Debates of 21 Jun 2022

MR SPEAKER
PRAYERS 11:17 a.m.

Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
Hon Members, we could
not commence early because this morning,
I had a message from the Majority Caucus
that they were having a Caucus meeting,
and they pleaded that we should start
Business today after the completion of
their Caucus meeting. The intention was to
have the meeting completed by 11:00 a.m.;
I think they have done that, but we still do
not have a lot of them in. So we are starting
Business a bit later than is scheduled; that
is the reason for the delay in commence-
ment of Proceedings today.
ANNOUNCEMENTS 11:17 a.m.

Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
We have a Message
from H. E. the President, and the Message
is dated 17th June, 2022. It was received
yesterday in my Office, and it reads:

Votes and Proceedings and the Official

Report
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
I do not have a formal communication today, and so we will move to the item numbered 4 - Correction of Votes and Proceedings and the Official Report.
We will start with the Correction of Votes and Proceedings of Friday, 17th June, 2022.
Page 1 …5 —
Mr Williams Okofo-Dateh — rose —
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
Yes?
Mr Williams Okofo-Dateh 11:17 a.m.
Mr Speaker, page 5 - I was absent with permission, but I have been marked as absent.
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
What item is that?
Mr Okofo-Dateh 11:17 a.m.
The item numbered
34.
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
Item numbered 34 - Okofo-Dateh Williams - the Hon Member of Parliament for Jaman South. So please, kindly capture him “absent with permi- ssion”, not “without permission”.
Mr Okofo-Dateh 11:17 a.m.
Mr Speaker, thank you.
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
Page 8 —
Mr Daniel Nsala Wakpal 11:17 a.m.
Mr
Speaker, on page 7 - the item numbered 45, I have been marked “absent”. It is supposed to be “absent with permission”. Thank you.
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
Page 7 — the item numbered 35?
Mr Daniel Nsala Wakpal 11:17 a.m.
Item
numbered 45 — Daniel Nsala Wakpal.
Mr Speaker 11:17 a.m.
Were you absent with
permission?
Mr Wakpal 11:17 a.m.
Mr Speaker, yes.
Mr Speaker 11:27 a.m.
Clerks-at-the-Table,
kindly take note.

Page 8…32.

Hon Members, in the absence of any

further corrections, the Votes and

Proceedings of the 14th Sitting held on

Friday, 17th June, 2022 is hereby adopted

as the true record of proceedings.

Hon Members, I have in my

possession a copy of the Official Report of

15th June, 2022. Any corrections?
  • [No Correction was made to the Official Report of 15th June, 2022]
  • Mr Speaker 11:27 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Majority
    Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:27 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    Leadership got correspondence from the
    Hon Minister for Transport that he is
    unavoidably absent and he communicates
    his regret hence he is unable to attend upon
    the House to do Business. So, Mr Speaker,
    that is the news we have from the Hon
    Minister of Transport. Thank you.
    Mr Speaker 11:27 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Minority
    Chief Whip?
    Alhaji Mohammed-Mubarak Muntaka 11:27 a.m.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker. It is worrying that
    Hon Ministers are gradually turning this
    House, for lack of a better word, like a joke.
    They would wait until the morning of
    asking the Questions then they would run
    to us that they could not come because of
    one urgent thing or the other.
    Mr Speaker, as you are very much
    aware, these Questions were transmitted to
    the Ministries long before even the
    Business Committee met on Thursday and
    immediately after the Business of the
    House, they wrote to them to remind them
    that on a particular date, they are required
    to appear. If they wait until the day of the
    Questions and they do this — Mr Speaker, as you rightly know, the number of
    Questions we have outstanding is
    gradually getting out of hand.
    Mr Speaker, for the Hon Minister for
    Transport in particular, he used to be one
    of those who would happily come to the
    House to answer Questions but of late, time
    and time again, I can recollect that this
    would be about the third time I am raising
    the concern about his inability to appear
    before the House.
    Mr Speaker, we would be grateful if
    you could help the House to hold these Hon Ministers accountable because this is one of the tools that is used in holding them accountable. So, for the Hon Ministers to be picking and choosing when they would like to come, I believe as a House, we need to resolve that unless the person is sick— they have Deputy Ministers yet they do not have the courtesy of sending a Deputy Minister but just write to say that they are not available. I do not think that is tenable and if we continue to allow that to stand - Mr Speaker, I am sorry but this is how we

    would continue to be weak. We would be grateful if you could give some strong wording to the Hon Minister and get him to appear before the House soonest, probably within this same week to answer the Questions because refusing to come to the House is refusing to answer to the ordinary citizens of this country.

    We hope that you would give a very strong warning to the Hon Minister and get him to come to the House within the week to answer these Questions. Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Speaker 11:27 a.m.
    Yes, available Leader of the Majority Side, what do you have to say?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:27 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I think this is a straightforward matter and I am in total agreement with what my Colleague said except to say that I think it is high time we named and shamed. We should not box all the Hon Ministers together.
    There are Hon Ministers who have been doing their work diligently and they take the House seriously. I do not want to mention any name. Anytime a number of them are unable to attend upon the House, they give notice ahead of time and in my view that is the crux of their worry; their notice should come ahead of time. We understand that it is a human institution they are manning but they cannot bring their correspondence or excuse duty on the same day that they are supposed to appear
    before the House, that is totally unaccep- table and it is something we should not romance at all.
    Having said that, we would reach out
    to the Hon Minister and let him know that
    the House is not happy about this and we
    would work assiduously to ensure that we
    re-programme this as soon as possible. I
    would plead with my Colleagues, maybe,
    we would give him the benefit of the doubt
    and probably this would be the last; we
    would not entertain this kind of attitude of
    bringing the notice the very day they are
    supposed to take their Question. That
    would not be accepted and I am not too
    happy about it. So, I am in total agreement
    with the worries my Hon Colleague has
    expressed, especially in relation to the Hon
    Minister for Transport. Like he rightly
    said, the Hon Minister is one of the
    Ministers who has been very diligent but
    these days, his attitude leaves a lot to be
    desired.
    Mr Speaker, I am only going to plead
    that we would try and re-programme him
    to appear and do the needful.
    Mr Speaker 11:37 a.m.
    Hon Members, the
    Leaders have taken us through the Motion
    of how Questions are asked of Hon
    Ministers. The Question is filed by the Hon
    Member through the Leadership of the
    Caucus of the Hon Member to the Speaker.
    The Speaker admits the Question and it is

    processed through the Business Committee

    after it is submitted to the respective

    Ministry. The Ministry is given three

    weeks to submit the Answer to the House

    and then, it is processed through the

    Business Committee and the Hon Minister

    is informed. A date is then scheduled

    where the Hon Minister is required to

    appear before the House to answer the

    Question and the Standing Orders are very

    clear on that. It is mandatory for the Hon

    Minister to appear to answer the Question.

    Now, from what I have been given, the

    Hon Minister, through the Ag. Chief

    Director, Mrs Mabel Sagoe, submitted a

    letter dated 20th of June, 2022; that is just

    yesterday and it was received at 10:30 a.m.

    today, 21st of June, 2022, at the Table

    Office by the Clerks-at-the-Table and then

    processed through to the Leadership. I have

    just been given a copy of that letter.

    Hon Members, I agree with

    Leadership that this is not good enough

    because the Hon Minister has been given

    sufficient notice to appear today to answer

    the Questions. The Hon Minister has used

    his Ag. Chief Director to inform the House

    that he would not be available to answer

    the Questions today and that he prefers that

    the Questions be re-scheduled for

    Thursday, 23rd June, 2022.

    Hon Members, Hon Ministers do not

    decide when they would appear before the

    House to answer the Questions. That

    decision is not for Hon Ministers to make.

    That decision is for the House and the Rt

    Hon Speaker. So, by the constitutional

    provision, if you all read article 122 of the

    1992 Constitution, this constitutes contempt

    of the House. The article states that:

    “An act or omission which obstructs or impedes Parliament in the

    performance of its functions or

    which obstructs or impedes a

    member or officer of Parliament in

    the discharge of his duties, or

    affronts the dignity of Parliament

    or which tends either directly or

    indirectly to produce that result, is

    contempt of Parliament.”

    This provision has been captured in

    our Standing Orders as Order 28. I agree

    with the submission made by the Leaders

    of the House that this is one of the Hon

    Ministers who used to be very punctual in

    responding to Questions asked by Hon

    Members. But of late, his conduct seems to

    be negating all the gains he made in the

    House. I am tempted to refer his conduct to

    the Committee of Privileges, but because

    of the intervention of Leadership, I would

    resist that temptation and not refer him to

    the Committee of Privileges for today, but

    the next conduct tantamount to this

    behaviour would be referred to the

    Committee of Privileges.

    I would not accept his request that the

    Questions be re-scheduled for Thursday. I

    would refer the Questions back to the

    Business Committee to re-schedule them at

    the appropriate date for him to answer. We

    have 20 Questions for today; therefore, I

    would excuse him for today and ask the

    Business Committee to re-schedule the

    Questions, but give him notice that this

    House would no longer entertain that kind

    of behaviour.

    If for any good reason — Chief Directors and Ag. Chief Directors be told

    in very clear language that we are not going

    to accept any language as, “The Hon Minister is unavoidably absent”.

    We are not going to accept that

    language and there must be an acceptable

    reason why the Hon Minister is absent, not

    “unavoidably absent”. What is the meaning of “unavoidably absent” to the Ministry? Please, there must be good reasons the Hon

    Minister cannot attend upon the House and

    answer the Questions. We are all human

    and have all been in this business for some

    time, and we would understand if the

    reason is cogent, acceptable, and

    reasonable, but not “unavoidably absent”.

    In view of this, the Question that

    stands in the name of the Hon Members— Questions numbered 543, 549, 554, 556,

    674, 987, 1099, 1272, and 1273 on pages 3

    and 4 of the Order Paper are accordingly

    referred back to the Business Committee to

    re-schedule for the Hon Minister for

    Transport to appear before this House to

    answer the Questions. As I stated earlier,

    the Hon Minister should take notice that

    this is the last time this House would grant

    him such an opportunity. The next absence

    of the Hon Minister for unavoidable reasons,

    he would be referred to the Committee of

    Privileges for a conduct tantamount to a

    breach of the privilege of this House and

    the Committee would summon him to

    answer why he should not be mulched for

    breach of privileges of this House.

    I hereby direct accordingly—Business Committee, kindly re-schedule the

    Questions for the Hon Minister to appear to

    answer them.

    We would now move on to the page

    numbered 4, and we are honoured with the

    presence of the Hon Minister for Sanitation

    and Water Resources. She would take the

    appropriate seat and respond to the

    Questions.

    The first Question stands in the name

    of the Hon Member for Nadowli/Kaleo, Mr

    Anthony Mwinkaara Sumah. Please, the

    Hon Minister is properly seated. You may

    ask your Question now.
    ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS 11:37 a.m.

    MINISTRY OF SANITATION AND 11:37 a.m.

    WATER RESOURCES 11:37 a.m.

    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Hon Member for
    Nadowli/Kaleo, do you have any
    supplementary question?
    Mr Sumah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like
    to ask the Hon Minister when she is
    expecting the feasibility report from the
    Community Water and Sanitation Agency
    to enable her to source the funding.
    Ms Dapaah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, respectfully,
    the feasibility report would be presented
    when it is finished, but I cannot give a time
    frame. However, I know they are working
    on it.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Yes, Hon Member, any
    further supplementary question?
    Mr Sumah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, yes. In the
    response of the Hon Minister, she cited
    population growth as one of the reasons
    they currently have to do a feasibility study
    to address the problem, but besides the
    population growth, there are some
    communities such as Lonkoro, Tenpieni,
    Gongomuni, Vaaripur, and Bangu, where
    the topography is not good, so attempts to
    provide water through boreholes have not
    been successful. Does the Ministry have
    any plans?
    Ms Dapaah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the towns
    listed have not been included in the
    Question, but I would assume, and rightly
    so, that with the construction of the Small
    Town Pipe Water System, we can serve
    more people, so I would kindly ask the Hon
    Member to give us the list so that we could
    pipe these towns as well.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Actually, those areas are
    not new townships or communities; they
    are just part of the community called
    Sankana. They are sections of Sankana, but
    they are located on a rocky area and you
    know that has been my constituency for
    many years, so I know that place very well.

    Oral Answers to Questions

    Yes, but the boreholes provided for the

    community are 12 and not eight; if eight

    are functioning, then it means four have

    broken down and they need to work on

    them.

    Yes, Hon Member for Nadowli/Kaleo,

    any further supplementary question?
    Mr Sumah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, no, please.
    With further elaboration from you, I am
    done.
    Thank you.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Yes, so Hon Minister
    for Sanitation and Water Resources, get the
    Community Water and Sanitation Agency,
    and the Hon Member would also support to
    make the other four boreholes functional,
    while we pursue the Small-Town Pipe
    Water Project for the community.
    They have a very large dam that has a
    huge catchment of water that could be used
    for that purpose, so Hon Minister for
    Sanitation and Water Resources, kindly
    follow it up.
    Hon Members, because this is a
    constituency-specific Question, we would
    move on to the next Question, that is the
    Question numbered 425, which stands in
    the name of the Hon Member for Yilo
    Korobo, Mr Albert Tetteh Nyakotey.
    Hon Member, you may ask your
    Question now.
    Mr Albert Tetteh Nyakotey (NDC - Yilo Krobo) 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Hon Minister for —
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    I am sorry, Hon
    Member. Please, it is not your turn; it is the
    turn of Mr Eric Afful, the Hon Member for
    Amenfi West, which is the Question
    numbered 361.
    Yes, Hon Member for Amenfi West?
    Connecting Wassa Dunkwa, Asankran-
    Moseaso et cetera, to the Community
    Water Programme
    Mr Eric Afful (NDC — Amenfi West) 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Hon
    Minister for Sanitation and Water
    Resources when the following commu-
    nities in the Amenfi West Constituency
    would be connected to the Community
    Water Programme under the Ministry: (i)
    Wassa Dunkwa (ii) Asankran-Moseaso
    (iii) Asankran-Kwabeng (iv) Oda Kotuamso
    (v) Mumuni (vi) Prestea Nkwanta.
    Ms Dapaah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, most of the
    above-mentioned communities in the
    Amenfi West Constituency: Wassa
    Dunkwa, Asankran-Moseaso, Asankran-
    Kwabeng, Oda Kotuamso and Mumuni are
    provided with boreholes for the supply of
    potable water. It is only Prestea Nkwanta
    which is yet to be provided with borehole
    facilities.

    Oral Answers to Questions

    Mr Speaker, in recognition of popular- tion growth and its effects on the water systems in these communities, the Ministry of Sanitation and Water Resources, through the Community Water and Sanitation Agency, is considering sourcing for funding for the rehabilitation of the borehole facilities, and construction of a Small Town Water System with the boreholes serving as the source of water.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Hon Member for Amenfi
    West, any supplementary question?
    Mr Afful 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, yes.
    Mr Speaker, if I may quote the second
    paragraph of the Hon Minister for Sanitation and Water Resources' response,
    “… in recognition of population growth and its effects on the water systems in these communities, the Ministry of Sanitation and Water Resources, through the Community Water and Sanitation Agency, is considering sourcing for funding for the rehabilitation of the bore- holes facilities, and construction of a Small Town Water System with the boreholes serving as the source of water.”
    Mr Speaker, the emphasis is on
    “considering”. I would like the Hon Minister for Sanitation and Water Resources to assure me if the Ministry would consider this project in the 2023 Budget Statement of the Ministry and for that matter the Government.
    What I am saying is that —
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Is your question
    whether the Hon Minister for Sanitation and Water Resources could assure you that she would consider?
    Mr Afful 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, exactly.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    All right.
    Ms Dapaah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, we would
    surely consider that.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    The answer is, “we
    Mr Afful 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would like to
    thank her for assuring the House and the people of Amenfi West that these four or five communities would be considered in the Budget Statement for 2023.
    Mr Speaker 11:47 p.m.
    Hon Minister for

    Now, Hon Member for Yilo Krobo, it

    is your turn.

    Measures to Curb the Perennial Water Crisis in Yilo Krobo

    Mr Albert Tetteh Nyakotey (NDC

    — Yilo Krobo): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Hon Minister for Sanitation and Water Resources what measures the Ministry is putting in place to curb the perennial water crisis in the Yilo Krobo Constituency.

    Oral Answers to Questions
    Ms Dapaah 11:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the supply
    of potable water in the Yilo Krobo
    Municipality is provided by both the
    Community Water and Sanitation Agency
    (CWSA) and the Ghana Water Company
    Limited (GWCL). The communities are
    mainly served by a point source scheme
    which is managed on the basis of a
    community ownership structure.
    Mr Speaker, currently, the GWCL is
    undertaking water supply expansion works
    to connect Huhunya to Boti, Agogo,
    Opesika, Sutapon, Akpo, Akpamu and the
    surrounding communities. Although, the
    project suffered a major setback when
    some aggrieved residents burnt and destroyed
    the pipelines within the constituency, the
    GWCL has expedited action in replacing
    the damaged pipelines and has laid 3.7km
    of 110mm HDPE pipelines and 8km of
    160mm HDPE pipelines as distribution
    lines to serve the above listed communities.
    Furthermore, interconnections are also
    underway on the existing transmission
    mains serving Koforidua from the booster
    station at Kwasidiaka. It is expected that
    the works will be completed by the second
    quarter of the year 2023.
    Mr Speaker, when all these interven-
    tions are completed, the Yilo Krobo
    Municipality will see marked improvement
    in water supply.
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Member for
    Yilo Krobo, any further supplementary question?
    Mr Nyakotey 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I have a further question, but before I ask my question, if you would permit me, I would plead with the Hon Minister to kindly withdraw a statement in her response that ‘aggrieved residents burned and destroyed pipelines'. This is false and follows the usual narrative —
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Hon Member, please,
    supplementary question.
    Mr Nyakotey 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, could the
    Hon Minister tell us when the 3.7 km pipeline was constructed and in which communities?
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    When and which
    communities?
    Ms Dapaah 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, if I heard
    the Hon Member right, he is asking where the 3.7 km pipeline is.
    Mr Nyakotey 11:57 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Minister.
    Ms Dapaah 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I cannot
    give the exact location as I stand here. I would get the answer to the Hon Member when I get to the office.
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Yes, any further
    supplementary?

    Oral Answers to Questions
    Mr Nyakotey 11:57 a.m.
    Hon Minister, I again asked when the 3.7km pipeline was constructed. I am, however, grateful for your response and I pray that you come back to the House. I wish to add, however, that not a metre of pipeline has been added to the previous Government Dawhenya, Oti, Bosomtwi, Agogo, Opesika, Nsutakpong, Akwamu Pipeline Project after the current Government took over the governance in
    2017.
    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Yes, Hon Minister?
    Ms Dapaah 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, according
    to my Answer, I would want to humbly suggest to the Hon Member to get to the second paragraph.
    These pipelines were destroyed by the
    aggrieved residents and these are being replaced. So, that is what I know and that is what I have been given by Ghana Water Company Limited and I do not doubt the authenticity of the report.
    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Mr Nyakotey 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, this is all
    for now.
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    We would move on to
    Question numbered 760, which stands in the name of the Hon Member for Krachi West, Ms Helen Adjoa Ntoso.
    Hon Member, you may ask the
    Question now.
    Plans to Tap Water from the Volta
    Lake for Residents of Krachi West
    Ms Helen Adjoa Ntoso (NDC — Krachi West) 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask
    the Minister for Sanitation and Water
    Resources whether the Ministry has any
    plans to tap water from the Volta Lake to
    give the people of Krachi West regular
    flow of water.
    Ms Dapaah 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, the Krachi
    West Municipality during the resettlement
    period benefited from boreholes fitted with
    motorised pumps that supplied water to
    reinforced concrete ground tanks with a
    total storage capacity of about 460m3. The
    water system became dysfunctional and in
    2003, the Government of Ghana (GoG)
    together with GTZ/KfW intervened
    through the Eastern and Volta Region
    Assistance Project (EVORAP) providing
    some boreholes which were mechanised to
    deliver water into a 12m high elevated
    180m3 reinforced concrete reservoir.
    Mr Speaker, to improve potable water
    delivery in the Municipality, the
    Community Water and Sanitation Agency
    carried out an assessment on the water
    system in March 2018. Taking into
    consideration the extent of deterioration
    and the water supply challenges to the large
    population, the CWSA intervened in
    March 2019 and undertook rehabilitation
    works to the tune of about GH₵330,000.00 to improve water delivery. Currently, the

    Oral Answers to Questions

    water system supplies potable water at 29

    standpipes and 642 private connections.

    Mr Speaker, taking into consideration

    the safe yields of the boreholes and the

    capacity of the installed pumps, the water

    system can daily produce 582.4 m3/day of

    safe water. This total daily production has

    the ability to meet the daily water demand

    of the Kete Krachi community at the

    present estimated demand of 554.92

    m3/day. The challenge, however, is the

    incessant power supply interruption from

    Northern Electricity Distribution Company

    (NEDCo).

    Mr Speaker, the Community Water

    and Sanitation Agency (CWSA) is in

    discussion with a number of agencies

    including the Grundfos Ghana Limited, to

    develop a Public Private Partnership

    Agreement for the development of a

    surface water supply system drawing raw

    water from the Volta Lake. In the long

    term, the Kete Krachi Municipality and its

    environs would be supplied with potable

    water from the Volta Lake.
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Hon Member, any
    supplementary question?
    Ms Ntoso 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am surprised
    and my people would be equally surprised
    that an amount of GH₵330,000 has been used to improve the water delivery in
    Krachi. I would like the Hon Minister to
    know that a stakeholders meeting was held
    in 2019 and the CWSA promised to return
    to work on the water system and has not
    returned.
    That is why my people are suffering
    from irregular flow of water, so I just want
    the Hon Minister to take notice of this and
    investigate whether they have really
    worked on the water system in my
    constituency. So, the next question as a
    follow up and also to let the Hon Minister
    know that the water table has really
    dropped. Krachi West is almost peninsula.
    I would want to —
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Hon Member, it is
    because of your seniority that I have just
    given you some leeway, but you are now
    abusing that grace. By rules, you are not
    supposed to make this long commentary
    before asking supplementary question, but
    I just gave you the opportunity to seek
    some clarification. Now, ask the
    supplementary question.
    Ms Ntoso 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, what I am
    saying is that the water table has dropped
    and water is not flowing. The Hon Minister
    is saying that they have worked on the
    system. They have not worked on the
    system and she is saying that the CWSA —
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Hon Member, Standing
    Order 68 (5)(6) do not permit what you are
    doing. So, please, ask your supplementary
    question.
    Ms Ntoso 11:57 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, my next
    question is water is not flowing in my

    Oral Answers to Questions

    Constituency — [Laughter] — Would the Hon Minister consider drilling mechanised

    boreholes for my people because water is

    not flowing in Krachi West?
    Mr Speaker 11:57 a.m.
    Hon Minister, do you
    see how passionate the Hon Member is?
    Would you consider drilling mechanised
    boreholes?
    Ms Daapah 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, with your
    indulgence, the reason for the interruptions
    in water supply is the incessant interruption
    in power supply.
    Mr Speaker, again, it is Community
    Water and Sanitation Agency (CWSA) not
    Ghana Water and Sanitation Agency. It is
    CWSA, which is in charge of that project.
    As I speak, the Chief Executive Officer
    (CEO) is in the room. I have asked my Hon
    Deputy Minister to find out on the spot, and
    he said the contractors are even still not on
    site. Therefore, I would humbly suggest
    that from here, I would have a tripartite
    meeting with the Hon Member and the
    CEO.
    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    Yes, thank you, Hon
    Minister. That is the way to go. The Hon
    Member should get in touch with the Hon
    Minister so that they meet the CWSA to
    discuss this thoroughly to know what the
    facts are. There is some misunderstanding
    as to what is really happening on the
    ground. You cannot fight this on the floor
    of the House. You have to go to the ground
    to really find out what the people are
    experiencing and what CWSA is doing on
    the ground. However, if you have any
    further supplementary question, you are at
    liberty to ask.
    Hon Member, any further supple-
    mentary question?
    Ms Ntoso 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am not
    aware that this is happening in my
    constituency, so I would liaise with her. I
    want an assurance from her that the
    pump would be worked on. If it is not
    working, —
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    You would go to the
    ground with her so that the people there
    would talk.
    Ms Ntoso 12:07 p.m.
    Yes, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    Yes, take the Hon
    Minister and then the CWSA to the ground
    so that they get the feel that you are getting.
    Ms Ntoso 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, they are not
    on the grounds so I would make a follow
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    Thank you.
    Hon Members, we would move on to
    the Question numbered 832, which stands
    in the name of the Hon Member for

    Oral Answers to Questions

    Kumbungu, Dr Hamza Adam. Hon Member,

    you may now ask your Question.

    Completion of Toilet Facilities under

    Special Initiatives in Communities

    in Kumbungu
    Dr Hamza Adam (NDC — Kumbungu) 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Minister for Sanitation and Water
    Resources when the toilet facilities under
    the special initiatives in the following
    communities would be completed: (i)
    Zangbalun (ii) Kumbungu (iii) Vogu (iv)
    Cheshegu and (v) Zugu.
    Ms Dapaah 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I respect-
    fully wish to indicate that the toilet
    facilities being implemented under the
    special initiatives in Zangbalun, Kumbungu,
    Vogu, Cheshegu and Zugu were under the
    ambit of the erstwhile Ministry of Special
    Development Initiatives, whose work is
    now being handled by the Special
    Development Initiatives Secretariat, Office
    of the President, for attention.
    Dr H. Adam 12:07 p.m.
    Thank you very much,
    Hon Minister for your response. May I
    know from you, which Ministry now
    oversees the Special Development Initia-
    tives Secretariat so that I can redirect my
    Question to the appropriate Ministry?
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    It is the Office of the
    President that oversees it. It is in the
    Answer. Hon Minister, I could see it in the
    Answer; you said the Office of the
    President.
    Dr H. Adam 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank you
    very much for the opportunity to ask the
    Question.
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    Hon Members, we
    would move to Question numbered 1031.
    The Second Deputy Speaker would be
    taking the Chair soon. That Question
    stands in the name of the Hon Member for
    Kwesimintsim, Dr Prince Hamidu Armah.
    Hon Member, you may ask your Question.
    Mr Vincent Ekow Assafuah 12:07 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, I am most grateful. With your
    leave, I have the authority of Dr Prince
    Hamidu Armah to ask this Question on his
    behalf.
    Mr Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    All right. I have granted
    you leave. You may ask your Question.
    State and Quality of Water Reserves
    in the Country
    Mr Vincent Ekow Assafuah (on
    behalf of Dr Prince Hamidu Armah)
    (NPP — Kwesimintsim): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister for Sanitation and
    Water Resources the state and quality of
    our water reserves in the country.
    Ms Dapaah 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, water reserves involve both the quantity (availability) and quality (health). In terms of quantity, the country is sufficiently

    Oral Answers to Questions

    endowed with both surface and ground- water resources. The total actual renewable freshwater resources (that is surface water) is estimated to be 53.2 billion cubic m3 per year, of which about 14 per cent is withdrawn and used annually. Out of the 14 per cent used, irrigation takes 68 per cent, domestic water supply uses 20 per cent, industrial purposes (including mining) use 10 per cent, and other uses take 2 per cent.

    Mr Speaker, however, the amount of water available changes markedly from season to season. The distribution within the country is also not uniform, with the south-western part (rain forest zone) being better watered than the coastal and northern regions (savannah zones).

    Mr Speaker, in addition to the surface water resources, groundwater is also available and occurs according to the local geology. About 5 per cent of the urban water supply and 95 per cent of the rural water supply are sourced from ground- water. There has been a proliferation of groundwater for household and small to large scale commercial bottled water companies. However, initial assessment of groundwater recharge and development suggests that it would be sustainable at least in the foreseeable future.

    Mr Speaker, in terms of quality (health), the water resources are generally not in a healthy state, but the extent of deterioration varies according to the river system and river basin. —

    12.15 p.m. —
    MR SECOND DEPUTY SPEAKER
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, we shall move to Question
    numbered 1052, which stands in the name
    of the Hon Member for Zabazugu, Mr
    Jabaah John Bennam.
    Mr Habib Iddrisu 12:07 p.m.
    — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:07 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, are you the Hon Member for
    Zabzugu?
    Mr H. Iddrisu 12:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am not
    but with your leave, I would like to ask the
    Question for the Hon Member. I have his
    permission to do so.

    Oral Answers to Questions
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    All
    right.
    Plans to Provide Small Town Water
    Systems to Nakpali, Kukpaligu, et
    cetera Communities
    Mr Habib Iddrisu (on behalf of Mr
    Jabaah John Bennam) (NPP — Zabzugu): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Minister for Sanitation and Water
    Resources what plans are in place to
    provide small town water systems to the
    following fast developing communities
    and when those plans will materialise: (i)
    Nakpali, (ii) Kukpaligu (iii) Kuntumbiyile
    (iv) Woribugu.
    Ms Dapaah 12:16 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, Nakpali,
    Kukpaligu, Kuntumbiyile, and Woribogu
    have each been provided with a number of
    boreholes fitted with hand pump, whilst
    Nakpali and Kukpaligu, in addition, have
    piped water systems. However, due to
    heavy usage as a result of population
    increase, and lack of appropriate mainte-
    nance, most of the boreholes and water
    systems have broken down.
    Mr Speaker, to address potable water
    supply in these communities, in the
    interim, the Community Water and
    Sanitation Agency (CWSA), through the
    Zabzugu District Assembly, will assist the
    communities to repair the seven (7) hand
    pumps that are broken down.
    Furthermore, the Ministry of Sanita-
    tion and Water Resources, as part of the
    Government's ‘Water for All' agenda, is working with CWSA on a number of
    projects to upgrade water supply facilities
    across the country under the policy
    reforms, and these four (4) communities
    would be catered for.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    We
    would move to Question numbered 1054,
    which stands in the name of the Hon
    Member for Ablekuma North, Ms Sheila
    Bartels.
    Contribution of ‘Galamsey' to Deterioration of Water Bodies
    Ms Sheila Bartels (NPP — Ablekuma North) 12:16 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the
    Minister for Sanitation and Water Resources
    the extent to which illegal mining (galamsey)
    is contributing to the deterioration of our
    water bodies.
    Ms Dapaah 12:16 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, illegal
    mining, galamsey, increases the turbidity
    and colourisation of water bodies.
    Turbidity is a measure of the degree to
    which the water loses its transparency due
    to the presence of suspended particles. The
    more total suspended solids in the water,
    the murkier (dirtier) it seems, and the
    higher the turbidity. The acceptable
    turbidity value for drinking water is 5
    Nephelometric Turbidity Unit (NTU),

    Oral Answers to Questions

    while values of 80-150 NTU are acceptable

    for other water uses as appropriate.

    Mr Speaker, at the end of February

    2022, the average turbidity (NTU) of the

    Southwestern River System, which is the

    main illegal mining area in the country,

    was 1,313; the Volta River System was 40;

    and the Coastal River System was 105.

    In terms of coverage, the Volta River

    System drains 70 per cent of the country;

    the Southwestern takes 22 per cent; and the

    Coastal System takes 8 per cent. Therefore,

    illegal mining is pronounced, and it affects

    about 22 per cent of our surface water

    resources with contaminants and pollutants

    such as mercury, et cetera.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    Hon
    Member for Ablekuma North, do you have
    any supplementary questions?
    Mr Alexander Afenyo-Markin 12:16 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, with respect, I have a little
    application to make —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    Hon
    Leader, I would come to you. I would like
    to finish with that Question, then I will
    come to you.
    Ms Bartels, do you have any
    supplementary questions?
    Ms Bartels 12:16 p.m.
    Yes, Mr Speaker. I would
    want to find out from the Hon Minister
    what the Ministry is doing to curb illegal
    mining?
    Ms Dapaah 12:16 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I must
    humbly say that the fight against illegal
    mining is a national war. It is not only the
    Ministry that is fighting it. It is a war that
    has been declared across the country.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    Thank
    you very much. Hon Leader, let me hear
    you now.
    Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:16 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with your leave, we have agreed to vary the
    order of Business, and proceed to item

    Mr Speaker, there has been some

    miscommunication, and it has been

    corrected. We would proceed to finish with

    the Hon Minister. She has somewhere to

    go, so we would agree that she finishes and

    leaves.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    Very well.
    Let us move to Question numbered
    1056, which stands in the name of the Hon
    Member for Bortianor-Ngleshie Amanfro,
    Mr Sylvester Tetteh.
    Mr Vincent Ekow Assafuah — rose —

    Oral Answers to Questions
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, are you standing in for him? All
    right. Let us hear you.
    Efficiency of the Teshie Desalination
    Treatment Plant
    Mr Vincent Ekow Assafuah (on
    behalf of Mr Sylvester Tetteh) (NPP — Bortianor-Ngleshie Amanfro): Mr Speaker,
    I beg to ask the Minister for Sanitation and
    Water Resources how efficient the Teshie
    Desalination Treatment Plant is and the
    extent of its contribution to the supply of
    water to residents of Teshie and its
    environs.
    Ms Dapaah 12:16 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, in 2011, as
    part of measures to ameliorate water
    supply challenges within the Teshie-
    Nungua enclave, which is situated at the
    terminal ends of the Kpong and Weija
    water supply production systems, the con-
    struction of a Sea Water Reverse Osmosis
    (SWRO) desalination plant under a public
    private partnership arrangement (Build
    Own Operate Transfer) was considered by
    GWCL. The proposal was to design and
    develop a 60,000m3 (13.2 million gallons
    per day) capacity desalination plant for an
    estimated population size of half a million
    people in the Teshie-Nungua area.
    Mr Speaker, in 2019, after the completion of the 450mm High Density Polythene (HDPE) pipeline to uptake the total volume of treated water from the
    plant, GWCL requested for the full complement of the contracted capacity of the desalination plant (60,000m3/day) —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:16 p.m.
    Hon Minister, hold on. Hon Members, it appears that nobody is listening to the Hon Minister. I have been looking around. Please, let us be attentive to the Hon Minister. That is why we have brought her here.
    Hon Minister, you may go on.
    Ms Dapaah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, out of the total contracted capacity of 20,999,910m3 (4,620MGD) in 2019, the plant was able to supply 8,311,516m3 (1,829MGD) repre- senting 41 per cent supply efficiency. In 2020, out of the total contracted capacity of 21,057,444m3 (4,633MGD) the plant was able to supply 12,113,558m3 (2,665MGD) representing 59 per cent supply efficiency.

    In 2021, out of the total contracted capacity of 20,999,910m3 (4,620MGD), the plant was able to supply 16,719,226m3 (3,679MGD) representing 80 per cent supply efficiency. The shortfalls in volume supplied were mainly as a result of:

    • Breakdown of raw water trans- mission pipeline (in 2019);

    • Poor sea water quality (i.e. high

    temperature and total suspended solids);

    Oral Answers to Questions

    • GWCL network high pressures;

    • Ultra-filtration challenges;

    • Frequent fouling of Reverse Osmosis (RO) racks;

    • Breakdown of self-cleaning filters;

    • Low tide; and

    • Internal and external power challenges.

    Mr Speaker, from 1st January, 2022, to

    31st March, 2022, representing the first

    quarter, out of the expected total contracted

    capacity of 5,514,000m3 (1213.2 MGD),

    the desalination plant has supplied

    2,156,907 m3 (474.6 MGD) of treated

    water to GWCL network representing 39

    per cent supply efficiency for the period.

    Two out of four of the RO filter membrane

    racks are currently inefficient, and directly

    accounting for the decline in the expected

    output of the plant as reported by the plant

    operator.

    With the current happenings, GWCL

    has been unable to provide the required quality of service to the people of Teshie

    and its environs. To forestall this, the Ministries of Sanitation and Water Resources, Finance, Justice and Attorney-

    General's Department and GWCL are currently involved in the restructuring of the Water Purchase Agreement (WPA)

    governing the project, and the engagement

    of a new investor promoted by the plant operator.

    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Mr Assafuah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I would
    want to find out from the Hon Minister when the restructuring is supposed to take place.
    Ms Dapaah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the meetings are ongoing so, I believe that with these
    challenges, they would be expedited.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:27 p.m.
    We
    now move to Question numbered 1058, which stands in the name of the Hon Member for Manyia North, Mr Akwasi
    Konadu.
    Utilisation of Sanitation and Pollution
    Levy Funds
    Mr Akwasi Konadu (NPP — Manhyia
    North): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister for Sanitation and Water Resources how much the Ministry has
    received from the Sanitation and Pollution Levy, and how those funds are being utilised to tackle sanitation issues in the
    country.
    Ms Dapaah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the Ministry
    of Finance is responsible for the receipt of the Sanitation and Pollution Levy (SPL). We have not had notice of the accrued
    amount yet, but we at the Ministry of Sanitation and Water Resources have

    Oral Answers to Questions

    proposed plans to utilise our portion of the

    SPL funds across the country in the following areas:

    • Solid waste management infra- structure and services;

    • Liquid waste management and services; and

    • Public sensitisation, law enforce- ment, monitoring and evaluation.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:27 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, any follow-up question?
    Mr Konadu 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, no, thank
    you.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:27 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Deputy Minority Leader (Mr James
    Klutse Avedzi): Mr Speaker, I have a
    follow-up question. The Hon Minister says
    that the Ministry of Finance has not
    notified the Ministry of Sanitation and
    Water Resources, yet the Ministry has
    planned to use the fund on solid waste
    management infrastructure and services. If
    they do not know how much they have,
    then how do they plan to utilise the fund?
    Ms Dapaah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, what I did
    say was that we have these plans to be
    executed, and we would liaise with the
    Ministry of Finance to use part of our
    portion of the funds for those structures.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:27 p.m.
    We
    now move to Question numbered *1237,
    which stands in the name of the Hon
    Member for Techiman South, Mr Martin
    Kwaku Adjei-Mensah Korsah. Hon
    Member, you have the Floor now.
    State and Scope of Techiman Water
    Supply Rehabilitation and Expansion
    Project
    Mr Martin Kwaku Adjei-Mensah
    Korsah (NPP — Techniman South): Mr Speaker, I beg to ask the Minister for
    Sanitation and Water Resources the state
    and scope of the Techiman Water Supply
    Rehabilitation and Expansion Project
    under the Korean Economic Development
    Cooperation Fund (EDCF) Loan.
    Ms Dapaah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, the existing
    water supply system in Techiman, with an
    installed capacity of 4,500m3 per day (1
    MGD) was inaugurated in 1997. The water
    system, over the years, has not been
    rehabilitated and expanded to meet the
    ever-increasing water demand of the area.
    Mr Speaker, as a result of this growth
    in population, as well as economic growth
    in the Techiman Municipality, it became
    necessary to expand the existing water
    supply system to meet the current and
    future water demand of Techiman and
    some identified beneficiary towns.
    Government secured a concessional
    loan of US$100 million from the Korean

    Oral Answers to Questions

    Exim Bank to finance the project

    scheduled to be completed within 36

    months after commencement.

    Mr Speaker, the scope of the project

    includes inter-alia:

    1. Rehabilitation of the existing raw water intake and water

    treatment plant 4,500 m3 per

    day, (1 MGD).

    2. Construction of a weir with a capacity of 550,000 m3 on the

    Tano River.

    3. Construction of a new intake and water treatment plant with a

    capacity of 17,000m3 per day

    (3.8 MGD).

    4. Transmission pipelines with a total length of 25km.

    5. Distribution pipelines with a total length of 147km.

    6. There would be a booster pumping station.

    7. Service pipelines complete with meters.

    8. Public standpipes.

    Mr Speaker, the current status of the

    project, as I speak, is that:

    • Parliament graciously granted approval for the loan agreement

    on 5th November, 2020.

    • The loan agreement was signed on 17th December, 2020.

    • Request for proposal for the consultant for the design and

    construction supervision was

    issued out to shortlisted firms

    for submission by 12th February,

    2021.

    • Evaluation of the technical proposals for the shortlisted

    firms have been completed and

    “No Objection” has been granted by the Korean Exim

    Bank.

    • Opening of the financial proposal of the firm that won the

    technical proposal has been

    completed.

    • Contract award being processed for the consultant to move to site

    to undertake detailed feasibility

    study and design work.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:27 p.m.
    Mr
    Korsah, any supplementary questions?
    Mr Korsah 12:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, that would
    be all from me.

    Oral Answers to Questions
    Mrs Elizabeth Ofosu-Adjare 12:37 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, thank you for the opportunity. I beg to further ask the Hon Minister what date the project would start in earnest. This is because in her Answer, she stated that, and with your kind permission, I beg to quote:
    “…Korean Exim Bank to finance the project, scheduled to be completed within 36 months after commencement.”
    So I would want to find out when the
    project would commence.
    Ms Dapaah 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, commen-
    cement is when the feasibility studies have been done and finished and the site designs have been completed.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:37 p.m.
    Hon
    Minister, on behalf of the House, we thank you for attending upon the House to answer 11 separate Questions. We are grateful.
    You are hereby discharged.
    Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with your leave, we may now proceed to item numbered 21, Motions. [Interruption] — It is so, because we have agreed to seek your leave to proceed with item numbered 21, if it pleases you.
    Alhaji Muntaka 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, yes, it
    was discussed. Since it is just one item, we would go back to Statements later.
    Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, as
    usual, you control this House from the east
    so we would take your leave once again,
    that the Hon Minister is unavoidably
    absent, but one of his abled Hon Deputies,
    who happens to be an Hon Member of this
    House, is present to take the duty in the

    Mr Speaker, since I returned on

    Friday, the Hon Minority Chief Whip,

    Alhaji Muntaka and I have been good

    friends so he should not greet me with — I have made this small application that the

    Hon Minister is unavoidably absent, but his

    Hon Deputy, who is one of us, is in the

    House. I beg of him.

    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Alhaji Muntaka 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, yes,
    the Hon Deputy Minister is one of our Hon
    Colleagues, and there is no doubt about his
    capability to do this. However, Hon
    Ministers cannot relegate the Business of
    this House to their Hon Deputies and then
    come to ask that the Business of the House
    be varied. The Hon Minister should have
    been here himself. I hope he is not busy out
    there campaigning to the detriment of his
    duty in Parliament.
    Mr Speaker, the Hon Deputy Minister
    for Trade and Industry, Mr Michael Okyere
    Baafi is an Hon Colleague and there is no
    doubt that he is capable of doing this so we
    would grant him — We hope that the Hon Minister would find time to be in the House

    to attend to the business of his Ministry instead of sending his Hon Deputies.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:37 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, page 17 item numbered 21 — Motions. Yes, Hon Deputy Minister for Trade and Industry?
    BILLS — THIRD READING
    Ghana Standards Authority Bill, 2022
    The Ghana Standards Authority Bill,
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:37 p.m.
    Yes,
    Leadership?
    Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, on
    behalf of the Hon Majority Leader, we thank the Committee for its industry and we hope that the urgency would be fortified in the discharge of its duties to help the economy.
    Mr Speaker, we are thankful to you
    and the House, especially the technical team; the Clerks-at-the-Table.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:37 p.m.
    Hon
    Deputy Majority Leader, could we go to item numbered 7?
    Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:37 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, at
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:37 p.m.
    Hon
    Deputy Majority Leader, I know you would pray for the order of Business to be
    varied. If that is so, we could take item numbered 7 and come back to Statements later.
    Hon Majority Leader, I do not know if
    PAPERS 12:37 p.m.

    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:37 p.m.
    Shall we
    take the 7 (b)?
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 12:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with respect, if I may present the Paper on behalf of the Hon Minister for Finance, that is item numbered 7(b).
    By the Minister for Parliamentary
    Affairs (Mr Osei Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu) (on behalf of the Minister for Finance) -
    Request for waiver of Import Duties, Import VAT, GETFund Levy, NHIL, EXIM Levy, Special Import Levy, COVID-19 Levy and Domestic VAT amounting to the Ghana Cedi equi- valent of four million, six hundred and fifty-six thousand, two hundred and seventy-two euros and ninety cents (€4,656,272.90 [made up of €3,770,234.00 on imports and €886,038.90 on local purchases]) on materials, equipment and services/works to be procured for the construction and equipping of the Shama District Hospital in the Western Region by Messrs Poly Changda Overseas Engineering Company Limited of China.
    Referred to the Finance Committee.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:47 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Deputy Minority Leader?
    Mr Avedzi 12:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, this is a
    finance-related issue and last week, the Rt Hon Speaker gave a directive that the Finance Committee should not handle any finance-related issues until the Hon Minister for Finance appears in the Chamber to respond to outstanding issues.
    I would like to remind you that this is
    also a referral to the Finance Committee so, if you could give same directive so that the Committee does not go to work and report on it.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:47 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Yes, Hon Majority Leader?
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 12:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    was going to plead that we ask the Leadership of the Committee on Health to join in the consideration of the matter that has been referred to the Finance Committee.
    Mr Speaker, tomorrow is Wednesday
    and we said that after the referral, the Committee would have to wait until the Hon Minister for Finance comes with the Statements as well as to answer the Questions that are outstanding. It is just tomorrow, so once he finishes, the way would be paved for that.
    However, I want us to be straight with
    ourselves that it was a decision of the

    House, not the Rt Hon Speaker's. The Rt Hon Speaker only encapsulated the sentiments of the House because in truth, a Speaker cannot say that a Committee cannot do a particular thing. It was a collective sentiment of the House that the Rt Hon Speaker represented. This is because technically, the Rt Hon Speaker cannot direct that he would not allow a Committee to work on any referral. That is unacceptable.

    However, I would want to believe that
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:47 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Shall we go back to Statements?
    Yes, Hon Majority Leader?
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 12:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    there is a major matter that we should be dealing with but you had given an indication to the Hon Member for Bia East, Mr Acheampong to make his Statement. So, we may have to stand down the consideration of the item listed as 14, so we could listen to the Statement from, the Hon Member for Bia East, Mr Acheampong and two other Hon Members.
    Mr Speaker, you would have to
    manage the time so that you do not have too many contributions to their Statements by our Hon Colleagues. Then we can move
    on to item numbered 14, once we are through with the Statement.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:47 p.m.
    Very
    Well.
    Yes, Hon Member for Bia East, Mr
    Acheampong, let us listen to you.
    STATEMENTS 12:47 p.m.

    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:47 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, hold on for a moment.
    Hon Deputy Majority Leader?
    Mr Afenyo-Markin 12:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    am on my feet as a matter of procedure because my Hon Colleague before proceeding had invoked procedure.
    Mr Speaker, a Statement that has been
    considered as admissible cannot be preceded with some other letter which was not part of the Statement which was admitted. In any event, even if it was so done, it was for the purpose of backing the application for admissibility.
    Mr Speaker, it has never been - let us
    take it easy. Else, we would set a bad precedent that would haunt us one day. It has never been part of the jurisprudence of this House that when a Statement is admitted and an Hon Member is to read that Statement, he would move into another territory by saying that there is an accompanying fact, which fact he used to support his application must also be read with the sole aim of perhaps, attacking an individual's reputation. The person whose name he would want to mention is not even
    in the House and has no right of audience on this Floor and I go by the rule of the Hon Minority Chief Whip, Alhaji Muntaka.
    I am relying on the wisdom of the Hon
    Minority Chief Whip, in a certain ex-parte application I made regarding Joy FM. I was guided by his wisdom whereupon he said Joy FM may be wrong but I have another forum to deal with it and because Joy FM has no right of audience, I could not come, specifically, on issues regarding Joy FM.
    On the basis of that, it is my prayer that
    the Hon Colleague should just proceed to read his Statement and not go into some letters he spotted. Else, we may have to wait to get the person whose name would be mentioned to come to the House and have a right of audience. [Interruption] — It does not matter. We would respect procedure. There are senior lawyers in the House who know this. We know - the Order he quoted said “a Statement be read”. That is what Standing Order 72 says. No! Standing Order 72 that he quoted to rely on for what he is doing says that “a Statement on a matter of urgent public importance” that is why it has been admitted. The memorandum that he attached for Rt Hon Speaker to consider cannot be part of his submission. It cannot.
    Mr Speaker, let us not set a bad record
    that would haunt this House. Posterity is watching. We should not. [Interruption]— - the Hon Member for Bolgatanga East, Dr Ayine, is aware of this. We should not [Interruption] I am not afraid of anything but we should respect procedure. The Hon Minority Leader, has been guiding us with

    Statements

    matters of procedure, so, let us assist Mr Speaker [Interruption] — the Hon Minority Leader is unduly frustrating my submission.

    Mr Speaker, at the risk of being

    repetitive, it is my submission that the Hon Member can only read the Statement as admitted and nothing more.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:47 p.m.
    Yes, let
    me listen to the Hon Deputy Minority Leader.
    Mr Avedzi 12:57 p.m.
    The Hon Member is
    coming under Standing Order 72 and the Statement is of urgent public importance.
    Mr Speaker, the Hon Member is
    reading the letter to strengthen the point he is making but if you insist that he should not read the letter, we would advise the Hon Member to go by his Statement and make his point.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:57 p.m.
    Hon
    Member, just go ahead and read the Statement.
    Mr R. Acheampong 12:57 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    thank you very much. I do not know the fears of my Hon Colleagues and the lamentations that they sought to give this morning — This is because, I had wanted to give a background for the consumption of the House before reading the Statement without which, I would have been questioned about what my evidence was. However, if my Hon Colleagues are afraid
    of what the background is, I would go ahead and read the Statement so that they cannot come back to ask for any evidence whatsoever. Mr Speaker, therefore, I call on you to invite the Hon Minister responsible for Agriculture to explain to the good people of this country through Parliament, why Ghana Cocoa Board (COCOBOD) intends to take this very decision. My request hints on the fact that in Bia East alone, 1,700 hectares of cocoa farmlands are under the rehabilitation programme of which 1,800,000 plantain suckers are required before cocoa seedlings could be planted. As I speak, only 30,000 plantain suckers have been supplied and distributed to farmers which translates into about 1.7 per cent.
    In addition, COCOBOD owes the
    workers, that is “the weeding gang,” since April 2022. The question is that if Government, with all the financial muscle could not maintain these farms and pay “weeding gangs”, how can a private service provider carry this very burden? Mean- while, a provision was made in the 2021- 2022 Cocoa Syndicated Loan contracted to purchase cocoa beans.
    Mr Speaker, the question is 12:57 p.m.
    “Where is
    the money”? The Hon Minister must come and explain to us, because the workers, as well as the affected cocoa farmers, are going through hell.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker for the
    opportunity. — [Pause] —
    Alhaji Muntaka 12:57 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, this
    Statement is a very important one. These

    Statements

    are Statements that help this House to be proactive and not to wait until a complete mess has been created before crying over the wrongdoings that are happening.

    Mr Speaker, we know the structure of

    COCOBOD with all its extension services,

    the quality assurance, and all those

    groupings. If for any reason COCOBOD

    thinks that some components of the work

    of the extension services could be

    privatised because they are not able to pay

    promptly, then we all need to ask at what

    cost that would be to the State? What

    would be the mechanism for them to use to

    even ensure that the proper things are being

    done?

    Mr Speaker, I am a cocoa farmer,

    though an absentee one. Due to the

    challenges that the cocoa farmers and their

    managers experience across the country, it

    is not surprising that we have dwindling

    production levels. If we are not careful, and

    this lackadaisical attitude is entertained,

    what we are going to see is that so much

    money would be pumped into the system in

    the name of trying to improve production,

    and yet the outcome would be disastrous.

    I strongly believe that the Hon

    Minister has questions to answer and he

    must be encouraged to come before the

    House, even if it is going to be in a

    Committee of the Whole. It is better than

    not to ask and wait until the privatisation is

    done, whereby, at the end of the day,

    people would not carry out any services

    and yet take Government money.

    Mr Speaker, we are very much aware of many other things that are happening under this so-called attempt of trying to outsource these services to the private sector. The cocoa industry in our country is one of the main sustenance of our economy. If we just allow it to be treated the way they are planning to do, the consequences would be dire.

    Mr Speaker, it is important that we

    invite the Hon Minister to come before the House to explain the rationale and be able to convince us beyond reasonable doubt. If we sit and allow this to happen, and a year or two later, we all start crying that so much money has been paid to private people who have not done any work, we would have ourselves to blame. Without mentioning specific private companies that have been outsourced by Government, many of them, due to liquidity issues do not carry out the functions, but when the moneys are available, they present reports to indicate that they have done all the work over the period and claim the money, even when those works have not been properly done.

    The Ghana Cocoa Board has been in

    existence long before our independence and having worked in that sector, it is one institution that has a lot of structure that is capable of holding the cocoa industry to be more productive. This attitude of trying to outsource and give it out to private individuals could be a dangerous one.

    Mr Speaker, I would like to add my

    voice to that of the Hon Member who made the Statement that we would invite the Hon Minister for Agriculture to come before the

    Statements

    House to explain to us in much detail, the rationale behind this and why he thinks that this would be a better venture than the current arrangement.

    With this comment, I would like to

    commend my Hon Colleague for bringing

    the attention of the House to this very

    important issue. I now hope that once

    again, the House would not sit aloof but

    would act proactively to ensure that the

    right things are done.

    Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
    Mr John Jinapor 12:57 p.m.
    Thank you very

    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu — rose —
    Mr J. Jinapor 12:57 p.m.
    Leadership would
    normally wind up.
    An Hon Member 12:57 p.m.
    Are you the
    Speaker?
    Mr J. Jinapor 12:57 p.m.
    Mr Speaker called me.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:57 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    When I looked at this Side, I did not
    see you, that is why —
    An Hon Member 12:57 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank
    you very much, for this opportunity.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:57 p.m.
    Hon
    Majority Leader, once I have already called
    the Hon Member, let him finish. I did not
    see you, that is why I turned — Hon Majority Leader, let me give the Hon
    Member two minutes and I would come to
    you.
    An Hon Member 12:57 p.m.
    Thank you, Mr
    Speaker — [Interruption]. No, he called me.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:57 p.m.
    I would
    come to you. Hon Member, you may go on.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 12:57 p.m.
    Hon
    John Jinapor, let us arrange it this way. Let
    me go to Dr Stephen Amoah. I would come
    to you, then the Hon Majority Leader
    would conclude.
    Dr Stephen Amoah, let us hear you.
    Dr Stephen Amoah (NPP — Nhyiaeso) 1:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank you for this
    great opportunity. As much as I partially
    side with my Hon Brother from the other
    Side of the political divide, of course,
    cocoa plays a very critical role in the socio-
    economic development framework of this
    country, such that we need to give anything
    that would create a deficit in terms of our
    outlays to the key stakeholders, that is,
    farmers, et cetera the needed attention and
    concentration as a country.

    Statements

    However, if we try to politicise everything with cocoa farms, then some of us would let them have the historical record.

    I do not know whether you have ever

    Mr Speaker, this was a very common

    household name during the Administration of the National Democratic Congress (NDC). Even cocoa farmers who had weighed their cocoa and gone to the banks to take their monies were not paid under the regime of the NDC. What was the practice, culturally, was that the man (farmer) would tell his wife, “My wife, Akwasi is about to go school, yet we have not been paid for the cocoa we have produced. So, I am taking my cheque to a fellow Ghanaian (farmer) to find out if he or she could pay me...” Therefore, if the value of the cocoa was GHȻ 100.00, the farmer would then be paid GHȻ 80.00, and that is why the practice was referred to as, “Ghana-to-Ghana.”

    Mr Speaker, I make this point in order

    for our Hon Colleagues on the other Side to understand that when we talk about their inability to perform their obligation in the area of the cocoa sector, they do not have the moral right to complain the way they have done, except that we all agree that cocoa is an essential commodity that we need to give the needed attention.

    Moreover, any person who is abreast

    with what is happening in the world and in

    Ghana, understands the fact that we are

    experiencing quite a stressed fiscal space.

    Therefore, liquidity just like any other

    country in the world, is a big challenge.

    Hence in our attempt to solve some of

    these problems, let us do so in the right

    context, and do away with the politics.

    Mr Speaker, in the year 2014, some

    cocoa farmers had to sell their farms at a

    reduced price because the cocoa farms

    were taken over by Akate (Swollen Shoot

    Disease) because the NDC government just

    looked on for the fertilizers and pest

    control chemicals to be transported across

    our borders. My point is that even though

    it is true we have challenges today, our Hon

    Colleagues on the other Side should not

    behave as if they had a better or equal

    situation than it is now.

    Mr Speaker, let us compare the current

    real variables and the parametres of our

    fiscal space with what pertained under their

    Administration, and understand the outlier

    situation we find ourselves in. Even today,

    this Government is making the attempt to

    ensure that the global problem is being

    mitigated because of good governance

    which they could not do — If the NDC were in power today, the problems of cocoa

    farmers would have been quadrupled; they

    could not have done anything equal to what

    is happening. So, when they make comments,

    Statements

    they should present the right comparable

    parametres for us to understand the fact

    that, this is the time that we have a

    Government that understands the matrix of

    the factors that we are managing.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:07 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, Order!
    Mr John A. Jinapor (NDC — Yapei- Kusawgu) 1:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, first of all,
    Mr J. Jinapor 1:07 p.m.
    I would like to
    commend Mr Richard Acheampong who is
    an Hon Member of the Finance Committee
    for the indefatigable way he conducts
    research. When I read the document, I am
    convinced beyond reasonable doubt that he
    spent sleepless nights working on the

    Mr Speaker, I would like to correct an

    erroneous impression that is being created

    here. This is a House of records, and you

    always encourage us to speak with facts

    and evidence. I would like to refer you to

    the utilisation of the 2019-2020 facility: the

    first draw down of the African

    Development Bank (AfDB) loan, and the

    2020-2021 Syndicated loan presented to

    this House by the Finance Committee. I

    would like to refer to table 1 of page 2,

    which talks about the volume of cocoa

    production in Ghana. I say this because

    Hon Stephen Amoah, said that there was

    Akate, and production was so low that

    farmers had to cut down their cocoa trees

    and sell their farms. The production

    volumes are as follows: 2013-2014, the

    volume of cocoa production was 896,000

    metric tons. [Hear! Hear!] 2019-2020, we

    Mr Speaker, the year that Mr Stephen

    Amoah claimed that production was bad,

    we produced 896,000 metric tons.

    However, the year he said that they had

    done so well, they produced 756,000

    metric tons. I understand that he is a first-

    timer, and we need to walk him through the

    rudiments so I would not belabour the

    point; I would leave it at that. [Uproar].

    This is because when we make Statements,

    we do not want to generate debate, so I
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:07 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, please —
    Mr Carlos Ahenkorah 1:07 p.m.
    On a point of
    order.
    Mr Speaker, I think that my Hon
    Colleague on the other Side has been unfair
    to our Hon Colleague who just presented
    his opinion on the Statement that was
    presented.
    I think it is unfair to refer to him as a first-timer who needs to be hand-held and walked through the corridors of his contributions. It is true that he is a first-

    Statements
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:07 p.m.
    Hon Members, please let us listen to him, so that when you also rise, others would listen to you.
    Mr Ahenkorah 1:07 p.m.
    I hope that this unruly behaviour would be controlled. I think that my Hon Colleague has been unfair to Dr Stephen Amoah by referring to him as a first-timer. I hope that he would see the Hon Member as a well-educated person and knowledgeable in whatever he hears or discusses on the Floor. Therefore, by what he has said, he has tried to demean the Hon Member, and I would like him to withdraw and apologise. [Uproar]
    Alhaji Muntaka 1:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I do not know what my Hon Colleague wanted to achieve. These Standing Orders are our guide, and our hope was that he would quote the relevant Standing Orders to buttress the point that, if an Hon Member refers to another Hon Member in terms of tenures — For example, how does reference to the Hon Member for Suame, the Hon Majority Leader who is a seventh- timer; and Mr Afenyo-Markin who is a third-timer, offend our rules?
    Therefore, Hon Ahenkorah should show where in our Standing Orders this offends the rules. There is no reference to
    it as an offence, and we use these expressions to let each other appreciate how long or short we have stayed in this House. There is nothing wrong with it unless he can provide evidence that the Standing Orders frown on the reference to each other by the number of terms one has done. I think he should be ruled out of order so that my Hon Colleague could continue to make his contribution.
    Mr J.A. Jinapor 1:18 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, all I
    did was to set the records straight. If there
    is anybody that I have learnt from, in terms
    of experience, then it is the Hon Member
    for Suame (Mr Osei Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu),
    a seventh-timer who has proved that as one
    stays long in this House, one becomes
    wise, matured and one metamorphosises,
    gravitates, and graduates into the realm of

    Mr Speaker, on that note, it is

    important that we pay attention to these

    critical issues because the document I

    referred to, talks about the allocations.

    The document I was referring to, even

    talks of the allocation and if you look at the

    allocations, a whopping GH₵68 million was allocated for hand pollination and

    GH₵140 million for these purposes. Therefore, beyond the issues that we are

    talking about, these are very important

    issues because cocoa is a major cash crop

    that generates a lot of revenue for this

    country.

    Statements

    Some of us who were trained as

    agriculturists understand the benefits of

    cocoa, not just the economic aspect, but

    also the ecological and environmental

    aspects of it. Mr Speaker, he has made an

    application to you that if you may consider,

    probably through Leadership, the Hon

    Minister could brief us so we know where

    we are, especially as we are seeing the

    volumes declining which is quite worrying.

    Mr Speaker, thank you for indulging me.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
    Very
    well. I do not know but I believe the
    Chairman of the Committee on Food,
    Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs would like
    to speak on that.
    Yes, Hon Chairman, let us hear you.
    Chairman of the Committee (Mr
    John Frimpong Osei): Mr Speaker, I
    would like to commend the Hon Colleague,
    Mr Acheampong, for coming up with this;
    that he wants the House to invite the Hon
    Minister to come and explain what is
    happening in the cocoa sector to
    Ghanaians.
    About the final part of 2021, my good
    self and the leadership of the Committee on
    Food, Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs,
    together with Members of the Finance
    Committee took a trip to some cocoa
    growing areas in Ghana in about six
    regions. What we found out there was so
    impressive to the extent that the Hon
    Members who were present commended
    COCOBOD and the Regional Managers
    for coming up with such a programme to
    bring out the results we had in the last
    growing season.
    Mr Speaker, some time has elapsed so
    if my Hon Colleague has found out that
    there is a letter going around telling them
    to cease operations and that COCOBOD is
    going to outsource the programme to
    private members, I believe that what is
    right for us to do as a Committee and for
    that matter the Finance Committee,
    because they also championed the
    Syndication Fund, is to invite COCOBOD
    first to find out what has gone on so far.
    Beyond that, I believe the Hon Minister
    could also add his voice to it. Therefore, I
    would want to make it clear to the the
    House that COCOBOD has done very well
    with regard to what they are doing; the
    rehabilitation of cocoa farms and other
    programmes that brought out the result we
    had during the last cocoa season.
    As the Chairman of the Committee, I
    would also call my members to have a
    discussion with the management of
    COCOBOD so that we could also properly
    brief the House when the time comes.
    Mr Speaker, thank you for the
    opportunity.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Majority Leader?

    Statements
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:18 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    we have heard the Hon Member raise a
    very important matter, but I thought that
    when such an important matter is to be
    raised in the House, just so that it does not
    leave the House, unattended to, the
    relevant Minister would be summoned to
    the House at the time the Statement is
    being made so that we could have some
    proper response to it. It also positions us to
    appreciate the issues raised.
    However, if as increasingly as it is
    happening these days, the Rt Hon Speaker
    is ambushed as though it is an urgent
    Statement, we are not wiser by the
    Statement that is made in the House. I
    believe that a better arrangement - and in this particular case, if you heard the Hon
    Minority Chief Whip in his own response,
    he was talking about the fact that there are
    some outstanding issues that may have to
    be responded to by the Hon Minister; what
    is being done, what is the cost. He asked at
    what cost and what is the mechanism that
    is being employed to pursue what he is
    referring to. Therefore, with this statement
    that he made, how does he achieve the
    purpose? As far as I am concerned, it
    should have been a Question. The vehicle
    should have been a Question so that the
    Hon Minister would come and respond to
    it, but if he comes and submits such a
    Statement, how is the House made wiser by
    this?
    I am not too sure that we are achieving
    or attaining the result that is intended to be achieved by the Statement that he has just
    made. The House is not made richer or wiser by such choice of vehicle. I am not sure that that is the way to grow Parliament.
    Mr Speaker, however, it is not to
    downplay the issue that he has raised. I am only saying that there should have been a better vehicle to prosecute this matter; a Question, whether an Urgent Question or perhaps even a Motion. The purpose of the Statement that he made, really, is not to engender any debate. The Question, if the Hon Minister comes to respond to it and his response is not adequate, the House could hold his tail. Even a Motion, that the House must pursue a course.
    So Mr Speaker, I am not too sure that
    I agree with my Hon Colleague on the choice of vehicle; just a third Statement and that is the end of it. I do not think so at all. A Question would have been much better. And indeed, as one of our Hon Colleagues also related to, we are relegating the business of the various Committees to the background. For the Constitution provides in Article 103 what the purpose of the Committees of Parliament are supposed to be. For the elucidation of my Hon Colleagues, Article 103(3) provides — Mr Speaker, with your kind indulgence, I would like to read:
    “Committees of Parliament shall be charged with such functions, including the investigation and inquiry into the activities and administration of ministries and departments as Parliament may determine;”

    Statements

    Therefore, he should have used this vehicle and if anybody is found wanting or culpable, then it would have come up that somebody is short changing this country by the allocation of sums of money that have been made to the person's department or unit. Not to overflog the issue, I agree that the matter raised is germane and relevant but I am not too sure that I support the vehicle that he elected to bring the matter to the Chamber. It does help us to bring the facts out, facts that, really, all of us could relate to. Therefore, I would believe that, as a sequel, if maybe the relevant Questions could be raised, whether Urgent Questions, I believe that it would help the House better than the third Statement that has been made in the House.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:18 p.m.
    Hon Majority Leader, let me be clear. In this sense, should I ask the Hon Member to put in a Question or he should give it to the Committee to work on or we should ask the Hon Minster to come and respond to it? I am a bit — because as you said, the vehicle he chose is a bit —
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:27 p.m.
    Mr speaker, I would prefer that you refer this matter to the Committee on Food, Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs immediately to go into it and maybe report to this House within a very short time, maybe in about two weeks before the House adjourns so that we are able to unearth the truth about this. This is because if the Hon Minister is invited to
    come and give a Statement, he comes to offer the Statement and there is no investigation on the part of Parliament, we may be obliged to take whatever he comes to tell us hook, line and sinker. If the Committee goes into it, it would bring out better results and all of us would be better educated. Therefore, I believe that the directive would be to forward this to the Committee and they would be charged with the responsibility of going deeper into it and coming out with their findings as I am saying Parliament has to adjourn on the 24th or 27th of July. We could give them a limited time, not more than three weeks, to report back to this House what their findings are.
    Mr Speaker, thank you.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:27 p.m.
    Very
    well. Yes, Hon Minority Chief Whip?
    Minority Chief Whip (Alhaji Mohammed-Mubarak Muntaka) 1:27 p.m.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker. I could not have agreed more with the Hon Majority Leader. I support what he said, if we could get the Committee on Food, Agriculture, and Cocoa Affairs to quickly look at it. Mr Speaker, I even think a week should do, but that notwithstanding, it would suffice just to make sure that we get the Report before we rise since the Hon Majority Leader himself is aware that that is one of the things we are trying to cure in the new Standing Orders. This is because, as he read from Standing Order 103 — yes, but according to our Standing Orders, the

    Statements

    Committee, on their own, cannot just go working and be able to find space to report on the Floor; the matter would have to be first referred to them. So, I think that this vehicle gives us the opportunity now to refer it to them so that they can work on it and report to us, and I agree with the Hon Majority Leader. This is urgent, and we must be able to get a Report from the Committee on Food, Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs before we go on recess.

    Mr Speaker, however, I would like to add that because of the syndicated loan, if we could add the leadership of the Committee on Finance to the Committee on Food, Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs, they may be very useful; since they have been managing the syndicated loans. Even if the Chairperson and the Ranking Member cannot join, they may choose one or two Hon Members from their Committee to join the Committee on Food, Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs to be able to furnish us with a Report before we go on recess.
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I think that we may have to let the Committee on Finance select some Hon Members from their Committee to join ranks together. If we limit it to the leadership, given the volume of work that has been assigned to the Committee on Finance, the leadership would not be able to join them, and in the process, they may stall the work. So, we should let the Committee on Finance, in meeting, appoint, maybe, a couple of their own to join it, not
    necessarily the leadership. If we restrict it to leadership, they would stall the Business that has been referred to them.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:27 p.m.
    Very
    well. So, Hon Members, the issue that has
    been raised from the Statement from our
    Hon Brother is referred to the Committee
    on Food, Agriculture and Cocoa Affairs.
    You are given two weeks to report back,
    but as it has been said, we will ask the
    leadership of the Committee on Finance to
    join you to investigate and report back to
    this House in two weeks' time. I so direct.
    Hon Majority Leader, let us hear you.
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    I understand there are two other
    Statements. I do not know the nature of
    those Statements, if, maybe —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:27 p.m.
    World
    Refugee Day —
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:27 p.m.
    All right,
    and then the other one?
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:27 p.m.
    I think
    the other one is personal: “Decimation of our Local Music Industry”.
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the other one is a commemorative Statement,
    so, if the Hon Member could read it into the
    records without attracting any comments,
    then we could do the other Motion, and
    then come back to the third Statement. So,

    Statements

    let us deal with the commemorative

    Statement.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:27 p.m.
    Very
    well.
    Hon Member for South Dayi, Mr
    Rockson-Nelson Dafeamekpor, on the
    occasion of the World Refugee Day, 2022.
    You may now have the Floor.
    STATEMENTS 1:27 p.m.

    Mr Osei Keyi-Mensah-Bonsu 1:37 p.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, as I said, that is a commemorative
    Statement. However, there is another one.
    So, I would kindly plead with my Hon
    Colleagues that we move on to the next
    Statement because I think the highlights, as
    espoused by the Hon Member who made
    the Statement, really capture everything.

    Statements
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:47 p.m.
    Hon
    Majority Leader, so are you going to the
    item numbered 8?
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    I understand there is a third Statement in
    your custody.
    Mr Kyei-Mensah-Bonsu 1:47 p.m.
    I am
    inviting you for us to take that one too and
    then we move on from there.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:47 p.m.
    So,
    Hon Members, let me invite you to also ask
    the Hon Member for Tema Central
    Constituency to make a Statement on the
    #seesomethingsaysomething by the
    Ministry of National Security. Hon Member
    for Tema Central, Mr Yves Hanson-
    Nortey, you may now take the floor.
    STATEMENTS 1:47 p.m.

    Mr Yves Hanson-Nortey (NPP — Tema Central) 1:47 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I want to
    thank you for giving me this opportunity.
    Mr Speaker, the National Security
    Strategy of Ghana, launched in 2020, is a
    response to the changing nature of the
    security threats to the country while high-
    lighting contemporary methods of addressing
    them. The central theme of the Strategy is
    the usage of the whole-of-Government and
    whole-of-society approach, grounded in
    the principles of unity of purpose in
    combating security threats. In line with this
    approach, the Ministry of National
    Security, on May 24, 2022, launched the
    #seesomething-saysomething campaign to
    encourage citizens to report suspicious
    activities in their communities, particularly,
    those relating to terrorism. Citizens can
    report such activities to the nearest police
    station, the community leaders, and
    through a call to the short code "999" or a
    message to the social media handles of the
    Ghana Police Service.
    Mr Speaker, statistics from the 2022
    Global Terrorism Index indicate that Sub-
    Saharan Africa has suffered a staggering
    48 per cent of all terrorism-related deaths
    globally. Most of these casualties come
    from Nigeria, Niger, Mali, the Democratic
    Republic of Congo (DRC) and our closest
    neighbour, Burkina Faso. An analysis of
    the recent threat of terrorist attacks in the
    sub-region highlights a southward drive to
    littoral states along the Gulf of Guinea. The
    most recent of these attacks were in the
    Republic of Togo, where eight soldiers
    were killed and thirteen wounded.
    Hitherto, Togo had been spared from the
    scourge of terrorism. With terrorism hitting
    close to home, it behoves us to put in place
    strategies to prevent the spread of this
    canker into our beloved country, Ghana.

    Statements

    After all, when you see your neighbour's

    beard on fire, it is advisable to get water by

    yours.

    Mr Speaker, it goes without saying

    that terrorism has dire effects on the

    political stability as well as the socio-

    economic development of any country. In

    Burkina Faso, for instance, the disposition

    of former President Roch Kabore on

    January 24, 2022, was allegedly fuelled by

    his inability to curtail jihadist expansion in

    the country, particularly after the

    November 14, 2021, terrorist attack on the

    Inata Gendarmerie Garrison in northern

    Burkina Faso that left 53 of the 120 troops

    dead. After 30 years of peace and

    democracy in Ghana, we must prevent

    terrorists from eroding the gains made in

    the Fourth Republic. The menace would

    further derail international trade and

    investment in the country. There would be

    no liberty to access basic amenities of life.

    To epitomise this, Burkina Faso has

    witnessed the closure of 1000 schools and

    the internal displacement of 1.5 million

    people, some of whom have sort refuge in

    the northern regions of Ghana. Is this what

    we want for our country? Certainly not.

    Mr Speaker, having established the effects terrorism would have on our nation, what exactly are we to look out for in our efforts to notify security and intelligence agencies of suspicious activities related to terrorism? An analysis of the modus operandi of terrorists seems to point to recruiters targeting young people through

    social media such as Facebook, Twitter and WhatsApp, enticing them with promises of competitive remuneration or a better life in heaven. Consequently, should we see any person or organisation mobilising young people for an unclear agenda or revolving around religious fundamentalism, we must say something for our Security and Intelli- gence Agencies to monitor and assess the situation. Social media users must also report posts with violence or religious fundamentalist elements, particularly videos showing people brandishing arms or how to make improvised explosive devices and chemical weapons.

    Mr Speaker, the campaign is laudable

    and deserves more attention than it currently has. A synopsis of the recent attack on a Texas school by Salvador Ramos shows that he had revealed his sinister plans to a Facebook friend before he executed them. Had this person been conscious of the tell-tale signs of impending doom, she would have said something when she saw the messages. Mr Speaker, the latest of them all is the deadly massacre on Sunday, 5th June, 2022, of over one hundred (100) members of a Catholic Parish at Owo in the Ondo State of Nigeria. We commiserate with the families of the victims and the Nigerian people, with whom we share so many things in common.

    Mr Speaker and Members of this

    honourable House, as stakeholders in our communities, let us conscientise our constituents about the threat of terrorism,

    Statements

    to encourage them to say something when they see something. In so doing, we will be fulfilling our civic responsibility of defen- ding the cause of freedom and rights as espoused in the National Anthem. When we "see something, we say something".

    Mr Speaker, thank you for giving me

    the opportunity to make this very important

    Statement.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:57 p.m.
    So, we
    would invite contributors to both State-
    ments. You may decide which Statement to
    contribute to.
    Yes, let me listen to the Hon Member
    for Klottey-Korle.
    Dr Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings
    (NDC — Klottey-Korle): Mr Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity to contribute
    to the Statement made by the Hon
    Members on the commemoration of the
    International Day for Refugees as well as
    National Security.
    Mr Speaker, in speaking about refugees,
    there is a tendency to forget that a huge
    number of people that we do not advert our
    minds to, are the internally-displaced
    persons, and by definition, they satisfy all
    the other criteria for refugees except that
    they have not crossed internationally-
    recognised State borders.
    Mr Speaker, just to give an idea of the
    severity of the Internationally-Displaced
    Persons (IDPs) globally, in Yemen, there
    are 2.5 million IDPs; in Myanmar,
    644,000; Nigeria, 2.2 million; South
    Sudan, 1.6 million; Afghanistan, 1.2
    million; Somalia, 1.2 million, and Syria
    and Iraq have between 7 and 8 million
    IDPs which represent about 20 per cent of
    the refugees globally.
    Mr Speaker, the majority of those
    affected when there is a conflict or any
    disaster are women and children.
    Unfortunately, a lot of the data does not
    break down the extent of the suffering that
    the women and children go through, and a
    lot of these are exposures that happen
    which are underlining problems during
    peace times, which become aggravated
    during times of conflict or disaster.
    Mr Speaker, this ties in nicely to the
    issue of our national security and the
    concept of #seesomethingsaysomething.
    Mr Speaker, perhaps, it would be an oppor-
    tunity for the Hon Minister for National
    Security to present a full Statement to the
    House because we need to know what the
    chain of command is. Who are you to say
    something to when you see it?

    Mr Speaker, in addition to that, the

    cost of having to deal with a terrorist attack within a country is so high that we cannot afford to go down that path. As we can see in some of these countries where terrorist attacks and violent extremism spreading, it is quite clear that break between Central Government and the rest of the country is

    Statements

    one of the areas where there is a gap in the provision of services between the Government and the people, and others coming in providing those services turn to be seen as the saviours of those communities.

    Mr Speaker, the danger in allowing

    terrorism to make itself manifest in the country is that, it becomes a profitable business, and difficult to weed out. Therefore, we have a lot at stake, and it is in our best interest to ensure that we do not allow any of such activities to become rooted in our country, lest it becomes so profitable that our quest to put an end to it becomes futile. This does not need anything than for us to just pass round the sub regions, to see the difficulty with which certain terrorist groups are being brought under control because it has now become more profitable for them to exist.

    There are groups that profit by

    conflict; profit when there is chaos, and profit when there is war. We must ensure that we have enough education within our country, to make sure that our citizens understand the value of ensuring that their safety and national security are preserved, and that they have a role to play. Thank you very much for the opportunity.

    Some Hon Members — rose —
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 1:57 p.m.
    Thank
    you very much. Yes. Let me give the opportunity to the Member of Parliament for Wa West.
    Mr Peter Lanchene Toobu (NDC — Wa West) 1:57 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, thank you very
    much for the opportunity to contribute to
    the Statement. I wish I could do it for the
    first one that talked about refugees, but my
    heart was touched when my Colleague
    from Tema Central made a very good
    Statement about terrorism — “See Something, Say Something”. I would therefore want to make a contribution
    towards that. Am I to be guided, please?
    Mr Toobu 1:57 p.m.
    Thank you. The fight
    against terrorism in the world is gradually
    gaining attraction, and it is gaining
    complexity and the attention of nations
    towards acts of terror is eating so much into
    the national budget. Unfortunately for us in
    Ghana, when one looks at the strategic
    blueprint of the National Security, it is
    clearly stated in there, that youth
    unemployment remains a huge security
    threat to this nation. And recruitment of
    young people who are virtually doing
    nothing by terrorist groups, is a highway
    towards national distraction.
    So when the issue of “See Something, Say Something” was launched, all of us within the security and political circles got
    so excited, because in a democracy where
    it is all about sharing your own opinion, as
    it is said in the local parlance, ka bi ma men
    ka bi — To wit, “express your opinion and let me express mine”. It is an environment that people can say what they want to say,

    Statements

    so saying something is part of our

    democratic tenet; saying it to who is what

    we need to define. What I am supposed to

    say is what we need to get clarity.

    But I think that the many prank calls

    that was experienced immediately after the

    launch of this very important project tells

    us a country that we need to get serious,

    and try as much as we can to enhance the

    security consciousness of the populace to

    understand that where the State is weak, all

    of us must come together as a people to

    strengthen the path that will give us the

    best of security.

    A weak State is an avenue for

    terrorists to strive, but all of us as a people

    will have to understand that when one finds

    something and does not say it, insecurity

    anywhere in this country — in any village, will amount to insecurity everywhere. So

    when it happens in one's village and one decides to keep quiet, when it becomes a

    national issue, the individual might be

    affected in a way that will surprise him or

    her.

    Mr Speaker, “See Something, Say Something”, is a project by the National Security that intends to push us to a level

    that all of us will appreciate that it is not

    about keeping quiet or sitting on the fence,

    but it is about expressing one's opinion; seeing something that can affect the

    security of this country and saying it right

    and timely. The timely submission of a

    message within security circles could allow

    for a simple analysis, to ensure that the

    State can react appropriately and timely.

    Mr Speaker, “See Something, Say Something” is a very passionate strategy that would enhance national security. But

    we ought to take note of this; using hard

    power to fight terrorism is gradually

    becoming something that is not working.

    We ought to enforce the power that we

    require to fight terrorism to be a soft power.

    The application of soft power, in other

    words, empowering the State in a soft

    angle — every village, town, and community will appreciate the fact that the

    power that we have actually resides in us.

    It is every individual and citizen's responsibility to “Say Something” when they “See Something” to support national security to keep this nation peaceful.

    Because as we all sit here, we are potential

    refugees — potential refugees because if terrorists attack this country, we cannot

    stay here. We have to run across the

    country; if one does not run across the

    country, they will become an Internally-

    Displaced Person. So all of us are potential

    refugees, and because we want to prevent

    it, we should be able to “Say Something” when we “See Something”.

    Mr Speaker, with these few words, I

    would want to thank you for the

    opportunity to contribute to this very

    important Statement.

    Statements
    Ms Dzifa Abla Gomashie (NDC — Ketu South) 2:07 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am grateful
    for the opportunity. I am the Member of
    Parliament for Ketu South, which shares a
    border with Togo. This morning, I had the
    opportunity to speak about the movement
    or part of the activities at the border from
    Aflao to Akanu.
    Mr Speaker, coming in here and
    listening to both Statements; one by my
    Brother, Rockson-Nelson Etse Dafeamekpor
    and Mr Yves Nii Noi Hanson-Nortey, it got
    me thinking. At what point is the Hon
    Minister for the Interior going to involve
    those of us in charge of the border
    communities.
    Mr Speaker, if you see the evidence
    that is in this country, it says that in la Cote
    d'Ivoire — well, we have 9,000 Ivorians as refugees; It goes on to say we have 3,500
    Togolese as refugees. In most of our
    communities, when we see foreigners, we
    normally assume that the ones who are
    poor, and walk barefooted and appear in as
    a certain manner as refugees. Yet, we have
    not been approached as members of
    communities though people use these
    communities as entry points into the
    country.
    When we see something, whom
    should we talk to? As my Hon Colleague
    just said, when do we say it? Is anybody
    preparing some guidelines for us to share
    in our communities? Or the kinds of things
    to look out for, which should draw our
    attention to saying something to the
    appropriate authority. In the Statement
    read by Mr Yves Nii Noi Hanson-Nortey,
    perhaps he did, but I do not recall that he
    mentioned where, and to whom the
    messages should be given to. Whom
    should we say it to in our various
    communities? It is important that the
    message and guidelines are clear, and as
    stakeholders, we would embrace it and
    assist the State because really, as he just
    said, we are all potential refugees of a sort.
    Mr Speaker, in my view, the linkages
    are very clear. If someone is here as a
    refugee, it means something may have
    happened in their own communities. We
    are trying to protect ours from being a
    recipient of those kinds of terrorism or
    activities, that lead people to become
    refugees. But I do not think that I am
    empowered enough by the Ministry of the
    Interior to be the voice in my community,
    so that we can address this. I say this
    especially because on many occasions, the
    Hon Minister for the Interior has told me
    that the reason we have mainly checkpoints
    and barriers in my constituency and from
    my constituency to Accra, is because of the
    fear of terrorism.

    But it is only said in passing, and I do

    not believe that any concrete step is being

    taken to help us as a nation protect all of us

    from being potential refugees.

    Statements

    Mr Speaker, I hope these would be taken into consideration and the House and its Members would be approached properly so we could assist. I thank you for the opportunity.
    Mr Speaker 2:07 p.m.
    Thank you very much. Can I come to Leadership?
    Alhaji Muntaka 2:07 p.m.
    Thank you, Mr Speaker. I would just pass it on to Mr Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa.
    Mr Speaker 2:07 p.m.
    Are you yielding it to him? Very well.
    Mr Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa
    (NDC — North Tongu): Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. I would like to commend my Hon Chief Whip for his magnanimity.
    Mr Speaker, the two Statements made by Mr Rockson-Nelson Dafeamekpor and Mr Yves Hanson-Nortey are very important Statements and I must commend them highly for a very well researched Statement.
    Mr Speaker, the first Statement on World Refugee Day is a timely one. There is a current Global Refugee Crisis.
    Mr Speaker 2:07 p.m.
    Hon Member, hold on. I think the time is five minutes past 2 p.m. so please indulge me to extend Sitting beyond the normal hours.
    Mr Ablakwa 2:17 p.m.
    So, Mr Speaker, as Mr Dafeamekpor shared with us, there are
    millions of our compatriots across the world who have been displaced by no fault of theirs, largely due to conflict, poverty, human trafficking and all kinds of severe conditions that have come upon them. They are very vulnerable and are fleeing all of these challenges to a safe haven.
    Mr Speaker, as Mr Dafeamekpor
    observed, as a country, we have occupied a
    pride of place in how we have welcomed
    refugees. We have been celebrated
    internationally for hosting refugees for the
    longest period, particularly from countries
    like Liberia, in particular, and in recent
    years, La Cote d'Ivoire, when it saw conflict after the election dispute. So, as a
    country, we have really excelled and that is
    why on this day, it is important to remind
    everybody that we are a common humanity
    and we must always look out for each
    other. As we say that, we must point out to
    some disturbing development at the
    refugee front. The ongoing conflict in
    Ukraine; the invasion of Ukraine by Russia
    saw many people fleeing that country.
    Mr Speaker, what the world has
    observed is that even with managing
    refugee crisis, there is discrimination. We
    see how western nations open their doors
    happily and warmly to Ukrainian-Caucasian
    refugees but shut the door at Africans, and
    there have been numerous cases on how
    African refugees, largely students, who are
    also fleeing the conflict in Ukraine. Even
    at the border point, we had Ukrainian
    border officials discriminating. The African

    Statements

    Union and United Nations had to issue a

    statement and we had all seen harrowing

    accounts of how African refugees were

    discriminated against. We could not have a

    situation in this world where some refugees

    are better and preferred than others; they

    are all vulnerable regardless of the colour

    of their skin and they must be treated

    equally.

    So, Mr Speaker, on this day, I

    condemn all those actions that go to

    discriminate against refugees of any kind

    just because of the colour of their skin,

    background or status. Having said that,

    there is also a ranging issue which is a new

    policy the United Kingdom is pursuing on

    the refugee front where they are seeking to

    just bundle refugees and then hand them

    over to Rwanda.

    Mr Speaker, activists all over the

    world have spoken against such policy.

    The United Nations has declared the policy

    inhuman and against the International Law.

    The United Nations High Commissioner

    for Refugees (UNHCR) is very clear about

    it, yet the United Kingdom Government is

    hell-bent. The irony is that: a number of

    countries were approached. I must

    commend Ghana and Nigeria Government

    for declining to be part of this offer.

    Surprisingly, the Rwandan Government

    agreed. We have heard it is about a

    £150million package, but clearly Rwanda

    has been doing a lot of good things; they

    have got a lot of development policies

    right, we may critique their human rights

    records, but this particular policy aligning

    with the Boris Johnson Administration to

    allow refugees to be just bundled, their

    rights violated, to host them and claim that

    they are processing them for asylum in

    Rwanda is most unfortunate.

    Particularly this week, as the Common-

    wealth Heads of States are meeting in

    Kigali, I hope that Rwanda would change

    its mind. Fortunately, activists took the

    United Kingdom's Government to court and there is an Court of Appeal decision

    because they lost at the High Court but the

    Court of Appeal is looking at their review

    and we expect a decision in July. I hope

    that the activists would succeed and that

    the Rwandan Government would really

    change its mind because the international

    community is really disappointed in the

    Kagame Administration for accepting to go

    into this deal with the Boris Johnson

    Administration.

    We must all recognise that people do

    not flee safe havens; if they were

    comfortable where they are, not under

    attack or suffering from the disgrace of

    harsh conditions, they would not be fleeing

    their homes so we need to offer empathy

    and we need to extend some love and care

    to refugees. I hope that on World Refugee

    Day, the world leaders would reflect that

    some of these inhumane policies against

    refugees, against people who are fleeing

    from conflict, poverty deprivation and all

    kinds of turbulence to be accorded much

    more respect.

    Statements

    Mr Speaker, as I conclude, I would like to commend my Hon Brother, Mr Yves Hanson-Nortey, for his Statement on “See something, Say something” and we expect the Hon Minister for National Security to come and brief us fully. However, we see that there is a lot of public campaign and education and it is very much in order. So far, it appears that we are the only country in the sub-region that has not been attacked, so we must all come together. What we see in other countries is that, the political class in particular only come together after an attack, and they wish that they were more united and had all collaborated before the attacks.

    So, let us learn that lesson and come together as one people and as a political elite that has a responsibility to offer leadership and to help protect our people. I commend the various initiatives and the only concern so far is that the help-line does not seem to be working when people call in; they are not as responsive as it should. I hope that the National Security Secretariat would work on that particular concern and all of us would put our shoulders to the wheel and be alert; the public education should be taken seriously. Many people do not know how to take personal security and keep an eye out and be on the lookout for suspicious activity.

    Mr Speaker, I hope that we would all refresh our alertness and be more educated on how to prevent this dastardly act that takes place. We must all protect our

    country and we must be proud that as a country we have never suffered any terrorist attack. We must keep that reputation, and do all in our power as political leaders to keep our people safe.

    Mr Speaker, I commend the Hon

    Members who made the Statements and I

    thank you very much for your kind

    indulgence.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:27 p.m.
    I hope
    Hon Member from Leadership is yielding
    his position.
    Mr Kobina Tahir Hammond (NPP
    — Adansi Asokwa): Mr Speaker, whenever I am here, you also recognise that I am
    around so — [Interruption] — I miss you a lot seriously. [Laughter] Mr Speaker, I
    thank you very much for the opportunity to
    speak for the first time since the House
    resumed for this Meeting. I have not seen
    you for a long while —
    Mr Speaker, two important Statements
    have been made by our Hon Colleagues,
    and I believe they are both worth
    contributing to. Let me take the matter of
    refugees first, and I would go to the one on
    national security. It is World Refugee Day,
    and the prayer is that respective
    governments should be careful in the way
    they look after and treat refugees.
    Mr Speaker, for many years when I
    practised at the Bar of England and Wales, I did quite a lot of work with respect to refugees, particularly, those who had come

    Statements

    from “areas of persecution” or “so-called persecution areas” so the matter of refugee issues really is not new to me. The whole concept seems to be getting slightly confusing. The 1951 Refugee Convention and the 1967 Protocol are very clear on who a refugee is. The legal system developed the concept to include many variants. Here, it is not so much the case that because one fears persecution or prosecution, he would just jump onto the next available vehicle and then find himself in some advanced countries.

    Mr Speaker, there has been a

    conflation of persecution, so speaking, and prosecution. A lot of people are com- plaining about prosecution as being equivalent of persecution. What is even worse as we see it is economic migration, which is masquerading under the pseudonym of persecution and for that matter, the need of international protection. Three days or so ago, I read something on the internet, I think Ghanaweb or something, where a young man in Germany, who I think is a Ghanaian said, and I quote: “I renounced citizenship of Ghana to be German”.

    Mr Speaker, he seems to be suggesting

    that we can all go to Germany to apply for refugee status because there is hardship in this country. Indeed, it was so bad. The statement was to the effect that even if one's area is affected by rains, he could go and apply for refugee status in Germany. It was on the internet and inviting Ghanaians so to do. That is not the basis for which one applies for persecution.

    I can understand the need for everybody to seek economic welfare and wellbeing because we all would want to be comfortable, but if there are genuine reasons why we go to the advanced countries, we must find the appropriate and legitimate means of going to the place. I do not think we should just go and tell all kinds of lies and there has been so many of them.

    Mr Speaker, I recall those days when Ghanaians would come to my office, and I would ask them why they applied for refugee status in the United Kingdom and they talk to me like I am not a Ghanaian. They tell me the conditions in Ghana and would want to apply for whatever —

    Mr Speaker, it gets more complicated. Look at what is happening with the people who are now crossing from France to the United Kingdom between Calais and across the channel. Can we think about it? The British Government is bereft of ideas on what to do. Recently, it was rumoured, and it was eventually denied that they were seeking to make Ghana a safe haven and to repatriate those people to Ghana. That was the original story that we heard, and was eventually denied, but in the end, the lot centered on Rwanda so the British Government has now decided that whoever takes the arduous journey of crossing the channel and reaching the United Kingdom and through that strait would be returned to Rwanda to apply for refugee status in that country.

    Statements

    It was so dead serious that I believe

    about three or four days ago, a flight was

    actually taken, and it was about to take-off

    and for the last minute — indeed, the lawyers have challenged it in the High

    Court and they have failed; they have made

    unsuccessful attempts at the Court of

    Appeal and have failed; the Supreme Court

    of England had given the go ahead for the

    flight to take them to Rwanda. At the

    eleventh hour, the European Court of

    Human Rights granted an injunction

    grounding the flight and it did not take-off.

    Mr Speaker, these are the things and as

    much as we sympathise with people who

    would want economic welfare, the distinc-

    tion between economic migration and the

    real political refugee — people in need of protection must be clearly dichotomised.

    Other than that, international refugee

    protection would lose its essence. Every-

    body is scrambling under the pseudonym

    of “protection”. There are people who do not need protection; they should stay in

    their respective countries.

    Mr Speaker, look at Ghana for

    example, if everybody else were to come to

    Ghana because it is peaceful and whatever,

    could we contain them? There is also

    another aspect of it. When Ukraine fell

    because of all the crises — it has not completely fallen, but with the crisis going

    on there, we assumed that our students

    would come back home, yet what we heard

    was that some of them said since they were

    already in Europe, they would do all sorts

    of things and apply for other statuses.

    Home is home so people should be careful.

    Mr Speaker, we do not have time to

    debate the whole issue of refugee

    protection; it would take us hours. The

    other part of the Statement is about the

    security situation in our sub-region,

    particularly, lately in Ghana. It is a matter

    of grave concern. I always suggest that we

    should pipe it down. When it comes to

    matters of this nature, I prefer that it is kept

    on the quiet. There have been many

    discussions and variations with various

    permutations. I am concerned that that is

    rather giving oxygen to whoever is

    planning to harm us. Is it the case that we

    are actually advising them on what to do or

    not?

    Mr Speaker, National Security, I

    presume, is on top of what is going on. If

    we listen to the debate on radio, most of the

    pseudo-experts — we hear their names and they say they are experts in whatever, but

    they are not doing the country any good.

    Mr Speaker, we should calm down. Yes, it

    is the — [Interruption] — Sorry. You keep saying something, but I cannot hear you — [Interruption] — The conclusion? Na wabrɛ a, ko fie ɛ — to wit: why not go home if you are tired? [Laughter]

    Mr Speaker, let us pretend you did not

    hear that one. He wants me to conclude; I

    think he is tired. He is one of the young

    ones I have been talking to. He is not

    looking at me, but he is one of them.

    Statements

    These Hon Members are part of the

    few that I need to chat with about how they

    go about things, so we would talk. I would

    not mention their names, but they have

    seen me, so they know those I have referred

    to.

    Mr Speaker, it is also important that

    this whole business about “coup d'état” is kept to their respective selves. Today, we

    are talking about security and terrorists in

    the other areas and regions, but the worst

    form of it is that the coup d'état that we talk about every day, I mean, if we — what is the worst form of subverting the national

    security of the country and what people

    have been preaching and talking about?

    The last one has to do with people who

    wanted to go on demonstration and sought

    for permission to go with arms. I read

    yesterday that one of our young Hon

    Colleagues, who I guesses sympathises

    with Oliver Mawuse Barker-Vormawor's group, — but he should not talk about the foolishness of coup d'état and such issues. Well, he should not sympathise with Mr

    Barker-Vormawor for there is nothing

    good about what he is doing. He is creating

    disunity and chaos, which does not help the

    system. There was another statement

    which I read from GhanaWeb that the coup

    d'état has started already. How does that manifest itself?

    Mr Speaker, we should be careful,

    because this is the only country we have,

    and we should be mindful of the way we go

    about discussing these matters. I keep

    saying that those who are old enough and

    saw the June 4th or even the 31st December

    Revolutions would not think about a coup

    d'état. This is the best system we ever can have: four years of governance. If the

    government is not good, the people are

    there, and would do what they have to do.

    They would go to the polls and change the

    government, but we should not wish the

    country worse by imposing this sort of

    atrocities on it.

    Mr Speaker, looking at my Hon

    Colleagues, they are tired, so I would spare

    them. They were enjoying it, were they

    not?

    Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:27 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, we have brought Statement time
    to a close. I thank the Hon Members who
    made the Statements and all the
    contributors.
    Leadership, may I come to you?
    Mr Habib Iddrisu 2:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, it is
    past 2.00 p.m., and we are in your hands for
    adjournment.
    Mr Rockson-Nelson E. K. Dafeamekpor 2:27 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, we are not opposed.
    Mr Second Deputy Speaker 2:27 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, it is already past 2.00 p.m.,
    therefore, I would move to adjourn the
    House to tomorrow at 10.00 a.m.
    I thank you very much.
    ADJOURNMENT 2:27 p.m.