under whose authority

and instruction a lot more people

have seen education.

Mr Speaker, when we talk about

education, it brings me to the Free

Senior High School Policy of our

Government. It is my humble

submission that every child, no

matter the circumstances of his birth,

should have Free Senior High School

(Free SHS) education. I would also

want to further submit that it should

not be political at all. This great

country of ours should subscribe to

the fact that no matter who is in

power, Free SHS should be the pivot

of social transformation and an

arrangement should permit people to

rise up the social ladder, until we

come to the point where majority of

our people are well educated and will

free this nation from the blindness of

ignorance. At the pivot of this

arrangement, it is a teacher whom we

are celebrating.

Mr Speaker, I would also touch

on a very important dimension to this

eulogy, and with your permission, I

beg to quote:

“Mr Speaker, Hon M. A. Seidu served in leadership as

Deputy Majority Leader

where his mature, calm, soft-

spoken and affable persona

made him a stabilising force

for Government Business in

the Second Parliament of the

Fourth Republic, from 1997

to 2001.”

Mr Speaker, that is very

instructive, because any time a

person becomes a Leader, one of the

things which should define that

person should be a stabilising force.

Leadership of acrimony, antagonism,

and sometimes, cantankerous

behaviour, is always very divisive

and does not help the course of

anybody. I am excited that this is the

personality who is being eulogised.

Mr Speaker, finally, I do not

know the circumstances of his

departing, whether after he left

Parliament, his fortunes were good

and he lived a good life. Everybody

who steps into this House, no matter

the circumstances, should that person

leave here, his fortune should not

plummet in the evening of his years.

He should be that kind of individual

that people will go to and take advice

and he should live a comfortable life.

The whole idea of coming to

Parliament is that, we should not be

dishonoured and we should not be

devalued when we exit this House. I

pray to the Almighty Allah that He

gives him a place of rest.

Mr Speaker, thank you for the

opportunity to say a few words to

complement what has been said

about our senior Colleague.

Dr Abdul-Rashid Hassan

Pelpuo (NDC - Wa Central): Mr Speaker, thank you for the

opportunity to contribute to this

Statement eulogising this great man

Hon Mumuni Abudu Seidu, who we

refer to as Hon M. A. Seidu.

Mr Speaker, Hon M. A. Seidu in

his life can only be referred to as one

of the greatest men who ever lived in

the Upper West Region. He served

his people and he served his Lord. I

came into contact with him when he

was the headmaster of the secondary

school I attended, Wa Secondary

School. As a student in that school,

anybody who came into contact with

him recognised that he was not just a

secondary school headmaster, but

also, a father, a guide and an

inspiring soul. When one goes

through the system with him, he or

she would understand that it is not

just about the education, but also

about building a life fully outside the

secondary system.

Mr Speaker, every young person

who went through the school

recognised that that was not a place

to toy with; that was not a place to

ignore and pretend as though one was

not in a system which was under

strict control. He was forthright,

insightful and very determined to

build the students. Aside a

headmaster, I recognised that he was

a father too. In his life as an

educationist, he did not just practice

as a public servant and a headmaster,

but also established a school. That

school became the first private

school in Wa that churned out lots of

people, which include lawyers,

doctors and many others. That school

is recognised throughout the Upper

West Region. Today, the school

stands out as one of the best private

schools in the Upper West Region.

Mr Speaker, because of him, Wa

Secondary School had one particular

character which we are all very proud

of. He built the school and

sportsmen, and nobody was left to go

unprepared for the kind of job they

wanted to do in future. Many

sportsmen went through his hands,

including Mr Maxwell Konadu a

former coach of the Black Stars, and

Mr Kwesi Nyantakyi, former

president of Ghana Football Associa-

tion. We all benefited from him. We

were part of his system, playing

various sports in the school.

Mr Speaker, he developed Wa

Secondary School to the point that

we became the best sporting school

in the Upper West Region. We

ventured into the rest of the northern

part of the country and I recalled how

we beat both the Navrongo

Secondary School and the Tamale

Secondary School (TAMASCO) in

football to the surprise of the

students. This is because Wa

Secondary School was virtually a

very small school. However, because

of sports and his own interest and

push, we became known throughout

the north as a great secondary school.

Mr Speaker, this man was great,

and we cannot, but recognise the fact

that being who he was made us who

we are today. I recalled in my earlier

years in 1996, I was a young graduate

and was being pushed by the youth of

Wa Central to contest him. It became

so serious that the elders met and

informed me that he was not the man

I should contest, so, I should let him

go. I went to him privately to tell him

that I would never contest him, but it

would not be possible for me to turn

round and tell the young people that

it was not possible for me to contest,

but he should be rest assured that I

would not contest him. He told me

that he knew that.

Mr Speaker, again in 2000, I was

called upon by the same young

people who pushed very hard for me

to contest him. I went to see him in

private and told him that I respected

him too much as my headmaster, and

that the noise being made outside

would definitely not compel me to

contest him. I told him to allow those

advocating for me do what they

wanted. Maybe, it was for the future

and not then. He once again

understood me.

Mr Speaker, he was a man I

respected so much; we all adored

him; he was a mentor to all of us he

guided us in everything we did; and

he was a source of inspiration and

deliverance to us in our educational

enterprise. Many of the people who

we regard today, including the Rt

Hon Speaker, were his students and

were directly influenced by him.

Mr Speaker, I recall once again

that in the course of the revolution in

1982, the military came to our school

and lots of lies were told about him.

He was manhandled and then,

subsequently, the military men called

the leadership of the secondary

school to a meeting, and we were all

asked to say something about the

headmaster. The lies that were told

about him were just unacceptable.

In the midst of all the students, I

got up and said that so many of the

lies about him were unacceptable,

and that I believed the headmaster

was good. He was the only

headmaster who could kill a cow for

the students so, if people said the

students were going hungry and were

not being taken care of, it was not

possible for me to sit there and agree

to it.

Mr Speaker, I was treated like a

traitor amongst my students, but I

saved him from the trouble. After

that, the soldiers interviewed me. I

gave every detail about him, and he

was released from the trouble that he

went through. This was how I

devoted myself into recognising his

essence whilst I was a young man.

Mr Speaker, may his soul rest in

perfect peace, and may the Almighty

Allah forgive him for every sin that

he may have committed on this earth.

Once again, I send my deep

condolences to the family and his

children who have suffered the

greater of the loss.
rose
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:08 p.m.
Is
any of you a Member for Wa East or
Wa West? I will give the floor to an
Hon Member for one of the Wa
constituencies before I come to the
rest.
Mr Peter Lanchene Toobu
(NDC - Wa West): Mr Speaker, I thank you very much for the
opportunity to join Hon Colleagues
in eulogising a distinctive man who
has departed from this world.
Though he is gone, he remains in our
hearts and minds.
Mr Speaker, the late Hon M. A.
Seidu, affectionately called “M. A.”, was a man of few words. He left the
youth of the Upper West Region with
some three core values which I

would want to recount. The late Hon

M. A. Seidu believed in three core

values. The first one is respect for

diversity. He advocated for respect

for diversity in the sense that he was

a Muslim and died a Muslim.

In the Muslim fraternity, there are

a lot of differences. He believed in

diversity so much that he saw no

differences between his sect and the

orthodox Muslims. He even saw no

differences between himself and

Christians. Both Christians and the

orthodox Muslims were in love with

him. This was a man who believed

that respect for diversity was the way

to go.

Again, the Hon M. A. Seidu

believed that every human being

must be selfless. In that selfless

spirit, in 2004, when the Wa West

Constituency was carved out of the

Wa Central Constituency, everybody

in Wa West Constituency wanted

him to come back as the Hon MP

who would nurture that new

constituency. However, as selfless as

Hon M. A. Seidu was, he said he

would rather give way for fresh

blood. He stepped down and allowed

a new MP to take over the new

constituency and drive it forward.

That was how selfless he was. At the

time that he was loved most and was

needed to stay in the political realm,

he bowed out with grace.

Mr Speaker, he believed so much

in thae fact that human beings must

have integrity. The late former Hon

M. A. Seidu, as we said, was a man

of few words. He walked the talk.

Whatever he said was what he did.

He believed that education was the

tool for development. He did not just

demonstrate it when he was a

headmaster, or a teacher; he

demonstrated it when he was even a

politician by establishing the first

private school in Wa, Dan-ibu

International School. The school has

produced a lot of scholars. As I speak

the late Hon M. A. Seidu is honoured

by many people who believed that it

was through him that they saw the

light.

Mr Speaker, the late M. A. as we

affectionately called him was not just

a politician and a father, but he was a

traditional person who believed that

wherever he stood, Ghana should be

a better place because he had

children who were coming up. He

believed that if Ghana were a better

place, his children would be

beneficiaries.

Mr Speaker, he lived life to its

fullest, and died at an advanced age

of 82. I believe that he died very

happy in his heart because I joined

former President John Dramani

Mahama and paid him a visit at his

own residence in Wa. On that day,

one could see the excitement on his

face. He came out to chat with us, we

accompanied former President

Mahama to his vehicle and he

departed. I then took him back to his

house.

Mr Speaker, in less than a week,

we heard of his passing. I wish him

check to frefect the pharase in Hon

Haruna Iddrisu's statement. Jannah tul firdaus. May the good Lord

accept him wholeheartedly, forgive

him all his sins, and give him a

resting place because we know that

one day, we shall meet again. I would

want to convey once again my

deepest condolences to the family,

many of whom are my friends; his

daughters are my friends.

Mr Speaker, in conclusion, I

would want to repeat the respect for

diversity aspect of his core values

that he believed in so much. Even in

that diversity, one of his daughters

got married to somebody outside the

Region. Fortunately for us, he is the

Hon MP for North Tongu. The Hon

Member for North Tongu is a son-in-

law of the late Hon M. A. Seidu. That

is how diversified he was.

Mr Speaker, with these few

words, may his soul rest in perfect

peace.

Mr Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa

(NDC - North Tongu): Mr Speaker,

I am most grateful for the

opportunity to contribute to this

eulogy which has been very

eloquently delivered by the Hon

Minority Leader, the venerable

Haruna Iddrisu.

Mr Speaker, as a son-in-law, it is

both an honour and a lot of difficulty

to eulogise a father, a mentor and a

big brother who was ever so kind,

very warm and always embracing.

He always had a listening ear and

never raised his voice all the years

that I knew him. He was modest, and

down to earth, and he carried no airs

at all.

He was a man of the people in the

true sense of the word, always

welcoming of other views. He was a

very good listener. He would listen to

you, and even if he had contrary

opinions, he would share them after

he had listened to you.

Mr Speaker, he was a very fine

gentleman; refined and sweet soul.

These are some of the people we

wish would never die. He epitomised

maturity and states-manship. At all

times, he would ask you to pursue

what was in the national interest.

I was privileged to know him

very closely. He shared a lot of

history with me, not only because he

studied history and political science

for his first degree, but he had lived

through history. Having been born in

the Gold Coast as far back as 1939 in

the Northern territories, he witnessed

a lot of transitions when the Northern

territories were further split into the

Upper Region, and later, Upper West

and Upper East Regions. He saw the

various military coup d'états, and he himself was a victim of some of the

excesses of those checkered periods

in our history.

He was keen to see this country

transition into a multi-party

democracy, and so, he offered

himself as the first MP for the Wa

Central Constituency in 1992 when

we returned to multi-party

democracy. It is to the credit of

people like him that we continue to

enjoy this Republic, which has

become the most enduring of the four

Republics that we have had as a

country.

Mr Speaker, having served as

Minister of State and Deputy

Majority Leader, the verdict about

his stewardship across the political

divide always makes one to be very

proud to be associated with him, his

legacy and his family. Everybody

speaks fondly of him. Since his

passing, all those who knew him and

have reached out to us, have been

very generous and profess their

remarkable recollections of the man

we celebrate today.

Mr Speaker, if anybody had any

doubt about how a unifier or con-

summate democrat he was, when we

go through his debates in this House,

we would realise that this was

indeed, a true patriot. Mr Speaker, I

hold in my hands the Official Report

of 12th January, 1995.

Contributing to the debate on the

Sessional Address as delivered by H.

E. Jerry John Rawlings, this is what

the Hon M. A. Seidu had to say at

column 69:

“Mr Speaker, this is a hallmark of a great states-

man, to confess to his people

where he feels that he has not

performed satisfactorily. No

part of the Address com-

forted me more than the

conciliatory tone of it. This

time, His Excellency was

appealing for tolerance not

only appealing to the

opposition parties but he

included even the Pro-

gressive Alliance, asking

that all people in the country

should avoid utterances that

are likely to jeopardise the

peace and stability which we

have enjoyed so much. Mr

Speaker, peace and stability

has been with us for so long

that many people take them

for granted. They just think it

is a matter of course that we

are enjoying peace, but I

think this is in the best

direction and it has been

brought about by the

Government as well as the

security agencies.''

Mr Speaker, he continued at

10.55 a. m.:

“The other appeal I would like to draw attention of

fellow Ghanaians to is the

fact that the President

mentioned that important

national issues should not

be politicised - things like education, the economy of

the country the stability of

the country. These, he

thinks, should be devoid of

all political interests

because they concern all of

us. Mr Speaker, permit me

to give you an analogy

from my constituency to

illustrate this point. We

often say that you cannot

turn a mud fish into tilapia,

neither can you turn

herrings into tuna fish. But

when it comes to the

question of refilling a

dried-up river where all the

fishes live, then it must be

the concern of all the

fishes. It is only when there

is water in the river that the

fishes can survive; when

there is water, then they

can agree to disagree. The

herrings can decide to

swim on top of the water,

the mud fish can go under

the water and live in holes

and eat each other there,

while the tuna can be

swimming in the middle.

But when there is no water,

they cannot exercise these

right that they have. I liken

the river to Ghana, the

fishes to the political

parties that we are thinking

of and the development of

the economy to the

development of this nation;

that is the water. When the

whole nation has

developed, then we can

agree to disagree within a

developed nation and

nobody would become

deprived. So I think we

have to take seriously his

call that we should not

politicise things that are in

the interest of this nation as

a whole. I think that this is

wisdom from a really great

leader and statesman”

This was the late Hon M. A.

Seidu. Depth, wisdom, intellect and

maturity, an outstanding politician of

his era.

Mr Speaker, his legacy lives on.

Much has been said about the

institution he established, the Dan-

ibu International School. Having

worked at the Ministry of Education

for four years, I can confirm that

there was no year that that school did

not feature awardees in the

prestigious Head of State Awards.

Every year, one could rest assured

that the Head of State Awards would

have students from the Dan-ibu

International School.

Hon Members who spoke before

me, including my very good friend,

Hon Peter Toobu, who was our

Junior Common Room (JCR)

President when we were in Com-

monwealth Hall, have talked about

some of the products from that

illustrious school.

Mr Speaker, this country is really

blessed to have had Hon M. A. Seidu

pass not only through this House, but

our educational institutions. What I

really admired about him was that as

far back as 1969 when he graduated

from the University of Ghana, he

decided to go back to the Upper West

Region and give back, starting as a

class teacher and rising all the way to

become a headmaster and the first

Upper West Regional Director of the

Ghana Education Service.

How many people would do that

these days: return to their hometowns

right after graduation and not remain

in the capital, looking for bigger jobs

and opportunities and bigger and

fatter pay cheques? He immediately

returned and dedicated all his life

toward the advancement of his home

region. What a shining example for

many young people today to emulate.

I am deeply inspired by the work,

legacy and his commitment to sports-

manship that he exhibited in his

lifetime.

Mr Speaker, as I conclude, I can

only pray that the good Lord would

strengthen his dear wife, Mama

Christie as we call her; my beloved

wife and sweetheart, Nuhela - [Hear! Hear!] - big sister, Shamima

as we call her; the last pampered son,

Holi; Halida and all the others. May

the Almighty grant the beautiful soul

of Hon M. A. Seidu, Jannah-tul

firdaus.

Majority Leader (Mr Osei

Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu): Mr Speaker,

I beg to join ranks with the Hon

Minority Leader in the tribute that he

has rendered in memory of the late

Hon Mumuni Abudu Seidu, affect-

tionately called M. A. Seidu.

Mr Speaker, I met the person

whose memory we are eulogising

today in Parliament in 1997. I just

learnt today that when I met him in

1997, he was 58 years at the time and

I was 39 years. The late M. A. Seidu

was from royal ancestry and carried

himself as such in the House. He was

baptised into politics by his father

who was a member of the colonial

Legislative Council and later, the

Legislative Assembly.

Mr Speaker, he trained as a

teacher, and eventually rose to

become the headmaster of Wa

Secondary School as it was known at

the time. He was a sportsman in his

early days and when he grew up, he

became a keen sports enthusiast. He

is on record as the first person to

establish an international school in

Wa which was at the time, part of the

greater Upper Region.

Mr Speaker, Hon M. A. Seidu,

whose life we celebrate today, was a

three-time MP for Wa which has now

been partitioned into two: Wa

Central and Wa West. His tenure

spanned the period, January 7, 1993

to January 7, 2005. The Hon Member

was noted for his calmness in

Parliament. He was a very well-

composed gentleman and a pleasant

character.

His strong passion in Parliament

was about the introduction of quality

education in Ghana. I remember

when we came to debate the

introduction of the Free Compulsory

Universal Basic Education (FCUBE)

by President Rawlings, he was most

passionate and spoke to the fact that

he wanted to live to see the day when,

as a country, with resources availing

itself to us, we could introduce free

compulsory universal tertiary

education in this country. He was so

concerned about the nation being

able to spread education to all

corners of the country to enable our

youth benefit from this.

Mr Speaker, the quotation by the

Hon Minority Leader is most apt.

That is when the House was debating

the Ghana Education Service on 19th

July, 1995, some of us were not in the

House at the time, but this quotation

has been made. In fact, I think that

when we came to introduce the Free

Senior High School programme, it

was quoted by an Hon Member

whose name I have forgotten. He

quoted Hon M. A. Seidu.

Mr Speaker, it is by a strange

coincidence that the Hon Minority

Leader has quoted the same words

attributable to Hon M. A. Seidu. To

me, the relevant portion is:

“Taking into consideration that the fee-free compulsory

education was introduced in

this country since 1961, as at

now, statistics indicate that

only about 75 per cent of

children in the southern

sector and 30 per cent in

northern sector of school

going age gain admission or

really go to school. So I think

that there is still a lot to be

done to improve education in

this country”.

Mr Speaker, that epitomises the

personality whose memory we

eulogise today. When we first met

him in Parliament in 1997, he was the

Deputy Majority Leader. He served

under Hon J. H. Owusu Acheampong

and subsequently under Hon Dr

Kwabena Adjei who were the

Majority Leaders between 1997 and

2000. He served as their deputies.

Mr Speaker, in the blood and

thunder days of the 31st December,

1981 revolution, Hon M. A. Seidu, in

his earlier life, came under the gavel,

he was bastardised and indeed, torn

to shreds, but eventually, truth

triumphed over lies. That is how

come the system persuaded him to

contest as an MP on the ticket of the

NDC in Wa Central.

Mr Speaker, as a country, a

people and as MPs, we should not

lament when people elect to

bastardise us.

The lessons to learn is to stay

focused and do what we think is

right, and I believe that in the fullness

of time, as it happened to M. A.

Seidu, we shall be resonerated. Prof.

Busia once said that in Africa, if one

wants to be a successful politician,

the person must have a large stomach

to swallow everything; the good and

the bad - what is worthy and what is rubbish. He said to us that we should

stay focused as the Hon M. A. Seidu

did, and in the end, he was rewarded

massively and recognised by a

society as a man of merit.

May his soul rest in perfect peace.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:08 p.m.
Hon
Members, as it is customary, we shall
rise and observe a minute's silence in honour of our fallen Hon Colleague.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:08 p.m.
May
the soul of Hon M. A. Seidu and all
the faithful departed rest in eternal
peace. Amen.
Mr Habib Iddrisu 1:08 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
with your leave, we could go back to
the item numbered 5 - Questions.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:08 p.m.
Item
numbered 5 - Questions to be answered by the Hon Minister for
Health.
Hon Minister, you may take
your seat now.
ORAL ANSWERS TO 1:08 p.m.

QUESTIONS 1:08 p.m.

MINISTRY OF HEALTH 1:08 p.m.

Ms Akanvariba 1:08 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
from the Hon Minister's printed Answer, he says “Currently, zonal consultants and contractors are
finalising mobilisation activities to
site for works to commence shortly
by the end of November, 2021''. Could he tell us the timelines when
the work would actually commence
since November 2021 has passed?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:08 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I am sorry. There were
some typographical errors on the
Order Paper and that little portion
should have been corrected. The
“end of November, 2021'' should not have been printed because it is not
part of the answer to this Question.
Mr Speaker, with regard to
timelines, when contracts are
awarded, it is difficult for us to sit in
the Ministry or any office outside the
contractor's purview to determine timelines. When contractors face
challenges, it may delay the projects
and they would come back for us to
facilitate them to move back. So far,
we have not got that indication.

When I said “shortly” it meant that the contractor without

challenges should by now be on site

because some of the Agenda 111

projects have started. Some of the

contractors have laid the foundations

and some have prepared the land and

with this particular area, we are now

working on the site preparations to

get on to work. So, I would not be

able to give specific timelines until

later after some time, when actual

works have started.
Ms Akanvariba 1:08 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
believe the Hon Minister is aware
that there are no district health
facilities in the Tempane, Garu and
Pusiga districts. Infant and maternal
mortalities are very high, so, what
urgent steps would he take to make
sure that a district hospital is
constructed to reduce this canker that
worries the three districts?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:08 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I would want to thank my
Hon Colleague for coming out with
the distress situation that her
constituency faces. In view of this, I
would personally pay particular
attention to works in Tempane so that
this issue would be resolved, and if
there are challenges, I would
facilitate for the project to be done
quickly.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:08 p.m.
Hon
Member, you have one more
supplementary question. Are you
done?
Ms Akanvariba 1:08 p.m.
Yes, Mr
Speaker.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:08 p.m.
Very
well.
Question 162 which stands in the
name of the Hon Member for Keta,
Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey.
Delay in the Payment of Salaries
of the Ghana Health
Service/Ministry of Health Staff
who worked on the Global Fund
Programme
Mr Kwame Dzudzorli Gakpey
(NDC - Keta): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Hon Minister for Health the
circumstances surrounding the delay
in the payment of salaries of Ghana
Health Service/Ministry of Health
staff who worked on the Global Fund
programmes.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, at the moment, there are no
delays in the payment of salaries. The
Programme staff normally submit
salary request and when it is
approved, it is sent to the bank and
staff accounts are credited. They are
paid with Global Fund resources. For

October salaries, the memorandum

for salary request was submitted and

payment approved on the 20th and

27th for National HIV/AIDS Control

Programme and National Malaria

and TB Control Programmes

respectively.

Mr Speaker, contracts of some

staff are paid in the local currency,

but salaries are actually quoted in

United States dollars using a dollar

rate of GH₵3.50 to the dollar. With the depreciation of the dollar by day,

a dollar to cedi conversion rate went

up to GH₵4.30. Staff paid themselves using the new exchange

rate which must be deducted. The

rational is that Global Fund pegged

the conversion rate at GH₵3.50 because any time the dollar

depreciates and it is changed, it

distorts the salary systems within the

health sector. So for instance, some

junior staff drivers could probably

earn more than some medical

officers.

Mr Speaker, from January to

April, contracts had expired and staff

had to be re-issued with new

contracts. However, because they

had received unearned salaries, they

refused to be paid with the dollar to

cedi conversion rate of GH₵3.5 and

agreed to wait until a new agreement

was made with Global Fund.
Mr Gakpey 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
terms of reference for the agreement
did not indicate that an exchange rate
of US$1 to GH₵3.5 should be applicable throughout the lifespan of
the Project. Why is the Hon Minister
insisting that a GH₵3.5 rate should be applied?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I am afraid but I am not
insisting. These staff are on the
payroll of Global Fund and they had
their own arrangement in disbursing
funds in-country. These funds are not
generated from the consolidated
accounts and that was the agreement
Global Fund had with them.
No matter how much we try to
fight for our own staff who are
Ghanaians, Global Fund refused and
up till today, they have refused to
adjust the exchange rate as they have
pegged it. Last year when this
problem started, they were about to
sack some of the staff and it lingered
on for about four months when I was
intervening with the Global Fund to
see how best we could negotiate for
them to stay without sending them
home. That is what happened.
Mr Speaker, so, Global Fund's insistence was based on the

arrangement from the management

and board in Geneva and that is what

we are adopting here. That is why

they have pegged the rate at

GH₵3.5.

It would amaze you to know that

the moneys they paid themselves

three or four months ago, last year,

they made us deduct from their

current salaries other than that Global

Fund would not agree to disburse

funds to the programmes. That is the

situation we are facing.

Mr Speaker, when you have a

partner who insist on getting certain

things done; giving donations and

good money for the health sector, at

the end of the day, you cannot do

what you want to do and there are

certain things that are good for the

staff and instead of them being

sacked - which is even bigger than the salaries we take in the country - that is the best we could negotiate.
Mr Gakpey 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, from
the year 2015 to 2019, the rate was
based on GH₵3.5 per dollar and in the same period, some staff of the
Ministry of Health were using a rate
of GH₵4.3 and GH₵4.8 respec- tively and were benefitting while
others benefitted from the GH₵3.5 per dollar rate.
Mr Speaker, it may interest you to
note that I have worked there and I
know what I am saying. So, why are
some using a rate of GH₵3.5 per dollar while others are using
GH₵4.8? Can the Hon Minister provide better and further particulars
with regard to that?
Hon Afenyo-Markin — rose —
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
Hon
Minister, kindly hold on while I
listen to the Hon Deputy Majority
Leader.
Mr Alexander Afenyo-Markin 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, my Hon Colleague who
was on his feet said that he is one of
the affected persons. These were his
words. He should not use parlia-
mentary privilege to litigate a
personal claim. We need to get the
construct right; he said and these
were his words that he is one of them
— [Interruption].
Mr Speaker, if he has a claim

— So, he used to work there means he is one of the affected persons and

that is what he said. My Hon

Colleagues should not be shouting as

we need to get things right. He used

to work there and as an affected

person and this means that he is also

affected. If he has an issue, he should

either go to court or pursue it but not

to use Parliament — [Interruption] — Is it not in conflict?

If it is not so, the Hon Member

should rise and say that he is not one

of the affected. Maybe, it was a slip

of tongue.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
Hon
Member, are you asking your
Question of which you are personally
interested?
Mr Gakpey 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am
asking the Question for the affected
workers there; I am for the people.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
Hon
Member, I asked whether you are
personally interested?
Mr Gakpey 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have
no personal interest because I no
longer work there.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
Hon
Minister, kindly answer the
Question.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I am glad my Hon
Colleague has said that he is not
personally interested. Maybe, he
would be close to those of his
constituents working there.
The Hon Member mentioned
those workers being paid with the
rate of GH₵4.3; they are those from whom we are deducting the illegal
payment from their salaries. That is,
what they overpaid themselves from
their salaries. They did not seek
approval and they just changed the
rate from GH₵3.5 to GH₵4.3. We fought this issue for more than a year
and that caused their salaries to be
withheld for about four months in the
year 2021. This is what explains why
some got paid with a rate of GH₵4.3 and others stayed at GH₵3.5.
Mr Gakpey 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
grant has ended and I would like to
find out from the Hon Minister if the
Global Fund has sanctioned the
deductions? If yes, into which
accounts did those deductions go?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the deductions are being put
in a particular account that the money
sits for Global Fund to give us
approval on what we want to do with
the money other than that we cannot
touch it.
So, we are accumulating the
deductions and working with Global
Fund to look at how best we can
apply that money. What we are
happy with is the fact that they will
not take the money back but they
may allow us to do something in the
health sector with the money. So, the

money is sitting in a particular ring-

fenced account.
Mr James Klutse Avedzi 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I would like to find out from
the Hon Minister if the people who
enjoyed the unearned salary, some of
them are no longer under the
programme. How is he retrieving the
difference of that unearned portion
since they are no longer working
with the Ministry?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I am talking about
deductions and we have engaged
them and they have agreed that we
bring it back from GH₵4.3 to GH₵3.5. So, we calculated what they earned between the GH₵3.5 and GH₵4.3 rates till the time they stopped. That amount is what we are
deducting over a number of months,
we are not doing it at a go to let them
suffer challenges. These are the
deductions I have been talking about.
Mr Avedzi 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am
referring to how the Hon Minister
would retrieve the money from those
who are no longer working with the
Ministry of Health or the Global
Fund.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:18 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, fortunately, almost all of
them are in the system.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
Very
well.
Hon Members, Question
numbered 285 which stands in the
name of the Hon Member for Builsa
South - Dr Clement Apaak.
Secured Funding for Proposed
Builsa South District Hospital and
Commencement of Work
Dr Clement A. Apaak (NDC - Builsa South) 1:18 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to
ask the Hon Minister for Health if
funding has been secured for the
proposed Builsa South District
Hospital under Agenda 111, and
when work would commence.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:28 p.m.
Mr.
Speaker, The Agenda 111 project is
being funded through budgetary
allocations by the Government of
Ghana. Secured Provisions have
been made to ensure Interim
Payment Certificates (IPCs) that will
be raised for payment in the course of
the project duration would be
honoured assuredly.
Dr Apaak 1:28 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I am
grateful to the Hon Minister for
indicating that funding has been
secured.

Mr Speaker, for the sake of

clarity, I want to know from the Hon

Minister if it would be a new hospital

or an upgrade of the existing Fumbisi

Healthcare Centre?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:28 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, because of the numbers
involved in this project, I would not
be able to instantly identify the
location of the Builsa South District
Hospital at the moment. I may have
to crosscheck and ascertain, sure but
if it is in Fumbisi then it may mean
that it would be at a different location
or we may upgrade the existing one.
Mr Speaker, I do not want to stand
here and guess because this is a
House of records, so I want the
House to grant me space so that I
crosscheck and give my Hon
Colleague a proper answer. Mr
Speaker, I think we can do so in the
corridors of this Chamber or closer to
the Fumbisi valley where I have been
visiting lately.
Dr Apaak 1:28 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
words by the Hon Minister are quite
tasteful and I can see that he is trying
to lure me away from the Floor to the
corridors. I would be expecting him
to provide me with further and better
particulars so that there could be
clarity. Either we are upgrading the
current health centre of which a
request has been made for the
provision of healthcare material, or a
new hospital is being added.
Mr Speaker, I would yield and
wait for the Hon Minister's clarity on whether we are getting a new
hospital in Fumbisi or the existing
one would be upgraded.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:28 p.m.
Very
well.
Hon Members, we would move to
Question numbered 287 standing in
the name of the Hon Member for
Salaga South, Ms Zuweira
Mohammed Ibrahimah.
Completion of Kafaba Health
Centre
Ms Zuwera Mohammed
Ibrahimah (NDC - Salaga South)
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister
for Health when the Kafaba Health
Centre would be completed and
made operational.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:28 p.m.
Mr.
Speaker, the Ministry was informed
that the Kafaba Health Centre was
funded by the Northern Development
Authority (NDA). The project is
currently at roofing stage and efforts
are being made to complete it by the
NDA. I would urge the Northern
Regional Director of Health Services
to follow up with the Northern

Development Authority towards its

completion.
Ms Ibrahimah 1:28 p.m.
Mr Speaker, the
Hon Minister indicated in his
Answer that he would urge the
Northern Regional Director of
Health, but I may have to remind the
Hon Minister that Kafaba is in the
Savannah Region and not in the
Northern Region.
Mr Speaker, most importantly,
the facility was undergoing
renovation during September or
October last year, and for about six
months now, the people in that
enclave have been deprived of a
health facility. Mr Speaker, so if
there is any person that could ensure
that the Northern Development
Authority would speed up with
works on this facility, then it should
be the Hon Minister for Health. So, I
want to plead with him not to leave
this to the Savannah Regional Health
Directorate because we need his
personal intervention in this matter to
ensure that the clinic is completed in
good time for the people of Kafaba
and its environs.
Mr Speaker, thank you.
Mr Agyeman -Manu 1:28 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would take counsel from
my Hon Colleague. The actual
problem is that the Northern
Development Authority have their
own resources that they are using to
do these things and that is why I said
that I would engage with the
Northern Regional Health Director to
engage with the Hon Regional
Minister, who supervises the
Authority's projects. However, with the plea by my Hon Colleague, I
would see how best I could get closer
and get it done.
Also, I thank the Hon Member for
the correction of Northern Region to
Savannah Region.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:28 p.m.
Very
well.
We would take Question
numbered 288 standing in the name
of the Hon Member for Salaga South,
Ms Ibrahimah.
Status of 60-Bed Salaga Euroget
Hospital Project
Ms. Zuwera Mohammed
Ibrahimah (Salaga South): Mr
Speaker I beg to ask the Minister for
Health about the status of the 60-bed
Salaga Euroget Hospital project and
when it would be completed.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:28 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the project forms part of the
8 No. hospitals being undertaken by

Euroget. Salaga Hospital at the initial

stages suffered some challenges in

the implementation, including a two

year injunction due to issues between

the main Contractor Messrs Euroget

De Invest and the subcontractor

Messrs Maico Ghana Limited.

Mr Speaker, with all these

challenges the project is ongoing

with a progress rate of 68 per cent of

completion and the contractor's estimated completion date is the first

quarter of 2022 per their work

programme. The Contractor has also

agreed to mobilise staff from other

locations during the farming season

to continue with works on the project

in order to achieve the expected

project completion date.

Mr Speaker, we are monitoring

Euroget efforts very seriously to

make sure that all the eight hospitals

that they are handling would be

completed before the close of this

year, but specifically for Salaga, we

would make sure that by the end of

the first quarter we should see a

completion of the project.
Ms Ibrahimah 1:38 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
would want the Hon Minister for
Health to give us a concrete
assurance as to when the project
would be completed? I say this
because the first quarter of 2022, as
contained in the Hon Minister's
Answer, is the end of next month
which is 31st March.

In the same Answer, the Hon

Minister suggested that the

contractor has mobilised staff from

other areas during the farming

season. The farming season in the

north is way outside the first quarter

of the calendar so I am a little bit

confused about what the timings are.

I would want the Hon Minister to

elaborate more on this and give us

some concrete assurance of when this

project would be completed?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:38 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, we have been talking to
Euroget and his management staff
and the answer they gave us is what I
actually came up to. We did some
check ups there to ascertain the
actual progress of work there. We
have pinned Euroget to the fact that
project completion dates cannot be
varied any longer and we are trying
to provide the resources and the
facilitation that he needs. The end of
the first quarter, for me, is what we
have arranged with him and that is
his information to us. So, we would
follow up and try to see how best this
project would get off our heads by
the end of the quarter. That is March
and we have two months to go. He
has got all his materials from outside

on site and we believe that if he gets

more hands on the work, he would be

able to complete the work for us.
Ms Ibrahimah 1:38 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
thank the Hon Minister for the
efforts. I want to suggest that where
possible, he can arrange a field trip - I would be happy to come along with
him so that we can all have first-hand
information on the exact happenings
on the project site and what the
possible timelines might be. I think
the project needs the Hon
Minister's visit. Can I get an assurance that he would make
time and go and see the
project?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:38 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, as part of my work
programme for the year, I plan
on visiting some of the
regions. I cannot visit all the
regions in one year. But
because of our COVID-19
situation and attendance to
Parliament, I am finding it
difficult to even schedule to do
my regional tours. That part of
the country would be part of
my tour because the first tour I
did when I joined the Ministry
- though I went to the Northern Region, I could not visit the
Savannah area at all . I was in
the North East Region at the
time. This time round, my
concentration would be the
Savannah Region. So, at the
appropriate time, I would see
how best I can schedule to visit
the place. But I would keep on
getting information and I may
be talking to the Hon Member,
again in the corridors , to give
her progress of work as we
move ahead.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:38 p.m.
Very well. Question numbered
289, also in the name of the
Hon Member for Salaga South.
Resourcing and
Operationalisation of Kulpi,
Yayielie et cetera CHPS
Compounds
Ms Zuwera Mohammed
Ibrahimah (NDC - Salaga South): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister
for Health when the CHPS
Compounds in Kulpi, Yayielie, and
Dagombia would be resourced and
made operational.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:38 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, information gathered
indicates that the Kulpi and Yayiele
CHPS compounds were awarded and
constructed in 2014 by the East
Gonja Municipal Assembly.
Subsequently, the Kulpi facility is
being operationalised but not well
equipped, whereas the Yayiele is not
operationalised since the structure

has deteriorated and requires serious

renovation.

The Dagombia CHPS Compound

was constructed by a Village

Connect which is a Non-Govern-

mental Organisation (NGO) from the

Netherlands, in the year 2020. It is

however not operational due to lack

of furniture. That is strictly an NGO

project.
Ms Ibrahimah 1:38 p.m.
Mr Speaker, this
Question was filed sometime in June,
last year, so it has taken about seven
months for the Question to be
answered. Within that period, we
took it upon ourselves to renovate the
Yayiele CHPS compound and made
it operational for use but the
Dagombia CHPS compound, as the
Hon Minister has indicated, has also
started giving way. It has been locked
up for almost two years now, and the
last time I visited Dagombia, it had
started developing cracks and other
defects. So, I would want to appeal to
the Hon Minister to get the Regional
and Municipal Health Directorate to
pay some attention to these facilities.
This is because once they are
constructed and left unused, we
spend money that could otherwise
have been used to rehabilitate the
buildings and furnish them. We are
done with Yayiele and we are still
looking for furniture. So, the Hon
Minister should let us pay attention - we have too many of them scattered
around the constituency. We have
built and left unused. I think there
must be a policy to ensure that when
we spend government money to put
up structures, they are used for the
purposes for which they were put up.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:38 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I have taken my Hon
Colleague's appeal seriously into consideration but I would also appeal
to her and all other Hon Members in
the Chamber that some of these
CHPS compounds were started by
NGOs who do not have government
investment into their operations.
Even if we want to touch the projects,
we may need to engage the NGOs for
them to release these facilities for us
to continue to do what we want to do
for the place. In this situation, since
all of us are members of the
Assemblies where we come from, the
best area to even get support would
not be the health directorates in the
regions and the districts but rather
from the Assemblies. So, though I
would continue to look at what we
can do for that small area, I would
plead with my Hon Colleague that
she should also contact the autho-
rities of the District Assembly to see
how best they could support to get
the Dagombia compound opera-
tionalised and probably maintained
very well.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:38 p.m.
Very
well. Question numbered 365, which

stand in the name of the Hon Member

for Amenfi West, Mr Eric Afful.

Status of Construction of Wassa

Dunkwa Polyclinic
Mr Eric Afful (NDC - Amenfi West) 1:38 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Health the current status
of construction of the Wassa Dunkwa
Polyclinic in the Amenfi West Con-
stituency and when the polyclinic
would be completed and com-
missioned.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:38 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the Wassa Dunkwa Poly-
clinic is part of the construction of
public health care facilities in
selected Districts in the Western
Region as a big project. There are
five of them: Akontombra, Tarkwa
Nsuaem, Wassa Dunkwa, and two
other places I cannot easily mention.
The contractor is VAMED and we all
know VAMED is a big time
contractor in our country. Since I
joined, they had done a lot of projects
for us.
The funding is from the
Netherlands Government, which
commenced in July 2019. The
facility which is at 52 per cent level
of completion will achieve a 42-bed
capacity hospital. The project is
scheduled to be completed and
handed over by April 2022, all things
being equal. This is the latest
information I have from the
contractors.
Mr Afful 1:48 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I would
like to remind the Hon Minister that
this project under consideration is a
Turnkey Project with funding from
Netherlands Government, so there
are funds available. As we speak
today, the project is at 52 per cent
completion. Could the Hon Minister
give the only reason why for about
two years now, the project is still
about 52 per cent complete?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, when I come to the
Chamber, I do not plead alibi with
COVID-19. But it is part of the
impact of COVID-19; almost all our
projects that are being handled by
foreign contractors came to a stop.
The Hon Member has seen some
people from outside on that project,
and they have given that project to
subcontractors. They are drawing
monies from banks outside the
country, and there are restrictions
and protocols outside. People were
not going to work; they worked from
home. That explains why for nearly
two years, we did not see much
progress on the project. They were all
scheduled to have been completed by
2021.

Mr Speaker, the Hon Member is

from the Western Region. I have told

him to go and see the polyclinic in

Tarkwa- Nsuaem. It is not different

from the one in Wassa Dunkwa so let

us exercise some restraints. In April

2022, we would see how best some

of these facilities would be

completed. They have brought in all

the materials. It is not the lack of

funds but challenges with COVID-19

restrictions and others. I am the one

who signs their certificates and I

know where they are. They have got

the money and they are prepared for

this project.
Mr Afful 1:48 p.m.
Mr Speaker, if so, can
the Hon Minister give a timeline as to
when the project would be completed
and commissioned?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the best I can say is that the
project will be completed not beyond
2022. It should be completed latest
by December 2022. The Hon
Member will see the hospital and I
will invite him to come and join me
to see the operationalisation of the
Wassa Dunkwa Polyclinic.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:48 p.m.
Very
well. Question numbered 447, which
stands in the name of the Hon
Member for Jaman South, William
Okofo-Dateh.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I am very sorry. The Order
Paper has got something on page 15,
the last paragraph, that is supposed to
be some part of an answer to another
Question. That should be deleted
because that Question was not listed.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:48 p.m.
Hon
Minister, I did not understand you. Is
the Kekele hospital supposed to be
part of the answer to a Question not
listed for today?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, yes.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:48 p.m.
Very
well.
Yes, Hon Member for Jaman
South, you may ask your Question.
Information on Japekrom
Health Facility
Mr Williams Okofo-Dateh
(NDC - Jaman South): Mr Speaker,
I beg to ask the Minister for Health
the type of health facility under
construction at Japekrom, the status
of work so far, the contractor
working on the Project, and the
contract details.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I cannot find the answer to
the Question numbered 447 on the
Order Paper, but I have an answer
that I submitted. With your

indulgence, if it is permitted, I can

answer the Question outside the

publication of the Order Paper.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:48 p.m.
Hon
Minister, I do not see any objection,
so please proceed.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, information gathered
indicates that the type of health
facility under construction at
Japekrom is a health centre with a
two-bedroom accommodation unit.
The contract was awarded and
implemented by the District
Assembly under the Middle Belt
Development Authority - that is part of the US$1 million per constituency
project - in February 2020. The contractor for the project is
EOANKS Yuns Services with a
contract sum of GHȻ900,000.00, to be completed in 12 months.
Mr Speaker, we have been
informed that the current progress of
work on the facility is at foundation
level, while the two-bedroom
bungalow is at roofing level of
completion. It would be important
for us to liaise with the Middle Belt
Development Authority to provide
the necessary funds to complete the
project, as it was not captured in the
Ministry's budget.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:48 p.m.
Hon
Member, do you have a follow-up
question? Please, proceed.
Mr Okofo-Dateh 1:48 p.m.
Mr Speaker, it
is unfortunate we do not have the
answer provided on the Order Paper.
That notwithstanding, the Hon
Minister said the project was
supposed to be completed last year
but it is over two years now and the
project is still at the foundation level.
Can the Hon Minister tell me what
has accounted for this? Is there any
attempt to get the contractor come
back to site and work on the project?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, unfortunately, I cannot
answer the supplementary question. I
mentioned that the project is under
the Middle Belt Development
Authority; it is not under the purview
of the Ministry of Health. So, it is a
difficult organisation that is
implementing the project. I do not
know that contractor and there is no
information in the Ministry about the
contractor. We do not have the
budget for it. That was why I said we
would have to liaise with the Middle
Belt Development Authority. Since
the Hon Member is closer to the
Middle Belt Development Authority,
he can help me get it done.
Mr Speaker, but I would convey
the Hon Member's sentiments and

concerns to see how best this can go

on.
Mr James Klutse Avedzi 1:48 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, the Hon Minister said that
because the project is under the
Middle Belt Development Authority,
even though it is a health facility, he
cannot answer the question.
Mr Speaker, I would want to find
out the relationship between the
Ministry and any agency that wants
to support the Ministry in terms of
building health facilities. There is the
need to provide a standard structure
and technical advice. The Hon
Minister says that it is under the
Middle Belt Development Authority
and the Ministry is not providing any
input. It does not sound right.
Mr Speaker, what is the relation-
ship between the Ministry of Health
and the Middle Belt Development
Authority?
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:48 p.m.
Yes,
Hon Minister - But before then, in accordance with Order 40(3), I direct
that the House Sits outside the
regular Sitting hours.
Hon Minister, please proceed.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, that is the ideal situation.
But we know in this world, we do not
live in an utopia; that has never
happened in most instances. It is not
only with the Middle Belt
Development Authority. Parliament
approves some contracts for the
construction of roads and com-
mercial contracts for the construction
of some hospitals — the Ministry of Roads and Highways begins to
implement the projects on the blind
side of the Ministry of Health.
In some instances, people would
call and tell us of facilities in places
which were completed two years
ago, and ask us to go and
operationalise it. But when we go and
do our investigations, we find out
that an agency, as part of a big
contract, has put the facility there.
Mr Speaker, I can give examples.
When we were doing that Nsawam
Road from Neoplan Lorry Station,
they built a hospital as part of the
road project, but we never got to
know about it. When I went to the
Ministry, people complained about it
on social media. I then sent the
Directors from the Ministry there.
The design did not conform to the
normal design of health facilities,
and we had to go and try to calm
down tensions in the community.

Mr Speaker, so for some of these

projects, they would not tell us, but

before we are aware, they would

have started. With some of the

Assemblies, the District Chief

Executives (DCEs) and the NGOs

would start the projects, but when

they are brought to our notice, we

move around to try to correct what

might have gone wrong.
Mr James Klutse Avedzi 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, with the Hon Minister
knowing these facts or details, what
would he do to ensure that the ideal
situation that he explained works?
The Hon Minister cannot sit down
and say that such is the situation and
he is helpless about it. He must
correct the system. What would he do
about it?
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Hon
Member, when a community decides
to put up a clinic, sometimes, if they
do not like you the Hon Member of
Parliament (MP), they would not tell
you anything. It is when they are
stuck midway and need money that
they would come to inform you of
what they were doing. It is the same
situation.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, I would take his advice and
try to see the best I can do. We have
been talking to some of the
Ministries who are fond of doing
these things like the Ministry of
Roads and Highways for example.
Now, it seems they have stopped. So,
when they inform us, we come in.
These days, some come and ask for
permission. They show us their
drawings and things like that, so we
are working gradually on that matter.
Mr Okofo-Dateh 1:58 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I
would want to ask the Hon Minister
a question. This Question was filed
about five to six months ago. When
the Hon Minister got the Question,
please, did he reach out to the Middle
Belt Authority, and what did they tell
him about the project with regard to
its completion and what is being
done on it? Did he get any
information from the Middle Belt
Authority? I ask because I want my
constituents and everybody to hear
the answer being given to this
Question in Parliament, so that my
constituents would know what is
happening on site and know what to
expect. I would want the Hon
Minister to tell me the answers he got
from the Middle Belt Authority.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, if I had not consulted the
Middle Belt Authority, I would not
have even gotten any Answer to
provide here. So, his supplementary
question is a very difficult question
for me now, but I would take his
advice and try to see if I can go back
and consult them and try to give him
a definite answer. I would talk to him

in the corridors of the Chamber when

I get some more information on the

project.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Hon
Minister, if the Middle Belt
Authority is building a hospital, does
it become your responsibility until
they have finished?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, not until they finish and,
maybe, hand it over to us, it is not my
responsibility. So, when they finish
and call us to take over, run, and
manage the facility, then we send
staff and other hospital devices and
equipment to support the entire
hospital.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Hon
Members, we would take the
Question numbered 448, which
stands in the name of the Member for
Madina, the Hon Francis-Xavier
Kojo Sosu.
Steps taken to address the
Safety and Security Concerns of
Pantang Hospital Staff
Mr Francis-Xavier Kojo Sosu
(NDC - Madina): Mr Speaker, before I ask the Question, I have a
preliminary remark on page 15.
There was an earlier Question on
Kekeli Hospital, and I have realised
that only a part of the Answer has
been provided on page 15 of the
Order Paper, even though it is not the
substantive Question.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Hon
Member, the Answer would be given
by the Hon Minister, so you should
ask your Question, and if there are
any issues, then it would come in.
Mr Sosu 1:58 p.m.
Mr Speaker, that
Question is not part of today's Questions.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
The
Hon Minister has already stated so,
that some Answers there do not
belong there.
Mr Sosu 1:58 p.m.
Very well, Mr Speaker.
Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
Minister for Health the steps being
taken by the Ministry to address the
safety and security concerns of
Pantang Hospital staff, which is the
basis of their current strike action on
account of allegation of encroach-
ment of the hospital land.
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, currently, the Ministry of
Health has taken all necessary steps
to construct a fence wall around the
perimeters of the facility to enhance
the safety of personnel in the
hospital. In addition, a 24-hour
security has been provided for the
management, staff, and patients in
and around the hospital environment,

and my Hon Colleague, I think, is

aware of this because at one stage, I

was consulting him.

Mr Speaker, the La

Nkwantanang/Madina Municipal

Assembly has also initiated a court

process for a restraining order to stop

private developers from further

constructions on the Hospital's property. Again, the Ministry of

Health, assisted by the Assembly,

would ensure that structures without

the Assembly's permit on the land are duly demolished, and we are

working towards that.

Mr Speaker, the Ministry of the

Interior and the National Security

have actually posted adequate Police

personnel to the Hospital's Police post. The Ministry of Lands and

Natural Resources is also facilitating

it through their Lands Commission to

ensure that areas that have been fully

developed that they claimed is not

ours, if that is correct, would be com-

pulsorily purchased so that we would

have peace in the facility. We are

collaborating with all these

Ministries in our efforts to restore

peace on the land.
Mr Sosu 1:58 p.m.
Mr Speaker, I have one
supplementary question. Does the
Hon Minister have any benchmarks
or timelines for some of these steps
being taken by the Ministry?
Mr Agyeman-Manu 1:58 p.m.
Mr
Speaker, in my life, I have always
tried to avoid giving benchmarks for
any activity, especially when one is
asked to come for money. The person
may come and there would not be
any money as at the time, so I try to
avoid benchmarks. In this particular
instance, it is a continuous process.
We cannot have benchmarks,
especially with the court system. A
court process is underway and I do
not control the judges or anybody
else in the courts. So, if I give the
benchmarks here, I would be
goofing. So, I would plead with my
Hon Colleague to allow us end the
issue on the benchmarks for us to see
how he and I could collaborate with
the Assembly, where he belongs, to
try to see if we can bring peace in that
area.
Mr Speaker, our problem with
hospital lands and encroachments is
not only encountered in the La
Nkwantanang/Madina Municipality.
So, I have set up a small committee
in the Ministry, headed by a Deputy
Minister, to be working on these
encroachment issues; Tema, Cape
Coast, La Nkwantanang/Madina
Municipality, and everywhere else.
We all know that hospitals in the
olden days were built with ample
land around them, but now people are
just encroaching on them. It is like

getting money to build fence wall

around all of them has become a

challenge, and that is why we find it

difficult to protect all these lands. We

are however, making all the

necessary efforts to, at least, protect

the La Nkwantanang/Madina Muni-

cipality.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Hon
Member, are you done?
Very well.
Any question from the Leader-
ship?
All right, Hon Minister, we thank
you for attending upon the House to
answer our Questions. You are now
discharged.
Mr Habib Iddrisu 1:58 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
at the Commencement of Public
Business, we would now move on to
the item numbered 7 - Presentation of Papers.
So, we would take the Papers
numbered 7(b)(i), (ii) and (iii).
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Those Reports are ready for
presentation. Is that the suggestion? I
have not called for any of them yet; I
am only verifying. I would want to
know if those Reports are ready
Mr Habib Iddrisu 1:58 p.m.
Mr Speaker,
the Papers are ready.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 1:58 p.m.
Very
well, Hon Members, we would take
the item numbered 7(b)(i)—By the Hon Chairman of the Committee.
PAPERS 1:58 p.m.

  • [including Atradius Premium]) to finance the construction of a Bridge over the Volta River at Adawso-Ekyi Amanfrom.
  • Mr Habib Iddrisu 2:08 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    we are still on the item numbered 7,
    and we would now take the items
    numbered 7(c)(i) and (ii).
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 2:08 a.m.
    Hon
    Members, the item numbered
    7(c)(i)(ii) by the Chairman of the
    Committee on Roads and Transport.
    By Chairman of the Committee —
    (i) Report of the committee
    on Roads and Transport
    on the Commercial
    Contract Agreement
    between the Government
    of the Republic of Ghana
    (acting through the
    Ministry of Roads and
    Highways and repre-
    sented by the Ghana
    Highway Authority) and
    Contracta Construction
    UK Limited for an
    amount of One Hundred
    and Fifty Million Euros
    (€150,000,000.00) for the Construction of the
    Bunso - Adawso Road and specified approach
    roads to the Adawso
    Bridge Project (104Km,
    comprising:
    Takorowatwen - Ekyi Amanfrom Road— 22Km; Adawso -Kwahu Tafo Road—20Km; Kwahu Tafo - Miaso Road—29Km, Miaso - Begoro Road—26Km; and Begoro - Obuoho Road—7Km).
    (ii) Report of the Committee
    on Roads and Transport
    on the Design-Build
    Contract Agreement
    between the Government

    of the Republic of Ghana

    (acting through the

    Ministry of Roads and

    Highways and

    represented by the Ghana

    Highway Authority) and

    BNIP-Janson-Adowso

    Consortium of Nether-

    lands for an amount of

    Two Hundred Million

    Euros (€200,000,000.00) for the Construction of a

    Bridge over the Volta

    River at Adawso-Ekyi

    Amanfrom.
    Mr Habib Iddrisu 2:08 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    we could move to page 6 and take the
    item numbered 9, Motion.
    Mr Avedzi 2:08 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, indeed,
    the debated was concluded and
    Question is to be put. If we have the
    numbers, you can put the Question
    but if we do not have the numbers,
    then we could defer it.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 2:08 a.m.
    Yes,
    Leaders, the Question is to be put, are
    you ready?
    — [Pause] —
    Yes, Leader, do you have the
    number to take a decision?
    Mr Habib Iddrisu 2:08 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    just on the same page 6, the item
    numbered 9; just for the Question to
    be put, and then, we would be in your
    hands.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 2:08 a.m.
    Yes,
    the Hon Member raising the issue, do
    we have the number to take a
    decision?
    Mr Habib Iddrisu 2:08 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    where we are, I do not think we are
    counting numbers to get it, and I am
    very convinced that we have the
    numbers for the Question to be put.
    So, if you put the Question, it would
    be in the right direction. [Pause] —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 2:08 a.m.
    Yes,
    Leaders, I am looking at you.
    Mr Habib Iddrisu 2:08 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    I think we are in your hands for
    adjournment. A lot has been done; I
    can see that some Hon Members are
    holding Standing Orders but this is
    not the E-Levy Bill. The debate has
    been concluded, it is just a Question
    to be put. At certain times, we need
    to be considerate about some of these
    issues.
    Mr Speaker, we are in your hands
    for adjournment.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 2:08 a.m.
    Hon
    Members, the House is adjourned to
    tomorrow, Wednesday, 2nd February,
    2022 at 10.00 in the forenoo
    ADJOURNMENT 2:08 a.m.