Debates of 23 Jun 2023

MR FIRST DEPUTY SPEAKER
PRAYERS 11:20 a.m.

Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:20 a.m.
Hon
Members, it is time to consider the Votes
and Proceedings for Thursday, 22nd
June, 2023.
Page 1...11 —
First Deputy Minority Whip (Mr
Ahmed Ibrahim): Mr Speaker, sorry to
take you back to the page numbered 10,
the directive from the Chair:
The Rt Hon Speaker directed the
Business Committee to schedule the
Hon Ministers responsible for
Works and Housing and Finance to
apprise the House on measures
being taken to address the situation
latest by the end of next week.
Mr Speaker, the timeline that was
given, which is by the end of next week,
should have been there.
Majority Chief Whip (Mr Frank
Annoh-Dompreh): Mr Speaker, I do not
intend to raise the temperature this
morning, but that was not the directive.
Indeed, the Rt Hon Speaker mentioned
the two Hon Ministers; the Hon
Ministers for Works and Housing and
Finance however, he said that the
Business Committee should programme
them as soon as possible; he did not say
the end of next week, and, so, my good
Friend — [Interruption] — Me nso meteeɛ.
Mr Speaker, I recollect that was the
directive of the Rt Hon Speaker and if
my Hon Colleague is still in doubt, we
could check the records.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:20 a.m.
Very
well. Hon Members, the Department of
Official Report would have the record.
Let them be guided by the record so there
is no controversy here.
Mr A. Ibrahim 11:20 a.m.
Mr Speaker, the Rt
Hon Speaker went on to say that even if
the Hon Minister for Finance is not there
because he has travelled, the other Hon
Minister of State who is at the Ministry
of Finance could come.
[Interruption] Yes, that was what he
said.
Mr Eugene Boakye Antwi 11:20 a.m.
Mr Speaker, I was right here, and what the Rt Hon Speaker said was that he was aware that the Hon Minister for Finance
was out of the country, but if the need arose for the Deputies to come in and address the House, so be it, but he did not give a timeline. He said the Business
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:20 a.m.

Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:20 a.m.
Hon Members, there is no need to generate
controversy here. This is the record of Parliament. There is a department in this Parliament which is responsible for producing the verbatim report, so I direct the Department of Official Report to verify the exact directive the Rt Hon Speaker gave and to amend the minutes accordingly. I so direct.
Page 11...18 —
Prof Kingsley Nyarko 11:20 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page 18, item 3(viii), the designation of “Dr Ahmed-Rufai Ibrahim”, “Metropolitan Coordinating Director, Accra Metropolitan Municipal Assembly” should be “Metropolitan Coordinating Director, Accra Metropolitan Assembly”. Let us cancel the word “Municipal”. Thank you.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:20 a.m.
Very well. The Clerks-at-the-Table would effect the correction.
Page 19...20 —
Minority Chief Whip (Mr Kwame
Governs Agbodza): Mr Speaker, the item numbered 3(xxxi) on page 20 reads, “Ag Municipal Cordinating Director”; the spelling “Cordinating” needs to be corrected to “Coordinating”.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:20 a.m.
“Coordinating”? Is there a correction there? I cannot see any.
Mr Agbodza 11:20 a.m.
Mr Speaker, yes. It is
spelt as “C-o-o-r-d-i-n-a-t-i-n-g”, except in the item numbered 3(xxxi) where it is
“C-o-r-d-i-n-a-t-i-n-g”. There is a little correction that needs to be done on that.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:20 a.m.
Really?
Very well. We would leave that to the
Clerks-at-the-Table to make the
correction.
Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:20 a.m.
Mr Speaker,
let me apologise; I did not catch your
attention.
Mr Speaker, with the greatest of
apology, if we may go back to the item
numbered 4(6) on page 7. I checked and
realised that my Hon Deputy Majority
Leader, Mr Alexander Kwamena
Afenyo-Markin, is captured as absent.
Mr Speaker, he did submit a leave of
absence. I followed up and got it
confirmed that he was actually granted.
So, his name should rather be captured
under “Members Absent with Permission”.
Mr Speaker, then on page 8, the item
numbered 32, the Hon Member for
Tolon, Mr Habib Iddrisu, my Hon
Second Deputy Majority Whip, was
actually present yesterday but he has
been captured under “Members Absent”. Again, the item numbered 42 on page 8,
Mr Augustine Collins Ntim has also been
captured as absent. His leave of absence
was also approved. Finally, with the item
numbered 49, Mrs Ursula G. Owusu-
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:20 a.m.

Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
Very
well.
The Clerks-at-the-Table will effect
the corrections because I am aware that
their leaves of absence were brought to
me and I granted them leave to be absent.
Mr Agbodza 11:30 a.m.
Mr Speaker, with your
indulgence, the Hon Minority Leader, Dr
Cassiel Ato Baah Forson, was also here
yesterday.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
The
Clerks-at-the-Table will effect the
correction. I also was in the precincts of
Parliament, but I am marked absent. I
will deal with that.
Page 22…25 —
Prof Nyarko 11:30 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page
25, under “Public Accounts Committee, Opening”, it reads, “The Committee met on Tuesday, 18th May, 2023…”. On page 17, under “Public Accounts Committee, Opening”, it also reads, “The Committee met on Tuesday, 16th May, 2023…”. On page 17, Tuesday is 16th May while on
page 25, Tuesday is 18th May. If it were
a Thursday, then, it was 18th May so, they
should check and reconcile the two dates.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
Very
well. One Tuesday cannot be both 16th
and 18th May, 2023, unless they are
reporting two events. The Clerks-at-the-
Table will check and effect the
appropriate correction.
Page 26…36 —
Prof Nyarko 11:30 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page
36, under “Opening”, which reads, “The Committee met on Thursday, 15th June,
2023, at 10:30 a.m. and embarked on an
inspection tour of ongoing housing
project…”, “project” should be plural, so we should add “s” to it.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
Very
well. The Table should take note and
effect the correction.
Page 37…42 —
Prof Nyarko 11:30 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page
42, the last sentence under “Opening” has my Hon Chairman's name, Mr Kwabena Amankwa Asiamah, wrongly
spelt. There is an omission of “n”. It should be “A-m-a-n-k-w-a”, not “A-m- a-k-w-a”.
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
Very
well. The Table will effect the
correction.
Page 43…44 —
Prof Nyarko 11:30 a.m.
Mr Speaker, on page
44, the item numbered 3(xxiii), “Mr Saaka Sayufi” should be “Mr Saaka Sayuti”. He used to be my deputy when I was at the National Accreditation Board
(NAB).
Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
Very
well. The Table should effect the
appropriate correction.
VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS AND THE OFFICIAL REPORT 11:30 a.m.

  • [No correction was made to the Official Report of Friday, 24th February, 2023]
  • [Pupils and staff of Happy Days Academy rose to be acknowledged]
  • Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    You are
    welcome to Parliament. Please sit.
    There is also a delegation from
    Mfantsipim School. They are led by Mr
    Joseph William-Duncan from Cape
    Coast.
  • [Pupils and staff of Mfantsipim School rose to be acknowledged]
  • Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    Mfantsipim School, you are also
    welcome to Parliament; you may now
    resume your seats.
    There are also members of the
    Church of Pentecost, Frami District, led
    by Pastor Richard Ekow Donkor.
  • [Members of the Church of Pentecost, Frami District rose to be acknowledged]
  • Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    Very
    well. You are welcome to the Parliament
    of Ghana.
    Finally, we have the Fruitful Land
    Academy from Gomoa East, led by Mr
    Isaac Korsah.
  • [Pupils and staff of Fruitful Land Academy rose to be acknowledged]
  • Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    Very
    well. You are welcome to Parliament.
    Hon Members, we move to item
    numbered 5 — Business Statement. Yes, Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:30 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    may I seek your leave to present the
    Business Statement for and on behalf of
    the Hon Chairman of the Business
    Committee.
    Mr Agbodza 11:30 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, we do not
    have any objection, but he should have
    added that his Leaders are at Assin North,

    and that is why they are not here, but it is

    okay for him to present it.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    Who is
    at Assin North?
    Mr Agbodza 11:30 a.m.
    The Hon Chairman of
    the Committee and his Deputy are in
    Assin North.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:30 a.m.
    Did he
    ask leave of you?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:40 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    what I can confirm is that the Leader of
    Government Business and the Hon
    Chairman of the Business Committee is
    out of the jurisdiction. However, I am
    very sure of the presence of the Hon
    Minority Leader at Assin North; that I
    can confirm.
    Mr Speaker, having said that, I would
    go ahead and present the Business
    Statement.
    BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE 11:40 a.m.

    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon
    Members, do you have any comments?
    Mr Asamoah — rose —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Member?
    Mr Vincent Oppong Asamoah 11:40 a.m.
    Mr
    Speaker, I would like to find out why the
    Questions we had for the Hon Minister
    for Education two weeks ago have not
    been captured for next week.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon
    Members, do you have any further

    Yes, Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:40 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    my Hon Colleague's concern about Questions directed to the Ministry of
    Education is — I guess my Hon Colleague knows that admissibility of
    Questions is in the bosom of the Rt Hon
    Speaker. It is when the Rt Hon Speaker
    admits these Questions that same are
    transmitted to the Table Office to be
    programmed by the Business
    Committee. I would advise the Hon
    Member to follow up through the very
    hardworking Hon Minority Chief
    Whip's office. I am sure he would be able to know the stage at which his
    Question is then we can confirm the
    status of the Question.
    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon
    Majority Chief Whip, if I understood the
    Hon Member, he says that the Business

    Business of the House

    Committee had actually scheduled those

    Questions earlier, but something

    happened, and the Questions were not

    answered so, it is for the Business

    Committee to reschedule.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:40 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    kindly bear with me; I did not get that
    understanding. If that is the case, then, I
    would relate to the Table Office and the
    Business Committee to ensure that we
    reschedule duly. I apologise for the mix-
    up.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Hon
    Members, any more comments?
    Mr A. Ibrahim — rose —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Yes,
    Hon First Deputy Minority Whip
    Mr A. Ibrahim 11:40 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, earlier,
    I raised the question relating to the
    directive from the Chair, which was
    disputed, and you sent for a check at the
    Department of Official Report for
    confirmation. In fact, they have brought
    the confirmation to the Hon Majority
    Chief Whip, which says that what I said
    was right, and he was wrong.
    Mr Speaker, based on that, before the
    adoption of the Business Statement,
    because the Business Committee would
    not sit again till the end of next week,
    while the directive was emphatic that
    looking at the importance and urgency of
    the matter, we must programme the two
    Hon Ministers to appear before us before
    the end of next week, which is Friday — Wednesday will be a holiday —
    I do not know whether before the
    adoption of the Business Statement, we
    could consider programming the two
    Hon Ministers to appear before us on
    Thursday or Friday because Tuesday is
    the only working day before the statutory
    public holiday, which will be Wednesday.
    So, we seek your indulgence for the two
    Hon Ministers to appear before us by the
    latter part of the week so that they would
    have ample time to prepare. This is
    because the directive came as a result of
    many people losing their lives — at least three in Accra and three in Kumasi. That
    is why the Rt Hon Speaker gave that
    urgent directive that the Committee on
    Works and Housing must do something.
    However, the two Hon Ministers must
    appear before us to apprise the House on
    the measures taken to combat it on
    Thursday or Friday, depending on which
    of the day would be convenient.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:40 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    indeed, my Hon Colleague is right; that
    was the directive. So, we do not need to
    litigate this matter further. On the
    adoption of the Business Statement and
    the concerns about confirmation of when
    the two Hon Ministers can appear before
    the House, I would say that we can adopt
    the Business Statement subject to the
    necessary amendments. However, I
    would liaise with the Hon Leader of
    Government Business for us to reach out
    necessarily to ensure that we can have
    the two Hon Ministers in the House,
    preferably on Thursday because the Hon
    First Deputy Minority Whip and I know
    that Friday is not often a convenient

    Business of the House

    time, and we have dedicated Friday to

    the Hon Minister for Roads and

    Highways to come and answer a backlog

    of Questions. So, we should be working

    towards Thursday. The Hon First Deputy

    Minority Whip himself is a member of

    the Business Committee, so, we will talk

    in whispers and do the needful to ensure

    that we get the two Hon Ministers to

    attend upon the House.

    Mr Speaker, if I may, we also made a

    point to which the Rt Hon Speaker

    agreed, that in accordance with our

    Standing Orders, Order 192(2), which

    says that Committees should not

    necessarily be given referrals before they

    undertake what they are supposed to do.

    With your permission, I beg to quote:

    No instruction shall be given to a

    Committee to do that which it is

    already empowered to do or to deal

    with a question beyond the scope of

    a Bill or matter.

    Mr Speaker, the Rt Hon Speaker

    encouraged that the Committee on

    Works and Housing should also visit

    these places and be armed with the

    reality on the grounds so that even while

    we wait for the two Hon Ministers to

    come and apprise us, we, as a House,

    would also have some good information

    on the reality on the ground. Therefore,

    it is also a matter that is important, and

    we expect the leadership, both the

    Ranking Member and the Chairman, to

    heed to this good counsel and be seen to

    be working. I do not know if this answers

    my Hon good Friend's concern.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:40 a.m.
    Very
    well, Hon Majority Chief Whip. So, you
    will find room to invite the Hon
    Ministers to appear next week certainly.
    Further, I have been directed by the Rt
    Hon Speaker to bring two matters to the
    attention of the Business Committee.
    One, the Standing Orders Committee's Report should be programmed for
    Thursday. So, please take note and have
    it programmed for Thursday. Two, the
    Promotion of Proper Human Sexual
    Rights and Ghanaian Family Values Bill,
    2021 should be programmed for Tuesday
    or Thursday, but whatever it is, it must
    be on the Order Paper next week. The
    Motion for the Second Reading of that
    Bill should be programmed for Tuesday
    or Thursday. These are the directives of
    the Rt Hon Speaker.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:40 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    we will do as directed. I thank you.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Very
    well.
    Yes, Hon First Deputy Minority
    Whip?
    Mr A. Ibrahim 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I think
    this is a very sensitive matter, and a
    number of Civil Society Organisations
    (CSOs), political workers, as well as
    constitutional workers have interest in it
    and would be watching this House. You
    have given either Tuesday or Thursday,
    but we know the Assin North by-
    elections would be on Tuesday, and we
    know that a number of Hon Members,
    and maybe, your good self, would be

    Business of the House

    there. We need to have a very

    comprehensive and well-researched

    debate on the issue. Sensing and

    foreseeing that the numbers may not be

    good to organise the debate on Tuesday,

    if you could be specific for the Motion be

    taken on Thursday, which we know our

    Colleague Hon Members who would

    celebrate Eid-ul-Adha on Wednesday,

    and those who would be at Assin North

    for the by-election on Tuesday would all

    be here, so that the House would be

    properly constituted to take that

    historical debate —

    Mr Annoh-Dompreh — rose —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon
    Majority Chief Whip, are you standing
    on a point of order?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    my Hon good Friend made a valid point
    and observation, except that he should
    depart from the path of drawing the Hon
    First Deputy Speaker into it. Why would
    he say that the Hon First Deputy Speaker
    would go to Assin North? Does he know
    that for a reality? He should stay clear
    from that and make his point. He should
    not enroll you into his tactics.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon
    Majority Chief Whip, thank you. The
    Hon Member was actually out of order
    but I ignored him.
    Hon First Deputy Minority Whip,
    make your point about the appropriate
    date now.
    Mr A. Ibrahim 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, I
    would just like to be specific that we
    should be emphatic for all those who
    would like to take part in that debate in
    the form of watching proceedings in
    Parliament either from the gallery,
    homes or media, everybody should be
    prepared that the debate would take place
    on Thursday, so that people do not come
    here on Tuesday, and the debate would
    not be done. Therefore, let us firm up
    Thursday for that important debate.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with respect to my Hon Colleague,
    maybe he did not listen to you well. You
    said that it was a directive from the Rt
    Hon Speaker, and he has given two days.
    The Assin North by-election is a national
    exercise and the Parliament of Ghana is
    also a national exercise. So, if an Hon
    Member is interested, he or she must
    prioritise. We do not need to gravitate
    unnecessarily and oscillate between the
    two. If it is Thursday, let us stick to it,
    and anybody who is interested in this
    debate must show up. Hon Members
    cannot prioritise Assin North over
    Parliament and expect the House to wait
    for them. I disagree with my Hon
    Colleague and with respect, he should
    abandon his submission. Both are
    national exercises, so, Hon Members
    should choose one. We cannot have the
    two, but he would like to have the two.
    We should stick to Tuesday.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    As I
    explained, if Tuesday is not alright, then
    Thursday should be, but either Tuesday
    or Thursday, those two subjects must be
    on the Order Paper. It does not mean that
    we would necessarily conclude work on
    them, but once they appear on the Order
    Paper, we are sure that work could be

    Business of the House

    done irrespective of the day. I have

    actually been advised that the Hon

    Chairman and Hon Ranking Member for

    the Committee on Constitutional, Legal

    and Parliamentary Affairs are actually

    out of the jurisdiction now. Hopefully,

    they may return to the jurisdiction before

    any of these two days. Both of you are

    Hon Members of the Business

    Committee, so I suggest that you take

    your agreements and disagreements to

    the Committee.

    Hon Members, are there any further

    comments on the Business Statement?

    Hon Members, subject to the

    proposed inclusion of certain Bills and

    Questions, the Business Statement is

    hereby adopted.

    Yes, Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    with respect, at the Commencement of
    Public Business, may we now turn to
    page 4 of today's Order Paper and take the item numbered 14. I would further
    seek your leave for the substantive
    Motion to be taken by the Hon Deputy
    Minister for Trade and Industry.
    Mr A. Ibrahim 11:50 a.m.
    — rose —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon
    First Deputy Minority Whip?
    Mr A. Ibrahim 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, we just
    approved the Hon Minister for Trade and
    Industry in this House, and this is his first
    Bill. If the Hon Majority Chief Whip
    would like to ask for the leave of this
    House for the Hon Deputy Minister for
    Trade and Industry to do the job of the
    substantive Minister, he must tell us the
    whereabouts of the substantive Hon
    Minister and the reason for seeking the
    leave of the Speaker for the Hon Deputy
    Minister to do the work on behalf of the
    Hon Minister.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon
    First Deputy Minority Whip, hold on.
    Could I be guided on which of the
    Standing Orders you are anchoring your
    suggestion that we should know where
    the substantive Minister is?
    Mr A. Ibrahim 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker, Order
    75 is clear about the procedure, manner
    or mode of laying Papers. Papers may be
    laid by Hon Members or Hon Ministers
    in this House. There is nowhere that
    “Deputy Minister” is even mentioned, so based on that, the Hon Deputy Minister
    is incapacitated to lay the Paper in this
    House. I so submit.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    our Hon Colleague should read the Order
    he quoted again. It is actually Order 74,
    and not 75, and I beg to quote:
    A Paper may be presented to the
    House only by Mr Speaker, the
    Chairman of a Committee, a
    Member or a Minister.
    Mr Speaker, our Hon Colleague is a
    proud Hon Member of Parliament for
    New Juaben South, so beside the point, it
    is an established convention, and if the
    Hon First Deputy Minority Whip would
    like to know the reason —

    Business of the House

    Mr A. Ibrahim — rose —
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the Hon First Deputy Minority Whip
    should sit down.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 11:50 a.m.
    Hon
    Majority Chief Whip, you have the floor.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 11:50 a.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    the Hon Minister who is a very regular
    member of this House is out of this
    jurisdiction on an official duty in
    London, and that is what I know. He
    personally called me, so Hon
    Colleagues, let us not overly drag this
    matter. He is one of us, and he is often in
    the Chamber, so I would like to appeal to
    my Hon Colleagues. Please abandon
    your position and let us make progress.
    Mr A. Ibrahim noon
    Mr Speaker, the
    Hon Majority Chief Whip knows that he
    came to meet me in this House, and when
    it comes to the interpretation of the
    Standing Orders, I am well-equipped. I
    did not open the Standing Orders, I just
    quoted extempore. The Orders are here; I
    cannot be wrong. The mode or manner of
    Presentation of Papers is in Order 75 and
    not 74, but the specific Paper that may be
    laid is what he talked about in Order 74.
    When it comes to how to implement or
    execute it, it is in Order 75. The Hon
    Majority Chief Whip should show me
    where “Deputy Minister” is written in even the Order 74 that he quoted. It is not
    there, and it does not talk of conventions
    here.
    Mr Speaker, you asked me which
    Standing Order and I quoted it, so, if it is
    not quoted in the Standing Orders that an
    Hon Deputy Minister can lay a Paper, it
    means he is incapacitated. The practice
    in this House is that Deputy Ministers
    have been laying papers, but Mr Speaker
    asked me which particular Order I was
    referring to and I came by Order 75,
    which is the mode, manner or how it is
    done, and Lawyer Samuel Atta Kyea is
    here to even confirm what I am saying.
    Mr Speaker, I know that we should
    not litigate this. I was just interested in
    the whereabouts of the Hon Minister, but
    since he had respect for this House and
    called the Hon Majority Chief Whip and
    sought his leave to be unavoidably
    absent from the House — I so submit.

    I would like to give up on my

    rendition and allow the Hon Deputy

    Minister for Trade and Industry to do that

    job on behalf of the Hon Minister for

    Trade and Industry, Mr K. T. Hammond.
    Mr Agbodza noon
    Mr Speaker, I agree
    with my Hon Colleague that we take this
    Paper. However, the Hon Majority Chief
    Whip must know that this is a House of
    Records. He said, and I listened to him
    say that, our Hon Colleague, the Hon
    Minister for Trade is a regular member
    of this House. That is a bit problematic.
    This is because he is not regular in the
    House as we can see. He comes
    sometimes. I am told that even at the
    Committee meeting, he did not appear.
    Rather, it was his Deputy who did. It is a
    rare concern.

    Business of the House

    Mr Speaker, if one is a Cabinet

    Minister — We all knew how he struggled to be confirmed and if after

    being confirmed, he is not in the House

    to supervise the first Bill he has brought

    to the House, then there is a real reason

    to see whether he actually wanted the job

    the way he was desperate for it when he

    went through the confirmation process.

    Mr Speaker, beyond that, our Hon

    Colleague, the Hon Deputy Minister for

    Trade and Industry, is an Hon Member

    of the House and we accord him that

    respect. He can lay the Paper for today

    but if it becomes regular then he should

    think of being the substantive Hon

    Minister for Trade and Industry so that

    he could be regular here to take the Bills.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Hon
    Members, I did not expect this to
    generate a debate. I am surprised that we
    are making an issue out of an Hon
    Deputy Minister moving a Motion and
    not presenting a Paper. So, the Standing
    Order that has been referred to is about
    the laying of Papers and not about
    moving a Motion. This is because I am
    not aware of any Order in the Standing
    Orders which requires that when an Hon
    Deputy is standing in for his Minister,
    the person making the application must
    give reasons. It is our practice that we ask
    — If it is said that the Hon Minister is not in, we ask about his whereabouts.
    However, it is not anchored in any of our
    rules and I wanted that to be emphasised.
    It is our practice and sometimes we do
    that against non-Members of Parliament
    who do not like appearing before us.
    However, when an Hon Minister is a
    member of the House and the Hon
    Deputy is also a member, as in this case,
    it is our practice that we overlook. This
    is because if an Hon Member is absent,
    the rules will deal with him. So, we
    should avoid making this an issue —
    Mr Emmanuel Akwasi Gyamfi — rose —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Yes,
    Hon Senior Member for Odotobri
    Constituency? Let me hear you before — Hon Deputy Minister, kindly wait. Yes,
    Hon Member for Odotobri?
    Mr Emmanuel Akwasi Gyamfi noon
    Mr
    Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity.
    Mr Speaker, my Hon Colleague who
    happens to be the Hon Minority Chief
    Whip, Mr Agbodza, said something
    about the Hon Minister for Trade and
    Industry, Mr K. T. Hammond, which, I
    believe, should not be part of today's proceedings.
    Mr Speaker, it is on record that Mr K.
    T. Hammond is not a regular member of
    this House and he attends Committee
    meetings. He was a member of and is
    currently even a member of the
    Committee on Mines and Energy. He
    attended meetings. Unfortunately, the
    statement that has been made by my Hon
    Colleague, Mr Agbodza, is not fair. The
    Hon Minister for Trade and Industry, Mr
    K. T. Hammond, is not here. So, I would
    plead with him that since Mr K. T.
    Hammond is a senior member of this
    House, he should not say this and it
    should not be part of our Records.

    Mr Speaker, I thank you.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Hon
    Member, unfortunately, I may not have paid attention to what he said. What specifically are you talking about?
    Mr Gyamfi noon
    Mr Speaker, he, Mr
    Agbodza, said that the Hon Minister for Trade and Industry and Hon Member of Parliament for Adansi Asokwa, Mr K. T. Hammond, is not a regular Member of the House, and that, he has not been seeing him coming to and attending upon Parliament. He mentioned that he has also not been attending committee meetings. [Interruption] — It is a very unfair statement.
    Mr Speaker, Mr K. T. Hammond is a
    regular member of this honourable House. So, I suggest that his comments should not be part of the Records of this august House.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Hon
    Member, I thought that those were comments on a lighter side. So, let the Record reflect that Mr K. T. Hammond is a senior regular serious Member of this House.
    Yes, Hon Deputy Minister for Trade
    and Industry, you may move the procedural Motion, the item numbered 14 on page 4 of the Order Paper of Friday, 23rd June, 2023.
    MOTIONS noon

    Mr Yussif Sulemana noon
    Mr Speaker, I
    second the Motion.
    Question put and Motion agreed to.
    Resolved accordingly.
    BILLS — SECOND READING
    Ghana Accreditation Service
    Bill, 2023
    Deputy Minister for Trade and
    Industry (Mr Michael Okyere Baafi)
    on behalf of the Minister: Mr Speaker, I
    beg to move, that the Ghana
    Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 be now
    read a Second time.
    Mr Speaker, I so move.
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh noon
    Mr Speaker, I
    would seek your leave to second the
    Motion and also present the Committee's Report.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Yes,
    proceed.
    Mr Agbodza noon
    Mr Speaker, we do not
    have any objection to that. We want to
    make progress. He wants to take the Report

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    and I am saying that we do not have any

    problem with that.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Please
    proceed.
    Mr Frank Annoh-Dompreh on
    behalf of the Chairman of the
    Committee: Mr Speaker, I beg to second
    the Motion moved by the Hon Deputy
    Minister for Trade and Industry, and in
    so doing present the Committee's Report. Let the Hansard capture the
    entirety of the Report.
    1.0. Introduction
    11. The Ghana Accreditation Service
    Bill, 2023 was presented and read for the
    first time in the House on Tuesday, 6th
    June, 2023 by the Minister responsible
    for Trade and Industry, Hon Kobina
    Tahir Hammond, in accordance with
    article 106 (1) of the 1992 Constitution.
    Pursuant to Order 159 of the Standing
    Orders of Parliament, the Rt Hon
    Speaker, on the request of the Minister
    for the Bill to be taken under the
    certificate of urgency, referred the Bill to
    the Select Committee on Trade, Industry
    and Tourism and Leadership of the
    Committee on Constitutional, Legal and
    Parliamentary Affairs to determine the
    urgency or otherwise of the Bill and
    report to the House.
    2.0. Urgency of the Bill
    2.1. The Committee subsequently,
    determined and certified that the Bill is
    of an urgent nature and may therefore, be
    taken through all the stages of passage in
    one day in accordance with article 106
    (13) of the 1992 Constitution and Order
    119 of the Standing Orders of the House.
    On the 8th June, 2023, the Committee
    presented a Report on the urgency of the
    Bill to the House, and the Report was
    adopted.
    3.0. Deliberations
    3.1. The Committee first held
    Stakeholders meeting on Thursday, 15th
    June, 2023. The Committee further met
    from 20th to 21st and considered the Bill.
    Present at the meetings were officials
    from the Ministry of Trade and Industry
    led by the Deputy Minister, Ms Nana
    Ama Dokua Asiamah-Adjei on behalf of
    the Minister. Other participants included
    officials from the Attorney-General's
    Department, representatives of the
    Ghana Standard Authority (GSA),
    Health Facilities Regulatory Authority
    (HeFRA), Cyber Security Authority
    (CSA) and National Petroleum Authority
    (NPA).
    The Committee is grateful to the
    Ministry and other officials for their
    invaluable inputs.
    4.0. References
    The Committee referred to and was
    guided by the following documents inter
    alia during its deliberations on the Bill:
    i. The 1992 Constitution of the
    Republic of Ghana;
    ii. The Standing Orders of the
    Parliament of Ghana;

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    iii. Interpretation Act, 2009 (Act

    792);

    iv. Ghana Standard Authority Act,

    2022 (Act1078);

    v. Trade Policy (2005 to 2009); and

    vi. Industrial Policy (2011 to 2015)

    5.0. Background

    5.1. The need to establish an

    accreditation body was initially

    prescribed in the Trade Policy (2005 to

    2009) and the Industrial Policy (2011 to

    2015). Subsequently, the Ghana National

    Accreditation Service (GhaNAS) was

    established by the Ministry of Trade and

    Industry as a company limited by

    guarantee under the then Companies Act,

    1963 (Act 179) and became operational

    in September, 2018.

    5.2. The establishment of GhaNAS

    emanated from the country's need for an

    internationally recognised national

    accreditation system as a crucial element

    of a well-functioning quality infrastructure

    aligned with international best practices.

    Further, GhaNAS was established to

    ensure that the accreditation system

    supports the needs of Ghanaian

    enterprises competing in a fast-paced

    global economy and ensures support for

    public policy objectives in terms of

    health and safety of citizens of the

    country and the protection of the

    environment.

    5.3. Prior to the establishment of

    GhaNAS in 2018, public and private

    conformity assessment bodies seeking

    international recognition through

    accreditation turned to foreign

    accreditation bodies for accreditation for

    which the conformity assessment bodies

    paid exorbitant fees.

    This also led to the transfer of the

    already scarce foreign exchange out of

    the country.

    5.4. As the national accreditation

    body, the GhaNAS has been responsible

    for the independent attestation of the

    technical capabilities of conformity

    assessment service providers in line with

    international standards and in

    accordance with requirements detailed in

    World Trade Organisation (WTO)

    Agreements on Technical Barriers to

    Trade (TBT), International Accreditation

    Forum (IAF), International Laboratory

    Accreditation Cooperation (ILAC),

    African Accreditation Cooperation

    (AFRAC) and others.

    5.5. In April 2022, the country

    adopted a National Quality Policy which

    prescribed the development and

    promulgation of legislation to regulate

    conformity assessment activities and

    establish a national accreditation body.

    5.6. It is imperative that a credible

    Quality Infrastructure in terms of

    standardisation, accreditation, conformity

    assessment, and metrology is firmly in

    place to assure markets of Ghana's

    adherence to international standards and

    a national accreditation body is the

    central pillar of that assurance.

    5.7. The Bill forms part of the

    Government's commitment to ensuring

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    that consumers of goods and services are

    protected in accordance with clause 9 of

    Article 36 of the 1992 Constitution

    which provides that “The State shall take appropriate measures needed to protect

    and safeguard the national environment

    for posterity; and shall seek co-operation

    with other states and bodies for purposes

    of protecting the wider international

    environment for mankind.

    5.8. Further, the establishment of the

    Ghana Accreditation Service will also

    ensure that accreditation bodies,

    inspection bodies, calibration or testing

    laboratories and other conformity

    assessment bodies meet established

    standards that will enable them to

    provide services that are credible,

    reliable, and independent.

    6.0. Object of the Bill

    6.1. The object of the Bill is to

    establish the Ghana Accreditation

    Service to provide for an efficient and

    effective accreditation system for the

    accreditation of conformity assessment.

    7.0. Highlights of the Bill

    7.1. The Bill contains a total of fifty-

    nine (59) clauses.

    7.2. Clause 1 deals with the

    application of the Bill. The Bill applies

    to the accreditation of conformity

    assessment bodies such as calibration

    laboratories, testing laboratories;

    validation bodies, verification bodies;

    certification bodies, inspection bodies;

    rating agencies; and any other body

    determined by the Minister and or by

    Executive Instrument.

    7.3. Clauses 2 to 5 provide for the

    establishment of the Ghana

    Accreditation Service, the object of the

    Bill, functions, and membership.

    7.4. Clauses 6 to 17 provide for the

    composition of the membership of the

    governing body of the Ghana

    Accreditation Service, the duties, tenure

    of office of the members, meetings,

    disclosure of interest, establishment of

    sub-committees of the governing body,

    allowances, adherence to policy

    directives of the Minister, establishment

    of Accreditation Committee, functions

    of the Accreditation Committee and

    establishment of sub-committees of the

    Accreditation Committee.

    7.5. Clauses 18 to 25 deal with the

    appointment and functions of the

    Director-General, the appointment, and

    functions of the Deputy-Director

    General, the appointment of other staff,

    the creation of divisions, directorates,

    and units, and establishment of Regional

    offices of the Service and Internal Audit

    Unit.

    7.6. Clauses 26 to 31 provide for

    financial matters including sources of

    funds of the Service, opening of a Bank

    account, borrowing powers, accounts,

    and audits; and annual reports to comply

    with relevant laws.

    7.7. Clauses 32 to 34 deal with

    matters of accreditation schemes

    including the establishment of the

    accreditation schemes, mandatory

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    accreditation of conformity assessment

    activities, and compliance with

    mandatory accreditation.

    7.8. Clauses 35 to 47 provide for

    licensing, and requirements for

    accreditation. Application for license to

    use accreditation symbol, consideration

    of the application, grant of licence,

    validity, and duration of licence, non-

    transferability of licence, extension of

    scope of accreditation, suspension of

    licence, reduction of scope or withdrawal

    of licence, appeal against decisions of the

    Service, register of licence, indemnity

    and restrictions on the use certain words.

    7.9. Miscellaneous dealt with in

    clauses 48 to 59 and makes provisions

    scheme of service, confidentiality,

    impartiality in the performance of

    assigned functions under the Act,

    administrative penalties, offences,

    custody and use of common seal,

    Regulations and Interpretation, Repeal,

    transitional provisions, dissolution, and

    savings.

    8.0. Observation

    8.1. Concerns of Stakeholders

    8.1.1. Concerns were expressed by

    some stakeholders including the Ghana

    Standard Authority (GSA) and Health

    Facilities Regularity Authority (HeFRA)

    in relation to the scope of the mandate of

    Ghana Accreditation Service when

    established. In the view of the concerned

    stakeholders, extending the scope of the

    mandate of the Ghana Accreditation

    Service beyond the third-party

    accreditation, to include monitoring of

    the activities of the conformity

    assessment bodies is likely to result in

    duplication of functions, increase the

    cost of doing business and create

    potential conflicts with some existing

    Regulatory Agencies.

    For instance, under Ghana Standard

    Authority Act, 2022 (Act 1078), GSA is

    mandated to carry out conformity

    assessment activities. GSA further

    argues that it is well positioned to carry

    out this conformity assessment

    considering the reference laboratories

    GSA has constructed, in addition to the

    cumulative wealth of experience and

    competence in conformity assessment

    (testing, inspection, and certification).

    8.1.2. The Ministry, however,

    explained that the best practice requires

    that all the Pillars of Quality

    Infrastructure (Standardisation, Metrology,

    Conformity, Assessment, and

    Accreditation) should be independent.

    Accordingly, the Ministry has decided to

    transfer the monitoring role of GSA for

    conformity assessment role as currently

    contains in Act 1078, and place it under

    Ghana Accreditation Service, whiles the

    Ministry takes steps to develop other

    Quality Infrastructure Bodies. The role

    of GSA will thus be limited to

    standardisation. HeFRA on the other

    hand, will remain and monitor

    compliance to standards by the health

    facilities in Ghana.

    8.2. High Cost of foreign accreditation

    8.2.1. The Committee was informed

    that the average minimum cost of foreign

    accreditation services including

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    preparatory work and travel expenses of

    foreign consultants, is approximately

    US$120,000, exclusive of the cost of

    maintenance assessments and re-

    assessments. The prohibitively high cost

    of foreign accreditation services and

    expertise has been a major disincentive

    for the conformity assessment bodies to

    seek accreditation services for their

    activities. This has negatively affected

    their ability to remain internationally

    competitive for their business.

    8.2.2. The Committee was, however,

    delighted to note that the same range of

    accreditation services to be provided

    locally will cost about US$ 50,000 when

    the Ghana Accreditation Service is

    established.

    8.3. Economic Transformation

    8.3.1. The Committee noted that the

    establishment of the National Accre-

    ditation Service has become more

    imperative as Ghana aims to leverage

    private-sector-led industrialisation, and

    trade and investment to stimulate high

    economic growth and sustainable

    development. The establishment of a

    local Accreditation Body with

    international recognition will offer an

    opportunity to the private sector to

    harness the benefits of market access

    under Preferential Trade Agreements,

    including but not limited to, the African

    Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA)

    Agreement, the EU-Ghana Economic

    Partnership Agreement (EPA), UK-

    Ghana Trade Partnership Agreement

    (TPA), Africa Growth and Opportunity

    Act (AGOA) and the ECOWAS Trade

    Liberalisation Scheme (ETLS).

    8.3.2. The relatively cheaper and

    easy access to Accreditation locally will

    also enable industries operating in Ghana

    to compete favourably with their

    counterparts in other countries.

    8.4. Donor Support

    8.4.1. The Committee was further

    informed that the World Bank has

    committed an amount of US$5.1 million,

    under the Ghana Economic

    Transformation Project to support the

    Ghana Accreditation Service. An

    amount of US$2.5 million out of the total

    support (US$5.1 million) is earmarked

    for supporting the activities of the Ghana

    Accreditation Service in the 2023

    financial year on condition that the

    Accreditation Service Bill is

    promulgated by June, 2023.

    8.5. Public Health and Safety

    8.5.1. The establishment of the

    Ghana Accreditation Service is in

    furtherance of the realisation of the

    aspirations of article 36(9) of the 1992

    Constitution which enjoins the State to

    take appropriate measures needed to

    protect and safeguard the national and

    wider international environment for

    posterity, through co-operation with

    other states and bodies.

    8.5.2. The creation of the Ghana

    Accreditation Service will ensure that

    conformity assessment bodies are

    competent to verify the health and safety

    of products and services whiles at the

    same time, preventing unhealthy, unsafe,

    and environmentally harmful products

    from entering the marketplace.

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    8.6. Financial Sustainability Analysis

    8.6.1. The financial sustainability

    assessment indicates that the enterprise

    is financially sustainable, because it is

    self-financing in the medium term. The

    Government of Ghana is expected to

    contribute an amount of GH₵1,548,895.28 comprising of GH₵1,421,267.28 as Compensation and GH₵127,628.00 as Goods and Services for the establish-

    ment and operationalisation of the Ghana

    Accreditation Service in one financial year.

    8.6.2. However, the estimated

    income from Internally Generated Funds

    (IGF) shows an increasing upward trend

    from GH₵853,000.00 in year 1, GH₵1,023,600.00 in year 2, GH₵1,228,320.00 in year 3, GH₵1,473,984.00 in year 4 and GH₵1,768,780.00 in year 5.

    The trend, therefore, gives an

    indication that the Ghana Accreditation

    Service will be able to finance all of its

    activities through IGF after the fifth year.

    8.6.2. In addition, the Ghana

    Accreditation Service is expected to

    receive a total amount of USD 5.1

    million from 2023-2026 under the Ghana

    Economic Transformation Project,

    averaging US$1.275 million per annum

    to support its operations.

    9.0. Recommendation and Conclusion

    9.1. The Committee after extensive

    deliberations on the policy rationale of

    the proposed legislation, noted inter alia

    that the Bill seeks to improve trade

    facilitation and capacity to attract clients

    due to high assurances for quality and

    reliability; improve Ghana's capacity to

    take advantage of trade agreements

    including opportunities offered by

    AfCFTA; and ensures health, safety and

    environmental protection in consonance

    with the aspirations of article 36 (9) of

    the 1992 Constitution of the Republic of

    Ghana.

    9.2. The Committee accordingly

    recommends to the House to adopt this

    Report and pass the Ghana Accreditation

    Service Bill, 2023 into law in accordance

    with article 106 (13) of the 1992

    Constitution and Order 119 of the

    Standing Orders of Parliament, subject to

    the attached proposed amendments

    (Appendix I).

    Respectfully submitted.

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading
    APPENDIX I noon

    GHANA ACCREDITATION noon

    AMENDMENTS noon

    Mr First Deputy Speaker noon
    Yes,
    Hon Ranking Member?
    Mr Yusif Sulemana (NDC — Bamboi) 12:20 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, I am rather the
    Deputy Ranking Member of the
    Committee.
    Mr Speaker, I rise to support the
    Motion numbered 15 on today's Order Paper.

    Mr Speaker, your good self, referred

    this Bill to us to determine whether or not

    it should be taken under a certificate of

    urgency. We reported to the House and

    recommended that there was the need for

    us to take it under a certificate of

    urgency. Your Committee now went

    back to deliberate on the content of the

    Bill.

    Mr Speaker, as part of Ghana's trade policy, we would require a national

    quality infrastructure and as part of the

    national quality infrastructure, we would

    need Ghana Accreditation Service as one

    of the pillars. So, when we met, we

    brought on board a lot of stakeholders

    and we all agreed that there was the need

    for us to pass this Bill into an Act.

    At the meeting, Health Facilities

    Regulatory Agency (HeFRA) which is

    under the Ministry of Health, raised

    some concerns that they wanted some

    clauses in the Bill expunged. We had a

    serious deliberation and at the end of the

    day, they agreed that they were going to

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    limit their activities, provide exactly

    what they are mandated to do and to

    leave monitoring to Ghana Accreditation

    Service when it is established.

    Mr Speaker, another stakeholder that

    raised concerns and brought a petition is

    Ghana Standards Authority (GSA).

    Ghana Standards Authority was there

    and presented a petition and explained

    why they think that certain aspects of the

    Bill be expunged or should not be

    considered. Upon a thorough

    deliberation, they also agreed that that

    aspect is supposed to be under the

    Accreditation Service Institute. So, they

    agreed that we should go on with the Bill

    as it stands.

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill,

    2023, which if passed into an Act will

    give legitimacy to the Ghana

    Accreditation Service has some benefits

    and it is important that we enumerate

    some of them. Most organisations that

    require some kind of attestation and

    confirmation would have to travel

    outside this country for accreditation.

    What happens is that they have to pay

    huge sums of foreign currency which

    means that we are transferring foreign

    currency to other countries. Establishing

    this organisation here would mean that

    these facilities would not go out of this

    country for accreditation. So, we would

    end up saving some foreign exchange.

    Mr Speaker, it is also important to

    realise that in today's global village where there is the need for us to inter-

    trade, we cannot do that if we do not have

    our goods and services accredited. Most

    of our commodities in this country are

    not accredited and it becomes difficult

    for us to be competitive and sell outside

    the boundaries of this country. When we

    establish this organisation, we would be

    able to accredit most of our institutions

    that provide goods and service within

    and outside to be very competitive. So,

    we thought that there is the need for us to

    have this institution established.

    Again, today we are talking about the

    African Continental Free Trade Area

    (AfCFTA) and we would be able to make

    maximum use of it if our institutions are

    accredited so that they can produce

    goods and services that will meet

    standards within and outside this

    country.

    Mr Speaker, it is also important to

    mention the importance of public health

    when it comes to accreditation. Most of

    our laboratories and other institutions

    need to be accredited so that we can have

    confidence in the results they give out,

    especially when our health is concerned.

    So, this institution is also going to

    address that issue.

    Upon these deliberations, the

    Committee recommended that there was

    the need for us to pass this Bill into an

    Act and to do it in a quick manner

    because the World Bank is supposed to

    give us some support and they want us to

    pass this Bill before the end of this

    month. If we are not able to pass it before

    the end of this month, that support would

    not be given to us.

    On this note, I call on the House to

    adopt this Report and pass this Bill into

    an Act. I thank you so much.

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    Prof Kingsley Nyarko (NPP —

    Kwadaso): Mr Speaker, I am grateful for

    the opportunity to contribute to the

    Motion under discussion. Since I have

    worked within the sector of accreditation

    and quality assurance before, I see this

    Bill as very crucial and important if we

    want to advance the course of the country

    in terms of our trade volumes, quality

    and all that.

    Going through the Report, I saw that

    most of these trade institutions normally

    pay about US$120,000 to foreigners for

    accreditation. It is huge, but if we are

    able to pass this Bill and have the Ghana

    Accreditation Service in place, then we

    are more likely to obtain accreditation

    for our institutions at half the price —

    about US$50,000. For me, that is very

    important.

    Mr Speaker, we live in a global

    environment where competition has

    become so fierce, and foreign countries

    would always depend on the assurances

    of quality of products that are exported to

    them. So, I am happy that this is

    happening because it makes it very

    competitive, gives assurance to potential

    buyers of our produce that our produce is

    of certain high quality. That would also

    help us to get increased volumes of our

    exports with its consequential positive

    effects of increased foreign exchange

    which will help us to deal with our

    balance of payment issues.

    I thank you for the opportunity and

    would plead with the House to adopt and

    pass this Bill to the benefit of this nation,

    especially within the trade environment.

    Thank you for the opportunity, Mr

    Speaker.

    Dr Kwabena Donkor (NDC — Pru

    East): Mr Speaker, I beg to lend my

    support to the adoption of this Bill. In

    doing that, I also want to draw the

    attention of the House that having the

    legal framework in place alone has never

    been enough.

    This country has never lacked

    appropriate laws, the challenge has been

    the policy environment and the will to

    implement whatever the law sets out to

    do. Therefore, in contributing to the

    adoption of this Bill, I would want a clear

    commitment from the Ghanaian State,

    represented here by the Ministry of

    Trade and Industry that this should not

    just be another piece of legislation, as an

    Hon Colleague said, to conform to the

    demand of a third party. I heard the

    World Bank has some facility and if we

    do not pass this by the end of the month,

    that facility would elapse.

    Mr Speaker, I would not like to see

    us doing things because there is money

    to support this, but I would like to see it

    as, taking this far more seriously, the

    need for this country to particularly

    increase exports which cannot be

    debated.

    It is so paramount and imperative that

    we establish an export driven economy if

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    we are to create the necessary jobs for the

    teeming number of youths coming

    especially from our tertiary and pseudo-

    tertiary institutions. Therefore, while

    supporting this Motion, when it comes to

    the details, I would like us to look at a

    wording that empowers, which would

    put an obligation on the Ghanaian State

    to ensure that this does not remain a

    paper tiger. I thank you, Mr Speaker, for

    the opportunity.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    Dr
    Kwabena Donkor, I am laughing because
    no matter what word we use to write the
    Bill or the law, the desire to do it is in the
    person implementing it, and unless we
    are willing and ready, any word we use
    would not make any difference.
    Yes, Hon Member for Keta South,
    Ms Dzifa Abla Gomeshie?
    Ms Dzifa Abla Gomeshie (NDC —
    Ketu South): Mr Speaker, really, my
    interest is about the economic
    transformation that this document seeks
    to achieve. As we have in other
    countries, I think it is about time we had
    agencies that work to promote and
    facilitate the work that people in the
    business sector do. Point 8.3,
    particularly, which talks about the
    economic transformation is of interest to
    me because of the financial stability that
    this seeks to achieve.
    However, Mr Speaker, in this
    Chamber, I miss my Hon Chairman, and
    any Hon Member on the other Side of the
    House from the Committee. We as a
    Committee were mandated to take to
    look at this because it came under some
    urgency. It is unfortunate that I do not see
    my Chairman in the Chamber. However,
    looking at the work that we have done in
    the past three days, I would like to
    commend all of us who participated in
    the discussion and to urge that this House
    takes a serious look at it. I thank you, Mr
    Speaker, for the opportunity.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    Hon
    Members, I think that Leadership may
    wish to comment now.
    Mr George Kwabena Obeng Takyi
    — rose —
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:20 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Member for Manso-Nkwanta?
    Mr George Kwabena Obeng Takyi
    (NPP — Manso-Nkwanta): Thank you, Mr Speaker, for this opportunity to make
    some few contributions to this important
    Bill. We are moving into a world of
    technology and today, people are talking
    about Artificial Intelligence (AI). If we
    look at the advance world, they are
    taking the lead in terms of how best they
    are coming out with regulations to ensure
    that this new technology would not take
    them by surprise. What are we doing as
    a country in our part of the world? It is
    time we also take note of this all-
    important Bill to ensure that we
    incorporate into the Bill some of these
    new developments in an advance and
    ahead of time so that we do not allow our
    society to be overburdened and
    overtaken by events.
    Mr Speaker, when you look at the
    implications of this Bill and what we are
    going to see from this new development,

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    we shall have some social, health,

    educational and economic implications.

    However, if we look at the health

    implication, technology is going to come

    out with a lot of side effects and other

    things that could impair the development

    of our health system. So, we need to take

    steps as the Bill is trying to seek to ensure

    that we incorporate all the necessary

    steps to ensure we protect our people

    from such developments that would be

    negative to us.

    Mr Speaker, to conclude, I would

    also like to say that this new

    development in technology and other

    things have certain financial implication.

    If we allow ourselves without having in

    place measures to retain and ensure that

    our fair share in terms of the economic

    implication on us are taken care of, we

    may end up being on the losing side. This

    is because, without taking steps to make

    sure that we also get the right benefits to

    fight some of these negatives, the effect

    of some technologies shifts the cost on

    us.

    So, Mr Speaker, in support of this

    Bill, I am also encouraging members of

    the Committee and the House to ensure

    that we incorporate into this Bill, all that

    is said to ensure that we have our value

    for money so that in future we do not

    ridicule ourselves into such negatives of

    modern technology.

    Thank you, Mr Speaker, for this

    opportunity to contribute to this Bill.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Yes,
    Leadership?
    Mr Kwame Governs Agbodza
    (NDC — Adaklu): Mr Speaker, I thank you for the opportunity to make a few
    comments about the Report as presented
    by the Hon Majority Chief Whip.
    Mr Speaker, my first comment is
    about the fact that when this Bill was
    read the First time, in fact, that day there
    was even a debate as to whether it should
    be taken under certificate of urgency. So,
    it is surprising that whiles we made the
    debate and agreed that this was supposed
    to be taken under certificate of urgency,
    it took all these days for us to come back
    and deal with it. I think the Committee
    and the Ministry should take this
    seriously.
    Mr Speaker, my second point is about
    the highlight of the fact that one of the
    reasons we are doing this is because of
    donor support. We are trying to pass a
    law which may outlive us. So, what is the
    essence of US$5 million which is
    pushing us; US$5 million is nothing so,
    we should not be passing laws because
    the country would lose US$5 million. If
    we are passing the law because we
    believe we need to do this, let us say so
    but to say that the World Bank is offering
    us US$5 million, so, we should do it, I do
    not think that is appropriate and we
    should not even be putting things like
    this in the Report. This is because, it is as
    if without US$5 million, we cannot do
    our own law. I do not feel comfortable
    about that. I do not think we are making
    the law because we are about to get US$5
    million.
    Mr Speaker, paragraph 8.5 talks
    about the health and safety issues.

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    Indeed, we have encountered both

    locally and imported products in this

    country and we have questioned the

    quality and standards by which these

    things were produced and are in use.

    Hopefully, this entity, if established, may

    be able to deal with this. We are told

    financial sustainability analysis have

    been done and this entity may sustain

    itself beyond the donor support.

    However, Mr Speaker, there is a

    concern raised by the stakeholders. If we

    go to paragraph 8.1, we are told that the

    Ghana Standards Authority (GSA) and

    others raised concerns on the duplication

    of service. In any case, the Ghana

    Standards Authority (GSA) and this new

    one is going to be Ghana Accreditation

    Service (GAS), so, the question is, which

    one comes first? I think the Ministry of

    Trade and Industry would have to do a

    good job by clearly stating in an

    organogram, as to which one comes first

    or the role of one being separated from

    the other. Otherwise, as they have

    already stated here, it appears Ghana

    Standard Authority is feeling that part of

    their mandate is what would be taken by

    this. It is important when we come to the

    Consideration Stage, we clearly state this

    and separate them appropriately.

    Mr Speaker, we are told this Bill has

    about 60 clauses so, it is not that much

    but the question is when can we get this

    done? Another point raised was that, it

    costs about US$120,000.00 to get

    accreditation from abroad and it is

    proposed that if we do this by ourselves

    it would cost US$50,000.00. Once again,

    I am not sure how they arrived at this. If

    it costs US$120,000.00 to get an

    accreditation for a product in London,

    how did they work it out that it would

    cost US$50,000.00 here? Does it even

    need to cost US$50,000.00 here? I am

    not sure if these figures are based on any

    facts or they are arbitrary figures put

    here.

    Once again, we are told in paragraph

    8.3 — economic transformation. There is a lot of nice English Language written

    and quoting where things have been

    turned around because of this.

    Mr Speaker, if this law is passed, it

    would not automatically transform our

    country except we all agree that if one

    needs accreditation, they need to get

    approval to have a product, unless they

    follow it, that is the only thing that will

    bring the transformation. However, if we

    pass this law, just like the way we have

    traffic lights yet some people get to the

    traffic lights and decide to go through

    because the policeman is not standing

    there, that will not automatically reduce

    carnage on our roads. In the same way, if

    we pass this law and we do not enforce

    it, it may not lead to this economic

    transformation we are talking about.

    Mr Speaker, with this, I feel that the

    bulk of the work will be how the

    Ministry structures the body of the law to

    separate the functions of the Ghana

    Standards Authority (GSA) with this

    new body, GAS, to make sure that they

    all perform their functions effectively

    and improve the standards of products

    and services that we have in this country.

    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill, 2023 — Second Reading

    That will be a plus and this House will

    also be proud if that happens.

    Mr Speaker, with these few words, I

    lend my support to this Report and urge

    Hon Colleagues to support as well.

    Mr Speaker, thank you for the

    opportunity.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Does the
    Hon Deputy Minister wish to conclude?
    Mr Baafi 12:30 p.m.
    Mr Speaker, there are few
    issues that I would like to clarify. The
    first one is as regards the US$5 million
    being extended to the Government of
    Ghana by the World Bank through the
    Economic Transmission Project. I think
    that money is meant for the short-term
    project. I am talking about the fact that
    we need to start the venture and,
    therefore, we would need some money.
    So, we decided to extend that facility so
    that we would be able to start the service.
    Mr Speaker, I guess Hon Members
    know or are all convinced that this
    service is going to create a lot of revenue
    for the country, in the sense that, in the
    sub-region, it is going to be the only
    accreditation body that is going to serve
    the community. We believe that we are
    not only going to benefit from service
    providers in Ghana or conformity
    association bodies in Ghana, but other
    jurisdictions may also take advantage of
    our services.
    Mr Speaker, also, as regards the GSA
    issues, I think paragraph 8.1 and 8.2
    would be able to answer those questions,
    so the Hon Member could refer to the
    Report. It answers the questions clearly.
    Specific roles have been given to all
    these agencies under the Ministry of
    Trade and Industry, so GSA is not going
    to have conflicts with the Ghana
    National Accreditation Service at all.
    Mr Speaker, about the US$120
    million, this number is the long-term
    number. As I said earlier, it would
    interest Hon Members to know that
    during COVID-19, we realised that this
    service was going to benefit this country
    a great deal because the kind of numbers
    we got, albeit we did not have a
    legislation governing us, we were able to
    provide service to the big labs in the
    mining sector of this country. So, we
    believe that in the long term, we are
    going to generate a lot of revenue for the
    country, so I believe that it is a good
    number.
    Mr Speaker, with these few words, I
    thank you.
    Question put and Motion agreed to.
    Ghana Accreditation Service Bill,
    2023 accordingly read a Second
    time.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon Majority Chief Whip?
    Mr Annoh-Dompreh 12:30 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    having regard to the time and also
    discussion by Leadership, I would want
    to move for the House to adjourn to
    Tuesday 10 o'clock in the forenoon.
    Mr First Deputy Speaker 12:30 p.m.
    Yes,
    Hon First Deputy Minority Whip?
    Mr Ahmed Ibrahim 12:30 p.m.
    Mr Speaker,
    Tuesday is a great day. We will be
    coming with Mr James Gyakye Quayson
    for the second time. So, that being the
    case, I second the Motion for
    adjournment.
    Question put and Motion agreed to.
    ADJOURNMENT 12:30 p.m.